Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

Yeah, but ....

 

I think the problem is, the explanation in TEH introduces Mycroft into the equation. And once Mycroft's involved, why is anyone else necessary? They've made it look as though he has unlimited power and resources; surely he could have procured someone to do the same things Molly did, and not at the last minute.

 

TRF makes us believe that Sherlock is figuring out Moriarty's each move as he goes along; he goes for the ride in the cab by himself because he needs to think; he appears to have the sudden realization that he needs to die after they leave Kitty's; etc. On the roof he seems to still be putting some of the pieces together.

 

But in TEH, we learn that everything was planned months in advance. Mycroft already knew about the key code; info was fed to Moriarty precisely so he woulld take the actions he did; they'd already worked out a scenario in case Sherlock had to kill himself; etc.

 

Yes, it's clever that the Holmes boys were able to fool everyone; but it's not as emotionally satisfying as believing Sherlock was alone, desperate and survived by his wits. (Well, I guess it was emotionally satisfying for the Holmes boys. :D ) I think that's why I keep kicking against it.

 

And really, given what else we've been shown of their relationship, is it believable that Sherlock would have gone to Mycroft for help against Moriarty? It seems more likely to me that it was Mycroft's plan from the start, micromanaged down to the last detail, with Sherlock in the center as bait.

 

Yet at the same time I think we're supposed to believe what we saw in TRF was real, except for the roof scene ... Moffat has "admitted" that Sherlock was faking on the roof, and anyway that was an obvious assumption, imo, the moment we saw Sherlock was really alive.

 

It's just that it doesn't really fit with the explanation in TEH. *sigh*

 

No, it doesn't. The other day I caught myself thinking "I wonder how much of The Reichenbach Fall was actually real".

 

I am afraid the explanation would boil down to different writers and finishing the second series before it was clear that there would be a third. I really did not get the impression that series 2 and 3 were created in one go. It seemed to me more like they finished 2, then got the contract for three, took a (short) look at the story so far and went, hmmm... where could we go from here?

 

I do think we are all overestimating Mycroft, though. He likes to act as if he had unlimited power and resources and had every situation under control at any time, but I doubt it. His judgment also is not quite as infallible as he'd like. For example, he was unable to foresee that Irene Adler would be able to put Sherlock under her spell. I also think he really did not expect the shooting of Magnussen. And he doesn't just send Sherlock on missions because he wants to keep him off drugs, but he needs him sometimes, I think - when there's stuff to be done that not only requires legwork but is also too far outside the law for a civil servant to be officially involved.

 

 

  • Like 4
Posted

The other day I caught myself thinking "I wonder how much of The Reichenbach Fall was actually real".

 

I am afraid the explanation would boil down to different writers and finishing the second series before it was clear that there would be a third. I really did not get the impression that series 2 and 3 were created in one go. It seemed to me more like they finished 2, then got the contract for three, took a (short) look at the story so far and went, hmmm... where could we go from here?

I rather suspect you're right.  They specifically mentioned that they got the idea about the corpse having been one of Moriarty's henchmen from a friend who had already seen "Reichenbach."  And if they'd had "Empty Hearse" even sketched out by the time they filmed "Reichenbach," then surely they'd have filmed the flashback scenes for "Hearse" at the same time.

 

Not that there's anything wrong with that approach.  It's not my style, but I can certainly see that it would offer a challenge.  In fact, when we try to make sense of the apparent inconsistencies, we're doing the same thing -- and we enjoy it.

 

I do think we are all overestimating Mycroft ... he doesn't just send Sherlock on missions because he wants to keep him off drugs, but he needs him sometimes, I think - when there's stuff to be done that not only requires legwork but is also too far outside the law for a civil servant to be officially involved.

Sounds reasonable.  And if Mary really does/did work for him, that explanation could cover her as well.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

I do think we are all overestimating Mycroft, though. He likes to act as if he had unlimited power and resources and had every situation under control at any time, but I doubt it. His judgment also is not quite as infallible as he'd like. For example, he was unable to foresee that Irene Adler would be able to put Sherlock under her spell. I also think he really did not expect the shooting of Magnussen. And he doesn't just send Sherlock on missions because he wants to keep him off drugs, but he needs him sometimes, I think - when there's stuff to be done that not only requires legwork but is also too far outside the law for a civil servant to be officially involved.

 

 

^^^THIS

  • Like 2
Posted

 

And if they'd had "Empty Hearse" even sketched out by the time they filmed "Reichenbach," then surely they'd have filmed the flashback scenes for "Hearse" at the same time.

If you mean the fall explanations - they haven't. Watch for the trees in both episodes. :naughty:

Posted

Right -- they did not.  For one thing, there was news coverage of them filming the flashbacks during S3 production.  And as you say, them trees ain't there anymore.

