Jump to content

What did you think of "The Final Problem?"  

112 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Awful.


Recommended Posts

Posted

I think also when Molly turned the tables on him and told him to say ILY first and he says it - not one but twice, the second te with feeling and meaning - yes, he did mean it - and him finally hearing the words from her lips in response. Broke him open. He'd never said ILY to anyone in the show. Not anyone. It's not just that I ship it but that the ship had been sailing strongly since S3. Even Loo said, "Something happened in the last season (3), and now we no longer laughed at the idea that yes, something could happen between them (Sherlock and Molly)."

 

 

I'm not going to battle that ship here, but for him to say the words ILY were not just manipulation. Not at all. Oh, and she is wearing a thin gold ring on her ring finger when she enters 221B at the end. Yes she is. And she's heading happily in Sherlock's direction.

Yes that scene wouldn't have been nearly as impactful if Sherlock hadn't said it first. Both BC and LB were really good.

  • Like 2
Posted

About the way that Sherlock deduced that it was Molly in the coffin- obviously the 'I love you' was the only clue needed, but did anyone think his other deductions were a bit woolly?

 

How did he know from a coffin that the person was unmarried, practical about death and alone?

 

Like, isn't everyone alone in a coffin? There aren't any extra tragic single-persons coffins are there? How do any of these words come from the type of coffin it is? Are we supposed to surmise that because it isn't a PVC covered coffin full of whips that it isn't Irene Adler?

Posted

:smile:

 

No, I think the deduction about the coffin was pretty believable. Someone less practical about death would have chosen a more plush coffin, for the greater comfort of the, er, occupant. Ditto if she had been married/not alone; a married woman is more likely to be able to afford a fancier coffin, and the surviving partner is more likely to want the best they could afford, not the economy model. (The point about being alone wasn't about being alone in the coffin, but alone in life.)

 

I'm not quite sure how he came up with her height; I wasn't aware coffins were custom made. But perhaps he was referring to the arrangement of the interior; there seems to have been a headrest, the placement of which might indicate the overall height of the person.

 

Irene is wealthy, thinks highly of herself, and is a far more whimsical person; she would have chosen a much fancier coffin. Possibly with whips. ;)

 

How do I know it was an economy model coffin? Had to help choose one once. The differences between the lower and higher priced models are pretty profound. No lonely nights on Google required. :smile:

  • Like 6
Posted

Thank you for the info, though I'm sorry for the circumstances from which you came by the information.

 

Somehow it makes me feel even worse for Molly that she was getting lumbered with a cheap coffin on top of everything. Oh well, at least it is all smashed up now.  :D

Posted

 

Sfmpco, I think I agree with what you say, but ... why did he have to feel emotions, to remember the past, to play the game? Because it seems to me that what happened next was he solved the riddle of the song and the gravestones ... and I can't figure out how his emotional state, or his memories, factor into that. What are your thoughts on this?

 

I don't know that he had to specifically feel emotions to remember the past -  but here's where TAB comes more into play than one would think.  Remember his little conversation with Watson:Eu

 

From Ariane Devere's transcript:

 

WATSON: As your friend – as someone who ... worries about you – what made you like this?

HOLMES: Oh, Watson. Nothing made me.

(From somewhere to his left, scrabbling claws can be heard together with a sound of a dog whimpering anxiously, or as if it is in pain. Holmes turns his head in the direction of the sound.)

HOLMES: I made me.

(The scrabbling and whimpering continues. Holmes frowns in confusion.)

HOLMES: Redbeard?

