Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

In the "Funniest Moments on Set" video that comes up after that one (but which I cannot seem to link to), there's a new face, who I believe is mentioned somewhere along the line as Tim McInnerny.  Den of Geek had this to say about his role:  "Lately, we've learnt that Blackadder alumnus Tim McInnerny (he most famously played Lord Percy Percy and Captain Darling in the BBC comedy) will be appearing as Sir Edwin, a name shared with Simon Kunz' character from His Last Vow. Is that just a coincidence? It would seem unlikely."

 

But IMDb does not yet list him in the cast.  (Maybe he's some relation to Martin Freeman's character in Captain America.)

 

  • Like 1
Posted

As well as portraying the inimitable Percy, not to mention Captain Darling, Tim McInnerny was also in the Jeremy Brett series of the Sherlock Holmes stories.  He played John Clay in "The Red-Headed League," a story I always liked for its sheer silliness.  Apparently, it was one of ACD's favourites as well.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

As well as portraying the inimitable Percy, not to mention Captain Darling, Tim McInnerny was also in the Jeremy Brett series of the Sherlock Holmes stories.  He played John Clay in "The Red-Headed League," a story I always liked for its sheer silliness.  Apparently, it was one of ACD's favourites as well.

 

That story certainly does abound in "sheer silliness" -- I keep wanting to slap some common sense into the client!

 

Thanks for alerting us to Mr. McInnerny's prior Conan-Doyle ties.  Wonder if he'll play a villain this time around?

Posted

It's interesting that fans can have such profoundly different reactions to the material.  For myself, I read all the ACD stories when I was in my early teens, about 50 years ago, and fell in love with both Mr Holmes and Dr Watson.  Since then, I've watched various adaptations - obviously, the Jeremy Brett version was very good, although I'll always have a soft spot for Douglas Wilmer and Nigel Stock.  I'm also old enough to remember the UK copyright expiring and the subsequent flood of pastiches, sequels, etc.  I've read a lot of them because I'm addicted to the characters, even though some of the stuff was pretty bad and must have had poor old ACD turning in his grave.  Laurie King's Mary Russell books were probably the best, though the series has gone steadily downhill.  So I didn't have great hopes of Sherlock before it aired.  Now I consider it to be the only really successful non-ACD version of Holmes.

 

Why?  Well, obviously it's well-made and beautifully acted, but that wouldn't make it unique.  One reason is that it takes very familiar characters and puts an original slant on them, without making them positively unrecognisable.  (Like Mycroft, for instance, in Elementary.  That one had me screaming at the tv.  As for their Moriarty, the least said the better!)  Another is that it is unpredictable without being totally irrational.  I like it when I can't predict what will happen, but not when it makes no sense at all.  (Yes, I admit there have been moments in Sherlock that defy logic - such as "How would he have survived the Fall if Moriarty, instead of killing himself, had stood on the roof and watched?") but, in general, the plots do hang together.  I also like that fact that, very often, it is genuinely funny.  I don't think we should underestimate the value of humour, as the brightness serves to make the dark moments even darker.  And I have to say that I enjoy all the little references to the ACD canon.  To create something original and yet pay homage to the source material seems, to me, to be quite a difficult thing to achieve.  It doesn't bother me if these references appear in places where they would not appear in the ACD stories.  I don't see this writing as a rip-off of Doyle, but as the writers having fun and, hopefully, communicating this playfulness to the fans.

 

What matters, I think, is that the essential characters of Holmes and Watson are preserved and that their friendship remains central.  Other than that, Sherlock can fold napkins and make speeches, dash around in a Belstaff or an Inverness cape, have his hair slick and straight or long and curly, swan-dive off roofs or retreat to his mind palace, and I'm happy to go along for the ride.  I'll even grit my teeth and bear it when I do feel he does something he shouldn't, such as solve a problem with a gun rather than with logic, because there is enough of the essential Sherlock Holmes there to make it worth watching.  And I'll be glued to my tv set on New Year's Day, pretty sure that I'm going to be entranced and entertained, even if there are plenty of points which infuriate me enough to make me come here and start arguing about them...

 

... and I am looking forward to reading your thoughts on it once you've seen it. Good to have you back!

 

I agree whole-heartedly with what you said above.

 

 

Posted

Haven't seen this pic of Watson. But then, I decided to avoid more information/spoilers. It's only 2 weeks. EEEEEEK! panic.gif

 

Very nice!  I'd never noticed his sideburns before -- not that he'd get anywhere in a competition with Lestrade!

Posted

Thanks, T.o.b.y!  I'm sure we are going to have a lot to discuss after we've seen The Abominable Bride.  Hopefully, enough to keep us going until Series 4.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

A few things were new to me, at least:

 

 

 

Watson's chrome MacBook has been replaced by a clunking manual typewriter. The bison skull on the wall no longer wears its ironic headphones....

 

 

 

Cumberbatch deploys his most diplomatic smile when quizzed on how this slice of Victoriana ties into the show’s present-day setting, [...] conceding only that while the trip into the 19th century “is a great deal of fun, it does advance things. It’s not just on its own.”

 

 

 

Freeman [...] says, “We’re trying not to be too winky about it, and too self-knowing."

 

 

 

Cumberbatch has period arcana to deal with, including a fancy meerschaum that is, he notes darkly, “a pyrotechnic pipe. That doesn’t mean it blows up in my face. I’m just not smoking.”
Posted

What was new to me (in addition to Carol's list) was

It is widely believed that the fourth season of Sherlock may be its last

 

 

Widely believed by whom??

