Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Lying Detective"?  

70 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Awful.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

 

 

ou don't even reference anyone else in the above example.  So how is that specific example about others and not himself?

I did. It's me.

You miss my point.  Or are you saying his not wanting to feel pain is a choice he makes to benefit you somehow - ie you are Sherlock's goal, not himself - and that is your answer to why this particular act is not selfish, but is selfless.

His not wanting to feel pain is a choice he makes to benefit him.

Me not wanting to feel pain is a choice I makes to benefit me.

 

Even if the word choice is not really applicable here. The way of coping with problems is not always a matter of a conscious choice.

  • Like 1
Posted

Self-preservation can be selfless, because in taking care of yourself, you are ensuring that society, and others don't need to step in and help.

Except that is not the reason provided in the example under question.  In that example, the reason given is not 'because Sherlock doesn't want to negatively impact "society"'.  The reason given is 'because Sherlock doesn't want to feel pain'.  I asked how that particular reason is not selfish - ie is an example of selflessness.  The above does not address, let alone answer, that question.

 

Posted

John loves Sherlock a lot as a friend, but I think it is just hard for him to empathise, because Sherlock conceals a lot of his feelings from John.

He conceals his feelings for the most part from everyone doesn't he? And Sherlock has no qualms about lying to any of the people closest to him so it would make it almost impossible to know the "real" Sherlock. That's why Eurus is interesting because she knows him so well she can push all of his buttons and yet most wouldn't consider her someone close to Sherlock. Ironic.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Self-preservation can be selfless, because in taking care of yourself, you are ensuring that society, and others don't need to step in and help.

Except that is not the reason provided in the example under question.  In the given example, the reason given not 'because Sherlock doesn't want to negatively impact "society" but 'because Sherlock doesn't want to feel pain'.  I asked how that reason is not selfish - is an example of selflessness.  The above does not address nor answer that question.

 

 

It depends where the pain is coming from. If you want to avoid the pain of hurting others, then you are avoiding your own pain, which is selfish, and their pain, which is selfless. So, again, not either-or in my opinion. I think we see examples in the series where Sherlock's pain comes from hurting others- with Molly, and of course the big one is TST with Mary- he has a lot of pain as a result of his handing of Norbury playing a role in Mary's death

 

So, it could fit my example- Sherlock didn't want to feel the pain of hurting Mycroft through his drug habit, he could get help for his problems and save himself (self preservation) and save Mycroft from the continued heartache and worry (selfless)

 

 

 

John loves Sherlock a lot as a friend, but I think it is just hard for him to empathise, because Sherlock conceals a lot of his feelings from John.

He conceals his feelings for the most part from everyone doesn't he? And Sherlock has no qualms about lying to any of the people closest to him so it would make it almost impossible to know the "real" Sherlock. That's why Eurus is interesting because she knows him so well she can push all of his buttons and yet most wouldn't consider her someone close to Sherlock. Ironic.

 

Yes, I still can't quite figure out how it is that Eurus, of all people could see so deeply into what would upset Sherlock.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

 

ou don't even reference anyone else in the above example.  So how is that specific example about others and not himself?

I did. It's me.

You miss my point.  Or are you saying his not wanting to feel pain is a choice he makes to benefit you somehow - ie you are Sherlock's goal, not himself - and that is your answer to why this particular act is not selfish, but is selfless.

His not wanting to feel pain is a choice he makes to benefit him.

Me not wanting to feel pain is a choice I makes to benefit me.

Good.  So we are back on the same page now.  And since we both now know the specific example I am referencing: "His not wanting to feel pain is a choice he makes to benefit him."  I ask my unanswered question again then:

 

"I'll note, however, you haven't identified why you claim the above supposedly is not selfish ie how the "self-preservation" you identify above is "selfless".  The standard is himself.  He doesn't want to feel "so much pain".  You don't even reference anyone else in the above example.  So how is that specific example supposedly about others and not himself?"

