Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Oh, lol.  I thought you were arguing for N and was all eh?  lol

 

Not at all :D More like bored while waiting for RP further down this forum to start ^.^

Posted

I like the theory too, but I also think it's too far-fetched.  I know I'm in a minority, but I just never think that Sherlock's drug use was ever that bad.  I've always thought that everyone around him, particularly Mycroft, leaps to calling it "substance abuse" and a "drug habit" when Sherlock is more or less in control of it.  I've written a meta I plan to post on AO3 about this subject, but I suppose I keep getting cold feet because I don't have the prevailing opinion.

I don't think you're necessarily in the minority here in that regard. You may well be in the minority among fanfic writers in general, but so what? Several of us here write non-slash fiction! If we're all in the minority, does that make us the majority?

 

S/N:  I think Mycroft is more of a classic Sensor.  He has positioned himself to where his work allows him an eagle-eye view of a situation, and then he reacts accordingly.  His work may well have made him more of an S than he was as a young man.  I think Sherlock, again, is close to the S/N line.  He wants data, but then he uses that data to make intuitive leaps.

That's interesting -- my feeling is that Sherlock's deductions are based on flashes of insight that he strings together with logic. But maybe that's just my "N" talking!

 

... in SiB, I think the meeting with John about what to tell Sherlock about Irene is ... some sort of test for John to determine his acting ability (and later used to decide whether to recruit him in Sherlock's disappearance in Reichenbach or to leave him outside).

Oh, I like that! The more devious Mycroft is, the better I love to hate him!

 

The three types most often attributed to Mycroft on the web are ISTJ, INTJ, INTP.

If Mycroft is an INTP, I hereby resign!

Posted

 

S/N:  I think Mycroft is more of a classic Sensor.  He has positioned himself to where his work allows him an eagle-eye view of a situation, and then he reacts accordingly.  His work may well have made him more of an S than he was as a young man.  I think Sherlock, again, is close to the S/N line.  He wants data, but then he uses that data to make intuitive leaps.

That's interesting -- my feeling is that Sherlock's deductions are based on flashes of insight that he strings together with logic. But maybe that's just my "N" talking!

 

Chicken or egg, which one came first?  :P 

 

 

 

... in SiB, I think the meeting with John about what to tell Sherlock about Irene is ... some sort of test for John to determine his acting ability (and later used to decide whether to recruit him in Sherlock's disappearance in Reichenbach or to leave him outside).

Oh, I like that! The more devious Mycroft is, the better I love to hate him!

 

 

Don't forget his collaborator. You know, the one who used John Watson as experimental subject in Baskerville.  :D

 

 

 

The three types most often attributed to Mycroft on the web are ISTJ, INTJ, INTP.

If Mycroft is an INTP, I hereby resign!

 

Which one? *whistle innocently*  :angel2:

 

tumblr_inline_mnfhnp7Iu21qz4rgp.jpg

 

Or

 

mycroft-holmes.jpg

  • Like 2
Posted

 

tumblr_inline_mnfhnp7Iu21qz4rgp.jpg

 

 

I love that picture of Mycroft before the British flag! It's absolutely perfect.

 

:lol: Mycrfot really infuriates me, and I keep thinking I dislike him, but then I see a picture like that and remember all his glorious lines and go awwww... Poor Mycroft never gets half enough recognition from me. The show wouldn't be the same without him.

 

I guess he's the kind of character I love to hate.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I love that picture of Mycroft before the British flag! It's absolutely perfect.

:lol: Mycrfot really infuriates me, and I keep thinking I dislike him, but then I see a picture like that and remember all his glorious lines and go awwww... Poor Mycroft never gets half enough recognition from me. The show wouldn't be the same without him.

 

I guess he's the kind of character I love to hate.

 

 

 

Besuited smug busybody?  :giggle:

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I like the theory too, but I also think it's too far-fetched.  I know I'm in a minority, but I just never think that Sherlock's drug use was ever that bad.  I've always thought that everyone around him, particularly Mycroft, leaps to calling it "substance abuse" and a "drug habit" when Sherlock is more or less in control of it.  I've written a meta I plan to post on AO3 about this subject, but I suppose I keep getting cold feet because I don't have the prevailing opinion.

I don't think you're necessarily in the minority here in that regard. You may well be in the minority among fanfic writers in general, but so what? Several of us here write non-slash fiction! If we're all in the minority, does that make us the majority?

