Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

But how did he help her do that? What did she understand after he found her in her room that she didn't understand before?

 

Sherlock solved her riddle and understood the context behind what Euros was doing. Then he told her it wasn't too late for her and Sherlock still loved her?

 

I don't think there was any deep profound meaning to it. It's just the typical love conquers all ending. I mean what else can you possibly make out from the dialogue:

 

SHERLOCK: Look how brilliant you are. Your mind has created the perfect metaphor. You’re high above us, all alone in the sky, and you understand everything except how to land. (He shifts round and sits down in front of her, breathless and anxious.) Now, I’m just an idiot, but I’m on the ground. (He reaches out and puts his fingers onto her hands.) I can bring you home.

EURUS (her eyes still closed, plaintively): No.

(Her voice reverts to its adult tone.)

EURUS: No, no. (She shivers.) It’s too late now.

SHERLOCK (shifting closer to her and lowering his hand): No it’s not. It’s not too late.

(She cries, her eyes screwed tight and her face twisted with fear.)

EURUS: Every time I close my eyes, I’m on the plane. I’m lost, lost in the sky and ... no-one can hear me.

(She pulls her knees closer to herself, crying silently. Sherlock reaches out and gently puts his hand onto hers again.)

SHERLOCK (in a whisper): Open your eyes. I’m here.

(She opens her eyes and slowly raises her head.)

SHERLOCK (in a whisper): You’re not lost any more.

(He shifts even closer and reaches out to embrace her. She shuffles forward and wraps her arms around him and they hug each other tightly while she cries.)

SHERLOCK (softly, stroking her hair): Now, you ... you just ... you just went the wrong way last time, that’s all. (His voice becomes tearful.) This time, get it right. (Still softly but more clearly) Tell me how to save my friend.

  • Like 3
Posted

I thought the context he gave her was in the form of making a connection with her himself. In much the same way that he and Mycroft give each other context, through both their connection and the fact they have things in common that the rest of the world wouldn't understand- due to both their intelligence and their common upbringing. When Mycroft took away Eurus' family, he robbed her of a sense of context within the world, and Sherlock was able to return that to her, or 'bring her home' metaphorically speaking.

  • Like 2
Posted

I thought the context he gave her was in the form of making a connection with her himself. In much the same way that he and Mycroft give each other context, through both their connection and the fact they have things in common that the rest of the world wouldn't understand- due to both their intelligence and their common upbringing. When Mycroft took away Eurus' family, he robbed her of a sense of context within the world, and Sherlock was able to return that to her, or 'bring her home' metaphorically speaking.

 

Just wondering: do you blame Mycroft for sending Euros to Sherrinford and hiding her from his family?

 

Honestly I think he made the right call for what he knew. They couldn't solve the puzzle so Mycroft could only act on what he could see of Euros. Euros was really dangerous and her parents would have been horrified if they heard of what a dangerous psychopath she had become.

Posted

That sort of scruffy look he had really worked for him, didn't it?

Yes! Definitely. Obviously. Absolutely. He looks... hot. :naughty:

 

Maybe take the gun away from him though, he's a menace with that thing. Oh, wait, Mrs. H has already done that, hasn't she? :smile:

Not for long. Mrs.H is good, but she can fool him twice. Anyway, I suppose he wanted it to happen, after all he predicted he would be in the therapist office since two weeks ago, and he was not going to walk there by himself. So he went berserk to push Mrs.H up to the edge? He probably has already known stuffs about her. Ha.. it's so fun, isn't it? :P

 

 

Just in reference to Sherlock and his parents... I was thinking about how he had said his mother understands very little- but when he says that he has no understanding himself that Eurus was a secret being kept from him (and in a sense by him, or part of his brain anyway).

 

I wonder if this affected how his parents treated him, and his impressions of them? They must have always considered him to have a slightly fragile mental state, on the verge of somehow remembering the Victor trauma. It might have meant they tried to shield him, or seemed obtuse when they were deliberately with-holding information that could trigger a memory for him.

 

I do find it strange that Mrs. Hudson seems closer to him than his own mother, though. Mrs. Holmes describing Sherlock as the 'adult' always throws me. It makes me think his family always expected more from him than he could deliver, somehow. Whereas, whenever Mrs. Huson makes an observation on Sherlock (it was her that called him 'emotional' I think?'), she gets it right on the money, with no muss, no fuss.

Agree. I love how she lectures Mycroft.

