Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

As far as I'm aware, nobody's ever killed off Sherlock Holmes -- except for Conan Doyle's failed attempt.

There is always first time for everything?

First modern Sherlock, first female John, ..

The first modern Sherlock was written by Conan Doyle.  ;)  Most of the Rathbone/Bruce films were set in the 1940's.  There have even been female Watsons before, e.g., here and here.  So yes, there's always a first time.  But that was a while back.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Or just a fan of good storytelling. That's what drew me in.

 

Yup-P.

And The Voice. I have to admit that one hot me first. :P

 

 

Oh, I'm not saying that isn't one of the reasons I stick around.... :naughty:  But it was the whole show (and that accursed scarf) that got me here in the first place. Why, why, why does this happen to me........................................

Posted

Are we off topic yet?

 

No, but we could get there quickly.   ;)

 

For the sake of moderator sanity, I'll try to nudge us back to TJLC territory.  Since we mentioned the first female Watsons, why do you think there isn't a parallel "Joanlock conspiracy" surrounding Elementary?  (Or there isn't that I know of.)  So, basically, I'm throwing out the question of whether it is important/interesting/inevitable/plausible that Holmes and Watson (in any incarnation) get together, or that Sherlock and John, specifically, get together?  Regardless of what you think, why do you think that?  

 

(I have some thoughts but they are really nebulous, so I'll save them and see if anyone else has a more coherent opinion.)

  • Like 2
Posted

To be honest, I'm mystified why Joan is female in Elementary if the idea wasn't to get them together without there being controversy. The thing is, I think Martin and Benedict actually have much more on screen chemistry than Johnny and Lucy (feel weird using all their first names like they're people I know), and maybe that's why there isn't a Joanlock conspiracy. I don't even know why they made Joan female, it doesn't seem to have any bearing on the story or any real point, and I've mentioned before but it irritates me that they took away her army background - why couldn't Joan have been a military doctor since the military is such a huge part of John's character. 

  • Like 2
Posted

Yep! We hijacked TJLC! It started derailing back on p. 11.

Talking about Elementary, Joan is paired off with Mycroft for a brief fling, and there are dark allusions by Sherlock to her pairing with Moreland Holmes.

And having been an Army doctor didn't play a huge part in the ACD version of Dr Watson.

  • Like 1
Posted

To be honest, I'm mystified why Joan is female in Elementary if the idea wasn't to get them together without there being controversy. The thing is, I think Martin and Benedict actually have much more on screen chemistry than Johnny and Lucy (feel weird using all their first names like they're people I know), and maybe that's why there isn't a Joanlock conspiracy. I don't even know why they made Joan female, it doesn't seem to have any bearing on the story or any real point, and I've mentioned before but it irritates me that they took away her army background - why couldn't Joan have been a military doctor since the military is such a huge part of John's character. 

 

I personally think they made Joan female to differentiate Elementary as much as possible from Sherlock, since they had originally wanted permission to make an American version of BBC Sherlock and were told in no uncertain terms to keep away from that particular set of intellectual property.  

 

That said, if anyone has ever set out to prove that you can put two opposite sex, heterosexual characters in close living quarters and demonstrate that they have absolutely zero sexual or romantic chemistry, it has been Elementary.  I don't watch religiously, but almost every time I come away wondering if those two even like each other, let alone being the "best friends ever" or "secretly attracted."

 

Maybe that's enough to squelch a "Joanlock conspiracy?" But it seems like, if you want Sherlock and John together specifically, you would have to see something in the fundamental Holmes/Watson relationship that allows for that, so that it is a possibility in most/all incarnations. Maybe?

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm surprised they didn't make Sherlock female, or both female and just gone the whole hog. I think we could do with a female Sherlock who is just as anti-social and arsey as the male version.

  • Like 2
Posted

My guess as to why the fans aren't demanding Joanlock (assuming that they aren't -- I really wouldn't know) is that it would be cliche.  Boring.  Same ol', same ol'.

