Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't find it too grim. There's a major plot line at the moment though that we are meant to care about that is boring the life out of me.

 

Maybe it's just the episodes I tried to watch, but they were very dark and utterly without humor, so I just assumed the whole series was like that. Doesn't make them bad, just not what I'm looking for. Do different episodes have different tones?

 

Any thoughts on the new Star Trek series trailer? I think it looks pretty good. Though I'm not sure about the death guy, he's a bit cheesy. 

 

 

Michelle Yeoh, yeah!!! Love her. Oh my yessiree, this definitely looks like it's worth giving a try.

Posted

Ah, no in that case they are all pretty similar, they are all very very serious. In that regard I guess it is all dark since it's all played so straight.

 

Re Star Trek I love how slick it looks, series these days look just as sophisticated as films.

  • Like 1
Posted

I think that's what's putting me off a bit.  This is supposed to be before Kirk's era, right?  Yet there seems to be a female captain?  (Well, maybe it's not a starship?)  And the ship is pretty sleek.  Of course, 10 years before Kirk puts it 90 years after ST: Enterprise, so you wouldn't expect things to be nearly as all-the-bolts-showing as that ship.  But still, I find it noticeably sleeker than Kirk's original Enterprise, which seems a bit off.  (Not that I'm expecting the props to be made out of plywood, mind you!)

 

They're needing to tread a fine line -- slick enough for modern audiences, yet believably pre-Kirk.  I'd have to see more to know what I think.

  • Like 1
Posted

Or they could be going AU. I really like the Chris Pine et al reboot, much better than any of the "in universe" sequels, so apparently lack of continuity doesn't bother me. Well, I know that it does, actually, but somehow I'm able to regard the reboots as simply a different universe, and let it go at that. Sort of like how I could care less whether "our" Sherlock behaves like Doyle's.

 

I did like Voyager, I seem to be one of the few. Although I didn't watch it religiously, which says a lot. Only the first series inspired that level of devotion.

  • Like 1
Posted

I know what you mean about how slick it is, but my magpie side likes shiny things too much to care. ;)

 

I liked Voyager, though Jane Way's voice used to freak me out a bit. Deep Space 9 used to bore the life out of me since it took out all the exploring fun out. 

  • Like 1
Posted

OMG, you're right, that's it ... that's why I never could get anything out of DS9! It bored me too but I never realized why. I guess because I was too bored to think about it.
 
I know what you mean about Janeway's voice, but I got used to it. I loved Picard's voice, but got tired of it. Next Gen just tried too hard, or something.

 

Now I feel like Mama and Papa Bear; "It's too soft! It's too cold! Complain complain!" :d

Posted

Hmm, maybe the spinoffs palled after a while simply because they kept going past their prime? Whereas TOS was basically abandoned after two seasons, then left to die an ugly death.

  • Like 1
Posted

It might be a generational thing as well, when I grew up TNG was the one on TV, and was my favourite, TOS seemed like a kitchy throwback with naff effects by then. 

Posted

Can't argue about the effects! They were really cool at the time (for those of us who'd grown up with the old Flash Gordon matinee serials on television). But not only were special effects still in their infancy then, they also had hardly any budget (by today's standards). A lot of the gadgetry on the walls is simply discarded foam packing material, spray painted. I saw one of the desktop communicators once -- it was plywood. But for that time, it was great -- and inspired more ambitious effects, which make their inspirations look cheesy. Such is progress!

  • Like 1
Posted

I was watching "Court Martial" the other night and was surprised at how effective one of the shots of the Enterprise was. But Engineering looked like it had been built out of giant tinker toys. Wooden ones. :D
 
Also Shatner was really good in his role at that point, I have a tendency to remember him as really hammy, but he wasn't, at least, not in those early episodes.
 
At lot of the music is pretty cringeworthy, though. In the canteen scene they were playing Muzak versions of the theme music. Egad. :blink:

 

Posted

Engineering probably *was* built out of Tinkertoys.  Hey, *you* try building a starship on a $5 budget!

 

It always looked to me like Shatner did a beautiful job in the good episodes, but didn't bother if the script wasn't up to his standards.  He and I seem to have similar taste in Trek episodes, but his careless attitude still seems pretty unprofessional to me.

 

Apparently they didn't have much of a music budget either.  (But Roddenberry managed to get a slice of it for himself, despite having made no musical contributions to the show.  He wrote "lyrics" to the theme music -- which were never used, and were in fact unsingable -- and then claimed half the royalties.  Alexander Courage was not amused.)

Posted

I haven't been watching the episodes I don't like, so I can't compare the acting chops. But I associate the hamminess mostly with S3, and S3 with most of the bad scripts, so that makes sense.

 

One S3 episode I liked that most people seem to put down: "Turnabout Intruder." I thought Shatner did a good job of revealing little feminine characteristics here and there. And I never thought the woman was considered incapable just because she was a woman; I thought it was because she was nutz.

  • Like 1
Posted

There are some lines in that episode that can be interpreted to mean that women were (at least de facto) barred from being starship captains at that time. But in her case, nuts for sure, yeah.

