Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Okay, you folks clearly never saw Mr. Moffat's remarks about that scene. I, alas, did, and I've been looking for the brain bleach ever since. Don't go looking, you might end up like me. :(

 

Remember the lady cop who shows up on Sherlock's doorstep, talking to Greg? I think they originally meant her to be Donovan, but the actress wasn't available.

Posted

Moffat seems to say one thing one interview and something different the next interview, I take a lot of what he says with a pinch of salt. I've seen him (or maybe it was Gatiss?) saying that the scene was him losing. 

 

The lady cop in 4.1? I can't see Donovan ever going to Sherlock to help, and if she did I hope he would tell her to shove it. I hope she didn't get promoted to DI after what she did.

  • Like 1
Posted

Okay, you folks clearly never saw Mr. Moffat's remarks about that scene. I, alas, did, and I've been looking for the brain bleach ever since. Don't go looking, you might end up like me. :(

 

Ooooohh, but now you've got me curious, my dominant driving force (and probably also weakness).  I have to get in the cab...

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Welcome to the forum, mishab! :welcome: Glad you've finally come inside!

 

Thanks for the welcome Carol!

 

 

 I have always contended that Moftiss doesn't really understand John. For example, I don't think he craves danger or seeks out dangerous people (as expounded incessantly by Moftiss and mentioned here a few posts ago). As you may have heard me say while you were lurking, I think he's merely not afraid of them, and therefore does not actively avoid them the way most people do. He barged into the drug den, not because he was seeking danger, but rather because Mary's friend had asked him to rescue her son. As a doctor he's concerned for Isaac's health, and as a soldier he's not afraid to go there

 

 

 

Yeah. He does not go round doing stupid things just to satisfy his cravings for danger. He is a more sensible and balanced person than that. I don't understand why people always interpret his sense of adventure as something darker.  

  • Like 1
Posted

There are definitely times when John is Sherlock's moral compass, but there are times when Sherlock is John's too, in my opinion.

 

There are a lot of things Sherlock teaches John about himself. He talks to him about how he chose Mary because he is drawn to danger- really he argues here for John to give Mary and himself another chance. He talks to him in TLD about accepting being human and prone to mistakes. And also in TLD, he puts himself at huge risk, mostly to show John how much value his own life still has, to encourage John to find that value through helping someone else.

 

I think from ASIP on we see two men who express it quite differently, but have similar moral values and ways of seeing the world. It is why John can kill the cabbie and Sherlock can kill Magnussen- both are willing to do what they believe is right according to their own moral code, without much care for what society might think. With Magnussen, the writers were on iffy ground because they were trying to be too clever. And it won't be the last time I'll say that, if the show comes back, I'm sure.

  • Like 3
Posted

^ Yes!

 

 

Posted

I don't see Sherlock as someone who desperately needed a moral compass. He is already on the side of angels, all the time. What he needs is someone to say him how to behave and someone to root him in his own life.
 

 

Au contraire, I don't think we're supposed to cheer when Sherlock shoots Magnussen. He saw that he could not beat Magnussen with his intellect. He had lost. So he cheated. He kicked over the chessboard.
(...)
Sherlock saw that he couldn't beat Magnussen by winning, so he sacrificed his own integrity to beat him by losing.

 
Yes he did. But when does he - or anyone in the show - acknowledge that? That's the piece I'm missing.

THIS! Not even Mary. Again we have to assume that someone did say thank you.

My reaction to the shooting was exactly like that of Mycroft: What  have you done! :o

  • Like 4
Posted

Yep, that too.

 

Given the emotional distance that seemed to exist between Sherlock and John during much of the last two seasons, you have to wonder if John ever said anything about it to Sherlock. I almost get the impression they just left it lying between them, unaddressed, with John torn between horror at the outcome and gratitude at the, er, outcome. Just more guilt for him to bear, imo. Poor guy, he never gets a break from anyone. Geez, now I'm starting to feel like beating Sherlock up myself. NOT!

Posted

Okay, you folks clearly never saw Mr. Moffat's remarks about that scene. I, alas, did, and I've been looking for the brain bleach ever since. Don't go looking, you might end up like me. :(

 

Are you referring to this interview?

http://www.vulture.com/2014/01/sherlock-finale-postmortem-steven-moffat-interview.html

  • Like 1
Posted

Me and my big mouth. Yes, I'm afraid that's the one. :( I'll try to pretend I didn't see it. :p

Posted

I think Moffat is partly telling the truth and partly trying to yank our chains.

 

I can understand his basic point (the one hiding behind the snark), and agree with it to some extent.  My main objection is to his slander of John Watson!

Posted

My main objection is to his slander of John Watson!

???

Posted

 

My main objection is to his slander of John Watson!

???

