Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm intrigued by the street scene with the portion of the room... 

 

I think that's got to be almost a mind palace thing where he's working out a crime.

Posted

 

I don't see the problem here! J.P. travelled to London for the convention, Poland is next door, can be reached by train from Stuttgart! Surely, a two-day leave would not be so hard to arrange! The same way I shall try to go to Denmark, based on Toby's reassurance about subtitles. When there's a will, there's a way, and we are quite obstreperous, dedicated fans, after all!

Besides, they keep announcing deals with additional countries. Surely they're working toward something in Germany!

 

. . Keep Calm . .

. . . . . and . . . . .

. Watch the List .

 

  • Like 2
Posted

OK! What gives with the trailer aired this morning on BBC One?

If they have gone and ripped off The Noble Bachelor, Mummy Holmes's threat of turning really monstrous will be as nothing to the acerbity, acidity and derision heaped on TAB by Sherlock Holmes fans, as opposed to Messers Moffat and Gatiss's creation!

Posted

OK! What gives with the trailer aired this morning on BBC One?

 

Do you mean this one? https://www.facebook.com/Sherlock.BBCW/videos/vb.163565280410742/764306653669932/?type=2&theater&notif_t=notify_me_page

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Exactly, dear Arcadia! Anyone who has seen the Noble Bachelor will recognise the " dead" line said by Lord St.Simon to his second wife, before the whole edifice of the chapel ruin comes tumbling down on him!

What are they driving at, besides driving us to distraction with their allusions, red herrings and general disregard for their mainland Europe audience?

  • Like 1
Posted

Inge, you have me really puzzled.  :huh:  It's been my understanding all along that Sherlock is meant have some plots loosely based on Conan Doyle's stories, plus some new plots in the style of Conan Doyle, and also lots of little tidbits from various Conan Doyle stories.  I enjoy the combination, and am amused and delighted when I recognize one of those little tidbits.  However, you seem to be annoyed by them, and that's what puzzles me.

 

Near as I can figure, you think that Sherlock should be either a faithful reproduction of the Conan Doyle stories (but Jeremy Brett's already done that) or else something entirely original (in which case why call it Sherlock?).  Or am I missing your actual opinion?

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh dear! No, Carol, I watch and rewatch and try to make sense of the three seasons up to now, hope to be around to watch S4 when it finally materialises! But that doesn't mean that all Sherlock Holmes adaptations to date rate equally in my personal scale based on quality, inventiveness, interpretation and overall wit. I particularly dislike being led a merry dance for the sake of marketing, and please remember that I fell victim to all the hype about their personally selected stories and their so-called "prefaces"!

Also, on principle, I dislike hypocrisy: either they are true fan boys with the means and the wherewithal to indulge their inner fan by modernising their alleged boyhood hero for the 20th century, or they stick to the tried and tested Victorian-Edwardian Sherlock Holmes version. Neither fish nor fowl is more than a bit NOT GOOD!

In your innmost thoughts, would you, as a real Sherlock Holmes fan, rate S3 as highly as S1 & S2, overall, despite TBB?

  • Like 2
Posted

In your innmost thoughts, would you, as a real Sherlock Holmes fan, rate S3 as highly as S1 & S2, overall, despite TBB?

 

First, I'm not sure I qualify as "a real Sherlock Holmes fan."  I had seen and greatly enjoyed the Brett series when it was on PBS, and likewise an assortment of Holmes-based movies, but I wasn't hooked on any of them.  I was immediately hooked on Sherlock from the very first episode.  But I had never read a single one of the Conan Doyle stories until the Moftisses announced their three clue words for Series 2.  Even I, neophyte that I was, had absorbed enough Holmesian lore by cultural osmosis to deduce that the new episodes would be based on "Scandal in Bohemia," "The Hound of the Baskervilles," and "The Final Problem," so I dug out my father's old Baring-Gould annotated set and read those three stories (though I got bogged down about halfway through "Hound").  Alex was also interested, so I read the two short stories aloud to him, and we discussed them as we went along.  That's how I became something of a Conan Doyle fan (though I still prefer Sherlock).

 

Now I wish that I could answer your question!  I still don't know quite what to make of S3, and I suspect that's at least partly because I engaged in forum discussion immediately after watching the episodes -- whereas with the first two series, I had plenty of time to digest the episodes and develop my own opinions, because the forum didn't even exist till after S2.

