Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Lying Detective"?  

70 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Awful.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

Oh, is that what John says! :d It's edited out here. Guess I should watch my DVD and see what other exciting bits of dialog I've missed. ;)

Posted

I have to admit I'm curious how Sherlock knows the only perk to being suicidal is chips...

 

I sort of assumed that he was feeling suicidal himself, what with the ups and downs of drug use and the continual waiting for John to finally take some sort of notice and charge in, like Mary said. And that he'd been consoling himself with eating lots of chips.

  • Like 1
Posted

I sort of assumed that he was feeling suicidal himself, what with the ups and downs of drug use and the continual waiting for John to finally take some sort of notice and charge in, like Mary said. And that he'd been consoling himself with eating lots of chips.

I dunno... it seemed like he was previously suicidal. It's hard to explain, like he'd been talked down before and taken for chips. I took a friend for ice cream once. I don't think there was anyone around to talk him down after Mary died. He turned to drugs, not taking himself out. It was never his intention to kill himself in this episode, he just wanted John's attention and then he wanted to take down Smith. No matter what he says I don't think that the plan was to actually kill himself. He just wanted to be ill enough to be in the hospital.

 

I think he was depressed, but he understood that you're death happens to those around you, not you yourself. As self-centered as he behaves, that doesn't seem like a lesson he would learn unless he'd experienced it himself. Writers, we need backstory!

  • Like 4
Posted

I think it's possible he was suicidal but knew he couldn't actually do anything since Mary had died to save him. If he'd then killed himself her sacrifice would be in vain. Doesn't mean he doesn't feel it though. I don't know if I believe he's suicidal in this episode, I'm torn on it. As you said, without knowing more of his backstory, between the whole Euros debacle and ASIP, we'll never know. I can't imagine his school and uni years were very happy.

  • Like 3
Posted
I think he was depressed, but he understood that you're death happens to those around you, not you yourself. As self-centered as he behaves, that doesn't seem like a lesson he would learn unless he'd experienced it himself. Writers, we need backstory!

 

I have three ideas concerning this:

 

1.) It's canon. Holmes was violently opposed to suicide, which I believe to be due mostly to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Catholicism.

2.) Sherlock has just lost a friend, Mary, and he feels her loss. Even though she did not commit suicide in the strictest sense of the word, she did have control over her own death, and Sherlock is one of the people whom her life was taken from.

3.) Sherlock sees the devastating effect Mary's death has on John. Personally, I think that's his main eye-opener here. And I can't help believing that he finally understands what he did to John when he jumped off that roof and pretended to commit suicide himself. I doubt he still considers this a good joke. My theory is that Sherlock is not just feeling guilt over Mary's death (which really isn't his fault) but also over that older harm he did.

 

Welcome the forum, by the way! :welcome:

  • Like 4
Posted

I think it's possible he was suicidal but knew he couldn't actually do anything since Mary had died to save him. If he'd then killed himself her sacrifice would be in vain. Doesn't mean he doesn't feel it though. I don't know if I believe he's suicidal in this episode, I'm torn on it. As you said, without knowing more of his backstory, between the whole Euros debacle and ASIP, we'll never know. I can't imagine his school and uni years were very happy.

SHERLOCK (quietly): In saving my life, she conferred a value on it. (He hesitates for a moment.) It is a currency I do not know how to spend.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I think it's possible he was suicidal but knew he couldn't actually do anything since Mary had died to save him. If he'd then killed himself her sacrifice would be in vain. Doesn't mean he doesn't feel it though. I don't know if I believe he's suicidal in this episode, I'm torn on it. As you said, without knowing more of his backstory, between the whole Euros debacle and ASIP, we'll never know. I can't imagine his school and uni years were very happy.

SHERLOCK (quietly): In saving my life, she conferred a value on it. (He hesitates for a moment.) It is a currency I do not know how to spend.

 

 

Precisely. 

  • Like 1
Posted

3.) Sherlock sees the devastating effect Mary's death has on John. Personally, I think that's his main eye-opener here. And I can't help believing that he finally understands what he did to John when he jumped off that roof and pretended to commit suicide himself. I doubt he still considers this a good joke. My theory is that Sherlock is not just feeling guilt over Mary's death (which really isn't his fault) but also over that older harm he did.

I think it's possible he was suicidal but knew he couldn't actually do anything since Mary had died to save him. If he'd then killed himself her sacrifice would be in vain. Doesn't mean he doesn't feel it though. I don't know if I believe he's suicidal in this episode, I'm torn on it. As you said, without knowing more of his backstory, between the whole Euros debacle and ASIP, we'll never know. I can't imagine his school and uni years were very happy.