 

At the same time, the creators don't want to go that route because -- despite what anybody wants intellectually -- there's a certain amount of sexual tension inherent in the current situation, and sexual tension keeps people coming back (if only out of indignation that the creators might get S&J together).  So surely to some extent, they're stringing us along.  What's that called -- straightbaiting?

 

  • Like 3
Posted

There's just zero chemistry between those two though. The idea of seeing them in bed together would be horrifying, like seeing a brother and sister in bed. Unless they write an entire sub-plot having them get closer together and something developing I can't see it. I like both the actors but I wonder why they chose them since there does seem to be so little chemistry.

Posted

 

At the same time, the creators don't want to go that route because -- despite what anybody wants intellectually -- there's a certain amount of sexual tension inherent in the current situation, and sexual tension keeps people coming back (if only out of indignation that the creators might get S&J together).  So surely to some extent, they're stringing us along.  What's that called -- straightbaiting?

 

 

So, there really is a Joanlock Conspiracy!  :-)

 

And "straightbaiting."  I love that.

 

There's just zero chemistry between those two though. The idea of seeing them in bed together would be horrifying, like seeing a brother and sister in bed. Unless they write an entire sub-plot having them get closer together and something developing I can't see it. I like both the actors but I wonder why they chose them since there does seem to be so little chemistry.

 

Agree, and I don't think it is the fault of the actors.  But LL is so good at playing these very cool, controlled characters, and then JLM is playing this increasingly-autistic Sherlock, and I think seeing them in bed together would make me need brain bleach. 

 

I think I have an easier time seeing chemistry between the leads in The Great Mouse Detective.

 

great-mouse-detective.jpg

  • Like 2
Posted

Basil! Bow-chicca-wow-wow! :P

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

jhkUHcY.jpg

  • Like 6
Posted

Heh, that's where Sherlock really gets his bolts of inspiration. :D

 

I liked Elementary initially, but it started losing me with the watering down of all the characters;

 

John - Military doctor newly invalided home from a war. No, doctor who lost confidence so became a sober companion. 

Mycroft - THE British government. No, a restauranteur. 

Lestrade - A good cop who perhaps relies on Sherlock a little too much. No, a snivelling, slimy and backhanded excuse of a copper. (Note; this is Lestrade not Gregson.)

Papa Holmes - I'm not aware of many previous incarnations of him, but I HATE this one - the less said there the better. 

 

Even Sherlock, I liked him in the first season, and I think there was a moment between Joan and Sherlock when he asked her to stay on as his partner, but since then he's been played/written as increasingly autistic and dull. He doesn't seem particularly intelligent or insightful, I don't know if I've ever seen him deduce anyone more than any of the other characters, certainly not in any of the recent episodes, and on the odd occasion he does an experiment it's something dumb. I remember in a recent episode he had set up what I very loosely term an experiment involving setting up drugged meat in a park so see if the rats would go for it or if they would be able to smell/sense the drugs and hence avoid it. Something vaguely to do with a drug addict murder I believe. The problem is that this supposedly genius detective ran the experiment with him sitting and observing a couple of foot away. Then, when the rats didn't go for it, he concluded it was due to the drugs, not to do with the fact he was sitting right there watching! Argh! The writing just seems to be getting lazier and lazier, he doesn't seem intelligent or special and I think at the beginning Elementary had promise but it's gone right downhill. 

 

Sorry, rant over :P And yup off topic again. Oops.

  • Like 2
Posted

Heh, that's where Sherlock really gets his bolts of inspiration. :D

 

I liked Elementary initially, but it started losing me with the watering down of all the characters;

 

John - Military doctor newly invalided home from a war. No, doctor who lost confidence so became a sober companion.

Mycroft - THE British government. No, a restauranteur.

Lestrade - A good cop who perhaps relies on Sherlock a little too much. No, a snivelling, slimy and backhanded excuse of a copper. (Note; this is Lestrade not Gregson.)

