Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Lying Detective"?  

70 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Awful.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

I can see where you're coming from with the Web MD definition, but they do admit a lot of the traits are similar. It seems like different psychologists have different interpretations of what the differences are.

 

Sorry, I think you have the wrong quote, the one I mentioned is from this interview (transcribed from radio)

 

 

Interviewer: And this Sherlock we see in the 21st century is kind of a sociopath, maybe even psychopath on that scale, which, I guess, the 21st century allows you to fully realize? 

Steven Moffatt: You know, I don't think he is. I think that's what people would be inclined in the 21st century to call him. 

I: Ah, hah. That diagnosis problem... 
 

SM: Yes, we all. And people have done it ever since Doyle created this character. Everyone wants to diagnose Sherlock Holmes. And that's our running joke, none of it is true. He's not autistic, he's not a psychopath, he's not a sociopath. He's none of those things. He's a man who chooses to be the way he is, because he thinks it makes him better. It's a monastic decision. He takes himself out of touch with his sexuality, and out of touch with any of his emotions in order to make himself better. And that's just a frightening idea that somebody could do that. otions, in order to make himself better," Moffat said. "And the reason he's apologetic and shameless is he’s happy in his own skin. He's actually having quite a good time.”

 

 

So I do agree you have found a totally different quote where he said he'd like to be one.I don't dispute he might think he'd like to be one, but a true sociopath would never feel that way- so it actually proves the opposite to your point earlier that he is a sociopath that somehow gets cured in TFP:

 


 


 

BLS_Pro, on 05 Feb 2017 - 04:56 AM, said

 

I don't believe Sherlock was ever a sociopath

This appears to be the fundamental disagreement at the root of our discussion.  And I can only say the writers themselves state Sherlock is a sociopath.  He is a "bad man".  And his journey is that of becoming good, which they claim he has done by TFP.  In other words, by the end of TFP, Sherlock is no longer a sociopath.

 

 

 

 

And in your own quote also, you can see Moffat is actually saying he's not a sociopath. It's really just a running joke to them, as he says in my quote, and it isn't true. To hope to be something and to be it are two totally different things. If you'd said he no longer aspires to have sociopathic qualities, that would have been a bit closer to the truth, probably. 

 

It is also reductive to say his desire to be sociopathic is just for ego driven reasons.

 

An extremely sensitive person might wish to be like a sociopath, just because then they would not feel so much pain, and that wouldn't be about ego at all. In my opinion, there is a little bit of that in Sherlock's reasoning, too.

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh please, Moffat is an artist not a psychiatrist. He didn't bother looking through a medical dictionary to see if 'psychopath' or 'sociopath' was the right word to describe the Sherlock. He chose 'sociopath' most likely because it wasn't used as much as 'psychopath' in everyday speech so it would be fun to make a joke out of how people call Sherlock a 'psychopath' and have Sherlock (who's always a smart aleck) rebut by claiming he's a 'high-functioning sociopath'.

 

Sometimes I think fans look more into an artist's work then even the artists do themselves. I think that fans really need to consider if the artist's themselves got into the technicalities of a certain detail before they try to use it to interpret a text.

 

As for Sherlock being a 'good man', I just saw that as a feeble attempt by Moffatiss to tie up all the lose ends in Sherlock.

 

Honestly I don't see how Sherlock wasn't a good man ever since The Reichenbach Fall. By then he was already playing the hero. He was even portrayed as a good man who was saving people who were kidnapped etc. Moriarty's entire plan was about destroying Sherlock's good reputation. In The Empty Hearse, John even commented on how Sherlock loved being the hero. 

 

Sherlock was a good man long before Season 4 even started. That's why Lestrade's line at the end of Season 4 just felt like a ploy to make The Final Problem a better written episode then it really was.

  • Like 4
Posted

Oh please, Moffat is an artist not a psychiatrist. He didn't bother looking through a medical dictionary to see if 'psychopath' or 'sociopath' was the right word to describe the Sherlock. He chose 'sociopath' most likely because it wasn't used as much as 'psychopath' in everyday speech so it would be fun to make a joke out of how people call Sherlock a 'psychopath' and have Sherlock (who's always a smart aleck) rebut by claiming he's a 'high-functioning sociopath'.

