Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I thought it was kind of implied by John seeming a bit put out that Sherlock was getting most of the attention at Irene's place. Mostly in a, 'typical, Sherlock is getting all the female attention again,' kind of way, but I though he at least noticed her, as an attractive woman. I mean, it would have been hard not to! Did you see it differently?

  • Like 1
Posted

Ooops, cross posted. Again...
 

When have you seen John shown any attraction or interest in Irene?

When she says she likes detectives, John perks up and sits down next to her, then Sherlock comes out with his garbled "positionofthecar" remark. That could be interpreted as John taking an interest in her, and it could be interpreted as Sherlock feeling a little competitive and rushing in to cut him off. Of course, it could be interpreted in several other ways as well. :/

  • Like 4
Posted

Everything is open to interpretation of course, but having seen two men both falling over themselves vying for the attention of a pretty woman before... it pretty much looks like those two in Irene's living room (in my albeit limited experience of the world).

  • Like 3
Posted

It's probably just me but I didn't get that interpretation from SiB at all. Maybe I'd have to see it again but I've seen that episode several times and I didn't see a competitiveness over Irene.

 

Edited to add I always felt the put out attitude John had in that scene was being ordered around doing Sherlock's bidding like when the smoke detector went off and Sherlock was still telling him what to do, lol. There have been other episodes where John is annoyed with Sherlock for similar things.

Posted

Tbh, and I don't mean this in a Johnlock way, I always saw John as being jealous over Irene getting Sherlock's attention, and also disliking her because he felt she was taking advantage. Just look at how protective he is in the warehouse scene. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I agree with everything above. That scene is a perfect storm of ambiguity. And in the context of the show at that time, it worked beautifully.

Posted

Well, more that Sherlock portrays himself to both John and Mycroft as being above all that sentimental business, and (this part might sound a bit mad) I think he might feel he's somehow diminished in their eyes, and his own, if he doesn't hold himself to that standard. I never saw Sherlock as someone who doesn't feel, but rather someone who holds the ideal of 'cold reason' above all else- and it is so central to how he sees himself, and how he wants the world to see him, that I think it would be extra hard for him to have the cracks start to appear, in front of John and (even worse in his eyes) Mycroft. It's not even that it is embarrassment exactly- but it leaves him so, so far outside his comfort zone, and therefore quite vulnerable. That feeling BC describes of being undecided, in my view would be a really discomfiting place for Sherlock to be, especially so with an audience.

 

As much as the scene was an attack on Molly's dignity, it was an attack in Sherlock's too- in the sense that whatever he's feeling here is likely something he wanted kept private (and because I read the situation that way, for me John wouldn't continue on that violation of privacy by pulling at the threads even more). Which is not to say he wouldn't love to know what is going on, much as I would.

 

About Irene, I thought the part of the scene you mention that was really telling was when Sherlock asked for the phone. To me, that was an admission on his part to John that yes, he did have feelings for Irene. It was really significant to me that he can trust John with that information about himself. And it makes a sort of sense that in season four John would still bring up Irene, because that was in some ways the last he had heard about Sherlock's feelings for a woman.

I do agree that Sherlock holds himself to a standard about a lack of romantic entanglements and he probably assumes that Mycroft would tease him if he succumbed to one like Mycroft teased Sherlock about needing friends in TEH. Alternatively, Sherlock would have to know that John doesn't agree with that because he's actively encouraged Sherlock to embrace that part of life. I would also assume Sherlock would probably to try to hide any real romantic entanglement he may enter into from everyone just like he has hid whatever goes on between him and Irene and between him and Molly.

 

I don't think John or Mycroft needed the phone to know that Sherlock had some sort of feeling for Irene because they observed his reaction when he thought she died. I mean he even composed a song over it, however, even at the end of SiB Mycroft and John are still unsure of what exactly is there from Sherlock's perspective. I'm not sure either and I still wonder if Sherlock knows?

Posted

 

I don't think John or Mycroft needed the phone to know that Sherlock had some sort of feeling for Irene because they observed his reaction when he thought she died. I mean he even composed a song over it, however, even at the end of SiB Mycroft and John are still unsure of what exactly is there from Sherlock's perspective. I'm not sure either and I still wonder if Sherlock knows?

 

Once I tried out an interpretation in which Sherlock knows the body isn't Irene, I really have problems to go back to the POV I believe the makers try to make us believe. :P

Posted

Tbh, and I don't mean this in a Johnlock way, I always saw John as being jealous over Irene getting Sherlock's attention, and also disliking her because he felt she was taking advantage. Just look at how protective he is in the warehouse scene. 

