Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "His Last Vow"?  

157 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

True dat. :d

Posted

 

About the exile, I think that Mycroft would never send his brother to a suicide mission, maybe he thinks it could be a suicide mission for "normal" people but not for Sherlock, or maybe he only says that it is a suicide mission to convince the others that Sherlock will have his punishment

Well, Lady Smalwood's remark "it's hardly merciful" implies something cruel...

 

But...

What if we are mislead to believe in the suicide mission. Or a mission at all. Maybe Sherlock is lying to John AGAIN?

Which would be devastating because it would AGAIN ruin the tarmac scene. Completely.

It's bad enough to consider Sherlock being high in that moment which I consider the most emotional in the whole series.  angry5-1.gif

Posted

Oh lord, don't even go there! I'm just now recovering from the trauma of Sherlock being sent to his death, I don't need to find out it was all a big fake! No, Moftiss, shoo, don't listen, go away.....

 

That's why I particularly don't want the solution to be that it is Sherlock faking Moriarty's return. That would make a mockery of all the feels in HLV, which is the only thing that holds that episode together, imo, and which is why it's one of my favorite episodes. No no no, I don't want to find out Sherlock was faking everything on the tarmac...... ak!

  • Like 1
Posted

No, I think that Moftiss won't do this, otherwise TAB would be completely senseless. All that trip in Sherlock's mind palace is lived only by Sherlock who is trying to understand how Moriarty could be back. No one really knows what happened in Sherlock's mind and, if he really wanted to fake Moriarty's return, he could simply lie saying that he had been in his mind palace, even if it isn't true. I think that, if Sherlock had faken(?) Moriarty's return, we would have known it, like we knew that he wasn't really dead in TRF.

  • Like 1
Posted

Nah.. you have my word that it's not Sherlock. No prove, but I'm very sure because if it's Sherlock it would be stupid, horrible idea, HORRIBLE, it doesn't make sense! Hear that Moftiss? (Poke Poke Poke with baseball bat)

 

While we are in topic about HLV...:D

Anyway, I always wonder about Kate. Am I being heartless? But she is banging people's door early in the morning (it could be only six , Sherlock asks John about time after everything in drug house, lab, Mycroft etc and it's only eight), what does she expect from them? Apparently not for John to go the drug house because even Mary is surprised when John decides to do that. And it's usual, again.

To talk? But it's early in the morning, usual, again..!  Recurring events. It's her son, she knows where he is, she could send him to rehab or..something. I think she is at least having medium income living in that neighbourhood, she could do something..anything else!

 

I bet John would tell Mary the first chance he gets about Sherlock and Janine. He has time from morning until around seven when he meets Sherlock. They would at least meet at home or at work or text each other, Sherlock Holmes has a girlfriend for Pete's sake.

So... could Mary actually know that Sherlock would be in Magnussen's office? She knows who Janine is and should be able to put things together. Could she plan it but miscalculate that John would be there too, maybe John lies to her.

I don't know if that makes sense..

 

  • Like 5
Posted

I don't think Mary would know they go to Magnusen's office, because I think John didn't know where they go. Or did he?

 

Maybe the fact of Janine being Sherlock's girlfriend urged her to take an action though. Maybe she was afraid CAM would give away her past to Sherlock?

  • Like 1
Posted

While we are in topic about HLV... :D

Anyway, I always wonder about Kate. Am I being heartless? But she is banging people's door early in the morning (it could be only six , Sherlock asks John about time after everything in drug house, lab, Mycroft etc and it's only eight), what does she expect from them? Apparently not for John to go the drug house because even Mary is surprised when John decides to do that. And it's usual, again.

To talk? But it's early in the morning, usual, again..!  Recurring events. It's her son, she knows where he is, she could send him to rehab or..something. I think she is at least having medium income living in that neighbourhood, she could do something..anything else!

Well, it's nice to think that everyone can handle their own problems, but imo, some people, for whatever reason, just aren't equipped for it. So they turn to someone who is, and just hope that person is generous enough to help. Maybe Kate's one of those who is just too overwhelmed to cope on her own?

