Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Is Sherlock the first fandom for most of you? Disclaimer: I'm honestly curious, not trying to be patronizing or anything likewise stupid, but it seems many of you have never seen a shipping war before.

 

 

 

Not my first fandom; I was/am part of Star Trek and Harry Potter.  But this is the first fandom for which I've actively sought out people to discuss the material with. I was vaguely aware of slash back in grad school because I had heard of Kirk/Spock fan fiction, but I thought that was preposterous, and it was easy to avoid.  I just didn't seek that out if I went to a convention (which, full disclosure, I've only done about 3 times, and two of those times were with my Dad, so we weren't seeking out any shipping of any kind!).  And, like I've said before, I think Roddenberry also subtly encouraged that part of the fandom while officially disclaiming it, through his support of words like the Vulcan t'hy'la.  

 

I had never heard the term "shipping" before the Sherlock fandom, and I honestly still don't particularly enjoy trying to impose a sexual/romantic relationship on any characters beyond what I see portrayed on screen.  That doesn't mean I don't now understand the fun of creating an AU in which there are relationships that are not strictly canonical and then seeing how that changes (or doesn't change) the dynamic.

 

While I will probably never be a proponent of TJLC, fiction that underlines the fact that inserting superimposing a sexual relationship on Sherlock and John would probably change absolutely nothing about the canon relationship that we see on screen would probably go a long way toward making me enjoy their position argument more. However, a lot of the stuff seems to turn into things that change the fundamental natures of the characters or the relationship.

  • Like 1
Posted

Is Sherlock the first fandom for most of you? Disclaimer: I'm honestly curious, not trying to be patronizing or anything likewise stupid, but it seems many of you have never seen a shipping war before.

 

For me, it is definitely the first. In fact, I detested the very word "fan" before I knew Sherlock and I would have never called myself one of anything. I was the teenager who never hung up any posters. I didn't even know the expression "to ship" somebody with somebody else until it was mentioned on this forum. Of course I know the feeling... I used to become so emotionally invested in the protagonists of my favorite books that I often had to go ahead and read the ending in advance to make sure everything would be all right and person A would end up with person B before I could go on with the story. If I had had internet access and found an online community that discussed Victorian novels, I would sure as hell have signed up there. I always wished there was someone whom I could talk to about what I read. But there wasn't. In retrospect, that probably saved me a world of drama at an age where I had an abundance of that anyway and no emotional resilience whatsoever.

 

Also, I have never before followed a work in progress. Any other work of fiction I ever got excited about was (often long since) finished, so there really couldn't have been much speculation about future developments. As for subtext interpretation, yeah, I know that there are for example people who believe that Jane Austen's Emma is gay and in love with Harriet, but they can't very well dig the author up and tell her so plus the book clearly and unmistakably ends with Emma marrying a guy out of her own free will and being perfectly happy with that. So I doubt there's much room for the kind of discussion we're seeing here.

 

I don't think I've come across anything so extreme that the creators are genuinely upset enough to have to make an official statement about it.

 

I suspect that it's particularly hurtful for Mr Gatiss to be accused of somehow "failing" gay people and / or to be told that just because he is gay himself, he has to write his stories and characters a certain way. Doubly so because he has stated plenty of times that he does care a lot about gay representation and gay rights. It would be like people telling me that because I write one female character in such and such a way, I am hurting women and women's rights in general and if I don't change my story, I clearly do not care about my gender at all. I would make a hell of an official statement too, I can tell you...

 

...I don't think that Moffat and Gatiss are such entirely blameless victims in this as they apparently see themselves. To keep planting hints and allegations into a series from ep1 onwards, to have in-series shippers like Mrs Hudson, and then act all surprised that some folks think this all has some meaning and to declare that as absurd, that's disingenuous if you ask me. You tease a ship, you get shippers - and like I said above, I have yet to see anything about TJLC that makes it extreme or stand out from other shipping wars in any way (idiots are sadly everywhere, so that in itself is not unusual, the world would be a better place if it were).

 

In spite of what I said above, I have got to agree with you here. After reading some interviews with the above named gentlemen, I have wanted to ask them if they have actually seen their own show recently. Unlike on Star Trek, for example (as far as I know, correct me if I am wrong), it was them who brought the matter up in the first place, explicitly and repeatedly, on screen. I am very willing to believe that they did not anticipate how far the fandom would run with their little jokes, but it is easy enough to see where it started.