Posted

I agree Mycroft can't be omnipotent; I'm just saying that's how they present him. Maybe we're just witnessing Sherlock's view of him?

 

They do say somewhere that they knew that he landed on some sort of air mattress when they filmed TRF. But that's not the detail that bothers me, it's all the angst Sherlock exhibits ... I want it to be real, not part of some act for John/the audience's benefit. Like Toby, I end up wondering if any of it is real.

Posted

They do say somewhere that they knew that he landed on some sort of air mattress when they filmed TRF. But that's not the detail that bothers me, it's all the angst Sherlock exhibits ... I want it to be real, not part of some act for John/the audience's benefit. Like Toby, I end up wondering if any of it is real.

 

Stepping off a four-story building is no cake-walk, air bag or no air bag.  It's tricky enough for someone with lots of training, who's been able to work up to the high falls gradually over time.  Even if the air bag was one item among many possibilities in Sherlock's massive flow chart, I doubt that he'd had any practice whatsoever.  However, I'm sure he was well aware that things could go badly wrong if he miscalculated.  (Presumably including landing head-first and breaking his neck, hitting too near the edge of the bag and bouncing off, or missing the bag altogether.)  He could wind up physically crippled or mentally incapacitated -- worse than death for a man who can't sit still and who identifies with his brain.

 

Then there's afterward.  He was walking into unknown dangers in unfamiliar territory without his usual support system -- most especially without the companionship of the man he'd come to depend on (and I don't mean Mycroft!).

 

Is that enough angst fodder for you?

  • Like 1
Posted

I agree Mycroft can't be omnipotent; I'm just saying that's how they present him. Maybe we're just witnessing Sherlock's view of him?

 

They do say somewhere that they knew that he landed on some sort of air mattress when they filmed TRF. But that's not the detail that bothers me, it's all the angst Sherlock exhibits ... I want it to be real, not part of some act for John/the audience's benefit. Like Toby, I end up wondering if any of it is real.

 

The "Angst" (it's so funny to use this word in English; it's actually German and means plain old fear) still makes plenty of sense to me even considering what we learned in The Empty Hearse - or rather I can still make plenty of sense of it.

 

When we saw The Reichenbach Fall, we thought Sherlock was truly contemplating death or some other kind of total ruin at the hands or Moriarty. Now we know that he and Mycroft actually had a plan very early on and that many of the upsetting events we witnessed were anticipated. But this also means that all along, Sherlock must have been fully aware that he was lying to everyone around him and also that he might have to use John as a witness for a fake suicide and that he would have to play dead for a while, leave London and live on the run in secrecy. He might have been more confident that he could take Moriarty down than he let on, but he must have been very aware of the price he needed to pay for that.

 

Now, I don't "ship" our boys as a romantic couple, but I am of the opinion that most of what happens in the series and especially Sherlock's behavior makes more sense if we assume that the one with John is Sherlock's primary relationship. People who called them a couple during the first two series weren't completely wrong, they were just assuming there was a sexual side to the partnership whereas we can, I think, be 99,9% sure there wasn't and never will be. But this does not mean it didn't exist.

 

Between The Hounds of Baskerville and The Reichenbach Fall, Sherlock was actually in a very good place. I don't know what his life was like before, but there are hints that it left plenty to be desired, that he was on drugs for a while, had almost no friends and no place to call a home in the true sense of the word. It's very likely that being at Baker St, clean, under Mrs Hudson's loving care and John's loyal companionship, with plenty of casework, a working alliance with the police via Lestrade and a rising reputation, our hero was probably as happy as he'd ever been for a long while. And then he realized that in order to win against Moriarty, he would have to give all that up. And he's smart enough to anticipate all possible consequences of such a sacrifice. Plus he has just enough heart to feel badly about being such a complete dickhead to the first and for a long time only friend in his life.

 

And the Angst is still there when he returns. Mycroft is talking about terrorist threats and Sherlock goes: "what about John Watson?" He doesn't seem to give a F*** about nutcases blowing up London, but it is highly relevant to him whether John is still around and whether there's any kind of chance that they can pick up where they left off two years ago.

 

 

Actually, if you look at things this way, his behavior towards Molly in that last lovely scene where he comes to her for help makes more sense as well. He didn't need her for the corpse. He could have gotten that from anybody, Mycroft could have made it appear somehow, he could have worked around it entirely. He needed one person with whom he could be honest. One friend whom he was not going to have to betray, who would not be trying to "move on" from him while he was away, but who would wait and love and welcome him back someday for sure. I think he also needed someone to just be vulnerable with. Even Sherlock must need that sometimes. And I'm sure it's easier for him to admit he's "not okay" to her than to John - let alone to Mycroft.