 

Sometimes I think fans look more into an artist's work then even the artists do themselves. I think that fans really need to consider if the artist's themselves got into the technicalities of a certain detail before they try to use it to interpret a text.

 

As for Sherlock being a 'good man', I just saw that as a feeble attempt by Moffatiss to tie up all the lose ends in Sherlock.

 

Honestly I don't see how Sherlock wasn't a good man ever since The Reichenbach Fall. By then he was already playing the hero. He was even portrayed as a good man who was saving people who were kidnapped etc. Moriarty's entire plan was about destroying Sherlock's good reputation. In The Empty Hearse, John even commented on how Sherlock loved being the hero. 

 

Sherlock was a good man long before Season 4 even started. That's why Lestrade's line at the end of Season 4 just felt like a ploy to make The Final Problem a better written episode then it really was.

 

I do suspect Moftiss of not doing much research into the area- but then why should they, when they don't have to prove that sherlock meant what he was saying? Also, they can vary a lot from one interview to another.

 

And what you say next is the sort of thing I was trying to get at earlier, there were many instances of Sherlock trying to be a better man from early on. 

  • Like 1
Posted
I do agree you have found a totally different quote where he said he'd like to be one.I don't dispute he might think he'd like to be one

I am glad you now agree that Moffat does say this about Sherlock.  That sociopath is the "standard" to which Sherlock "aspires".  That it is his philosophy to intentionally limit his empathy - for ego-driven reasons (so he can supposedly be "better" at being "clever").

 

Again, what Moffat says makes my case.

 

your point earlier that he is a sociopath that somehow gets cured in TFP

That was neither my point, nor my terminology.  I have stated many times that Sherlock's behavior is not deterministic.  He chooses his behavior.  He is not 'sick', mentally or otherwise.  Nor does he get "cured" of any supposed sickness in TFP.

 

Sherlock is a "monster" because of his moral choices - the choice of ego (himself) as his standard, rather than empathy (others) as his standard.  Again, as Moffat states, Sherlock is a "bad man".  And the show is his journey to becoming a "good man".

 

That is the opposite of being "cured" of a mental illness.  That is a man learning and practicing moral truths.  It is a moral journey, not a medical 'cure'.

 

 

It is also reductive to say his desire to be sociopathic is just for ego driven reasons.

Putting aside your addition of the term "just" again, no it is not reductive.  It is the central theme and conflict of the entire series: Ego vs Empathy.   

 

To reference your example, that Sherlock doesn't want to feel pain and so rejects empathy as his standard: that is Sherlock acting profoundly selfishly.  It is him choosing ego (himself), not empathy (others), as his standard.  Empathy is being selfless.  As John says, and Sherlock agrees, it is being a 'soldier' and saying 'it's not about us'.  It's not about our pain and whether we want it or not.  It's about the other person and what they need.  That is choosing empathy (others), rather than ego (self), as one's standard.

 

 

Posted

 

 

It is also reductive to say his desire to be sociopathic is just for ego driven reasons.

No it is not.  It is the central theme and conflict of the entire series: Ego vs Empathy.   

 

That he doesn't want to feel pain is Sherlock acting selfishly.  It is him choosing ego (himself), not empathy (others), as his standard.  Empathy is being selfless.  As John says, and Sherlock agrees, it is being a 'soldier' and saying 'it's not about us'.  It's not about our pain and whether we want it or not.  It's about the other person and what they need.  That is choosing empathy (others), rather than ego (self), as his standard.

 

 

Have the writers declared that their central theme? 

 

And to do something because of you ego is to act for reasons relating to your self-esteem and self importance. What I'm talking about is that he was acting for  other emotional reasons, because the pain of some of his memories proved too much, and he didn't want to experience that level of pain again. It's like not touching a flame again once you've been burned. I don't consider that selfish, any more than it is selfish to avoid crossing the street when you see an oncoming truck.