 

 

 

 

Heh.   ;)   Thanks for the encouragement.  I've been writing a series of non-slash, pro-Janine stories that include Sherlock being in control of his drug use.  I think I could just email the four people who share my perspective and be done with it.

 

Shadow, I like that picture of Mycroft, too.  Whether you think he's an ISTJ, INTJ, or INTP, the Mycroft personality has its benefits.  Mycroft gets things done.  He marshals resources and applies them to problems until he has solutions.  I don't know that I particularly "like" Mycroft, but I think he's a fascinating character, and he fulfills a particular role in the Sherlock universe that we would otherwise miss, I think.  I love what Moftiss have done with the part writing-wise and what Gatiss does with the acting, because he is so much more than he is in the books/stories while remaining absolutely true to them.

  • Like 1
Posted

Am I the only one who just really loves Mycroft? :)

  • Like 1
Posted

Am I the only one who just really loves Mycroft? :)

 

:wave:  :cheers:  :lol4:

  • Like 2
Posted

I think this is why I'm not opposed to a potential 3rd Holmes brother, besides the far-fetched rumors of Hiddleston.  Sherlock and Mycroft are both so fantabulous to me that a 3rd just seems like more awesome.

  • Like 1
Posted

Am I the only one who just really loves Mycroft? :)

 

 

No I do too.

  • Like 1
Posted

I like the theory too, but I also think it's too far-fetched.  I know I'm in a minority, but I just never think that Sherlock's drug use was ever that bad.  I've always thought that everyone around him, particularly Mycroft, leaps to calling it "substance abuse" and a "drug habit" when Sherlock is more or less in control of it.  I've written a meta I plan to post on AO3 about this subject, but I suppose I keep getting cold feet because I don't have the prevailing opinion. 

 

So? What a boring place the world would be if we all agreed on everything!

 

I suppose the problem here is that in real life, there is no such thing as "being in control of" drug use, and I guess a lot of people protest against the idea in fiction because they are concerned that it will give impressible, naive audience members bad ideas. I don't look to fiction for advice on how to run my life, though, so personally, I don't give a damn. On the contrary, I become annoyed when I get the impression that a writer is trying to be preachy. All I want is a good story and interesting characters. Sermons are for church. 

 

Unfortunately, I have an immature liking for characters who are pretty damaged, so I'd probably be nothing short of delighted if it turned out that Sherlock did at some early time in his life have a considerable drug problem and was in a very bad state, but I see absolutely zero evidence of that in what we've been shown so far. I think Sherlock really is in control of his drug intake and only does it for fun when he has nothing else to keep his brain from rotting, and he can do that because he's F***ing Sherlock Holmes and not an ordinary goldfish like the rest of us.

 

As for what Mycroft thinks or says about Sherlock, Mycroft is the one who thinks his brother is stupid, so I wouldn't exactly take his word as gospel.

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think Mycroft really thinks Sherlock is stupid.  If he did, why would he trust him with the cases he gives him?  The missions he sends him on?  I think Sherlock thinks Mycroft thinks he's stupid.

 

I think the only two times Sherlock's stupidity is brought up are:

 

(from Ariane DeVere)

 

MYCROFT: Don’t be smart.
SHERLOCK: That takes me back. (In a little boy’s voice) “Don’t be smart, Sherlock. I’m the smart one.”
MYCROFT (glowering at him): I am the smart one.
(Sherlock looks off to the side reflectively.)
SHERLOCK: I used to think I was an idiot.
MYCROFT: Both of us thought you were an idiot, Sherlock. We had nothing else to go on ’til we met other children.
 
MYCROFT: It doesn’t matter about the gun. Don’t be stupid.
(Sherlock turns and walks towards him. Mycroft leans forward and folds his hands on the table in front of him.)
MYCROFT: You always were so stupid.
(Sherlock continues towards him, but now he’s a young boy – about eleven years old – and wearing dark trousers and a shirt with a buttoned dark green cardigan over it. He walks slowly towards his big brother.)
MYCROFT: Such a disappointment.
YOUNG SHERLOCK (angrily): I’m not stupid.
MYCROFT (sternly): You’re a very stupid little boy.
 
Right?  Am I forgetting any?
 
