Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

When I found that quote, there was another dialog nearby that included something like this; if TJLC isn't true, then John is a bad person. If TJLC is true, then the story is about his journey out of the closet and into Sherlock's arms. But if it isn't true, then John is just a jerk who doesn't care that Sherlock is in love with him. At which point I stopped reading and started screaming "But there's no proof Sherlock is in love with him, you git!!!!" Tumblr is definitely bad for my blood pressure.

 

But hey, it saves so much time to assume that the point you're trying to prove is true!

 

Thanks for the quiz link.  Even though (or possibly because) I couldn't answer about half of the questions -- as you say, who are these people? -- it labeled me a gamma.  Which I mind a heck of a lot less than either of their alternatives.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

When I found that quote, there was another dialog nearby that included something like this; if TJLC isn't true, then John is a bad person. If TJLC is true, then the story is about his journey out of the closet and into Sherlock's arms. But if it isn't true, then John is just a jerk who doesn't care that Sherlock is in love with him. At which point I stopped reading and started screaming "But there's no proof Sherlock is in love with him, you git!!!!" Tumblr is definitely bad for my blood pressure.

You may have oversimplified or misrepresented that, of course, due to not understanding it.  But let's assume for the sake of argument that Sherlock is indeed in love with John, but the feeling is not reciprocated.  How does that make John a bad person?  Is it his duty to somehow become gay (or bi) just to make Sherlock happy?  Or maybe the complaint is that he hasn't expressed his sympathy to Sherlock.  How do we know that he hasn't?  That would be kind of a private conversation, after all.  (And frankly, I doubt it'd turn out much more satisfactorily than the greenhouse scene in TAB.)  So once again, I don't understand the TJLC position, at least as you've outlined it.

 

I think the main problem here is that many of us have been so dismissive of the idea that anyone who finds it convincing or even intriguing might be hesitant to speak up.  It'd be like me having the guts to explain my objections on a TJLC forum.  So of course we aren't having much of a dialog.  There's that damned polarization again.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I think the main problem here is that many of us have been so dismissive of the idea that anyone who finds it convincing or even intriguing might be hesitant to speak up. It'd be like me having the guts to explain my objections on a TJLC forum. So of course we aren't having much of a dialog. There's that damned polarization again.

I think so too, I don't mind good intention debate, it would be interesting. However I doubt that there would be any conclusion. It could be just fun discussion and agree to disagree. I still always keep my mind open for convincing though, even when it's clear where I stand now, I always allow good reasonable windows to change my mind. I appreciate the exercise, but good exercise.

 

@Arcadia, no offense, eh wrong, I meant, full offense: your quiz sucks. :)

  • Like 2
Posted

 

When I found that quote, there was another dialog nearby that included something like this; if TJLC isn't true, then John is a bad person. If TJLC is true, then the story is about his journey out of the closet and into Sherlock's arms. But if it isn't true, then John is just a jerk who doesn't care that Sherlock is in love with him. At which point I stopped reading and started screaming "But there's no proof Sherlock is in love with him, you git!!!!" Tumblr is definitely bad for my blood pressure.

You may have oversimplified or misrepresented that, of course, due to not understanding it.  But let's assume for the sake of argument that Sherlock is indeed in love with John, but the feeling is not reciprocated.  How does that make John a bad person?  Is it his duty to somehow become gay (or bi) just to make Sherlock happy?  Or maybe the complaint is that he hasn't expressed his sympathy to Sherlock.  How do we know that he hasn't?  That would be kind of a private conversation, after all.  (And frankly, I doubt it'd turn out much more satisfactorily than the greenhouse scene in TAB.)  So once again, I don't understand the TJLC position, at least as you've outlined it.

 

Why do you think I started screaming at it? :P There's no understanding it because there's no logic to it! gaah.gif *pant pant pant*

 

Ahem.

 

To be fair, this was one of the more circular reasonings I've come across. I'll see if I can find it again (trembles fearfully) and you can take a look, if you want. There's some well thought out comments on that particular page. This wasn't one of them. :P

 

 

I think the main problem here is that many of us have been so dismissive of the idea that anyone who finds it convincing or even intriguing might be hesitant to speak up. It'd be like me having the guts to explain my objections on a TJLC forum. So of course we aren't having much of a dialog. There's that damned polarization again.

I think so too, I don't mind good intention debate, it would be interesting. However I doubt that there would be any conclusion. It could be just fun discussion and agree to disagree. I still always keep my mind open for convincing though, even when it's clear where I stand now, I always allow good reasonable windows to change my mind. I appreciate the exercise, but good exercise.