 

John does seem to not like being left out by Sherlock as well, so I can see where you are coming from there. Really, no part of the Irene/Sherlock interaction is good for John's ego- except maybe when she says that he knows where to look, I guess you could see that as a compliment, if you squinted? And I do agree about him being protective of Sherlock in the warehouse, which is quite sweet actually. I think by then he has decided that Irene is bad medicine, which perhaps puts him off Irene, and has the opposite effect on Sherlock.

 

 

...

I do agree that Sherlock holds himself to a standard about a lack of romantic entanglements and he probably assumes that Mycroft would tease him if he succumbed to one like Mycroft teased Sherlock about needing friends in TEH. Alternatively, Sherlock would have to know that John doesn't agree with that because he's actively encouraged Sherlock to embrace that part of life. I would also assume Sherlock would probably to try to hide any real romantic entanglement he may enter into from everyone just like he has hid whatever goes on between him and Irene and between him and Molly.

 

The other thing is, that Mycroft hasn't only teased Sherlock about his knowledge of sex, he's humiliated him a bit about it too- you know, when he's talking about how sex would alarm him. Even Moriarty referred to Sherlock as The Virgin. It's really neither here nor there whether he is or not, but he's certainly not what you would call emotionally mature or experienced in that emotional sense when it comes to women. So for me, part of why Sherlock doesn't want to be shown up on this subject is because he knows it is one he doesn't excel at- it is an achilles heel.

 

He might call it a choice, too, but there is always that possibility that for him women are a bit more difficult to understand than criminal masterminds, and that part of the reason he avoids those sorts of attachments is because he doesn't have much confidence that he'd be good at them. 

 

Whilst he would know John wouldn't judge him for pursuing a relationship, it might also be hard for him to admit to John that he hasn't been the man he's let himself on to be... Plus, again, I don't think he wants John to see him not excelling with women.

 

There's a little bit of that between those two in SiB too, I think... it's not so much about winning Irene, but about each of them wanting to prove that that they could, if they wanted to. Sherlock definitely gets a kick out of being able to charm Janine in TSOT/ HLV too. But charming a woman with an act, or even a show of detection skills, it a totally different thing than being able to have an emotional relationship one, and that's the bit, in my opinion where Sherlock knows he couldn't fake it, the bit where he could be found wanting. You could even ask, why, apart from the desire to remain at least a fraction of a gentleman, did Sherlock never sleep with Janine? My guess is that a small part of him worried he wouldn't be able to stay detached if he did. And also, that she'd realise pretty quickly he was more than a little out of his depth.

  • Like 1
Posted

I think John just felt awkward and confused because Irene walked up to him completely naked and John couldn't help but look at her private parts.

 

I don't think John was jealous or anything. Just extremely embarrassed and confused like most men are after they've seen a women that's completely naked. I think ever since he just acted awkwardly around Irene.

Posted

I'm glad I'm not the only one that saw it that way. I was starting to think I was crazy!

Posted

I don't think he didn't sleep with Janine because he was afraid of becoming attached, it was because he knew that even by his standards it would be a scummy thing to do. Also we still don't know that he's straight. 

 

I didn't see any attraction from John towards Irene, other than aesthetically. Remember the first time they met her she whacked Sherlock with her whip and drugged him. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think he didn't sleep with Janine because he was afraid of becoming attached, it was because he knew that even by his standards it would be a scummy thing to do. Also we still don't know that he's straight. 

 

I didn't see any attraction from John towards Irene, other than aesthetically. Remember the first time they met her she whacked Sherlock with her whip and drugged him. 

 

I always assumed that what we see in Scandal shows that Sherlock at least has an interest in women (if not necessarily straight)? Even the fact that he keeps Irene's phone for sentimental reasons, or writes that piece of music for her?

 

I thought from what Janine said, she wouldn't have minded having a bit of a fling with him, and wouldn't have been too heartbroken if it ended. That's how I took it when she said to him in the hospital, when she said that just once would have been nice. 

 

Yes, I didn't like Irene's behaviour towards Sherlock much, but he seemed to get over it pretty quickly. It would have put me off, certainly. But I only thought John seemed attracted to her (as you say, for aesthetic reasons) just at the beginning of meeting her, that is to say before he got to know her personality. John always seemed to prefer the 'good girls'- well, until Mary. And he did have issues around her not so good past, too.

  • Like 3
Posted

I don't know if Sherlock is attracted to Irene in a typical sense - I think it's more that he finds her fascinating. He's drawn to her, finds her appealing, but I don't know if it's in a romantic/sexual way. If it is I suspect it's more about her brain than her body, in my opinion she could have been male or female, it's the way she operates that really catches him. 

 

I think Janine would have been quite happy sleeping with Sherlock, but it still would have left a bitter taste in her mouth when she realised he was using her.

 

Oh God, if we're not careful this is going to veer back into 'violin fingers' territory again.