 

Also, it could be that's not early for Kate. Six or earlier is the norm for people getting up around here, because so many people have to commute an hour or more to work. (One of my acquaintances leaves the house at 5:30 every morning. :blink:  ) Or maybe Kate's just coming home, having worked the night shift. And being in the medical profession, I imagine John & Mary's schedules often has them up at wee hours, so she might have known there was a good chance they'd be up already. And from Mary's reaction I gather this isn't the first time she's gone to them for emotional support, so they may have been a comfort to her in the past -- another indication that it was okay for her to come over.

 

Or it's possible that she's just an selfish clod who thinks only of her own needs. :D

 

The surprise to me was that John was so insensitive to her. I thought he was supposed to be the caring one! At least he took positive action in the end, which was better than simply providing comfort, imo. So Kate chose well! :smile:

 

You know you're desperate when you start an in-depth analysis of the motives of a minor, throwaway character.... Next: Isaac Whitney and the social, moral and geopolitical influences that led him to become a drug addict, and how it ties in with the overarching theme of the series.

 

I bet John would tell Mary the first chance he gets about Sherlock and Janine. He has time from morning until around seven when he meets Sherlock. They would at least meet at home or at work or text each other, Sherlock Holmes has a girlfriend for Pete's sake.

So... could Mary actually know that Sherlock would be in Magnussen's office? She knows who Janine is and should be able to put things together. Could she plan it but miscalculate that John would be there too, maybe John lies to her.

I don't know if that makes sense..

Oooo. Yeah, that makes sense alright. Maybe hearing about Janine was what convinced Mary she had to act, NOW, before Sherlock uncovered something that would lead to her.

 

However, Janine did sort of indicate she didn't want John to tell Mary yet, and John being a guy, I can see him remaining hush hush about it for the sake of his pal.

 

I really do think it was just one of many unlikely coincidences that put Mary and Sherlock in CAM's office at the same time. The universe may not be so lazy, but I suspect Mofftis sometimes is. :P

 

I have to admit, though, I'll be a little disappointed if the Moriarty gif appearing just in time to save Sherlock from exile turns out to be a coincidence. I hope the Moftisses are a little more clever than that!

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think Mary would know they go to Magnusen's office, because I think John didn't know where they go. Or did he?

 

Maybe the fact of Janine being Sherlock's girlfriend urged her to take an action though. Maybe she was afraid CAM would give away her past to Sherlock?

Ooops, cross-posted.

 

Actually, John must have known he was going to CAM's office, because didn't they meet there? Otherwise I don't see how John knew when and where to show up. But whether he relayed that information to Mary is anyone's guess. I can see how that would have driven her to act quickly, though, even more than knowing Sherlock was involved with Janine. Put the two together, and it must have seemed pretty urgent to her to deal with CAM before Sherlock got to him.

 

Still ... I got the impression she was just as surprised to see Sherlock as he was to see her. And when she asked if John was with him ... that indicates that she didn't know John's plans, and therefore didn't expect them to be there. So I'm still left thinking it's all just coincidence.

 

As one fanfic put it recently ... between the two of them, Mary and Sherlock managed to botch the whole case.

  • Like 1
Posted

Mary meeting Sherlock in CAM's office is hardly a coincidence. It was a day when Sherlock checked with Mary if John is available, so she knew John wouldn't be at home so she could sneak away without having to explain.

Posted

But wouldm't it be enough for Sherlock just to say the address, John looks quite surprised when he realizes where they are going... Dang, have to watch it again :wacko:

And then, John probably said "I'm out with Sherlock" to Mary and she didn't ask for details.

 

Of course Mary was surprised - she expected the guys to be on a case and not breaking into CAM's office. :D I also see her question about John as a quite natural reaction.

  • Like 1
Posted

Mary meeting Sherlock in CAM's office is hardly a coincidence. It was a day when Sherlock checked with Mary if John is available, so she knew John wouldn't be at home so she could sneak away without having to explain.

 

Yeah, but it's a coincidence in the sense that they both broke into the same place ... surely if she'd known that's where they were going, she wouldn't have been there when they arrived?

 

And why wasn't CAM at his meeting like he was supposed to be? Because Mary had detained him? Just how long was she in his office? If it was a while, that points to her having a plan other than just killing him... another mystery.....

 

But wouldm't it be enough for Sherlock just to say the address, John looks quite surprised when he realizes where they are going... Dang, have to watch it again :wacko:

And then, John probably said "I'm out with Sherlock" to Mary and she didn't ask for details.

