Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Toby, I see your point, but I e.g. needed a clear subtext explanation to be able to look at the story from this perspective. And it's another show from the one I fell in love with.

That's fine. But some people do see it that way, and that's fine too. It's all fine. We don't all have to be watching precisely the same show in order to have an interesting discussion about it. In fact, I doubt that any two of us are watching precisely the same show.

  • Like 1
Posted

As far as I see it everyone is entitled to their interpretation and can enjoy the show in their own way. It's when they start actively attacking the creators, particularly one for being a 'traitor' to his sexuality, that it becomes wrong. 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Seriously, it may have sounded that way, but I don't mean to imply that interpretations "can't" take place, I just mean what you said ... admit that's all they are. That's what Moftiss have done re: Doyle, I don't think it would harm the fans of their work to do likewise for them.

 

 

 

And for those of us who are not part of TJLC.  I guess I've criticized those who espouse that view, although I have limited my remarks basically to this forum, where I think we have intelligent people willing to have what amounts to a literary discussion of a TV show.  (Which, BTW, is really cool, y'all, and thank you!)

 

But sometimes I feel a little attacked by those who are strong proponents of TJLC when I read their perspective off this forum, that somehow it's not OK to watch the show and simply see a deep and uncommon friendship that has no sexual component -- that it's not OK to believe Moftiss when they say that the relationship is not heading for a sexual resolution. The fact is that reading/hearing too much of TJLC lessens my enjoyment of the show because it forces me to try to see the show through a lens that doesn't feel comfortable and authentic to me and one that doesn't match up with my own experiences and worldview.  The people who do have that perspective are welcome to have it and to enjoy the show through that lens, but I think I balk because I want to feel just as supported by the fandom in enjoying the show in the way that requires fewer mental gymnastics and allows more relaxation for me.  

 

(And yes, the answer is for me to stay out of TJLC sites other than this fun discussion, and that's what I try to do.  I'm just sayin'.)

  • Like 3
Posted

Before you try to explain to me how all this proves nothing: I know. I know, I know, I know. I was just trying to point out why I think it is totally understandable that fans who already wanted the boys to be in love and came to the series with that wish got their hopes up. The story is told like a romance. I totally agree that nowhere does it say anything about sex or sexual attraction, but from prior viewing / reading experiences, I think we are used to associate romance with sex, so jumping to that conclusion isn't entirely preposterous. As for intent: Sorry, but if you are a professional author and you don't intend to write a romance, then don't. You should know at least a little about how this works. I can go around calling people idiots and protest as much as I like that I didn't intend it to be an insult, but as long as people can prove I actually speak English, my argument is going to be kind of weak.

 

Well, I think you've said the words that I have often felt I am not allowed to say: "fans who already wanted the boys to be in love." Typically, when anyone comes close to saying something like that, there are cries of "but I didn't want it, I just saw it!" Well, I didn't want it either, and I didn't see it. Soooo ... there's that. No point in arguing it.

 

But what I really came here to say was ... I don't agree that those are romantic tropes you are describing. Or to be more accurate, some of them can be ... but are not necessarily. They can serve other purposes too. Just to grab the first one I came across: "prancing around his brother's quarters in full peacock mode asking whether his shirt is okay. Yeah, that's... totally what I always thought guy-bros do before meeting up." Well, that is exactly what Sherlock does, isn't it? He's always fussy about his clothes. They're perfectly tailored. He turns his collar up to look cool. Dresses up (sort of) to meet Irene. Mutters "into battle" when putting on his morning suit, as if it were armor. Because he's one of those people for whom how he looks helps define who he is. Not to impress John, but to impress everybody, including himself. He'd been gone from his world for two years, he wanted to go back into it as who he projects himself to be. I seriously think he would have taken the same care dressing if he'd just decided to take a walk first and had no plans to find John. In fact, now that I think of it, that's what I do when I return from vacation; dress my best the first time I go out to the places I haven't been in awhile. It fortifies me, somehow. So I don't see a romantic trope of "dressing his best to meet his lover" -- I see a more subtle trope of putting on his disguise -- his armor -- before he faces the entire world.

 

(And also, I think that scene was more about him and Mycroft than him and John. He pretended not to take the threat seriously, because it annoyed Mycroft. Period. As we found out later, he took it very seriously.)