SHERLOCK (quietly): In saving my life, she conferred a value on it. (He hesitates for a moment.) It is a currency I do not know how to spend.

 

Oh, you three.... :Worship:  :'( 

 

We've talked before about Sherlock's seeming lack of a sense of self-worth, haven't we? I think that's why half the people here always go around thinking he's in need of a good cuddle...

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

3.) Sherlock sees the devastating effect Mary's death has on John. Personally, I think that's his main eye-opener here. And I can't help believing that he finally understands what he did to John when he jumped off that roof and pretended to commit suicide himself. I doubt he still considers this a good joke. My theory is that Sherlock is not just feeling guilt over Mary's death (which really isn't his fault) but also over that older harm he did.

I think it's possible he was suicidal but knew he couldn't actually do anything since Mary had died to save him. If he'd then killed himself her sacrifice would be in vain. Doesn't mean he doesn't feel it though. I don't know if I believe he's suicidal in this episode, I'm torn on it. As you said, without knowing more of his backstory, between the whole Euros debacle and ASIP, we'll never know. I can't imagine his school and uni years were very happy.

SHERLOCK (quietly): In saving my life, she conferred a value on it. (He hesitates for a moment.) It is a currency I do not know how to spend.

Oh, you three.... :Worship: :'(

 

We've talked before about Sherlock's seeming lack of a sense of self-worth, haven't we? I think that's why half the people here always go around thinking he's in need of a good cuddle...

Lol... this season he definitely needed a cuddle... it's surprising because in the episode, it seems like no one checked on him other than Mrs. Hudson. Mary sacrificed herself for him. That would mess with anyone's brain and it doesn't look like anyone even checked on him. John said no one had seen him for weeks. You have a friend who you know was drug issues and that suffered a trauma and you left them alone for weeks? I just can't imagine it. I would have thought Molly or Lestrade knowing him would have forced their way in (although I'm sort of glad Lestrade didn't... would have been a completely different show lol). Shoot, that Mycroft didn't put his foot down over the drugs is surprising.

 

I've always thought Sherlock needed a friend that wouldn't get pissed off and walk away. Someone who would stay and fight back when he was being an idiot.

 

I agree, I think his younger years must have been difficult. There is something the writers are implying. Just not sure what the extent is.

 

I don't know that feeling sad, lonely and guilty mean suicidal though. I don't know. If we get more episodes, I'm sure Mycroft will let out what happened in the past...

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Lol... this season he definitely needed a cuddle... it's surprising because in the episode, it seems like no one checked on him other than Mrs. Hudson. Mary sacrificed herself for him. That would mess with anyone's brain and it doesn't look like anyone even checked on him. John said no one had seen him for weeks. You have a friend who you know was drug issues and that suffered a trauma and you left them alone for weeks? I just can't imagine it. I would have thought Molly or Lestrade knowing him would have forced their way in (although I'm sort of glad Lestrade didn't... would have been a completely different show lol). Shoot, that Mycroft didn't put his foot down over the drugs is surprising.

I wondered that too; why Hudders or Mycroft didn't do something sooner. Maybe they were all in on it? That's a bit much, and I have a hard time believing Mycroft would go along with such a scheme. And if Hudders was in on it, why stage the little ballet with the teacup and the gun?

 

Does anyone else think that this episode kind of exists in its own little bubble? To me, it's so stylistically different than the other two; the filming is more cinematic, Sherlock's in control of the situation (although we don't know that until the end), he looks different, it's more like the first two seasons in it's plot ... it feels like an episode of Sherlock, whereas the other two feel like imitations. Add to all that, all the secondary characters seem to act as if life is going on as usual, no one's checking in with either Sherlock or John to see how they're handling Mary's death. It's a little bit weird. I love this episode to bits, but it does seem like it's running in a different reality than the other two.

  • Like 1
Posted

Even if Hudders knew what he was doing and why she should still have put her foot down. Hell, she should have done something when she saw the DVD - perhaps pointed out that he, Sherlock, was worth just as much as John, and Mary had no right telling him to practically destroy himself to save him. Going by the gun and tea incident I'm guessing she had some idea but wasn't expecting it to spiral out of control to the extent it did. 