  • Like 5
Posted

I thought about playing devil's advocate here and pointing out why Sherlock could have been, in fact, an actual complete dickhead, but Van Buren might kill me so I'll let it slide. Besides, I'm pretty sure I did that already. :P
 
So I'll change the subject slightly. Even if Sherlock needs a little human comfort every once in a while ... would he ever admit such a thing to himself? Enough to do something about it? Or would he just tell himself to get over it and get on with "The Work?"
 
I think the audience has seen from day one that Sherlock needs John. But does Sherlock see that? I kind of think TAB is the first time he's ever admitted it; that he not merely enjoys John's company, but actually needs his loyalty and friendship. At least, that's one way I interpret the penultimate sequence.
 
So I'm not convinced Sherlock suffered from loneliness during the hiatus, or went to Molly out of a desire for friendship, or any of those other touchy-feely things ... simply because allowing himself to be affected by his feelings would have interfered with "The Work." As was confirmed rather disastrously at the end of HLV.
 
Aw, now I just want to hug him and tell him it's okay to be vulnerable sometimes...... :wub:

  • Like 1
Posted

.. However, I'm sure he was well aware that things could go badly wrong if he miscalculated. (Presumably including landing head-first and breaking his neck, hitting too near the edge of the bag and bouncing off, or missing the bag altogether.) He could wind up physically crippled or mentally incapacitated -- worse than death for a man who can't sit still and who identifies with his brain.

 

Then there's afterward. He was walking into unknown dangers in unfamiliar territory without his usual support system -- most especially without the companionship of the man he'd come to depend on (and I don't mean Mycroft!).

 

 

..

And then he realized that in order to win against Moriarty, he would have to give all that up. And he's smart enough to anticipate all possible consequences of such a sacrifice. Plus he has just enough heart to feel badly about being such a complete dickhead to the first and for a long time only friend in his life.

 

And the Angst is still there when he returns. Mycroft is talking about terrorist threats and Sherlock goes: "what about John Watson?" He doesn't seem to give a f*** about nutcases blowing up London, but it is highly relevant to him whether John is still around and whether there's any kind of chance that they can pick up where they left off two years ago.

 

 

Actually, if you look at things this way, his behavior towards Molly in that last lovely scene where he comes to her for help makes more sense as well. He didn't need her for the corpse. He could have gotten that from anybody, Mycroft could have made it appear somehow, he could have worked around it entirely. He needed one person with whom he could be honest. One friend whom he was not going to have to betray, who would not be trying to "move on" from him while he was away, but who would wait and love and welcome him back someday for sure. I think he also needed someone to just be vulnerable with. Even Sherlock must need that sometimes. And I'm sure it's easier for him to admit he's "not okay" to her than to John - let alone to Mycroft.

 

Nicely put, guys.

I have more but I can't articulate them well and all along those lines.

 

Maybe I'm in minority, but TEH never disturb TRF for me, not for one bit. Because there are a lot of reasons that I can make, and if all else fails, there is still one thing that I can hold on, which what the writers hold on too, that the true explanation is never known. His big blue theory and all he said to Anderson is presented in a way that we can never be sure, which is a safe way to see that if we want to move on from the loopholes. We still have fun mocking them though, nothing is wrong with that. It's endearing.

(The only thing that I brush aside is someone said about Moffat's comment that Sherlock is faking it, didn't see this myself. I'll have a word with him, I'm sure he didn't mean that. I want to test headbutt with him too if he insists)

 

TEH is far than perfect and has so many things 'wrong' with it, it's probably the only one they need to film some fillers to get 90 minutes. But I still love it, maybe because the explanation doesn't bother me too much (but I understand that it bothers a lot of fans who spent whole lot of time to theorize about it during the hiatus - must be frustating!).

 

To me, Sherlock-John, Mycroft-Sherlock, Sherlock-Molly scenes are precious, and most important of all: Sherlock is back.

 

I thought about playing devil's advocate here and pointing out why Sherlock could have been, in fact, an actual complete dickhead, but Van Buren might kill me so I'll let it slide. Besides, I'm pretty sure I did that already. :P

Whuuoott... did I ever? :p

No... no..no.. I think it's wiser to put you in straight jacket and talk about shoess... :)

  • Like 1
Posted

Nooo no no no no, not ... The Shoes!!!! I'll behave, I promise!!!!

  • Like 1
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

I've been thinking - Why did Sherlock say to Molly, "I think I'm going to die."

 

Well, I've been pondering it, because it never made sense to me that he was thinking someone was going to kill him.  Really kill him.  Rather, I think the more emotionally connecting paraphrase might read, "I think I need to fake my death and be dead for a while."  I think that's a really painful thing for him to have to think of because he knows it will hurt John, Mrs. Hudson, even Lestrade.  It will hurt Molly a little but less so because she's in on it.  But he has that devastating plan to work out.  He's already figured out that he's been turned into the villain and as such should be expected to die, but it still has to hurt to know that he's going to have to leave everyone grieving while he goes undercover for two years - or as long as it will take.

