Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

Found this:
 

I saw the purple-to-white shirt commented on elsewhere on the internet a while back, so rewatched the episode to check, and it turned out to have a perfectly unamazing explanation. That was a while ago, but near as I recall, his shirt had come untucked during the fall, so that his underwear was showing around his waist. The purple shirt was still visible in his chest area.

 
Unfortunately, I have no idea exactly what I'd seen "elsewhere on the internet."

  • Like 1
Posted

Underwear? But to appear on waist level he must had massive wedgie? Err.. and he wears tighty whitey :blanket:?

 

And this white thing is not visible when he was on the stretcher.

Posted

Thinking about the falling rate if he's falling at a rate of 9.8 m/s/s (approximately 32 ft/s/s), wouldn't it be closer to 3 seconds for the length of his fall (ignoring dramatic/filming style license taken)?

 

Never mind my math. Realized that would actually be 2 seconds not 3. I blame it on the rain we're getting again.

  • Like 2
Posted

Underwear? But to appear on waist level he must had massive wedgie? Err.. and he wears tighty whitey :blanket:?

 

And this white thing is not visible when he was on the stretcher.

 

Undershirt, not pants.  He must have tucked it back in while they were putting the makeup on his face, before he laid down on the sidewalk.

Posted

To me it's just a little glitch in the production. The best take of the falling happened to be the one with whateveritis visible.

 

Okay... it WAS.

 

Because it is on every picture and they are probably from several takes until they filmed with multiple cameras (but I think I've read/heard somewhere that there were several takes made.)

 

And...

 

On some of those pics above it looks like something attached to Ben's belly. A pouch?

 

thk.gif
 

I KNOW! It's an AIRBAG!

... and the thing that everyone has missed according to Moff.

 

 

medal_L.gif

  • Like 3
Posted

THAT'S IT!!!!! JP, you're brilliant. :rolleyes:

 

Hmmm, apparentely I failed to push the "Post" button after my previous comment, which was: "Undershirt? Sherlock wears an undershirt? He doesn't seem like the type."

Posted

Hmmm, apparentely I failed to push the "Post" button after my previous comment, which was: "Undershirt? Sherlock wears an undershirt? He doesn't seem like the type."

 

Maybe only when he's wearing a harness?  ;)

Posted

That actually makes sense... I think. :unsure:
 
Whatever it is, apparently they didn't think it was enough of an issue to "photoshop" it out, which you think would have been relatively easy. 'Tis a puzzlement.

Posted

Maybe they didn't think we'd notice something that small, for just a few seconds, what with everything else that was going on?  Or maybe they figured, so what if Sherlock's undershirt was showing?  It wasn't as though they'd left the harness showing.  (Though, yeah, as long as they were working on those same frames, painting that out....)

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Oh, of course! Obvious once you think about it ... NOT!!!!!   :rolleyes:

Posted

What drives me crazy with that picture are the uneven coat, material and the trimmings. :D Wrong wrong wrong!

 

I'm afraid I have to push him before I get even crazier.

  • Like 1
Posted

Okay, is that one any better?

Cric2O5WAAA6T9v.jpg

:D

Not really.. I want to say that he should be facing this way and run to me.

Then you would say but this is Khan and he doesn't like people.

Then I'd say, but you ask whether it's better and I give you good answer. It's better than Dr.Strange but it's not satisfactory. :p XD.

Then you would say, everyone is a critic.

 

See? Geez J.P, nothing seems to make you happy. :D

  • Like 2
  • 1 month later...
Posted

Sorry in advance if this has been asked before: TRF is decidedly NOT one of my favourite episodes, like HLV: why Kitty Reilly?

I mean, they take the name of a really courageous young woman in the Illustrious Client, and give it to a sleazy, down-at-heel reporter working freelance: any ideas as to why?

Posted

... why Kitty Reilly?

I mean, they take the name of a really courageous young woman in the Illustrious Client, and give it to a sleazy, down-at-heel reporter working freelance: any ideas as to why?

I assume you're talking about Kitty Winter? Other than sharing a first name, I see no similarities between the two characters, so I see no reason to assume that Miss Reilly was based on Miss Winter. Note that Sir Arthur himself named a great many of his male characters "James" (including Sir James in "Illustrious Client," two of the Moriarty brothers, and even Dr. Watson on one occasion). Surely there can be two unrelated Kittys in the universe he created.

