Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

I not only expected you to remember, you did!

  • Like 1
Posted

My initial thought was that the call was Sherlock's idea. But somewhere in the web there is an explanation why it wouldn't work. Will find it, but again it's after midnight. Need to tobed.gif again.

  • Like 1
Posted

My initial thought was that the call was Sherlock's idea. But somewhere in the web there is an explanation why it wouldn't work. Will find it, but again it's after midnight. Need to tobed.gif again.

Sleep is boring. :D

Posted

I not only expected you to remember, you did!

 

Nope.  Didn't.  Forum search worked pretty well, though.

 

My initial thought was that the call was Sherlock's idea. But somewhere in the web there is an explanation why it wouldn't work. Will find it....

 

Yes, please, once you've had some sleep.  The deleted scene was fine to establish the writers' initial intent, but such things do sometimes change, so I'd love to see why it really couldn't have been Sherlock.

Posted

OmsyFCk.jpg

 

As much as it is done well, I just can't like it. The emotional feels. And the artist's initials look like they are JM which adds to it a little.

 

Eta: I should say, I can't click the like button. I like everything about it, but clicking the like button just seems wrong for reasons stated above.

Posted

I don't know, but I never got any emotional feels over it... perhaps because I knew there was a series 3 available to watch, so I knew that he somehow survived, even before I saw him at the end of the episode.  After all, you can't kill off your protagonist/hero.  Either that,  or my heart is even smaller than Sherlock's.

  • Like 2
Posted

Thanks, J.P.!  Talk about thorough!
 
However, I'm not entirely certain that everything cited as evidence there is actually evidence.  For example, consider this:
 

The sniper whose job it was to watch Sherlock’s fall or shoot John didn’t show up right away. He arrived at his station across from St. Bart’s after Jim shot himself, but before John had returned to the hospital.

 
Admittedly, that's the order those events are shown in -- but it seems plausible to me that the sequence is thematic rather than chronological.  (You can see the sequence on Ariane DeVere's transcript.)  If the sequence is indeed meant to be taken literally, though, that's a very interesting point.
 
As is this:
 

Jim never started a countdown timer. He never said Sherlock had to jump within 15 minutes or by 9:00 or in any way communicated at what point the gunmen would give up on the possibility of Sherlock jumping and shoot his friends instead. And this is Jim Moriarty we’re talking about here. Half of his gimmick in The Great Game was making Sherlock do things before the allotted time ran out.

 
That's another very interesting point, and consistent with the previous one.  If we can ignore Moriarty-the-deadline-maniac for a moment, though, couldn't the "deadline" have been simply "The only way you're allowed to leave the roof is by jumping"?
 
But taken together, those points are indeed compelling, especially when capped with this:
 
 

John was the countdown timer, and Sherlock knew it.
 
... The sniper had been told that if Sherlock didn’t jump, John should be shot as soon as he tried to enter the hospital.....
 
That’s why Sherlock had to be standing on the ledge before John’s cab arrived—he needed to make it clear to the sniper that he was preparing to jump. He couldn’t have John get shot simply because it looked like he wasn’t going to go through with it.
 
And that’s why Sherlock sounded so insistent and even worried when he was convincing John to stop and turn around within a few feet of the hospital entrance.

 
 That thought makes the chills run down my spine!
 

I knew that he somehow survived, even before I saw him at the end of the episode.  After all, you can't kill off your protagonist/hero.

 
Yup.  Me too.  It had to be some kind of a trick.  I was sad for what John was going through, rather than on my own behalf.
 
I was bewildered when I heard that some people still thought he was really dead even after seeing that final scene.  Though on further thought, I guess if you didn't already have the "it's only a trick" mindset, Sherlock's personal appearance at the cemetery could easily be interpreted as symbolic, or perhaps as his ghost watching over John.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

I knew that he somehow survived, even before I saw him at the end of the episode.  After all, you can't kill off your protagonist/hero.

 

Yup.  Me too.  It had to be some kind of a trick.  I was sad for what John was going through, rather than on my own behalf.

 

I was bewildered when I heard that some people still thought he was really dead even after seeing that final scene.  Though on further thought, I guess if you didn't already have the "it's only a trick" mindset, Sherlock's personal appearance at the cemetery could easily be interpreted as symbolic, or perhaps as his ghost watching over John.

 

You should give Game of Thrones a try some day. It might be an interesting experience ;).

Posted

Thanks, J.P.!  Talk about thorough!

 

However, I'm not entirely certain that everything cited as evidence there is actually evidence.  For example, consider this:

 

The sniper whose job it was to watch Sherlock’s fall or shoot John didn’t show up right away. He arrived at his station across from St. Bart’s after Jim shot himself, but before John had returned to the hospital.

 

Admittedly, that's the order those events are shown in -- but it seems plausible to me that the sequence is thematic rather than chronological.  (You can see the sequence on Ariane DeVere's transcript.)  If the sequence is indeed meant to be taken literally, though, that's a very interesting point.

 

As is this:

 

Jim never started a countdown timer. He never said Sherlock had to jump within 15 minutes or by 9:00 or in any way communicated at what point the gunmen would give up on the possibility of Sherlock jumping and shoot his friends instead. And this is Jim Moriarty we’re talking about here. Half of his gimmick in The Great Game was making Sherlock do things before the allotted time ran out.

 

That's another very interesting point, and consistent with the previous one.  If we can ignore Moriarty-the-deadline-maniac for a moment, though, couldn't the "deadline" have been simply "The only way you're allowed to leave the roof is by jumping"?