 

So now that you've pointed out the "romantic" interpretation, I can see that too. But it doesn't sit right with me, because it doesn't fit with the other things I've observed about Sherlock and John. And it doesn't fit with my observations of real men who are "just" friends. I've witnessed some pretty close male friendships, and yes, a straight man can feel sad or abandoned when his straight best bud gets married. Yes, a straight man can get jealous when his straight best friend is suddenly close friends with a different man (or even with a woman). The writers even make it a point that Sherlock sees a parallel between himself and the good soldier, Sholto; so yes, of course he would sacrifice himself for his comrade-in-arms (your "damsel in distress"), John. It's what good soldiers do.

 

See my point? When you point out a different interpretation of a scene, I can see it; but it's not "obvious." To me, other interpretations are far more obvious. Because I am who I am, of course. Doesn't mean I'm right. Doesn't mean I'm wrong, either. (This is why it's so hard for people to get along --- different perceptions of the same thing!) But I simply can't agree that the story is told as a romance and be done with it .... because I perceive something else going on. A love story, yes. But not a romance. And that's nothing new. Old Yeller is a love story. So is To Kill a Mockingbird, or Lord of the Rings. But none of those are romances; not in the sense we're using the word.

 

Just imagine one of the guys was a gal. Are you sure you would still be so adamant about "just friends"?

Good question, one I don't know the answer to. It's easy to assume that I, as a heterosexual female, would see "more than friendship" between characters of the opposite sex, but I can't be sure that's actually true ... because I'm familiar with stories where the male and female leads were never, in fact, "together", and I bought it; because I never saw anything else in the story to suggest they were together. But I will be the first to admit that I am not predisposed to see romance in every pairing; I'm a little too cynical for that, I'm afraid.

 

For some reason the only example I can think of at the moment is The DaVinci Code (a movie I didn't even like that much). I never assumed the leads would become a couple, even though they were guy and gal; and I saw nothing on screen that would have made me think otherwise. Of course, I don't think they were ever close friends either, so it's not a parallel situation to Sherlock. (Is there anything that is? :smile: ) But it's the best example I can come up with at the moment.

 

Still, given my background, yeah, a female/male pairing would probably be easier for me to ship. But if Moftiss really "wanted" us to see a romance story, I also think they would have put a little more effort into it for doofs like me who can't find their way out of the toilet without a map. :P

  • Like 2
Posted

 

But sometimes I feel a little attacked by those who are strong proponents of TJLC when I read their perspective off this forum, that somehow it's not OK to watch the show and simply see a deep and uncommon friendship that has no sexual component -- that it's not OK to believe Moftiss when they say that the relationship is not heading for a sexual resolution. The fact is that reading/hearing too much of TJLC lessens my enjoyment of the show because it forces me to try to see the show through a lens that doesn't feel comfortable and authentic to me and one that doesn't match up with my own experiences and worldview.  The people who do have that perspective are welcome to have it and to enjoy the show through that lens, but I think I balk because I want to feel just as supported by the fandom in enjoying the show in the way that requires fewer mental gymnastics and allows more relaxation for me.  

 

(And yes, the answer is for me to stay out of TJLC sites other than this fun discussion, and that's what I try to do.  I'm just sayin'.)

 

 

Yep. I don't expect anyone to remember, but I even complained about something similar a little while back; when I started encountering TJLC en masse, I felt my gender was under attack. That the problem with Mary, for example, was not that she was a rival; she was a female rival, and that was somehow wrong.

 

I can only imagine, though, that there are some of the same feelings on the other side. People who think the "non-believers" are denying Johnlock because it's wrong for two men to be lovers. And maybe some of us do think that (I haven't seen it around here, but it's bound to be out there.)

 

So ... there we are. Not much chance for one big happy resolution, methinks. That's only in the fairytales. But I think I like Pseud's point the best. Believe what you want ... just be civil about it.

 

And this has been one helluva cool conversation, chock full of ideas. Thanks, ladies!

  • Like 4
Posted

*I drink tea minimum 3 cups a day for more than ten years but I'm still bloody straight. My tea must be broken.

 

 

Agree with Pseu, Boton and Arcadia's posts.

 

@Toby's post.

All those appear as nothing more than friendship to me, special one, yes, because it is Sherlock, who just gets the hang of it, and he is Sherlock. Merely friendship, not romance in that way.

 

But you did explain how they see it, it makes sense I think.

I just hope that it's totally reasonable that 'don't see it' makes sense too. That's why I believe the creator's intention is not as mean as what they are accused to be. Insensitive, I don't know, maybe, but to be honest, I don't blame them. It's pretty hard to feel what is sensitive or not nowadays, because I am struggling with it. Sometimes I feel I can't say anything at all to certain people, because they would take offense to everything I say.

