Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Has there ever been a conspiracy theory that has been proven to be true? There's so many of them, you'd think at least one would have turned out to be correct. But I'm drawing a blank ... (can't even think of a theory, let alone one that's been proved, to be honest. :smile: )

 

[....]

 

You mean because the quality of the acting makes you believe the characters are real? Or am I misunderstanding? Hmmm, I really do need to try and find some examples. Ooof, sounds like work. :smile: And even then, they'll be so dated .... well, we'll see.

No, there aren't any conspiracy theories that have been proven, because once they're proven they're no longer conspiracy theories, they're history. (Or, to quote Louise Mortimer, you're only a nutter if you're wrong.) For example, Watergate.

 

Yes, the quality of the acting, writing, and directing makes the characters and their friendship seem very real to me. By comparison, other shows I've watched seem kinda "low resolution."

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, that's sort of what I meant, I guess ... have any of them become accepted as historical fact? I actually did a google, but no "reliable" site came up (do we even have those any more? :smile: )

 

Okay, I see what you mean about "more real." Just wanted to make sure. So that kinda confirms what I thought; if I found some examples from, say, the 70's, it would look so campy by today's standards that it wouldn't mean anything. Good, let's me off the hook. :p

Posted

Well, that's sort of what I meant, I guess ... have any of them become accepted as historical fact?

 

Watergate ain't good enough for ya?  I mean, if Woodward and Bernstein hadn't been able to come up with strong evidence, people would have dismissed them as just another couple of conspiracy buffs.

 

Okay, I see what you mean about "more real." Just wanted to make sure. So that kinda confirms what I thought; if I found some examples from, say, the 70's, it would look so campy by today's standards that it wouldn't mean anything. Good, let's me off the hook. :p

It definitely does.  Just as one example, back in the late 70's, I was really hooked on a mystery show called Quincy, ME (with Jack Klugman as a medical examiner).  We recently bought the DVD with great anticipation -- and the acting was umm, highly stylized? overblown? soap-opera-ish?  Anyhow, we gave up after just a few episodes, just couldn't get into it anymore.

  • Like 3
Posted

Conspiracy theory, try Project MK Ultra.

It's a conspiracy theory about CIA's secret brainwashing and mind control experiment during Cold War that turned out to be true.

 

And if I'm not wrong, that is not the only disturbing conspiracy theory about CIA.

Posted

Watergate! Of course. How quickly we forget.

 

There's LOADS of conspiracy theories surrounding the CIA. Stirring up suspicions is what they do best. :d

Posted

 

 

 

 

Actually, we can be pretty sure Sherlock isn't in love with John since we've spent a whole 90 min inside his mind palace now. Mind palace on drugs, mind you. I would have thought that when in the privacy of his own head, with his inhibitions lowered by large doses of illegal substances, he would let his fantasies and wishes run amok at least at little if he had any. He'd have to be pretty far in denial to not even "let" himself be with John in his imagination if that was what he wanted. We know he has no problem fooling around with a naked Irene in there when he's not "busy". The mind palace clearly isn't all work and no play...

 

Of course John is there in the mind palace, features prominently, keeps Sherlock right, calls his BS and comes to save his ass when it counts the most. And yes, Mary is conveniently absent often, to the point where it seems that Sherlock initially forgot all about her and then inserted her not-amused person with an ooops, wait, I forgot John doesn't live with me any more sort of jerk. I do think Sherlock wishes that things could go back to the way they were, but if John were single and back at Baker St, he wouldn't be trying to get into his pants, he'd be trying to make him run around London chasing criminals at all hours. Sherlock genuinely is "married to his work", so his work partner may well be just as important to him as another person's lover is to them. But that doesn't mean he'd like to make John his lover. Sherlock just operates on a different system than most people. That's my take on him, anyway. 

 

 

I was thinking about this last night.  (In relation to Star Trek, actually, but that's too long of a digression.)  I'm really glad that I took the time to watch TAB about 3-4 times and even write a fan fic or two before I really got online and started seeing other opinions.  My perceptions of TAB are pretty well solidified, and I don't think there's an argument that could make me see the whole thing as Johnlock at this point.

 

As you say, the entire thing was a 90 minute, drug fueled, mental exploration in Sherlock's head about his opinion on women.  And they are all there; Molly, who he has sidelined into a "work only" relationship; Janine, who joins Molly in a lineup that is explicitly named as "potential brides;" Irene, carried in the watch fob that he wears every day; and even Ms. Admirably-High-Arches, who Sherlock must have noticed while he was high, while he was boarding a plane getting ready to be exiled.  The man clearly notices women.

 

He sits in the mind-palace greenhouse and basically has an argument with himself (in the person of mind-palace John) about why he won't let himself get close enough to any woman to marry them; it's him that brings up the word marriage, not John.  And then, to top it all off, yes, mental-Moriarty does in fact say that John and Sherlock should elope, but the pair of them (both Sherlock; still the mind palace) call that "impertinent" and "offensive" and push Moriarty off a waterfall.  

