Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "His Last Vow"?  

157 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

Recovering from a serious heart condition is IMO different from recovering from a wound. It would be also different it he had damaged muscles/nerves/bones and needed physiotherapy after the recovery. He just needed to heal properly and recover from the long time in bed. Plus I cannot imagine him being at any rehab longer than a day. :)

 

So probably the easiest explanation is that the boys met several times during the summer, as Carol suggests.

Posted

Recovering from a serious heart condition is IMO different from recovering from a wound. It would be also different it he had damaged muscles/nerves/bones and needed physiotherapy after the recovery. He just needed to heal properly and recover from the long time in bed. Plus I cannot imagine him being at any rehab longer than a day. :)

 

So probably the easiest explanation is that the boys met several times during the summer, as Carol suggests.

 

I certainly won't argue with that (especially since you are partially agreeing with me!), but you may be oversimplifying Sherlock's condition.  He not only had a bullet hole in his chest, his heart had stopped beating for long enough that the doctors had given up on him.  Therefore, like the woman I referred to, I think it's possible that he may have suffered some brain damage, which could require therapy.  I agree that he could be a "difficult" client, but if the damage was obvious to him (which would be the case if his motor functions were affected), then he might have agreed to cooperate, albeit reluctantly.

 

So I see it as several possible alternatives -- he may have actually been under treatment of some sort for many months and/or he may have seen John since the wedding and/or quite possibly I'm overlooking some other possibilities.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have to go with May 18 for the wedding because it was shown in the episode, no matter how difficult that makes other things.  I sort of assume that Sherlock and John must have seen each other at least once or twice after the Sex Holiday just to exchange presents that Sherlock collected from the wedding or to hand off keys, belongings, etc.  So, you can pretty easily get the initial shooting to the beginning of July.

 

From the other end, you can wiggle a bit and say that Sherlock got "out of hospital" -- whatever that means -- sometime in November, and Mummy is reacting to this being the first time she's seen him since.

 

In between, I agree that there had to be some sort of rehabilitation.  Even if Sherlock was a model patient (ha!) the second time around, he has had at least one if not two cardiac arrests along with the initial shooting and the repair surgery.  Your strength goes down hill really fast when you are lying in bed.  I had a stupid kidney stone that precipitated a three-day hospital stay (long story), and it took me a week after to really feel like myself, and that was with minimally-invasive surgery.  There had to be a period in which Sherlock was pretty weak and doing rehab, because he seems to have no problem running around CAM's house and shooting him on Christmas day.  Maybe his rehab facility was a Mycroft-sponsored MI6 facility that also had a shooting range?  (Actually, I think sfmpco has proposed something of the sort in her fan fiction, except without being as snarky as I just was!)

  • Like 1
Posted

I have to go with May 18 for the wedding because it was shown in the episode, no matter how difficult that makes other things.  I sort of assume that Sherlock and John must have seen each other at least once or twice after the Sex Holiday just to exchange presents that Sherlock collected from the wedding or to hand off keys, belongings, etc.  So, you can pretty easily get the initial shooting to the beginning of July.

 

From the other end, you can wiggle a bit and say that Sherlock got "out of hospital" -- whatever that means -- sometime in November, and Mummy is reacting to this being the first time she's seen him since.

 

In between, I agree that there had to be some sort of rehabilitation[....]

 

I admire your ability to finagle!  :D

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, we also all forget about the press... what in the world was going on in the press after Janine's fake press releases, and obviously the very public information that Sherlock had been shot - i.e. flowers from all over including Pentonville and even the Woman, from wherever she was in hiding.  "Who shot Sherlock?" would seem to cause greater news than "Who shot J.R.?"

 

I would think that if he did go to a rehab center that it would be ultra private simply because the media might be in a tremendous frenzy over him.

  • Like 3
Posted

Well, we also all forget about the press... what in the world was going on in the press after Janine's fake press releases, and obviously the very public information that Sherlock had been shot - i.e. flowers from all over including Pentonville and even the Woman, from wherever she was in hiding.  "Who shot Sherlock?" would seem to cause greater news than "Who shot J.R.?"