 

And Lestrade, really where does he get off? He's fine staging a fake drugs bust in ASIP, but when Sherlock has a full blown drugs lab in his kitchen he doesn't even drop by? Despite seeing everything that happened and knowing that Sherlock has issues with drugs? And Mycroft 'I worry about him constantly' Holmes... it's appalling he didn't give a shit, he must have known what was likely going on. He had people watching for when Sherlock might leave the building - what, like it's impossible for him to overdose inside?TBH the whole thing of him being an overprotective big brother only ever comes into play when it's useful for the writers. Someone shoots Sherlock? Mycroft doesn't care. Sherlock is chained up being beaten? Mycroft doesn't seem bothered. Sherlock gets high to the point of overdose? Mycroft ignores it. Sherlock gets the shit kicked out of him by his best friend? Mycroft ignores that too. Bloody hell, I'm not close to any of my siblings, but surely any of those would be cause for serious concern. It seems when Sherlock could actually do with someone stepping in to help him Mycroft can't be bothered, he just likes to interfere when things are going well. I hate the trope of Mycroft always swooping in to save the day as much as the next person, but I would actually like him to do it once or twice, and not in the name of solving a case via his surveillance but in the name of actually trying to save his brother. Mycroft, or hell even Sherlock's parents, should have dragged him off to rehab, or at least held him under observation, as soon as he showed signs of spiralling off the deep end. Are we meant to believe that Mycroft Holmes, who probably knew exactly what was on that DVD, cared more about saving John than saving Sherlock? John is just a goldfish after all. 

When Mycroft realises Sherlock is high on the plane in TAB he seems concerned and upset, we have a flashback of him finding and helping Sherlock in a doss house when they were younger, but now in TLD he's suddenly not bothered? Give me a break.  

 

Yes, I agree TLD is in it's own bubble. It's also the only one with any real impressive deductions or a real case, and honestly the filming made Sherlock look more haggard in T6T than he did whilst high in TLD. I wonder if the things you pointed out contribute to my feelings about the beating - it doesn't just feel like John has abandoned him, everyone has. He's obviously going through a tough time and the only person who spends any time with him is Wiggins? Where are his friends? Again, since Molly is apparently in love with him she's not doing a whole lot to try to save him - not that I think she could or he'd listen to her but she could at least try. Another sign of Sherlock's poor self-worth is that he expects and accepts everyone abandoning him. It must feel like everyone is blaming him, not just John. 

 

Also, when John tells Lestrade he beat up Sherlock Lestrade doesn't even react. A little line about how that's not okay would have done wonders. "John, mate, I know you're going through hell but you can't do that. It's assault."

 

Perhaps it's more head-cannon than anything else, but I always imagined Lestrade met Sherlock when he was in his early twenties and strung out, I think the possibility of working on more cases probably helped Sherlock get clean. I imagine Sherlock stumbling onto his first crime scene, high as a kite but incandescently brilliant, and Lestrade being blown away. Who the hell is this kid? How does he know what happened? Was he involved? After that Sherlock sort of latches on and starts emailing and ringing in tips to Lestrade, who withholds further access unless Sherlock gets clean. I always thought Lestrade would feel a bit, well, if not paternal at least big brotherly towards Sherlock. I thought there was some loyalty there, that Lestrade would step in if Sherlock was hurting himself or being hurt. Perhaps I'm reading too much into a professional relationship, but since Lestrade was one of the people Sherlock jumped to save (which indicated a closer relationship than I expected at the time, but hey, they wrote it), then surely that friendship and loyalty would also go the other way since Lestrade is the more normal out of the two of them. 

 

Oops, that got a bit ranty. Ah well.  :blush:

 

  • Like 4
Posted

We seem to be going round and round in circles, just like the teddy bear in the garden in TGG :D

OK: proper plot hole question: How did the Lady in Red reach the flat?

Wiggins is sequestered in the kitchen/meth lab, Mrs Hudson seemingly has no idea, since she comes out of her flat just as Sherlock is preparing to leave.

Did they beam her into the flat, or what?

Posted

We seem to be going round and round in circles, just like the teddy bear in the garden in TGG :D

OK: proper plot hole question: How did the Lady in Red reach the flat?

Wiggins is sequestered in the kitchen/meth lab, Mrs Hudson seemingly has no idea, since she comes out of her flat just as Sherlock is preparing to leave.

Did they beam her into the flat, or what?

I was under the impression she'd arrived in a cab but had dismissed it. Did I dream that?

Posted

I think Inge means how she got in the door since neither Hudson nor Wiggins let her in. If Sherlock knew she was coming he could have just told her the door was unlocked and to come on up. 

