Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Eh, I take that "violin lessons" stuff with a grain of salt. She may have taught him a few things, but I'm willing to bet he had more instruction long after she disappeared from his life.

 

I've always wondered how Sherlock stays fit, since he supposedly just lounges around the flat for days on end. That's just another one of those things I have to assume; he's got a gym membership, and regularly spars with the martial arts master there. :smile: Although some people have speculated that he might have gotten some MI6 training at some point.

  • Like 4
Posted

Eh, I take that "violin lessons" stuff with a grain of salt. She may have taught him a few things, but I'm willing to bet he had more instruction long after she disappeared from his life.

 

I've always wondered how Sherlock stays fit, since he supposedly just lounges around the flat for days on end. That's just another one of those things I have to assume; he's got a gym membership, and regularly spars with the martial arts master there. :smile: Although some people have speculated that he might have gotten some MI6 training at some point.

 

I was thinking about that recently because I've been trying to eat healthier. And I thought of Sherlock and his chips and Mrs. Hudson's fry ups, but still being super fit. So unfair. Maybe it is all the aforementioned fighting that keeps him fit? Or yes, the gym.

 

Maybe Mycroft got him training in advance of one of his 'missions' for him? Shame he never considered getting it himself, if so!

  • Like 1
Posted

 

[sherlock] is the wisest man. Who writes this?!?

Well, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, for one. I believe that's Watson's description of Holmes while he's "dead" (so either the original Final Problem or else The Empty House.)

 

Actually, I meant these:

 

Taking your own life. Taking it from who? Once it's over, it's not you who'll miss it.

Your own death is something that happens to everybody else.

 

Whoever wrote those, he/she have my admiring eyes. :P

 

 

Surelock, on 02 Feb 2017 - 04:33 AM, said:

Also it's true that Mycroft let Moriarty speak to Euros for 5 minutes unsupervised but I wouldn't describe as what he did as giving ammunition. I mean Moriarty never brought up Euros with Sherlock although he could. You could argue that's a plot hole. I mean Moriarty likes messing with Sherlock. if he knew about Euros, then why didn't he ever talk to him about her?

 

I think that Moriarty- Euros connection was just poorly written and not given much thought. It looks like Moffatiss only gave them a connection because they wanted to foreshadow Euros' impending threat but they didn't want to give it away so they used Moriarty as a ruse (via his 'Miss me?' videos).

Alas, I have to agree ... they didn't do a good job of explaining Moriarty's role in all this. His appearance felt very much like an afterthought, and I felt sort of cheated that they didn't explain what he and Eurus said to each other. And it didn't make sense that Eurus told Jim about Redbeard, but he never used that knowledge to his advantage.

 

So I have to assume she didn't tell him the truth. At any rate, I thought their meeting was more about her getting information ... and those wholly unnecessary videos ... from him, than about her giving him anything. He just played along. For some reason.

 

Yah. I think Eurus just making use of Moriary for connection to outside world with the lure of destroying both of her brothers that must be getting in Moriarty’s nerve although he likes to play with them. That is enough of incentive for him. Also, Moriarty enjoys the sibling turning on each other with battle of wits and their respective oddness. It must be amusing for them. I wonder what nickname he gives her. Ice Man, The Virgin and.. ?

Can’t think of anything now, anyone who gets a nice one will have my admiring eyes! :D :D :D

 

I don't know why she was so angry at Sherlock. Maybe it was just because he couldn't solve her puzzle?

I believe it’s because she thought Sherlock didn’t want to play with her.

In her logic, Redbeard got in their way. Redbeard gone, Sherlock should then play with her. But no, Sherlock was trying to find Redbeard.

 

Thank God his hair remained in tact anyway, as he has such great hair! How evil would you need to be to destroy it? Shameful.

:lol5:

Thanks. My Monday is better. Bahahahha..

 

 

 

 

The question is: where did Sherlock get his combat abilities from?

In my mind, he is curious and does in own training, based on personal interest and curiosity.

And Sherlock is practical guy who likes to get his hand dirty directly.

He wants to poke into crime scene, chase baddies, and hang out at night jumping from one rooftop to another, it would be much easier when he is lean and able to defend himself (or offend if needed to).

Initially he probably needs it to get to his homeless network. Pickpockets, stabbers would be interested with his expensive Belstaff coat and gorgeous hair for wig.

 

In short answer, he needs it and he knows that, so he makes it happens.

Not Mycroft, or Eurus, all Sherlock. :wub:

 

Which bring me to another realization:

So he becomes a detective because of Eurus then.

