Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

According to the Mofftiss, he was genuine in approaching Molly, which I always thought (because she had already read him anyhow), but he was faking it on the roof.  But I don't feel he was 100% faking it on the roof.  I think he was really bothered by what he had to do to John and his friends.  But later when we see him observing John at the grave, we see that he has shut off his emotions and he's off to take care of business.

Posted

We Americans avoid the entire issue by not using milk in our tea at all.

Speak for yourself! :smile: We're a "tea in first" crowd in this neck of the woods, although oddly enough I put the milk in first with my coffee.

 

Sorry, I know perfectly well that some Americans use milk in their tea.  So I should have said, "Most Americans avoid the entire issue...."  There.  Am I forgiven?

 

... what if John had tried to run back into the building? I think the bicycle would have still have knocked him down, or maybe there were some other tricks planned to keep him in place. Apparently Sherlock's entire scheme depended on convincing John he was dead. Why that is so, I still have trouble understanding.

 

I agree that John seemed to be the target audience.  As to why --

 

Have you ever seen a TV show where the detective suspected that a person assumed to be dead was actually just hiding out somewhere -- simply because the "widow" didn't seem genuinely grief-stricken?  Substitute Moriarty's gang for the detective, and John for the widow, and I suspect that was Sherlock's rationale.

 

(Besides, that's what Sherlock told John in, I believe, the third restaurant in "Empty Hearse" -- and it's what Holmes told Watson.  Not that I routinely believe either of them, but we do know that John's a lousy actor, so this time their explanation makes sense to me.)

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

Apparently Sherlock's entire scheme depended on convincing John he was dead. Why that is so, I still have trouble understanding.

 

*Sigh*... me too. It's a mystery. One of those unfathomable Sherlock things. I think it's got something to do with "alone protects me", and I have an inkling it wouldn't have happened if Moriarty had not decked out John in explosives three episodes earlier. But who knows.

 

 

 

I think this is one of those canon-adherence things, actually.  Moftiss don't have any problem deviating from Conan Doyle when they want to -- they invented Molly, they say in the DVD commentary that John decking Sherlock upon his return was something that they always felt should have happened instead of him fainting (I agree).  But I think there are bits of Conan Doyle that just *mean* Sherlock Holmes to the pair, things that they don't feel like they can deviate from without changing the Holmesian nature of things.  

 

I think this is one of them.  I think, to them, they needed to not only preserve the Great Hiatus but also preserve John's lack of knowledge of the thing.  There's really very little reason to suppose that Sherlock could not have trusted John, at least after the fact of the Fall.  John may be a bad actor, but so am I, and I guarantee you that if my best friend told me that her life, my life, and our friends' lives depended on me selling her death, I'd be able to trot myself to her fake grave once a week, spill some tears, and go back to our hypothetical apartment and start boxing things up, all for show.  John's ex-Army; he doesn't have to weep like a girl.  He just needs to look and act like he's in mourning.

 

As far as in-universe head canon, I always just assume that that Sherlock figures that John "knows his methods" by that point, and that probably John eventually put two and two together and realized that the idea of Sherlock being actually dead while Mycroft kept 221B intact and undisturbed, among other things, was preposterous.  Sherlock's problem was that he didn't realize that John would not just respond emotionally but keep responding emotionally rather than analytically.  

 

Plus, it does make the return hysterical.  Hit him again, John!

  • Like 3
Posted

I think this is one of those canon-adherence things, actually.  Moftiss don't have any problem deviating from Conan Doyle when they want to -- they invented Molly, they say in the DVD commentary that John decking Sherlock upon his return was something that they always felt should have happened instead of him fainting (I agree).  But I think there are bits of Conan Doyle that just *mean* Sherlock Holmes to the pair, things that they don't feel like they can deviate from without changing the Holmesian nature of things.

 

Yes, I think that's at the heart of it.  And there are some other clear nods to "The Final Problem" and "The Empty House," such as:

 

The recovered painting, Turner's Falls of the Reichenbach, refers to the place where Holmes supposedly died.