 

My biggest concern here is a very selfish one: I really do fear that all this will do the show harm. It will lose it's innocence, so to speak, and become terribly cautious and self-conscious. I actually liked the fun. The joke was never on John and Sherlock or on gay people in general, it was on all the others, real and fictional, who see sex everywhere and can't imagine any relationship outside of the few neat little boxes they are used to ticking off inside their silly little brains. It was on the fans since Sherlock Holmes began, on stuffy old Doyle and Victorian culture. Also, there was a serious undertone to it that I really appreciated. When Irene says "you're a couple", she's not entirely wrong. What she sees and what Mrs Hudson and Mycroft and Mary and even villains like Moriarty and Magnussen see and comment on is something very real and tender and touching that yes, from what I have been shown so far, I would call love. It's not anything exclusive - John can get married, Sherlock can experiment with Janine and continue his strange romance with Molly and fantasize about Irene's naked body - and it has very little to do with sex. But it's real. It's also, from my point of view, the heart and soul of this show, and if it's taken away just because some radical fans couldn't handle it and the creators couldn't handle their reactions, well... I will be terribly disappointed, that's all.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

...I don't think that Moffat and Gatiss are such entirely blameless victims in this as they apparently see themselves. To keep planting hints and allegations into a series from ep1 onwards, to have in-series shippers like Mrs Hudson, and then act all surprised that some folks think this all has some meaning and to declare that as absurd, that's disingenuous if you ask me. You tease a ship, you get shippers - and like I said above, I have yet to see anything about TJLC that makes it extreme or stand out from other shipping wars in any way (idiots are sadly everywhere, so that in itself is not unusual, the world would be a better place if it were).

 

In spite of what I said above, I have got to agree with you here. After reading some interviews with the above named gentlemen, I have wanted to ask them if they have actually seen their own show recently. Unlike on Star Trek, for example (as far as I know, correct me if I am wrong), it was them who brought the matter up in the first place, explicitly and repeatedly, on screen. I am very willing to believe that they did not anticipate how far the fandom would run with their little jokes, but it is easy enough to see where it started.

 

My biggest concern here is a very selfish one: I really do fear that all this will do the show harm. It will lose it's innocence, so to speak, and become terribly cautious and self-conscious. I actually liked the fun. The joke was never on John and Sherlock or on gay people in general, it was on all the others, real and fictional, who see sex everywhere and can't imagine any relationship outside of the few neat little boxes they are used to ticking off inside their silly little brains. It was on the fans since Sherlock Holmes began, on stuffy old Doyle and Victorian culture. Also, there was a serious undertone to it that I really appreciated. When Irene says "you're a couple", she's not entirely wrong. What she sees and what Mrs Hudson and Mycroft and Mary and even villains like Moriarty and Magnussen see and comment on is something very real and tender and touching that yes, from what I have been shown so far, I would call love. It's not anything exclusive - John can get married, Sherlock can experiment with Janine and continue his strange romance with Molly and fantasize about Irene's naked body - and it has very little to do with sex. But it's real. It's also, from my point of view, the heart and soul of this show, and if it's taken away just because some radical fans couldn't handle it and the creators couldn't handle their reactions, well... I will be terribly disappointed, that's all.

 

 

Exactly. Toby, you are so brilliant at this kind of analysis. I'm so jealous. :smile:

 

But I have to wonder ... why is it that some of us can see that the joke is just a joke, and that the joke is on the viewers? And those who don't see the jokes, who interpret them as clues ... are they somehow to blame for their "failure of imagination"? Or to put it the other way around, are Moftiss to blame for those who fail to get the joke? I don't know ... that's a puzzler to me. It doesn't seem quite fair to lay blame on either side, to be honest. Ah, I know ... they could share the blame! :D

 

I think probably Moftiss are also weary of being called liars when they're not lying. Been there, done that, I made a heartfelt and public (not that public! :smile: ) statement defending myself too. I wouldn't even call their real lies "lying" ... they're just protecting their work from being spoiled before it's even viewed. Call it "misdirecting." Personally, I thank them for that from the bottom of my heart.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

 

My biggest concern here is a very selfish one: I really do fear that all this will do the show harm. It will lose it's innocence, so to speak, and become terribly cautious and self-conscious. I actually liked the fun. The joke was never on John and Sherlock or on gay people in general, it was on all the others, real and fictional, who see sex everywhere and can't imagine any relationship outside of the few neat little boxes they are used to ticking off inside their silly little brains. It was on the fans since Sherlock Holmes began, on stuffy old Doyle and Victorian culture. Also, there was a serious undertone to it that I really appreciated. When Irene says "you're a couple", she's not entirely wrong. What she sees and what Mrs Hudson and Mycroft and Mary and even villains like Moriarty and Magnussen see and comment on is something very real and tender and touching that yes, from what I have been shown so far, I would call love. It's not anything exclusive - John can get married, Sherlock can experiment with Janine and continue his strange romance with Molly and fantasize about Irene's naked body - and it has very little to do with sex. But it's real. It's also, from my point of view, the heart and soul of this show, and if it's taken away just because some radical fans couldn't handle it and the creators couldn't handle their reactions, well... I will be terribly disappointed, that's all.