 

I guess that's why I keep reading these things when I run into them; I'm curious how people think, or something. I even toy with the idea of engaging with them; then I read a comment like the one I refer to above, and am glad I don't. That is not something I, at least, can reason with; I'd just get annoyed. Best to stay on my side of the fence for now, imho. What's that phrase? Good fences make good neighbors? :smile:

 

@Arcadia, no offense, eh wrong, I meant, full offense: your quiz sucks. :)

Why thank you, offense taken! How generous. I'll stick it under the next conspiracy argument that ticks me off and enjoy the fireworks. :D

 

Srsly, you'll get no argument from me on that one; I chose most of my answers at random.  But I'll bet if we were all still teenagers, it would make perfect sense. :P

Posted

... I'll bet if we were all still teenagers, it would make perfect sense. :P

Uh, no, if we were *still* teenagers, we'd still know the bands and celebrities from back when things were cool B) -- not the (I assume) current ones.

Posted

Oh lord, guys, I would really love to jump into this discussion, but I have to go to work and later continue to fix up my new apartment (yup, I am moving and will soon no longer live alone, YAY!).

 

Just one quick note: Everyone who "doesn't see it", that's FINE! I wasn't trying to force a certain interpretation that the makers I believe really never intended on anybody, just trying to point out in a slightly provocative manner why I consider it naive for a professional writer / showmaker to be surprised that some fans came to expect a romantic conclusion. (And in this light, I also consider it slightly rude and unfair to call these people absurd, but then I also understand how frustrating it must be to have people tell you you mean A when you actually mean B and if you don't mean A you are wrong, so I guess a little backlash is understandable.)

 

More later... Much later. In the meantime: Have fun and please don't be mad at me. :) To you all and :hugz:

  • Like 4
Posted

Hey, Tobe, can't speak for anyone else, but I understood you the first time. So no apologies needed.

 

Dare I ask who you'll soon be living *with*?

Posted

 

... I'll bet if we were all still teenagers, it would make perfect sense. :P

Uh, no, if we were *still* teenagers, we'd still know the bands and celebrities from back when things were cool B) -- not the (I assume) current ones.

 

Hey, speak for yourself. If I were still a teen I'd be so mod I'd know the bands before they were even formed. :metal:

 

 

Hey, Tobe, can't speak for anyone else, but I understood you the first time. So no apologies needed.

Okay, now you can speak for me too. :smile:

 

ETA: Oops, I forgot ... I found the link to the opinion I referenced above (y'know, about John being a jerk if TJLC isn't true.) http://isitandwonder.tumblr.com/post/148342911186/the-john-watson-problem Read on if you dare.

Posted

 

 

... I'll bet if we were all still teenagers, it would make perfect sense. :P

Uh, no, if we were *still* teenagers, we'd still know the bands and celebrities from back when things were cool B) -- not the (I assume) current ones.
Hey, speak for yourself. If I were still a teen I'd be so mod I'd know the bands before they were even formed. :metal:
Eh, if I were still a teen I wouldn't know that much about those bands as well. I remember those 'popular' kids or so they think were being so hyped about some singers and spreading creepy laughs while flirting with boys and happily being chased by 'bra snapper' while I was busy giving death glare, whoever dared to even try, I'd whack their faces with teacher's wooden giant ruler.

The craze for the singer and bra snapping somehow exist together in my memory, not really sure why. I think this group of teens in my time always tried to be trendsetters in ridiculous stuffs.

 

Eh, I think that's why I was not 'hip' :p. But I was always safe. :bouncy:

 

 

@Toby, what are you talking about?

Not sure for others but for me, I always understand you the first time, since.. eh, always?

If I had to put a list of least offensive member here, you'd be on top almost outside my paper range.

 

ETA: Oops, I forgot ... I found the link to the opinion I referenced above (y'know, about John being a jerk if TJLC isn't true.) http://isitandwonder...-watson-problem Read on if you dare.

I am a bit tired now, let me get myself even more tired until my blood pressure asleep then I'll read that.
Posted

I found the link to the opinion I referenced above (y'know, about John being a jerk if TJLC isn't true.) http://isitandwonder.tumblr.com/post/148342911186/the-john-watson-problem Read on if you dare.

I've read it, and I'd say you paraphrased it pretty fairly. I remain bewildered (especially since the writer says s/he has always liked John -- so this isn't just an exercise in trashing the character). The writer might want to consider the *possibility* that Sherlock does NOT have romantic/sexual feelings for John.

 

Added: Or alternatively, that John is unaware of those feelings.

Posted

When I wake up there are so many posts to catch up on! :o

 

I think that's part of the irritation, the willfully sticking to one unproven fact as the basis for the entire theory. As Sherlock MUST be in love with John it means everything else follows on without any evidence for the first point. Eurgh, it exhausts me. One of the posts I read that annoyed me after the whole debacle of the anti-TJLC interview was saying if TJLC isn't endgame it means the entire series is 'trash.' Why? It's the same series it's always been, just because you saw something in it that was unintended and won't come to fruition doesn't mean the series is suddenly rubbish where as before it was brilliant. And what do these people expect if Johnlock was endgame and did happen? The show couldn't even change that much without losing the entire essence of what it's about. Hell, for all we know Sherlock could be out at gay bars every other night, it's nothing to do with the overarching story so we don't see it because it doesn't matter. (Not that I think he is of course ;P)

 

Sorry if that's a bit garbled, I'm not a morning person, takes hours for my brain to come online properly!