 

Of course Mary was surprised - she expected the guys to be on a case and not breaking into CAM's office. :D I also see her question about John as a quite natural reaction.

So that points to her NOT knowing what they were up to, and it just being a coincidence that she decided to take out CAM at the very same moment Sherlock decided to do his little piece of burglary.

 

I think I'm getting dizzy....

Posted

I don't think Mary wanted to kill CAM. It would bring her nothing, as long as she (and the whole world) thought there is a material evidence in Appledore's vaults.

Posted

Okay, watched it. There is nothing to clear the question how much John knew about the case in advance.

 

Anyway, I have notices some other details.

This time it stroke me how mad Lady Smalwood was at the beginning. She says something like: "nobody stops him(CAM), nobody even tries" - then she thinks of Sherlock. May it be that there was another game running in the background? That - maybe - she wanted CAM to be stopped by any means, especially after her husband's suicide. I don't know how it affects the possible interpretations, it's just a thought.

 

Then I noticed this little detail:

GCHMDE.png

 

It seems CAM got rid of another person who didn't like him.

 

Then - the office where Magnussen is questioned at the beginning is the same place where they discuss Sherlock's fate at the end.

 

EK6FN.png

 

Sherlock's shock vision. First we are confronted with the time stretch inside of Sherlock's mind. Molly talks about 3 seconds and we have a whole sequence that fitted in this time. Secondly, Mycroft in Sherlock's head saying: "You always were so stupid. Such a disappointment." Ouch, this is how Sherlock thinks Mycroft sees him. So, so sad.

 

And finally - When CAM reads Sherlock, in the pressure points list, one of them is opium (which would be a third substance, I wonder if it was what he was taking to catch CAM's attention) and another is THE HOUNDS OF THE BASKERVILLE. Not the Hound. HOUNDS and THE Baskerville. Could be a mistake, but what do we say about mistakes?

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Okay, watched it. There is nothing to clear the question how much John knew about the case in advance.

 

Anyway, I have notices some other details.

This time it stroke me how mad Lady Smalwood was at the beginning. She says something like: "nobody stops him(CAM), nobody even tries" - then she thinks of Sherlock. May it be that there was another game running in the background? That - maybe - she wanted CAM to be stopped by any means, especially after her husband's suicide. I don't know how it affects the possible interpretations, it's just a thought.

I think that's true ... she wanted him stopped ... but would "another game" have any effect on the outcome? What I mean is, her motives didn't matter to how Sherlock approached the problem, did it? Am I making sense?

 

Then - the office where Magnussen is questioned at the beginning is the same place where they discuss Sherlock's fate at the end.

 

EK6FN.png

Yep, looks like the same location, but I'm not convinced it's meant to be ... because where did the tables go? I suppose in real life the office staff could drag those puppies in and out as needed, but is the British government that frugal, that they wouldn't have a room devoted exclusively to hearings? Or is it Hartwood that's being frugal, and reusing the same location? :d

 

... and another is THE HOUNDS OF THE BASKERVILLE. Not the Hound. HOUNDS and THE Baskerville. Could be a mistake, but what do we say about mistakes?

To err is human, to forgive is divine? :P

Posted

Well, it's nice to think that everyone can handle their own problems, but imo, some people, for whatever reason, just aren't equipped for it. So they turn to someone who is, and just hope that person is generous enough to help. Maybe Kate's one of those who is just too overwhelmed to cope on her own?

 

Also, it could be that's not early for Kate. Six or earlier is the norm for people getting up around here, because so many people have to commute an hour or more to work. (One of my acquaintances leaves the house at 5:30 every morning. :blink:  ) Or maybe Kate's just coming home, having worked the night shift. And being in the medical profession, I imagine John & Mary's schedules often has them up at wee hours, so she might have known there was a good chance they'd be up already. And from Mary's reaction I gather this isn't the first time she's gone to them for emotional support, so they may have been a comfort to her in the past -- another indication that it was okay for her to come over.

So, to conclude. Heartless then. XD

Yes, six is fine. I wake up before six daily unless there are rare circumstances when I'm taking break at my home town. And yes, I left house at 5 o'clock for two years when I was in high school. So six is not too early...for yourself, dog, family, school and work. Not for someone banging my door to talk about their problem that is ongoing, usual, with no conclusion or solution or effort.