Posted
I don't consider that selfish, any more than it is selfish to avoid crossing the street when you see an oncoming truck.

That is the definition of selfish.  You are avoiding these things to save yourself.  You.  You are the standard, not others.  You are choosing your actions in order to achieve your goals, not someone else's goals.

 

Lacking agreement on such a basic concept, I think we're done.

Posted

Oh, and are we supposed to consider his look towards Dr Watson to get his assent before setting his sights on the bomb-vest in TGG, his frantic search to find said doctor and Sarah through deciphering the code in TBB, his despair and frantic search for an alternate solution in TRF, his altruism in preparing the whole wedding (waste of an episode) in SoT, his iron determination to bring the Watson's together even at the expense of his own life and liberty in HLV, not to mention TLD, as selfish?

How many more times does this version of Sherlock Holmes need to lay down his life and his reputation in the cause of Dr Watson's happiness in order to be considered simply eccentric?

Anyway, that wasn't my original point, but your cyclical argument brought about a knee-jerk reaction.

A while ago, I asked why Mrs Hudson does NOT consider herself a civilian: and the proof is Mycroft talking from the Cabinet Office (I just love thinking of him as Sir Humphrey Appleby, rather than Bond's M)

to the hapless policeman after the car chase. So Mycroft has been monitoring Sherlock's descent into hell, but how does Mrs Hudson fit in?

  • Like 4
Posted

... So Mycroft has been monitoring Sherlock's descent into hell, but how does Mrs Hudson fit in?

 

If she's been working for Mycroft, it would explain how she can afford to have such a hap-hazard approach to being a landlady.

 

But, personally I'm not sure I'd have the gall to call my boss a reptile to his face and throw him out.

  • Like 1
Posted

knee-jerk reaction.

Knee jerk indeed, since it was explicitly identified that there is a conflict between ego and empathy inside Sherlock - ie between selfishness and selflessness.  He is both (though one is by far more predominant - which is why he is not a "good man" through most of the series. 

 

In other words, it was never claimed - and in fact explicitly identified otherwise - that Sherlock is not "just" driven by ego, not "just" consuming people, not "just" etc etc ad nauseum. 

 

So why the "knee jerk" attacks on straw men?  Or is the definition of "knee jerk" the answer to that question?

 

Posted

It is also reductive to say his desire to be sociopathic is just for ego driven reasons.

 

An extremely sensitive person might wish to be like a sociopath, just because then they would not feel so much pain, and that wouldn't be about ego at all. In my opinion, there is a little bit of that in Sherlock's reasoning, too.

*Rises hand* This!

 

It's not selfish. Sometimes it's a matter of self-preservation. I'm not talking about psychology books, I'm talking about me and my own experience.

 

Plus - I don't see anything generally wrong with putting my needs before the others'. Because, with exception of my parents, nobody puts my needs before theirs.

 

Plus - Is this selfish?

 

SHERLOCK: This hospital’s full of people dying, Doctor. Why don’t you go and cry by their bedside and see what good it does them?

Or this?

 

JOHN: There are lives at stake, Sherlock – actual human lives... Just – just so I know, do you care about that at all?

SHERLOCK (irritably): Will caring about them help save them?

JOHN: Nope.

SHERLOCK: Then I’ll continue not to make that mistake.

Sherlock chooses to put the direct empathy and emotion aside, to be better at helping people. And then he even denies the fact that he wants to help out of good will, because it would expose his need to help and make him too human - something he denies out of self-preservation.

  • Like 4
Posted

Hello, *waves*, psychology person here.  I just wanted to weigh in on the whole sociopath thing; this isn't directed at anyone in particular.