 

 

I'm guessing Carol the Dabbler is referring to how Moffat seems to think that John shooting a serial killing cabbie that was trying to get Sherlock killed is equivalent to Sherlock shooting a sinister but innocent man who was not intending on taking any life but was fine with simply ruining them. The former is much more justified than the latter.

Posted

Actually the parts that I most object to were the snide remark about him shooting the cabbie "in the back" -- as though any sensible person (attempting to avert what looks like a homicide in progress) would ask a serial killer to please turn around so he can play fair and shoot him in the front -- and the repeated comment about him "giggling" afterward (that sounded to me like a nervous laughter of the stress-relief type, not "ha-ha I just shot a guy, so what").

 

It's no wonder the bad guys feel free to kidnap John and flick his face and that his best friend runs experiments on him, considering how little respect at least half of the writing team seems to have for him. :P

Posted

Ah. I missed that. Maybe Moffat was just having a bad day? ;)

Posted

I suspect he was just trying to make a point by exaggerating. He seems to do that -- which is one reason it doesn't pay to assume that he means what he's literally saying.

  • Like 1
Posted

This thread really makes me want a good solid John storyline where we get to understand him and really see what he's capable of. Don't think we'll ever get it though :(

I wonder if there are things in his past that make him see himself as not a good man. 

  • Like 2
Posted

I think getting invalided home from the war made him doubt his own self-worth. He self-identifies as a doctor and a soldier, and suddenly the army is telling him he's not wanted in either capacity. I think that's one reason he so readily took up with Sherlock -- he had something to contribute, and his presence was valued. Maybe he also craves adventure, maybe not. But it seems to me that he definitely has a strong need to feel useful.

 

In Series 3 and early Series 4, he seemed to be sonething of a fifth wheel, so he may have felt unneeded and unappreciated once more, which would undermine his sense of self-worth. This may explain why he responded to the woman on the bus -- which of course only made him feel worse about himself and fear that he was not a good man.

  • Like 3
Posted

This thread really makes me want a good solid John storyline where we get to understand him and really see what he's capable of. Don't think we'll ever get it though :(

I wonder if there are things in his past that make him see himself as not a good man. 

 

It might never happen, but I would love for them to make a special episode like TAB which is about John's life. 

Posted

Aw, if only this was in show. 

 

f868b8dfe9de132cb9a95503f0001eeb.gif

 

For supposed best friends John and Sherlock never look that happy to see each other. 

  • Like 4
Posted

I suspect he was just trying to make a point by exaggerating. He seems to do that -- which is one reason it doesn't pay to assume that he means what he's literally saying.

 

Amen! :p

 

Aw, if only this was in show. 

 

f868b8dfe9de132cb9a95503f0001eeb.gif

 

For supposed best friends John and Sherlock never look that happy to see each other. 

 

Yeah, I love it too. Maybe some fan will edit it into a video.

Posted

What is that from? Is it faked, or is it MF and BC at the end of a good take, or what?

Posted

I think it's from the Behind the Scenes of The Final Problem.

  • Like 1
Posted

Yea it's MF and BC. I found the end of it too:

 

4f1d1d85c0e6d1ac0d9cc6c075cf4294.gif

  • Like 3
Posted

I think getting invalided home from the war made him doubt his own self-worth. He self-identifies as a doctor and a soldier, and suddenly the army is telling him he's not wanted in either capacity. I think that's one reason he so readily took up with Sherlock -- he had something to contribute, and his presence was valued. Maybe he also craves adventure, maybe not. But it seems to me that he definitely has a strong need to feel useful.

 

In Series 3 and early Series 4, he seemed to be sonething of a fifth wheel, so he may have felt unneeded and unappreciated once more, which would undermine his sense of self-worth. This may explain why he responded to the woman on the bus -- which of course only made him feel worse about himself and fear that he was not a good man.

 

Starting from series 3, the only function for John seems to be Sherlock's damsel in distress. Instead of making him a complementary partner to Sherlock, he is just made out to be source of drama for Sherlock and give him the opportunity to play the self sacrificing hero. This character arc for Sherlock, to be a good man, could only happen if John is weak. So they took away all the strengths that made John such a compelling character in S1 & s2.  Add to that Mary, who not only takes over John's function but also almost takes over Sherlock's not to mention the function of a client. Her character dev is just unbelievable, think of every good quality a person can have and they have put it in her. Every other character in the show has a flaw but not her. And people call  John a mary-sue!  

 

I think Moftiss can only respect characters who show extraordinary abilities. People like John, Molly and Lestrade are ignored while Mary, Sherlock and Mycroft are  given more and more to do. Mrs Hudson too has to be a race car driving, drug cartel running woman to be taken seriously. Why could not she just have been a regular yet be a strong person?  

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 87 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.