 

 

^^^ This x1000  Well said, Toby.

  • Like 1
Posted

Now that we've all depressed ourselves by fearing the show will change ... let me point out that Moftiss themselves have said the relationship between the boys IS the show, or words to that effect. Right from the beginning, when they cast Martin, and many times since. Yeah, they could change their minds and go a different way, but I'd hate to put money on it. :smile:

  • Like 2
Posted

Now that we've all depressed ourselves by fearing the show will change ... let me point out that Moftiss themselves have said the relationship between the boys IS the show, or words to that effect. Right from the beginning, when they cast Martin, and many times since. Yeah, they could change their minds and go a different way, but I'd hate to put money on it. :smile:

Let's hope you are right. After all, the topic was forced on them after series 2 as well and look what we got next - three episodes that left even me wondering whether there wasn't maybe more to the relationship than I had thought so far. (How they can seriously be surprised by fan hopes and theories after series 3 is a mystery to me. Are guys really this naive about feelings and relationships?)

  • Like 1
Posted

Mofftiss fault was to assume people were joking too.I
It would be stupid on the other hand, to expect them to monitor the fandom and watch what's fermenting there.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Are guys really this naive about feelings and relationships?

I was this naive. But then, I shouldn't be taken for an example of an average fan... :P

  • Like 1
Posted

(How they can seriously be surprised by fan hopes and theories after series 3 is a mystery to me. Are guys really this naive about feelings and relationships?)

Guilty too. Naive is the nicer word. Clueless fits as well.

 

To be honest, I thought John-Sherlock was meant to be a joke and I found it funny, I enjoyed and I laughed, nothing more. Nothing mean, just clueless.

So when we were in subtext thread, I found out that there are people who see it differently. Based on natural curiosity, I am genuinely interested to see the reason behind it, but from what were presented, I don't buy it.

 

That is fine, I am honest about not buying it and even find some 'proves' ridiculous, but again, agree to disagree, we just look at things differently. Still, I thought everything is fair and fun.

 

Then lately, it appears to me that JL was taken THAT seriously, it's very surprising to me. Again, I saw it as a joke and I think that is what the creators meant as well. So when I see that the jokes have devastating impact to some, I feel a bit of guilt because I don't want to laugh at the cost of that, for this case. (I say for this case, because I am a jerk who actually enjoy laughing at other people's expenses when I believe they deserve it. But to be fair to myself, I will defend people who are not deserved to be laughed at, and to be fair again, I am that jerk who will laugh at a friend's face to ease the tension and my inability to deal with overloading emotion like TEH end train scene, so okay, I am a jerk).

 

Anyway, yes, I don't want to laugh on this matter because the jokes actually devastating for many Johnlockers, and I feel bad I didn't realize that.

 

However, maybe there is room for them to understand too that there are people who think that as purely jokes without meaning any harm, disrespect or undermining their beliefs. Clueless, yes, but not everyone is equipped with the same understanding about feelings and relationships. And imho that is what the creators were trying to explain in the con, and with them saying that it will never happen, it's not at all to laugh or run away or punishment, but to prevent Johnlockers getting their hopes up and I think they mean well. Are they? Yes, I believe so.

 

So when it leads to even more outrages, insults, abuses, threats it doesn't go well with me at all. I don't think they deserve that. It's their show. I get that people are disappointed when it 'strays' from books or strays from expectation, feel free to show it, to talk about it, about why it disappoints you, BUT don't forget the reasons, the logic, not (insert abuse, insult, critic) just because it's not in the book or it doesn't meet your expectation (without further reasonings). Those are lame excuses, and I tend not to respect that. But when the excuse are something like it doesn't fit the character because I think JL is obvious from the way this that reason, based on this that events, then those are fair, there are reasonings. I don't always agree but I'd respect it.

 

Bottom line to me, whatever is that, it's not okay to threaten, insult, abuse and name calling when things doesn't go their way. Again, I don't think the creators and actors deserve that. Fundamental point: it's their show.

 

And yes, good point that not all JL do that and it should be remembered. I am sure some of them are horrified with their fellow shippers.

And yes, I feel very bad for Gatiss.

Now if the both creators are straight, the attack would be different, the point is, people always find things to blame. It's not entirely bad, but be civil about it.

  • Like 3
Posted

I've been thinking about this off and on today, and it all seems terribly familiar. But I'm not sure why. I've never been this involved in a fandom before -- (which I attribute mainly to the internet. I participate because I can; not like the old days, when I had to drive an hour to another town to find like-minded fans. Only to end up being .... ahem ... the oldest person (by far) in the room. Awkward!)

