Jump to content

What did you think of "The Six Thatchers"?  

93 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Awful.


Recommended Posts

Posted

Yes, I thought it was weird. As was his holding her at the end. The whole fact of Rosie's existence is weird to me, unless they have plans for her in the future. Why introduce a character that has no part in the story?

Posted

Yup. I was sure she was going to be gone by the end of the season. I know I've said it before but since she was barely in or mentioned in TLD or TFP why include her at all?

  • Like 1
Posted

I am still under the impression that at one time they had more plot than we actually ended up seeing (like there wasn't too much already. :D) Maybe they trimmed out something that would have explained why they included her.

 

I did remember that she's the reason John and Mary arrived separately at the aquarium. But since I can think of about 20 other ways they could have made that happen, that's not much of a reason. (And if they had arrived together, would it have changed anything? I think not.)

 

Perplexing season.

Posted

I am still under the impression that at one time they had more plot than we actually ended up seeing (like there wasn't too much already. :D) Maybe they trimmed out something that would have explained why they included her.

 

 

Even if there was more plot, I don't see how you can use a newborn baby in a detective show. Maybe a child that is few years of age can work in a detective show but a newborn baby just has a lot of trouble fitting in.

 

I could see Rosie perhaps used as a plot device. Like maybe John has to rescue her from a bad guy who kidnaps here but a rescue can be done with any character. It doesn't need to be a newborn baby.

 

I think Moffatiss just used Rosie as a red herring to stop people from figuring out that Mary was going to die. They thought that if people saw that John and Mary had a baby (which is a deviation from the book) then it may mean Mary would survive (which is also a deviation form the books).

  • Like 2
Posted

True. Personally, I would have preferred that they kept Mary too, so she could stay home with the baby. Sooo sexist of me, I know. :p

Posted

Well, I've even thought if they made her a psychologist (or if she graduated in philosophy), John could stay home with Rosie and Sherlock could continue to solve crimes with (the other) Dr Watson. :P

  • Like 1
Posted

I think the point of Rosie was:

 

1.) To give John a plausible reason for staying together with Mary even after he found out about her deception.

2.) To recreate the sense of "abandonment" Holmes only half-jokingly refers to in the original after Watson's marriage (unclear whether to Miss Morstan or a later one to an anonymous person but no matter). Because if John and Mary had just gotten married, nothing would have needed to change, really, but with a baby at home John's priorities must shift to a degree that Sherlock can reasonably feel sad about.

3.) To add tragedy to Mary's death.

4.) Maybe also to give John a good reason not to shoot himself after Mary's death.

  • Like 1
Posted

If Rosie was used for that purpose why didn't John mention her at all in TLD or TFP? They never acted like John was a father now at all other than to show his boredom/dissatisfaction at domestic life in TST.

Posted

If Rosie was used for that purpose why didn't John mention her at all in TLD or TFP? They never acted like John was a father now at all other than to show his boredom/dissatisfaction at domestic life in TST.

John does mention her. When talking to Eurus posing as his therapist, he says she is "with friends" and he protestes when his inability to take proper care of her due to his grief is excused as being "understandable".

 

Since he isn't parenting, at least not full time, then, of course we don't see much of him as a father during that episode. And The Final Problem mostly takes place away from home. Rosie is mentioned there when Sherlock asks if John would have time for a phone call before they set off the grenade. We also see her during the final montage.

  • Like 2
Posted

I knew about the montage but that wasn't dialogue. I don't remember John mentioning Rosie before the grenade. Off to the TFP transcript....

 

Regarding TLD, if that's the only passing mention, I stand by what I said. He doesn't mention her at all with ghost Mary and considering that his daughter is now motherless that's odd. Also, when discussing his grief and regrets with Sherlock at the end, there's no mention of his family, only himself and what Mary meant to him. If Rosie's existence was to add tragedy you'd think she'd be more of a focus in the dialogue and John's stated motivation to plug at the viewer's heart strings.

Posted

Well, that certainly would be one way to do it. Perhaps we just have to accept that Moftiss chose a different direction. That's what people DO. :smile:

Posted

The whole fact of Rosie's existence is weird to me, unless they have plans for her in the future. Why introduce a character that has no part in the story?

 

They may not be thinking of her as a character, more of a plot device (as Surelock said later).  But yeah, she hasn't played much of a role -- yet.

 

 I don't see how you can use a newborn baby in a detective show. Maybe a child that is few years of age can work in a detective show but a newborn baby just has a lot of trouble fitting in.

 

The thing is, children start out as newborn babies.  I suppose they could have brought Archie back (and I hope they do!), but they may have some ideas in mind that would require John to have a daughter.  So he's in the process of growing one.