The psychologist in bedelia's first article is partially correct when she says that there is no difference between psychopathy and sociopathy from a psychological diagnostic standpoint.  The DSM-5 excludes both terms and generally umbrellas them under Antisocial Personality Disorder, and diagnostically there are no distinguishing traits between the two.  However, the use and meaning of both terms is highly debated in the psychology sphere, especially over the last 10 years or so, and has frequently changed (e.g. for a few years it was just psychopaths that completely lacked empathy and conscience, then just sociopaths, then both, etc.).  The most current leading train of thought is that psychopathy and sociopathy should be considered one and the same, but there are still many different ideas and arguments put forth about it in articles, scientific journals, textbooks, etc., all official-sounding stuff.  My point being that no matter your personal view on the subject, you are sure to find information to back it up.  So until psychologists make up their minds and settle on a description, the argument over whether sociopathy and psychopathy are different or not is almost entirely personal opinion and a bit moot.

For numerous reasons (I'd rather not write an essay), my personal view is that Sherlock is not a sociopath (nor a psychopath, nor a "bad man"), and never was.  Whether he is more selfish or egocentric than empathetic is a different debate (egocentricity being a fundamental aspect of a sociopath, but not enough by itself to pin somebody as one).  You could reasonably argue that the average person is more selfish than not.  I think we have seen him be self-sacrificing prior to series 4, and I personally don't see him lacking in empathy, though I see him express it in different ways than the rest of the characters.  I think there's also something to be said for the necessity to moderate empathy, to balance it out, compartmentalize it, or even suppress it in order to complete his work.  The nature of his work only allows for a certain degree of empathy.  After a point it becomes inefficient, it could slow him down or even paralyze him, and that wouldn't help him or (by extension) the people he is trying to help.

On that note, as a matter of curiosity: Sherlock's degree of empathy is often discussed, but I wonder what you all think of the empathy (or perhaps lack thereof?) shown by the rest of the characters, particularly towards him or in comparison to him?  As I said above, I don't really see Sherlock as having less empathy than the others, just expressed differently.  In what ways do you see Sherlock on the receiving end of empathy (not just tolerance, actual empathy)?  I've been thinking about this, and to be honest, the character I really see showing the most notable amount of empathy to anyone is Molly.  Though Mrs. Hudson also comes to mind, especially in TLD.  I'm not even sure I see John showing all that much empathy, thinking back, although he certainly cares for Sherlock.  Thoughts?

 

  • Like 4
Posted

I just remembered, I was watching TBB the other day and I wanted to mention this one brief instance, because it stuck out to me and I rarely see it brought up.  This is immediately after Sherlock rescued John and Sarah:
 

(Gasping for breath, Sherlock stands up and looks around.  Distant running footsteps can be heard – General Shan is leaving the building.  He looks in the direction of the sound as if considering following, but Sarah's anguished muffled sobs distract him and he unloops the red scarf from around his neck and then drops to his knees beside her.)
SHERLOCK (soothingly): It's all right.
(On the floor, John groans as he struggles to get up onto his elbows.  Sherlock unties Sarah's gag and takes it from her mouth.)
SHERLOCK (softly): You're gonna be all right.  It's over now.  It's over.
(Stroking his hands comfortingly down her arms, he then bends down to untie the ropes.  She begins to sob as John looks up at her from the floor.  He smiles wearily.)
JOHN: Don't worry.  Next date won't be like this.
(She continues to sob as Sherlock straightens up and stands behind her, putting a reassuring hand on her shoulder. [...] He looks down the tunnel wistfully.)

Link: http://arianedevere.livejournal.com/44496.html

 

I thought this was a nice example of Sherlock showing empathy.  A sociopath would not think to comfort someone without a calculated reason, and Sherlock does this instinctively and without prodding.

 

 

 

  • Like 3
Posted

Sherlock chooses to put the direct empathy and emotion aside, to be better at helping people. And then he even denies the fact that he wants to help out of good will, because it would expose his need to help and make him too human - something he denies out of self-preservation.

 

^ Yeeeeeeeeees, this!