I think it must be very difficult for Sherlock to be the 'dumb' one, especially that he was an 'emotional' kid. He was probably very expressive before Redbeard happened, then suddenly shut down and became what he is. I can imagine Mycroft and his parents cracked their head trying to find 'the right way' to deal with him, but they never did and they don't know how to reach him, eventhough they try hard. Probably way too hard? What he actually needs is someone like Mrs.Hudson and John.

 

 

Just wondering: do you blame Mycroft for sending Euros to Sherrinford and hiding her from his family?

 

Honestly I think he made the right call for what he knew. They couldn't solve the puzzle so Mycroft could only act on what he could see of Euros. Euros was really dangerous and her parents would have been horrified if they heard of what a dangerous psychopath she had become.

I was thinking about this too.

I think it's harsh, probably a bit too harsh because as far we know, nobody really knew what happened with Redbeard, and they couldn't be sure that Eurus killed him. She was creepy and commited arson etc, but I don't think it's enough justification to pluck her away like that at that very young age.

Now, with the fact that she killed Redbeard and posed some threats to her family, I still not sure. She should be locked away, yes, I agree with that, but it's probably better if she's allowed contacts and interactions or attempts to understand how she thinks and whether there is a way to reform it. After all, she was a kid at that time. A kid! What I'm saying it, someone not murderous would probably turn murderous if they are treated that way, taken, locked and treated as experiment subjects where everyone that matters to her doesn't even know she still exists.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

I thought the context he gave her was in the form of making a connection with her himself. In much the same way that he and Mycroft give each other context, through both their connection and the fact they have things in common that the rest of the world wouldn't understand- due to both their intelligence and their common upbringing. When Mycroft took away Eurus' family, he robbed her of a sense of context within the world, and Sherlock was able to return that to her, or 'bring her home' metaphorically speaking.

Just wondering: do you blame Mycroft for sending Euros to Sherrinford and hiding her from his family?

 

Honestly I think he made the right call for what he knew. They couldn't solve the puzzle so Mycroft could only act on what he could see of Euros. Euros was really dangerous and her parents would have been horrified if they heard of what a dangerous psychopath she had become.

Mycroft is one of my favourite characters, but I think he made several wrong calls with Eurus. It wasn't his call to make, keeping her from her parents. I also think they already knew she was a psychopath, and were capable of compartmentalising that and spending time with her, as shown at the end. Taking their child from them is something he had no business doing, and he's not a father himself so he has no context to understand what he's doing. He also was just too arrogant in assuming he could contain her, doubly so if he was planning on doing favours for her like having her meet Moriarty. He basically destroyed any chance of maintaining the charade at that point- giving Sherlock's worst enemy the ammunition of a secret like that to use against him? He protected the family temporarily, but he also set them up for a spectacular fall. I do quite like the narrative effect of having the smartest character make one of the biggest mistakes in the show, but I definitely see it as a mistake.

 

I think he meant well, and he is more human to me now as a result of this episode.

  • Like 1
Posted

My take about Sherlock after S4... there are so much! I can't organize my head so I'd just blurt out whatever comes to mind.

It doesn't help that it takes me bloody long to construct a post with time I don't have.

 

So a couple of takes:

- regarding shooting the Big G. Sherlock is not allowed to do it, Eurus asks him to choose between Mycroft and John. Why?

Is it because she thinks he could do it? After Magnussen, and because Moriarty also thinks so? (The whole thing with side of angel but not one and he is capable to make Moriarty talks).

What do you guys think?

For me, I think he could do it.

It's horrendous, it's nightmare, but he would do it because there is no other way out, and he is willing to get his hands dirty to make things, better things, to his perception, works.

It's not ordinary, it's crazy, but I think that is the hero quality in him, eventhough it's probably more like anti-hero.

And if, he was the one who pulls the trigger, what would you guys think about him?

For me, I stand by what he did to Magnussen, and I stand by to this as well. It's not a pleasant thing to think about, at all.

 

- Aiz. He is the wisest man. Who writes this?!? I am so smitten.

Taking your own life. Taking it from who? Once it's over, it's not you who'll miss it.

Your own death is something that happens to everybody else.

He certainly doesn't think so in TRF, or understand the impact when he came back in TEH.

But now, all these. After Mary, and probably the unbearable pain after Redbeard in his subconsciousness.

He is the wisest man, isn't he? Just need more time to learn.

 

I recently read 'The Adventure of A Creeping Man', and there is a quote that I love and make me very appreciative with the wisdom of ACD/Sherlock as character:

There is a danger there - A very real danger to humanity. Consider, Watson, that the material, the sensual, the worldly would all prolong their worthless lives. The spiritual would not avoid the call of something higher. It would be survival of the least fit. What sort of cesspool may not our poor world become?