 

  • Like 3
Posted

I've seen it broken down like this:

 

Alphas: popular

Betas: want to be Alphas

Gammas: don't care

 

What about do care, but refuse to go against their own principles? And more to the point, realize they haven't a clue how to fake being like the popular girls, even if they did want to be a phoney? Which they don't?

 

Not saying the popular girls were phonies, merely that whatever they had was not one of my natural attributes, and I'm no good at faking either, which is just as well because I can't stand phonies and wouldn't care to be one.

 

I have no idea whether I've phrased that coherently (even after taking two stabs at it), but if not, it'll have to wait till morning!

Posted

Read that article, and I have a confession to make: all throughout school and university considered Alpha because of sheer willpower, mental capacity and sailing through classes without really doing any hard work; still remember classmates phoning to have the homework explained to them and phone calls lasting over an hour, with Mum complaining that I was hogging the line. Aced everything, and if anyone even dared to call me a geek or a nerd, they got pummelled into changing their views. I must have been really horrible to live with, but was elected class president throughout high school, but talk about bands and stuff: like Sherlock, I was into Mozart, Liszt, Schubert, Wagner and Rimsky-Korsakov. Go figure! My intellectual arrogance has been smoothed around the edges over the years, but it only takes a difference of opinion for it to flare up, even in the forum, for which I apologise to all fellow members, just in case!

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh yes, about ships: the only ship that was confirmed on screen is... Mycake. And even this only sort of, because it was all in Sherlock's head. :D

  • Like 3
Posted

Mycake :D

I don't know about Twitter, it always seems like a cesspool of trolls, and people always seem to be quitting it for one reason or another. Admittedly I'm not big on social media anyway, I don't have a facebook, a twitter, a snapchat etc etc etc. I'm not particularly old, but I am massively anti-social. When I'm at home I don't want to have to deal with other people's sh*t invading my email. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I think I have just found out that there is a limit to how many posts you can quote in multiquote...

 

@Carol: Of course you may ask whom I am moving in with and the answer is: The person I should have been living with all along, my dear husband. He has finally found work near enough that he will be able to commute from our now joined home. It's a pretty long train ride, but it's doable. The things people do for love... I am a little anxious hoping he won't regret it. But mostly just happy and grateful.

 

Toby, I see your point, but I e.g. needed a clear subtext explanation to be able to look at the story from this perspective. And it's another show from the one I fell in love with.

With 17 I unexpectedly lost a near (and back then only) friend to a marriage and a child. That's my perspective.

 

It's another show from what the makers intended, too, I think, so no worries, J.P. All I was trying to say was that I consider it naive to write and present a story the way they did with Sherlock and be surprised when a portion of your viewers interprets it in a romantic way, especially if you are a professional who has been creating fiction and dealing with fandoms for a while.

 

Of course our personal experiences heavily influence what we see, especially in a show that appeals to us as much as this one. We both I think relate to Sherlock in a way that feels specific to each of us. And because he is fictional, he can accommodate both our self-projections and many other people's as well. Fictional characters are great that way.

 

As far as I see it everyone is entitled to their interpretation and can enjoy the show in their own way. It's when they start actively attacking the creators, particularly one for being a 'traitor' to his sexuality, that it becomes wrong. 

 

Yu - P.

 

And for those of us who are not part of TJLC.  I guess I've criticized those who espouse that view, although I have limited my remarks basically to this forum, where I think we have intelligent people willing to have what amounts to a literary discussion of a TV show.  (Which, BTW, is really cool, y'all, and thank you!)

 

Thanks, Boton! I feel kind of silly often talking and thinking so much about a bit of entertainment. But on the other hand, why not. Who says that because the subject matter is trivial, a discussion can't be meaningful all the same. And anyway, it's lots of fun.

 

 
Well, I think you've said the words that I have often felt I am not allowed to say: "fans who already wanted the boys to be in love." Typically, when anyone comes close to saying something like that, there are cries of "but I didn't want it, I just saw it!" Well, I didn't want it either, and I didn't see it. Soooo ... there's that. No point in arguing it.
 
But what I really came here to say was ... I don't agree that those are romantic tropes you are describing. Or to be more accurate, some of them can be ... but are not necessarily. They can serve other purposes too. Just to grab the first one I came across: "prancing around his brother's quarters in full peacock mode asking whether his shirt is okay. Yeah, that's... totally what I always thought guy-bros do before meeting up." Well, that is exactly what Sherlock does, isn't it? He's always fussy about his clothes. They're perfectly tailored. He turns his collar up to look cool. Dresses up (sort of) to meet Irene. Mutters "into battle" when putting on his morning suit, as if it were armor. Because he's one of those people for whom how he looks helps define who he is. Not to impress John, but to impress everybody, including himself. He'd been gone from his world for two years, he wanted to go back into it as who he projects himself to be. I seriously think he would have taken the same care dressing if he'd just decided to take a walk first and had no plans to find John. In fact, now that I think of it, that's what I do when I return from vacation; dress my best the first time I go out to the places I haven't been in awhile. It fortifies me, somehow. So I don't see a romantic trope of "dressing his best to meet his lover" -- I see a more subtle trope of putting on his disguise -- his armor -- before he faces the entire world.
 