 

Come to think of it, outside influence seems to be my main problem with all the series.  I liked "Blind Banker" just fine till I read a deadly-accurate parody, and after that all I could see was its shortcomings.  I might have liked "Scandal in Belgravia" just fine had I not been expecting something more like "Scandal in Bohemia," so you may blame Sir ACD's influence there.  Likewise with HLV -- I had read his original "Sign" and didn't care for what Moftiss did with Mary any better than I had liked what they did with Irene.

 

I think that for me, the secret to enjoying Sherlock may be to have no expectations whatsoever.  That's not the same not having high expectations, let me hasten to add.  I'm not saying I should expect the worst, but rather that I should not expect anything in particular, just as was the case when I watched S1.  And even after watching a new series, I should probably avoid the spoiler threads for a while, till my own take on the episodes has had a chance to gel.

  • Like 2
Posted

Ooops! Then the problem lies with me! I'm so sorry, my lovely, patient, witty waterfowl princess! As I introduced ACD to the youngsters quite early on, so my father used the Sherlock Holmes 'canon' , along with all Erle Stanley Gardner crime stories to get me to improve my English! I have been reading them independently since about fourteen, and I re-read all 56 stories once a year, the same as the whole Commissaire Maigret for French. I cannot remember how many times I have watched the entire JB series!

I came to Sherlock when it aired (dubbed), got the original DVDs, and the rest is history, as they say! I got hooked on S1, loved S2 up to the end of HOB, loathed parts of TRF, and when S3 came around I bought the DVDs, the calendar, the DVD Special Edition, you name it! My expectations were getting higher and higher, until they plummeted with SoT and most definitely with HLV! Not just Mary as Mrs Smith, but Sherlock Holmes, the quintessence of a thinking machine pulling a gun and committing (justifiable) homicide?

So, now, I'm going to go for every spoiler, teaser, what have you, available, despite having already pre-ordered my DVD copy, and try to piece their little ploy together. But, I shall heed your very logical advice, and have no expectations whatsoever!

  • Like 1
Posted

I shall heed your very logical advice, and have no expectations whatsoever!

 

Well, good luck with that!  :D   (To both of us, actually....)

  • Like 3
Posted

The latest trailer/teaser did nothing to endear the creators to a hard-core Sherlock Holmes fan like me, either! I shall dutifully watch their Special, but the glaringly obvious ignorance of ACD background stories is the main reason I visit this forum only occasionally, so I have no expectations, either! I shall dutifully escort my party of four to the local cinema which is showing TAB,  and be very careful not to spoil their fun by snorting in derision or chortling with glee at any hijinx the creators have thought up. After all, it's the season to be jolly and forgive and forget past insults (to your intelligence)!

  • Like 1
Posted

I think you might be onto something Carol -- I know I've often said that the only movie I've seen that I thought was as good as the book it was based on is To Kill a Mockingbird. Everything else has suffered by comparison. I loved Dances with Wolves the movie, so I read the book, and was disappointed. I know the Lord of the Rings novels practically by heart, and was disappointed in the movies (not nearly as disappointed as I was by The Hobbit movies, though!) I recognize that they were in some ways brilliant, but they weren't my version of Lord of the Rings.
 
Love The Searchers movie, disappointed upon reading the book. Love Shane the novel, disappointed by the movie. (Sorry, can't think of more recent examples but I know they exist! :D ) Saw Sherlock; loved it. Read a bit of ACD Holmes; didn't get much out of it. Etc etc etc.
 
This isn't a commentary on the quality of any of these books or movies, though. I just became attached to one version, and it sort of spoiled the other version for me. So I either need to stop reading books, or stop watching movies; or learn to live with disappointment! :p Or learn to detach myself from the version I'm familiar with. Hmmmm......

  • Like 4
Posted

One cannot simply stop reading books just because someone else may decide to make film versions of the same! Suspension of belief can only go so far, as well!

Posted

[...] my father used the Sherlock Holmes 'canon' , along with all Erle Stanley Gardner crime stories to get me to improve my English! I have been reading them independently since about fourteen, and I re-read all 56 stories once a year, the same as the whole Commissaire Maigret for French. I cannot remember how many times I have watched the entire JB series!

I came to Sherlock when it aired (dubbed), got the original DVDs, and the rest is history, as they say! I got hooked on S1, loved S2 up to the end of HOB, loathed parts of TRF[....]