An unsolved case, that sends him to solving all other cases he can get his hand on.

I am glad actually, pirates almost always have bad hygiene. :P

  • Like 3
Posted

 

Taking your own life. Taking it from who? Once it's over, it's not you who'll miss it.

Your own death is something that happens to everybody else.

 

Whoever wrote those, he/she have my admiring eyes. :P

Add mine too. One of the lines in the series that hits you like a lightning. Along with "your life doesn't belong to you…" or something like that. :P

  • Like 1
Posted

Question: Sherlock's therapist in TST, was that real or in his mind palace? Did the walls look kind of iffy, as if the setting couldn't be real? (They didn't reach the floor, did they?)

 

If it was real, that was a huge leap for him to realise he needed that sort of help. And if he has a mind palace therapist- well that's kind of nifty, as think of the savings on therapy bills!

Posted

That's what I decided, after TLD.

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh okay, that makes sense I guess, though I thought that would be frowned upon, from an ethical standpoint?

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh, I'm sure it is!  And I seriously doubt that Ella told Sherlock anything about John -- but that wouldn't stop him from trying, would it?

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh, I'm sure it is!  And I seriously doubt that Ella told Sherlock anything about John -- but that wouldn't stop him from trying, would it?

 

Of course not! And he might have thought he could deduce something out of her, or peek at her files at some point. You never know with Sherlock...

 

Posted

Definitely peeks her files and cracks her password. He knows everything about John, Ella and half of her patients during her scripted five minutes buffer when she left the room. Mrs. H helps make it happen.

  • Like 1
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

We discuss that article a little bit somewhere ... but where? *think thinkity think think....*

Posted

Is this when you said the author might be a hiding Johnlocker? This could indeed apply, but the other points are very close to my own feeling - I even wrote it as a comment: there is a point when you just cannot make it "better" any more, and the only thing you can add is fireworks.

 

On the other hand you have to wonder, how on Earth this superhuman can be wrong almost all the time in S4 :P

 

 

Anyway, another observation about Sherlock. I cannot point any certain moments from memory, but while watching S4 I realized that Sherlock often smiles that very grown up, knowing smile - like when we see him at the end of TSOT when he's congratulating John and Mary for being pregnant. I don't know how conscious this was of the writers or BC himself, but to me this smile felt like the best prove, he indeed became wise and human human being.

Posted

 

Anyway, another observation about Sherlock. I cannot point any certain moments from memory, but while watching S4 I realized that Sherlock often smiles that very grown up, knowing smile - like when we see him at the end of TSOT when he's congratulating John and Mary for being pregnant. I don't know how conscious this was of the writers or BC himself, but to me this smile felt like the best prove, he indeed became wise and human human being.

 

Well, I *like* your analysis better than my own gut reaction, but my feeling was:

 

1.  On seeing TSoT the first time, I read that smile not so much as adult and knowing as pained and hiding it. Maybe I was projecting, but I think I've given that version of a smile when I've had friends give me news that they really wanted but that I felt would take them away from me somehow. I felt like I could see the war between "I should project happiness because I want them happy" and "I want to go crawl into a hole somewhere."

 

2. Also, to be completely pragmatic about it, even the best actors only have so many "directions" their faces will go. BC is wildly talented, but I feel like I see that smile on him once in a while, and I think it is partly just the way his smiles "work."

  • Like 1
Posted

Is this when you said the author might be a hiding Johnlocker? This could indeed apply, but the other points are very close to my own feeling - I even wrote it as a comment: there is a point when you just cannot make it "better" any more, and the only thing you can add is fireworks.

 

Somebody said that, but I don't think it was me. But I still can't remember where it was.

Posted

We discuss that article a little bit somewhere ... but where? *think thinkity think think....*

 

Already deleted it from your Memory Palace?

 

We had this discussion 5 days ago in The Final Problem thread:

http://www.sherlockforum.com/forum/topic/3549-episode-43-the-final-problem/page-50

 

 

Is this when you said the author might be a hiding Johnlocker? 

 

Actually I was the one that said that.

  • Like 2
Posted

Thanks Surelock!!! Here, have a cookie. :cookie:
 
If only I had a mind palace.... mine's more like a mind hut....