The fake phone call parallels the fake note that called Watson back to the hotel to tend to a dying Englishwoman --

. . . . so that he did not witness Holmes' confrontation with Moriarty

Sherlock supposedly dies by falling, just at Holmes supposedly did.

Sherlock watches John at the cemetery, as Holmes watched Watson investigate his "death"

 

In addition, the kidnapping subplot is an adaptation of the Jeremy Brett adaptation of "The Priory School."

  • Like 1
Posted

 

As far as in-universe head canon, I always just assume that that Sherlock figures that John "knows his methods" by that point, and that probably John eventually put two and two together and realized that the idea of Sherlock being actually dead while Mycroft kept 221B intact and undisturbed, among other things, was preposterous.  Sherlock's problem was that he didn't realize that John would not just respond emotionally but keep responding emotionally rather than analytically. 

 

If Sherlock thought that, he'd have used it in his defense, though. But he didn't, and I don't think it likely that he expected ordinary goldfish John to figure out what had really happened on his own.

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

As far as in-universe head canon, I always just assume that that Sherlock figures that John "knows his methods" by that point, and that probably John eventually put two and two together and realized that the idea of Sherlock being actually dead while Mycroft kept 221B intact and undisturbed, among other things, was preposterous.  Sherlock's problem was that he didn't realize that John would not just respond emotionally but keep responding emotionally rather than analytically. 

 

If Sherlock thought that, he'd have used it in his defense, though. But he didn't, and I don't think it likely that he expected ordinary goldfish John to figure out what had really happened on his own.

 

 

 

 

Possibly.  You make sense there.

 

However, even though I think having John beat the tar out of Sherlock on his return was hysterical and completely called for, I think John was a bit of an idiot.  Maybe I'll try to write this as a story one day, but I keep trying to imagine the confrontation that must have occurred to keep John from seeing Sherlock's body after it was laid out and before the funeral, given that no one could have given him the standard excuses for a closed casket.  And there were, I think, other clues like the flat being left intact.

 

Often, my sympathies are with Sherlock in TRF.  He has watched his reputation get trashed by Moriarty, and he knows he's headed off on a mission that could be every bit the suicide mission that he almost took at the end of HLV.  He needs to believe that he's doing this because he's protecting his friends, and that his life will be as he left it for him to return to.  And then it turns out his best friend responded emotionally to his death, which I don't think Sherlock did a very good job of predicting.  I don't know -- I just always feel for Sherlock on this one.

  • Like 1
Posted

However, even though I think having John beat the tar out of Sherlock on his return was hysterical and completely called for, I think John was a bit of an idiot.  Maybe I'll try to write this as a story one day, but I keep trying to imagine the confrontation that must have occurred to keep John from seeing Sherlock's body after it was laid out and before the funeral, given that no one could have given him the standard excuses for a closed casket.  And there were, I think, other clues like the flat being left intact.

 

Often, my sympathies are with Sherlock in TRF.  He has watched his reputation get trashed by Moriarty, and he knows he's headed off on a mission that could be every bit the suicide mission that he almost took at the end of HLV.  He needs to believe that he's doing this because he's protecting his friends, and that his life will be as he left it for him to return to.  And then it turns out his best friend responded emotionally to his death, which I don't think Sherlock did a very good job of predicting.  I don't know -- I just always feel for Sherlock on this one.

 

Oh, I almost always feel with Sherlock. He's strangely relatable. And he doesn't mean to be a bastard.

 

I feel very sorry for Sherlock when the reunion goes wrong. I wouldn't have wanted it to go any other way, but I still feel sorry for him.

 

About the flat... Maybe that's why they had John break off contact with Mrs Hudson, so that the whole thing would make more sense, because it seem she didn't know the place had been kept the way it was.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

However, even though I think having John beat the tar out of Sherlock on his return was hysterical and completely called for, I think John was a bit of an idiot.  Maybe I'll try to write this as a story one day, but I keep trying to imagine the confrontation that must have occurred to keep John from seeing Sherlock's body after it was laid out and before the funeral, given that no one could have given him the standard excuses for a closed casket.  And there were, I think, other clues like the flat being left intact.

