Jump to content

What did you think of "The Six Thatchers"?  

93 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Awful.


Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm only up to page 4, so my apologies if any of this has already been covered.
 

Early on, when they introduced that new female police officer coming to Sherlock for help- that bothered me because I thought instantly, why are they upping the female quota on the cast, to me it already suggested they were getting rid of another actress and wanted a bit more balance in future.


I read -- somewhere -- that they intended to have Sally Donovan back for that scene, but Vinette Robinson was not available, so they (thanks to whoever pointed this out) used the name of a canon police officer for another actress.  As to why they would decide to bring Sally back at precisely this point, though, you may be right.

 

* * * * *

 

Several people have mentioned Sherlock's inability to recognize/remember Margaret Thatcher, after having exhibited basic knowledge of her in Hounds.  In this episode, John seems to think that Sherlock is just being difficult, and I find it prudent to agree.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

What I don't understand is why the hell they brought the word "amo" into TST.

Just to make us dance around the ILU scene?

 

Yeah, probably. -_-

 

Then they could do us a favor and at least write some kind of connection.

Moftiiis.gif

 

 

 

I have to say that perhaps in time this episode will grow on me more, but from the start I felt it was off-putting.  From Sherlock's weird behavior in the private cabinet meeting to Mary's jump in front of the bullet, I was wincing a bit.  Mind you, I was thinking they were going to off Mary, but once the gun is fired, the bullet would have been in Sherlock a split second later.  No way could she have moved that fast.  I didn't buy that particular way of offing her character.  

 

I think there are some interesting bits in the episode, and certainly if he could have found that pearl on top of everything else, that would have been nice. 

 

Something about the episode, however, didn't quite fit with the episodes that had come before.  And I still don't get that thing about him furiously texting.  That little bit never went anywhere.

 

The "amo" thing and the texting ... I really thought those were either going to turn out to be red herrings, or have some significance in the later episodes. But they were neither ... just pointless detail, imo. I do think "amo" was meant to be a red herring, but they muffed it if it was.

 

That's the main thing I notice about T6T, sfmpco ... it doesn't fit, it feels like it's from a different TV show. And it drives me freakin' nutz. :wacko: I think I could accept some of the silliness more if the dang thing didn't just LOOK so wrong .... ak!!!!!!!!

 

 

I sort of felt like none of S4 fit, but there were some nice moments in each episode with TLD having the bulk of the good moments.

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm only up to page 4, so my apologies if any of this has already been covered.

 

Early on, when they introduced that new female police officer coming to Sherlock for help- that bothered me because I thought instantly, why are they upping the female quota on the cast, to me it already suggested they were getting rid of another actress and wanted a bit more balance in future.

I read -- somewhere -- that they intended to have Sally Donovan back for that scene, but Vinette Robinson was not available, so they (thanks to whoever pointed this out) used the name of a canon police officer for another actress.  As to why they would decide to bring Sally back at precisely this point, though, you may be right.

 

As it is, it made no sense to have the new cop there, since they never went anywhere with it. If it had been Sally at least we would have had the pleasure (?) of knowing that 1) she's been promoted and 2) she now believes in Sherlock too and 3) he still treats her like dirt. :p Plus the subtext in that dialog would have been funnier if it had been Sally; as it is, to me it almost feels as if Gatiss is mocking the shippers. No, not almost. It does feel that way to me.

  • Like 1
Posted

Was there some sort of hint that Lestrade could have had a romantic entanglement with her? If so, it was very poorly fleshed out, and perhaps better cut. 

 

Speaking of Rupert Graves, I watched the Forsyte Saga (2002) this weekend, a bit melodramatic but he is so good in it!

  • Like 1
Posted

They were hinting at a romance with Lestrade and someone, but we never got a hint who and it never came up again ... so why bring it up the first time? I thought that was cheesy too. :( Boy, T6T can sure make me grumpy....

  • Like 1
Posted

If I remember right, it was very slap dash, some one liner from Sherlock about how his next date wasn't the one. Very much a feel of 'Sherlock mocks Lestrade's love life, box ticked, moving on.'

  • Like 3
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Well, if anyone of you ever watched Mr Gatiss's The Crooked House, you would understand why his attempts at writing drama don't come out as intended.

Posted

The 'amo" wasn't a red herring as it clearly went back to the code name LOVE of one of the people involved with the Tblisi incident, although that person, Lady Smallwood, was nearly framed for what her secretary actually did.

Agreed. For some reason, I thought the "amo" bit was rather clever. And love has always been a dangerous thing to meddle with in Sherlock's world, quite fitting that this should be the code word in the betrayal of AGRA.