(And also, I think that scene was more about him and Mycroft than him and John. He pretended not to take the threat seriously, because it annoyed Mycroft. Period. As we found out later, he took it very seriously.)
 
So now that you've pointed out the "romantic" interpretation, I can see that too. But it doesn't sit right with me, because it doesn't fit with the other things I've observed about Sherlock and John. And it doesn't fit with my observations of real men who are "just" friends. I've witnessed some pretty close male friendships, and yes, a straight man can feel sad or abandoned when his straight best bud gets married. Yes, a straight man can get jealous when his straight best friend is suddenly close friends with a different man (or even with a woman). The writers even make it a point that Sherlock sees a parallel between himself and the good soldier, Sholto; so yes, of course he would sacrifice himself for his comrade-in-arms (your "damsel in distress"), John. It's what good soldiers do.
 
See my point? When you point out a different interpretation of a scene, I can see it; but it's not "obvious." To me, other interpretations are far more obvious. Because I am who I am, of course. Doesn't mean I'm right. Doesn't mean I'm wrong, either. (This is why it's so hard for people to get along --- different perceptions of the same thing!) But I simply can't agree that the story is told as a romance and be done with it .... because I perceive something else going on. A love story, yes. But not a romance. And that's nothing new. Old Yeller is a love story. So is To Kill a Mockingbird, or Lord of the Rings. But none of those are romances; not in the sense we're using the word.

 

Other interpretations are not only more obvious to many people, they are also almost certainly more "correct" in the sense of the creators. I wasn't trying to say any other interpretation is inaccurate, I was only trying to point out why I think it's utterly unsurprising that the John / Sherlock "ship" took sail and traveled as far and into as stormy waters as it did. There have been at least as determined fan pairings that had far, far less basis in the actual work of fiction.

 

For the record: I saw it without wanting to. I saw series 3 and it just went "click" inside my brain and I thought oh! Yeah. I get it now. Not sure if I like it, but I get it. Then after a long while, I decided I neither like nor dislike it. To me personally, it's very unimportant whether John and Sherlock will ever kiss (they won't, I am certain) or whether either of them is gay, bi, straight, whatever. The only way I care is that for me, it is an essential part of the traditional Sherlock Holmes character that he does not enter into conventional partnerships, that he is a loner and an eternal bachelor. But I like the love story here so much that if it were necessary to introduce an element of physical attraction or romantic commitment to keep it alive, I would accept that.

 

Even you called it a love story. Do you call every story about a deep and meaningful friendship a love story? If so, good on you, actually. But many people, as far as I have observed, associate love with sex. Many films, books, plays and games portray sexual relationships as the strongest, most meaningful, most "loving". So I think it is natural and understandable, albeit perhaps a bit sad and limiting, that for some, where there's love there must be sex too. Again, I think a creator should know that. Not agree with it, God forbid! I don't agree with it at all. But know about it. Not be totally surprised and shocked and call people "absurd" for going by what they have learned based on their experiences as an audience.

 

I can only imagine, though, that there are some of the same feelings on the other side. People who think the "non-believers" are denying Johnlock because it's wrong for two men to be lovers. And maybe some of us do think that (I haven't seen it around here, but it's bound to be out there.)

 

Guilty! Yes, I do feel as if the John / Sherlock pairing gets an extra amount of ridicule and disapproval from some quarters because it's not a straight one. There's much less fuss made about Sherlock / Molly, which has about the same level of "evidence" on screen.

 

This bothers me and it makes me feel a bit protective of an idea that isn't in itself all that appealing to me.

 

I just hope that it's totally reasonable that 'don't see it' makes sense too.

 

Absolutely! It's fine, it's ALL FINE! (One of my favorite John quotes. Hell, one of my favorite quotes ever).

 

And one more thing I wanted to say ... does everyone else really think stories about male friendships are all that rare? That's odd to me, because it seems that's almost the only kind of stories there were when I was a young, impressionable tot. To me, the idea of straight but close male friends is as commonplace as ... well, male / female romances.

 

To me too. And I argue that the way the relationship between John and Sherlock is presented is different than the way a close male friendship is usually presented in fiction. I am very willing to elaborate on that, if you are interested, but I fear this will have to be postponed to another time because this post is already ridiculously long.

 

ETA: Oops, I forgot ... I found the link to the opinion I referenced above (y'know, about John being a jerk if TJLC isn't true.) http://isitandwonder.tumblr.com/post/148342911186/the-john-watson-problem Read on if you dare.

 

I dared... I think I understand that person's point of view, but I don't agree.

 

Okay, I do think there's more of a case to be made for Sherlock being secretly in love with John than for a mutual attraction, but even if that were true, John would in no way be a bad person for not feeling the same way about him and instead acting on feelings he does have for somebody else. And if he's said to be a bad person for the way he interacts with his friend, that can only be on the condition that he's aware of said friend's feelings, which he very, very clearly isn't, assuming those feelings even exist in the first place.

