Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think Mary was actually playing dumb on that whole skip code thing.  After all, she could have just rescued John herself.  I know that code came from Magnussen, and she knew it too, but if she didn't bring Sherlock into the picture, he likely was threatening to expose her.  I still say that at the end of TEH when CAM is replaying the scene in his mind palace that he is more focused on Mary screaming "John!  John!" than anything else.  CAM is using her to get to Sherlock to get to Mycroft... and she knows full well that she is being used.  CAM has no beef with John. John is only a pawn.  Even when Mary has a gun to his head, CAM is protesting that John is an honorable man.  

 

She's not his poppet.  The poppet comment comes in someone else's telegram.  Poppet is a term of endearment, usually reserved for a child.  She is temporarily his puppet, however, and he is pulling her strings.

  • Like 3
Posted

The third indication is the wedding telegram from CAM where he tells her he's sorry her family couldn't be there... he's bullying her in public knowing the telegram would be read out loud.  CAM knows she is not who she says she is, that of course Mary Morstan could not possibly have family since there is no such real person.  He was putting that clue to the public, and it went right over Sherlock's head at that moment, but it didn't go over Mary's head.  It unnerved her.

 

You know, the more I think about that "telegram," the odder it gets.  CAM presumably wanted his little barb to blend in with the congratulatory messages.  But who would tell an orphan, "Sorry your family couldn't be here"?  Well, maybe an old family friend, who had known the orphan all her life, since well before she was an orphan.  But otherwise it seems just thoughtless and cruel.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

The third indication is the wedding telegram from CAM where he tells her he's sorry her family couldn't be there... he's bullying her in public knowing the telegram would be read out loud.  CAM knows she is not who she says she is, that of course Mary Morstan could not possibly have family since there is no such real person.  He was putting that clue to the public, and it went right over Sherlock's head at that moment, but it didn't go over Mary's head.  It unnerved her.

 

You know, the more I think about that "telegram," the odder it gets.  CAM presumably wanted his little barb to blend in with the congratulatory messages.  But who would tell an orphan, "Sorry your family couldn't be here"?  Well, maybe an old family friend, who had known the orphan all her life, since well before she was an orphan.  But otherwise it seems just thoughtless and cruel.

 

 

But CAM knows that she isn't an orphan but has a fake persona of an orphan, and that's why his telegram unnerves her so.  He has potentially just exposed her, but it went over Sherlock's and John's heads.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

The second indication is when she says the words "skip code."  Now here's where I hope I don't start rambling.  However, I suspect she knew precisely what was in the skip code but she was being blackmailed by Magnussen, and I think she was told to get Sherlock's help on that skip code because Magnussen was after Sherlock's pressure points,

Okay, this is a new perspective, at least for me, but it definitely makes sense, probably more than anything else.

 

I've had that thought as well ... if she knew it was a skip code, then she could read the message for herself, yeah? So why go to Sherlock? But then I thought, not being a native Londoner, maybe she didn't know where (or what) St. James the Less was. Although you'd think looking in the phonebook would have been a good start..... ;)

 

On the other hand, if the point of putting John in the fire was to test Sherlock's response, why not just send the message directly to him? Why go through Mary?

 

 

The third indication is the wedding telegram from CAM where he tells her he's sorry her family couldn't be there... he's bullying her in public knowing the telegram would be read out loud.  CAM knows she is not who she says she is, that of course Mary Morstan could not possibly have family

Another good point. I was thinking more in a way that they knew each other for long already, and him sending the telegram was reminding her that she's still his poppet. And maybe the fact that she had no family was his doing. ....