 

Hmm, good point -- the basic fact that Sherlock had been shot must have been in the news, or Irene would presumably have had no way of finding out about it.  I'm gonna guess that instead of trying to hush up the whole thing, they released a made-up story about it having been an accident of some sort.

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, I think we forget that Sherlock has become a celebrity in his own right albeit a reluctant one.  His death and resurrection cemented that in his world.  So no doubt he is fodder at all times for the Daily Mail and the Guardian plus various other gutter press.  He is tabloid candy.  So whatever the story was that was leaked to the press regarding the fact that he was shot, I am quite sure he was in the papers pretty much daily as friends, fans and enemies clamored for information.   Also was probably the toast of social media.

  • Like 1
Posted

I should also add that John, by association, would be getting some of that press attention as well.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Hey, what they intended doesn't count!  :P  If it's not in the finished episode, it's not canon -- especially if it contradicts what was explicitly said or shown in the episode (e.g., the invitation).  And John's blog has other apparent date inconsistencies (e.g., as Julia Mae has pointed out, Sherlock and John really can't have met at Baker Street, London, at 7 pm on January 30th in broad daylight).

 

 

I don't give too much credence to the blogs as they haven't been kept up with.  It's as if the BBC/Hartswood thought they would be a good idea but then abandoned them once the show became such a juggernaut.  

Posted

Hey, what they intended doesn't count!  :P  If it's not in the finished episode, it's not canon -- especially if it contradicts what was explicitly said or shown in the episode (e.g., the invitation).  And John's blog has other apparent date inconsistencies (e.g., as Julia Mae has pointed out, Sherlock and John really can't have met at Baker Street, London, at 7 pm on January 30th in broad daylight).

 

I don't give too much credence to the blogs as they haven't been kept up with.  It's as if the BBC/Hartswood thought they would be a good idea but then abandoned them once the show became such a juggernaut.  

 

They've been pretty good about resurrecting the blogs when a new series is imminent -- but they do indeed languish between times.

 

Which reminds me -- maybe we should keep an eye on John's blog.  At this point there's nothing since Sign of Three (and I find it perfectly understandable that John would not have posted anything during "Last Vow").  I believe that before S3, they started doing new posts a little while ahead of time.  Don't suppose he'll be posting from 1895, but maybe in that modern-day cemetery scene...?

  • Like 1
Posted

Yes they did..... and somewhere in between S1 and S2, too. I think they've kept it up pretty well, actually ... there's just gaps, for some reason.... ;)

  • Like 1
Posted

So, I rewatched HLV last night (because it's the Christmas episode, or something), and I think I have two more points that argue for a 6-month or so recuperation for Sherlock.  Neither of these prove it, but, as Mycroft would say, "balance of probability...."

 

1.  In the "addicted to a certain lifestyle" speech, Sherlock mentions that John couldn't stay in the suburbs a month without storming a crack den and beating up a junkie.  We can be fairly certain that John and Mary were living together prior to their marriage.  So, probably he had already been in the suburbs, and the month countdown began in Sherlock's mind with the wedding.  

 

It's possible that John and Mary returned from the Sex Holiday and bought a house and moved to the suburbs, but then that would mean that the previous comment about John and Sherlock not seeing each other for a month started that count from the time of the move.  It doesn't make sense to me that the pair would visit, call, or text up until John moved, then completely lose touch.  It seems more likely to me that John returned home to the house he shared with Mary and got overwhelmed with the transitions in his life.  That also fits with Mrs. Hudson's story about her chief bridesmaid in TSoT.  So, the day of Magnussen's visit and the initial shooting was probably no later than the first half of July.

 

2.  On Christmas day, Mary says, "Months of silence, and we're going to do this, now," meaning talk about the flash drive.  Her "months of silence" had to count from the day she handed over the flash drive to Christmas day.  While it is conceivable that months (plural) could mean as few as two or three, I think her inflection on "months" indicates that they've endured several months of not talking to each other even when living together.  So, I think that argues for a silence that has run for at least several months, again arguing for a mid-summer initial shooting and secondary collapse for Sherlock.