 

I like the episode itself well enough, partly because I'm fascinated by mind-swap stories. And I found the guest actress's performance as Kirk quite convincing. She and/or the director had done their homework.

 

Warning: Rant ahead. You happened to push one of my buttons.

 

However, I was not the least bit impressed by Shatner's performance as the woman. It struck me as more of a parody of a woman, Kirk in drag. If he was indeed portraying a woman, she was certainly not Janice Lester.

 

For comparison (though there really is none), I refer you to Martin Freeman's performances in another mind-swap story, Boy Meets Girl. Freeman isn't playing a woman there, he's being a woman.

 

End of rant. :D

Posted

Eh, you remember it better than I do. The channel that is running Trek just restarted S1, it will be awhile before I get a chance to check it out. I dimly remember something like what you said, though. About women captains, I mean.

 

Mostly I remember the scene where Kirk is filing his nails. I thought he walked a nice line between characterization and parody, there. But it's been a lonnnnnng time since I've seen it, I might hate it now.

Posted

When you do get a chance to see it (presumably in three or four months), pay careful attention to Kirk and Lester's behavior before the swap.  Then see how well you think they each portray the other, post-swap.  And please feel free to disagree with me.  I'd love to discuss this.  :jedi:

 

Posted

Remind me. :D

Posted

When you do get a chance to see it (presumably in three or four months), pay careful attention to Kirk and Lester's behavior before the swap.  Then see how well you think they each portray the other, post-swap.  And please feel free to disagree with me.  I'd love to discuss this.  :jedi:

 

I actually am in the camp that thinks Shatner did a good job portraying Kirk-as-Lester, especially given that Lester is slowly (or quickly) losing her mind throughout the whole thing. I have always thought Shatner did a good job with a horrible script on that one. 

 

It's funny, I don't really believe that Starfleet at that time would disallow female captains, but I believe it for the purposes of that episode.  That and the fact that in "The Cage," Pike tells Yeoman Colt he can't get used to having a woman on the bridge, other than Number One, who he apparently doesn't view as a woman. So those two things together make me think that Discovery must be in the reboot universe rather than the classic one.

  • Like 1
Posted

It's crazy that in the distant future, where Earthlings all get along and aliens are common place, women are still not allowed to be captains. How could they not have realised how backwards that was? They were happily breaking other prejudices, that seems a weird one to keep. 

Posted

The story I heard was that Roddenberry wanted to be more progressive than that, but he was told by the networks that having both an alien and a woman on the bridge (as he did in The Cage) would be asking the audience to believe too much fantasy, and that he could keep Spock or Number One.  Since he was already dating Majel Barrett, he kept Leonard Nimoy as Spock and later found a way to sneak Majel in there with a bleach job as Nurse Chapel.  Happily, she appeared or was heard (as the voice of the computer) in every version of Star Trek until her death.

  • Like 1
Posted

Right -- the upcoming reboot movie will be the first one without Majel's computer voice -- the end of an era.
 
Regarding Roddenberry's story about having to choose between Spock and Number One, one reason he gave for choosing Spock was that having someone who's obviously not human right there on the bridge was a constant reminder to the audience that they were in outer space.  So apparently he chose making the show more believable over making it more progressive -- probably the better choice, actually.  Progressive doesn't do much good if you've lost the audience.
 
Unfortunately for Majel, Nurse Chapel was a big step down from Number One as regards having anything to sink her teeth into.  The poor actress wouldn't get another decent role in the Trekverse till Lwaxana Troi in NextGen (and that character was a joy to watch!).
 

It's funny, I don't really believe that Starfleet at that time would disallow female captains, but I believe it for the purposes of that episode.  That and the fact that in "The Cage," Pike tells Yeoman Colt he can't get used to having a woman on the bridge, other than Number One, who he apparently doesn't view as a woman. So those two things together make me think that Discovery must be in the reboot universe rather than the classic one.


Oh, good point.  That would make more sense.

  • Like 1
Posted

The idea of having a *gasp* female alien, such as making Spock female, didn't occur? Must have been too 'out there' sadly. I don't know a lot about the original series I admit. 

Posted

According to Roddenberry, he'd had Nimoy in mind for that sort of role since before he actually thought of Star Trek. So, no, recasting wasn't really an option.

 

There was one "sex change" on the bridge, though. The original communications officer was male.

  • Like 1
Posted

Was Uhura the comms officer?

 

Judging from the trailer the new cap seems to be half Vulcan? I'm surprised she doesn't have pointy ears (I know she wouldn't have to, but everyone loves a good pair of pointy ears). Or am I missing something?

Posted

Right, Uhura replaced a black male comm officer, Lt. Alden, who appeared only in the second pilot, Where No Man Has Gone Before.

  • Like 1
Posted

Y'know, I always rationalized it (the attitude towards women) by assuming some sort of Dark Ages had occurred in Earth's history, and women were only just reestablishing their equality. Given some of the beliefs still rampant today, that doesn't really seem so far-fetched to me. :(

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 115 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.