Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Unfortunately, I think Ben's tried to train himself out of it.

SLAP. SLAP. SLAP

How dare you Ben, throwing away the beautiful gift you were born with.

 

Everyone who had been victims of my straying twiddling objects would agree.

  • Like 2
Posted

NOPE! He's trained himself not to fiddle with props, ergo twiddle them. On the other hand, he hasn't managed to get on with some more violin lessons, so he will be very rarely shown touching, much less playing that beautiful instrument. Pity, that!

Posted

I think Sherlock can handle emotions, he only doesn't know how / unused to respond the way society expect him to. Isn't such thing actually come with training? But if his 'mental energy' to deal with emotions, particularly other people's and negative ones, is not much compared with those who revel on such thing, if battered with too many of it he might snap and revert to his default mode out of self-preservation.

  • Like 2
Posted

Posted in the wrong thread somehow :S Don't think I can delete a post?

Posted

Posted in the wrong thread somehow :S Don't think I can delete a post?

No you can't delete a post -- but you can hide it, which serves the same purpose. Once you hide a post, it's visible only to staff members. You won't even be able to see it yourself.

Posted

Might as well leave it here now, but thanks - handy to know for next time! :D

  • Like 1
  • 4 months later...
Posted

Okay, now that we've seen season 4, what do we think? In what ways has Sherlock changed? In what ways is he the same? Do you like the changes? How have the events of S4 affected him? And pretty much any other reflection you have on his character. Have fun!

Posted

Great to see all these new threads!

 

There are some wonderful moments for Sherlock in season 4. For me the standouts are his scene with John in Baker Street near the end of TLD, His scene with 'Faith' (Eurus), His interaction with Mycroft during TFP, and the scene he has on the phone with Molly.

 

I had the suspicion in season 3 that Sherlock had come back a changed man, with a new appreciation for the people in his life, but season 4 is where you see it all pay dividends. There is an emotional generosity there in his patience and understanding with John, and a kindness there with Eurus, that show tremendous character growth. With Mycroft, I felt I was finally seeing the love that must have always been there between them. And the scene with Molly was brilliant partly because I wasn't quite sure what was going on between them, and I think I liked that part most of all.

 

One small thing I thought of whilst looking back, is that I would have liked a little more on his feelings about Mary's death. I think it was pretty devastating for him. It is understandable that we focus on John, of course, but I would have liked to hear Sherlock talk a little to someone else about it. His line to Mrs. Hudson about never letting him get too arrogant did say a lot though.

  • Like 4
Posted

That's right, we never really got his reaction to Mary's death, did we? What we got was his reaction to John's pain instead. Hmmm. Well, I don't believe his drug use was wholly in response to Mary's "miss me" disk -- I think it was also to dull the pain of her death. But that's just my "head canon", there's no evidence for it in the show.
 
I too thought he'd come back from the Fall a bit more mature, but the opening scenes of T6T made me wonder. But I guess now they just wanted to remind us of how he "used to be" (but I never saw him that way! :() so that we would notice more where he ends up.

Posted

I would rarely say it about the show, but I thought in the beginning of TST, he seemed out of character.

 

Then again, though his drug- phase might have only lasted a few months in his life, in our lifetimes it went on over three years (!!!), so I was definitely more than ready to finish with Sherlock being high. I also thought there would be more at the root of his extensive mobile phone use, but turned out he was just looking for signs of strange things going on.

 

I can see the drugs being partly a reaction to Mary's death. Though, to me that is at odds with the fact that seemed like he really wanted to be strong for John too (maybe it took the video hint from Mary to get him to that stage).

Posted

Before I respond to that ... can I just say how much I adored Sherlock in TLD? In spite of the idiocy of drug use (which I can almost forgive, given the reason he was doing it). Here he is in all his glory ...

tumblr_ojj8lsAbPW1ttko1so4_250.gif

He was smart, funny, kind, clever, eccentric, normal, extraordinary, sassy, gentle, abrupt, unpredictable, quixotic, and except for being a bit unkempt, looked damn fine. :wub:

 

Arcadia out.

  • Like 2
Posted

I would rarely say it about the show, but I thought in the beginning of TST, he seemed out of character.

Yep. And undignified, that's what bothered me. I suppose it was Moftiss poking fun at the pomp and circumstance of power, but it left a bad taste in my mouth. I also wondered if that "glad to be alive" was supposed to be their version of Sherlock "warbling like a lark", but if so, they didn't really pull it off, imo.

 

Then again, though his drug- phase might have only lasted a few months in his life, in our lifetimes it went on over three years (!!!), so I was definitely more than ready to finish with Sherlock being high. I also thought there would be more at the root of his extensive mobile phone use, but turned out he was just looking for signs of strange things going on.

Ah, I took him at his word that he stopped using as soon as he had a new "case" (the Moriarty gif) and only started again after Mary died.

 

I keep meaning to ask; how old does everyone think Rosie looks at the end of TFP? I thought around 12 months -- 18 at the most? Although I'm a lousy judge of age. Anyway, she was born shortly after the events of HLV, so I figure Season 4 took place in, and ended in, our past.