I agree. In my headcanon, John did notice that some things didn't quite fit the official story, and in some versions, he actually figured out that Sherlock wasn't really dead. But of course, Moftiss wouldn't write it that way, because in the original, Watson is totally clueless.

 

About the flat... Maybe that's why they had John break off contact with Mrs Hudson, so that the whole thing would make more sense, because it seem she didn't know the place had been kept the way it was.

For a real-life reason, that makes perfect sense. And it's also fairly consistent with canon, where Watson had already moved out of Baker Street (due to his marriage to Mary Morstan) well before Holmes supposedly died.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

 

However, even though I think having John beat the tar out of Sherlock on his return was hysterical and completely called for, I think John was a bit of an idiot. Maybe I'll try to write this as a story one day, but I keep trying to imagine the confrontation that must have occurred to keep John from seeing Sherlock's body after it was laid out and before the funeral, given that no one could have given him the standard excuses for a closed casket. And there were, I think, other clues like the flat being left intact.

 

Often, my sympathies are with Sherlock in TRF. He has watched his reputation get trashed by Moriarty, and he knows he's headed off on a mission that could be every bit the suicide mission that he almost took at the end of HLV. He needs to believe that he's doing this because he's protecting his friends, and that his life will be as he left it for him to return to. And then it turns out his best friend responded emotionally to his death, which I don't think Sherlock did a very good job of predicting. I don't know -- I just always feel for Sherlock on this one.

Oh, I almost always feel with Sherlock. He's strangely relatable. And he doesn't mean to be a bastard.

 

I feel very sorry for Sherlock when the reunion goes wrong. I wouldn't have wanted it to go any other way, but I still feel sorry for him.

 

About the flat... Maybe that's why they had John break off contact with Mrs Hudson, so that the whole thing would make more sense, because it seem she didn't know the place had been kept the way it was.

The whole sequence is hilarious! I do agree that Sherlock's explanation stands, that he was afraid John might blurt something out in an unguarded moment, which also runs close to the whole Empty House rationalisation, but I think that from the moment he recognises his mistake in the restaurant ("Bit mean springing it on you like that") he lets John get away with everything from trying to throttle him to giving him a bloody nose, because he could at any moment immobilise Dr. Watson very effectively. Martial arts notwithstanding, he is taller, stronger even than Mycroft, as is obvious in their encounter in his flat in HLV, has a longer reach and cat-like reflexes. He complains about "overreacting", but all the rest is endured in his endeavour to win Dr. Watson's forgiveness. As for the funeral thing, Molly obviously rushed the whole thing through with Mycroft's help that Dr. Watson was left with just a fleeting impression of his friend having no pulse.
  • Like 2
Posted

Oh, make no mistake about it, Sherlock is stronger than John and Mycroft.  Even when Sherlock and John are having that bit off a tussle in ASIB, I never feel like SH is in any danger from John but that SH is sort of just putting up with him but that he could throw him off in a moment's notice.

  • Like 2
Posted

I don't know who might win a non-surprise fight (Sherlock's reach is obviously longer, but John could still be stronger and/or more determined).  However I think one reason Sherlock lost all of the above-mentioned tussles is that he consistently underestimates John.

 

  • Like 3
Posted

I don't know who might win a non-surprise fight (Sherlock's reach is obviously longer, but John could still be stronger and/or more determined).  However I think one reason Sherlock lost all of the above-mentioned tussles is that he consistently underestimates John.

I don't know if he's underestimating John so much as he's over-estimating himself! :lol:

Posted

Sherlock is supposed to know some martial arts (if we stick to canon on that) so it's possible that he could out power John in a non-surprise fight. However, we're never told if the doctor has any training of that sort which could change the dynamic if he does.

Posted

Right.  John's apparently had extensive firearm training -- so who knows what else he may have learned in the army?

