Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm sure they will, because the term had changed meaning before I ever heard it. Language is like that, though. People keep using "moot" to mean irrelevant, and they pay no attention when I point out that it actually means debatable. I'm afraid I've lost that one (among others!).

 

But please note that I did not say she presumably thought of her position as politically correct; I said "politically correct.". Please bear our agreement in mind -- with the quote marks it means something like "appropriate to a specific version of righteousness." And I'm sure that woman thought of her position as entirely righteous.

 

 

Ooops, did we have an agreement on that? Sorry, another victim of my poor memory, I'm afraid. Anyway, your intent is acknowledged, understood and accepted. :smile:

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Ooops, did we have an agreement on that? Sorry, another victim of my poor memory, I'm afraid. Anyway, your intent is acknowledged, understood and accepted. :smile:

 

Yup, just like when Sherlock says "we agreed" -- and I'm reasonably sure that you weren't even in Dublin at the time. ;)

Posted

No, it's more likely that I was half-asleep! :d

  • Like 1
Posted

Ugh, don't be. Chronic insomnia. It's a real pain sometimes, and mostly my own fault. I keep on thinking of things more interesting to do than sleeping. Getting better, though. Well, sometimes .... :blush:

  • Like 1
Posted

Just want to say rose.gif

@Carol n Arcadia. You make a good team.

 

Now I got a furball to swim with.

  • Like 2
Posted

Ugh, don't be. Chronic insomnia. It's a real pain sometimes, and mostly my own fault. I keep on thinking of things more interesting to do than sleeping. Getting better, though. Well, sometimes .... :blush:

 

LOL.

I have that problem with meditation. I'm afraid that if I stop thinking I might miss something interesting.

And then I need to sit down to think properly - well, what can you deduce about my fitness... :blush:

 

... but I think we are hijacking this thread... again...

  • Like 2
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

That's pretty grim :( 

I wish people wouldn't get so militant over such ridiculous things. Yes, representation is important, but this is a show about Sherlock Holmes, it's never claimed to be about representation, in fact they seem to pointedly not make Sherlock's sexuality an issue. Whatever he is, or isn't, doesn't matter because that isn't the focus of the show. I only came across TJLC a few months ago and at first I thought it was a tongue in cheek joke too. :S

  • Like 3
Posted

I wish people would just stay in their own corner of the internet and enjoy their ship (whatever that is) and just leave everyone else alone.  To some extent, I feel like this is nothing new under the sun.  The shipper (MSR) and noromo wars back in the day were terrible, awful within the X-Files fandom.  The only plus side, it was kept among the fans, at least.  But I think the one thing that is making everything worse exponentially worse is social media.  People now have direct access to the show creators, the actors, and just say whatever they feel like to them.  I'm convinced if they had to say these things to others' faces, everyone would play a lot nicer. 

 

I feel like I should be more shocked by that tumblr post, but I'm just not.  I'm on tumblr and I've seen it, not just from TJLC, and it's... disturbing.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

 

I feel like I should be more shocked by that tumblr post, but I'm just not.  I'm on tumblr and I've seen it, not just from TJLC, and it's... disturbing.

 

I spend a little time on Tumblr, and it's a scary, scary place.  If you don't conform to some people's expectations in your view, they will conduct the worst cyber-bullying you've ever seen.  And most of it is about things like TV shows, which is ridiculous.

 

The tongue-in-cheek part of Johnlock is actually great fun.

 

Yeah, I agree about that.  I mean, I ague vociferously about it actually being "endgame" (I hate that word...), but sometimes I get a big kick out of thinking that the subtext is just a big joke on our John.  Like everyone is saying, "Hey, John, see how easy it would be to be a couple with Sherlock? All of the conditions are just right; they have been since ACD's time.  You just have to make your move."  And poor John keeps yelling at everyone (including the fourth wall), "but I'm not gay!" 

 

One place this (BNFs and cyber-harassment over ships) has gotten weirdly meta is on Twitter.  I follow William Shatner (Captain Kirk) on Twitter, and he actually has an opinion about some ship or other on some show (I can't tell which one because I don't watch whatever it is), and he has taken massive abuse on Twitter from all of these BNFs about his choice of ship!  It's very bizarre watching a man who played a character that was half of one of the biggest non-canonical ships in history be told that he can't root for his OTP.   :wtf:

  • Like 3
Posted

I often compared this with the Moon landing deniers. But now I'm asking myself if this isn't even worse. Did anyone of you ever heard of the second group ever demanded of re-writing history books? This is a serious question, but I would like to save some time if some of you know something about it already.