Papa Holmes - I'm not aware of many previous incarnations of him, but I HATE this one - the less said there the better.

 

Even Sherlock, I liked him in the first season, and I think there was a moment between Joan and Sherlock when he asked her to stay on as his partner, but since then he's been played/written as increasingly autistic and dull. He doesn't seem particularly intelligent or insightful, I don't know if I've ever seen him deduce anyone more than any of the other characters, certainly not in any of the recent episodes, and on the odd occasion he does an experiment it's something dumb. I remember in a recent episode he had set up what I very loosely term an experiment involving setting up drugged meat in a park so see if the rats would go for it or if they would be able to smell/sense the drugs and hence avoid it. Something vaguely to do with a drug addict murder I believe. The problem is that this supposedly genius detective ran the experiment with him sitting and observing a couple of foot away. Then, when the rats didn't go for it, he concluded it was due to the drugs, not to do with the fact he was sitting right there watching! Argh! The writing just seems to be getting lazier and lazier, he doesn't seem intelligent or special and I think at the beginning Elementary had promise but it's gone right downhill.

 

Sorry, rant over :P And yup off topic again. Oops.

This just shows that there is a very reasonable deduction that there probably isn't a joanlock conspiracy to any extent remotely close to that of our version's johnlock conspiracy.

  • Like 1
Posted

Maybe that's enough to squelch a "Joanlock conspiracy?" But it seems like, if you want Sherlock and John together specifically, you would have to see something in the fundamental Holmes/Watson relationship that allows for that, so that it is a possibility in most/all incarnations. Maybe?

 

Definitely. And as far as I know, speculation of this kind about these characters has indeed been around almost ever since they existed, because Victorian writing was so indirect and so coded that if somebody had wanted to write about a gay couple, the result would not have been much different.

 

As for Elementary, I can't say anything about that because I have never watched it - and I don't intend to.

 

I'm surprised they didn't make Sherlock female, or both female and just gone the whole hog. I think we could do with a female Sherlock who is just as anti-social and arsey as the male version.

 

Yes. I want a female Sherlock. And I want her to be played by Louise Brealey. And I want the first episode to have the following title: "Sherlock is actually a girl's name."

  • Like 4
Posted

I just can't see Louise Brealey as Sherlock. I like her, but she's too mousey. Sherlock is supposed to be impressive and striking, bright and sharp, I see him/her as being borderline intimidating and Brealey just isn't. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I just can't see Louise Brealey as Sherlock. I like her, but she's too mousey. Sherlock is supposed to be impressive and striking, bright and sharp, I see him/her as being borderline intimidating and Brealey just isn't. 

 

Well, Diana Rigg is too old for the role now. And ever since I saw Louise Brealey in Sherlock's wig doing that classic pose, I have been thinking that she could very well play a female version. I bet she can do much more than mousy Molly. She's a fantastic actress.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

She's physically mousey though, even if she is playing badass, make up and costume can only do so much. I can see her being more convincing as John maybe, I think she could rock at something like that, playing someone much more dangerous and tough than they originally seem. The only female mock up I'm ever seen as convincing is Eva Green, who I'm not even that keen on, but she definitely has the sharp, intimidating stare. 

 

Edit: it's the physicality not the personality I have issue with. Changing the personality is what acting is all about, physicality is what a lot of actors are hired for along with their skills, they have to look the part, Martin would never have been hired as Sherlock for example no matter how talented he is. 

Posted

You mean she's short? Well, who says Sherlock Holmes has to be tall. Especially if you change his gender.

 

I do think the character should always be a little androgynous.

Posted

No, not just short. I just don't see it, great to those of you who do, but I don't.  :bouncy:

Posted

I just don't see it, great to those of you who do, but I don't.  :bouncy:

 

... and we're back on topic! :D

 

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm too tired for further debate, lol.

Posted

 

She's physically mousey though, even if she is playing badass,

I would say she's badass playing mousey. :)

This was the greatest surprise at Sherlocked. My jaw hit the floor...

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.