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Thank you, I was wondering if it makes sense for anyone but me. Which means I make (kind of) sense too, because I see so much of myself in Sherlock in that regard. :D

  • Like 3
Posted

On that note, as a matter of curiosity: Sherlock's degree of empathy is often discussed, but I wonder what you all think of the empathy (or perhaps lack thereof?) shown by the rest of the characters, particularly towards him or in comparison to him?  As I said above, I don't really see Sherlock as having less empathy than the others, just expressed differently.  In what ways do you see Sherlock on the receiving end of empathy (not just tolerance, actual empathy)?  I've been thinking about this, and to be honest, the character I really see showing the most notable amount of empathy to anyone is Molly.  Though Mrs. Hudson also comes to mind, especially in TLD.  I'm not even sure I see John showing all that much empathy, thinking back, although he certainly cares for Sherlock.  Thoughts?

 

 

 

This particular episode, I think John doesn't have enough empathy towards Sherlock, but he has understandable reasons for that. I think John finds Sherlock hard to read in general. To me, that's why he goes clutching at straws with his Irene Adler theory. He so wants Sherlock, as his friend, to share his experience of love (because only then will Sherlock ever truly understand what John has lost), that he will project his own feelings on to him to achieve it. John loves Sherlock a lot as a friend, but I think it is just hard for him to empathise, because Sherlock conceals a lot of his feelings from John.

 

I think Sherlock wants to have a sort of persona for John, that he's this strong, rational hero. Which is why he's jealous of the Major in TSOT, who was all of those things to John, without trying. It is why he takes a beating for him in TLD- it's the better man he has always tried to be for John. Now, maybe,as in that scene it gets taken too far, no-one should have to take a beating to show that. But when John talks about being a better man for Mary, that's like what Sherlock does for John- he's a better man because John is watching. And I don't mean to equate that with romance, but it is still valid, and for me one of most important aspects to the arc of Sherlock's character in the show.

 

Molly is one of the most empathetic characters on the show. The only time she was a little bit cold to Sherlock, just in my opinion, was at the end of TST, when I thought she could have been a little bit more concerned for his wellbeing, too, as well as John's. I felt like there was maybe a line of dialogue missing there where she checked how he was doing, too. And Mrs. Hudson, bless her, just gets him.

  • Like 3
Posted

Just got to this thread, y'all have been busy! Loved the psychological debate, by the way, and kudos to everyone who kept a cool head during it. I appreciate that no one resorted to shouting. (Alas, yes, it's been known to happen. You should have seen what was going on when I first joined!)

Nevertheless, I thought about dropping a scary moderator warning in at this point, because the tone of the debate came near to being hostile a couple of times. But cool heads prevailed (thank you!) so I will just keep it to this ...  language is a tricky thing. Sometimes when we're trying to be precise with words, they come out rather sharp. And sharp things can be, even unintentionally, rather wounding. We want this to be a comfortable place for everyone, so any time any of us makes an effort to soften the tone of our remarks, it's beneficial to all. Oh ... and don't forget ... unless you are Mr. Moffat or Mr. Gatiss, your interpretation of their words is just that; yours. We all know that, but it's nice when the interpreter acknowledges that with, er, softer language.

 

Capisce? :smile:

Okay, carry on.

  • Like 3
Posted

On that note, as a matter of curiosity: Sherlock's degree of empathy is often discussed, but I wonder what you all think of the empathy (or perhaps lack thereof?) shown by the rest of the characters, particularly towards him or in comparison to him?  As I said above, I don't really see Sherlock as having less empathy than the others, just expressed differently.  In what ways do you see Sherlock on the receiving end of empathy (not just tolerance, actual empathy)?  I've been thinking about this, and to be honest, the character I really see showing the most notable amount of empathy to anyone is Molly.  Though Mrs. Hudson also comes to mind, especially in TLD.  I'm not even sure I see John showing all that much empathy, thinking back, although he certainly cares for Sherlock.  Thoughts?

 

Interesting question. I think it's hard for the others to show Sherlock empathy directly, because his most likely response is to bristle at them and ruin the mood.