 

If that is naive, why not, I am happy to see at least there are many who think the same.

Like I said, I feel bad I couldn't see that it's so devastating for some. I just need to learn that, but all the same, I think it's not totally laughable that some of us see nothing but friendship.

 

I get also that both sides may view each other as wrong, ridiculous, naive or whatever, and go at it I say, nicely though, and healthily. This may not be 'just a show' for some, but it's not worth hurting yourself mentally and physically I say.

And I will still defend that the creators and actors don't deserve all those abuses.

  • Like 4
Posted

And one more thing I wanted to say ... does everyone else really think stories about male friendships are all that rare? That's odd to me, because it seems that's almost the only kind of stories there were when I was a young, impressionable tot. To me, the idea of straight but close male friends is as commonplace as ... well, male/female romances. I think I mostly watched Westerns as a child (but that's because they had horses, so I may have missed something. XD) And then there was Starsky and Hutch, and the Die Hard movies, and assorted war films that I can't recall the name of right now. I do remember a scene from the TV show Combat where a character cried because his friend was killed; that made a big impression on me. (Men can cry????) And of course, my dad and my brothers had close male friends; some of them still stay in touch with me simply because that friendship was so close. So I'm really surprised by the idea that the friendship between Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson is something rare. What did I miss?

 

And two likes for your post, VBS! Gently, gently, as Moftiss would say.... :d

  • Like 3
Posted

 

But I will be the first to admit that I am not predisposed to see romance in every pairing; I'm a little too cynical for that, I'm afraid.

I would say you are a great romantic who don't like triviality. ;)

 

PS: Re the looks John seems to give Sherlock (at least at the numerous gifs): What I always see is: "Damn, it's amazing that I haven't killed him yet!"

  • Like 3
Posted

Why, thank you! I will accept that as a compliment. :smile:
 
I was thinking John's looks were more "I am going to kill you....." :D

  • Like 1
Posted

And one more thing I wanted to say ... does everyone else really think stories about male friendships are all that rare? That's odd to me, because it seems that's almost the only kind of stories there were when I was a young, impressionable tot. To me, the idea of straight but close male friends is as commonplace as ... well, male/female romances. 

 

And two likes for your post, VBS! Gently, gently, as Moftiss would say.... :D

 

I don't think they are rare, but I think they have become somewhat less common, and I think our cultural definition of what is "masculine" without being homoerotic has narrowed somewhat.  (To take a very well-worn example, ACD's Holmes and Watson could walk around arm in arm; men don't do that today without there being "subtext.") So, I think maybe we are culturally just a little bit more primed to see a romantic/sexual relationship (boy, we need a word for that) and say, "that's fine" than we are to see a deep friendship.

 

That said, I think the Sherlock and John relationship is supposed to be uncommonly close.  We are supposed to understand that they are closer than married couples, closer than soldiers from the trenches, closer than brothers -- closer than anyone has ever been.  And I think that is part of the "romance" subtext -- to emphasize that they are closer than any other relationship we could compare them to.

 

 

 

 

But I will be the first to admit that I am not predisposed to see romance in every pairing; I'm a little too cynical for that, I'm afraid.

I would say you are a great romantic who don't like triviality. ;)

 

PS: Re the looks John seems to give Sherlock (at least at the numerous gifs): What I always see is: "Damn, it's amazing that I haven't killed him yet!"

 

 

See, and that's part of the subtext that I think gets ignored.  Part of the "subtext joke" even comes out in SiB, when John is getting ready to throttle Sherlock and says, "I always hear 'punch me in the face' when you're talking, but that's subtext."  There's a little bit of Moftiss poking fun at the romantic subtext by literally having John say, "I don't see it," in the same way he can have Irene say that they (S&J) are a couple, and John says, "just in case anyone cares, I'm not gay!"  

 

I think part of this debate arises not just because of what people want to see or what they do see based on their own experience and worldview, but also because of the relatively small amount of information we have over the course of 15 hours of content.  In that time, we have been expected to learn how Sherlock and John are with each other and how that is the same or different from how they are with other people.  Other than TBB, we haven't had time for that; we have to focus on them together, because that is the primary relationship in the show and that's what we have time for. That kind of artificially concentrates the interactions and leaves more to interpretation.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

And one more thing I wanted to say ... does everyone else really think stories about male friendships are all that rare? That's odd to me, because it seems that's almost the only kind of stories there were when I was a young, impressionable tot. To me, the idea of straight but close male friends is as commonplace as ... well, male/female romances. 