Posted
So, it could fit my example

Except, again, 'your example' is not the example I have asked about.  It doesn't answer my question.  Instead, you offer different examples (like 'Sherlock doesn't want to hurt society, or Mycroft' etc) which is not the example in question.

 

I'm searching for an answer to the question I asked, not to some other question. 

 

If it helps, one can reference a prior example you offered: you claimed Sherlock not wanting to burn his hand again - something you described as a simple act of "self-preservation" - is not an act of selfishness.  Why?

 

Note, the question is not:  "Why is not wanting to burn your hand, so as to save "society" the cost of repair or the like (etc), an act of selflessness?" but "Why is not wanting to burn your hand, simply so as to prevent yourself from feeling that pain and with no 'ulterior' motives - just "self-preservation" as it was put - how is that an act of selflessness?  How is that not selfishness, as was claimed?".

 

 

Posted

In both instances when this Sherlock version descents into the hell of drug-taking, the action starts with a selfless motive: a)Magnussen's pressure against Lord Smallwood for a non-existent case, since the man stopped communicating with the girl immediately after realising she was underage, and

b )At the direct behest of Mary, perhaps weighed down by his feelings about the shooting that resulted in her death.

c) Even his standing there like sculpted out of marble waiting for that bullet to hit, knowing that his observations had driven Mrs Norbury to distraction, is a sign of his willingness to take responsibility for his actions, just like he did in HLV when he found out he had been outwitted by Magnussen, simply in order to keep this Dr Watson and his assassin wife together.

It doesn't get any more selfless! Abnegation is not the trademark of any anti-social personality disorder.

  • Like 2
Posted

a)

b )

c)

One must ask if these bullet points are intended as just random observations, or if they are presented supposedly to refute some argument offered here.  If the latter, the complete absence of any references to which argument they are supposed to address and how they supposedly refute it, renders them inert.

 

Posted

In both instances when this Sherlock version descents into the hell of drug-taking, the action starts with a selfless motive: a)Magnussen's pressure against Lord Smallwood for a non-existent case, since the man stopped communicating with the girl immediately after realising she was underage, and

b )At the direct behest of Mary, perhaps weighed down by his feelings about the shooting that resulted in her death.

c) Even his standing there like sculpted out of marble waiting for that bullet to hit, knowing that his observations had driven Mrs Norbury to distraction, is a sign of his willingness to take responsibility for his actions, just like he did in HLV when he found out he had been outwitted by Magnussen, simply in order to keep this Dr Watson and his assassin wife together.

It doesn't get any more selfless! Abnegation is not the trademark of any anti-social personality disorder.

 

Yes, this is actually exactly what I'm talking about.

 

Sherlock sometimes is too selfless- especially in HLV- and then he hurts himself and others as a result. Because he isn't perfect, but actually, as he suggests in TLD, just as human as the rest of us.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

a)

b )

c)

One must ask if these bullet points are intended as just random observations, or if they are presented supposedly to refute some argument offered here.  If the latter, the complete absence of any references to which argument they are supposed to address and how they supposedly refute it, renders them inert.

 

 

Dearie, may I gently remind you that you are not moderating this discussion and/or forum? As long as the content is not against forum policies (say, hurtful, NSFW, or spam) anyone here is free to express their opinion (!) in any way they choose, and others are free to take their point or not. No one owes you (or anyone else except for Tim, for that matter, who selflessly keeps giving us this space for our musings) anything, sweetie.

 

While we're at it, a quick self-quote (that sounds kinda dirty :lol:) :

 

Okay, so just in case someone else didn't know about this and has trouble with the process, it's totally easy. The official explanation is here, but here comes Caya's Handy Two-Step Guide to Ignoring:

 

1. Click on your name (top right), then choose Manage Ignore Prefs and click on that, too.

 

jCC5s5w.jpg

 

2. The screen wil change to this. Enter the name of the user of your, er, choice, then don't forget to check the boxes for what you want to ignore (when in doubt, check all :P), click on Save Changes - and that's it, no more blather.