 

Two things of importance - 1) his admission that he made himself.  This is a subconscious admission that perfectly dovetails Mycroft's words in TFP of "Every choice you ever made; every path you've ever taken - the man you are today is your memory of Eurus."  Sherlock rewrote his own memories, something that is echoed in TST when Mycroft mentions that Sherlock rewrote the story of the Merchant of Samarra to have a better ending.  Sherlock has written a different memory regarding a dog instead of a best friend.  And he lost the dog.. although in TFP it makes it seem like the dog was drowned but in HLV is the mind palace line, "Hello, Redbeard.  They're putting me down too, now.  It's no fun, is it?"  This line makes it seem as if the dog was put to sleep, which is either a story inconsistency or that Sherlock had even rewritten that part of his memory to deal with the loss of the imaginary dog. So really, all the locked up, pent up emotions he feels are because of the lies he told himself to cover the truth - even the truth about his sister.  He blotted her out of his mind, likely because he knew the truth but it was too much to bear.  Interesting in MHR when he says, "Only lies have detail."  How true that is of how he rewrote his memories.  Notice also that in the TAB quote above it seems to imply that Redbeard is trapped somewhere and clawing to get out.  Of course this is his drug-addled mind palace but it seems to imply a different ending for Redbeard than just that he was put down.

 

2.  When he first meets Eurus at her cell, she can see that he is still mentally blocked...so blocked that he can't see the obvious - that there is no glass in her cell to keep her in.  She wants to play with him, but she can't fully do that if he can't remember the truth.

 

Eurus lacks empathy although she is not totally without emotional context herself.  She experiences the fear of being alone in her supreme intelligence.  But she also has pity on Sherlock that he has blocked out the truth.  I suspect she knows that she is about to have a complete mental breakdown, but she also needs Sherlock to solve that puzzle she left for him as a child.  If he had solved it as a child and had then gone to her room, she likely wouldn't have set the place of fire and would have told him where to find his friend.  

  

The truth is locked up in Sherlock, and part of his maintaining control is to keep that truth locked up.  He won't let sentiment or love, or anything breach that lock, because then the buried truth will come out.  In a way, that's the true final problem - the unlocking of Sherlock.  It is a parting gift to him from her, but to unlock him, she has to push all his buttons, his pressure points.  Even Sherlock admits that what she is putting him through is vivisection.  She is not just cracking his shell but breaking it wide open and allowing the Sherlock that once was to live again.  I am always reminded of Moriary's line from TGG where he says, "I will burn the heart out of you" because I never felt he did that.  But Eurus is certainly doing it.  This time, solve the riddle of the headstones, save Eurus from killing Sherlock's best friend again.   She just wants to be loved and have a friend, and the gentle tenderness he shows her when he finds her in her old Musgrave room are the most kindness and tenderness he has perhaps show anyone in any of the episodes,  Eurus did that to him.  All the other people around him may have softened his edges some over the years, but Eurus broke him - and thereby fixed him.  Bad analogy, but he was in a cocoon and he emerged a butterfly.

 

 

Thanks sfmpco! And I think your analogy is rather perfect. He's a somewhat bruised and battered butterfly, but at least he's emerged from the cocoon.

  • Like 2
Posted

Thank you for the info, though I'm sorry for the circumstances from which you came by the information.

 

Somehow it makes me feel even worse for Molly that she was getting lumbered with a cheap coffin on top of everything. Oh well, at least it is all smashed up now.  :D

Yeah, that was a little heart-breaking. Although I suppose from a practical p.o.v., it had to be a cheap coffin, because no way Sherlock could've broken up one of those high end things with his bare hands.  :P

 

If it makes any of us feel better, though, Sherlock did say it wasn't the lowest end on the coffin scale, just ... practical. Not showy. Like our Molls. :wub:

 

And thanks for the sympathetic word. I'm okay, it was a long time ago.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Just wondering: is it normal for people to choose their coffins when they're in their 30's like Molly? I thought people only chose their coffins when they reached old age. I was a bit surprised Molly actually had a coffin. Was she expecting to die? Maybe she just chose early because she worked in a morgue.

Posted

I think Euros picked that coffin for Molly.

  • Like 2
Posted

Someone who is living alone and is practical about death - yes. She might have her last will and all arrangememts made, because she knows how easy it is to die, also if you are young.