  • Like 1
Posted

So, I rewatched HLV last night (because it's the Christmas episode, or something),

:D  In the same sense that Die Hard is a Christmas movie, right? :rofl:

 

and I think I have two more points that argue for a 6-month or so recuperation for Sherlock.  Neither of these prove it, but, as Mycroft would say, "balance of probability...."

 

1.  In the "addicted to a certain lifestyle" speech, Sherlock mentions that John couldn't stay in the suburbs a month without storming a crack den and beating up a junkie.  We can be fairly certain that John and Mary were living together prior to their marriage.  So, probably he had already been in the suburbs, and the month countdown began in Sherlock's mind with the wedding.  

 

It's possible that John and Mary returned from the Sex Holiday and bought a house and moved to the suburbs, but then that would mean that the previous comment about John and Sherlock not seeing each other for a month started that count from the time of the move.  It doesn't make sense to me that the pair would visit, call, or text up until John moved, then completely lose touch.  It seems more likely to me that John returned home to the house he shared with Mary and got overwhelmed with the transitions in his life.  That also fits with Mrs. Hudson's story about her chief bridesmaid in TSoT.  So, the day of Magnussen's visit and the initial shooting was probably no later than the first half of July.

 

2.  On Christmas day, Mary says, "Months of silence, and we're going to do this, now," meaning talk about the flash drive.  Her "months of silence" had to count from the day she handed over the flash drive to Christmas day.  While it is conceivable that months (plural) could mean as few as two or three, I think her inflection on "months" indicates that they've endured several months of not talking to each other even when living together.  So, I think that argues for a silence that has run for at least several months, again arguing for a mid-summer initial shooting and secondary collapse for Sherlock.

 

I agree with your second point, "months of silence" in my mind has to have been at minimum three months. (For two months, I at least would say "weeks of silence.") Assuming John shut down the day he learned Mary was the shooter, that puts the shooting, at latest, somewhere in September. I think that's what I base my assumption of three months on, although to my mind that's still an unlikely length for a hospital stay, and a bit of a stretch even for rehab.

 

I definitely agree with at least six months of "recuperation" -- but Mummy Holmes said "home from hospital", not "finally recuperated". But rather than offer an in universe explanation, I find it easier to accept that Moffat was being deliberately vague here -- just to be in keeping with the rest of the script, I presume. :P It's also easier for me to accept that the blog -- which they have a hand in, it's not just some guy writing whatever he feels like writing -- just possibly has the right date for the wedding after all. As much as I'm loathe to admit that my fellow artists have failings, I do realize that tv art departments make mistakes sometimes.... :P :P

 

As to your first point, it occurs to me that "haven't seen him in a month" doesn't mean that John hasn't called, texted or emailed Sherlock in a month. We know Sherlock and Mary have been in touch during that time ("Mary and I" think John has gained 7 pounds) if not actually seen each  other, so why not John and Sherlock? They just haven't done things together. Which surely must have been true even before The Fall; they must have had weeks in which the extent of their interaction amounted to saying "good morning" in the hallway. :smile: Not sure I have a point here, just something that occurred to me!

 

I don't know why, but I assumed John and Mary moved to the 'burbs after they got married -- perhaps because that's the first time it's mentioned? If I had time, I would go back and look at the early scenes of John in TEH, and see if I can determine from that whether John appears to be living in the suburbs or not. We know he lives far enough from work to be taking the tube, but that doesn't help much. (Presumably this was before he started biking to work.... )

 

In fact, the discussion of John's weight amused me, because one of my first thoughts when TEH aired was that filming The Hobbit must have done Martin Freeman some good, as he was looking much trimmer than before! Or for an in-universe explanation, John's grief had taken its toll in the form of weight loss. Either way, he was looking damn fine in dem jeans ..... :D

  • Like 3
Posted

 

So, I rewatched HLV last night (because it's the Christmas episode, or something),

:D  In the same sense that Die Hard is a Christmas movie, right? :rofl:

 

 

In fact, the discussion of John's weight amused me, because one of my first thoughts when TEH aired was that filming The Hobbit must have done Martin Freeman some good, as he was looking much trimmer than before! Or for an in-universe explanation, John's grief had taken its toll in the form of weight loss. Either way, he was looking damn fine in dem jeans ..... :D

 

 

Yeah, exactly, on the Christmas movie thing!