 

mvgLlBJ.jpg

 

Also of interest to our mobile users may be the little inconspicuous box there on the top left - check that (don't forget about Save Changes) and no more signatures, which might come in handy when reading on a small screen.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

a)

b )

c)

One must ask if these bullet points are intended as just random observations, or if they are presented supposedly to refute some argument offered here.  If the latter, the complete absence of any references to which argument they are supposed to address and how they supposedly refute it, renders them inert.

 

Dearie, may I gently remind you that you are not moderating this discussion and/or forum?

No one owes you...anything, sweetie

Good thing I wasn't trying to moderate nor declaring someone "owed" me anything then, eh?  :)

 

I asked a question about a post - ie I was trying to understand if a commenter was simply making random observations or if their comments were intended to address an (unspecified) argument.  It certainly seemed like the latter, but - as I noted - given the lack of any reference to such an argument, it was unclear as to which argument and how it addressed it (thus enervating the comment's effectiveness to that end) - if that was even their intent.  I couldn't be sure one way or the other - thus the question.

 

I'm sorry if asking that question - ie trying to understand someone's "musings" - offended you "dearie".

Posted

I don't like the tone the discussion here has taken on lately. I would like to get back to talking peacefully about the episode.

 

Really like Artemis' prompt below:

 

 

On that note, as a matter of curiosity: Sherlock's degree of empathy is often discussed, but I wonder what you all think of the empathy (or perhaps lack thereof?) shown by the rest of the characters, particularly towards him or in comparison to him?  As I said above, I don't really see Sherlock as having less empathy than the others, just expressed differently.  In what ways do you see Sherlock on the receiving end of empathy (not just tolerance, actual empathy)?  I've been thinking about this, and to be honest, the character I really see showing the most notable amount of empathy to anyone is Molly.  Though Mrs. Hudson also comes to mind, especially in TLD.  I'm not even sure I see John showing all that much empathy, thinking back, although he certainly cares for Sherlock.  Thoughts?

 
Interesting question. I think it's hard for the others to show Sherlock empathy directly, because his most likely response is to bristle at them and ruin the mood.
 
But Mary, in TSo3, when she realizes he's nervous about the upcoming nuptials, and again, when she realizes he's jealous of Sholto. Even when she's dying, as sappy as it is, she spares a word for him. :rolleyes: And at the beginning, when they first meet, she says she'll talk John around. Now that I think on it, it seems to me that Sherlock and Mary are the ones who really "get" each other in this show (although I think Mary gets John, too.)
 
Molly, of course. Mrs. Hudson? She's such a flake (like his real mom! What does this say about the Moftisses attitudes towards their mothers, I wonder? ;)) ... I don't know if I'd call it empathy, she simply loves him like a son.
 
Mycroft, in his own way ... offering a cigarette after Irene "dies", telling Sherlock he has some "utility" at Christmas ... he's cold about it, but I think that's partly because that's all Sherlock will accept from him. Even after the "I love you" scene, Mycroft started to say something, but Sherlock wouldn't let him.
 
John ... I think John leans towards "just tolerance", but isn't that more what Sherlock is looking for? Not someone to acknowledge his feelings, but someone to accept him for what he is? At least at the beginning. By the end, they've become so close it's almost a moot point ...

 

I agree that Molly shows most empathy towards Sherlock - and the most appreciation for him as a person, rather than a genius. I think they were trying to show Mary as even more understanding of and affectionate towards him but I am not sure that I consider their efforts very successful. She often comes off as more smug and condescending than anything else to me.

 

John doesn't strike me as particularly empathic in general. And Mycroft... Somehow, I can't quite fit "Mycroft" and "empathy" into the same box in my brain. :P I see Mycroft as having more rational, conscious knowledge about his brother. He's studied him, so to speak, and deals with him on the basis of observations, not intuition.