 

 

  • Like 3
Posted

I think Moffatiss deliberately try to keep Sherlock's relationship with women ambiguous in order to appease the Johnlockers and the other shipping fans.

 

This is one reason why I dislike shipping . It almost always interferes with characterisation. Is this character gay or straight? We'll never know because the writer doesn't want to displease any of the shippers.

Posted

I like that we'll never know. It's refreshing. 

Posted

I think Moffatiss deliberately try to keep Sherlock's relationship with women ambiguous in order to appease the Johnlockers and the other shipping fans.

 

This is one reason why I dislike shipping . It almost always interferes with characterisation. Is this character gay or straight? We'll never know because the writer doesn't want to displease any of the shippers.

I've never heard of writers of a TV series being so beholden to shippers that it would dictate what they do plotwise. I think this show has always been ambiguous about lots of things, not just Sherlock and women. How Sherlock faked his death is one. Eurus' whole personality is one. It seems more a writing style than anything.

  • Like 2
Posted

I don't really believe Moftiss would change their game-plan for the sake of shippers. 

 

I think they find themselves especially clever when they write things so that they can be interpreted in several different ways.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think he didn't sleep with Janine because he was afraid of becoming attached, it was because he knew that even by his standards it would be a scummy thing to do. Also we still don't know that he's straight.

I agree. He didn't think much of Irene other than as a means to an end.

  • Like 1
Posted

And Scandal was written before TJLC really became a thing. Once it did become a thing, I feel like they started to become less ambiguous ... but by then it was beyond their control.

Posted

 

I've never heard of writers of a TV series being so beholden to shippers that it would dictate what they do plotwise. 

 

 

But Sherlock's sexuality is never really part of the plot. It's simply part of his character that is never fully explored similar to Sherlock's combat abilities. It's just there and it's left vague and mysterious.

 

In the future, I think Moffatiss are always going to keep it vague and mysterious for the reason I already mentioned. 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

 

I've never heard of writers of a TV series being so beholden to shippers that it would dictate what they do plotwise.

 

But Sherlock's sexuality is never really part of the plot. It's simply part of his character that is never fully explored similar to Sherlock's combat abilities. It's just there and it's left vague and mysterious.

 

In the future, I think Moffatiss are always going to keep it vague and mysterious for the reason I already mentioned.

But the only reason for them to be unvague about Sherlock's sexuality is for plot reasons. If they don't intend for Sherlock to be in a romantic relationship, there's no reason for them to define his sexuality. TBH that's why the ILY exchange and subsequent coffin smashing surprised me. By making Sherlock that emotional over a woman, more even than Irene, it was the closest they've gotten to saying Sherlock could be capable of ordinary male sexual/romantic feelings. I still don't think that scene will lead anywhere but it was definitely more than the usual non responses he usually gives so maybe they'd continue to be less vague over time if there are more episodes? Dunno. I do think these writers determine plot first and adjust characterization accordingly.
Posted

Okay, I took advantage of a lull in the posting to finally merge the "Series 4 John" thread with the "regular John" thread ... hope everyone finds it! Discussing John has been popular lately ... poor guy. :p

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

 

I've never heard of writers of a TV series being so beholden to shippers that it would dictate what they do plotwise.

But Sherlock's sexuality is never really part of the plot. It's simply part of his character that is never fully explored similar to Sherlock's combat abilities. It's just there and it's left vague and mysterious.

 

In the future, I think Moffatiss are always going to keep it vague and mysterious for the reason I already mentioned.

But the only reason for them to be unvague about Sherlock's sexuality is for plot reasons. If they don't intend for Sherlock to be in a romantic relationship, there's no reason for them to define his sexuality. 

 

I can similarly argue that there's no reason for them to avoid it either. If Sherlock's sexuality is not planned to be part of the plot then why be so ambiguous about it? Why don't they just state his sexuality and move along? I mean a lot of people would like to know.

 

 

 

TBH that's why the ILY exchange and subsequent coffin smashing surprised me. By making Sherlock that emotional over a woman, more even than Irene, it was the closest they've gotten to saying Sherlock could be capable of ordinary male sexual/romantic feelings. I still don't think that scene will lead anywhere but it was definitely more than the usual non responses he usually gives so maybe they'd continue to be less vague over time if there are more episodes? Dunno. I do think these writers determine plot first and adjust characterization accordingly.

 

I didn't really sense romantic tension in that scene from Sherlock. I just think he was upset because he had been manipulated into taking advantage of Molly's feelings for him.

 

 

Anyway my opinion is based largely around what I've seen in the entertainment industry. It's based on my own observations so I can see why you and others would disagree with it. But I have read about how producers etc sometimes ask writers to add ambiguous romantic things in between their characters to appeal to the shipping crowd.