 

I really like the first half of The Six Thatchers. Unlike many of you, I enjoy the scene where Sherlock behaves like a teenager in front of Mycroft's illustrious colleagues; it appeals to a secret side of my own character that I have hardly ever allowed to play out even when I was a teen and that I indulge vicariously through fictional characters.

 

I love that they finally did the Toby scene from canon and how they did it (also: great casting, the dog is perfect). I love Mary as a mother and I get a kick out of the contrast between her "civilian" behavior and her background.

 

The case seems interesting enough at first - and nice touch that they mentioned the pearl from the original but then went in a different direction.

 

I even like the fight at the pool. Original Holmes had his moments of being an action hero and won physical fights as well as mental ones occasionally so I didn't think it out of character and it was, for me, fun to watch.

 

But after that... I just feel like everything went downhill. I am glad they did Mary's backstory but I feel it could have been so much better and I would have preferred something at least remotely canon-related (why oh why did they pass over the chance to do a version of The Valley of Fear?).

 

I didn't think AJ was a particularly compelling character. And I wish they had dared to go to a darker place with Mary herself; they made her too good, imo. She had plenty of sinister potential that I wish they had tapped into, it would have made her character more interesting. I think they tried too hard to make her a saint.

 

I have complained enough about her death scene. It's just... Bad. Sorry.

 

I didn't notice anything different than usual about the cinematography but then I just don't have an eye for that kind of thing, I guess.

  • Like 3
Posted

I don't think it's as bad as most people seem to, I enjoyed it when I watched it, and probably still will next time. Yes, it has plenty of flaws, but honestly I have more of a problem with the other two episodes than this one. TLD would be the best if I didn't hate John in it so much. The part that grates the most now is not the beating (though I still hate it with a passion) but that scene at the end - the lecture over accepting love (or Irene), and the 'are you okay?' followed by yet more angry John. The old Sherlock would never have asked if John was okay, this one does and gets a nasty, angry response anyway. That would have been hard for Sherlock to ask, but he wanted to say something to show he cared - yes, it's not the most sensitive question, but John knows he's socially awkward and to still respond that nastily, I just...  :blowmytop: 

It's the type of thing I could see myself doing, wanting to show concern, struggling to choke out a fairly generic question and then feeling like sh*t when I get slapped down with that kind of response. If John's answer was delivered differently, a little softer then okay, it's not even what he says it's the way he says it, his body language, like he's about to thump Sherlock again for daring to ask. TLD has ruined John for me. It's like he's had a personality transplant, and it's not just grief, he's unpleasant all around, especially since he is then the trusty best bud again in TFP.  

 

Agreed, they should have had the guts to make Mary darker. They started to go that direction last season, and it's like they chickened out and veered off. Mary couldn't think John would be all that bothered by her being a merc if all she did was save people in hostage situations. That implies there was darker stuff on that memory stick that convinced her that seeing it meant he wouldn't love her any more. I wonder if the accusations of misogyny made them change their minds from making her evil/morally dubious and they thought making her more of a good guy would prove they could write women well. Except they went too far in the opposite direction and, as you said, made her almost saintly. 

 

The other thing that bugs me is her being so determined to tag along with John and Sherlock. From the case clips we see in TSoT she is happy for them to go off and do their own thing, and she goes off and does hers. We assume she has a life and friends outside of her interactions with her husband's best mate, but now suddenly she doesn't? Is she now solely reduced to a life as John's wife and Rosie's mother, rather than as a woman with her own interests? I don't like her, was against the inclusion of her from the start, but I was willing to give her a chance if she was interesting and likeable. Sadly I don't think she was. 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I was thinking they were going to off Mary, but once the gun is fired, the bullet would have been in Sherlock a split second later.  No way could she have moved that fast.

 

I took that as a bit of dramatic license.  In "real life," Mary must have seen Vivian start to aim and immediately jumped.

 

Yepp. Sally would make much more sense in the scene.

 

I would guess that they were still trying to get her till it was too late to rewrite the scenes (especially if BC had already filmed Sherlock's end of the Skype conversation).  Too bad, it would've been nice to have her back, if only briefly.

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

Working my way back into this thread a little, now that I finally have some free time for it. 
 

Oh, yes, this really bothered me:
How comes that Sherlock, after decucting the „Maggie“ password in HOB suddenly doesn‘t know who she is. Has he deleted it?

 
Maybe it's been said at another time, but I thought they made it pretty clear that Sherlock was pretending not to know who Thatcher was in order to buy himself some more time to look at and think about the missing statue. John even says something like "For God's sake, you know who she is, why are you stalling for time?"
 