 

Maybe twenty years from now (in Series 6), Archie and Rosie get married.  Who knows?

Posted

True. Personally, I would have preferred that they kept Mary too, so she could stay home with the baby. Sooo sexist of me, I know. :P

 

In an interview, Moffat said the reason that Mary was killed off was because they always wanted Sherlock and John to be a duo. So Mary didn't need to die. It was more that they needed to get her out of Sherlock and John's life because the two of them are supposed to be a duo.

 

They didn't need to kill Mary off to achieve this. They could have written it so Mary stops participating in Sherlock and John's cases because she has to look after baby Rosie at home. But hey if Moffat wrote that, people would call him sexist again and it looks like Moffat was trying to prove he wasn't sexist judging by how he wrote strong female characters into The Abominable Bride and Season 4.

 

So instead they went with the killing Mary off option. They even had another woman kill Mary off. That way nobody can throw any sexist allegations. 

Posted

I would have preferred that she realized her past was catching up with her, and went on the lam (thus remaining available if needed, but otherwise out of the way).  But she tried that, dammit, and Mr. Sherlock "Smarter Than You" Holmes screwed it up for her (aided and abetted by Dr. John "For Your Own Good" Watson).

  • Like 2
Posted

I would have preferred that she realized her past was catching up with her, and went on the lam (thus remaining available if needed, but otherwise out of the way).  But she tried that, dammit, and Mr. Sherlock "Smarter Than You" Holmes screwed it up for her (aided and abetted by Dr. John "For Your Own Good" Watson).

 

Exactly. If they had just let her be, she might well have stayed alive.

 

Posted

They should have left it at that, her out there somewhere. Especially if she'd left John an, er, 'Dear John' rather than an 'I love you, I shall return!' Have her leave him and Rosie for their own good, and he could still be furious and upset. Though making him furious and upset at Sherlock might take more wrangling, but could be done. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Would he have accepted that, though? I feel like he would have asked Sherlock to help him find her anyway, and Sherlock probably would have done it for him.

  • Like 1
Posted

Sherlock might have agreed it was the safest thing for John and Rosie and refused. Or she could had Mycroft help hide her by saying it would keep his little brother safer. 

Posted

Still, I'm not sure I see John just giving up on it. At least not for awhile. If Sherlock couldn't or wouldn't help then I'd imagine John would try to do it himself. And if he did, I could envision a scenario where he's putting himself in enough danger in the process that he essentially forces Sherlock's hand to help him. I'm not sure Sherlock could stand to see John so hurting and depressed if he thought there were something he could do about it either, no matter what he personally thought of the situation.

 

Maybe, though.

  • Like 3
Posted

Well, how likeable would she have been if she had left her daughter like that, though? Moftiss wanted her to be likeable (too bad about that shooting Sherlock thing. :smile:) But I can see already the vitriole that would have been heaped on her if she abandoned the child. Possibly it would have been even worse than the vitriole that was heaped on her for existing in the first place. :P

  • Like 1
Posted

Too bad about being an assassin for hire too. That was worse for her character's likability than shooting Sherlock was in my opinion.

  • Like 2
  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

Question: in His Last Vow, Mary said "AGRA" were her initials. But if John had looked at the content of the memory stick she gave him, he would have found out almost immediately that this wasn't true. So did she anticipate that he wouldn't read it? Did she say "you won't love me when you're finished" to prevent him from going near that thing which she handed over only to appear as making a clean breast of her past while ensuring that her secrets actually remained safe? That would be quite manipulative and not in keeping with the saintly character they wanted her to bear in S4. But I can't think of any other explanation.

Posted

Well, they were partly her initials.  Maybe she figured that was close enough for the time being, and if he read the file, he'd understand what those letters actually were.  And if not, then never mind.

 

I don't interpret her "you won't love me" line as manipulative, just expressing her fear.  She looks pretty distraught there, and as far as we know, she'd not able to weep on cue the way Sherlock can.

  • Like 2
Posted

Tbh that's my suspicion. They set Mary up to be a villain, having her shooting the hero of the series, having this dark twisted 'you won't love me' past, and then all of a sudden in T6T she's a saint, even her dubious past has her suddenly on the side of good. Helping to free hostages - that's a job John would empathise with not something he would despise her for. I know I've said it before, but not following through on Mary's history makes the whole storyline a complete waste of time - they could have killed her off in any number of ways, including a myriad of ways in which John would be well within his rights to hold Sherlock responsible, and still have had the same outcome of TLD if that's what they were determined to go with. Hell, making Mary an actual nice person would have given her death much more impact and poignancy - as it was I was just glad she was gone.

  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 99 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.