Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "His Last Vow"?  

157 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

 

 

However, I never doubted he was shot, because of the impact of the fall, the position of the hand and the way he fall.

And the sound of the gun firing. ;)

 

Just for the sake of argument (now that my visitors have left :smile: ) ... let's say Sherlock did punch Magnussen. Meaning the creep is still alive, I presume? But Mycroft told everyone he was murdered because ... um ... er ... because he's got CAM squirreled away somewhere with a pack of dogs who constantly lick his face. Because ... um ... because Lady Smallwood said she'd shoot him herself otherwise, and Mycroft would rather his little brother get the blame. Because, um ... just because. (This is why I am NOT a scriptwriter, folks!)

 

Mycroft told everyone he had been murdered to:

 

- protect Sherlock? Because he wants to send him away, because he knows Moriaty is alive and planning something nasty. And he wants Sherlock to get away from John becahse John is 'dangerous disadvantage' to Sherlock.

But nah. It doesn't work. Sherlock would not comply, and he would for sure know if Magnussen is not dead. And he would want to play with Moriarty. Theory stumped.

 

- Mycroft wants to use it as a bait for any Magnussen acquantainces. Provided Sherlock did shot M in the face, but he survived. But Mycroft decides to hide the fact for that purpose, even from Sherlock.

 

But nah, I don't think he can fool Sherlock, he of all people, should know the exact impact of the shoot. I don't doubt that he shoot to kill, he probably even know the coagulation of his tongue at that very moment. So, theory stumped.

 

But, but, with that theory, Sherlock should know as well whether Moriarty was in fact dead or not in that rooftop.

(I vote for dead and impersonator/twin/whatever except not dead for season 4 anyway).

 

Did I write a lot of nonsense?

 

Yes you did but isn't that raaaather the point? :D

 

I got it! Magnussen DID figure out that John had a gun in his pocket, had his security people replace the bullets with blanks when neither John nor Sherlock were looking, and FAKED being shot in the face. It's a scheme between him and Moriarty to... um.... um.... be evil.

 

Anyway, I like the idea about dogs constantly licking Magnussen :rofl:, but I can't endorse that kind of animal cruelty and have made some calls.

SPCA will knock on your home and join you for Christmas Dinner.

 

Point taken. To save the dignity of the dogs, replace them with an automated car wash, and keep running CAM through the wash, sans car.

 

SPCA welcome, but do they eat beef roast? :blink:

  • Like 4
Posted

Because, um ... just because.  (This is why I am NOT a scriptwriter, folks!)

Why not?  The Moftisses use that technique all the time!

 

I am delighted to see that I actually did stir up a little trouble.  We are all too ready for that Special, aren't we?  :P

  • Like 2
Posted

SPCA welcome, but do they eat beef roast? :blink:

 

Eh..I don't know actually, but I suppose so. It isn't PETA. :)

 

I am delighted to see that I actually did stir up a little trouble. We are all too ready for that Special, aren't we? :P

Yes indeed!

Although I think for me, it's opposite. I try to be here as much as I could because not really sure whether I could join discussing the Special on time. But enough about the whinning, I believe in Christmas miracle and will be here soon after it's aired!

There is nothing wrong about blind confidence. :)

  • Like 3
  • 2 months later...
Posted

Okay, I think it must have been mentioned before: A quite obvious explanation for the "other one". But I haven't seen it yet.

 

 

Teri White

3h ago

Am I the only person to think that the words ‘the other one’ referred to a previous agent sent on the suicide mission and not another Holmes?

Found here:

https://wordpress.com/read/feeds/32988939/posts/964510360

  • Like 2
Posted

First time I've heard that. I'm trying to think if it makes sense.

 

MYCROFT: There will always come a time when we need Sherlock Holmes.
(Several men sitting at tables in the room look back at him silently but the man standing near him speaks.)
SIR EDWIN: If this is some expression of familial sentiment ...
(Mycroft rolls his eyes, sighs and turns to him.)
MYCROFT: Don’t be absurd. I am not given to outbursts of brotherly compassion.
(He looks down for a moment, then turns to Sir Edwin again.)
MYCROFT: You know what happened to the other one.