 

As for Mrs Hudson, my idea of her is that she's a lot less flaky beneath the surface than she appears. For example, I think she drew John's attention to Mary's DVD on purpose, she just acted like she didn't know what it was about. Because we saw her watch the thing with Sherlock before and while this show isn't immune to continuity errors, this would be too big a mistake for only two writers to make from one episode to another.

 

  • Like 5
Posted

 

 

 

 

a)

b )

c)

 

One must ask if these bullet points are intended as just random observations, or if they are presented supposedly to refute some argument offered here. If the latter, the complete absence of any references to which argument they are supposed to address and how they supposedly refute it, renders them inert.

Dearie, may I gently remind you that you are not moderating this discussion and/or forum?

No one owes you...anything, sweetie

Good thing I wasn't trying to moderate nor declaring someone "owed" me anything then, eh? :)

I asked a question about a post - ie I was trying to understand if a commenter was simply making random observations or if their comments were intended to address an argument. It certainly seemed like the latter, but - as I noted - given the lack of any reference to such an argument, it was unclear as to which argument and how it addressed it (thus inervating its effectiveness to that end) - if that was even their intent. I couldn't be sure one way or the other - thus the question.

I'm sorry if asking that question - ie trying to understand someone's "musings" - offended you "dearie".

Sorry, BLS, but your post also struck me as rather harshly critical, as though you thought all posts here are required to be in explicit response to some prior post. Even if that was not your intent (and after reading your subsequent post, I can see that it may not have been), that was the immediate effect that your post had on at least two people who are quite familiar with this forum. Perhaps a less formal tone could help to avert future misunderstandings of this sort.

 

May I also remind you that the forum rules preclude arguing with a moderator on the open forum. Next time you have a beef with one of us, please send a PM instead. Thank you.

  • Like 3
Posted

Okay, people, as you may have noticed, the mods are starting to circle like sharks.

There's a reason for that.

Language, remember? As in: use it gently, not to bludgeon someone else with your "brilliance."

In other words: the tone of one's language matters as much or more as the literal meaning of one's words.

May I suggest editing before posting?

Please?

 
Annnnd ... it looks like Carol and I cross-posted here. (See what I mean? :smile: ) But I'll let my statement stand, to reinforce hers.
 
Meanwhile....
 

I don't like the tone the discussion here has taken on lately. I would like to get back to talking peacefully about the episode.
 
Really like Artemis' prompt below:
 

On that note, as a matter of curiosity: Sherlock's degree of empathy is often discussed, but I wonder what you all think of the empathy (or perhaps lack thereof?) shown by the rest of the characters, particularly towards him or in comparison to him?  As I said above, I don't really see Sherlock as having less empathy than the others, just expressed differently.  In what ways do you see Sherlock on the receiving end of empathy (not just tolerance, actual empathy)?  I've been thinking about this, and to be honest, the character I really see showing the most notable amount of empathy to anyone is Molly.  Though Mrs. Hudson also comes to mind, especially in TLD.  I'm not even sure I see John showing all that much empathy, thinking back, although he certainly cares for Sherlock.  Thoughts?

 
I agree that Molly shows most empathy towards Sherlock - and the most appreciation for him as a person, rather than a genius. I think they were trying to show Mary as even more understanding of and affectionate towards him but I am not sure that I consider their efforts very successful. She often comes off as more smug and condescending than anything else to me.

 

Just like Sherlock, in other words? :D Maybe that's why they got along so well, they shared a rather dark sense of humor about us goldfish. I wonder what that says about John, that he's seems attracted to people like that? Eh, forget John, I wonder what it says about me....
 

... Somehow, I can't quite fit "Mycroft" and "empathy" into the same box in my brain. :P I see Mycroft as having more rational, conscious knowledge about his brother. He's studied him, so to speak, and deals with him on the basis of observations, not intuition.

