Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

To the best of my knowledge it means something like "can't speak because of all these FEELS".

Well, that is perfect definition of TRF to me.

  • Like 3
  • 1 month later...
Posted

I live in the USA and so I watched the Sherlock season 1 and 2 on Masterpiece on PBS when it had a marathon before season 4. Anyway, recently I bought Season 2 on DVD and was watching TRF. There are three Sherlock lines in the Molly scene where Sherlock asks for her help that aren't in the episode that aired on PBS. Is that common for PBS to cut out some of the scenes that would have aired on the BBC? If so, do all episodes have cut scenes or just some of them? I was surprised by that.

 

Edited to add: there was another scene at the end where Mycroft was reading the paper about Sherlock's "suicide" that was also cut by PBS.

Posted

Good grief, is PBS still running those mutilated versions of S1 and S2?

 

The thing was, they wanted to run the 90-minute episodes in 90-minute time slots, even though they were going to run lots of little tidbits along with them (the Masterpiece opening credits, the host's intro, the non-commercials, next week's preview, etc.).  So their answer was to have Hartswood chop 8 minutes out of each actual episode -- which must have felt (to Hartswood) like deciding which of your baby's fingers to chop off.

 

I first watched S2 on a region 2 DVD that we received in February, so by the time PBS ran the mutilated episodes in May, I had pretty well memorized the originals, and the cuts were (as you noted) glaringly obvious.  Here are the cuts I noticed at that time in "Scandal," "Hounds," and "Reichenbach."

Posted

Thanks! Wow 8 minutes???? Jeez.

 

I had also noted that scene in Scandal right before John leaves with Irene's friend to go to the warehouse and the lighter scene. Most of the cut scenes seemed relatively minor. The only obvious one that affected my viewing of the scene was the Molly scene because Sherlock showed appreciation for Molly's offer to help that you don't get from the scene with the lines cut.

 

But eight minutes is a lot. I feel like I have to re-watch all the episodes to find the other scenes I missed!

 

Thanks again for the information!

Posted

Watched Reichenbach today...when Moriarty was visiting Sherlock at Baker Street, and Sherlock said he "never liked riddles" - actually gave me a little lump in my throat this time, knowing the trauma he had trying to solve a riddle that lead to his best friend's death.  Well done, Moftiss.  :(

  • Like 4
Posted

Oh my, I never thought of that. Nice one, Redbeard.

  • 4 months later...
Posted

c004964c3147e5056f0c187c0319fb9a--runnin

 

I just noticed this graffiti for the first time (except I saw it in the scene where John is catching a taxi after finding out that Mrs. Hudson wasn't really shot).

 

One thing I like about this show: No matter how many times I watch, now and then I still catch new things I didn't see before.

  • Like 1
Posted

I've seen it mentioned, and I've seen screen caps of it like the one above ... but no, I've never managed to actually notice it while watching the episode. Too wrapped up in the plot by then, I suspect. But there's supposed to be an IOU associated with each of Moriarty's targets: John, Mrs. H, and Lestrade. I always catch the Lestrade one but not the other two. Can't even remember where the 3rd one is at the moment. And I'm never sure which one is for John, and which one is for Hudders.

Posted

The apparently Lestrade-related one (on the windows across from his office) is the most noticeable because it's part of the action (the lights go on, revealing the IOU, then immediately off again). The one across from number 221 is just background. I'm not coming up with a third one either, unless you mean the apple -- which is also part of the action

Posted

Hm, maybe. I just can't remember. Too subtle for the likes of me. :smile:

  • 5 months later...
Posted

You know what? It occurred to me that what John says at Sherlock's grave is this something Ella wanted him to say and he couldn't do it in her presence. What he says seems to be carefully prepared (which look like his usual way) and when it's over he looks like a pupil who just recited a complicated formula in front of a class. Only the "one more thing" seems to be spontaneous.

 

(sorry in case I've wrote it already)

Posted

Yes, that's how I've always read that scene as well. Poor John, I imagine he rehearsed that in his head for weeks. :cry:

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

We've an explanation of the "repeat of 1972" we were wondering about. This is from the script:
 

 

MYCROFT
Tradition, John. Our traditions
define us.
JOHN
Not allowed to talk to one another?
MYCROFT
For the best, believe me. Three
quarters of the diplomatic service
and half of the Tory front bench
all sharing one tea trolley.
JOHN
Can’t even say ‘Pass the sugar’?

MYCROFT
Lord, no. 1971. The last time
someone spoke in that room. Two
diplomats fighting over cream buns.
Nearly caused a coup in Venezuela.
Best if we keep mum.

 

Again, nothing of importance. Actually they should have left it out entirely, but I suspect they like to… watch us dance. (almost wrote it as watch us dense, which is also kind of true )

  • Like 2
Posted

Which now makes me wonder if 1971 was a real incident. :D

 

Hm, I see there was a coupe in Uganda that year.....

Posted

Oh geez, I didn't even notice .... :wacko:

Posted

Just started watching this ep again, still find it incredibly sexy the way he looms over Kitty Riley in the toilets immediately after she shuts the door. :drool: I think it must be the alpha male aspect of it. 

Posted

Agreed, Pseud,

That scene with Kitty is one of Bendi's hottest moments as Sherlock.  He sizes her up (up very close) like he's a black panther and she's dinner.  That scene is so hot, one forgets entirely that it's taking place in a public men's toilet.   Watching Ben loom so attractively, a person of my modest stature (165 cm) thinks, "Hell, yeah . .that's plenty tall enough for me!!  Whoo--can I get some water, please?"  His words say "You . .repel . .me".  Oddly, they have the exact reverse effect on the females listening.  I'm hearing "You, me, this wall right here will do . ." (It is the gents' toilets after all; I think the floor would be out of the question.)