 

Have you ever seen The Dark Side of the Moon by Wiliam Karel? It's a great film and I would highly recommend it but it's important to avoid spoilers which is actually any information.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90zneJONh0w

 

So if you intend to watch, avoid the spoilers below. If not read further.

 

 

Well, this is actually a mockumentary.
But it's so well done that even I lost the ground beneath my feet for a moment. Anyway, if you watch it till the end it becomes clear that the film is a joke. But still, after all the years it is used by conspiracy theorists to found their POV.

The story somehow remains me of the one from the blog.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I spend a little time on Tumblr, and it's a scary, scary place.  If you don't conform to some people's expectations in your view, they will conduct the worst cyber-bullying you've ever seen.  And most of it is about things like TV shows, which is ridiculous.

I think it's wonderful that Sherlock fans participate in the creative process.  Sherlock and John were first created over a hundred years ago, and during that time who knows how many people have participated in their ongoing creation?  It gives me a good feeling to know that I am (in a very minor way) one of those people.  My conception of the characters necessarily differs from anyone else's concepts, because I am not those other people, and they are not me.  But that's part of the fun.  Their stories are different from mine, so we can enjoy reading each others' fiction for a change of pace.  It's all fine.

 

Of course each of us is a bit protective of our version of the characters.  (Just watch me react when somebody refers to John as an adrenaline junkie!)  But at some point this character-protection stops being just an intellectual game, and takes on a life of its own.

 

I sympathize with those who are calling for fair representation of all sexual orientations on television.  Things have come a long way since Milton Berle got laughs by wearing a dress, but there's still room for improvement.  However, I wonder if this is actually what TJLC is all about -- because if it were, the call would logically be simply for Moftiss to write a gay romance between Sherlock and John into the story arc.  Whether or not they had intended that all along would be irrelevant.  The only important thing would be what ended up being shown on television.

 

On the other hand, the focus on intentions reminds me of members of political party A criticizing members of party B for supporting a program dear to the hearts of party A, but for the wrong reason.  This country (can't speak for the rest of the world) is becoming increasingly polarized.  Political parties that used to hammer out compromises and manage to work together a good bit of the time now seem to focus more on blaming each other than on actually solving problems.  Maybe the "intentions" aspect of TJLC is merely another symptom of this tendency toward demonization.  I remain bewildered by all of it.

 

  • Like 3
Posted

Just because people get obsessed with a specific world view does not validate that world view! I fervently wish that Auschwitz, Mauthausen and other such places were exactly what they were conceived as: work camps (Arbeit macht frei), but they degenerated into death camps.

TJLC has as much right to exist as any other slash material, no more, no less. Cyberbullying and trolling are definitely not on! I have a good friend who cannot use a lovely sketch of Sherlock holding a baby just because they are Sheriarty fans, so banned from using TJLC material. Utter nonsense and a violation of people's basic rights!

  • Like 4
Posted

TJLC has as much right to exist as any other slash material....

 

Or, for that matter, any other fan material whatsoever.

  • Like 3
Posted

Aiz...I'm really tired of this.

 

Actually feel very bad with the creators and actors, hope that they continue to do and have the right to do what they want to do and love what they decide to do.

 

And for everyone who is not happy watching their creations, just quit and watch other shows that fit their expectations, for own sanity. There are many other better things to waste time with.

  • Like 5
Posted

I genuinely felt bad for Gatiss at Comic Con... he was like I feel strongly about this... not joking when I'm saying it's not happening.   They just sound exasperated and done.

  • Like 2
Posted

I just don't get it.  If Sherlolly doesn't happen, and I'm fairly certain it's not, that doesn't stop my enjoyment of the show and the story they're telling.

  • Like 3
Posted

I've been thinking about this off and on today, and it all seems terribly familiar. But I'm not sure why. I've never been this involved in a fandom before -- (which I attribute mainly to the internet. I participate because I can; not like the old days, when I had to drive an hour to another town to find like-minded fans. Only to end up being .... ahem ... the oldest person (by far) in the room. Awkward!)

 

Anyway, the nearest thing I can think of that felt like this was the Kennedy assassination conspiracy theories. I never believed them, and I never saw any "evidence" to make me think otherwise. But I knew a few people who believed in them fervently (a couple right in my own family!) -- based on the same evidence that convinced me that it wasn't true. Go figure.