 

I always figured the same thing, JP, that they'd known each other a long time -- but sfmpco's take suddenly makes more sense to me; it's not that he is threatening her family, it's that he's telling her he knows she's a fake. Huh. So does this mean he only recently started putting pressure on her, beginning with John in the fire? But would that mean that the skip code really was just for her, not for Sherlock, and she just decided she needed help? Drat, now I'm getting confused .... gee, we must be discussing HLV!!!! :D  

 

 

Well, how long were people drugged for?  You would think Billy would make sure they were all sleeping soundly for quite a bit.  Yes, the computer had GPS but Mycroft still had to summon a helicopter, get troops assembled, etc.  It's not like a helicopter was landing in the Holmes' paddock in 2 minutes.  If Mycroft were truly drugged, I suspect he might not have even noticed his laptop was missing when he first came too.  Might have been too woozy.  So, there is duplicity in the act.  Maybe.  We will know in S4.

I'm thinking they only needed to be drugged for as long as it took for Sherlock to swipe the laptop and get on the helicopter, which was moments later. Mycroft could have been coming to even as they lifted into the air.

 

She's not his poppet.  The poppet comment comes in someone else's telegram.  Poppet is a term of endearment, usually reserved for a child.  She is temporarily his puppet, however, and he is pulling her strings.

I've always been confused by that too, but according to the excerpt from the script that's in my brand new copy (yay! :smile: ) of the Chronicles :smile:, "poppet" is in CAM's telegram. But Ariane DeVere shows it even more clearly:

 

SHERLOCK (reading the next card): “Mary – lots of love, ...”

(He breathes out an almost silent ‘Oh.’ John and Mary look up at him.)

JOHN: Yeah?

SHERLOCK (disparagingly): “... poppet ...”

(He loudly sounds the ‘t’ at the end of the word. John and Mary giggle.)

SHERLOCK: “... Oodles of love and heaps of good wishes from CAM.”

(Mary’s smile fades. Sherlock continues reading the message.)

SHERLOCK: “Wish your family could have seen this.”

(John looks round and sees Mary’s face. He reaches out and takes her hand.)

JOHN: Hey. Hmm?

(She smiles reassuringly at him.)

SHERLOCK (looking at the next card): Um, “special day” ...

So, yeah, I think "poppet" is just CAM's creepy way of taking "ownership" of Mary, not unlike licking Lady Smallwood. And a bit of a play on words, too, since it's so similar to "puppet."

 

You know, the more I think about that "telegram," the odder it gets.  CAM presumably wanted his little barb to blend in with the congratulatory messages.  But who would tell an orphan, "Sorry your family couldn't be here"?  Well, maybe an old family friend, who had known the orphan all her life, since well before she was an orphan.  But otherwise it seems just thoughtless and cruel.

But CAM is cruel. Or did I miss the point?

  • Like 4
Posted

CAM is in news, he tells the two quixotic idiots so! Dear sfmpco' s explanation makes perfect sense, but then the question remains between S2 and S3 who aimed Mary at Dr Watson, knowing his weaknesses and susceptibilities? Is it part of the whole subplot we have missed? Does it imply Magnussen was a collaborator of Moriarty? I have pointed out the possibility that Mary is Mor(st)an before. She could have been one of the snipers in both TRF (we are only given three exotic profiles) and one of the snipers in TGG. Great way to get to know your husband: as an assassin for hire, painting laser points on his chest! That may explain why she never tells John she loves him, and why she has such an elliptic contribution in TEH, where she is definitely bossing both Dr Watson around, and tries her hand at bossing Sherlock around, right at the end. Melodrama fine, can we get to straightforward crime-solving without Mrs Smith around?

As for the telemessage, it's from Magnussen AKA Mr Moffat, pulling Mary's strings, : poppet-puppet, perhaps because he needs her to do another task, so he chooses the most anodyne way to send a very personal, very specific message, perhaps not aware that Mary has already befriended Janine.

Posted

The skip code was definitely aimed at Sherlock, as it should show how much he cared for John.

Yes. But like Arcadia said, why didn't send it directly to Sherlock?

 

Is it his side purpose, other way to remind Mary that he owns her?

 

I think by this time CAM also knows a lot about Sherlock already. There are probably no one else who knows London street's shortcut like Sherlock, happens to know how to ride bike like a boss and capable of acquiring one as well. The time was what? Ten minutes?!