 

Yup.  Been there.  (Same thing with the midnight showing of The Hobbit.)  I don't mind, though -- as long as the younger fans aren't actually acting childish. ( Child-like is fine.  I think I do that myself sometimes.)

 

Anyway, the nearest thing I can think of that felt like this was the Kennedy assassination conspiracy theories. I never believed them, and I never saw any "evidence" to make me think otherwise. But I knew a few people who believed in them fervently (a couple right in my own family!) -- based on the same evidence that convinced me that it wasn't true. Go figure.

 

I read one such book, and found it quite interesting.  If everything the author said was true (and I have no idea whether it was or not), then he made a very good case that there was some sort of hanky-panky going on.  But I'd have to do a whole lot more reading and Googling to have anything like an opinion.  Right now, I'm not sure I believe anybody!

 

I'm guessing that's what drives a lot of the fervor ... not the desire for representation, but the desire to simply be proven "right". To be proven smarter, more observant, more clever than everyone else. Because if they're not proven right, they're going to look a bit foolish, or simply nuts? At any rate, I think that's what feels familiar to me ... the burning need to prove everyone else wrong.

 

Not sure that's quite it.  Can't say for sure, since I'm not one of that crowd, but I think the crux might be more like the desire for validation -- not precisely being proven right, but more like being taken seriously.  Unfortunately, nowadays, the world seems to be telling people that in order to be taken seriously, they have to prove everybody else wrong, and I think that's unfortunate.  A dialog can be a whole lot more rewarding than merely shutting everybody up.

 

And I don't think that Moffat and Gatiss are such entirely blameless victims in this as they apparently see themselves. To keep planting hints and allegations into a series from ep1 onwards, to have in-series shippers like Mrs Hudson, and then act all surprised that some folks think this all has some meaning and to declare that as absurd, that's disingenuous if you ask me. You tease a ship, you get shippers - and like I said above, I have yet to see anything about TJLC that makes it extreme or stand out from other shipping wars in any way (idiots are sadly everywhere, so that in itself is not unusual, the world would be a better place if it were).

 

I agree with you regarding Moftiss's apparent naivety.  I balk at the use of the word "idiots" however.  Anyone with an active imagination sometimes goes off in a direction not intended by the originators.  That doesn't make them wrong, just different.  (That does not, however, justify them bad-mouthing people who disagree with them -- or vice versa.)

 

Is Sherlock the first fandom for most of you? Disclaimer: I'm honestly curious, not trying to be patronizing or anything likewise stupid, but it seems many of you have never seen a shipping war before.

 

Not my first fandom, no.  But it's my first really active online fandom.  Back when fandoms operated at the speed of the post office, it was a bit harder to get up a head of steam!

 

Also, I have never before followed a work in progress. Any other work of fiction I ever got excited about was (often long since) finished, so there really couldn't have been much speculation about future developments....

Y'know, that may well be a strong factor.  By the time Star Trek fandom really got rolling, the show was just about off the air, and wouldn't get going again (in the original-cast films) for several more years.  So we were working with a completely known canon.

 

Unlike on Star Trek, for example (as far as I know, correct me if I am wrong), it was them who brought the matter up in the first place, explicitly and repeatedly, on screen. I am very willing to believe that they did not anticipate how far the fandom would run with their little jokes, but it is easy enough to see where it started.

 

I do believe you're right that there were no such hints on the original Star Trek series.  (For one thing, neither the FCC nor the network would have permitted it.)  The only original-cast possibility I can offhand think of was the hand-clasp that Spock initiated with Kirk at the end of The Motion Picture, some years after the dawn of K/S fanfiction.  Many fans (including the one who posted that screencap) have said it proves that Spock and Kirk were romantically involved.  And who knows, Roddenberry may well have intended that.  I certainly don't know!

 

But I have to wonder ... why is it that some of us can see that the joke is just a joke, and that the joke is on the viewers? And those who don't see the jokes, who interpret them as clues ... are they somehow to blame for their "failure of imagination"? Or to put it the other way around, are Moftiss to blame for those who fail to get the joke? I don't know ... that's a puzzler to me. It doesn't seem quite fair to lay blame on either side, to be honest. Ah, I know ... they could share the blame! :D

 

Just because Moftiss apparently meant it as a joke doesn't mean that's the only reasonable way to interpret it.

 

Someone ordered an article on slash/ship and where it comes from?

https://www.1843magazine.com/features/to-boldly-go

 

Thanks!  (But just to clarify a somewhat ambiguous statement in that article, I'm virtually certain that Spockanalia never printed any slash.)

