Jump to content

What did you think of "The Six Thatchers"?  

93 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Awful.


Recommended Posts

Posted

Maybe they wanted us to think it had something to do with Magnussen?  As though one villain reaching out with his cold dead fingers from beyond the grave wasn't enough?

 

It's probably something really mundane, though, like their location-selection team visited the London Aquarium and thought wow, this would make a great place for a dramatic scene.

  • Like 2
Posted

There are oodles of cool, and more unique, places around London. I'm guessing part of the reason they chose the aquarium was it's proximity to Vauxhall Cross. 

 

They should have gone for somewhere like Highgate Cemetery, or Saint Pauls, or hell, a pod on the Eye. Somewhere uniquely London. There are aquariums everywhere.

 

A pod could have been really cool actually; John, Mycroft and Lestrade stuck on the ground watching Norbury, Sherlock and Mary in a pod. They watch things escalate, see Mary get shot, but can't help until the pod comes to the ground. Imagine John, army doctor, unable to get to and save his dying wife. 

  • Like 2
Posted

Maybe they had a deal with the Aquarium. Because they knew fans would come to see the location. What a pity the next con isn't in London. :P

 

  • Like 2
Posted

I guess they needed the aquarium for the shark theme. Doesn't make that much sense to me though because the shark was Magnussen and he is dead and not important for series 4. Then there's the "deep water" motto for this season. That might be another reason why this particular setting was chosen.

  • Like 1
Posted

It's probably something really mundane, though, like their location-selection team visited the London Aquarium and thought wow, this would make a great place for a dramatic scene.

Didn't Gatiss say as much? Maybe I'm thinking of a different location, I know that's why they chose the fake houses where Sherlock met Mary in HLV; because Gatiss thought they were cool and was determined to get them into a story.

 

I don't think of an aquarium as deep water, so that idea doesn't work for me. Although now I wonder ... what does everyone else think is the symbolism of "deep water?" I'm afraid all I think of is drowning, but does it have other significance?

Posted

Isn't drowning the whole point though?

Posted

I don't know, you tell me! :D

 

Deep waters, all his life ... so Sherlock's been drowning all his life?

Posted

Does it say in Eurus' poem that Victor drowned? I can't remember. I don't even like the water imagery so *shrug*.

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

No, it seems so random to me. It doesn't evoke either the aquarium or the pool, it's just ... murky. Don't get it.

Posted

I think what Eurus meant was that the image / theme of deep water was what remained in Sherlock's conscious memory of the incident with Victor. On the show, it comes to symbolize Sherlock's hidden trauma and his greatest fears. I like how even meeting Moriarty at the pool in series 1 fits in here even though they probably didn't come up with the idea until later.

  • Like 3
Posted

The padded cell doesn't have any water theme (and it actually should) but it you stretch it a bit, you can say it looks like a bottom of a well…
…oh!…
thk.gif
and there is a chained person in it!

  • Like 3
Posted

I think what Eurus meant was that the image / theme of deep water was what remained in Sherlock's conscious memory of the incident with Victor. On the show, it comes to symbolize Sherlock's hidden trauma and his greatest fears. I like how even meeting Moriarty at the pool in series 1 fits in here even though they probably didn't come up with the idea until later.

 

Thanks, Toby, that's actually the answer I was looking for. I wish I had your ability to burrow into the heart of the matter! :Worship: I get stuck on all the surface glitz.

 

Interesting that Eurus is so insightful as well. My schedule's finally easing up, I find I'm getting into the mood for a rewatch finally, see if I can get any closer to an understanding of what they were trying to do with her character.

 

Posted

The padded cell doesn't have any water theme (and it actually should) but it you stretch it a bit, you can say it looks like a bottom of a well…

…oh!…

thk.gif

and there is a chained person in it!

 

Yowieee. And when they filmed that, they knew what they were going to do to Victor, right? Right? Oooooo....... No no no, let's not get our hopes up too high, it's probably all coincidence...... :unsure: (Dang you, Moftiss!)

  • Like 1
Posted

Does it matter? I don't think I am particularly insightful at all, I just like to make sense of things, whether that was intended by the creators or not. All I ask is that they give me a solid base for an interpretation that suits me and I think they did.

  • Like 1
Posted

Yowieee. And when they filmed that, they knew what they were going to do to Victor, right? Right? Oooooo....... No no no, let's not get our hopes up too high, it's probably all coincidence...... :unsure: (Dang you, Moftiss!)

But does it make any sense, beside being a visual analogy?

If it is a coincidence, it is one of several, and I find it fascinating how this kind of stuff continues throughout the show. We have Billy the Skull, we have the dog statuette looking a bit like Redbeard, we have the photo of a Cenote which is nothing else as a natural well, then… there is a reptile on the mantelpiece in S4. All of them having nothing to do with the canon.

In my headcanon I imagine the makers being inspired by the stuff lying around at 221b set, and they don't even know it. (been there done that myself)

On the other hand we have the magpie/Jim motif that apparently leads to nowhere.