 

As for going around in circles, that's pretty much all we have to do until (if) there are more episodes. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I can't say I feel remotely sorry for Sherlock in this circumstance, like he's a damsel in distress that needs to be rescued. Given the way he treats Mycroft, John and Molly when they show concern for him over years, why would they rush to beat their head up against a wall? Sherlock does what Sherlock wants to do. No one is going to stop him but when he's willing to accept their help, they help him like babysitting him when he's detoxing.

Posted

Thanks, Pseudonym, that was my query.

Second point in question: if Sherlock isn't allowed anywhere near Dr Watson, who implanted the listening device in Dr Watson's old walking stick three weeks before it was needed?

Also, is it just me, or is anybody else feel the lack of the scarf?

Posted

I wondered that about the walking stick too. 

Posted

I think Inge means how she got in the door since neither Hudson nor Wiggins let her in. If Sherlock knew she was coming he could have just told her the door was unlocked and to come on up. 

 

 

No surprise I misunderstood. I have a long history of sticking my foot in my mouth. I will withdraw now.

  • Like 1
Posted

No don't do that, it's no problem  :smile:

Posted

Even if Hudders knew what he was doing and why she should still have put her foot down. Hell, she should have done something when she saw the DVD - perhaps pointed out that he, Sherlock, was worth just as much as John, and Mary had no right telling him to practically destroy himself to save him. Going by the gun and tea incident I'm guessing she had some idea but wasn't expecting it to spiral out of control to the extent it did.

 

And Lestrade, really where does he get off? He's fine staging a fake drugs bust in ASIP, but when Sherlock has a full blown drugs lab in his kitchen he doesn't even drop by? Despite seeing everything that happened and knowing that Sherlock has issues with drugs? And Mycroft 'I worry about him constantly' Holmes... it's appalling he didn't give a shit, he must have known what was likely going on. He had people watching for when Sherlock might leave the building - what, like it's impossible for him to overdose inside?TBH the whole thing of him being an overprotective big brother only ever comes into play when it's useful for the writers. Someone shoots Sherlock? Mycroft doesn't care. Sherlock is chained up being beaten? Mycroft doesn't seem bothered. Sherlock gets high to the point of overdose? Mycroft ignores it. Sherlock gets the shit kicked out of him by his best friend? Mycroft ignores that too. Bloody hell, I'm not close to any of my siblings, but surely any of those would be cause for serious concern. It seems when Sherlock could actually do with someone stepping in to help him Mycroft can't be bothered, he just likes to interfere when things are going well. I hate the trope of Mycroft always swooping in to save the day as much as the next person, but I would actually like him to do it once or twice, and not in the name of solving a case via his surveillance but in the name of actually trying to save his brother. Mycroft, or hell even Sherlock's parents, should have dragged him off to rehab, or at least held him under observation, as soon as he showed signs of spiralling off the deep end. Are we meant to believe that Mycroft Holmes, who probably knew exactly what was on that DVD, cared more about saving John than saving Sherlock? John is just a goldfish after all.

When Mycroft realises Sherlock is high on the plane in TAB he seems concerned and upset, we have a flashback of him finding and helping Sherlock in a doss house when they were younger, but now in TLD he's suddenly not bothered? Give me a break.

 

Yes, I agree TLD is in it's own bubble. It's also the only one with any real impressive deductions or a real case, and honestly the filming made Sherlock look more haggard in T6T than he did whilst high in TLD. I wonder if the things you pointed out contribute to my feelings about the beating - it doesn't just feel like John has abandoned him, everyone has. He's obviously going through a tough time and the only person who spends any time with him is Wiggins? Where are his friends? Again, since Molly is apparently in love with him she's not doing a whole lot to try to save him - not that I think she could or he'd listen to her but she could at least try. Another sign of Sherlock's poor self-worth is that he expects and accepts everyone abandoning him. It must feel like everyone is blaming him, not just John.

 

Also, when John tells Lestrade he beat up Sherlock Lestrade doesn't even react. A little line about how that's not okay would have done wonders. "John, mate, I know you're going through hell but you can't do that. It's assault."