 

Actually, we can be pretty sure Sherlock isn't in love with John since we've spent a whole 90 min inside his mind palace now. Mind palace on drugs, mind you. I would have thought that when in the privacy of his own head, with his inhibitions lowered by large doses of illegal substances, he would let his fantasies and wishes run amok at least at little if he had any. He'd have to be pretty far in denial to not even "let" himself be with John in his imagination if that was what he wanted. We know he has no problem fooling around with a naked Irene in there when he's not "busy". The mind palace clearly isn't all work and no play...

 

Of course John is there in the mind palace, features prominently, keeps Sherlock right, calls his BS and comes to save his ass when it counts the most. And yes, Mary is conveniently absent often, to the point where it seems that Sherlock initially forgot all about her and then inserted her not-amused person with an ooops, wait, I forgot John doesn't live with me any more sort of jerk. I do think Sherlock wishes that things could go back to the way they were, but if John were single and back at Baker St, he wouldn't be trying to get into his pants, he'd be trying to make him run around London chasing criminals at all hours. Sherlock genuinely is "married to his work", so his work partner may well be just as important to him as another person's lover is to them. But that doesn't mean he'd like to make John his lover. Sherlock just operates on a different system than most people. That's my take on him, anyway. 

  • Like 2
Posted

Eh, if I were still a teen I wouldn't know that much about those bands as well. I remember those 'popular' kids or so they think were being so hyped about some singers and spreading creepy laughs while flirting with boys and happily being chased by 'bra snapper' while I was busy giving death glare, whoever dared to even try, I'd whack their faces with teacher's wooden giant ruler.

The craze for the singer and bra snapping somehow exist together in my memory, not really sure why. I think this group of teens in my time always tried to be trendsetters in ridiculous stuffs.

 

Eh, I think that's why I was not 'hip' :P. But I was always safe. :bouncy:

 

I probably shouldn't admit this, but my best friend and I were the acknowledged champions of rock'n'roll geekery.   :smile: ) You needed to know something about a band, we were your source. What was the 2nd song on so-and-so's 3rd album? Ask us, and we'd also tell you who wrote it, why, for whom, the brand of guitar used in the rhythm track, and the name of the engineer's son's puppy. Especially my friend, who even knew the details about bands we didn't even like. How we amassed this knowledge, and where it subsequently went, I can't imagine. These days I can barely remember all the names of the members of U2. Heck, I adore their last album but don't even know what it's called. :rolleyes:

 

 

I found the link to the opinion I referenced above (y'know, about John being a jerk if TJLC isn't true.) http://isitandwonder.tumblr.com/post/148342911186/the-john-watson-problem Read on if you dare.

I've read it, and I'd say you paraphrased it pretty fairly. I remain bewildered (especially since the writer says s/he has always liked John -- so this isn't just an exercise in trashing the character). The writer might want to consider the *possibility* that Sherlock does NOT have romantic/sexual feelings for John.

 

 

The writer "can't" consider that possibility, though, because if s/he does, the conclusion falls apart. And in cases like this, the conclusion is all, the soundness of the argument is irrelevant.

 

I think that's part of the irritation, the willfully sticking to one unproven fact as the basis for the entire theory. As Sherlock MUST be in love with John it means everything else follows on without any evidence for the first point. Eurgh, it exhausts me. One of the posts I read that annoyed me after the whole debacle of the anti-TJLC interview was saying if TJLC isn't endgame it means the entire series is 'trash.' Why? It's the same series it's always been, just because you saw something in it that was unintended and won't come to fruition doesn't mean the series is suddenly rubbish where as before it was brilliant. And what do these people expect if Johnlock was endgame and did happen? The show couldn't even change that much without losing the entire essence of what it's about. Hell, for all we know Sherlock could be out at gay bars every other night, it's nothing to do with the overarching story so we don't see it because it doesn't matter. (Not that I think he is of course ;P)

Join the club! As you can probably tell from the tone of my latest posts, that kind of argumentation exasperates me. I wanna grab 'em, shake 'em, and tell them to go to a debate class or something until they learn some critical thinking skills. Agh!!! 

 

Sorry, sorry, sorry, I'm almost calm now. This topic is worse than shoes!

 

 

I've seen it broken down like this:

 

Alphas: popular

Betas: want to be Alphas

Gammas: don't care

What about do care, but refuse to go against their own principles? And more to the point, realize they haven't a clue how to fake being like the popular girls, even if they did want to be a phoney? Which they don't?

 

Not saying the popular girls were phonies, merely that whatever they had was not one of my natural attributes, and I'm no good at faking either, which is just as well because I can't stand phonies and wouldn't care to be one.

 

I have no idea whether I've phrased that coherently (even after taking two stabs at it), but if not, it'll have to wait till morning!