We are all gratified to see that Sherlock Holmes washes his hands, though we never doubted it.

Kitty Riley is sort of a mash-up of a couple of Canon characters . . her name suggests Kitty Winter, the intrepid girl done so wrong by a bad man in 'The Illustrious Client' . . but her role, of the aggressive relentless journalist makes her more like Langdale Pike from 'The Three Gables".  We weren't really sure we liked Kitty, but we sure envied her that little encounter in the men's toilets at the Old Bailey, and that's not a sentence one has the opportunity to write every day, or more than once in a lifetime, really.  Kitty was an interesting figure and I would have liked to see her again.  Like after Sherl was resurrected and gave a press conference for all the London media outside 221B.  Kitty certainly would have been there . . and then barged her way inside and demanded the full scoop.

  • Like 1
Posted
On 2/12/2018 at 6:34 AM, Pseudonym said:

Just started watching this ep again, still find it incredibly sexy the way he looms over Kitty Riley in the toilets immediately after she shuts the door. :drool: I think it must be the alpha male aspect of it. 

 

On 2/12/2018 at 11:52 AM, Hikari said:

Agreed, Pseud,

That scene with Kitty is one of Bendi's hottest moments as Sherlock.  He sizes her up (up very close) like he's a black panther and she's dinner.  That scene is so hot, one forgets entirely that it's taking place in a public men's toilet.   Watching Ben loom so attractively, a person of my modest stature (165 cm) thinks, "Hell, yeah . .that's plenty tall enough for me!!  Whoo--can I get some water, please?"  His words say "You . .repel . .me".  Oddly, they have the exact reverse effect on the females listening.  I'm hearing "You, me, this wall right here will do . ." (It is the gents' toilets after all; I think the floor would be out of the question.)

 

Count me in on this one.  The alpha male thing really does it for me sometimes, and this is one of those times.

Posted

Poor me :P , I may have to watch this episode again just to gauge my reaction to this scene. Normally I'm quite uncomfortable around alpha people, unless their dominance is a result of competence, and not just ego. I adore paramedics, for example. :smile:

I do remember thinking he was pretty mean to Kitty, even when I realized it was all part of his plan to turn the press against himself. She was a bit creepy, but that's no reason to be as nasty as Sherlock was. But I tend to have a soft spot for reporters, too, which I suspect most people in the public eye do not. Can't really blame them.

  • Like 1
Posted
10 minutes ago, Arcadia said:

Poor me :P , I may have to watch this episode again just to gauge my reaction to this scene. Normally I'm quite uncomfortable around alpha people, unless their dominance is a result of competence, and not just ego. I adore paramedics, for example. :smile:

I do remember thinking he was pretty mean to Kitty, even when I realized it was all part of his plan to turn the press against himself. She was a bit creepy, but that's no reason to be as nasty as Sherlock was. But I tend to have a soft spot for reporters, too, which I suspect most people in the public eye do not. Can't really blame them.

Kitty hustles . . and is a bit of a hustler, as modern journalists must be if they are going to be successful.  I don't have the right pushy personality or energy levels to make a success as a reporter, so while I'm uncomfortable around Kitty-type people and find them both incredibly intrusive and also insensitive and cutthroat in the pursuit of a story or a scoop . .  they are only doing what is required in that business.  Kitty wasn't half as smart as she thought herself because she got used good by Moriarty.  Not only as a 'source' but, more fool her if she thought 'Rich Brook' was her boyfriend, too.  Still, Kitty has the makings of a very successful major metro crime beat reporter.  Gatiss should certainly have written her in to the 'Sherlock Resurrection Press Conference' where they could have a reenactment of 'You repel me'.  Actually, though, Kitty wound up doing Sherlock a favor . . she was both his and Mycroft's tool, really . .since her 'expose' of 'Rich Brook' was exactly according to plan.  She is an echo of Langdale Pike who is a potentially adversarial reporter who winds up helping Holmes.

The actress was cute and I have always wanted to have red hair and that kind of chutzpah.  She reminds me a lot of the actress who played "Kitty Winter" on Elementary, Ophelia Lovibond.  They have that same kind of street-smart waif vibe.

Posted

I was always surprised by how nasty the 'you repel me' line is, but then she had followed him into the men's toilets and prevented him from leaving when he tried to, which is pretty creepy whichever way you swing it. Plus pretending to be a starstruck fan when she actually just wanted to use him was pretty sleazy. I don't think reporters, especially that type of tabloid reporter, have a great rep in this country. Most people who don't read tabloids pretty much think those types of reporters are pretty scummy. Yes, she wants to think of herself as a hard-hitting investigative journalist, but from the way she portrays herself she's more likely to be writing for The Daily Mail or The Sun. 

It's funny you say you have a soft spot for reporters, I generally can't stand them. 

I never thought Sherlock was deliberately trying to turn the press against himself, it was more just something that would happen and wasn't worthy of his notice. He's too concerned with Moriarty himself and the fact he's turned NSY against him to bother himself with the press. 

It's not the scene in general I find sexy, though I do quite like it, it's that one moment of looming. He's right in her personal space, making a point of how much bigger he is, trying to silently intimidate her, though it doesn't seem to quite work. Maybe she's also too busy thinking :drool::drool::drool:

 

  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, J.P. said:

Isn't it the only time when Sherlock is intentionally nasty to someone? With the aim to hurt?


Anderson and Donovan don't count :D

What about Janine?  You don’t really think that’s the only time Sherlock was intentionally nasty do you?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 133 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.