 

But as much as I like the emotional impact of the scene, I'm sure it's not possible to break any coffin with your bare hands*, until it's made out of cardboard. And this is probably the first time when knowing the behind-the-scenes stuff got in my way of receiving a scene: I know from Danny's display at first Sherlocked, that they make breakable woood props out of balsa wood. It's very light and very breakable (and expensive :)). And you see that the coffin is very light when Sherlock smashes it. And it bothers me. :P

 

*did break a pine woood plank with my fist once. It was a beeping effort, to break the wood along the structure, and if you aren't a karate fighter, it's not something you can do several times in a row.

  • Like 1
Posted

I agree, even the cheapest coffin wouldn't be that flimsy, but I was hoping to maintain the willing suspension of disbelief. :D

  • Like 3
Posted

I agree too, it did look a bit too easy to smash up, even for a bargain range coffin.

 

Or, you know, maybe Sherlock was just so strong and passionate that his loss of control made the coffin look flimsy...  :wub:

 

Or, he was really angry because if he were choosing for her he would have picked a totally different design...

  • Like 3
Posted

He's so romantic .... :d

  • Like 3
Posted

In truth you couldn't smash a coffin with bare hands, but do we know that Eurus had a real coffin and not just a mock-up?  After all, when he first smashes it, those decorative  finials on the top popped off like they were barely glued on.  I have heard that BC sustained a splinter from that scene.  Having recently buried a friend, and she went in the lowest price one, I can still attest that the thing was solid as a rock.

Posted

My condolences for losing your friend. :(

 

And agreed, when I had to arrange for my aunt's funeral, I was directed to stand between and choose from different coffin models, and they were all built of thick, solid wood. Never understood the logic (I mean, they're meant to rot in the ground, after all) but that's tradition for you.

Posted

Yup, good thing Eurus had a fake built. Pretty clairvoyant, that lady! :d Otherwise Sherlock would have busted his hands up pretty good....

Posted

Besides Redbeard, what other instances in the entire series are there of people corrupting/deleting memories (intentionally or not) ie trying to create "better stories" to replace the truth?

Obviously there is Smith at the beginning of TLD.  There is the rewriting (at the beginning of T6T) of what happened to CAM.  There is Sherlock, in TGG,  'deleting' from his mind 'unimportant' facts like the Earth revolving around the Sun.  There is the direct analogy to Redbeard in Hound, misremembering a man as a dog.  There is Mary lying about her past as an "assassin" (thru S3).  And there is Moriarty's attempt to remake Sherlock's achievements as fraud in TRF.

Any others?

  • Like 1
Posted

Every word out of Mycroft's mouth? :d

 

How about the whole structure of TEH? Showing us multiple explanations for How He Did It, and never confirming which is the right one.

  • Like 3
Posted

How about the whole structure of TEH? Showing us multiple explanations for How He Did It, and never confirming which is the right one.

LOL!  Well, that's the writers.  I mean the characters.  :D

 

Posted

The Samara story.

What Mycroft told his parents.

Those are good ones.

Posted

I like Eurus. I hope we see her more in season 5.

  • Like 2
Posted

And of course, there is essentially the entirety of TLD (in regard to Mary's "case" for Sherlock), right down to its title.  :)

  • Like 1
Posted

More Existential References:

 

In the back of my mind, I wondered why the writers chose "Faith" as the name of Smith's daughter.  Now I know.  In my post to Inge in a different thread, I made reference to a liar.  And that triggered a memory for me:

 

One of the things the existentialist Sartre is famous for is an analysis of "self-deception" or "bad faith" ie false faith.  That is certainly what Eurus plays in TLD.  But more importantly, existentially "bad faith" is a reference to people being of "two minds" (the definition meaning "double mindedness or double heartedness") in contradiction with one another, but both existing within the same person.  That certainly describes Eurus the adult and Eurus the little girl trapped on a plane.  They are the same person, with the little girl knowing/feeling the truth of existential reality (she knows she needs Sherlock love), while the adult has deceived herself into believing it is not the truth (she thinks she doesn't need anyone's love).

 

In this way, she is a mirror of Sherlock throughout the series.  He had deceived himself into believing he didn't want or need love, but realized (thru John, and the rediscovery of Eurus) that he truly does want and need it.

 

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.