 

Somewhere or other, in ACD canon, I believe Holmes remarks that Watson gained 4.7 pounds after his wedding to Mary Morstan.  Someone else will probably find it before I can go through my Kindle highlights, but I'm almost positive it's in there, because I remember thinking that they took the two numbers and used it to make a joke.

 

But yes, I think we can safely assume that the cycling is, in fact, doing it for John in the form of letting him put on some muscle weight in all the right places.  In fact, one perhaps should be worried that neither Sherlock nor Mary have noticed his perceptible improvement in looks!   :D

 

ETA: Maybe that's the strongest possible argument against Johnlock:  If Sherlock didn't notice what John looked like in those jeans, he definitely isn't interested "that way."

  • Like 3
Posted

1.  In the "addicted to a certain lifestyle" speech, Sherlock mentions that John couldn't stay in the suburbs a month without storming a crack den and beating up a junkie.  We can be fairly certain that John and Mary were living together prior to their marriage.  So, probably he had already been in the suburbs, and the month countdown began in Sherlock's mind with the wedding.  

 

It's possible that John and Mary returned from the Sex Holiday and bought a house and moved to the suburbs, but then that would mean that the previous comment about John and Sherlock not seeing each other for a month started that count from the time of the move.  It doesn't make sense to me that the pair would visit, call, or text up until John moved, then completely lose touch.  It seems more likely to me that John returned home to the house he shared with Mary and got overwhelmed with the transitions in his life.

 

I still think Sherlock is reading too much into "storming a drug den" -- John has always been ready and willing to help someone who needs it, and Kate specifically asked him to help.  But be that as it may --

 

You have an excellent point about the timing, and I can bolster it a bit.  John was already living in that house (and maybe Mary was too) at the time of "Many Happy Returns" -- we see the same living room when Greg brings the box of memorabilia as when Kate visits in "Last Vow."  Although we have very little idea of when MHR took place, it was clearly before most of "The Empty Hearse," so there was no move after the wedding.

  • Like 1
Posted

And as I recall, it was said somewhere that MHR was originally part of TEH ... so there you go. What point were we trying to make again? :d

Posted

And as I recall, it was said somewhere that MHR was originally part of TEH ... so there you go. What point were we trying to make again? :D

 

It certainly does seem to be a prequel to TEH.  (On the other hand, it was clearly filmed along with HLV, considering that they used two of the same sets -- John's living room and Greg's pub.)  In any case, my point was that in HLV, John was still living in the same place where he lived in MHR.  So Boton's conjecture about a possible interim move did not apply -- which actually simplifies the point she was making.

  • Like 1
Posted

I feel like stirring up some trouble tonight.  :P

 

In "His Last Vow," do we ever actually see John's gun?  John says it's in his coat pocket, and I believe we see Sherlock reach around John toward his right-hand pocket shortly before he wishes Magnussen a Merry Christmas.  But my impression the first time I watched this episode was that Sherlock had punched Magnussen.  Does anyone in the episode ever actually say that Magnussen was shot?  Or are we all just assuming?

 

The only evidence I can think of is Mycroft referring to Sherlock as a murderer.  But we know that he's been trained in the martial arts.

 

After checking the screencaps on KissThemGoodbye.net:  Oh, darn, we do see the gun, at least briefly, here and here.  At least it could be a gun.  So -- balance of probability.  *sigh*

 

Posted

Wha.... that is not stirring up trouble if you conclude yourself and give up at the end of the post. :lol: :lol:..!