 

Beta. ;)

 

Read that article, and I have a confession to make: all throughout school and university considered Alpha because of sheer willpower, mental capacity and sailing through classes without really doing any hard work; still remember classmates phoning to have the homework explained to them and phone calls lasting over an hour, with Mum complaining that I was hogging the line. Aced everything, and if anyone even dared to call me a geek or a nerd, they got pummelled into changing their views. I must have been really horrible to live with, but was elected class president throughout high school, but talk about bands and stuff: like Sherlock, I was into Mozart, Liszt, Schubert, Wagner and Rimsky-Korsakov. Go figure! My intellectual arrogance has been smoothed around the edges over the years, but it only takes a difference of opinion for it to flare up, even in the forum, for which I apologise to all fellow members, just in case!

To be honest, you sound more like a gamma to me. Alpha's aren't generally known for their scholastic skills, but their social ones. They're not usually class presidents, but head cheerleaders and prom queens, and they throw the best parties. (As in, the parties the betas want to be invited to. :smile: ) They can also be good students,  or even bad ones, but it's their social status that makes them Alphas. Although you could have been all that too, for all I know! :D

  • Like 1
Posted

I think I have just found out that there is a limit to how many posts you can quote in multiquote...

Yup.  I've hit it a few times too.

 

@Carol: Of course you may ask whom I am moving in with and the answer is: The person I should have been living with all along, my dear husband. He has finally found work near enough that he will be able to commute from our now joined home. It's a pretty long train ride, but it's doable. The things people do for love... I am a little anxious hoping he won't regret it. But mostly just happy and grateful.

 

 Yay!  :D :bouncy::applause::boing::cowdance::thumbsup:

 

That's what I figured, but didn't dare hope!

 

Actually, we can be pretty sure Sherlock isn't in love with John since we've spent a whole 90 min inside his mind palace now. Mind palace on drugs, mind you. I would have thought that when in the privacy of his own head, with his inhibitions lowered by large doses of illegal substances, he would let his fantasies and wishes run amok at least at little if he had any.

 

Good point -- hadn't thought of that!  One more datum for the undecided -- which I guess is most of us, to one extent or another.

 

I've read it, and I'd say you paraphrased it pretty fairly. I remain bewildered (especially since the writer says s/he has always liked John -- so this isn't just an exercise in trashing the character). The writer might want to consider the *possibility* that Sherlock does NOT have romantic/sexual feelings for John.

 

The writer "can't" consider that possibility, though, because if s/he does, the conclusion falls apart. And in cases like this, the conclusion is all, the soundness of the argument is irrelevant.

 

You mean Sherlock fandom is like politics?  XD

 

Beta. ;)

You take that back!  :whip:

  • Like 2
Posted

I see all sorts of people slipped in and posted before mine; not ignoring you intentionally! This is just what happens when you fall asleep in the middle of responding..... :rolleyes:

 

Now to go back and read everything I missed...

Posted

Okay, we are not alone. I don't know if it makes me feel better or worse...

 

Steven Universe Artist Quits Twitter Over Fan Harassment

Better, because it looks like there are fandoms even crazier than ours. Worse, because we humans are just bat-shit crazy all the time, aren't we? :blink:

 

@Carol: Of course you may ask whom I am moving in with and the answer is: The person I should have been living with all along, my dear husband. He has finally found work near enough that he will be able to commute from our now joined home. It's a pretty long train ride, but it's doable. The things people do for love... I am a little anxious hoping he won't regret it. But mostly just happy and grateful.

YAYYYYYYYY!!!!!! I wondered too but unlike somebody was too polite to ask.... :D Congrats!!!!

 

I feel kind of silly often talking and thinking so much about a bit of entertainment. But on the other hand, why not. Who says that because the subject matter is trivial, a discussion can't be meaningful all the same. And anyway, it's lots of fun.

Amen to that.

 

Even you called it a love story. Do you call every story about a deep and meaningful friendship a love story? If so, good on you, actually. But many people, as far as I have observed, associate love with sex. Many films, books, plays and games portray sexual relationships as the strongest, most meaningful, most "loving". So I think it is natural and understandable, albeit perhaps a bit sad and limiting, that for some, where there's love there must be sex too. Again, I think a creator should know that. Not agree with it, God forbid! I don't agree with it at all. But know about it. Not be totally surprised and shocked and call people "absurd" for going by what they have learned based on their experiences as an audience.

I'll take Lord of the Rings as an example, because it's what I'm most familiar with. If someone asked me what kind of story it was, no, of course I wouldn't say it was a love story; I'd say it was a fantasy about good and evil. If someone asked me about Sherlock, I would say it was a story about a detective (but not a detective story. :smile: ) But if I got together with a group of people and we got into discussing the relationship between Frodo and Sam, I'm pretty sure at some point I would say it was a love story. Even Tolkien did, although not in those exact words.

 

But does that mean that Tolkien should have expected that some people would one day "ship" Frodo and Sam? I don't think so; because there's different types of love than sexual love, and Tolkien described very clearly what kind Frodo and Sam had; the servant's for his master, the master's for his comrade. I think Tolkien would have "expected" people to be attentive enough to what they were reading to recognize the cues that told them which kind of love he was writing about.