In the first scene, I just see them both acknowledging that Mycroft is the "smart one," and that Mycroft, and subsequently Sherlock, thought Sherlock was an idiot until they met other children.  I don't take this to mean Mycroft still thinks Sherlock is an idiot.  I think there's baggage there for Sherlock that Mycroft called him an idiot as kids, and probably still carries that with him internally, but I don't think Mycroft still thinks Sherlock is an idiot.  To me it's the remnants of a childish feud and bullying on the part of Mycroft.  Even though Sherlock logically knows he's not an idiot, I do think though that he may still think Mycroft think's he an idiot.
 
Second scene isn't even Mycroft; it's Sherlock's mind palace.  So this is just a recreation of what Sherlock believes Mycroft thinks.  

 

 

  • Like 4
Posted

On the drug use, I've always assumed that Sherlock's drug habit was probably out of control at one point until he started solving crimes to keep himself occupied.  I guess I've always assumed that because Mycroft gets pretty worked up (not visibly) when he thinks Sherlock might be in danger of using again (the night Irene Adler supposedly died, when he recruits Anderson and friends to sweep the apt. for drugs in HLV).

  • Like 2
Posted

 

I like the theory too, but I also think it's too far-fetched.  I know I'm in a minority, but I just never think that Sherlock's drug use was ever that bad.  I've always thought that everyone around him, particularly Mycroft, leaps to calling it "substance abuse" and a "drug habit" when Sherlock is more or less in control of it.  I've written a meta I plan to post on AO3 about this subject, but I suppose I keep getting cold feet because I don't have the prevailing opinion. 

 

So? What a boring place the world would be if we all agreed on everything!

 

I suppose the problem here is that in real life, there is no such thing as "being in control of" drug use, and I guess a lot of people protest against the idea in fiction because they are concerned that it will give impressible, naive audience members bad ideas. I don't look to fiction for advice on how to run my life, though, so personally, I don't give a damn. On the contrary, I become annoyed when I get the impression that a writer is trying to be preachy. All I want is a good story and interesting characters. Sermons are for church. 

 

Unfortunately, I have an immature liking for characters who are pretty damaged, so I'd probably be nothing short of delighted if it turned out that Sherlock did at some early time in his life have a considerable drug problem and was in a very bad state, but I see absolutely zero evidence of that in what we've been shown so far. I think Sherlock really is in control of his drug intake and only does it for fun when he has nothing else to keep his brain from rotting, and he can do that because he's F***ing Sherlock Holmes and not an ordinary goldfish like the rest of us.

 

As for what Mycroft thinks or says about Sherlock, Mycroft is the one who thinks his brother is stupid, so I wouldn't exactly take his word as gospel.

 

 

 

 

 

I do think it is possible to ride the line of drug use/abuse for a very long time.  I'm thinking of the number of people I know who "only smoke in bars," and therefore they smoke 4-6 times a year.  I'd say their nicotine addiction is "under control."  The problem, of course, is that as you slide up the scale toward heroin and cocaine, your ability to pull that stunt grows slimmer.  

 

I agree that Sherlock only does drugs when he's not immersed in a case, and that the drugs are the sub for the case, not the other way around.  And that he's in control because he's Sherlock F'ing Holmes and he can do this stuff, not because he's a role model in that regard that I'd trot out to show children.  I don't particularly want to see him addicted, and I certainly don't want to see him do rehab and all that rot -- I lived through all that while watching House, and if I want to see that, I'll re-watch those episodes.  I want to see our Sherlock walk the line.  

 

 

On the drug use, I've always assumed that Sherlock's drug habit was probably out of control at one point until he started solving crimes to keep himself occupied.  I guess I've always assumed that because Mycroft gets pretty worked up (not visibly) when he thinks Sherlock might be in danger of using again (the night Irene Adler supposedly died, when he recruits Anderson and friends to sweep the apt. for drugs in HLV).

 

I assume that he's had out of control moments but not out of control periods.  I'm assuming that any wild abandon with substances was eliminated in university because he realized that actual abuse could endanger the Work, and that he's really only used substances to self-medicate since, keeping a pretty tight hold on how much/how often.  I think Mycroft is a busy-body who, like any family member would, has freaked out about knowing that Sherlock used substances without knowing what we, the viewers, are allowed to think -- that he's Sherlock F'ing Holmes, and he's got this under control.

 

That, of course, is just my head canon, but its the perspective I use when I dabble with fiction.

Posted

 I think Mycroft is a busy-body who, like any family member would, has freaked out about knowing that Sherlock used substances without knowing what we, the viewers, are allowed to think -- that he's Sherlock F'ing Holmes, and he's got this under control.