 

I can see the drugs being partly a reaction to Mary's death. Though, to me that is at odds with the fact that seemed like he really wanted to be strong for John too (maybe it took the video hint from Mary to get him to that stage).

You never know with Sherlock, because as John says, he always lies. :( But I attribute the drug use primarily to Mary's death, because I don't know of any other reason why he'd do it. He didn't do it for the Smith case, because he was already using before he knew anything about that.

Posted

 

He was smart, funny, kind, clever, eccentric, normal, extraordinary, sassy, gentle, abrupt, unpredictable, quixotic, and except for being a bit unkempt, looked damn fine. :wub:

 

That sort of scruffy look he had really worked for him, didn't it?

 

 

Then again, though his drug- phase might have only lasted a few months in his life, in our lifetimes it went on over three years (!!!), so I was definitely more than ready to finish with Sherlock being high. I also thought there would be more at the root of his extensive mobile phone use, but turned out he was just looking for signs of strange things going on.

Ah, I took him at his word that he stopped using as soon as he had a new "case" (the Moriarty gif) and only started again after Mary died.

 

I keep meaning to ask; how old does everyone think Rosie looks at the end of TFP? I thought around 12 months -- 18 at the most? Although I'm a lousy judge of age. Anyway, she was born shortly after the events of HLV, so I figure Season 4 took place in, and ended in, our past.

 

I can see the drugs being partly a reaction to Mary's death. Though, to me that is at odds with the fact that seemed like he really wanted to be strong for John too (maybe it took the video hint from Mary to get him to that stage).

You never know with Sherlock, because as John says, he always lies. :( But I attribute the drug use primarily to Mary's death, because I don't know of any other reason why he'd do it. He didn't do it for the Smith case, because he was already using before he knew anything about that.

 

 

I think that after season 4, I see his problem with drugs as partly an attempt to repressed the buried memories and emotions that would come surging up for him. It seems so obvious now that The Abominable Bride was there to show us how close his past was to bubbling back to the surface.

 

I would guess about 18 months at the end- as there is a time shift, isn't there, between the final rescue and the flat being put back together. Like you, no clue about ages from how she looks.

  • Like 1
Posted

I grew to like Sherlock more this season (which believe me, I didn't think was possible).  His kindness sprinkled in with his...Sherlockiness...was kind of...can I say sexy?  Cause I know that is not a very deep analysis but I don't care lol.  I mean, his voice when speaking in kind, soothing, tones is kind of off the charts.  :wub:

  • Like 3
Posted

That sort of scruffy look he had really worked for him, didn't it?

For me, it wasn't the scruffiness, it was the way he was filmed; long and lean and dark and exotic looking. The scene between Smith and John in the morgue, for example; Sherlock's lurking in the background with his collar up and his coat drawn close; he looks a bit like a bat. :smile: That, for me, is the iconic Sherlock.

 

Aha ... he's not wearing The Coat so much in the other episodes, is he? (Think think think.) No, he's not. That's it, isn't it? That's why he looks less like himself. Well, one reason. Also lighting ... TLD got it right, the others didn't. Sorry, but I still blame the directors; imo, it's their job to notice things like that well before the audience has a chance to. Ah well.

 

 

Posted

 

That sort of scruffy look he had really worked for him, didn't it?

For me, it wasn't the scruffiness, it was the way he was filmed long and lean and dark and exotic looking. The scene between Smith and John in the morgue, for example; Sherlock's lurking in the background with his collar up and his coat drawn close; he looks a bit like a bat. :smile: That, for me, is the iconic Sherlock.

 

Aha ... he's not wearing The Coat so much in the other episodes, is he? (Think think think.) No, he's not. That's it, isn't it? That's why he looks less like himself. Well, one reason. Also lighting ... TLD got it right, the others didn't. Sorry, but I still blame the directors; imo, it's their job to notice things like that well before the audience has a chance to. Ah well.

 

 

I need to watch TLD again soon. I thought there was something wonderfully deconstructed about his look in TLD. He was so broken-down looking that it was almost wrong, and yet still somehow fully himself. I wonder is part of the issue with his look that in the season we sort of see him taken apart and then put back together?

 

If we can ignore the unfortunate display at the start of TST, as  a throwback to TAB, then he's doing pretty well with Mary and John, (some of his look is off in TST, but he does look pretty put together around the christening) there is a downward spiral in TLD, but there is some part of it he seems to enjoy, (partly the drugs, of course), but he has this looseness and freedom, an unpredictability about him. The scene where he is talking to Faith/ Eurus, he is simply electric and in some ways the most connected I think we've seen him to the outer world. That level of kindness to a person he doesn't know- I knew he was capable, but we so rarely see him at his best in that sense. Then when he's back to playing games in TFP, he's like his old self- but a reconstructed old self, slightly different from the original, a little bit of that fire from TLD still there.

 

I do love the portrayal of the character in TLD, but I wonder would it be healthy for him to stay that way? Or is that the way his character is going, if we do get to meet him again onscreen?