 

I'm guessing that's what drives a lot of the fervor ... not the desire for representation, but the desire to simply be proven "right". To be proven smarter, more observant, more clever than everyone else. Because if they're not proven right, they're going to look a bit foolish, or simply nuts? At any rate, I think that's what feels familiar to me ... the burning need to prove everyone else wrong.

 

But I think it's important to remember that, like all groups, not all TJLC'ers are alike. I'm sure some of them are absolutely horrible to other people; just as I'm sure that some of them are lovely to everyone. It's just that the ugly stuff is louder and sticks with us more. I thought midonz did a fair job of not demonizing all TJLC'ers ... but I'm equally willing to bet some people (on all sides of the issue) will think she did, and use her words in an attempt to put down others. Unfortunately, that seems to be human nature. But so is being thoughtful and reasonable (okay, sometimes :d ) so I prefer to emphasize that when I can.

  • Like 3
Posted

Is Sherlock the first fandom for most of you? Disclaimer: I'm honestly curious, not trying to be patronizing or anything likewise stupid, but it seems many of you have never seen a shipping war before.

 

Whenever people feel passionate about something, there are bound to be some who act out. TvTropes has its own page (with multiple subpages) devoted to Ship-to-Ship Combat (and no, not naval warfare :P), but for bonus idiocy, this can even happen within a shipping community (be very, very glad you never heard about Pawn to Queen). This is no new phenomenon, the belligerent subset of the TJLCers are just the latest in a long and sad line of folks who should maybe have thought twice before posting. And fortunately, so far the fallout has been confined to the screen afaik - at least I haven't heard yet of anyone getting doxxed, swatted or similar, thank the heavens (personally, I think this is because we're mostly gals - this level of awfulness seems predominantly a male pastime).

  • Like 3
Posted

Nope, been part of the Harry Potter fandom and the Supernatural fandom. There are always people with crazy beliefs in every fandom, the amount of Wincest always freaked me out, but I don't think I've come across anything so extreme that the creators are genuinely upset enough to have to make an official statement about it. I think what was said about the rise of social media is a big part of it, and the fact that Gatiss and Moffat are so visible. Most shows have teams of writers and I couldn't name or recognise any of them, but Moffat and Gatiss are very much out there and willing to be accessible to the fans at cons etc where it's usually just actors and directors. The downside of that is that they are targets for people who latch onto fandom beliefs as an excuse for trolling. 

  • Like 2
Posted

There have been accessible creators as long as there's been creative content. One example that immediately comes to mind is JMS of Bablyon 5 fame, who in the dawn of the internet as we know it today was active in newsgroups and answered fan questions tirelessly and patiently (the lovely Lurker's Guide, which I was suprised to see is still accessible even without the wayback machine, has a "jms speaks" part on every single episode's page with quotes).

 

And I don't think that Moffat and Gatiss are such entirely blameless victims in this as they apparently see themselves. To keep planting hints and allegations into a series from ep1 onwards, to have in-series shippers like Mrs Hudson, and then act all surprised that some folks think this all has some meaning and to declare that as absurd, that's disingenuous if you ask me. You tease a ship, you get shippers - and like I said above, I have yet to see anything about TJLC that makes it extreme or stand out from other shipping wars in any way (idiots are sadly everywhere, so that in itself is not unusual, the world would be a better place if it were).

  • Like 3
Posted

Actually, before I got on board this forum and another one about Sherlock, the only ships I knew of either sailed the world's seas or streaked around the universe as starships. Star Trek, Star Wars, Dune, you name it. It was a huge revelation when I found out about 'ships' and 'slash', and these 'ships' actually offend my grammarian self, because they are a lazy abbreviation of 'relationship' anyway! But the material here is of such high quality most of the time that I stick around for the information and the banter. The Collected Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is one of the books that deserved to be memorised in Farenheit 451!

As for Mrs Hudson, they started with "We get all sorts around here..." In SiP and finished with her indignant exclamation:"A woman?" in TEH. Blameless, they are not!

P.S. Were we to talk curls vs. slicked-back hair, now... ^_^

Posted

Actually, before I got on board this forum and another one about Sherlock, the only ships I knew of either sailed the world's seas or streaked around the universe as starships.

 

Same here! And I think I preferred it that way; I find the whole "shipping" thing a bit annoying. But that's my problem; I get why people do it. So ship away, folks, when I can't take it anymore I'll go hide in the "cute animals" thread. :P

  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 109 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.