 

Sherlock may indeed be thinking a lot about sexuality, but I think he's considering if it is something that he's as entitled to as John is.  Of course, it was not surprising that others saw this as an epic sexual romance for the two boys, but I've got my perspective.

 

The frustrating thing about TJLC is that sometimes the "proofs" are so arcane that I keep wondering if I'm either watching a different show or watching the same show "wrong," and that's when I start to feel marginalized in the fandom.  One proof that I read said that because there was a torch somewhere in the greenhouse scene that it symbolized Sherlock asking himself "do I still carry a torch for John."  Now, either that's some intricate textual analysis that's way over my head, or we're basically watching different shows.

 

I'll allow that one or the other or both could theoretically have sexual feelings for the other, but the way I imagine it is not something I think TJLC would like either.  Short version:

 

SHERLOCK:  "John, I've deduced that you are sexually attracted to me; I find myself reciprocating.  Fancy a shag?"

JOHN: "Yep, you're right.  Delighted to."

(The two walk into the bedroom.  45 minutes later....)

SHERLOCK: (smoothing down his shirt) "I'm starving; fancy a Chinese?"

JOHN: "A curry, I think."

SHERLOCK: "Fine."

  • Like 3
Posted

 

I'll allow that one or the other or both could theoretically have sexual feelings for the other, but the way I imagine it is not something I think TJLC would like either.  Short version:

 

SHERLOCK:  "John, I've deduced that you are sexually attracted to me; I find myself reciprocating.  Fancy a shag?"

JOHN: "Yep, you're right.  Delighted to."

(The two walk into the bedroom.  45 minutes later....)

SHERLOCK: (smoothing down his shirt) "I'm starving; fancy a Chinese?"

JOHN: "A curry, I think."

SHERLOCK: "Fine."

 

 

:D lol

  • Like 1
Posted

I think I've read that fanfic.  But yours is way funnier!  :D

  • Like 1
Posted
The frustrating thing about TJLC is that sometimes the "proofs" are so arcane that I keep wondering if I'm either watching a different show or watching the same show "wrong," and that's when I start to feel marginalized in the fandom. 

 

I don't think there is a "wrong" way of watching anything, especially something created mainly to entertain. We fans may get very passionate about the works we love and think very long and hard about them, but a show like Sherlock doesn't usually aspire to bring us any important philosophical, political, sociological or whatever message. If we want to find meaning in it, we largely have to create that for ourselves.

 

I found this observation by fanfic author (among other things) Plaidder on her blog the other day and I thought it was spot on:

 

(...) the power of TJLC is not just about the ship. TJLC is an explanatory narrative. It creates meaning. It assures the believer that the show *means something.*

 

I think many fan theories in many fandoms come to being in a similar way. Nerds and geeks and like-minded people take comic books, movies, games and TV shows way more seriously than the people who make them and attach a much deeper meaning to the content. The actually comparatively shallow nature of the source material, however, does not satisfy us as a rule rather intelligent and reflective beings, and so we end up burdening it with the ideas and revelations it triggered our brains to come up with based on our own experiences, expectations, questions and problems.

 

Sherlock is actually hella (and if you can tell me why I am all of a sudden using that expression, then I will consider you an uber-nerd and / or a weirdo like me, whatever you prefer :lol:) high-brow compared to other franchises I have witnessed people get into heated discussions about on the internet. The other day, I saw a youtube video where grown men got into a shouting match and almost went at each other's throats over the question whether "Suicide Squad" deserved the bad reviews it has gotten so far. It did not look staged or scripted. I shook my head in disbelief, turned up my nose ready to be all snooty and snobby about it and then it occurred to me that wait, this is what we Sherlock fans look like to the rest of the world, too! :D

 

Posted

 

 

(...) the power of TJLC is not just about the ship. TJLC is an explanatory narrative. It creates meaning. It assures the believer that the show *means something.*

 

I think many fan theories in many fandoms come to being in a similar way. Nerds and geeks and like-minded people take comic books, movies, games and TV shows way more seriously than the people who make them and attach a much deeper meaning to the content. The actually comparatively shallow nature of the source material, however, does not satisfy us as a rule rather intelligent and reflective beings, and so we end up burdening it with the ideas and revelations it triggered our brains to come up with based on our own experiences, expectations, questions and problems.

 

 

 

So, perhaps similar to the Aspie!Sherlock debate.  So many people take John's comment in HoB about Sherlock having Asperger's (now just called ASD, I know) seriously, and a lot of people have found a great deal of meaning in having a "hero" or a protagonist who is not just visible in the story but who might represent a goal of sorts.  And I've seen lots of really heated debates on Tumblr about why he does/doesn't have Asperger's.  (Personally, I think John was just being a little snot when he said that, but I can't deny that Sherlock sometimes behaves like he's on the spectrum somewhere.)