Posted

Well, I did end up causing myself some trouble!  And anybody is perfectly free to disagree with me.  In fact, I wish y'all would!

Posted

I disagree!

  • Like 1
Posted

I thought Sherlock and Magnussen were standing in the distance.

But I just checked it, Sherlock was moving nearer to him, so suspecting a close contact makes sense.

 

However, I never doubted he was shot, because of the impact of the fall, the position of the hand and the way he fall.

 

A normal right punch wouldn't result on that way of falling, an upper cut maybe, but Sherlock's hand didn't match an upper cut.

If it's special martial art that has ability to transform such a force with movement like pushing (tai chi maybe), it could be possible, although for taichi you need a moment/movement to 'gather' all the energy and it's usually slow movement, so I rule out that one as well.

 

Oh.. I think you did stir a bit of trouble in here. :)

 

 

Eta: Whacks..finally visit this forum from a bigger device than phone. My antlers are damn ugly.

  • Like 1
Posted

Eta: Whacks..finally visit this forum from a bigger device than phone. My antlers are damn ugly.

 

They weren't actually intended to look realistic, were they?  :D

 

You're probably right about Sherlock's movements not matching what he'd need to do in order to deck Magnussen.  But I'm not particularly knowledgeable about such things, and besides, it went by awfully fast.  Maybe that's why they needed Mycroft to say that Sherlock was a murderer -- just in case anyone else kinda missed that!

Posted

However, I never doubted he was shot, because of the impact of the fall, the position of the hand and the way he fall.

And the sound of the gun firing. ;)

 

Just for the sake of argument (now that my visitors have left :smile: ) ... let's say Sherlock did punch Magnussen. Meaning the creep is still alive, I presume? But Mycroft told everyone he was murdered because ... um ... er ... because he's got CAM squirreled away somewhere with a pack of dogs who constantly lick his face. Because ... um ... because Lady Smallwood said she'd shoot him herself otherwise, and Mycroft would rather his little brother get the blame. Because, um ... just because.  (This is why I am NOT a scriptwriter, folks!)

  • Like 2
Posted

 

However, I never doubted he was shot, because of the impact of the fall, the position of the hand and the way he fall.

And the sound of the gun firing. ;)

 

Just for the sake of argument (now that my visitors have left :smile: ) ... let's say Sherlock did punch Magnussen. Meaning the creep is still alive, I presume? But Mycroft told everyone he was murdered because ... um ... er ... because he's got CAM squirreled away somewhere with a pack of dogs who constantly lick his face. Because ... um ... because Lady Smallwood said she'd shoot him herself otherwise, and Mycroft would rather his little brother get the blame. Because, um ... just because. (This is why I am NOT a scriptwriter, folks!)

Mycroft told everyone he had been murdered to:

 

- protect Sherlock? Because he wants to send him away, because he knows Moriaty is alive and planning something nasty. And he wants Sherlock to get away from John becahse John is 'dangerous disadvantage' to Sherlock.

But nah. It doesn't work. Sherlock would not comply, and he would for sure know if Magnussen is not dead. And he would want to play with Moriarty. Theory stumped.

 

- Mycroft wants to use it as a bait for any Magnussen acquantainces. Provided Sherlock did shot M in the face, but he survived. But Mycroft decides to hide the fact for that purpose, even from Sherlock.

 

But nah, I don't think he can fool Sherlock, he of all people, should know the exact impact of the shoot. I don't doubt that he shoot to kill, he probably even know the coagulation of his tongue at that very moment. So, theory stumped.

 

But, but, with that theory, Sherlock should know as well whether Moriarty was in fact dead or not in that rooftop.

(I vote for dead and impersonator/twin/whatever except not dead for season 4 anyway).

 

Did I write a lot of nonsense?

 

Anyway, I like the idea about dogs constantly licking Magnussen :rofl:, but I can't endorse that kind of animal cruelty and have made some calls.

SPCA will knock on your home and join you for Christmas Dinner.

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.