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

I thought the context he gave her was in the form of making a connection with her himself. In much the same way that he and Mycroft give each other context, through both their connection and the fact they have things in common that the rest of the world wouldn't understand- due to both their intelligence and their common upbringing. When Mycroft took away Eurus' family, he robbed her of a sense of context within the world, and Sherlock was able to return that to her, or 'bring her home' metaphorically speaking.

Just wondering: do you blame Mycroft for sending Euros to Sherrinford and hiding her from his family?

 

Honestly I think he made the right call for what he knew. They couldn't solve the puzzle so Mycroft could only act on what he could see of Euros. Euros was really dangerous and her parents would have been horrified if they heard of what a dangerous psychopath she had become.

Mycroft is one of my favourite characters, but I think he made several wrong calls with Eurus. It wasn't his call to make, keeping her from her parents. I also think they already knew she was a psychopath, and were capable of compartmentalising that and spending time with her, as shown at the end. Taking their child from them is something he had no business doing, and he's not a father himself so he has no context to understand what he's doing. He also was just too arrogant in assuming he could contain her, doubly so if he was planning on doing favours for her like having her meet Moriarty. He basically destroyed any chance of maintaining the charade at that point- giving Sherlock's worst enemy the ammunition of a secret like that to use against him? He protected the family temporarily, but he also set them up for a spectacular fall. I do quite like the narrative effect of having the smartest character make one of the biggest mistakes in the show, but I definitely see it as a mistake.

 

I think he meant well, and he is more human to me now as a result of this episode.

 

 

I think one of the main reasons why Mycroft didn't allow Euros to interact with other people was because of her mind control powers.

 

Remember Mycroft said that Euros could reprogramme people ever since she was 5 years old. Sian Brooke confirmed in an interview that Euros was 5 years old when she was taken away to be locked up. So Euros had her mind control abilities even when she was a kid. It made sense for Mycroft to basically not allow anyone to talk to her except himself.

 

Now you can argue that Sherlock and their parents may have been immune to her mind control techniques. However it would make sense for Mycroft to not want to risk the possibility anyway. After all Euros' mind control abilities might get stronger as she got older. You heard what Euros did to people who talked to her. What if she one day convinced Mr. and Mrs. Holmes to kill each other?

 

 

 

Also it's true that Mycroft let Moriarty speak to Euros for 5 minutes unsupervised but I wouldn't describe as what he did as giving ammunition. I mean Moriarty never brought up Euros with Sherlock although he could. You could argue that's a plot hole. I mean Moriarty likes messing with Sherlock. if he knew about Euros, then why didn't he ever talk to him about her?

 

I think that Moriarty- Euros connection was just poorly written and not given much thought. It looks like Moffatiss only gave them a connection because they wanted to foreshadow Euros' impending threat but they didn't want to give it away so they used Moriarty as a ruse (via his 'Miss me?' videos).

  • Like 2
Posted

Great minds think alike ... I was just musing on the same things as above, but I stuck it over in the Mycroft thread. I might bring it over here instead, but right now have to run off. Have fun, y'all.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

 

I thought the context he gave her was in the form of making a connection with her himself. In much the same way that he and Mycroft give each other context, through both their connection and the fact they have things in common that the rest of the world wouldn't understand- due to both their intelligence and their common upbringing. When Mycroft took away Eurus' family, he robbed her of a sense of context within the world, and Sherlock was able to return that to her, or 'bring her home' metaphorically speaking.

Just wondering: do you blame Mycroft for sending Euros to Sherrinford and hiding her from his family?

 

Honestly I think he made the right call for what he knew. They couldn't solve the puzzle so Mycroft could only act on what he could see of Euros. Euros was really dangerous and her parents would have been horrified if they heard of what a dangerous psychopath she had become.

Mycroft is one of my favourite characters, but I think he made several wrong calls with Eurus. It wasn't his call to make, keeping her from her parents. I also think they already knew she was a psychopath, and were capable of compartmentalising that and spending time with her, as shown at the end. Taking their child from them is something he had no business doing, and he's not a father himself so he has no context to understand what he's doing. He also was just too arrogant in assuming he could contain her, doubly so if he was planning on doing favours for her like having her meet Moriarty. He basically destroyed any chance of maintaining the charade at that point- giving Sherlock's worst enemy the ammunition of a secret like that to use against him? He protected the family temporarily, but he also set them up for a spectacular fall. I do quite like the narrative effect of having the smartest character make one of the biggest mistakes in the show, but I definitely see it as a mistake.

 

I think he meant well, and he is more human to me now as a result of this episode.