 

Stuff like romance and sex appeal works really well from a financial standpoint. This is one of the main reasons why the depiction of poor people in the film, TV industry is highly inaccurate. Poor people are meant to look desperate and destitute but when was the last time you saw a poor person depicted like that within the main cast of a film or TV show?

 

In most cases, poor people (that are part of the main cast) in the film and TV industry look nothing like poor people in real life. They're always fairly good looking. A good example of that would be the characters from those districts from The Hunger Games that were supposed to be in poverty.

 

One of the main reasons behind this inaccurate portrayal is for sex appeal. Quite a number of people watch films and TV shows that they don't even like just because they think the lead actors and actresses are pretty. I wouldn't even be surprised if some people who watch Sherlock don't even care about the story and just watch it because they think Cumberbatch and Freeman are handsome.

Posted

Count me as the happiest person to see the discussion is out in the open now. And there are lots of things said since my last post, so it's good to be able to see, and I can come back as fast as possible.

 

 

As an aside, does anyone else find John's behaviour at the party really irritating? When Sherlock gets the parcel from Irene and goes off to his room John is all 'who's the parcel from Sherlock? What's wrong Sherlock? Where are you going Sherlock?' If I were Sherlock I'd be telling him to back the f**k off, but then I'm probably even more antisocial than he is.

His questions were probably his way to ask "what's wrong, Sherlock?", because even he noticed something was… at least unusual.

Yes, like you, I find John's behavior annoying as well, but I understand that John picked up something unusual like J.P said, therefore he was more persistent there.

 

However :p, personally, I find it more irritating because I usually retract myself whenever I don't feel good, in trouble or something is wrong. So having someone around who picks up on that at that very moment is irritating (but I am well aware that is a good thing, that person cares and actually understands you better). It's just that I prefer to be left alone because having the attention that you know something is wrong and try to help may break the exoskeleton or show my emotions and that's not something that I want to do willingly. And the only way to avoid that situation is by leaving the scene, so, in this case, shutting the door since he was already so close.

I am sure, John, bless him there, was going to demand more and more explanation if Sherlock attempts to get away without being rude, because he cared. So shutting door is what he does although it seems rude.

 

 

...

The best way to test it out would probably be some inconspicuous detail, like Lestrade has a a third nipple or something, and to get all the writers from across the various shipping factions to agree to add it in, and then see it it ever made it on to the show.

 

...

 

I think Sherlock was having the worst party ever. It also seemed to annoy him that Molly mentioned he was upset about John leaving for Christmas- though he more than got his own back.

:D at third nipple, it's probably not easy to incorporate it in the stories though. :p But I haven't read any fan-fiction, for all I know, it's probably full of nipples and ships. Ship full of nipples, or whatev. :p GAH.

 

I remember we did have discussion and I had bunch of reasons about why Sherlock seems very upset in that party, especially at Molly. Not sure where it is, maybe in SIB thread. Basically because Molly blabbers a lot about him. Nothing wrong, it's just girl in love thingy and she tried to get his attention. But Sherlock wasn't aware and annoyed, which is understandable from his PoV there.

 

 

.... Though I'm curious why you feel the coffin scene would affect John's decision about Molly either way?

Can't speak for VBS, but seems to me that hearing Sherlock and Molly say "I love you" to each other would -- minimally -- make John stop and think before putting the move on Molly. Guys seem to have an unwritten code against dating a friend's gal, or gal the friend has his eye on, or even the friend's ex-gal.

Regarding the unwritten guy code, I agree it exists but does Molly qualify as that gal for Sherlock?

Carol has a point, it's part of my reason, some kind of bro code.

But to add to that, that scene is deeper. Sherlock was crushed and broken. It was a vivisection. Whatever feelings he has for Molly, we don't know for sure, I don't think he knows as well, that scene destroys him emotionally. Now that he is forced to do that, there will be a lot of questions for him, Molly, what it is about, where is it going, and how they handle that. The only, possibly, ideal way is that they end up together, BUT, that won't be the case, at least not in Sherlock's mind at that moment, that's why he was so crushed because he realizes that is actually something not reversible. He could say anything to anyone; insult, condemn, make fun, chastise or indirectly saying something endearing but he never ever ever say things like that because I am sure, he doesn't know how to process that yet. It is still the currency he doesn't know how to use, and he is forced to do that in quite brutal ways. To me, there is every reason of why that coffin is in pieces.

 

And John witnessing that, whatever and where this might go, he should know that Molly means something to Sherlock, not sure if it's really romance or anything, but Sherlock's outburst should show that she has special position, somewhere dear to him. It is possible for someone to care and appreciate another in special way without the needs of it being romantic, and I think Sherlock has that for Molly. And John knows almost exactly how Molly feels to Sherlock, so yah, he should never, especially after that coffin scene.

  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 114 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.