 

Nah, I don't think it works, because Mycroft says "brotherly compassion" before he mentions the other one, not just "compassion". I suppose it's vague enough to leave some wiggle room, but 'm still expecting another sibling to appear some day.

 

What's always puzzled me more is the part that comes next:

 

(Sir Edwin looks away, grimacing slightly. Mycroft turns to look out the window again.)
MYCROFT: In any event, there is no prison in which we could incarcerate Sherlock without causing a riot on a daily basis. The alternative, however ...
(He looks left towards where Lady Smallwood is sitting at a table.)
MYCROFT: ... would require your approval.
LADY SMALLWOOD: Hardly merciful, Mr Holmes.
MYCROFT: Regrettably, Lady Smallwood, my brother is a murderer.
(He turns away and looks out of the window again.)

 

Why does Mycroft make the case for keeping Sherlock on British soil with one breath ("we'll always need Sherlock") and then appear to ask Lady S. to send him into exile the next? Doesn't make sense! That's why I suspect the two of them are behind the Moriarty gif ... not that that really makes sense either.

Posted

I think it does make some sense... Look, the question about brotherly compassion implies that Mycroft tries to shelter Sherlock in some way. But Mycroft says that the mission...

 

ah, wait... at this moment the mission isn't mentioned yet. They are talking about keeping Sherlock handy...

Okay, it would make sense, if Mycroft was saying: "look, sending Sherlock on the mission is not a sign of mercy, the other agent died after two weeks."

But you are right. The "other one" appears first when Mycroft states they cannot keep Sherlock handy in a jail, so they have to keep him handy in East Europe. But this would imply that Mycroft thought the mission was not lethal... or that something would happen before the estimated 6 months...

 

Or it was not the mission he wanted Sherlock to decline at Christmas.

 

tuzki-bunny-emoticon-048.gif

 

Okay, another note for the big file to take to Sherlocked (not that there is much hope)

  • Like 2
Posted

I come here to see and....what?? Discussion over?

 

His last vow... think!

Actually I think Sherlock is sloppy for letting Magnussen's people to his parent's property. He is exposing himself to a very dangerous man. Well, I suppose he thinks Magnussen knows everything after all, and that is also his way to lure Mycroft. Dang, did I just counter what I said?

 

Okay, another. Mrs Holmes is not a very well-planned host, is she? It's only a while before it gets dark, and there are still potatoes on Mycroft's laptop. Don't you think she should have started/almost finished with the cooking by then?

 

Most hospital gowns that I saw leave only a bit of dignity. How come we don't see Sherlock's.. uh..? WHYYYYYYYYYYYY..

 

That is the price punishment for you for making me come here. :)

  • Like 2
Posted

.... The "other one" appears first when Mycroft states they cannot keep Sherlock handy in a jail, so they have to keep him handy in East Europe. But this would imply that Mycroft thought the mission was not lethal... or that something would happen before the estimated 6 months...

 

Or it was not the mission he wanted Sherlock to decline at Christmas.

I think it has to be the same mission, though, because of the whole "6 months" thing. Or ... well, the audience is supposed to believe that it's the same "suicide" mission, at least. I suppose they could pull the rabbit out of the hat next season and say it was a different, non-lethal six months mission. But I don't see any evidence of that now.

 

Here's my theory: when Mycroft says "the alternative would require your permission", the alternative he is referring to is not the exile; the alternative is Mycroft faking Moriarty's return. And when Lady S. says "hardly merciful", she means that it's a bit cruel for Sherlock to go up against the oh-so-superior-Mycroft, against whom baby brother has no chance of winning....

 

But I suspect ... and rather hope ... my theory is complete bollocks. :D

 

That is the price punishment for you for making me come here. :)

Because Moftiss doesn't already punish us enough, apparently.... :P
  • Like 2
Posted

Well, they might talk about almost anything, to be honest, beside needing Sherlock and impossibility of keeping him in jail, and the cruel alternative to the last.