 

I think Mary is very kind here. And yes, look at John, I don't think he is insensitive. He has just woken up from the nightmare, nervous (finger twitching, I didn't notice it but when I go to Ariane DeVere's transcript to look at the time, she mentioned it), he is stressed (Mycroft said about intermittent shaking or something on John's left hand in SIP when he is stressed), and he is making perfect sense I think, what does she expect from them. Look from her eyes, John and Mary is usual ordinary couple and the wife is expecting. You would think she needs rest/sleep/deal with morning sickness/daily life/odd working hour and they of course have their own problems.

She know for sure who Issac is hanging out with, where he is and what he is doing. Do something.. but that!

Ugh. I don't have any sympathy for her.

And Issac, yeah, we don't see much about him, but he seems cooperative, he even calls John "Dr.Watson", and asks Mary if he could get into the car. Yes, I know people could behave differently with family member, but he seems like a reasonable kid.

 

Or it's possible that she's just an selfish clod who thinks only of her own needs. :D

YES! :P

 

You know you're desperate when you start an in-depth analysis of the motives of a minor, throwaway character.... Next: Isaac Whitney and the social, moral and geopolitical influences that led him to become a drug addict, and how it ties in with the overarching theme of the series.

oooooohhhhh is that wrong? we...need... to survive... At least we are talking about human..remember when we talked about shoes? ;p

 

@John Garvie Yes, I remember noticing that in first and rewatch. That's why I maintain Magnussen is cancer and understand Sherlock's action.

@HOUNDS I think someone mentioned it during our rewatch, although I don't remember the conclusion...wait.. I think it was you J.P, but I could be wrong..

 

Regarding Mary's timing, I can't figure out as well, I think it's plothole.

Now I'm entertaining myself thinking how John breaks the news about Sherlock having girlfriend and Mary's (fake and genuine) reaction knowing that and knowing it's Janine.

Posted

Yep. Heartless. I wasn't going to say anything but since you admit it... :p

 

I'm afraid I would find her rather tiresome as well. :rolleyes: I'd like to be able to do what John did, but I'm nowhere near fierce enough. So I'd be reduced to patting her on the back and wishing she would take her troubles elsewhere.... ak.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Yep. Heartless. I wasn't going to say anything but since you admit it... :P

I find that soothing. XD

Now that you say it, I have excuse to get away with everything. :)

 

I'm afraid I would find her rather tiresome as well. :rolleyes: I'd like to be able to do what John did, but I'm nowhere near fierce enough. So I'd be reduced to patting her on the back and wishing she would take her troubles elsewhere.... ak.

I think it's good that you do that. It's good, isn't it? But how many times exactly you are willing to do that?

Pure curiosity, not judgement.

Because sometimes I wish, although rarely, that I have that kind of endurance.. eh..compassion.

Posted

Ah, the beauty of for... deleting things! You can enjoy discovering them more than once! :D

 

As for the room - it actually doesn't matter. :) Well, I can see an option though, that they put in the amount of tables to match the number of participants. And of course it was very convenient to shoot the scenes back to back in that room, whatever it is. Maybe it's even the same day.

 

PS: John reacts as I would - even without the nightmare and the whole stress. A big, bat question mark floating over my head while my brain tries to figure out what that woman wants from me...

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I'm afraid I would find her rather tiresome as well. :rolleyes: I'd like to be able to do what John did, but I'm nowhere near fierce enough. So I'd be reduced to patting her on the back and wishing she would take her troubles elsewhere.... ak.

I think it's good that you do that. It's good, isn't it? But how many times exactly you are willing to do that?

Pure curiosity, not judgement.

Because sometimes I wish, although rarely, that I have that kind of endurance.. eh..compassion.

 

Ah, endurance, that's a good word for it. I've known people who, if you show them a kindness once, they try to cling to you for the rest of their lives. I've had to cut off contact with more than one person like that ... I don't have the endurance to keep dealing with their "issues". I feel bad for them, but I have to protect myself first if I'm to be of any use at all.

 

On the other hand, I've long felt there's enough anguish in this world, there's no need for me to contribute to it if I can avoid doing so. So I like to help when I can, it makes me feel good. Operative words being, "when I can." It's hard to find the balance, sometimes. I genuinely admire people who can devote their lives to comforting others, but I'm not one of them.