Okay, I concede you that one! Scratch Mycroft from the empathy list! :D
 

As for Mrs Hudson, my idea of her is that she's a lot less flaky beneath the surface than she appears. For example, I think she drew John's attention to Mary's DVD on purpose, she just acted like she didn't know what it was about. Because we saw her watch the thing with Sherlock before and while this show isn't immune to continuity errors, this would be too big a mistake for only two writers to make from one episode to another.

Oi, don't even get me started there. I'm beginning to think no one actually reads the scripts. It's a wonder they make as much sense as they do, at this rate. :picard: (It's okay, Moftiss, we love you even if you're not always perfect... :smile: )

  • Like 2
Posted

Oi, don't even get me started there. I'm beginning to think no one actually reads the scripts. It's a wonder they make as much sense as they do, at this rate. :picard: (It's okay, Moftiss, we love you even if you're not always perfect... :smile: )

 

They certainly don't have to be perfect to please me. All I ask for is the option to make sense of things and create a kind of continuity in my own mind palace. As long as they don't disturb that... It's all fine.

 

They must have done some reading of their old scripts though, the way they fitted Euros and Redbeard and so on into Sherlock's history as if they had always been part of it. And they keep making references to older episodes (which I love).

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Yes, once I started to get the gist of what happened in S4, I was pleasantly surprised to see that the story arc fits together pretty dang well. And like you, I didn't expect anything resembling an ending, let alone such a satisfying one. Just have to remember not to tug at the loose threads too hard... :smile:

Posted

 

May I also remind you that the forum rules preclude arguing with a moderator on the open forum. Next time you have a beef with one of us, please send a PM instead. Thank you.

Understood.  PM it is.  Thank you.

  • Like 1
Posted

That's interesting. I didn't find the end of this season satisfying at all. It was by far my least favorite part. Like it wasn't earned.

  • Like 1
Posted

That's interesting. I didn't find the end of this season satisfying at all. It was by far my least favorite part. Like it wasn't earned.

Care to elaborate? It's always interesting to read different perspectives.

Posted

 

That's interesting. I didn't find the end of this season satisfying at all. It was by far my least favorite part. Like it wasn't earned.

Care to elaborate? It's always interesting to read different perspectives.

 

 

There are many ways the ending felt undeserved but I'd say the most telling one is what Mary says during the epilogue.

 

She talks about how this is the story of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson but John barely had anything to do with the final episode. The final episode focused on Sherlock's family so it spent a lot of time with Sherlock, Mycroft and Euros and not enough with John. Honestly John was little more than a plot device in The Final Problem.

 

That's why Mary's words at the end felt like they came out of nowhere. How did The Final Problem in any way lead into showing that Sherlock was the story of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson? 

 

In fact I'd say Season 4 has dialed down the relationship between Sherlock and John more than any other season. Usually each episode of Sherlock devotes a lot of time to Sherlock and John's relationship. I'd even argue that each episode has at least one big memorable moment for Sherlock and John's relationship.

 

However I can't say that about any of the episodes of Season 4 except The Lying Detective. The Six Thatchers spent too much time on Mary and The Final Problem spent too much time on Mycroft and Euros. I honestly thought Moffatiss could have done better. A Scandel in Belgravia focused on the relationship between Sherlock and Irene but John didn't feel neglected in that episode in terms of his relationship with Sherlock. He did have that moment at the end where he lied about Irene because he didn't want to hurt Sherlock's feelings. 

 

In many ways, John felt like a side character rather than the deuteragonist of the show in Season 4.

  • Like 1
Posted

Deuteragonist! I just learned a new word! :smile:

 

I partly agree with you ... John is definitely less of a major character than he was in the first two seasons, at least in my eyes. Too much time reacting instead of acting, perhaps? But I'm pretty satisfied with where he ended up in TFP, which was at Sherlock's side, and totally in sync with him. So often we see them at cross purposes, but not in TFP.

 

And TLD was in some ways all about John. But he's never going to stand out the way Sherlock does; he's not as flashy a character.