 

And two likes for your post, VBS! Gently, gently, as Moftiss would say.... :D

 

I don't think they are rare, but I think they have become somewhat less common, and I think our cultural definition of what is "masculine" without being homoerotic has narrowed somewhat.  (To take a very well-worn example, ACD's Holmes and Watson could walk around arm in arm; men don't do that today without there being "subtext.") So, I think maybe we are culturally just a little bit more primed to see a romantic/sexual relationship (boy, we need a word for that) and say, "that's fine" than we are to see a deep friendship.

 

Well, as you may have guessed, that's part of what I was getting at -- I wonder if a younger crowd is more inclined to think their relationship is "too close" to be just friends, because they had fewer examples of male friendships growing up than an old geezer like me. And of course, I recognize that younger generations than mine are more accustomed to seeing openly gay relationships.

 

But it does seem to me that in the process of accepting different romantic couplings, we have also diminished the value of friendship along the way. When everything is viewed through the lens of sexual orientation, it's hard to appreciate other nuances. That's a shame, really. Still, I wouldn't go back to the old days for anything. In order to gain something, you have to lose something, I guess. Equivalent exchange and all that.

 

That said, I think the Sherlock and John relationship is supposed to be uncommonly close.  We are supposed to understand that they are closer than married couples, closer than soldiers from the trenches, closer than brothers -- closer than anyone has ever been.  And I think that is part of the "romance" subtext -- to emphasize that they are closer than any other relationship we could compare them to.

That's another thing that sort of surprises me ... I don't see them as "uncommonly" close. In fact, before season 3, I didn't even think they were particularly close. John clearly had his own life and other friends, for example; I didn't get the impression he hung around the flat waiting for Sherlock to get up so they could go do something together.

 

After S3, they were obviously closer, because a traumatic experience does that to people. And I can't deny that Sherlock appears to have taken the label of "best friend" to heart a little more than the average bloke. But still, I think it does correlate exactly to the kind of friendships you mention; "brothers-in-arms" being the most relevant one for me. They're walking the battlefields together; that's a pretty strong bond; especially for men, I think. But I don't see them transcending that. At least, not yet.

 

But I suppose that still comes down to my background; in this case, growing up with the Vietnam War on our TV screens every night. Those guys literally went through hell for each other, what John and Sherlock have been through is a cakewalk by comparison. Maybe that's the difference; S&J are close from choice, not circumstances? Hmmmm, maybe.

  • Like 1
Posted

I cannot remember particular male friendship fiction from my youth, but there had to be something, because I do remember my best friend mentioning that she's jealous of male friendships because they are free from BS that female friendships are full of. And I remember me agreeing with her. :D

Posted

 

 

 

That said, I think the Sherlock and John relationship is supposed to be uncommonly close.  We are supposed to understand that they are closer than married couples, closer than soldiers from the trenches, closer than brothers -- closer than anyone has ever been.  And I think that is part of the "romance" subtext -- to emphasize that they are closer than any other relationship we could compare them to.

 

That's another thing that sort of surprises me ... I don't see them as "uncommonly" close. In fact, before season 3, I didn't even think they were particularly close. John clearly had his own life and other friends, for example; I didn't get the impression he hung around the flat waiting for Sherlock to get up so they could go do something together.

 

After S3, they were obviously closer, because a traumatic experience does that to people. And I can't deny that Sherlock appears to have taken the label of "best friend" to heart a little more than the average bloke. But still, I think it does correlate exactly to the kind of friendships you mention; "brothers-in-arms" being the most relevant one for me. They're walking the battlefields together; that's a pretty strong bond; especially for men, I think. But I don't see them transcending that. At least, not yet.

 

But I suppose that still comes down to my background; in this case, growing up with the Vietnam War on our TV screens every night. Those guys literally went through hell for each other, what John and Sherlock have been through is a cakewalk by comparison. Maybe that's the difference; S&J are close from choice, not circumstances? Hmmmm, maybe.

 

 

I actually am in agreement with you.  I have been doing a lot of reading about trench warfare in WWI, and what those men went through together absolutely has to have created bonds that were stronger than any other bond that a person could form; that level of trauma binds two people in a certain way.  And I think that's analogous to what Sherlock and John have, but I don't think they have been through that level of stress.