 

It's no wonder we are all nuts.

  • Like 1
Posted

Does it matter? I don't think I am particularly insightful at all, I just like to make sense of things, whether that was intended by the creators or not. All I ask is that they give me a solid base for an interpretation that suits me and I think they did.

 

I think making sense of things is a very useful skill! :d

 

 

Yowieee. And when they filmed that, they knew what they were going to do to Victor, right? Right? Oooooo....... No no no, let's not get our hopes up too high, it's probably all coincidence...... :unsure: (Dang you, Moftiss!)

But does it make any sense, beside being a visual analogy?

If it is a coincidence, it is one of several, and I find it fascinating how this kind of stuff continues throughout the show. We have Billy the Skull, we have the dog statuette looking a bit like Redbeard, we have the photo of a Cenote which is nothing else as a natural well, then… there is a reptile on the mantelpiece in S4. All of them having nothing to do with the canon.

In my headcanon I imagine the makers being inspired by the stuff lying around at 221b set, and they don't even know it. (been there done that myself)

On the other hand we have the magpie/Jim motif that apparently leads to nowhere.

 

It's no wonder we are all nuts.

 

 

It makes sense to me. Of course it's a visual analogy, but I always wondered; why Moriarty, which didn't make sense to me. Sherlock was dying; why was Jim the one who reminded him that John was in danger? That always bothered me, you'd think Moriarty would only be representing the impulse to give up and die, not also giving Sherlock the one reason he needed to keep on living.

 

But if the whole setup is a form of suppressed memory of the drowned Victor, it makes more sense. Sherlock's at his lowest point, he's ready to give up (and that's Jim talking); but some buried memory reminds him what happens when you fail to save a friend, and he struggles to stay alive.

 

Works for me!

 

Of course, the irony is, John wasn't in danger, not that time, but that's a different issue...

 

Oh! But it does help explain why Sherlock was so panicked when he thought John was about to burn up in the bonfire. I.e., when he thought he was about to lose his friend. Not that he needed another reason, it's just a nice tie in.

 

In fact, it sort of explains why Sherlock seemed so eager to have a friend in the first place, except that I don't believe they ever had the Victor scenario in mind when they wrote S1. But it's still a nice connection. I can fantasize that something about John reminded him of Victor. In fact, didn't someone mentioned that Victor looked like a younger version of John, or something? I didn't notice a resemblance myself, but it would be cool if it exists ... and is intentional. If, brother. If. :smile:

Posted

I know we only see a flash of Victor but I really can't see John reminding Sherlock of an exuberant five year old. I think the fact they became friends is simply because John was fascinated by Sherlock's deductions rather than decking him or running a mile... which in turn fascinated Sherlock.

 

For reminders there's a few of this type of thing floating around, though I don't buy it as any more than coincidence.

 

af5b237349aee9f6f3bcdab618ce341f.jpg

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh! But it does help explain why Sherlock was so panicked when he thought John was about to burn up in the bonfire....

 

Do we actually have a good start on the classical elements -- Earth, Air, Fire, and Water?

 

We've got water, God knows we've got water coming out our ears by now.  And the bonfire  When air moves then it's wind, and we have the East Wind (possibly a bit more than we'd like).  How about Earth?

Posted

Isn't a well kind of Earth and Water?

Posted

Folks, folks, that's proof there will be a season 5! So John can be buried alive!!!!! Woo hoo! (Did someone mention we are all nuts?)

  • Like 3
Posted

I'm so bitter about John I'd leave him there. 

  • Like 1
Posted

It makes sense to me. Of course it's a visual analogy, but I always wondered; why Moriarty, which didn't make sense to me. Sherlock was dying; why was Jim the one who reminded him that John was in danger? That always bothered me, you'd think Moriarty would only be representing the impulse to give up and die, not also giving Sherlock the one reason he needed to keep on living.

BUT…

Sherlock didn't know Victor drowned in a well. Nobody knew.

 

Nuts? We? Which kind?

Posted

I'm so bitter about John I'd leave him there.

 

nyIMUcf.gif

 

 

It makes sense to me. Of course it's a visual analogy, but I always wondered; why Moriarty, which didn't make sense to me. Sherlock was dying; why was Jim the one who reminded him that John was in danger? That always bothered me, you'd think Moriarty would only be representing the impulse to give up and die, not also giving Sherlock the one reason he needed to keep on living.

BUT…

Sherlock didn't know Victor drowned in a well. Nobody knew.

 

Nuts? We? Which kind?

 

Yeah, they did. Remember how Mycroft said Eurus started referring to him as "drowned Redbeard"? Okay, maybe they didn't know it was in a well. At this point, I'll consider that a minor oversight. :P

  • Like 1
Posted

If they knew it was a well, they'd probably find him, at least the body.

Why they didn't looked into the well, is another… thing.

 

As for John resembling Victor - there is a BTS photo of Martin and Victor actor, and they look like before and after pics in one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 96 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.