 

Mycroft just doesn't share our perspective on Sherlock. For him, he's not a cool hero detective genius, but his vulnerable, irresponsible, unpredictable, unwise little brother, always in danger of falling apart and taking half the world down with him.

 

 

  • Like 4
Posted

Oh, I wasn't trying to imply that N's can't be pragmatic.  I put more emphasis on my unfounded belief that Mycroft is a very methodical thinker, than on the pragmatism, in categorizing him as an S.  But the MBTI page I posted does mention pragmatism as an "S" quality.  I guess I brought up the pragmatism in relation to his not wasting time on abstract theories just for the sake of thinking about abstract theories.   And I interpreted that bit from this statement on the site:  "I like to work with symbols or abstract theories, even if I don't know how I will use them."  My impression of Mycroft is that he's not going to waste time working on theories without some concrete idea of what it is for and how it can be applied, or how it is useful to him.   I guess I'm not following though what you see in Mycroft that makes you think he's an N?  Or is that what you are saying?  Looking at the list of N characteristics from MBTI:

 

The following statements generally apply to me:
  • I remember events by what I read "between the lines" about their meaning.  - I can't even begin to guess how he remembers things.
  • I solve problems by leaping between different ideas and possibilities.  - Again, based on nothing but my own impression b/c I'm not privy to his through processes, I assume Mycroft is methodical.  So really this one is all open to interpretation.
  • I am interested in doing things that are new and different. - I have no idea on this one.  Does he care one way or the other?
  • I like to see the big picture, then to find out the facts. - I can't imagine Mycroft ever putting big picture ahead of facts, but maybe he does?
  • I trust impressions, symbols, and metaphors more than what I actually experienced. - In my mind this is the most anti-Mycroft item of them all.  I can't imagine Mycroft going off anything other than cold, hard facts.
  • Sometimes I think so much about new possibilities that I never look at how to make them a reality. - To me this would go against the pragmatism that I assume Mycroft has.

I find it very difficult to decipher and defend any take on a character's personality without some insight into their mind.  We've had the most insight into Sherlock's mind of any of the characters, and even he would be difficult to categorize for me, I think.  Plus there is the whole spectrum thing.  Like I'm an N, yet I LOVE facts and I'm also very detail oriented.  For years I didn't understand how I could be those things and also an N, but I remember facts only in the context of the larger picture.  If I can't find where fact or detail fits into the larger picture, then I don't retain it.  I also have a very unmethodical method of thinking.  My brain jumps all over the place to the point that people have a hard time following me when I explain how I got from point A to point B.

 

Mycroft calls Sherlock's mind palace "ridiculous" in HLV... of course he's IN the mind palace when he says that, but that's Sherlock's perception of how Mycroft views it... which tells me that Mycroft doesn't use that technique for being able to store information.  The mind palace is a developed technique that works for Sherlock but something which Mycroft doesn't use because he has a different and "higher" ability that Sherlock wasn't born with.

 

I am going to throw it out there that perhaps Mycroft has the very rare gift of hyperthymesia, which is a superior autobiographical memory in which people can recall pretty much every day of their life in exacting detail.  If you combine this with a photographic memory, then Mycroft's ability to access information becomes fairly unfathomable.  He doesn't seem to struggle with his intellect or I.Q.

 

Since the mind palace is a learned/developed technique for storing information then it is a coping/compensation method for Sherlock to survive in a world where he share the same DNA as Mycroft.

  • Like 1
Posted

The three types most often attributed to Mycroft on the web are ISTJ, INTJ, INTP.

If Mycroft is an INTP, I hereby resign!

Which one? *whistle innocently*  :angel2:

 

On the off-chance that anyone still cares, I was referring to Mr. Gatiss's version.  I never stopped to think that the analyses you referred to probably focused more on canon Mycroft, whom I like fine, and think Charles Gray did a fine job of portraying in the Jeremy Brett series.

 

Posted

MBTI, DISC, The Big Five.... Arcadia had opened a can of worms! XD

You're welcome! That was, of course, my intention all along..... :P

 

Enjoyed the ensuing discussion. However.....

 

If Mycroft is an INTP, I hereby resign!

Me too!!!!!!

  • Like 2
Posted

 

The three types most often attributed to Mycroft on the web are ISTJ, INTJ, INTP.

If Mycroft is an INTP, I hereby resign!

Which one? *whistle innocently*  :angel2:

 

On the off-chance that anyone still cares, I was referring to Mr. Gatiss's version.  I never stopped to think that the analyses you referred to probably focused more on canon Mycroft, whom I like fine, and think Charles Gray did a fine job of portraying in the Jeremy Brett series.