 

I think we are supposed to be viewing the evolution of a bond like this, because we start with the meeting and work our way toward what we see in S3, culminating with the waterfall scene in TAB, which, to me, symbolizes Sherlock's realization that he doesn't have to confront his own demons without John to support him.  That's where things start to get to a level of friendship that I think is, at least, not typical for many people, although certainly  not something completely inaccessible.  

 

And it's like you say, S&J have also chosen one another.  They just click; they are able to tolerate and compensate for each other's foibles in ways that maybe other people can't.  I don't think John particularly needs to hang around the flat waiting for Sherlock for entertainment; the reverse is also true.  But they have a baseline comfort level with one another before they start confronting Moriarty and kind of "seeing the battlefield" together.  That differentiates it from many (although not all) wartime relationships for me and just gives the S&J relationship a little extra level of bond.  But I don't in any way think that means that you couldn't find that kind of relationship among men you know if you just looked for it.

 

ETA:  I realize my statements are a bit contradictory regarding the uncommon bond.  I think what I'm trying to clarify, for myself too, is that we aren't necessarily seeing the full depth of the friendship yet in Sherlock, and certainly not before S3, but that we know that Holmes and Watson across the incarnations become what Moftiss have called "the two best friends ever."  They may have arrived at that point in their late 40s/early 50s, though, and not in their late 30s, like we are seeing now.  But the seeds are there.

  • Like 3
Posted

I cannot remember particular male friendship fiction from my youth, but there had to be something, because I do remember my best friend mentioning that she's jealous of male friendships because they are free from BS that female friendships are full of. And I remember me agreeing with her. :D

 

Y'know, I remember my best friend saying the same kind of thing to me once. But in my case I didn't relate, because we weren't that way, as far as I knew (God, I hope I wasn't bitchy to her and just didn't realize it!) But I knew what she meant, though, because I saw how other girls sometimes treated each other; the taunting about hair and makeup, e.g., which we simply weren't into. (Gammas, both of us. Surprise.)

 

On the other side; I remember my dad made a really deep impression on me once by saying he preferred to be in the company of women. When I asked why, he said it was because he liked the way we thought about things; we tossed ideas around, teasing them into shape. Men, he said, tended to prefer being competitive. Also they talked a lot rougher than when women were present.

 

Of course, it doesn't hurt to bear in mind that most of the women were his fellow teachers, and most of the men were the teacher's husbands. Still, I've never forgotten that. I was about 20; it was a real empowering thing to hear from my dad.

  • Like 2
Posted

They just click; they are able to tolerate and compensate for each other's foibles in ways that maybe other people can't.  I don't think John particularly needs to hang around the flat waiting for Sherlock for entertainment; the reverse is also true.  But they have a baseline comfort level with one another before they start confronting Moriarty and kind of "seeing the battlefield" together.  That differentiates it from many (although not all) wartime relationships for me and just gives the S&J relationship a little extra level of bond.  But I don't in any way think that means that you couldn't find that kind of relationship among men you know if you just looked for it.

 

Also bear in mind that we're seeing far more of their feelings for each other (e.g., John at Sherlock's grave) than we would ever be allowed to see in real life.  Men tend to hide their feelings, just as John waited till Mrs. Hudson was out of earshot before having his say.

 

... I saw how other girls sometimes treated each other; the taunting about hair and makeup, e.g., which we simply weren't into. (Gammas, both of us. Surprise.)

 

Gammas?

  • Like 1
Posted

Gammas?

Sorry, I've seen better articles, but you'll get the gist from this one... http://blablawriting.com/alpha-beta-and-gamma-the-divisions-of-girl-world-essay

Ah, I see.  Sounds like I was a Beta wannabe, till I figured out that simply wasn't working and became a Gamma wannabe.

Posted

Gah, one link just leads to another .... (get out of my head, Sherlock, I'm busy!) I've been wondering why this whole TJLC thing was so irritating to me ... if I don't like it, why don't I ignore it? But I stumbled across this on (god help me) Tumblr, and I think they nailed it:

 

On a conceptual level, by claiming canonicity TJLCers are taking power away from other interpretations and from the authors themselves. No wonder there are arguments surrounding our interactions with other non-TJLC fans and with the creators.

It's not the theory itself that annoys, it's the insistence that it's canon, isn't it? Well, I think that's what it is for me. 

 

If you want to read the whole discussion (my advice, don't bother, you've heard it all already) it's here: (I think. O Tumblr Tumblr, why for art thou so confusing?)