  • Like 4
Posted

Did he mess it up (about John being James) because he forgot? Also the wound position. But there are so few characters to remember, or maybe he mixed them up with his other works?

 

If he read Game of Thrones he would have throw the books to the wall, just like what I almost did on 2nd book.

Posted

Did he mess it up (about John being James) because he forgot? Also the wound position. But there are so few characters to remember, or maybe he mixed them up with his other works?

 

 

 

I sometimes suspect that, even in the course of writing 60 Sherlock Holmes stories, ACD paid less attention to the Sherlock Holmes universe than most fans of any of the interpretations today.  

  • Like 2
Posted

Which also might be true in case of our Sherlock's makers :D

 

You know, I kind of disagree.  I think Moffat and Gatiss spent quite a lot of their childhoods and teenage years fantasizing about being Sherlock Holmes and what kinds of adventures they could have, and then at a certain point, as they started acting, directing, and/or writing, it sort of morphed into "what could I do in that universe with my adult skills if I were allowed."  I almost bet that you could ask them all sorts of trivia questions about the ACD canon and they would be able to answer them, along with how they would modernize those elements or what they think is particularly fun or interesting about them.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Which also might be true in case of our Sherlock's makers :D

 

You know, I kind of disagree.  I think Moffat and Gatiss spent quite a lot of their childhoods and teenage years fantasizing about being Sherlock Holmes and what kinds of adventures they could have, and then at a certain point, as they started acting, directing, and/or writing, it sort of morphed into "what could I do in that universe with my adult skills if I were allowed."  I almost bet that you could ask them all sorts of trivia questions about the ACD canon and they would be able to answer them, along with how they would modernize those elements or what they think is particularly fun or interesting about them.

 

 

True, but I also sort of agree with JP. For example, I've seen it said many times "nothing happens on this show by accident." But I disagree; although I think the boys put a lot of thought and geekery into Sherlock, I also think they're busy professionals operating on a tight schedule, in collaboration with dozens of other professionals, and they simply can't triple-check every word, glance or camera angle to make sure the show's exactly the way they want it. Inconsistencies and flubs are bound to creep in, imo. Not as bad as getting names wrong, perhaps, but inconsistencies nonetheless. I just think it's the nature of the medium.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

Which also might be true in case of our Sherlock's makers :D

 

You know, I kind of disagree.  I think Moffat and Gatiss spent quite a lot of their childhoods and teenage years fantasizing about being Sherlock Holmes and what kinds of adventures they could have, and then at a certain point, as they started acting, directing, and/or writing, it sort of morphed into "what could I do in that universe with my adult skills if I were allowed."  I almost bet that you could ask them all sorts of trivia questions about the ACD canon and they would be able to answer them, along with how they would modernize those elements or what they think is particularly fun or interesting about them.

 

 

True, but I also sort of agree with JP. For example, I've seen it said many times "nothing happens on this show by accident." But I disagree; although I think the boys put a lot of thought and geekery into Sherlock, I also think they're busy professionals operating on a tight schedule, in collaboration with dozens of other professionals, and they simply can't triple-check every word, glance or camera angle to make sure the show's exactly the way they want it. Inconsistencies and flubs are bound to creep in, imo. Not as bad as getting names wrong, perhaps, but inconsistencies nonetheless. I just think it's the nature of the medium.

 

 

Oh, yes, I totally agree with this.  I would almost guarantee that the final product isn't 100% congruent with the vision in Moffat's or Gatiss' heads, to say nothing of the vision of the set designer and the composer and the lighting director and all the other professionals who simply must be allowed to practice their art in order to do good work.  And that's before we get into budgets or timelines or accidents.

 

But I'd be willing to bet you a nice dinner that neither Moffat nor Gatiss have ever said, "I can't remember quite what the canon inspiration for this scene was like, but my books are in my office and I can't be bothered to go check."   ;)

  • Like 1
Posted

Not taking that bet! :p

  • Like 1
Posted

They might have better knowledge about canon than about their own show. Remember the Ugly Duckling Mystery? :lol4:
Arwel didn't remember that there were trees in front of Bart's once...
On the other side there are things like the billboard with Information is power...

Dear God, grant me the power to accept the the non existence of some Easter Eggs,
Courage to obsess about the existent ones,
And an ability-to-read-minds/several-hours-stuck-in-an-elevator-with-Mark,-Steven,-Arwel-and-Sarah-Arthur to know the difference.

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 137 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.