 

Posted

Sherlock does prove his firearm prowess in shooting Smiley so accurately, however.  He doesn't manage to hit the Golem, but to be fair the lights were flashing off and on and he was literally shooting in the dark at times.

 

According to canon, he is also an expert swordsman, and I think we got a nod to it in TBB although he didn't use a sword - although someone came after him with one.

  • Like 1
Posted

Right! How many of you are actually irritated by the constant use of "assume" and all its derivatives that he uses? Like a good detective, he must bear in mind the injunction given to Jodie Foster in The Silence of the Lambs by her CIA ( I am not sure there is not a link to Mary in there) of not using "assume" because it makes an A

Posted

Does he assume stuff, though? You're probably right, I just can't think of an example right now.

 

I think he makes huge intuitive leaps sometimes, which make it look like he's winging it. And he assumes everything's dull and boring until he finds out otherwise. :smile: But when he's actually "deducing" something?

  • Like 1
Posted

I think that from the moment he recognises his mistake in the restaurant ("Bit mean springing it on you like that") he lets John get away with everything from trying to throttle him to giving him a bloody nose, because he could at any moment immobilise Dr. Watson very effectively. Martial arts notwithstanding, he is taller, stronger even than Mycroft, as is obvious in their encounter in his flat in HLV, has a longer reach and cat-like reflexes.

I don't think S is stronger than average, but he is quick and know some tricks. (Mycroft don't have to be strong. He has his mind.)

I think he was just taken by surprise - I bet he expected John would give him a big hug. In a way he did...  :D

 

BTW the restaurant scene literally blown me away. MF's performance - I swear I have never seen something like that before. Every time I watch it, I get a lump in my throat. I also want to slap the camera operator for Mary's head in the picture and rip the bloody mustache off from MF's lip so I could see his face clearly.

  • Like 3
Posted

Right! How many of you are actually irritated by the constant use of "assume" and all its derivatives that he uses? Like a good detective, he must bear in mind the injunction given to Jodie Foster in The Silence of the Lambs by her CIA ( I am not sure there is not a link to Mary in there) of not using "assume" because it makes an A

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I know you just discovered the show recently -- have you seen "Reichenbach Fall"?  From the very first episode, I was greatly impressed by the program as a whole, but had not singled out any specific character or actor till I saw "Reichenbach."  There are admittedly three wonderful performances there -- but Martin Freeman's performance really gets to me every time.  Same with the scene you mention in "Empty Hearse" as well as a number of others (in Sherlock and elsewhere).

 

Ugh, sorry I just realized going OT with my post. So back to the track:

I have seen everything. More than once. How could it be any other way, I'm already a MONTH into it. ;)

 

In TRF Freeman's performance is a part of long and very emotional sequence, while in TEH it takes you by surprise and you can hardly see what hits you.

 

The Fall starts already with a gem - the dialog with the therapist. It happened to me - losing my voice in an emotional moment (no matter how much you try, your vocal chords won't work) and I imagine it is hard to play. I don't think I could fake it.

The fall itself: everytime I hear "he's my friend" I feel queasy. Physically. I can imagine thousand ways to act in this scene and each would be weaker.

 

BTW, Freeman literally saved the finale of Hobbit for me. I wasn't moved by Thorin's death at all, until I saw Bilbo's reaction.

  • Like 4
Posted

Right. John's apparently had extensive firearm training -- so who knows what else he may have learned in the army?

This particular thread seems rather temperamental today! It won't allow me to post.
Posted

Yup.

 

I like your short response that ended up at the top of the page.  Had to review what was before it to get it's context. :)

Posted

Yup.

 

I hope you mentally popped that P.

  • Like 1
Posted

Right. John's apparently had extensive firearm training -- so who knows what else he may have learned in the army?

Wait a minute... does any army in the world send it's doctors in the field? It would be... erm... not so good. The "medics" in the battle zone are paramedics? So John actually shouldn't see too much action... scratch-head.gif I think I have to research on this. (or was it discussed elsewhere?)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 242 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.