 

[...] I've often said that the only movie I've seen that I thought was as good as the book it was based on is To Kill a Mockingbird. Everything else has suffered by comparison. I loved Dances with Wolves the movie, so I read the book, and was disappointed. I know the Lord of the Rings novels practically by heart, and was disappointed in the movies (not nearly as disappointed as I was by The Hobbit movies, though!) I recognize that they were in some ways brilliant, but they weren't my version of Lord of the Rings.

 

[...] Saw Sherlock; loved it. Read a bit of ACD Holmes; didn't get much out of it. Etc etc etc.

 

This isn't a commentary on the quality of any of these books or movies, though. I just became attached to one version, and it sort of spoiled the other version for me. So I either need to stop reading books, or stop watching movies; or learn to live with disappointment! :P Or learn to detach myself from the version I'm familiar with. Hmmmm......

 

One cannot simply stop reading books just because someone else may decide to make film versions of the same! Suspension of belief can only go so far, as well!

 

Aye, there's the rub!  I've gotten to the point where I'll check the Amazon reviews for the "other" version (book or movie, as the case may be) before actually reading / watching it, paying special attention to *why* people don't like it.  Then if I consider their reasons irrelevant, I'll go ahead with the other version.

 

I enjoyed Elementary right up to the second-season finale, when they revealed that

 

Irene Adler was actually Jamie Moriarty,

 

at which point I simply gave up on the whole show.  If I had *not* already been familiar with other versions of the Holmes stories (including, by that time, the relevant portions of canon), I suspect I'd have tolerated that plot point fairly well (even if I did still find it a little over-the-top).  By comparison, we've been watching Monk (on DVD) and we're enjoying it greatly.  The lead characters are similar in many ways to Elementary's Sherlock and Joan, but none of the characters have Holmesian names, so my expectations don't clash with the show's plots.

 

Inge, I can see that you're in a tough spot!  My advice would be, keep watching Sherlock only for as long as you're enjoying it.  If it gets to the point (and judging by your comments, it's pretty close already) where you find it more distressing than enjoyable, then for your own well-being, just stop!

  • Like 2
Posted

I think you might be onto something Carol -- I know I've often said that the only movie I've seen that I thought was as good as the book it was based on is To Kill a Mockingbird. Everything else has suffered by comparison. I loved Dances with Wolves the movie, so I read the book, and was disappointed. I know the Lord of the Rings novels practically by heart, and was disappointed in the movies (not nearly as disappointed as I was by The Hobbit movies, though!) I recognize that they were in some ways brilliant, but they weren't my version of Lord of the Rings.

 

Love The Searchers movie, disappointed upon reading the book. Love Shane the novel, disappointed by the movie. (Sorry, can't think of more recent examples but I know they exist! :D ) Saw Sherlock; loved it. Read a bit of ACD Holmes; didn't get much out of it. Etc etc etc.

 

This isn't a commentary on the quality of any of these books or movies, though. I just became attached to one version, and it sort of spoiled the other version for me. So I either need to stop reading books, or stop watching movies; or learn to live with disappointment! :P Or learn to detach myself from the version I'm familiar with. Hmmmm......

 

This is exactly why I usually stay away from literary adaptations, at least if I liked the book. Or, if I have that option, I watch the film / series first and then read the book.

 

I didn't want to see Sherlock at all originally. I was actually convinced because it was modern and so would be sufficiently different from the Doyle stories that I could file it away as "inspired by". But then I fell in love with it and I personally think Sherlock is a much better TV series than the Sherlock Holmes stories are a book series, but that's personal taste, obviously.

 

Now I've become so used to Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman as Sherlock and John that I'm thrilled to soon see them as Mr Holmes and Dr Watson as well, and I swear I will print out screen shots and glue them into my books as illustrations - never liked the real ones, anyway.

 

  • Like 5
Posted

Dear Carol and TOBY, your advice and personal views matter to me, because you and Arcadia, SherlockedCamper,J.P. ShadowDweller, sfmpco and a few others make this forum an interesting, home-from-home occupied by intelligent, perspicacious, well-informed 'neighbours'. I never read or watch any Sherlock Holmes adaptation or story for entertainment: I do so because, like the modern Irene Adler, I like detective stories and detectives (in fiction)!