Posted

Maybe CAM wanted them both rescuing John  together, although it's hard to think about a reason for it. To show Mary - directly - he can ruin her life in any second.

Posted

CAM is in news, he tells the two quixotic idiots so! Dear sfmpco' s explanation makes perfect sense, but then the question remains between S2 and S3 who aimed Mary at Dr Watsons, knowing his weaknesses and susceptibilities? Is it part of the whole subplot we have missed? Does it imply Magnussen was a collaborator of Moriarty? I have pointed out the possibility that Mary is Mor(st)an before. She could have been one of the snipers in both TRF (we are only given three exotic profiles) and one of the snipers in TGG. Great way to get to know your husband: as an assassin for hire, painting laser points on his chest! That may explain why she never tells John she loves him, and why she has such an elliptic contribution in TEH, where she is definitely bossing both Dr Watson around, and tries her hand at bossing Sherlock around, right at the end. Melodrama fine, can we get to straightforward crime-solving without Mrs Smith around?

Lots of unsubstantiated assumptions there, Inge! :smile:  Although I'm rather fond of the "Mary Mor--an" theory, for some reason. An assassin who falls for her prey ... there's something almost sweet about that. :lol:

 

Maybe CAM wanted them both rescuing John  together, although it's hard to think about a reason for it.

I thought of that, but like you I can't think of any reason, sensible or otherwise, why he'd want that. Which leads me back to ... it was Mary's decision, not threats from CAM, to go get Sherlock. In which case she inadvertently handed Sherlock to CAM on a platter ... there might have been no reason for CAM to connect the three of them otherwise.

 

Ooooo, here's a thought ... maybe it's Mary who was doing the manipulating! Maybe she included Sherlock in the rescue because she was hoping that would help get the two boys back together, and therefore she would, by extension, come under Sherlock's protection. In which case, her plan actually worked out ... for her. Hmmmm....... (But then why go after CAM herself? Arghh, too many, too many!!!!! Too many contradictory theories, that is. :smile: )

  • Like 1
Posted

But CAM put John into this pile of wood especially for Sherlock. He was the guinea pig so to say. :wacko:

How do we know that, though? CAM admitted he was behind it, and he said something to Sherlock like "Look how you care for John;" but did he ever indicate he put John in the fire specifically to test Sherlock's reaction? Or is it possible that it was all meant for Mary and Sherlock was a surprise bonus?

 

You're probably right, JP (Occam's Razor and all that), but the idea occurred to me so I'm running with it. :smile: It's this, or Cluedo.... ( we need new episodes......!!!)

  • Like 2
Posted

MAGNUSSEN: Anyway, you wouldn’t care if it was exposed, would you?

(Sherlock tilts his head, quirks his mouth and shrugs.)

MAGNUSSEN (looking at the screen): But look how you care about John Watson.

(In slow motion on the footage, Sherlock drags John out from under the bonfire again.)

MAGNUSSEN: Your damsel in distress.

(John turns around.)

JOHN: You ... (he walks closer to Magnussen, his voice tight and furious) ... put me in a fire ... for leverage?

MAGNUSSEN: Oh, I’d never let you burn, Doctor Watson.

For me it sounds as if it was meant as a test.

Posted

Dear Arcadia, to use Occam's razor in a Moffat series is inviting Parkinson's Law of filling even non-existent needs! :D

  • Like 2
Posted

In TEH at the end when we're introduced to CAM without finding out who he is, they show the bonfire scene again with him looking at it.  They seem to focus on Sherlock more than Mary in that replay (obviously it is a little hard to tell for sure as they periodically show CAM's face in between shots of the bonfire).  I can see it as being a sort of test.  CAM needed to figure out (confirm) the complete pressure point line he wanted to use for maximum effect.

  • Like 1
Posted

... the more I think about that "telegram," the odder it gets.  CAM presumably wanted his little barb to blend in with the congratulatory messages.  But who would tell an orphan, "Sorry your family couldn't be here"?  Well, maybe an old family friend, who had known the orphan all her life, since well before she was an orphan.  But otherwise it seems just thoughtless and cruel.