I think one of the main reasons why Mycroft didn't allow Euros to interact with other people was because of her mind control powers.

 

Remember Mycroft said that Euros could reprogramme people ever since she was 5 years old. Sian Brooke confirmed in an interview that Euros was 5 years old when she was taken away to be locked up. So Euros had her mind control abilities even when she was a kid. It made sense for Mycroft to basically not allow anyone to talk to her except himself.

 

Now you can argue that Sherlock and their parents may have been immune to her mind control techniques. However it would make sense for Mycroft to not want to risk the possibility anyway. After all Euros' mind control abilities might get stronger as she got older. You heard what Euros did to people who talked to her. What if she one day convinced Mr. and Mrs. Holmes to kill each other?

 

 

 

Also it's true that Mycroft let Moriarty speak to Euros for 5 minutes unsupervised but I wouldn't describe as what he did as giving ammunition. I mean Moriarty never brought up Euros with Sherlock although he could. You could argue that's a plot hole. I mean Moriarty likes messing with Sherlock. if he knew about Euros, then why didn't he ever talk to him about her?

 

I think that Moriarty- Euros connection was just poorly written and not given much thought. It looks like Moffatiss only gave them a connection because they wanted to foreshadow Euros' impending threat but they didn't want to give it away so they used Moriarty as a ruse (via his 'Miss me?' videos).

The problem with any excuse for Mycroft's cover up in terms of protecting the family is that he doesn't acknowledge his own susceptibility to Eurus' mind control. Which seems especially foolish and arrogant now that we know he handed Eurus the chance to meet Moriarty.

 

Moriarty does taunt Sherlock about Eurus, when he mentions the 'east wind's coming. And of course, he is present in that his brother assists Eurus in the 'Miss me?' message- and could help her in other ways in the future. Think of it this way, if you had a psychopathic sister with criminal leanings, would you introduce her to the head of a criminal network? How could that ever end well, especially when the contact was unsupervised? More arrogance from Mycroft, that he could somehow predict or handle the outcome.

 

I do agree that the writing is clumsy in parts, in that Eurus doesn't feel as well integrated into the past as she should- though there are those little mentions of Redbeard and the East wind. Then again, the point of her character is that she was cut out of Sherlock's memory with good reason, so they bought themselves some leeway with that.

 

I'm sorry, I'm conscious we should perhaps move this to the Mycroft thread! I had another point about Mycroft which I will post about over there.

 

Back on the topic of Sherlock, another of my favourite bits from TLD (Seriously, who is this man?):

 

tumblr_ojky29cZWx1teszvzo1_500.gif

Posted

It would take a bit more than a simple one-off blotting of that memory for Sherlock to have kept himself in the dark that long. A disappearance like that would be talked about in the area for years to come- and in the beginning surely Eurus' photographs and things- even her bedroom, would have still been in the house. It would have needed to be an almost wilful deletion, on a regular basis, to maintain the lack of awareness, for him. To support his delusion, the parents would have had to start hiding things.

 

As I recall, this was the sequence of events:

 

1. Eurus traps Victor in the well and he subsequently drowns

 

2. Eurus sets fire to the house (perhaps by accident, who knows?).

 

3. Eurus is sent to an institution.

 

4. The institution burns down (perhaps unrelated to Eurus's presence, who knows?).

 

5. Eurus is sent to Sherrinford.

 

So no, there would not have been any memorabilia left after the first fire, and clearly the family chose to move away rather than have the house restored, so not even her old bedroom would be a reminder. Likewise, local gossip would not have been a factor.

 

Did the family decide to move into their old summer place full time? And is that the house we see in HLV?

 

[sherlock] is the wisest man. Who writes this?!?

 

Well, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, for one. I believe that's Watson's description of Holmes while he's "dead" (so either the original Final Problem or else The Empty House.)

  • Like 1
Posted
...

 

As I recall, this was the sequence of events:

 

1. Eurus traps Victor in the well and he subsequently drowns

 

2. Eurus sets fire to the house (perhaps by accident, who knows?).

 

3. Eurus is sent to an institution.

 

4. The institution burns down (perhaps unrelated to Eurus's presence, who knows?).

 

5. Eurus is sent to Sherrinford.

 

So no, there would not have been any memorabilia left after the first fire, and clearly the family chose to move away rather than have the house restored, so not even her old bedroom would be a reminder. Likewise, local gossip would not have been a factor.

 

Did the family decide to move into their old summer place full time? And is that the house we see in HLV?

 

... 

 

You're right about the house, they never did restore it. I would have thought the family salvaged some things from the fire though? (like Mycroft's home movies, maybe some family photos?).