Posted

And this is someone just expressing my own chaotic emotions about Sherlock at S4

 

 

But there’s also this shattering piece of information that Sherlock now knows: all the things he’s valued most about himself are a fantasy. His entire identity has been constructed on a lie he created for himself as a child.

http://ivyblossom.tumblr.com/post/157550861385/burning-question-for-sherlock-fanfic-writers

 

This is probably the main cause for that abysmal sadness I felt at the end. Because the things Sherlock valued about himself, were also things I valued about him. And the tiny little bits I started to value about me because of him. And it all turned out to be built upon a fantasy, which really, really robs them of its value.

  • Like 1
Posted

Which things, JP? Because I don't see it quite that way; maybe we can figure out why it's not a fantasy. I still think he made conscious decisions to be the way he is, even if he didn't remember why.

Posted

I mean a conscious decision to stay away from emotions. The whole "I made me".

After S4 I don't see a decision but a survival mechanism. It was not chosen because it has a value, but because it's more bearable than the truth. Plus, most of it is Mycroft's work. Even if I was aware of Sherlock wanting be like his big brother, now it's like nobody believed that Sherlock from a certain age can cope with the truth, so he had to be tested and supervised. It's making him a victim of circumstances, not a self-made man.

Does it make sense?

  • Like 1
Posted

And this is someone just expressing my own chaotic emotions about Sherlock at S4

 

 

But there’s also this shattering piece of information that Sherlock now knows: all the things he’s valued most about himself are a fantasy. His entire identity has been constructed on a lie he created for himself as a child.

http://ivyblossom.tumblr.com/post/157550861385/burning-question-for-sherlock-fanfic-writers

 

This is probably the main cause for that abysmal sadness I felt at the end. Because the things Sherlock valued about himself, were also things I valued about him. And the tiny little bits I started to value about me because of him. And it all turned out to be built upon a fantasy, which really, really robs them of its value.

 

I don't really agree with the idea that Sherlock had made himself into a fantasy as a response to childhood trauma.

 

I think Mycroft was wrong to say that he was the man he was today because of Eurus. There is so much more to Sherlock than just that.

 

It is like anybody who goes through a traumatic event as a child- afterwards they will never know which parts are truly them and which parts might have been a response to the trauma. But it isn't an alchemy that transforms someone into a totally different person. I would imagine one of the most harmful things in that situation is an attitude like Mycroft's, that what happened is a reason for every problem that happens later in their lives.

 

Sherlock lost a very dear friend as a child- and if that theory of him cutting himself off, becoming the thing that had hurt him, were completely true, then he never would have let another very close friend into his life, in the way he let John in. TFP might have been a breakthrough moment, but as the audience we were there for the small battles than won the war.

 

I'm very sorry that you feel the character and even yourself are robbed of value, J.P., but I hope you won't take this last episode too seriously. To me, TFP happened in a box sort of removed from the greater series. If I remembered the show in the future, without any more episodes, I would remember the style of the early Sherlock most, and not consider that person he was to be less complete, or less true than the person we saw at the end. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I mean a conscious decision to stay away from emotions. The whole "I made me".

After S4 I don't see a decision but a survival mechanism. It was not chosen because it has a value, but because it's more bearable than the truth. Plus, most of it is Mycroft's work. Even if I was aware of Sherlock wanting be like his big brother, now it's like nobody believed that Sherlock from a certain age can cope with the truth, so he had to be tested and supervised. It's making him a victim of circumstances, not a self-made man.

Does it make sense?

 

Yes, it does make sense, but I think I largely agree with Bedelia ... he's still a self-made man, even if a childhood trauma affected his decisions. There's so many other paths he could have chosen ... he could have sunk so deep into the drugs that he never came out again, for example, or (!) turned to crime ... but he preferred to become a dragon slayer, which speaks a lot to both his courage and his fundamental humanity, imo. I mean, if he'd only wanted to stoke his ego, like some have suggested, there would have been a lot higher profile (and safer) professions to go into. But on some level I think he really wants to be a "hero". But doesn't want to admit to being so mundane. :d

 

At any rate, I also agree Mycroft got it wrong; because when Sherlock finally does learn the truth about his past, he copes just fine, doesn't he? He doesn't have a psychotic break or go rogue ... he solves the problem. He figures out what Eurus needs, and lets himself (unlike Mycroft) give it to her. That's not being a victim of circumstances, imo, that's prevailing over circumstances.

 

And I still think he'll be perfectly capable of putting emotions aside when the situation warrants ... but he'll also recognize when empathy is called for. Empathy doesn't mean he has to get tangled up in other people's problems, or make himself emotionally vulnerable; it just means he'll be more understanding; and hopefully, kinder. That's not such a bad thing, is it? :smile:

  • Like 4

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 97 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.