 

But CAM knows that she isn't an orphan but has a fake persona of an orphan, and that's why his telegram unnerves her so.  He has potentially just exposed her, but it went over Sherlock's and John's heads.

 

But CAM is cruel. Or did I miss the point?

 

No argument on either count.  But CAM was apparently trying to make his little message sound like just another sweet little wedding telegram (which would explain why he signed it "CAM" instead of using his full name), yet the message itself is weird.  Come to think of it, though, maybe he's simply such a cold-blooded bastard that he didn't realize how it might come across.  :unsure:

 

She's not his poppet.  The poppet comment comes in someone else's telegram.  Poppet is a term of endearment, usually reserved for a child.  She is temporarily his puppet, however, and he is pulling her strings.

 

I've always been confused by that too, but according to the excerpt from the script that's in my brand new copy (yay! :smile: ) of the Chronicles :smile:, "poppet" is in CAM's telegram. But Ariane DeVere shows it even more clearly:

 

SHERLOCK (reading the next card): “Mary – lots of love, ...”

(He breathes out an almost silent ‘Oh.’ John and Mary look up at him.)

JOHN: Yeah?

SHERLOCK (disparagingly): “... poppet ...”

(He loudly sounds the ‘t’ at the end of the word. John and Mary giggle.)

SHERLOCK: “... Oodles of love and heaps of good wishes from CAM.”

(Mary’s smile fades. Sherlock continues reading the message.)

SHERLOCK: “Wish your family could have seen this.”

(John looks round and sees Mary’s face. He reaches out and takes her hand.)

JOHN: Hey. Hmm?

(She smiles reassuringly at him.)

SHERLOCK (looking at the next card): Um, “special day” ...

 

So, yeah, I think "poppet" is just CAM's creepy way of taking "ownership" of Mary, not unlike licking Lady Smallwood. And a bit of a play on words, too, since it's so similar to "puppet."

I'm not convinced.  Admittedly, we're talking about a message sent by a true sociopath, but why would he say "Lots of love, poppet.  Oodles of love...."  Seems redundant.  Also, even watching very closely, I find it hard to tell whether or not Sherlock turns to another card at some point during that.  Could be that "Poppet" is somebody's nickname, used as the signature on the message that's followed by CAM's message.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

 

 

She's not his poppet.  The poppet comment comes in someone else's telegram.  Poppet is a term of endearment, usually reserved for a child.  She is temporarily his puppet, however, and he is pulling her strings.

 

I've always been confused by that too, but according to the excerpt from the script that's in my brand new copy (yay! :smile: ) of the Chronicles :smile:, "poppet" is in CAM's telegram. But Ariane DeVere shows it even more clearly:

 

SHERLOCK (reading the next card): “Mary – lots of love, ...”

(He breathes out an almost silent ‘Oh.’ John and Mary look up at him.)

JOHN: Yeah?

SHERLOCK (disparagingly): “... poppet ...”

(He loudly sounds the ‘t’ at the end of the word. John and Mary giggle.)

SHERLOCK: “... Oodles of love and heaps of good wishes from CAM.”

(Mary’s smile fades. Sherlock continues reading the message.)

SHERLOCK: “Wish your family could have seen this.”

(John looks round and sees Mary’s face. He reaches out and takes her hand.)

JOHN: Hey. Hmm?

(She smiles reassuringly at him.)

SHERLOCK (looking at the next card): Um, “special day” ...

 

So, yeah, I think "poppet" is just CAM's creepy way of taking "ownership" of Mary, not unlike licking Lady Smallwood. And a bit of a play on words, too, since it's so similar to "puppet."

I'm not convinced.  Admittedly, we're talking about a message sent by a true sociopath, but why would he say "Lots of love, poppet.  Oodles of love...."  Seems redundant.  Also, even watching very closely, I find it hard to tell whether or not Sherlock turns to another card at some point during that.  Could be that "Poppet" is somebody's nickname, used as the signature on the message that's followed by CAM's message.