 

 

 

 

MBTI, DISC, The Big Five.... Arcadia had opened a can of worms! XD

You're welcome! That was, of course, my intention all along..... :P

 

Enjoyed the ensuing discussion. However.....

 

If Mycroft is an INTP, I hereby resign!

Me too!!!!!!

 

 

 

No one going to resign since the general conclusion is, Mark Gatiss' Mycroft is as IxTJ as it come  :P

 

By the way, SherMol is widely favoured by many fanfic writers yet today I stumbled into MyMol fic; as expected, it is Defrost The The Ice Queen (although Mycroft is more like male version of The Iron Lady). Sooo.... which character according to you would make a fine match for His Brolliness and why?  :D

Posted

Oh, geez. :smile:

 

Uh ...... Mycroft and the Equerry!

Posted
which character according to you would make a fine match for His Brolliness and why?  :D

 

Eww, nobody, if you ask me. I can't imagine Mycroft in a relationship. The poor woman (or the poor man, whatever he prefers, I have absolutely no idea). The utmost I can picture is Mycroft hiring a professional once in a while to take care of his bodily needs, sort of in the same spirit as going to the hairdresser's.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Tsk tsk, Toby! XD If Sherlock can be in an asexual romance with a heterosexual male I don't know why Mycroft can't! I.e., if John is a fine match for Sherlock, surely someone out there must make a fine match for the Iceman. Another iceman, perhaps.

 

KIDDING! A bit. I can't see Mycroft as anything but hovering haughtily above the crowd either, but there must be a few up there with him......

Posted

 

which character according to you would make a fine match for His Brolliness and why?  :D

 

Eww, nobody, if you ask me. I can't imagine Mycroft in a relationship. The poor woman (or the poor man, whatever he prefers, I have absolutely no idea). The utmost I can picture is Mycroft hiring a professional once in a while to take care of his bodily needs, sort of in the same spirit as going to the hairdresser's.

 

 

 

 

Totally agree.  I halfway think the Diogenes Club has some sort of service one can use to take care of such things with a minimum of fuss and talking.  

 

Honestly, this is why I always scratch my head at Mystrade fan fiction.  I mean, whatever floats the authors' boats, of course, but I just can't picture a situation in which they would even meet and get to know one another, let alone form anything that someone would call a stable relationship.  It's Mycroft, for heaven's sake!

 

ETA:  I now can't get the picture of a to-do list on Mycroft's desk out of my mind:

 

To Do, December:

1.  Test bugs/cameras at Langley, White House, 10 Downing

2.  Schedule initial meeting for for Project Bond Air II (Don't tell Sherlock anything)

3.  Dental cleaning appointment

4.  Sex

5.  Have tires rotated on Range Rover

  • Like 1
Posted

Poor Mycroft, so far no one on his side, lol. Let's add one more option; what make you think that Mycroft is not romantic partner material? :D

Posted

Poor Mycroft, so far no one on his side, lol. Let's add one more option; what make you think that Mycroft is not romantic partner material? :D

 

OK, Shadow, I'll try to be serious.  (I'm not in a terribly serious mood today....)

 

I think Mycroft might be romantic partner material; in fact, I think in some ways he would be an ideal husband for the right man or woman.  Any vow he took he would take absolutely seriously; I think he would be relentlessly faithful; and I think he would have a certain quiet kindness.

 

I just don't think, from what I've seen, that Mycroft really sees things or feels things at that level.  The idea of divorcing himself from emotion seems to sit much more comfortably on Mycroft than it does on Sherlock.  I would have a hard time pointing to conclusive evidence, but my read on the Mycroft character is that he is interested in his work to the exclusion of all else, and that giving up romantic partnership or friends or other human interaction (Diogenes Club) isn't a hardship for him.  In some ways, I think his policy of being a loner is more of a justification of what he wants to do anyway rather than a discipline that he's embraced.  (Although, choosing MI5/6 as a career would intensify that natural inclination.)

 

I think Sherlock, in contrast, has embraced celebacy/avoidance of partnership because he philosophically thinks that such things distract him overmuch -- in other words, he's saying that he feels too much, and his feelings take over his intellect, which is what he actually values.  That's why I have trouble seeing Sherlock as asexual; I think he has the feelings but believes he should control them, and things like The Woman come along and trip him up in that quest.

  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 114 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.