Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

I'm going to be the odd man out and say I did not like the rooftop scene with Sherlock.  It felt hokey to me.  I may have laughed.   :unsure:

 

Don't worry, you're not the only one!  Several of us have similar reactions, but didn't include them in our recent analyses (presumably because we'd already discussed that scene earlier in this thread, starting here and again here).  Hokey is a good word for it, in my opinion.  Sherlock looked borderline-super-hero-ish, and John's facial expression struck me as uncomfortably close to hero worship.  Glad they dropped that.

 

 

I'm trying sooo hard to find a good gif of that moment.  I may have to make one tonight if one doesn't exist.  It's so Batman meets Sherlock or something... lol   Batlock?

  • Like 1
Posted

OMG....

 

0e779e51734591fb5510d3ce38e9ca9e.jpg

  • Like 4
Posted

 

I actually did a lot of ridiculous chasing around something or running around, almost for nothing, with certain crazy best friends, obviously not chasing murderer though.

 

But the silly giggles after that were always unbelivably satisfying. :lol:

 

 

Oh, yes, no doubt about it. I love that Moftiss recognized that and put it in the show.

 

 

Have you notice that Lestrade apparently forgot who John was? They met at the crime scene, but he still asked who John was at the end of the film.

OMG, I never noticed! Although to be fair to Lestrade, Sherlock never did identify John the first time. (And I must always be fair to Lestrade!)

 

 

BTW, I'm still trying to wrap my head around the phrase "Holmes virgin"........... :lol2:

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, they strayed from regulations when they put Sally in a skirt, a fault they rectified in SiP.

And as for the gun mentioned above, in SiP because Sherlock is not drugged he recognised it immediately for what it was and chose the lighter (which is what it was), while the other victims certainly did not possess his ballistics expertise. He does something similar under shock in HLV, where Mind Palace Mycroft intervenes to correct that line of inquiry as superfluous.

The lithographs on the walls have also appeared in other places during the series. The cut-glass mirror is very expertly hidden behind the jumble he has made between the coffee table and the Chesterfield sofa.

And I was really sad that they made the Anderson character save in SiP so as not to be confused with a villain, when one of the most famous forensic scientists on TV, Gil Grissom is bearded throughout CSI Las Vegas! Poor Anderson was allowed to retain his facial hair only once he had gone batty in TEH and lost his job ( which begs the question of why Sally kept hers in SoT) but that will be discussed at the proper place and time, I expect.

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh, you just reminded me: I actually liked Anderson's first appearance in UP. He seems more believable in his dislike of Sherlock with this little scene: we can handle this...

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh, I agree!  I mean, how would you like it if you'd studied for years and years to be accredited in your field -- and then some smart-ass amateur comes waltzing in, messes up your crime scene, and claims to have figured everything out?

 

  • Like 5
Posted

Sally was in a skirt when we see her at the crime scene in ASIP. Sherlock comments on her knees in both versions. Though, her outfit was terrible in the UP.

  • Like 1
Posted

Before filming the 90-minute version, they realized that a] a sergeant would not be in uniform (as Sally was in the pilot), and b] Lestrade wouldn't be "Inspector," these days he'd be "Detective Inspector" (or just D.I.).

 

Posted

Hi! Just done re-watching, since I have the DVD collection with the unaired pilot, and I must say, as a long-time Sherlock Holmes fan that the pilot keeps a lot of stuff from the ACD universe, from Dr Watson's meeting with Mike Stamford and their subsequent lunch at the Criterion to the dénouement, where Dr Watson stands in for Sebastian Moran, as he shoots the cabbie from the empty house across the street! You also get glimpses of Beryl Virtue in the Criterion scene, Dr Watson is given much more credit for figuring out that something is decidedly wrong about Sherlock's Headless Nun performance, (they actually reused the narcotic needle in SIB where Irene Adler repossessed her "camera-phone) , and the good doctor uses a different kind of stick ad a prop.

Really tense, definitely fan-boy stuff! Loved every minute of it, especially the absence of Mycroft, who had no business being there, as per original content.