 

 

I always read/heard it as Poppet was someone's name/nickname and CAM's telegram was different.

Posted

tuzki-bunny-emoticon-051.gif 

Okay, okay, I surrender!!!
 
Seriously, I'm sure you are all correct, just for a moment there I thought maybe I'd found something new to ponder ..... :P


Dear Arcadia, to use Occam's razor in a Moffat series is inviting Parkinson's Law of filling even non-existent needs! :D

:rofl: Score one for Inge!!!

  • Like 2
Posted

Whoops, sorry, there's a little fight left in me after all... :D

 

So, yeah, I think "poppet" is just CAM's creepy way of taking "ownership" of Mary, not unlike licking Lady Smallwood. And a bit of a play on words, too, since it's so similar to "puppet."


I'm not convinced.  Admittedly, we're talking about a message sent by a true sociopath, but why would he say "Lots of love, poppet.  Oodles of love...."  Seems redundant.  Also, even watching very closely, I find it hard to tell whether or not Sherlock turns to another card at some point during that.  Could be that "Poppet" is somebody's nickname, used as the signature on the message that's followed by CAM's message.

 

You dare to doubt Ariane DeVere? Ooooo, someone's cruisin' for trouble.... :lol:
 
Anyway, if it had been someone's nickname, I don't think Sherlock would have been so horrified by having to say it. It was the sentiment of it that almost made him choke, not the actual word, imo. And if I were really trying to creep someone out, I'd load on the endearments too, my sweet darling poppets!

enfant-5.gif

  • Like 2
Posted

Nope, no way, no how! That whole telegram is from Magnussen! Dear Arcadia is right! Just rewatched, Sherlock does NOT flip to another telemessage card! poppet=puppet, he wants her to do another job for him, perhaps Lady Smallwood was already proving a thorn in his side! The information about Magnussen having to face a committee appears in TEH already!

Posted

You dare to doubt Ariane DeVere?

 

Yup.  Every now and then.  She does admit to being human, after all.

 

Just rewatched, Sherlock does NOT flip to another telemessage card!

 

It's been a while, but I believe you're right that he doesn't flip to another card right at that moment.  But he might be glancing at a card, then flipping to the next while reciting the previous one from memory.  Seems like the sort of thing he'd be capable of doing.  So I'm not at all certain which physical cards go with which verbal messages.  I tried to keep track once, and failed miserably.

  • Like 1
Posted

Plus the very thinly veiled message: wish your parents could have seen this! He knows she's not the orphan she pretends to be! Goodness, combined with Lars Mikkelsen's spot-on acting, I shall start liking CAM! Oh, my ears and whiskers! Where's Colonel Caterpillar or even the dodgy Cheshire Cat when you want some sound advice?

  • Like 1
Posted

The "poppet" telegram is not part of CAM's telegram.  That's in the previous telegram.  Watch as Sherlock is reading them.  Forget the script.  

Posted

Nope. You can hear the Stella and Ted message drop to the table, and then he begins reading the next one. And the inflection of his voice makes it clear where the "poppet" message begins and ends, anyway.

 

(IMO. :smile: Amazing, isn't it, how different people can watch the same thing and still see something different. Ariane DeVere, the scriptwriters and I all see (and hear) "poppet" as part of the CAM message ... but others don't. It's a wonder we're ever able to agree on anything! :D )

 

Annnnnd....... now that I'm watching TSo3, I can't stop! Send help!!!!

  • Like 2
Posted

Now I want to watch tsot again. (While my son wants TRF again even though we watched it on Monday)

  • Like 1
Posted

Bet you your last cent you watch TRF! What son wants, son gets, even if he's not as smart as Sherlock, in my family! :D

As I said above, I re-watched: he keeps reading from the same telemessage. @sfmpco: what script, has it been released?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 127 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.