 

 I suppose moving away and losing their possessions would have made not talking about Eurus easier, all right. It also answers another question I had about whether Victor's family would have continued to approach the Holmes family looking for information. Though I still think it would have made sense for them to do this, when no body was recovered. It might have even been the sort of case that would have been mentioned in the news, you know, renewed appeals for information about missing children, in the years after they disappear? 

 

About the fires, we see Eurus with matches, so it is heavily implied that she lit the fire, at least the first one, anyway. The second was part of Mycroft's original cover story for her death, so I'm not sure what the real story was there.

 

I'm unsure whether the house the parents are in in HLV was where they would have moved to after the fire, or if it was a summer property (or then again if it still is a summer house). The family seem like they must be pretty wealthy, or they were in the past, to have owned the original house, but the new one is not as imposing, from what I remember?

Posted

Right, it's more homey looking. That's why I have the idea that it might have been their summer place before.

 

I'm not disputing that Eurus lit the fire, just that we don't know for sure that she meant to burn the house down. Maybe she only meant to burn some small object, but the flames got out of control. Don't suppose there's any way to know for sure.

Posted

It is odd, though, that two places where she was located both burned down--their home and the first institution she was placed in, after which she was moved to Sherrinford. I think it was implied that she started the second fire also, whether intentionally or not is unclear. But you know what Mycroft says about coincidence.

Posted

Oh, I'm not disputing that it's highly suspicious. I consider it very likely that she started both fires. The main question in my mind is "why?" Did she intend to burn both places down? Did she intend whatever deaths may have occurred at the institution? Or was she merely playing with matches?

Posted

The circumstances of the fire have been left vague, perhaps deliberately? Like, if it was at night and the family were asleep inside, that would have been more likely to kill them all? But nobody in the family was killed, or even had any serious burns from what we know? If not, maybe it was during the day, or when they were out, and then it might have been more an act of vandalism or attention seeking? 

 

A lot of things Eurus does don't seem very well thought out, in the sense that you see her endgame clearly. It's almost more like a 'cry for help'. Which makes her sound more innocent that I really believe she is.

  • Like 1
Posted

She may be honestly incapable of interacting with other humans in any sort of normal fashion, apparently due at least in part to her extraordinary IQ. So either she's physically separated from them, or she treats them the way some supposedly-sane "scientific" individuals treat cats and dogs.

 

Does that make her insane or just incredibly dangerous?

Posted

Just in reference to Sherlock and his parents... I was thinking about how he had said his mother understands very little- but when he says that he has no understanding himself that Eurus was a secret being kept from him (and in a sense by him, or part of his brain anyway).

 

I wonder if this affected how his parents treated him, and his impressions of them? They must have always considered him to have a slightly fragile mental state, on the verge of somehow remembering the Victor trauma. It might have meant they tried to shield him, or seemed obtuse when they were deliberately with-holding information that could trigger a memory for him.

 

It would take a bit more than a simple one-off blotting of that memory for Sherlock to have kept himself in the dark that long. A disappearance like that would be talked about in the area for years to come- and in the beginning surely Eurus' photographs and things- even her bedroom, would have still been in the house. It would have needed to be an almost wilful deletion, on a regular basis, to maintain the lack of awareness, for him. To support his delusion, the parents would have had to start hiding things. And they had to rope in Mycroft (the beginning of his career in a secret service?). The fact he stayed unaware is in such a contrast to how curious and dogged he usually is about small details that don't add up.

 

I don't think it is unbelievable, because the urge for self-preservation is so strong it could easily overcome his other traits if he was in so much pain- but it makes me reconsider the aspects of Sherlock that 'always misses something'- and deleted the solar system from his memory.

 

Finally got a chance to catch up on this thread.

 

Re: Sherlock not having any memories of Eurus', I think I see the answer in all of your assorted posts, but it sort of wandered off again. Try this on for size:

 

1. Sherlock's traumatized. He's about 6? I have a lot of confused memories from that age, even without the trauma; little kids misunderstand big things. And they're very focused on themselves and what they want. So I can believe he starts to remember Redbeard as the dog he longed for and lost, instead of a little boy.

 

2. Eurus burns the house down and they move to another. So most of the visual cues to her existence; photos, toys, her room, the grounds ... all gone. No need to hide things, they don't exist anymore. No neighbors hanging around talking about it. No visits to the places where the kids used to play. No other friends to talk about it. And parents who apparently don't care to tell the truth. (Aha! No wonder Sherlock's such a facile liar, he came by it honestly.......)