Speaking of sense. Mary's death scene. Factually, it's a disaster. Sherlock talks to the woman pointing the gun at him for ever and neither his brother nor Lestrade nor any of the police force they brought with him do a thing to defuse the situation. Super assassin Mary can't think of anything better to do than throw herself into the bullet (after she also had the chance to act much sooner and more wisely). Nobody tries any kind of first aid once she's been shot. And so on and so forth...


I thought maybe they all kind of fell into the hole that John did in HLV; they all believe so strongly in Sherlock and his ability to control a situation that it didn't occur to them to question or interfere. Only Mary ... "the professional" ... realized where his goading of Norbury was leading.
 
Another thought is that any move on their part to stop Norbury might have led her to pull the trigger even quicker. Maybe their best move was, in fact, to try and let Sherlock talk her down? Except, of course, that's not what he ended up doing.
 
To me, the problem with that scene is the staging of it ... it lacked visual interest and imagination. The "sacrificial death" plot is as old as mankind itself, and can be used effectively ... but they way they did it in T6T... urgh.

Posted

I'm still browsing through earlier parts of this thread to see what I missed in the heat of the moment.

 

Oh, btw, I felt a visceral kind of pleasure in seeing Sherlock fight. The original Holmes did fight on occasion and he enjoyed it, too. He wasn't all brain - that's Mycroft. Sherlock Holmes did "leg work" as well as brain work and he had more than one violent encounter with a criminal. During that pool scene, I found myself excitedly grabbing my blanket and yelling: "yeah, go, Sherlock!" :lol:

 

Yeh, that's something I wouldn't have minded seeing a little more of in the series. Just a LITTLE more, though! Is that why they pool fight went on so long, they were making up for all the times they didn't have Sherlock in action? :smile:

 

 

Another question ... why all the visual allusions to water? There's water effects in scene transitions, in reflections, in the sky at the end, and of course in the big dramatic climax, probably other places ... if this was Dr. Strange I'd say we're being pointed to his sister's drowning. But it isn't.

 

I thought it was strange to have all the shark references so soon after Magnussen, too. We're bound to make a connection, yet there doesn't seem to be any. Odd.

 

Rapid deduction:

Karl Powers > the pool scene in TGG > CAM as shark > the pool fight > the shark tanks at the Aquarium > flashback of Sherlock, Redbeard and someone at the seaside >

John in a well > the island and the boat from setlock.

 

 

There is A LOT of water.

 

PIRATE…

 

What if someone‘s DROWNING is Sherlock’s childhood trauma?

Sherrinford is in a nursing house because of a brain damage after he almost drown?

 

 

Oh, JP, you were sooooo close!!!!!! :applause:

 

Would have been nice, though, if they had carried over that motif into the other episodes in some way, just to confirm it was deliberate. If it was.

Posted

Wasn't the original Holmes a boxer? I wouldn't have said no to seeing Sherlock with a boxing bag. Mmm. Sweating a bit maybe. Out of those suits. Mmm. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I do wonder how he stays so fit just lounging around Baker Street all day. :smile:

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I would say good genes, but then... Mycroft. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh, was it me? I must have deleted… thblush.gif
I found the sharks rather distracting, as I expected some aftermath of CAM, but this time they led us somewhere else.

And I remember fight scenes from the RDJ film, and then that canon Holmes was an adept of a Far East martial arts… Baritsu?

Posted

Using sharks as both a representation of CAM, and then unrelated here was very shoddy. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I think the whole water/sharks thing was basically just foreshadowing the scene in the aquarium.

  • Like 1
Posted

I agree. But since they have already used the shark analogy for CAM it gets a bit muddled. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Piranhas! Perfect! They should hire you next time, JP.
 
Right now I'm sort of imagining Moftiss being like me when someone approaches me about a painting I did five years ago. "Oh, you're the one who did that painting of the train!" "Oh, um, hi. Which one? I've done several paintings of trains." "You know, the one where you put that blue speck on the third left wheel. I loved that! What made you decide to put that there?" *mumbling to myself: Blue speck? I don't remember painting a train with a blue speck! I put blue specks in everything! That's what she noticed? What the hell?*  Out loud: "Oh, well, you know, it just seemed to fit." "I see your new painting has a blue speck in it too. Does it mean something?"

 

Me: a12sreq.gif

  • Like 1
Posted

Why not set the aquarium scene elsewhere and not have it sea related at all? I know they are trying to have the 'deep water' theme going but since it doesn't really come up in TLD there's no need for it in T6T either. 

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 96 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.