 

BUT ... I will concede your point, to this extent: I recognize that some people are not, in fact, attentive; or are too attentive, or process the same words differently, or bring different experiences with them, or what have you. I concede that different interpretations can and will exist. I don't concede, though, that all interpretations are equally valid; especially once the author has stated his intention. I know I keep harping on that, but I can't let it go; intent matters! (I should put that on a t-shirt! :smile: )

 

 

I can only imagine, though, that there are some of the same feelings on the other side. People who think the "non-believers" are denying Johnlock because it's wrong for two men to be lovers. And maybe some of us do think that (I haven't seen it around here, but it's bound to be out there.)

Guilty! Yes, I do feel as if the John / Sherlock pairing gets an extra amount of ridicule and disapproval from some quarters because it's not a straight one. There's much less fuss made about Sherlock / Molly, which has about the same level of "evidence" on screen.

 

But there's no Sherlolly Conspiracy, that I'm aware of. (TSLC? :smile: ) I'm sure you're right, same sex pairings probably draw more fire; but it's not actually the pairing that annoys me, it's TJLC. I can't be sure, but I think if there were a "TSLC", being powered by the same kind of circular reasoning TJLC appears to be, I'd be pretty annoyed by it too.

 

 

And one more thing I wanted to say ... does everyone else really think stories about male friendships are all that rare? That's odd to me, because it seems that's almost the only kind of stories there were when I was a young, impressionable tot. To me, the idea of straight but close male friends is as commonplace as ... well, male / female romances.

To me too. And I argue that the way the relationship between John and Sherlock is presented is different than the way a close male friendship is usually presented in fiction. I am very willing to elaborate on that, if you are interested ...

More than you've already mentioned? No, I won't ask you to go through that, unless you just want to, in which case of course I'd be interested. But as it stands now, I simply have to disagree; I don't see that the presentation of this male friendship is different. Maybe if I could dig up some examples of what I mean, that would help. I'll have to put some thought into that ... where does one even find gifs of The Lone Ranger? :smile:

 

Sherlock just operates on a different system than most people. That's my take on him, anyway.

Yu-P. :smile:

Posted

 

Okay, we are not alone. I don't know if it makes me feel better or worse...

Steven Universe Artist Quits Twitter Over Fan Harassment

Better, because it looks like there are fandoms even crazier than ours. Worse, because we humans are just bat-shit crazy all the time, aren't we? :blink:

 

Probably, yeah... For me, it seems contradictory to call yourself a fan of something, then attack the people who made it in the first place. But what do I know.

 

YAYYYYYYYY!!!!!! I wondered too but unlike somebody was too polite to ask.... :D Congrats!!!!

 

Thank you! And thanks to Carol too for your kind words.

 

 

I'll take Lord of the Rings as an example, because it's what I'm most familiar with. If someone asked me what kind of story it was, no, of course I wouldn't say it was a love story; I'd say it was a fantasy about good and evil. If someone asked me about Sherlock, I would say it was a story about a detective (but not a detective story. :smile: ) But if I got together with a group of people and we got into discussing the relationship between Frodo and Sam, I'm pretty sure at some point I would say it was a love story. Even Tolkien did, although not in those exact words.

But does that mean that Tolkien should have expected that some people would one day "ship" Frodo and Sam? I don't think so; because there's different types of love than sexual love, and Tolkien described very clearly what kind Frodo and Sam had; the servant's for his master, the master's for his comrade. I think Tolkien would have "expected" people to be attentive enough to what they were reading to recognize the cues that told them which kind of love he was writing about.

 

:lol: Funny, I was thinking of Lord of the Rings in this context too. No, I do not think Tolkien should have expected people would see Sam and Frodo in a romantic, let alone sexual light, and here's why: At the time he wrote those books, roughly a hundred years ago, same-sex relationships were taboo and, in most parts of the world, illegal. The fact that two characters were of the same gender excluded any kind of sexual content, same as today, the fact that two characters are siblings does (unless you're watching Game of Thrones, of course). For the same reason, I do not think Doyle should have seen the Sherlock / John ship coming. Although sometimes I wonder whether he maybe did, or his publisher or a friend did and that's why he introduced Mary and Irene Adler in the first place, to protect himself from possible allegations. I say this because I think the poor women are written rather sloppily and I never had the impression that they meant much to Doyle as characters. Irene only appears in one story, then is hardly ever mentioned again, and Mary Watson née Morstan is just sort of forgotten after a while. (Another possible, and probably more accurate, explanation is that he simply thought his books would be more popular if they had romances and attractive girls in them; sex sells as we all know).

 

Sherlock and John, however, were taken out of their Victorian home into modern London. The rules are different now, thank goodness. Mrs Hudson is actually reasonable for considering the possibility that her new lodgers may require only one bedroom, and even though the poor woman doesn't handle the matter very tactfully, being herself from a different day and age and probably still a bit uncomfortable with it, at least she tries.