  • Like 3
Posted

 

Now that we've all depressed ourselves by fearing the show will change ... let me point out that Moftiss themselves have said the relationship between the boys IS the show, or words to that effect. Right from the beginning, when they cast Martin, and many times since. Yeah, they could change their minds and go a different way, but I'd hate to put money on it. :smile:

Let's hope you are right. After all, the topic was forced on them after series 2 as well and look what we got next - three episodes that left even me wondering whether there wasn't maybe more to the relationship than I had thought so far. (How they can seriously be surprised by fan hopes and theories after series 3 is a mystery to me. Are guys really this naive about feelings and relationships?)

 

I don't know about guys, but apparently I am that naïve. I didn't see anything other than male friendship until the possible other interpretations were pointed out to me. So yeah, if I'm anything to go by, I think it's entirely possible that Moftiss didn't realize that some people would take it the way they have.

 

Besides, I don't think they've said they're surprised, have they? Well, maybe they have, I can't remember. But it seems to me their concern is not so much that people are seeing a type of relationship they didn't intend. It's more that they don't want to be accused of "cheating" when the next series comes out, and it doesn't end up the way some people want it to. That must be very discouraging for a creator.

 

.... not everyone is equipped with the same understanding about feelings and relationships. And imho that is what the creators were trying to explain in the con, and with them saying that it will never happen, it's not at all to laugh or run away or punishment, but to prevent Johnlockers getting their hopes up and I think they mean well. Are they? Yes, I believe so.

Yeah. This. I believe so too.

 

Just because Moftiss apparently meant it as a joke doesn't mean that's the only reasonable way to interpret it.

Uh oh, I think we're back to "authorial intent" again. I still think it matters what they intended. Another interpretation may be reasonably possible, but once the author has made it clear what interpretation was intended, I'm afraid I still find it presumptious for fans to say they're lying and insist a different meaning is the only right one. I'm far less gracious on this matter than Moftiss have been, I fear. I guess because it strikes close to home.

Posted

 

And I don't think that Moffat and Gatiss are such entirely blameless victims in this as they apparently see themselves. To keep planting hints and allegations into a series from ep1 onwards, to have in-series shippers like Mrs Hudson, and then act all surprised that some folks think this all has some meaning and to declare that as absurd, that's disingenuous if you ask me. You tease a ship, you get shippers - and like I said above, I have yet to see anything about TJLC that makes it extreme or stand out from other shipping wars in any way (idiots are sadly everywhere, so that in itself is not unusual, the world would be a better place if it were).

 

I agree with you regarding Moftiss's apparent naivety.  I balk at the use of the word "idiots" however.  Anyone with an active imagination sometimes goes off in a direction not intended by the originators.  That doesn't make them wrong, just different.  (That does not, however, justify them bad-mouthing people who disagree with them -- or vice versa.)

 

Afraid this was badly worded by me, sorry - I NEVER meant to imply that all Johnlockers or TJLCers are idiots (and I point to my history on this board in defending the Johnlock PoV being as valid as anyone else's as evidence for the defense ;)), only that those among them who think that Moftiss *owe* them an on-screen Johnlock resolution and who are belligerent about this, are. This came across a bit clearer in my first post now that I'm re-reading this, so again, sorry for the misunderstanding.

 

 

Unlike on Star Trek, for example (as far as I know, correct me if I am wrong), it was them who brought the matter up in the first place, explicitly and repeatedly, on screen. I am very willing to believe that they did not anticipate how far the fandom would run with their little jokes, but it is easy enough to see where it started.

 

I do believe you're right that there were no such hints on the original Star Trek series.  (For one thing, neither the FCC nor the network would have permitted it.)  The only original-cast possibility I can offhand think of was the hand-clasp that Spock initiated with Kirk at the end of The Motion Picture, some years after the dawn of K/S fanfiction.  Many fans (including the one who posted that screencap) have said it proves that Spock and Kirk were romantically involved.  And who knows, Roddenberry may well have intended that.  I certainly don't know!

 

Wasn't there a discussion about Spock using the word t'h'yla in his thoughts about Kirk in the novelization? If Roddenberry wanted to squash the rumors, he certainly needn't have invented a Vulcan word that meant friend, brother or lover. Methinks he liked to toy with his audience, too. :smile: Love the Kirk quote, though, " ...  Also, I would dislike being thought of as so foolish that I would select a love partner who came into sexual heat only once every seven years." :lol:

  • Like 3
Posted

 

VBS:

Then lately, it appears to me that JL was taken THAT seriously, it's very surprising to me. Again, I saw it as a joke and I think that is what the creators meant as well. So when I see that the jokes have devastating impact to some, I feel a bit of guilt because I don't want to laugh at the cost of that, for this case. (I say for this case, because I am a jerk who actually enjoy laughing at other people's expenses when I believe they deserve it. But to be fair to myself, I will defend people who are not deserved to be laughed at, and to be fair again, I am that jerk who will laugh at a friend's face to ease the tension and my inability to deal with overloading emotion like TEH end train scene, so okay, I am a jerk).