 

But Mary, in TSo3, when she realizes he's nervous about the upcoming nuptials, and again, when she realizes he's jealous of Sholto. Even when she's dying, as sappy as it is, she spares a word for him. :rolleyes: And at the beginning, when they first meet, she says she'll talk John around. Now that I think on it, it seems to me that Sherlock and Mary are the ones who really "get" each other in this show (although I think Mary gets John, too.)

 

Molly, of course. Mrs. Hudson? She's such a flake (like his real mom! What does this say about the Moftisses attitudes towards their mothers, I wonder? ;)) ... I don't know if I'd call it empathy, she simply loves him like a son.

 

Mycroft, in his own way ... offering a cigarette after Irene "dies", telling Sherlock he has some "utility" at Christmas ... he's cold about it, but I think that's partly because that's all Sherlock will accept from him. Even after the "I love you" scene, Mycroft started to say something, but Sherlock wouldn't let him.

 

John ... I think John leans towards "just tolerance", but isn't that more what Sherlock is looking for? Not someone to acknowledge his feelings, but someone to accept him for what he is? At least at the beginning. By the end, they've become so close it's almost a moot point ...

  • Like 3
Posted

This particular episode, I think John doesn't have enough empathy towards Sherlock, but he has understandable reasons for that. I think John finds Sherlock hard to read in general.

 Oh, John can be an idiot too. We've been talking about it in an extra thread, now I can remember the moment in HOB when he doesn't recognize the desolate state Sherlock is in after they come back from the Hollow.

 

I think Sherlock wants to have a sort of persona for John, that he's this strong, rational hero. Which is why he's jealous of the Major in TSOT, who was all of those things to John, without trying. It is why he takes a beating for him in TLD- it's the better man he has always tried to be for John. Now, maybe,as in that scene it gets taken too far, no-one should have to take a beating to show that. But when John talks about being a better man for Mary, that's like what Sherlock does for John- he's a better man because John is watching. And I don't mean to equate that with romance, but it is still valid, and for me one of most important aspects to the arc of Sherlock's character in the show.

 

Yeah, surely a good point!

  • Like 2
Posted

 

It is also reductive to say his desire to be sociopathic is just for ego driven reasons.

 

An extremely sensitive person might wish to be like a sociopath, just because then they would not feel so much pain, and that wouldn't be about ego at all. In my opinion, there is a little bit of that in Sherlock's reasoning, too.

*Rises hand* This!

 

It's not selfish. Sometimes it's a matter of self-preservation. I'm not talking about psychology books, I'm talking about me and my own experience.

Obviously you disagree.  I'll note, however, you haven't identified why you claim the above supposedly is not selfish ie how the "self-preservation" you identify above is "selfless".  The standard is himself.  He doesn't want to feel "so much pain".  You don't even reference anyone else in the above example.  So how is that specific example about others and not himself?

 

Plus - I don't see anything generally wrong with putting my needs before the others'. Because, with exception of my parents, nobody puts my needs before theirs.

I am not making a case for altruism vs egoism.  It ain't my philosophy.  If I were, however, I would point out that just because others aren't moral is not a reason for you not to be moral.  In other words, if altruism is one's definition of moral good, then the fact that others are bad should have no bearing on being good or bad one's self.

 

Sherlock chooses to put the direct empathy and emotion aside, to be better at helping people.

No.  Because Sherlock's goal is not "helping people".  His goal is entertaining himself - keeping himself from being "bored" (like Moriarty).  It's about him, not them.  It's the reason he is not a member of the police.  He takes cases for the same reason he takes drugs, not because it helps others, but because it feeds him.  That it may also helps others is collateral benefit.

Posted

 

This particular episode, I think John doesn't have enough empathy towards Sherlock, but he has understandable reasons for that. I think John finds Sherlock hard to read in general.

 Oh, John can be an idiot too. We've been talking about it in an extra thread, now I can remember the moment in HOB when he doesn't recognize the desolate state Sherlock is in after they come back from the Hollow. 

 

 

 

Yes, John completely misses that. Also, John misses a lot of stuff with his girlfriends too, like the one he thought had a dog? Not always the most clued in.