 

Perhaps it's more head-cannon than anything else, but I always imagined Lestrade met Sherlock when he was in his early twenties and strung out, I think the possibility of working on more cases probably helped Sherlock get clean. I imagine Sherlock stumbling onto his first crime scene, high as a kite but incandescently brilliant, and Lestrade being blown away. Who the hell is this kid? How does he know what happened? Was he involved? After that Sherlock sort of latches on and starts emailing and ringing in tips to Lestrade, who withholds further access unless Sherlock gets clean. I always thought Lestrade would feel a bit, well, if not paternal at least big brotherly towards Sherlock. I thought there was some loyalty there, that Lestrade would step in if Sherlock was hurting himself or being hurt. Perhaps I'm reading too much into a professional relationship, but since Lestrade was one of the people Sherlock jumped to save (which indicated a closer relationship than I expected at the time, but hey, they wrote it), then surely that friendship and loyalty would also go the other way since Lestrade is the more normal out of the two of them.

 

Oops, that got a bit ranty. Ah well. :blush:

I kinda had the same backstory for Sherlock and Lestrade. Lestrade clearly knew he had drug problems in ASiP, I can't imagine he just forgot. They seemed closer than that. Lestrade always seemed a bit like the big brother Sherlock needed. He tried to run herd on him throughout the series and I think that's what Sherlock needed. I just don't get Lestrade abandoning him.

 

Same with Molly. She slaps him in HLV and scolds him over the drugs, but after what happened at John's house she doesn't even stop by? These are supposed to be people who love Sherlock... I swear there are times I think "friends" were the worst thing to happen to him.

 

I don't get Mycroft at all... he knew something was wrong and he didn't do anything? Just put surveillance on the house? I don't get that at all. If Sherlock wasn't responding to him, he could have called their parents. He's supposed to be the smart one who worries about his little brother. There's no real excuse for I'm letting this happen.

 

I'm just grateful for Mrs. Hudson, even if she should have reacted sooner. She at least did something and got him help.

 

I feel like TLD was the only Sherlock episode. The other two existed to drive the plot which is weird with Euros featuring so predominantly in TLD.

Posted

My head canon is, that Sherlock just rejected any contact. You cannot come into someone's house without their consent, until you are AGRA. I think Mrs Hudson believed that Sherlock has a plan, at least at the beginning, so maybe she was cooperating and not giving any information away.

 

As for Mycroft - in his notebook you see a list of Sherlock boltholes he is monitoring. And once Sherlock is outside, his movements are immediately a big thing in Big Brothers house. Beside that, he tried to call John - thinking that whatever trouble Sherlock is in, he would hear only to John.There is no proof that Mycroft knows how bad the situation is, but I wouldn't say he didn't care.

  • Like 2
Posted

My head canon is, that Sherlock just rejected any contact. You cannot come into someone's house without their consent, until you are AGRA. I think Mrs Hudson believed that Sherlock has a plan, at least at the beginning, so maybe she was cooperating and not giving any information away.

 

As for Mycroft - in his notebook you see a list of Sherlock boltholes he is monitoring. And once Sherlock is outside, his movements are immediately a big thing in Big Brothers house. Beside that, he tried to call John - thinking that whatever trouble Sherlock is in, he would hear only to John.There is no proof that Mycroft knows how bad the situation is, but I wouldn't say he didn't care.

 

Yes, I thought that the missing parts where his friends would have intervened- or at least tried to do so, were omitted to make way for plot. A problem with this whole season, actually, IMO, was too many basic human moments were missing, in order to make way for the huge amount of story they had to cover.

 

I did also feel it was semi-realistic that the aftermath of Mary's death left everyone a bit shell-shocked, blaming themselves, wounded, unsure and running for cover. We saw that Molly wasn't at her best at the end of TST, but even Mycroft and Lestrade probably didn't feel too good about the way that messy death scene went down. I do think in an event like that where a lot of people feel some (mostly) misplaced guilt, people can tend to connect less, just because it is harder to bridge that gap between where everyone is emotionally and where they expected to be/ wish they were.

 

And then, of course Sherlock goes on drugs- and I agree his loved ones should want to help him, and even think they did try (we just didn't see it), but there might have been a part of them wishing that he wouldn't make a really bad time even worse for everyone.

  • Like 3
Posted

I can't imagine Sherlock having much trouble breaking into John's flat and planting the bug, or having someone else do it.

 

As to the rest ... uhhh ... you got me. Wow. Ummm, how about this ... people tried to contact Sherlock, but he wouldn't talk to them or let them get anywhere near him? So they'd ask Mrs. H how he was doing, but she'd cover for him and say he was fine, just not feeling sociable? Until she finally decided he'd gone too far and took charge, as he knew she would, thereby setting his plan in motion....

 

Still, you'd think the others would be suspicious, knowing his proclivities .... ssssh, stupid brain!!!!

  • Like 5
Posted

Since he's so high his stubble is remarkably neat. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 111 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.