Posted
It is widely believed that the fourth season of Sherlock may be its last

 

Widely believed by whom??

 

By people who keep quoting other people who keep quoting other people who....

 

I've been hearing that ever since Series 3, I think.  In fact, I believe they were saying the same thing about Series 3.

  • Like 2
Posted

I haven't seen anything from Mofftiss to indicate that 4 is the last.  I'm operating under the assumption we'll at least get a season 5 also.

Posted

My understanding from some past interview was that Moftiss had an idea where they want to go with series 4 & 5 assuming the BBC signed on for it to go that far. So at this point it might be partially up to the BBC for there to be a S5 not just actors' schedules.

Posted

That's been my understanding as well -- they have a story arc in mind at least through the end of a S5. And BC's clearly willing.

Posted

That's been my understanding as well -- they have a story arc in mind at least through the end of a S5. And BC's clearly willing.

 

Ditto MF.  And speaking of the alphabet, the BBC (and PBS) would be idiots to pull the plug on such a popular show.

  • Like 4
Posted

If you want really long-running, regular shows (one season per year), then it's not Auntie Beeb you want! Talking of Holmes, it was Granada which produced all series from 1985 to 1995. It was an independent production company which created eight seasons of House MD, as many for Downtown Abbey, seven seasons of Star Trek The Next Generation, nine seasons of Dalgliesh, with a change in the male lead, innumerable Morse, Kavanagh Q.C., nine seasons of Lewis (ITV), and so on and so forth. And if they are going to wait three years between series, some of their original audience will have dropped off the twig, including the series' "not their housekeeper". Life happens, Sherlock became a phenomenon, hopefully it will remain good to its last minute, but it will eventually pass into film history, like all its predecessors and all its successors. May we all be around to watch S4, at least!

  • Like 2
Posted

Actually, Sherlock is not produced by the BBC either, it's produced by Hartswood, an independent company.  But it is indeed the BBC that calls the shots as to length of each episode and how many per series -- because they're the "customer."

 

Who first broadcast the Brett series?

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

10 days!!!!!

  • Like 4
Posted

Actually, Sherlock is not produced by the BBC either, it's produced by Hartswood, an independent company. But it is indeed the BBC that calls the shots as to length of each episode and how many per series -- because they're the "customer."

 

Who first broadcast the Brett series?

That series was made and broadcast by ITV. The BBC can be infuriating - I have never forgiven them for cancelling The Hour, which was an excellent series - but it makes some high quality programmes and usually recognises when it has a hit like Sherlock on its hands. I think that, when it is unable to recommision a series, the problem is often funding. It is a public service broadcaster and doesn't have to kowtow to advertisers, but it does have to deal with the government which controls its funding through the licence fees. The BBC usually manages to annoy whichever party is in power but the Conservatives particularly hate it, and they are ( unfortunately) our ruling party at the moment.

 

Given that antipathy, plus the general economic climate, and the BBC isn't exactly rolling in money at the moment. On the other hand, a hit like Sherlock must generate quite a bit of income through overseas sales, merchandising, etc, so hopefully they will be able to keep backing it.

  • Like 4
Posted

Here's a bit of the Special's background from Steven Moffat:

 

 

 

We’d been talking for ages, [asking], ‘Could we ever justify a 10-minute sequence where they dress up just for the hell of it?’ Then, we thought, ‘You know what? We’ve got this special to make, why don’t we just blatantly do the whole thing Victorian?

 

Then, we had to sort of justify that. We had to say, ‘Well, what can we get out of that that we can’t get out of our modern series?’ and really, the one thing that doesn’t travel to the modern day about Sherlock Holmes is the Victorian ghost story.

 

So apparently they were already committed to do a special before they decided to do something Victorian.

 

  • Like 3
Posted

:huh: Good thing they have plenty of self-confidence! Although ... don't forget Mr. Moffat tends to favor hyperbole, maybe things aren't quite what they sound like.... ??

  • Like 2
Posted

from Sherlockology:
 
tumblr_nzwpozzHdq1qkgkowo1_500.jpg
 

A very Merry Christmas from all of us at Sherlockology… and the best present arrives in 7 days - new Sherlock!

  • Like 4
Posted

from Sherlockology:
 
tumblr_nzym1jYwqs1qkgkowo1_500.jpg
 

6 days until the debut of Sherlock: The Abominable Bride in the UK on BBC One and in the USA on Masterpiece PBS!

  • Like 1
Posted

*Big Sigh*... Add 20 days for me. I just pre-ordered the DVD, and it won't arrive before Jan 20th. If it reaches me at all... because it's a UK import, the film hasn't been given an age rating yet in Germany, meaning it will be subjected to the same regulations as porn and hardcore slasher movies. I would have to be home when the mail comes and that isn't likely on a week day. I considered having it shipped to my parents, but I don't really want their neighbors getting weird ideas about them (as for my neighbors, I don't really care that much).

 

For a while, I was hoping I could see it at the cinema in Denmark, but there really isn't much of a chance that my family would accept me driving off across the border on my own, leaving them to celebrate the holiday by themselves, nor would anyone want to come with me. So I guess I'll just have to wait it out... Or find an internet-solution that isn't downright illegal and / or guaranteed to bring me a virus. (Much easier to retreat to my room around 9 p.m. on the first than to drive off to Denmark... I can easily fake a headache or extreme tiredness.)

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 104 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.