 

3. What Sherlock does remember about Eurus is hurtful ... so he apparently deletes her from his hard drive (along with, presumably, his knowledge of the solar system, feelings, and how to get along with people. :smile: ) That was some memory wipe! ... but it kind of makes sense.

 

4. It might even explain the "high-functioning sociopath" self-description; deep down, he knows he's screwed up in some way. But he doesn't know what it is. Even if his parents sent him to therapy, some people just won't cooperate with it; they have to want to get better, as I understand it, in order for therapy to help. But "getting better" for Sherlock may have meant remembering Eurus and Redbeard. Too painful...... he'd rather be a "sociopath?"

 

  

It is odd, though, that two places where she was located both burned down--their home and the first institution she was placed in, after which she was moved to Sherrinford. I think it was implied that she started the second fire also, whether intentionally or not is unclear. But you know what Mycroft says about coincidence.

 

​But remember ... the second fire never took place, that was just Uncle Rudi's (or Mycroft's) cover story for why Eurus disappeared. Sherlock immediately pinned that as a lie, and Mycroft conceded it was.

 

 I'm guessing they used that cover story because, having burned down one place, it would be easy for her parents to believe she did it again.

 

Oh, I'm not disputing that it's highly suspicious. I consider it very likely that she started both fires. The main question in my mind is "why?" Did she intend to burn both places down? Did she intend whatever deaths may have occurred at the institution? Or was she merely playing with matches?

I think the dialog, and the visuals, are intended to convey what they want us to know about the fire. (The only fire. :smile:) She's making all those threatening drawings of Sherlock (which I took to mean there were other signs, even at that age, that she was a threat to other people); then they have a menacing shot of the match being struck. And Mycroft says she was sent away because of the fire.

 

We're also presented with several pieces of evidence throughout the episode that she was homicidal, so yeah ... I believe the fire was deliberate, and meant to cause harm.

 

 

Posted

But remember ... the second fire never took place, that was just Uncle Rudi's (or Mycroft's) cover story for why Eurus disappeared. Sherlock immediately pinned that as a lie, and Mycroft conceded it was.

 

You may be overinterpreting that scene. How would Sherlock know -- instantly -- whether or not a place he was probably never told about had burned down some thirty years ago? I take the lie to be merely Eurus's death, which Sherlock knew was a falsehood because a} he and John had talked with someone claiming to be her, and b} Mycroft was still terrified of her.

 

I suspect the fire was all too real (and probably in all the papers). Otherwise why did they move her to Sherrinford, and why did Mum and Dad believe she was dead?

  • Like 2
Posted

bedelia1984, on 02 Feb 2017 - 03:06 AM, said:

I thought the context he gave her was in the form of making a connection with her himself. In much the same way that he and Mycroft give each other context, through both their connection and the fact they have things in common that the rest of the world wouldn't understand- due to both their intelligence and their common upbringing. When Mycroft took away Eurus' family, he robbed her of a sense of context within the world, and Sherlock was able to return that to her, or 'bring her home' metaphorically speaking.

Thanks, I think I'm finally starting to get this. I think my problem is, I never really see the connection being made, because I can't figure out why Eurus was suddenly so helpless when Sherlock burst into her room. I can't help it ... he's the hero, I keep looking for something he did that caused her to become vulnerable. But it's not there. (Is it?) She's just suddenly the lost little girl, because that's how she has to be if he is to connect with her. Or am I still missing something? (And why am I so fixated on this point? :blink: )

 

  

Van Buren Supernova, on 02 Feb 2017 - 04:01 AM, said:

 

Surelock, on 02 Feb 2017 - 03:21 AM, said:

Just wondering: do you blame Mycroft for sending Euros to Sherrinford and hiding her from his family?

 

Honestly I think he made the right call for what he knew. They couldn't solve the puzzle so Mycroft could only act on what he could see of Euros. Euros was really dangerous and her parents would have been horrified if they heard of what a dangerous psychopath she had become.

I was thinking about this too.

I think it's harsh, probably a bit too harsh because as far we know, nobody really knew what happened with Redbeard, and they couldn't be sure that Eurus killed him. She was creepy and commited arson etc, but I don't think it's enough justification to pluck her away like that at that very young age.

Now, with the fact that she killed Redbeard and posed some threats to her family, I still not sure. She should be locked away, yes, I agree with that, but it's probably better if she's allowed contacts and interactions or attempts to understand how she thinks and whether there is a way to reform it. After all, she was a kid at that time. A kid! What I'm saying it, someone not murderous would probably turn murderous if they are treated that way, taken, locked and treated as experiment subjects where everyone that matters to her doesn't even know she still exists.