  • Like 1
Posted

... I've seen lots of really heated debates on Tumblr about why he does/doesn't have Asperger's.  (Personally, I think John was just being a little snot when he said that, but I can't deny that Sherlock sometimes behaves like he's on the spectrum somewhere.)

Being a snot?  The scene doesn't strike me that way, but perhaps I'm misunderstanding what meant.

 

My take is this:  Lestrade is groping for a word to describe Sherlock's behavior, and John (feeling called upon to be the medical expert) simply picks a fairly-plausible term, probably somewhat at random.  His tone of voice sounds to me like a verbal shrug, so I'd say he doesn't intend that to be interpreted as a diagnosis.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

... I've seen lots of really heated debates on Tumblr about why he does/doesn't have Asperger's.  (Personally, I think John was just being a little snot when he said that, but I can't deny that Sherlock sometimes behaves like he's on the spectrum somewhere.)

Being a snot?  The scene doesn't strike me that way, but perhaps I'm misunderstanding what meant.

 

My take is this:  Lestrade is groping for a word to describe Sherlock's behavior, and John (feeling called upon to be the medical expert) simply picks a fairly-plausible term, probably somewhat at random.  His tone of voice sounds to me like a verbal shrug, so I'd say he doesn't intend that to be interpreted as a diagnosis.

 

 

I think it's all in how you hear it.  I hear a little bit of frustration in John's voice or see it in his body language or something, and I think he's throwing out a term that he knows Lestrade will understand the meaning behind.  (That is, that thanks to Sherlock's inability/lack of desire to read social cues, he's just no fun to go on a trip with.)  I don't think he even comes close to meaning it to be diagnostic, but I also know there are certain areas of Tumblr where you'd better not say that!

  • Like 3
Posted

That's always the way I've heard it too, for what that's worth. John just deflating Sherlock's balloon.

  • Like 1
Posted

I am wondering what would happen if the creators and actors have love lost with the series because of this (or maybe other things) and decide to kill Sherlock, similar to what ACD did originally.

 

How would the fans react in this internet-social-media time?

Posted

I am wondering what would happen if the creators and actors have love lost with the series because of this (or maybe other things) and decide to kill Sherlock, similar to what ACD did originally.

 

How would the fans react in this internet-social-media time?

:-D Nobody would believe he was really dead. The net would be ablaze with theories on how he pulled it off this time.

  • Like 5
Posted

Aiz, that is so true and so obvious.

 

And when they make statement in public and say that he is really dead, the net would call them liars and try to read between invisible lines.

New conspiracy, maybe TNSC "The Notdead Sherlock Conspiracy" would take root.

 

Meanwhile, I would crawl to my corner and bawl.

  • Like 3
Posted

It would be the trending hashtag #iBelieveInSherlockHolmes or #SherlockLives. Matching t-shirts everywhere. And mugs, and keyrings, and buttons etc etc. 

  • Like 1
Posted

And I would so be one of the conspirators! Sherlock Holmes is immortal. If his original creator couldn't kill him, then nobody can. Poor Doyle tried so hard to get rid of his most famous character, but he was just too much for him. Not even retirement worked out - come WWI, the great detective was back in the field.

 

Moffat and Co can decide whom he does and doesn't sleep with, but they sure don't have the power to end his life - or career. :-p

  • Like 4
Posted

And I would so be one of the conspirators! Sherlock Holmes is immortal. If his original creator couldn't kill him, then nobody can. Poor Doyle tried so hard to get rid of his most famous character, but he was just too much for him. Not even retirement worked out - come WWI, the great detective was back in the field.

 

Moffat and Co can decide whom he does and doesn't sleep with, but they sure don't have the power to end his life - or career. :-p

 

Sherlock Holmes was the original reboot king before reboots were cool.  

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Sherlock Holmes was the original reboot king before reboots were cool.  

 

 

Hipster Sherlock? That's why he wears a deerstalker :P

  • Like 2
Posted

But if Benedict's Sherlock died, I don't think any other reboot would work for me.

No other Sherlocks did.

Posted

As far as I'm aware, nobody's ever killed off Sherlock Holmes -- except for Conan Doyle's failed attempt.

Posted

One is either a Sherlock Holmes fan or a BC one, apparently! I am firmly in the camp of Sherlock Holmes, having watched from Rathbone to the modern version, going through Micael Caine (the horror!), John Gielgud on radio, Peter Cushing, Christopher Plummer, the idiot in the Private Life of Sherlock Holmes, Jeremy Brett above all else, Sir Ian McKellan's old Holmes, even Spielberg's Young Holmes series.

  • Like 1
Posted

Or just a fan of good storytelling. That's what drew me in.

Posted

Or just a fan of good storytelling. That's what drew me in.

 

Yup-P.

And The Voice. I have to admit that one hot me first. :p

 

 

As far as I'm aware, nobody's ever killed off Sherlock Holmes -- except for Conan Doyle's failed attempt.

There is always first time for everything?

First modern Sherlock, first female John, ..

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.