  • Like 1
Posted

My point being that no matter your personal view on the subject, you are sure to find information to back it up.  So until psychologists make up their minds and settle on a description, the argument over whether sociopathy and psychopathy are different or not is almost entirely personal opinion and a bit moot.

It isn't "moot" at all because the characters draw a distinction between them.  As such, whether some psychologists agree or not, the distinction between the two things is important - not because of any "personal view" of ours, but because of the writers.  Sociopathy, as opposed to psychopathy, is what the writers show and say is Sherlock's standard of behavior - what he strives to achieve.

 

For numerous reasons (I'd rather not write an essay), my personal view is that Sherlock is not a sociopath (nor a psychopath, nor a "bad man"), and never was.

My personal view differs from the writers stated views as well.  In other words, like you, I do not share their philosophy.  Unfortunately, my disagreement with those stated views doesn't change them.  :(

 

I think we have seen him be self-sacrificing prior to series 4, and I personally don't see him lacking in empathy

Agreed.  The question isn't whether he can act egotistically or empathetically (he has done both), but which is his standard?

 

On that note, as a matter of curiosity: Sherlock's degree of empathy is often discussed, but I wonder what you all think of the empathy (or perhaps lack thereof?) shown by the rest of the characters, particularly towards him or in comparison to him?  As I said above, I don't really see Sherlock as having less empathy than the others, just expressed differently.  In what ways do you see Sherlock on the receiving end of empathy (not just tolerance, actual empathy)?  I've been thinking about this, and to be honest, the character I really see showing the most notable amount of empathy to anyone is Molly.  Though Mrs. Hudson also comes to mind, especially in TLD.  I'm not even sure I see John showing all that much empathy, thinking back, although he certainly cares for Sherlock.  Thoughts?

This is a good question.  I'd say the issue boils down to the nature of empathy in this context.  I'd say it is the fundamental form of love one can have for others.  As such, it is the base -  the soil -  from which deeper forms of love grow and blossom.   Thus, in this context, I would say all those who love Sherlock in one way or another are necessarily empathetic to Sherlock.  Of course, as you say, that empathy - that love - can be expressed in different ways, such as when Molly slapped Sherlock hard, often, and angrily after he tested positive for drugs.

 

 

 

Posted

Concerning "sociopath" vs "psychopath": Because neither is a recognized medical diagnosis, I have trouble with both terms because it seems to me that they are used in different ways by different people and there doesn't seem to be a good definition of either that health professionals can agree upon.

 

Antisocial personality disorder is the closest medical term. You can read about the criteria here:

 

http://www.icd10data.com/ICD10CM/Codes/F01-F99/F60-F69/F60-/F60.2

 

and here:

 

http://www.psi.uba.ar/academica/carrerasdegrado/psicologia/sitios_catedras/practicas_profesionales/820_clinica_tr_personalidad_psicosis/material/dsm.pdf

 

 

I suppose Sherlock fits some of those. But because he's fictional and to a degree fantastic, I don't see that much point in applying diagnostic criteria invented for real people to him. He's just Sherlock. :)

 

 

  • Like 5
Posted

 

ou don't even reference anyone else in the above example.  So how is that specific example about others and not himself?

I did. It's me.

You miss my point.  Or are you saying Sherlock not wanting to feel pain is a choice he makes to benefit you somehow - ie you are Sherlock's goal, not himself - and that is your answer to why this particular act is not selfish, but is selfless?

Posted

Self-preservation can be selfless, because in taking care of yourself, you are ensuring that society, and others don't need to step in and help.

 

It is like Mycroft trying to take care of Sherlock when he's started taking drugs again- if Sherlock would only get some help, and look after himself better, he would help Mycroft, and John, and everyone who cares bout him enormously. There aren't black and white distinctions between what can be good for you and good for others too. If you save yourself so others don't have to, you are doing something which is both good for you and them- showing an awareness of your own worth and theirs, ego and empathy all at once. It doesn't have to be an either-or situation.

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 99 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.