In my understanding the jokes were not so much hurtful but were taken for clues of TJLC. And to be honest, there are no other clear - let's call them queer bits - in the show than those jokes. Isn't it that the clues/jokes not developing into something serious/true was the problem and not the jokes being hurtful?

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

And I don't think that Moffat and Gatiss are such entirely blameless victims in this as they apparently see themselves. To keep planting hints and allegations into a series from ep1 onwards, to have in-series shippers like Mrs Hudson, and then act all surprised that some folks think this all has some meaning and to declare that as absurd, that's disingenuous if you ask me. You tease a ship, you get shippers - and like I said above, I have yet to see anything about TJLC that makes it extreme or stand out from other shipping wars in any way (idiots are sadly everywhere, so that in itself is not unusual, the world would be a better place if it were).

 

I agree with you regarding Moftiss's apparent naivety.  I balk at the use of the word "idiots" however.  Anyone with an active imagination sometimes goes off in a direction not intended by the originators.  That doesn't make them wrong, just different.  (That does not, however, justify them bad-mouthing people who disagree with them -- or vice versa.)

 

Afraid this was badly worded by me, sorry - I NEVER meant to imply that all Johnlockers or TJLCers are idiots (and I point to my history on this board in defending the Johnlock PoV being as valid as anyone else's as evidence for the defense ;)), only that those among them who think that Moftiss *owe* them an on-screen Johnlock resolution and who are belligerent about this, are. This came across a bit clearer in my first post now that I'm re-reading this, so again, sorry for the misunderstanding.

 

For what it's worth, I understood your intent :smile: -- it's the people (on any side of the issue) who are abusive who are the idiots. It is, after all, intended to be entertainment, not a movement. Ooops, there I go with intent again. I guess that means I think it matters... ;)

 

Posted

 

 

VBS:

Then lately, it appears to me that JL was taken THAT seriously, it's very surprising to me. Again, I saw it as a joke and I think that is what the creators meant as well. So when I see that the jokes have devastating impact to some, I feel a bit of guilt because I don't want to laugh at the cost of that, for this case. (I say for this case, because I am a jerk who actually enjoy laughing at other people's expenses when I believe they deserve it. But to be fair to myself, I will defend people who are not deserved to be laughed at, and to be fair again, I am that jerk who will laugh at a friend's face to ease the tension and my inability to deal with overloading emotion like TEH end train scene, so okay, I am a jerk).

In my understanding the jokes were not so much hurtful but were taken for clues of TJLC. And to be honest, there are no other clear - let's call them queer bits - in the show than those jokes. Isn't it that the clues/jokes not developing into something serious/true was the problem and not the jokes being hurtful?

 

 

I think it goes a step beyond that. From what I've read, first the "hurt" stems from being told "no, you're wrong, the jokes are not clues." Then they get  angry because if the jokes aren't clues, then they must be queerbaiting. No other explanation, apparently.

 

And lord no, it's not just the jokes that are taken as "queer bits". Every time they look each other in the eyes, it's lust. John emerging from the shower in a robe means he's trying to seduce Sherlock. John touches Sherlock's knee; more lust. Oh, and my favorite; Sherlock drinks tea, which is "code" for being gay. It's all considered "obvious", for those with eyes to see.

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't know about guys, but apparently I am that naïve. I didn't see anything other than male friendship until the possible other interpretations were pointed out to me. So yeah, if I'm anything to go by, I think it's entirely possible that Moftiss didn't realize that some people would take it the way they have.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Yeah, me too.  I never saw anything but male friendship until it was pointed out online, and even now, I have to watch and say, "now, Boton, try to see the sexual subtext" in order to see it.  Mr. Boton, who is only a casual fan but who hears me talk about subtext once in a while, will walk by when I'm re-watching, pause for a scene, and say, "that's just how close male friends act; that's not sexual."  So, count us in as naive.

 

 

 

 

Wasn't there a discussion about Spock using the word t'h'yla in his thoughts about Kirk in the novelization? If Roddenberry wanted to squash the rumors, he certainly needn't have invented a Vulcan word that meant friend, brother or lover. Methinks he liked to toy with his audience, too. :smile: Love the Kirk quote, though, " ...  Also, I would dislike being thought of as so foolish that I would select a love partner who came into sexual heat only once every seven years." :lol:

 

 

I have mentioned t'hy'la, and I think that Roddenberry was playing with his audience, using t'hy'la (or allowing its definition) in one place and then having Kirk's comment above (which I love).  Regardless, same relationship, different day:  one ragingly heterosexual man + one nominally heterosexual, largely asexual man apparently = fodder for slash and subtext.  