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

Gammas?

Sorry, I've seen better articles, but you'll get the gist from this one... http://blablawriting.com/alpha-beta-and-gamma-the-divisions-of-girl-world-essay

 

Ah, I see.  Sounds like I was a Beta wannabe, till I figured out that simply wasn't working and became a Gamma wannabe.

 

I don't like that article because it takes sides; it makes the alphas sound bad and the gammas sound superior; which I don't think was the original intent of the theory. But still, it gives you the idea.
  • Like 1
Posted

Hm, don't know what I was. According to the article I'd be a beta, but since I didn't want or try to fit in I wouldn't agree with that. But then I wouldn't have been a gamma because I wasn't into extracurricular clubs and activities. Hm, I don't think I fit into any of them. 

Posted

For me, it's not exactly the claiming that it's canon, it's the claiming that they know what Moftiss have been intending to do all along, and if Moftiss claim that's not so, then they must be lying, because there is only one possible interpretation.

 

There's always another interpretation.  That's what keeps the world interesting.

 

Though as I understand it (not very well), the actual crux of the TJLC matter is the additional claim that if Moftiss have actually never intended to get Sherlock and John "together," then they're clearly "queerbaiting."  (I had trouble typing that word, being from a generation that considers the word "queer" to be a blatant insult.  And yes, I know, it's been repurposed.)  Again, they're claiming to know what's in Moftiss's hearts and minds, which strikes me as a bit of mind-police activity.  I do not deny that it's one possible interpretation of what we've seen -- but I consider it improbable, especially since Mr. Gatiss is not only gay himself, he's something of an activist.  Can't imagine that he'd be a party to that sort of nonsense.

  • Like 2
Posted

Hm, don't know what I was. According to the article I'd be a beta, but since I didn't want or try to fit in I wouldn't agree with that. But then I wouldn't have been a gamma because I wasn't into extracurricular clubs and activities. Hm, I don't think I fit into any of them.

There's a quiz: http://www.allthetests.com/quiz01/dasquiztd.php3?testid=1022689538 It even gave me the right answer. ;) (but who are some of those people?)

Posted

Well, according to the quiz I'm gamma, though on a lot of the questions none of the answers were relevant to me. Like the shoes question; wedge heels, flip flops, tennis shoes or Birkenstocks. None of the above. Docs, I live in Docs. I watch none of the TV shows, read none of the magazines, do none of the after school (after work?) activities. None of them were relevant when I was a kid either. Ah well. 

Posted

For me, it's not exactly the claiming that it's canon, it's the claiming that they know what Moftiss have been intending to do all along, and if Moftiss claim that's not so, then they must be lying, because there is only one possible interpretation.

 

There's always another interpretation.  That's what keeps the world interesting.

 

Though as I understand it (not very well), the actual crux of the TJLC matter is the additional claim that if Moftiss have actually never intended to get Sherlock and John "together," then they're clearly "queerbaiting."  (I had trouble typing that word, being from a generation that considers the word "queer" to be a blatant insult.  And yes, I know, it's been repurposed.)  Again, they're claiming to know what's in Moftiss's hearts and minds, which strikes me as a bit of mind-police activity.  I do not deny that it's one possible interpretation of what we've seen -- but I consider it improbable, especially since Mr. Gatiss is not only gay himself, he's something of an activist.  Can't imagine that he'd be a party to that sort of nonsense.

 

Or Ben either, given his oft-voiced support for gay men.

 

When I found that quote, there was another dialog nearby that included something like this; if TJLC isn't true, then John is a bad person. If TJLC is true, then the story is about his journey out of the closet and into Sherlock's arms. But if it isn't true, then John is just a jerk who doesn't care that Sherlock is in love with him. At which point I stopped reading and started screaming "But there's no proof Sherlock is in love with him, you git!!!!" Tumblr is definitely bad for my blood pressure.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Well, according to the quiz I'm gamma, though on a lot of the questions none of the answers were relevant to me. Like the shoes question; wedge heels, flip flops, tennis shoes or Birkenstocks. None of the above. Docs, I live in Docs. I watch none of the TV shows, read none of the magazines, do none of the after school (after work?) activities. None of them were relevant when I was a kid either. Ah well. 

I suspect the only question where the answer matters is the last one. ;)

 

I've seen it broken down like this:

 

Alphas: popular

Betas: want to be Alphas

Gammas: don't care

 

:smile:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.