 

I think they knew she killed Victor, and that she would kill again if not contained.

 

But ... I think Mycroft's failure was that he thought that meant it was okay to act as if she was just a machine, a biological machine. He devalued her innate worth as a human being, which is usually considered a bit not good by those who advocate "humanity" as a salve to the world's pain. So from that viewpoint, Mycroft devalued himself, as well; he's the one who actually became more like a machine. He showed he was "limited."

 

It's oddly timely, isn't it?  :(

 

 

Van Buren Supernova, on 02 Feb 2017 - 04:24 AM, said:

 

So a couple of takes:

- regarding shooting the Big G. Sherlock is not allowed to do it, Eurus asks him to choose between Mycroft and John. Why?

Is it because she thinks he could do it? After Magnussen, and because Moriarty also thinks so? (The whole thing with side of angel but not one and he is capable to make Moriarty talks).

What do you guys think?

I wondered at that too ... maybe it IS because she knew he was capable of it. I think he probably could have done it. :(

 

But I also wondered if she was testing to see how he would react to the trauma Mycroft and John felt in that situation. Would he encourage them to shoot, or try to talk them out of it? Comfort them, or go cold? Not sure, just thoughts. But if Eurus' goal was to push Sherlock's emotional buttons, it seems to me that test had to be more about he would react to his friend's situation. But I'm still not sure if that was Eurus' goal, or if she was just "playing"?

 

Surelock, on 02 Feb 2017 - 04:33 AM, said:

Also it's true that Mycroft let Moriarty speak to Euros for 5 minutes unsupervised but I wouldn't describe as what he did as giving ammunition. I mean Moriarty never brought up Euros with Sherlock although he could. You could argue that's a plot hole. I mean Moriarty likes messing with Sherlock. if he knew about Euros, then why didn't he ever talk to him about her?

 

I think that Moriarty- Euros connection was just poorly written and not given much thought. It looks like Moffatiss only gave them a connection because they wanted to foreshadow Euros' impending threat but they didn't want to give it away so they used Moriarty as a ruse (via his 'Miss me?' videos).

 

Alas, I have to agree ... they didn't do a good job of explaining Moriarty's role in all this. His appearance felt very much like an afterthought, and I felt sort of cheated that they didn't explain what he and Eurus said to each other. And it didn't make sense that Eurus told Jim about Redbeard, but he never used that knowledge to his advantage.

 

So I have to assume she didn't tell him the truth. At any rate, I thought their meeting was more about her getting information ... and those wholly unnecessary videos ... from him, than about her giving him anything. He just played along. For some reason.

  • Like 2
Posted

A lot of things Eurus does don't seem very well thought out, in the sense that you see her endgame clearly. It's almost more like a 'cry for help'. Which makes her sound more innocent that I really believe she is.

She may be honestly incapable of interacting with other humans in any sort of normal fashion, apparently due at least in part to her extraordinary IQ. So either she's physically separated from them, or she treats them the way some supposedly-sane "scientific" individuals treat cats and dogs.

 

Does that make her insane or just incredibly dangerous?

 

​Yeah, I'm struggling with this too ... how much is she accountable for what she does? Does she deserve compassion, or does she simply need to be contained for the safety of the rest of us? And all those other unanswerables that society faces when dealing with mental health. No answers here.

 

 

But remember ... the second fire never took place, that was just Uncle Rudi's (or Mycroft's) cover story for why Eurus disappeared. Sherlock immediately pinned that as a lie, and Mycroft conceded it was.

You may be overinterpreting that scene. How would Sherlock know -- instantly -- whether or not a place he was probably never told about had burned down some thirty years ago? I take the lie to be merely Eurus's death, which Sherlock knew was a falsehood because a} he and John had talked with someone claiming to be her, and b} Mycroft was still terrified of her.

 

I was going to say because he knows Mycroft well enough to tell when he's lying, but okay, I see your point ... Mycroft was lying about Eurus' death, but not necessarily about the fire. We're not told either way. Point Dabbler! :smile:

 

I suspect the fire was all too real (and probably in all the papers). Otherwise why did they move her to Sherrinford, and why did Mum and Dad believe she was dead?

​Whether the fire was real or not, or set by her or not, Mycroft says she was moved to Sherrinford because "The depth of Eurus’ psychosis and the extent of her abilities couldn’t hope to be contained in any ordinary institution." (And also, Sherlock conjectures, to avoid any future interference from the parents, which is a chilling thought.)  And Mum and Dad believed she was dead, because that's what they were told, surely?