  • Like 2
Posted

There are a lot of long, lingering looks which people pick up on - can't say I share looks like that with any of my friends, but then at the same time I'm never in such extreme circumstances. 

The whole tea drinking thing really infuriates me. I don't know why but that, in particular, really pees me off. Probably because it is so utterly ridiculous.

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, I'm a tea drinker myself, I have no interest in turning it into social commentary; I just like the taste of the stuff. So I would be pretty annoyed if someone claimed I was making a point every time I took a sip. (I really can't imagine how anyone came up with this; to my ears it sounds like some old Anglophobic joke from the '50's.)

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Just because Moftiss apparently meant it as a joke doesn't mean that's the only reasonable way to interpret it.

Uh oh, I think we're back to "authorial intent" again. I still think it matters what they intended. Another interpretation may be reasonably possible, but once the author has made it clear what interpretation was intended, I'm afraid I still find it presumptious for fans to say they're lying and insist a different meaning is the only right one. I'm far less gracious on this matter than Moftiss have been, I fear. I guess because it strikes close to home.

I see your point, but I still think there's room for alternative interpretations of a work. The only problem, as I see it, is like your example, if someone claims that their interpretation must have been the author's intent -- despite the author's clear statement to the contrary. And yes, I realize that's what some Johnockers are doing.

 

But if you could stop people from playing around with possible interpretations, you'd wipe out the entire field of literary interpretation -- to say nothing of fan fiction!

  • Like 2
Posted

The whole tea drinking thing really infuriates me. I don't know why but that, in particular, really pees me off. Probably because it is so utterly ridiculous.

 

The tea thing is ridiculous, I agree.

 

The reason why I consider it naive to be surprised that some fans seriously expect John and Sherlock to become a couple after series 3 is not long glances or bathrobes or tea or whatnot, it's the way the story is told. I look at fiction differently than I do at reality. In fiction, nothing happens without a reason, unless the creator was sloppy or unfocused, maybe. There are no coincidences and there's no time to be wasted on trivialities. Also, as a viewer and a reader I have, consciously and subconsciously, become used to certain storytelling conventions / tropes. So when I see something on screen or read it in a book, I will attach different meaning to it than to what I happen to observe in my daily life.

 

In The Empty Hearse, John has "moved on" from Sherlock by... not finding a new best friend but getting engaged. Um, okay. Right... Can't really blame Mrs Hudson for her initial reaction there. Sherlock meanwhile comes home from being tortured in Serbia to give exactly zero F***s about a terrorist threat, instead prioritizing an elaborate plan for reuniting with John, in preparation of which event he is shown prancing around his brother's quarters in full peacock mode asking whether his shirt is okay. Yeah, that's... totally what I always thought guy-bros do before meeting up. Then Sherlock crashes John's marriage proposal in classic last minute "wait, I am still alive (Buttercup)!" manner. A love song plays as they grapple on the floor and... um... yeah, this is totally common in non-romantic fiction about just really good friends, you know. Then the rest of the episode is a lot of drama, mention of broken hearts, Sherlock trying to replace John with the girl who has always had a crush on him (and calling her "John" for good measure). A dramatic rescue of the damsel in distress, uh, sorry, John again, awkward meeting with Sherlock's parents', Mary exhibiting behavior that is vaguely reminiscent of jealously of somebody's ex. Finally a tearful reunion and cut.

 

In The Sign of Three, Sherlock is mysteriously upset about John's upcoming wedding even though John's intended is an absolute trooper who is very ready to be best of friends with him and both John and Mary go to great lengths to assure him that neither The Work nor his friendship with John will suffer. For reasons best known to himself, he acts very jealous of a total stranger and there really wasn't any great reason to bring up jealousy at all unless...

The wedding is all about John and Sherlock, or at least the parts that we are shown and they are all that matters in fiction. We don't see John proposing to Mary, but we do see Sherlock completely speechless because John has asked him to be the best man. We don't see the couple exchanging their vows, but we hear Sherlock's first and Last Vow. We don't see an exchange of rings, we don't see "you may now kiss the bride", but we get the full best man's speech and we get The Hug. In the end, after revealing that he knew all along Mary is pregnant, Sherlock leaves the party where he could have easily found girls to dance with (you really think Molly would have refused if he had asked her? Poor Tom would not have stood a chance) and gloomily wanders off into the night...