 

I LOVE how Sherlock is never seen to be offended or bothered when people assume he and John are a couple. He simply does not seem to care. He knows what their relationship is really about (or at least he's learning) and that's all that matters. There's no misunderstanding between him and John, they settled that matter very early. Why would he give two straws for what anybody else thinks or what the press writes? It's not an insult or anything like that. Just another inaccurate assumption. People are idiots, they get things wrong all the time. Big deal. :lol: I also love how in spite of the many jabs and sneers he's gotten from Mycroft, Moriarty and Magnussen about it, Sherlock still is endearingly open and straight-forward about his affection for John. He knows what he means, John knows what he means, Mary gets it too, so why should he bother what his arrogant brother and a bunch of his enemies say? As for us, he doesn't know we exist, thank god.  :P

 

Poor John, with his military guy-culture no-homo background and possibly some unpleasant experiences around discrimination because of his sister, doesn't handle it quite so well... :lol: Which does not bother me in the least. I think it's realistic. That's what a guy like John would be like. Rationally, he'd know that it's all fine and nobody is insulting him, but he doesn't like it all the same. Besides, it did kind of hurt his chances with women before Mary came along and took that matter off his mind... 

 

More than you've already mentioned? No, I won't ask you to go through that, unless you just want to, in which case of course I'd be interested. But as it stands now, I simply have to disagree; I don't see that the presentation of this male friendship is different.

 

That's fine, we can agree to disagree. And don't worry, I won't go off on another long post full of "this is whys". :D

For now at least. :P

  • Like 2
Posted

I wondered too but unlike somebody was too polite to ask....

 

Hey!  I didn't ask!  I very politely asked permission to ask!  :P

 

I recognize that some people are not, in fact, attentive; or are too attentive, or process the same words differently, or bring different experiences with them, or what have you. I concede that different interpretations can and will exist. I don't concede, though, that all interpretations are equally valid; especially once the author has stated his intention. I know I keep harping on that, but I can't let it go; intent matters! (I should put that on a t-shirt! :smile: )

 

I think there's another, pretty different possibility; namely that some people prefer to see things differently.  They may realize that the creators didn't mean it that way, or they may not even care how the creators meant it.  They just have their own preferred take on things, and it makes them happy.  No problem.  That's a good basis for some interesting fanfic.  Just as long as they don't try to tell the rest of us that we're wrong.  And especially if they don't try to tell the creators that they're wrong!

 

I don't see that the presentation of this male friendship is different. Maybe if I could dig up some examples of what I mean, that would help.

OK, I think I finally figured out what it is that's different about this one.  The others I've seen were just play-acting.  They weren't "real" in the sense that they didn't particularly affect me.  Whereas Sherlock and (particularly) John really, really get to me.

 

That does not constitute proof, of course, at least not to anyone except me.  But it's my reason for saying that this time it's different.

Posted

@Arcadia dear: this side of the pond no cheerleaders and no proms available: ruling the entire Vegesack Gymnasium student population with an iron fist in a velvet glove emphatically yes. Watching out for bullying and confronting the perps, chemistry lab assistant for the senior years (ha! not only Holmes minor loves the science!) and being there when a fellow student needed help, yes.

Anyway, what's with CakeCroft? The way things are going we shall be over our heads in Parentlock!

Posted

 

I recognize that some people are not, in fact, attentive; or are too attentive, or process the same words differently, or bring different experiences with them, or what have you. I concede that different interpretations can and will exist. I don't concede, though, that all interpretations are equally valid; especially once the author has stated his intention. I know I keep harping on that, but I can't let it go; intent matters! (I should put that on a t-shirt! :smile: )

 

I think there's another, pretty different possibility; namely that some people prefer to see things differently.  They may realize that the creators didn't mean it that way, or they may not even care how the creators meant it.  They just have their own preferred take on things, and it makes them happy.  No problem.  That's a good basis for some interesting fanfic.  Just as long as they don't try to tell the rest of us that we're wrong.  And especially if they don't try to tell the creators that they're wrong!

 

The ones I've read get quite defensive when it's suggested it's what they prefer to see. But out of everything that's out there, I've only read -- skimmed, really -- a few, so maybe there are some who are okay with that. But I wouldn't mind betting the majority who champion TJLC will insist they see it because it exists. Which it does, in a way, but according to Moftiss, they're the ones who put it there. Which is not what they want to hear.

 

Has there ever been a conspiracy theory that has been proven to be true? There's so many of them, you'd think at least one would have turned out to be correct. But I'm drawing a blank ... (can't even think of a theory, let alone one that's been proved, to be honest. :smile: )

 

 

I don't see that the presentation of this male friendship is different. Maybe if I could dig up some examples of what I mean, that would help.

OK, I think I finally figured out what it is that's different about this one.  The others I've seen were just play-acting.  They weren't "real" in the sense that they didn't particularly affect me.  Whereas Sherlock and (particularly) John really, really get to me.

You mean because the quality of the acting makes you believe the characters are real? Or am I misunderstanding? Hmmm, I really do need to try and find some examples. Ooof, sounds like work. :smile: And even then, they'll be so dated .... well, we'll see.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.