 

I was hoping for some really big moment for John in S4; something spectacular that he alone could pull off. It didn't happen. :( But I still like where he ended up, even if it's a smaller role than I thought it would be. But at least there's the sense that he and Sherlock are a unit, now; you can't have one without the other. That's a good thing, yeah?

 

Anyway, what I primarily found satisfying about the ending was the fact that it actually wrapped up the current storyline. I.e., no cliffhanger. Yet at the same time I felt it left plenty of room for new stories without them feeling like they're tacked on as an afterthought. Still room for the characters to evolve, but they're not in limbo.

 

Except for Molly. I regret there wasn't something, anything, to give her a proper stopping point. She deserved better. *sigh*

  • Like 3
Posted

 

That's interesting. I didn't find the end of this season satisfying at all. It was by far my least favorite part. Like it wasn't earned.

Care to elaborate? It's always interesting to read different perspectives.
The montage/epilogue felt tacked on like it didn't naturally fit the rest of the episode with all the characters happy. There were no meaningful scenes of the Eurus aftermath, there were no real consequences to what was supposed to be a life changing experience, e.g. no resolution to the ILY scene or any ending scene with Mycroft and Sherlock about Eurus or the experience. All you so saw were happy characters but not how they got there. It was just very rushed like much of this season actually. Don't get me started on the idiocy of the Mary narration. What is it about that character that they felt she had to be in every episode even after she was dead and how many DVDs did she make? Annoying as all get out to me. Hated everything about it. Reminded me of how they ended Castle with a tacked on montage after a cliffhanger scene when they realized it wouldn't be renewed for another season.

 

Now contrast the ending of the last episode with the ending of TLD. The best part of TLD was the end and how Sherlock and Watson's relationship was explored properly based on the events of the episode. It was a natural ending to the spirit of the episode. Can't say that for TFP. It's like they wanted it to book end the entire 4 series but the buildup to the denouement didn't fit.

  • Like 3
Posted

I disagree about John's lack of focus this season. Much of TST was about John's wife Mary and TLD was all about his grief about Mary's death. I do think they marginalized John though when they wrote Mary in to the show like Mary was used to make John interesting rather than the other way around.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

There are many ways the ending felt undeserved but I'd say the most telling one is what Mary says during the epilogue.

 

She talks about how this is the story of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson but John barely had anything to do with the final episode. The final episode focused on Sherlock's family so it spent a lot of time with Sherlock, Mycroft and Euros and not enough with John. Honestly John was little more than a plot device in The Final Problem.

 

That's why Mary's words at the end felt like they came out of nowhere. How did The Final Problem in any way lead into showing that Sherlock was the story of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson? 

 

In fact I'd say Season 4 has dialed down the relationship between Sherlock and John more than any other season. Usually each episode of Sherlock devotes a lot of time to Sherlock and John's relationship. I'd even argue that each episode has at least one big memorable moment for Sherlock and John's relationship.

 

However I can't say that about any of the episodes of Season 4 except The Lying Detective. The Six Thatchers spent too much time on Mary and The Final Problem spent too much time on Mycroft and Euros. I honestly thought Moffatiss could have done better. A Scandel in Belgravia focused on the relationship between Sherlock and Irene but John didn't feel neglected in that episode in terms of his relationship with Sherlock. He did have that moment at the end where he lied about Irene because he didn't want to hurt Sherlock's feelings. 

 

In many ways, John felt like a side character rather than the deuteragonist of the show in Season 4.

 

 

I also felt that there was something a bit undeserved in the ending epilogue. For me, the show as a whole earned it, but the episode itself didn't , if that makes sense? Because it wasn't a classic Sherlock episode in the traditional format, it was sort of experimental, and as an ending I would have liked something more focused on Sherlock and John, and their adventures. I agree their friendship was dialled down. 