 

And on a purely selfish level, I'm hoping that being compassionate to others will be repaid to me when I need it from them. As I will someday; not getting any younger, y'know. :D

 

Ah, the beauty of for... deleting things! You can enjoy discovering them more than once! :D

Sorry, what are we deleting? Did I miss the memo?

 

PS: John reacts as I would - even without the nightmare and the whole stress. A big, bat question mark floating over my head while my brain tries to figure out what that woman wants from me...

But again ... John is supposed to be the compassionate one! He wasn't supposed to be like that! Why is he like that? :p

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Ah, endurance, that's a good word for it. I've known people who, if you show them a kindness once, they try to cling to you for the rest of their lives. I've had to cut off contact with more than one person like that ... I don't have the endurance to keep dealing with their "issues". I feel bad for them, but I have to protect myself first if I'm to be of any use at all.

 

On the other hand, I've long felt there's enough anguish in this world, there's no need for me to contribute to it if I can avoid doing so. So I like to help when I can, it makes me feel good. Operative words being, "when I can." It's hard to find the balance, sometimes. I genuinely admire people who can devote their lives to comforting others, but I'm not one of them.

 

And on a purely selfish level, I'm hoping that being compassionate to others will be repaid to me when I need it from them. As I will someday; not getting any younger, y'know. :D

Of all the things I don't believe, I believe in karma, in present life. So I get you. There is no altruism anyway, I guess. :)

 

Sorry, what are we deleting? Did I miss the memo?

Hounds. :P

 

But again ... John is supposed to be the compassionate one! He wasn't supposed to be like that! Why is he like that? :P

Because you chose him.

And everything is always your fault.

(You need a chair to kick? XD)

 

Because he's a man, at 6 o'clock in the morning. On Monday.

coffeemornin.gif

thsleepy.gif

Fair point. Ehm.. you think it's better on Tuesday? Nahhhhhhh...

 

About using the same room couple of posts above, I actually believe in frugality theory. I mean, look at that! A glass of water? No refreshment, or even coffee or tea?

Posted

 

You know you're desperate when you start an in-depth analysis of the motives of a minor, throwaway character.... Next: Isaac Whitney and the social, moral and geopolitical influences that led him to become a drug addict, and how it ties in with the overarching theme of the series.

oooooohhhhh is that wrong? we...need... to survive... At least we are talking about human..remember when we talked about shoes? ;p[

 

Please, don't remind me! :P

 

@John Garvie Yes, I remember noticing that in first and rewatch. That's why I maintain Magnussen is cancer and understand Sherlock's action.

John Garvie is an adulterer, a spendthrift, and a corrupt politician; the kind of person Sherlock takes down all the time. Are you sure we're rooting for the right guy here? Maybe Magnussen was just trying to rid the world of low lifes.... :rofl:

 

Because he's a man, at 6 o'clock in the morning. On Monday.

coffeemornin.gif

thsleepy.gif

Okay, then! Point conceded! :D

 

 

Sorry, what are we deleting? Did I miss the memo?

Hounds. :P

Oh. Right. See there? I was so focused on my own needs that I missed that completely.

 

 

But again ... John is supposed to be the compassionate one! He wasn't supposed to be like that! Why is he like that? :P

Because you chose him.

And everything is always your fault.

(You need a chair to kick? XD)

No, that's okay, I'll just kick you instead. Or beat someone up with a firework.

 

 

No refreshment, or even coffee or tea?

They want to keep it brief. So no extras :D

Maybe they were afraid Magnussen wouldn't be able to hold his coffee and would pee on the rug.

  • Like 2
Posted

Maybe he always do this coming into a new place. You know - marking new territory :P

 

Re John Garvie. My theory was more that he stood in CAM's way. So CAM "got him", most probably using his pressure points.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Well, it's nice to think that everyone can handle their own problems, but imo, some people, for whatever reason, just aren't equipped for it. So they turn to someone who is, and just hope that person is generous enough to help. Maybe Kate's one of those who is just too overwhelmed to cope on her own?