My absolute favourites are Adam Dalgliesh, Jules Maigret, Father Brown, Perry Mason and E. Morse. This modern parody of Holmes is simply what is available at the moment, and shall, in time, join all other adaptations in what shall pass for IMDb at the end of the century, having left its mark, just like all those preceding it and, no doubt following it. So, I watch and re-watch it for want of something better!

Enjoy it? What do you mean enjoy it? I'm ADDICTED to it up to and including HOB.

One thing I sometimes wish I could watch is Dr Gil Grissom dealing with this infantilised version of Sherlock, instead of the hapless Anderson! A Holmes-like rapier wit against a ridiculous caricature of the archetype!

I shall duly watch the Special, heeding your advice about no expectations, but I'm afraid that the Victorian setting is just a smokescreen, a red herring, like a Russian Babuschka doll, just the outermost shell. In any case, you will know much earlier. :evilmoff:

  • Like 1
Posted

Enjoy it? What do you mean enjoy it? I'm ADDICTED to it up to HOB.

 

What was it about HoB that "cured" your addiction?

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh, TRF "cured" me of my addiction! Should that read 'up to and including HOB'? I shall edit appropriately, then. Just because ACD had left a loophole in The Last Problem, by killing off Holmes off-screen, Mr Moffat explained in the commentary that they were going to do it on screen and with very few ways out, just to leave the fans hanging in there! Pure marketing ploy, once again, leaving hundreds of people coming up with improbable rescue measures, including their own Big Blue. Suspension of belief can only go so far, as I have said before!

S1 is irreplaceable, full of verve, drive, new concepts, S2 is starting to find a pace, hits all the right spots, and then...

I believe VBS has termed what happened in TRF Cumbersplat, which should actually read Sherlocksplat, taking all my hopes for something new and inventive along in that swan dive; S3 attempts a kickstart with TEH, but plummets, exactly like Sherlock at the end of TRF, in SoT. When both the creators KNOW from A Scandal in Bohemia that you don't need a best man, or a large wedding reception, and yet indulge in puerile games of forcing the greatest crime solver in fiction to look up folding serviettes on YouTube for the sake of a cheap laugh! Yeah, right!

  • Like 1
Posted

OK, so you prefer that your Holmeses hew a bit closer to the Conan Doyle line.  I personally felt that "Reichenbach" did a good job of adapting what was originally just a brief story intended to kill off the detective for real, and also a good job of fleshing out Moriarty.  But yeah, Series 3 has wandered pretty far away from both Conan Doyle and the show's own precedent.  As long as it's interesting and has some humor, I don't mind too awful much, though I do prefer the S1 - S2 tone myself.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

It's just another adaptation in a very l o n g list of adaptations! In time, along with the rest, it will be shelved and resurrected only as an aberration due to the modernisation attempt; nothing more, nothing less! However, trailers, teasers and snippets do not actually add up to more than about five minutes' worth of air-time, so, apart from no expectations whatsoever, I shall be keeping my fingers crossed during the film version.

Posted

It's interesting that fans can have such profoundly different reactions to the material.  For myself, I read all the ACD stories when I was in my early teens, about 50 years ago, and fell in love with both Mr Holmes and Dr Watson.  Since then, I've watched various adaptations - obviously, the Jeremy Brett version was very good, although I'll always have a soft spot for Douglas Wilmer and Nigel Stock.  I'm also old enough to remember the UK copyright expiring and the subsequent flood of pastiches, sequels, etc.  I've read a lot of them because I'm addicted to the characters, even though some of the stuff was pretty bad and must have had poor old ACD turning in his grave.  Laurie King's Mary Russell books were probably the best, though the series has gone steadily downhill.  So I didn't have great hopes of Sherlock before it aired.  Now I consider it to be the only really successful non-ACD version of Holmes.