 

...To be next seen totally wasted in a drug den. For a case, of course. Making completely sure that John realizes this is what he is doing (John would never have noticed him if he hadn't said hello. He wanted to be found.) Sherlock then rubs his sexy new girlfriend in John's face, not his brother's face, btw, even though it was Mycroft who kept teasing him about his presumed sexual inexperience. Mary is revealed as an assassin, who, very apropos, shoots Sherlock in the chest. He briefly dies of cardiac arrest, then wills himself to life because John. This is so not romantic. Anyway. Sherlock finally sacrifices his freedom and his future for John and Mary and the Waston baby, not before Magnussen has had a chance to treat John as the damsel in distress again and show us all the video of when he did it the first time. Several minutes of screen time are used up showing how John and Sherlock do not know how to properly say goodbye and we don't know it yet but Sherlock is actually high again and will spend his first minutes on the plane going into a drug-induced mind palace time travel trip where he meets John all over again and they have the best of times and finally push Moriarty off a cliff after he suggested they elope.

 

 

Before you try to explain to me how all this proves nothing: I know. I know, I know, I know. I was just trying to point out why I think it is totally understandable that fans who already wanted the boys to be in love and came to the series with that wish got their hopes up. The story is told like a romance. I totally agree that nowhere does it say anything about sex or sexual attraction, but from prior viewing / reading experiences, I think we are used to associate romance with sex, so jumping to that conclusion isn't entirely preposterous. As for intent: Sorry, but if you are a professional author and you don't intend to write a romance, then don't. You should know at least a little about how this works. I can go around calling people idiots and protest as much as I like that I didn't intend it to be an insult, but as long as people can prove I actually speak English, my argument is going to be kind of weak.

 

Just imagine one of the guys was a gal. Are you sure you would still be so adamant about "just friends"?

 

I understand why people are asking, why tell a story like this if you aren't going anywhere with it? The answer is, I hope, because they are not walking well-trodden paths but are creating something new and fresh and unusual and very realistic in a way. I love it. I still F***ing love this show and I really do not want it to change into anything more conventional. I don't want a gay wedding and I don't want a regular buddy tale. I want something more akin to the actual relationships in my actual life and I have personally experience the blending of romance, friendship, drama and all that. Sorry for everybody whose hopes for representation were crushed, but I feel very represented by a lot that goes on in the Sherlock universe.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

 

Just because Moftiss apparently meant it as a joke doesn't mean that's the only reasonable way to interpret it.

Uh oh, I think we're back to "authorial intent" again. I still think it matters what they intended. Another interpretation may be reasonably possible, but once the author has made it clear what interpretation was intended, I'm afraid I still find it presumptious for fans to say they're lying and insist a different meaning is the only right one. I'm far less gracious on this matter than Moftiss have been, I fear. I guess because it strikes close to home.

 

I see your point, but I still think there's room for alternative interpretations of a work. The only problem, as I see it, is like your example, if someone claims that their interpretation must have been the author's intent -- despite the author's clear statement to the contrary. And yes, I realize that's what some Johnockers are doing.

 

But if you could stop people from playing around with possible interpretations, you'd wipe out the entire field of literary interpretation -- to say nothing of fan fiction!

 And the problem with that would be ... ? XD

 

Seriously, it may have sounded that way, but I don't mean to imply that interpretations "can't" take place, I just mean what you said ... admit that's all they are. That's what Moftiss have done re: Doyle, I don't think it would harm the fans of their work to do likewise for them.

  • Like 1
Posted

Wow, T.o.b.y, that was great!  :applause:
 
But for the record, you didn't have to persuade me -- I just came back here to disagree (somewhat) with myself:
 

The only problem, as I see it, is like your example, if someone claims that their interpretation must have been the author's intent -- despite the author's clear statement to the contrary.


Yes, BUT -- sometimes it's awfully hard to resist doing precisely that.  Robert Frost always maintained that his poem "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" was simply and literally about a guy stopping to watch the snow falling on his way home.  Well, maybe!

 

So I'm sure not gonna be too hard on anyone who extrapolates the Sherlock story arc.

Posted

Always not forgetting the whole sacrifice arc: Dr Watson nonchalantly kills a stranger because he thinks Sherlock's life is in danger, calls Lestrade and Sherlock 'girls' in TGG but is willing to die by Sherlock's side if it means taking Moriarty out, too. Sherlock sacrifices his reputation, good name and seemingly his life at the end of TRF to save John first and foremost, he is exiled from London for two years for his pains, comes back to find that his 'best friend' has married an assassin and again throws away life and liberty to save his 'damsel in distress' one more time in HLV. No double entendres there whatsoever: why should the TJLC fans be up in arms: the creators didn't mean any harm: it was just their way of providing some heavy angst moments. Yeah, right!

On the subject of lying, in SDCC, Mr Moffat himself admitted that they lie to protect their intellectual property, so it comes down to how big their lies are, after all.

  • Like 1
Posted

Toby, I see your point, but I e.g. needed a clear subtext explanation to be able to look at the story from this perspective. And it's another show from the one I fell in love with.

With 17 I unexpectedly lost a near (and back then only) friend to a marriage and a child. That's my perspective.

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.