 

 

  • Like 3
Posted

That,

And I believe that he believes that there is a possibility he could really die. Like mentioned somewhere, he and Mycroft seem willing to go to extreme extent to get Moriarty.

 

Somewhat related (but not really!) lately I have been wondering why he only wears dressing gown when he was expecting Molly in TEH.

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, he was wearing just a little bit more than just a dressing gown! :d

 

Maybe he'd just woken up? The Coat was still in the dryer? He knew Molly would like it?

 

Posted

Well, he was wearing just a little bit more than just a dressing gown! :d

To my disappointment, yes, indeed more.

 

Maybe he'd just woken up? The Coat was still in the dryer?

Nope, he had met Mycroft in the morning, and that was around one o'clock.

 

He knew Molly would like it?

Hmmmmmmm
Posted

That settles it then ... he did it to please Molly! :smile:

  • 2 months later...
Posted

I was anxious, getting nuts from waiting for some news, so I was poking on TRF's big blue, don't recall we went this way before, so..

 

Warning: crazy alert.

 

How many seconds Sherlock has before he plummets onto the pavement?

 

To calculate this, we need the height of Barts.

Apparently it's not easy at all to get the information (because maybe noone needs it), and the info I found is: 62 feet 7 inch and the other is 135 feet. 135 feet could be another part of the building, the new center (and 135 feet sounds very high for four storey building while ~63 feet sounds very reasonable for style like Barts) but since there is only one source for each and they are nowhere close to each other I had to try another approach to be sure.

 

Outside Barts there is an iconic red telephone booth, by finding out its height, it could help to estimate the height of Barts by rough calculation by proportion. And dang, apparently there are multiple types of red telephone booths. Finally, the ones that fit as suspects are K2 and K6 type, based on material, availability, location and design. Closer look determine that it's K2 that has height of 9 feet (2.74 meter).

 

lwJpqNI.jpg

 

jhbZxxj.jpg

 

So by rough estimation from proportion it seems reasonable that Barts is 63 feet high (19.2 meter).

 

Free fall formula, with the principle that all objects regardless of their mass, free fall at the same rate of 9.8, and any resistance from air (drag) is neglected.

 

Formula: Height = 0.5 g.t^2

 

t is time in seconds.

So t = √(19.2x2)/9.8 = 1.98 seconds

 

The time Sherlock has to plummet onto the pavement is 1.98 seconds.

 

wm12syF.jpg

 

2pzzfgg.jpg

 

From John's point of view (blocked by Ambulance Station), Sherlock falls at least until there is one and half storey left from the ground, so he has one and half storey to start turning and falls on his back.

To simplify matter, increased acceleration (that actually matters a lot = the closer you are to the ground the faster you fall) is discounted, and even so, by the time Sherlock reaches that height he only has 0.74 seconds on average (and significantly less from acceleration) to turn around and fall.

 

30c0h8o.jpg

 

Plausible? Err... you are in big trouble Moffiss.

What is the impact? I don't really care, I still appreciate TRF so much even if Sherlock has to survive with real magic.

I just try to revenge my throbbing headache by making it thinks more. :)

 

(P.S. originally did this for Fun Fact thread, but decide that I could torture more people here :p

 

P.P.S I have temporary Imgur block on my area, so I can't see my own images. Hopefully it loads right)

  • Like 3
Posted

Aha! We agree that it's a K2 phone booth. That's good -- I wasn't sure on the other thread.

 

Added: But there's still one (?!) remaining question -- how long do we see Sherlock falling in the episode? Seems like a heck of a lot longer than a couple seconds! :wtf: (Yeah, I know -- dramatic license.)

  • Like 2
Posted

Yes I think they show it from different angles/POVs, that's why it's much longer.

 

Seems like some of my images don't appear properly, for some reason I can't access Imgur now, will try to reload it from another host tomorrow.

 

Eta: Fixed! As far as I know.

Posted

Doing this, I noticed something very obvious, but escaped me back then: the white thing on his waist, what is that? He wore black that time. Is it possible they are that careless not to notice that?

Posted

If you mean what I think you do, it's his shirt-tail, which apparently came untucked.

Posted

But he's wearing a dark shirt, isn't he?

 

Y'know, something about that white always struck me as odd, but I never could figure out what. But that's it ... he was wearing all dark clothes. So either he wears a white tee under that or that's his underpants, pulled really high. Or..... a safety harness. You would think they'd know to color that black though.

 

Huh.

  • Like 1
Posted

'Scuse me, I believe I meant undershirt.  Somebody posted what I considered convincing evidence a while back, presumably on this thread, but minimally somewhere on this forum.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 144 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.