  • Like 1
Posted

The lithographs on the walls have also appeared in other places during the series. The cut-glass mirror is very expertly hidden behind the jumble he has made between the coffee table and the Chesterfield sofa.

I'm amazed at how observant some of you are. There's a mirror? :D

 

Poor Anderson was allowed to retain his facial hair only once he had gone batty in TEH and lost his job ( which begs the question of why Sally kept hers in SoT) but that will be discussed at the proper place and time, I expect.

I think it's because she didn't go batty that she hasn't lost her job.

 

You also get glimpses of Beryl Virtue in the Criterion scene, Dr Watson is given much more credit for figuring out that something is decidedly wrong about Sherlock's Headless Nun performance,...

Again ... so observant! I'm beginning to think I watch this show with my eyes closed. And yeh, I like the bit where John realizes the plan's gone wrong too; although I guess something similar happens in "Pink" when he realizes the cabbie is the killer.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

I'm going to be the odd man out and say I did not like the rooftop scene with Sherlock.  It felt hokey to me.  I may have laughed.   :unsure:

 

Don't worry, you're not the only one!  Several of us have similar reactions, but didn't include them in our recent analyses (presumably because we'd already discussed that scene earlier in this thread, starting here and again here).  Hokey is a good word for it, in my opinion.  Sherlock looked borderline-super-hero-ish, and John's facial expression struck me as uncomfortably close to hero worship.  Glad they dropped that.

 

 

I'm trying sooo hard to find a good gif of that moment.  I may have to make one tonight if one doesn't exist.  It's so Batman meets Sherlock or something... lol   Batlock?

 

 

 

OMG....

 

0e779e51734591fb5510d3ce38e9ca9e.jpg

 

 

 

The lithographs on the walls have also appeared in other places during the series. The cut-glass mirror is very expertly hidden behind the jumble he has made between the coffee table and the Chesterfield sofa.

I'm amazed at how observant some of you are. There's a mirror? :D

 

Poor Anderson was allowed to retain his facial hair only once he had gone batty in TEH and lost his job ( which begs the question of why Sally kept hers in SoT) but that will be discussed at the proper place and time, I expect.

I think it's because she didn't go batty that she hasn't lost her job.

 

You also get glimpses of Beryl Virtue in the Criterion scene, Dr Watson is given much more credit for figuring out that something is decidedly wrong about Sherlock's Headless Nun performance,...

Again ... so observant! I'm beginning to think I watch this show with my eyes closed. And yeh, I like the bit where John realizes the plan's gone wrong too; although I guess something similar happens in "Pink" when he realizes the cabbie is the killer.

 

 

I've reached my like quote for the day...again.  All brilliant responses that I won't remember to like later when I can.  I've seen the meme before and still haven't gotten tired of seeing it.

Posted

You also get glimpses of Beryl Virtue in the Criterion scene....

... having lunch with Arwel Jones!

  • Like 1
Posted

I am really glad they changed the scene with the cabbie. Poor Sherlock rolling around on the floor while a creepy serial killer makes creepy remarks about his helpless state is definitely something I can do without. That worked much better with Irene.

  • Like 1
Posted

Moftiss seem to have a "thing" for helpless Sherlock being taunted by creepy bad guys -- first the cabbie, then Magnussen....  Glad they thought better of both cases.  Irene is definitely an improvement!

  • Like 2
Posted

Moftiss seem to have a "thing" for helpless Sherlock being taunted by creepy bad guys -- first the cabbie, then Magnussen....

...and in both cases, the scene got cut. For reason good, if you ask me. It still seems to be a popular trope in fan fiction.

Posted

And yet... the cut scenes still become part of canon...

Posted

Surely not ACD canon!

Posted

Moffat and Gatiss draw from all sources.  And all their work becomes new canon.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

So, no regret?

I remember you hesitated about watching the Pilot which was also the case for me. I don't love it but I don't regret having decided to give it a try. It's kind of Bizzaro Sherlock for me, and makes me appreciate the direction they took for the series much much more.

