Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

 

Sherlock's Louise Brealey and Beryl Vertue on 'kind, well-informed and considerate' Setlock fans

 

 

Wow, that's a fresh one! Thanks for sharing!
Oh really!

From my impression up to this point, going by the How would you fix HLV thread, about half of the members mentally cherish images of doing something violent to the sweet old lady's son-in-law! Are we getting paranoid here?

As for the lack of a smile, BC may not feel it appropriate in this costume, which is so very, very much a Jeremy Brett castoff down to the peculiar tie and watch chain!

Sfmpco and Arcadia, that slicked back hair is getting longer, apparently. Might you get the curly mop by the end of February?

  • Like 1
Posted

From my impression up to this point, going by the How would you fix HLV thread, about half of the members mentally cherish images of doing something violent to the sweet old lady's son-in-law!

Nothing permanent, mind you! Just maybe get his attention?  :rolleyes:

 

Please note that Beryl Vertue isn't just a sweet old lady -- she was made an OBE (Officer of ... the British Empire, the second rung on the ladder to Dame-hood) in 2000, and was awarded a BAFTA in 2004, all pre-Sherlock.  And since then, she's won even more awards.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

So is P.D. James, and Dalgliesh together with Morse are the two most famous modern versions of the lone genius in detection, although I have to hand it to the lady, her detective made only one major mistake in his deductions, while Morse goes all over the place based on intuition (remind you of anyone?)

Posted

 

If this counts as a smile, then here you are :smile:

 

tumblr_nj5hoxoBb61u57c32o1_1280.jpg

 

Good lord, no, that's almost a grimace. THIS is a smile. :P (Thanks for trying, though!)

Zi5EfR2.jpg?1

  • Like 3
Posted

So is P.D. James, and Dalgliesh together with Morse are the two most famous modern versions of the lone genius in detection, although I have to hand it to Dame James, her detective made only one major mistake in his deductions, while Morse goes all over the place based on intuition (remind you of anyone?)

 

Near as I can find online, P. D. James was, as you say, an OBE, so not quite a Dame (which would be a couple of steps upward).  If she had been a DBE or GBE, then I believe she would have been called Dame P. D. (or Dame Phyllis) rather than Dame James, but don't quote me on that.  I think one needs to be British to understand it!

 

Are you saying that Dalgliesh and Morse are take-offs on Holmes?  I've heard of both, especially Morse, but had never heard that particular description of either.  Or are you merely saying that they all have one trait in common, that of being a lone genius detective?

Posted

I think every couple detective show is a take off on Sherlock Holmes.

  • Like 1
Posted

I think every couple detective show is a take off on Sherlock Holmes.

X-Files? ;)

Posted

 

I think every couple detective show is a take off on Sherlock Holmes.

X-Files? ;)

 

 

X-files

Remington Steele

Hart 2 Heart

Diamonds (Canadian show)

MacMillian and Wife

Moonlighting

 

I can't even remember them all anymore.

Posted (edited)

 

 


Are you saying that Dalgliesh and Morse are take-offs on Holmes? I've heard of both, especially Morse, but had never heard that particular description of either. Or are you merely saying that they all have one trait in common, that of being a lone genius detective?

You are right, dear Carol, I corrected my previous post to reflect the appellation, but both characters owe a lot to Holmes the character. Dalgliesh has this inner core of "alone protects me", the way he sometimes treats his subordinates is imperious and demanding, he cannot abide fools, he essentially works alone despite the whole Scotland Yard setting, he is fiercely protective of anyone he takes under his wing and he has as much intellectual arrogance as Sherlock, though he expends his inner turmoil in writing poetry which is good enough to get published.
Morse, on the other hand, is much more intuitive and impatient and bustles about, with his sidekick, Sergeant Lewis being led a merry dance from one case to another as Morse tries out theories the same way Sherlock conducts experiments and he usually finds the solution in such a typically modern Sherlock revelation that I cannot help but smile when I see BC have the same moments of epiphany. Morse is an opera buff and a Wagner lover, like the original Holmes, who at the end of The Red Circle exclaims"By the way, it is not eight o'clock, and a Wagner night at Covent Garden! If we hurry, we might be in time for the second act."

Edited by Carol the Dabbler
Repaired quote codes
  • Like 1
Posted

Sherlock Holmes is recognised as being one of the original detectives, though I think Doyle based him on an Edgar Allen Poe character...I mean the crime fiction part, we know the man is Doyle's old medical tutor.

But I contend that all following detectives are based on Holmes.

Posted

I basically think ALL detective shows owe something to the original great detective, Sherlock Holmes, and I also think forensic science owes a huge debt to the fictional character.

  • Like 2
Posted

I suppose all detective shows (and books) owe something to Conan Doyle in the sense that he popularized detective fiction, thus basically inventing the genre.  But only certain fictional detectives are obvious Holmes types -- the usual example being House, of course.  I don't see much Holmes in Jessica Fletcher or Lt. Columbo, except in the sense that they notice things.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

And his long-suffering friend is Dr J. Wilson! House is definitely the medical equivalent of Holmes in his self-confidence, his willingness to experiment until he gets the result he wants, his isolation and drug-addiction, his musical interests (guitar, this time), his propensity to hoodwink staff, his boss and above all Wilson to reach his goals. Hugh Laurie is another versatile English actor of great calibre!

  • Like 1
Posted

Joanneta1, you would definitely enjoy the mashup video on Youtube of SHERLOCK-HOUSE-FORTYSOMETHING. I'd post a link but my computer is being a bit iffy with Shockwave.  But it's on this forum somewhere.  Maybe someone can find it.

 

Ah... here it is... enjoy.

 

  • Like 3
Posted

Preparations have begun at "221B Baker Street"

 

https://twitter.com/HiddlesPuddles/status/563374127512580098

Did you notice the comment though? Something about having a Victorian-style "Baker Street" sign in the truck. :wtf:

Posted

I didn't, Arcadia!  If they roll out the TARDIS, lemme know...  :P

  • Like 2
Posted

Up until this moment I thought that, at least, was an impossibility. Now I'm beginning to wonder.....

Posted

No, no tardis.  Of course they would have to do a Victorian front door to show the Victorian Holmes and Watson going in and out.

Posted

No, no tardis.  Of course they would have to do a Victorian front door to show the Victorian Holmes and Watson going in and out.

Erm... I think some of us were hoping that going to the Baker St. location would mean they were back in the modern era..... with, y'know, curls....

  • Like 3
Posted

 

No, no tardis.  Of course they would have to do a Victorian front door to show the Victorian Holmes and Watson going in and out.

Erm... I think some of us were hoping that going to the Baker St. location would mean they were back in the modern era..... with, y'know, curls....

 

 

Can somebody please do a Sherlock parady  on ALL ABOUT THE BASE but make it ALL ABOUT THE CURLS

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.