 

Why?  Well, obviously it's well-made and beautifully acted, but that wouldn't make it unique.  One reason is that it takes very familiar characters and puts an original slant on them, without making them positively unrecognisable.  (Like Mycroft, for instance, in Elementary.  That one had me screaming at the tv.  As for their Moriarty, the least said the better!)  Another is that it is unpredictable without being totally irrational.  I like it when I can't predict what will happen, but not when it makes no sense at all.  (Yes, I admit there have been moments in Sherlock that defy logic - such as "How would he have survived the Fall if Moriarty, instead of killing himself, had stood on the roof and watched?") but, in general, the plots do hang together.  I also like that fact that, very often, it is genuinely funny.  I don't think we should underestimate the value of humour, as the brightness serves to make the dark moments even darker.  And I have to say that I enjoy all the little references to the ACD canon.  To create something original and yet pay homage to the source material seems, to me, to be quite a difficult thing to achieve.  It doesn't bother me if these references appear in places where they would not appear in the ACD stories.  I don't see this writing as a rip-off of Doyle, but as the writers having fun and, hopefully, communicating this playfulness to the fans.

 

What matters, I think, is that the essential characters of Holmes and Watson are preserved and that their friendship remains central.  Other than that, Sherlock can fold napkins and make speeches, dash around in a Belstaff or an Inverness cape, have his hair slick and straight or long and curly, swan-dive off roofs or retreat to his mind palace, and I'm happy to go along for the ride.  I'll even grit my teeth and bear it when I do feel he does something he shouldn't, such as solve a problem with a gun rather than with logic, because there is enough of the essential Sherlock Holmes there to make it worth watching.  And I'll be glued to my tv set on New Year's Day, pretty sure that I'm going to be entranced and entertained, even if there are plenty of points which infuriate me enough to make me come here and start arguing about them...

  • Like 8
Posted

I admit there have been moments in Sherlock that defy logic - such as "How would he have survived the Fall if Moriarty, instead of killing himself, had stood on the roof and watched?"

 

Sherlock told Anderson that he had multiple plans prepared.  So if Moriarty had stuck around, Sherlock would presumably have switched to plan 17D -- not that we'll ever know what that was (other than fodder for fan fiction).

  • Like 3
Posted

It's interesting that fans can have such profoundly different reactions to the material.  For myself, I read all the ACD stories when I was in my early teens, about 50 years ago, and fell in love with both Mr Holmes and Dr Watson.  Since then, I've watched various adaptations - obviously, the Jeremy Brett version was very good, although I'll always have a soft spot for Douglas Wilmer and Nigel Stock.  I'm also old enough to remember the UK copyright expiring and the subsequent flood of pastiches, sequels, etc.  I've read a lot of them because I'm addicted to the characters, even though some of the stuff was pretty bad and must have had poor old ACD turning in his grave.  Laurie King's Mary Russell books were probably the best, though the series has gone steadily downhill.  So I didn't have great hopes of Sherlock before it aired.  Now I consider it to be the only really successful non-ACD version of Holmes.

 

Why?  Well, obviously it's well-made and beautifully acted, but that wouldn't make it unique.  One reason is that it takes very familiar characters and puts an original slant on them, without making them positively unrecognisable.  (Like Mycroft, for instance, in Elementary.  That one had me screaming at the tv.  As for their Moriarty, the least said the better!)  Another is that it is unpredictable without being totally irrational.  I like it when I can't predict what will happen, but not when it makes no sense at all.  (Yes, I admit there have been moments in Sherlock that defy logic - such as "How would he have survived the Fall if Moriarty, instead of killing himself, had stood on the roof and watched?") but, in general, the plots do hang together.  I also like that fact that, very often, it is genuinely funny.  I don't think we should underestimate the value of humour, as the brightness serves to make the dark moments even darker.  And I have to say that I enjoy all the little references to the ACD canon.  To create something original and yet pay homage to the source material seems, to me, to be quite a difficult thing to achieve.  It doesn't bother me if these references appear in places where they would not appear in the ACD stories.  I don't see this writing as a rip-off of Doyle, but as the writers having fun and, hopefully, communicating this playfulness to the fans.

 

What matters, I think, is that the essential characters of Holmes and Watson are preserved and that their friendship remains central.  Other than that, Sherlock can fold napkins and make speeches, dash around in a Belstaff or an Inverness cape, have his hair slick and straight or long and curly, swan-dive off roofs or retreat to his mind palace, and I'm happy to go along for the ride.  I'll even grit my teeth and bear it when I do feel he does something he shouldn't, such as solve a problem with a gun rather than with logic, because there is enough of the essential Sherlock Holmes there to make it worth watching.  And I'll be glued to my tv set on New Year's Day, pretty sure that I'm going to be entranced and entertained, even if there are plenty of points which infuriate me enough to make me come here and start arguing about them...

:Worship:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 117 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.