Posted

 

 

I suspect the fire was all too real (and probably in all the papers). Otherwise why did they move her to Sherrinford, and why did Mum and Dad believe she was dead?

​Whether the fire was real or not, or set by her or not, Mycroft says she was moved to Sherrinford because "The depth of Eurus’ psychosis and the extent of her abilities couldn’t hope to be contained in any ordinary institution." (And also, Sherlock conjectures, to avoid any future interference from the parents, which is a chilling thought.)  And Mum and Dad believed she was dead, because that's what they were told, surely?

 

 

Especially chilling when you consider that she was put to use for the government too. I wonder at what stage that began?

  • Like 1
Posted

The circumstances of the fire have been left vague, perhaps deliberately? Like, if it was at night and the family were asleep inside, that would have been more likely to kill them all? But nobody in the family was killed, or even had any serious burns from what we know? If not, maybe it was during the day, or when they were out, and then it might have been more an act of vandalism or attention seeking? 

 

A lot of things Eurus does don't seem very well thought out, in the sense that you see her endgame clearly. It's almost more like a 'cry for help'. Which makes her sound more innocent that I really believe she is.

 

It's likely that everyone was in the house when Euros lit the fire.

 

Remember it was after she hid Victor away. We hear Mr. and Mrs. Holmes arguing about what to do with her in the background. Euros also said that the last thing she asked Sherlock to do was to get her favourite hairband back from Mrs. Holmes. We don't know what Mycroft was doing but I doubt he would have left his family alone in the house with Euros.

 

As for why Euros lit the fire, it may have been because she was angry she was being punished by having her favourite hairband taken away. Or may have been just because she seemed angry at Sherlock. Look at those pictures she drew of Sherlock. She seemed to hate him and wanted him dead. One of those pictures even has Sherlock with his head on fire.

 

I don't know why she was so angry at Sherlock. Maybe it was just because he couldn't solve her puzzle?

Posted

Yeah, that was especially cold of Mycroft. Perhaps he thought he was giving her "utility", but to me it's just another aspect of treating her like a machine.

Posted

 

 

 

As for why Euros lit the fire, it may have been because she was angry she was being punished by having her favourite hairband taken away. Or may have been just because she seemed angry at Sherlock. Look at those pictures she drew of Sherlock. She seemed to hate him and wanted him dead. One of those pictures even has Sherlock with his head on fire.

 

I don't know why she was so angry at Sherlock. Maybe it was just because he couldn't solve her puzzle?

 

 

Thank God his hair remained in tact anyway, as he has such great hair! How evil would you need to be to destroy it? Shameful.

 

Yes, well from what you are saying, Eurus was already capable of mass murder at the age of five. Perhaps not old enough to know quite what she was doing- but as you say, all those 'RIP Sherlock' type drawings don't exactly paint a rosy picture. I believe that's called 'premeditation' in legal circles.

  • Like 1
Posted

Considering how Moffatiss tried to link every single aspect of Sherlock's character to originate from Euros, I think it's notable that there's one trait that they missed: Sherlock's combat abilities.

 

Sherlock is really good at fighting. That's how he was able to hold his own against a highly trained assassin like AJ. It also explains how he was able to destroy Molly's coffin with his bare hands. Season 4 isn't the first time that Sherlock has displayed his strength. He also did so in The Blind Banker where he held his own against those Chinese circus goons. 

 

I remember in the Behind the Scenes of The Six Thatchers, Benedict Cumberbatch spoke of how Sherlock had superior combat abilities even in the books. That's one of the reasons why they decided to have a James Bond-esque brawl in The Six Thatchers.

 

The question is: where did Sherlock get his combat abilities from? 

 

They obviously didn't come from Mycroft. I can see, however, why Mycroft would be okay with sending Sherlock on dangerous missions like disassembling Moriarty's network. Sherlock can use his combat abilities to keep himself safe.

 

But who taught Sherlock how to fight? Why did a clever guy like Sherlock learn to fight? Did he do it because it was the one thing Mycroft was bad at and he wanted something to tease Mycroft about?

 

It's funny that Season 4 tried to explain how Sherlock obtained all his traits but they missed his combat abilities. I guess it's understandable because Sherlock isn't exactly famous for his fighting abilities.

 

TBH I'm kind of glad Moffatiss didn't try to explain where Sherlock got his combat abilities. Judging by what they did in The Final Problem, I'm guessing they would have tried to somehow link Sherlock's fighting abilities to Euros. It would have been really implausible if Euros taught Sherlock martial arts. It was convoluted enough that she taught him how to play the violin when they were like 4 - 5 years old?

  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.