  • Like 2
Posted

Excellent point, and I seem to remember Moftiss & Co. pointing that out too; that in S4 we get to see Sherlock taken apart and put back together again. I assumed they would mean emotionally, not physically, but both is good. :smile:

 

I doubt if we'll see him so scrungy looking again, unless he's in disguise for a case. But I would very much like it if they went back to that lean, exotic profile on display in TLD, instead of the more business-suited look he ended up with in TFP. I like that Sherlock has become more human, but I don't want him to be ordinary!

 

I think another factor is that in TLD we get to see him moving around more ... so much of the series was shot on stage or in tight spaces that we don't get to see as much of the wonderful physicality of Sherlock that we're used to. Not enough stalking about in a flouncing coat! Let's see some more jumping on the furniture! Maybe take the gun away from him though, he's a menace with that thing. Oh, wait, Mrs. H has already done that, hasn't she? :smile:

  • Like 1
Posted

My main quibble with TFP is definitely the need for it to mostly take place in confined spaces. I wonder was this partly related to keeping the Eurus storyline twist secret?

 

But yes, I love the sense of movement in TLD. Especially the walk scene, the gun and the Mrs. Hudson driving, and all the knocks on the door that Sherlock has already anticipated. There's just a glorious sense of it all being a madcap caper, despite the serious subtext at work with Mary's recent death.

 

It really is fabulous to see Mrs Hudson put Sherlock in his place, too. That is one of the show's extraordinary friendships, without a doubt, so rarely touched on, but so solid and true. I do find it strange that Mrs. Hudson seems closer to him than his own mother, though. Mrs. Holmes describing Sherlock as the 'adult' always throws me. It makes me think his family always expected more from him than he could deliver, somehow. Whereas, whenever Mrs. Huson makes an observation on Sherlock (it was her that called him 'emotional' I think?'), she gets it right on the money, with no muss, no fuss.

  • Like 2
Posted

Sherlock says his mother "understands very little," I'm beginning to think he's not wrong.

 

His Dad seems imminently sensible, though. But maybe he's not "observant"?

Posted

Yes, she seems capable of huge oversights, or else she's in denial!

 

The father does seem like the more sensible one,  (or at least the 'sane' one) but I wonder how much that says about him? As I remember it, the mother is the one that really has a go at Mycroft at the end, and Sherlock has implied before that Mycroft 'has a file' on his mother, whereas Sherlock only has a list. I suppose that means that Sherlock was kind of her favourite?

 

Posted

Or just that Sherlock was more forgiving of her foibles. :smile:

Posted

Just in reference to Sherlock and his parents... I was thinking about how he had said his mother understands very little- but when he says that he has no understanding himself that Eurus was a secret being kept from him (and in a sense by him, or part of his brain anyway).

 

I wonder if this affected how his parents treated him, and his impressions of them? They must have always considered him to have a slightly fragile mental state, on the verge of somehow remembering the Victor trauma. It might have meant they tried to shield him, or seemed obtuse when they were deliberately with-holding information that could trigger a memory for him.

 

It would take a bit more than a simple one-off blotting of that memory for Sherlock to have kept himself in the dark that long. A disappearance like that would be talked about in the area for years to come- and in the beginning surely Eurus' photographs and things- even her bedroom, would have still been in the house. It would have needed to be an almost wilful deletion, on a regular basis, to maintain the lack of awareness, for him. To support his delusion, the parents would have had to start hiding things. And they had to rope in Mycroft (the beginning of his career in a secret service?). The fact he stayed unaware is in such a contrast to how curious and dogged he usually is about small details that don't add up.

 

I don't think it is unbelievable, because the urge for self-preservation is so strong it could easily overcome his other traits if he was in so much pain- but it makes me reconsider the aspects of Sherlock that 'always misses something'- and deleted the solar system from his memory. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I asked this before in a different thread, but having just come home and caught the last few minutes of TFP again ... I realized I'm still not sure what to make of this dialog ...

SHERLOCK (quietly, thoughtfully): I said I’d bring her home. I can’t, can I?
JOHN: Well, you gave her what she was looking for: context.
SHERLOCK (looking round at him): Is that good?
JOHN: It’s not good, it’s not bad. It’s ...
(He looks away and screws up his face, searching for the right words, then turns back to his friend.)
JOHN: It is what it is.

 

What is the context he gave her? Thoughts?

Posted

I asked this before in a different thread, but having just come home and caught the last few minutes of TFP again ... I realized I'm still not sure what to make of this dialog ...

 

SHERLOCK (quietly, thoughtfully): I said I’d bring her home. I can’t, can I?

JOHN: Well, you gave her what she was looking for: context.

SHERLOCK (looking round at him): Is that good?

JOHN: It’s not good, it’s not bad. It’s ...

(He looks away and screws up his face, searching for the right words, then turns back to his friend.)

JOHN: It is what it is.

 

What is the context he gave her? Thoughts?

 

Probably understanding Euros' metaphor of being on a plane high up in the sky and then helping her to land. 

Posted

But how did he help her do that? What did she understand after he found her in her room that she didn't understand before?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.