 

I also think they were suddenly over-burdened with plot- they had Mary's storyline, and the build up to Moriarty's 'miss me'- and only three measly episodes to do everything in. So there was a lot of plot and not as much character. Then, they had to sort of artificially create scenarios (Eurus's rooms) to reveal where the characters relationships were at the end- but I would have much rather seen all that character development as an organic part of the story. Sadly I don't think there was time.

 

 

 

 

I was hoping for some really big moment for John in S4; something spectacular that he alone could pull off. It didn't happen.  :( But I still like where he ended up, even if it's a smaller role than I thought it would be. But at least there's the sense that he and Sherlock are a unit, now; you can't have one without the other. That's a good thing, yeah?

 

Anyway, what I primarily found satisfying about the ending was the fact that it actually wrapped up the current storyline. I.e., no cliffhanger. Yet at the same time I felt it left plenty of room for new stories without them feeling like they're tacked on as an afterthought. Still room for the characters to evolve, but they're not in limbo.

 

Except for Molly. I regret there wasn't something, anything, to give her a proper stopping point. She deserved better. *sigh*

 

 

Season four left me wondering if they have simply run out of ideas for John? Even the infidelity story felt a bit like they were trying to give him something interesting to do.

 

I also really liked not having a cliffhanger.  It just seems to waste too much time in the next season (if there is one). And I also think Molly deserved a more solid ending. Though I was also very afraid she would be killed, so I'm glad they didn't do that.

 

 

 

 

That's interesting. I didn't find the end of this season satisfying at all. It was by far my least favorite part. Like it wasn't earned.

Care to elaborate? It's always interesting to read different perspectives.
The montage/epilogue felt tacked on like it didn't naturally fit the rest of the episode with all the characters happy. There were no meaningful scenes of the Eurus aftermath, there were no real consequences to what was supposed to be a life changing experience, e.g. no resolution to the ILY scene or any ending scene with Mycroft and Sherlock about Eurus or the experience. All you so saw were happy characters but not how they got there. It was just very rushed like much of this season actually. Don't get me started on the idiocy of the Mary narration. What is it about that character that they felt she had to be in every episode even after she was dead and how many DVDs did she make? Annoying as all get out to me. Hated everything about it. Reminded me of how they ended Castle with a tacked on montage after a cliffhanger scene when they realized it wouldn't be renewed for another season.

 

Now contrast the ending of the last episode with the ending of TLD. The best part of TLD was the end and how Sherlock and Watson's relationship was explored properly based on the events of the episode. It was a natural ending to the spirit of the episode. Can't say that for TFP. It's like they wanted it to book end the entire 4 series but the buildup to the denouement didn't fit.

 

 

I somehow got the feeling that they felt both guilty and regretful about killing off Mary. I think they could have done so much more with her, than with John, who I do feel they are struggling to write stuff for at this stage. 

 

Although, I say that, and they have a wonderful living female character in the form of Molly, and they do practically nothing with her too. What does a girl have to do to get the writers attention, die? I mean, her one scene in TFP was amazing and all, but it is a waste of the talent they have at their disposal. But Molly's ending especially felt tacked on for sure.

  • Like 4
Posted

Okay, I have to agree with almost everything you folks said, even though I still really like the ending. :wacko: How can this be!?!

 

For one thing ... I really, really liked Mary, so I was happy to see that she just hadn't disappeared as if she never existed (I was pleased that they honored her existence earlier in the episode, too, when Big G asked John if he were married.) I thought making her an assassin was silly and over the top, but I loved her personality and the way she interacted with the boys. And Amanda did a great job making me believe she actually could have been an assassin at one time.

 

But I'm struck by your point, Gerry, that it's almost like they were using Mary to make John interesting. I hadn't looked at it that way before, and there's something to it. They couldn't think of anything else to do with him so, hey, they give him a badass wife. :rolleyes: Good grief.

 

But still ...  after the hell they put their characters through this season, and after the brutally downer endings of the last two seasons, I guess I just felt the time was right for an out and out happy ending. Let them be in peace for awhile.

 

 

 

  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 97 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.