 

Also, it could be that's not early for Kate. Six or earlier is the norm for people getting up around here, because so many people have to commute an hour or more to work. (One of my acquaintances leaves the house at 5:30 every morning. :blink:  ) Or maybe Kate's just coming home, having worked the night shift. And being in the medical profession, I imagine John & Mary's schedules often has them up at wee hours, so she might have known there was a good chance they'd be up already. And from Mary's reaction I gather this isn't the first time she's gone to them for emotional support, so they may have been a comfort to her in the past -- another indication that it was okay for her to come over.

So, to conclude. Heartless then. XD

Yes, six is fine. I wake up before six daily unless there are rare circumstances when I'm taking break at my home town. And yes, I left house at 5 o'clock for two years when I was in high school. So six is not too early...for yourself, dog, family, school and work. Not for someone banging my door to talk about their problem that is ongoing, usual, with no conclusion or solution or effort.

 

I think Mary is very kind here. And yes, look at John, I don't think he is insensitive. He has just woken up from the nightmare, nervous (finger twitching, I didn't notice it but when I go to Ariane DeVere's transcript to look at the time, she mentioned it), he is stressed (Mycroft said about intermittent shaking or something on John's left hand in SIP when he is stressed), and he is making perfect sense I think, what does she expect from them. Look from her eyes, John and Mary is usual ordinary couple and the wife is expecting. You would think she needs rest/sleep/deal with morning sickness/daily life/odd working hour and they of course have their own problems.

She know for sure who Issac is hanging out with, where he is and what he is doing. Do something.. but that!

Ugh. I don't have any sympathy for her.

And Issac, yeah, we don't see much about him, but he seems cooperative, he even calls John "Dr.Watson", and asks Mary if he could get into the car. Yes, I know people could behave differently with family member, but he seems like a reasonable kid.

 

Or it's possible that she's just an selfish clod who thinks only of her own needs. :D

YES! :P

 

You know you're desperate when you start an in-depth analysis of the motives of a minor, throwaway character.... Next: Isaac Whitney and the social, moral and geopolitical influences that led him to become a drug addict, and how it ties in with the overarching theme of the series.

oooooohhhhh is that wrong? we...need... to survive... At least we are talking about human..remember when we talked about shoes? ;p

 

@John Garvie Yes, I remember noticing that in first and rewatch. That's why I maintain Magnussen is cancer and understand Sherlock's action.

@HOUNDS I think someone mentioned it during our rewatch, although I don't remember the conclusion...wait.. I think it was you J.P, but I could be wrong..

 

Regarding Mary's timing, I can't figure out as well, I think it's plothole.

Now I'm entertaining myself thinking how John breaks the news about Sherlock having girlfriend and Mary's (fake and genuine) reaction knowing that and knowing it's Janine.

 

 

Wow, now we're going at poor Kate Whitney?   :P  We ARE bored!

 

I've always thought that Kate has been slowly confiding in Mary, and I think that's more of a commentary on Mary than it is on Kate. I would imagine that one of Mary's strengths is her ability to take in and assimilate information that may come in handy at some point. After all, we've seen her be able to interpret a skip code and remember hotel room assignments, both abilities that don't appear to be particularly useful until you absolutely need them. Maybe this is part of Mary's ability as an agent; she just takes stuff in and waits for it to be needed.

 

Kate may not systematically run to John and Mary.  She says "I know it's early; really, I do," indicating that she's distraught, she doesn't know what to do about Isaac, and she's turned to her friend and neighbor at a time she may not normally do so.  I don't know anything about British drug law, but perhaps it's a case where Isaac is of age and the authorities won't do anything until he's actually doing something illegal, like disturbing the peace.  Maybe laying around a drug den is nasty but not technically illegal until you do something else, so Kate has no recourse, and she can't have him committed to rehab because he's of age.  (I'm making stuff up here, so don't use me as your source for British law.)

 

On the other hand, John has only heard about Isaac second-hand.  "Husband?" "No, son," John and Mary exchange, in an homage to Isa Whitney in ACD, but also indicating that John doesn't really know Isaac all that well.  "He's the drugs one, yes?," indicating that he has heard about Isaac's troubles mostly through Mary.  He does recognize Isaac enough that once he wakes up and remembers the conversation, he's able to ID Isaac, although Isaac does raise his hand when John calls out at him.

 

So, does someone want to coauthor a paper?  I'm thinking, "Saving Isaac: An Examination of the NHS Responses to Mental Health Issues and Chronic Drug Abuse."

  • Like 4

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 95 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.