I think I would not be a fan, would just watch and forget about it.

 

 

Amazingly, no regrets!   :)   I thought it would disrupt my mental head-canon to know that another version of ASIP exists out there, but in reality I was very detached while watching it and never got into the episode all that much.  I think it would be interesting if I was able to watch it with a clean slate.  I wonder if the pilot would have reeled me in the way ASIP did?  After viewing the pilot, I think I would assume what you just said... that I would have watched it and then forgotten about it.  But then, I don't know if that's true or fair to the pilot, because I'll never know how I would have reacted to it without having first seen ASIP.  

 

For me, it just didn't hook me enough to continue watching or obssesed about it. Maybe because imho, it's not unique or interesting enough, and a little bit into tacky territory. There are many other shows like that.

And sorryyy for young Sherlock's fan,

I Iike him older and more funny looking instead of just graduated from boy band. :)

 

:)

 

I think, if I had seen the UP, I would have felt about the show pretty much like I feel about Elementary.  I like it; it's fun.  Occasionally, I look at the interactions and say, "Oh, I see a hint of Sherlock Holmes there," but mostly I just enjoy it as "CSI Baker Street" and never rewatch an episode.

 

CSI Baker Street. :lol: 

Great way to put it. Agree wholeheartedly, because never care for CSI.

  • Like 3
Posted

Well, I was good at least for that: The pink shoes at the Con-Exhibition were from UP, while the clothes were from ASIP. Just saying.

 

Some more thoughts just because I had to watch and compare the scene (research purposes again):

 

I liked Sherlock's: "keep talking and there be more". Was this line used somewhere later?

 

After John's first time "Brilliant" Sherlock looks at Lestrade as if checking his reaction. Lestrade reactions are precious, btw. And he is happy as a little boy when he says there was no case. :D

 

On the other hand - because you need me sounds a bit too emotional, compared to ASIP.

Posted

Just noticed a little bit in the UP:  First of all, let's get to the email addresses:

 

Mycroft is:  mycroft@dsux.org

 

Gregson is: gregson@ftnu.co.uk

 

Lestrade is: lestrade@strade.org.uk

 

So in the UP, at least, Gregson and Lestrade are two separate people just as they are in original canon.  However, they have been combined into one by the time ASIP is put together.

  • Like 1
Posted

And I don't mean this to sound at all kinky, but I like the way he whips the corpse better in the UP than in ASIP.  He just really puts his all into it in UP with giant, wickedly hard strikes.

  • Like 2
Posted

Gregson is: gregson@ftnu.co.uk

 

Lestrade is: lestrade@strade.org.uk

 

So in the UP, at least, Gregson and Lestrade are two separate people just as they are in original canon.  However, they have been combined into one by the time ASIP is put together.

I've heard people say that before, but I'm curious as to why. Have Moftisses stated that they combined the two inspectors, or are people just assuming it because Lestrade is called "Greg" later on (first in "Hounds," I believe)?  The canon Lestrade's first initial is "G," which could stand for "Gregory" (or "Geoffrey" or "Gavin"!) just as easily as "Gregson."

 

Also, Gregson himself is mentioned again in "Reichenbach" (from Ariane DeVere's transcript):

 

CHIEF SUPERINTENDANT: We’ve been consulting with him – that’s what you’re telling me? Not used him on any proper cases, though, have we?

LESTRADE: Well, one or two.

ANDERSON: Or twenty or thirty.

CHIEF SUPERINTENDANT: What?

LESTRADE: Look, I’m not the only senior officer who did this. Gregson ...

CHIEF SUPERINTENDANT: Shut up!

 

So anyhow, I'm curious to know where the "Gregson and Lestrade have been combined" idea came from.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Interesting, I don't think I've come across Lestrade's first initial in my reading yet.   So I guess they didn't combine them at all then, if that's the case.

Posted

I don't recall which story this was in, but Lestrade sends Holmes a note signed "G. Lestrade."  (Wikipedia says it was "The Cardboard Box.")

 

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 111 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.