 

But taken together, those points are indeed compelling, especially when capped with this:

 

 

John was the countdown timer, and Sherlock knew it.

 

... The sniper had been told that if Sherlock didn’t jump, John should be shot as soon as he tried to enter the hospital.....

 

That’s why Sherlock had to be standing on the ledge before John’s cab arrived—he needed to make it clear to the sniper that he was preparing to jump. He couldn’t have John get shot simply because it looked like he wasn’t going to go through with it.

 

And that’s why Sherlock sounded so insistent and even worried when he was convincing John to stop and turn around within a few feet of the hospital entrance.

 

 That thought makes the chills run down my spine!

 

I knew that he somehow survived, even before I saw him at the end of the episode.  After all, you can't kill off your protagonist/hero.

 

Yup.  Me too.  It had to be some kind of a trick.  I was sad for what John was going through, rather than on my own behalf.

 

I was bewildered when I heard that some people still thought he was really dead even after seeing that final scene.  Though on further thought, I guess if you didn't already have the "it's only a trick" mindset, Sherlock's personal appearance at the cemetery could easily be interpreted as symbolic, or perhaps as his ghost watching over John.

 

The truly saddest part of it was when Sherlock was faking his death covered in blood on the ground and having to listen to John being anguished and starting to grieve.  

  • Like 2
Posted

You are right. Everyone thinks about John's emotions...

But we know that Sherlock can control his emotions very well. He was probably fully concentrated on fulfilling the action. How he slept that night is another question.

  • Like 1
Posted

Emotional feels just thinking about that. Never occurred to me about what could be going through Sherlock's head listening to John grieve while still at the sidewalk and then that night as he continued to prepare for his undercover work.

  • Like 1
Posted

Or at least a fanfic one-shot....hmmmm....

Posted

Or at least a fanfic one-shot....hmmmm....

 

I'd read the heck out of that.

 

Or, hey, I might write the heck out of that!  It would be fun for a group of us who play with fan fiction (or take it very seriously; YMMV) to take the same prompt and see what each of us do with it.  Could be a great way to see how people perceive Sherlock -- or, at least, how they perceive the Sherlock they write in their own fan fiction.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Or at least a fanfic one-shot....hmmmm....

 

I'd read the heck out of that.

 

Or, hey, I might write the heck out of that!  It would be fun for a group of us who play with fan fiction (or take it very seriously; YMMV) to take the same prompt and see what each of us do with it.  Could be a great way to see how people perceive Sherlock -- or, at least, how they perceive the Sherlock they write in their own fan fiction.

 

 

I'm up for the challenge.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

Or at least a fanfic one-shot....hmmmm....

 

I'd read the heck out of that.

 

Or, hey, I might write the heck out of that!  It would be fun for a group of us who play with fan fiction (or take it very seriously; YMMV) to take the same prompt and see what each of us do with it.  Could be a great way to see how people perceive Sherlock -- or, at least, how they perceive the Sherlock they write in their own fan fiction.

 

 

I'm up for the challenge.

 

 

I think I may play with it and see if I like where it goes for me.  If I like it, I'll bring it back here to the forums and be sure to share it with sfmpco and any interested others.  I have some ideas, but I think I need to double check details.  Oh, darn, guess I have to watch TRF again!

 

Can't wait to see where you take things, sfmpco (and others)!

Posted

OK, guys, here's my entry in the "what was Sherlock thinking" fan fic discussion.  Can't wait to see some from the rest of you!

 

http://archiveofourown.org/works/3552500

 

I put all of my author's comments in the story itself, so no one has to deal with discussing things here if they don't want.  Mods, if this turns into something where you think we should start a separate thread under Fan Fiction, let me know, and I'll do so.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Read 'Lazarus' a few hours ago and send a Kudo. One thing confuse me, why Sherlock choose to endanger his friends and the mission by leaving clues? Is he really already that far on leaving the rational cage he surrounded himself for so long or is it an impulsive act brought by misguided guilt?

Posted

I will take a look at the story. But I spotted a mistake Sherlock made, that could have been (and maybe still can be) fatal. He said “I want you to tell Lestrade; I want you to tell Mrs. Hudson, and Molly." MOLLY!? If his phone was monitored, or if there were any microphones on Jim, or Jim weren't dead - Sherlock just exposed his most importand ally.

 

That's fodder for some really gruesome future scenarios. thtrenches.gif

Posted

Read 'Lazarus' a few hours ago and send a Kudo. One thing confuse me, why Sherlock choose to endanger his friends and the mission by leaving clues? Is he really already that far on leaving the rational cage he surrounded himself for so long or is it an impulsive act brought by misguided guilt?

 

Thank you for reading, Shadow Dweller!  My head canon says that Sherlock assumes that there are clues that the "goldfish" of the world can't decipher, but that people like he and Mycroft can.  I think that, by this point, he's taken John into that group subconsciously.  In TRF, John makes some comment about Sherlock making the "we both know what's going on" face when John is still confused.  I kind of ran with that and conjectured that Sherlock thinks John picks up on more than maybe John is able to.

 

Of course, the real world reason for me exploring that is that I've always been annoyed/perplexed at Sherlock throwing the phone away before he jumps, because I would assume he would take any evidence with him if he were trying to fake his death.  To make that "better" in my own mind, I made the phone into a clue that only those who knew him would suspect.

Posted

I see.... so, in light of the atmosphere of the story, Sherlock want John to know that the suicide is fake. But why, what motivate & drive him to that act?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 235 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.