It makes no sense. They cannot keep him handy by sending him to a suicide mission. What the heck is going on? :wacko:

 

It could be just a huge plothole, of course.

Posted

It could be, but usually their plot holes don't call that much attention to themselves. Well, we shall see. I assume. Unless we don't. :p

Posted

I come here to see and....what?? Discussion over?

 

His last vow... think!

Actually I think Sherlock is sloppy for letting Magnussen's people to his parent's property. He is exposing himself to a very dangerous man. Well, I suppose he thinks Magnussen knows everything after all, and that is also his way to lure Mycroft. Dang, did I just counter what I said?

 

Okay, another. Mrs Holmes is not a very well-planned host, is she? It's only a while before it gets dark, and there are still potatoes on Mycroft's laptop. Don't you think she should have started/almost finished with the cooking by then?

 

Most hospital gowns that I saw leave only a bit of dignity. How come we don't see Sherlock's.. uh..? WHYYYYYYYYYYYY..

 

That is the price punishment for you for making me come here. :)

 

We can never let the discussion of HLV end!  Let's see....

 

Maybe Mrs. Holmes is making mashed potatoes and is the kind who cuts her raw potatoes into smaller chunks, necessitating less boil time?  Although, how do you not notice you're cutting/piling potatoes on a laptop?  And where has Mycroft had that thing; that could be really gross!

 

As far as the hospital gown, what really bugs me is that Sherlock managed to put his coat on and take it off in the restaurant without dislodging his IV!  Guys, I tried this with a robe when I was in the hospital, and I couldn't manage to lift the saline off the pole and thread it through the sleeve to get the robe on.  Maybe Sherlock was just feeling better than I was for my real-world test, but the guy can hardly extend his arms to take CAM's glasses off, let alone twist around to the degree required to reposition a bag of saline!

 

(Yes, I did just admit that I tried to test a Sherlock plot point while I was ill.  Do I get some sort of crazy fan prize for that?)

  • Like 3
Posted

I think it does make some sense... Look, the question about brotherly compassion implies that Mycroft tries to shelter Sherlock in some way. But Mycroft says that the mission...

 

ah, wait... at this moment the mission isn't mentioned yet. They are talking about keeping Sherlock handy...

Okay, it would make sense, if Mycroft was saying: "look, sending Sherlock on the mission is not a sign of mercy, the other agent died after two weeks."

But you are right. The "other one" appears first when Mycroft states they cannot keep Sherlock handy in a jail, so they have to keep him handy in East Europe. But this would imply that Mycroft thought the mission was not lethal... or that something would happen before the estimated 6 months...

 

Or it was not the mission he wanted Sherlock to decline at Christmas.

..

Actually, I am a bit confused why you are confused.

I think the mission is lethal. Sherlock is probably granted immunity from Magnussen's murder but he has to take up the mission. It is the same mission they talk about during Christmas. But this time, Sherlock doesn't have option to decline it.

Mycroft suggests that because the other option is Sherlock going through trial and prison, that would cause riot according to him (and of course it would be difficult for Mycroft to arrange something else without being obvious once they go that path because it would be very public). Also, Mycroft is choosing that option eventhough he believes it's lethal so that he won't be accused of nepotism, unlawful or sentimental with risk of it being rejected.

At least, with that option, he thinks he has more time to figure out some solution, conundrum, solution that is acceptable for both parties with minimal damage.

From there,.. we have a lot of theories. :)

 

 

We can never let the discussion of HLV end!  Let's see....

 

Maybe Mrs. Holmes is making mashed potatoes and is the kind who cuts her raw potatoes into smaller chunks, necessitating less boil time?  Although, how do you not notice you're cutting/piling potatoes on a laptop?  And where has Mycroft had that thing; that could be really gross!

:D :D Yup..! And nobody is helping her cooking...!

 

 

 

 

As far as the hospital gown, what really bugs me is that Sherlock managed to put his coat on and take it off in the restaurant without dislodging his IV!  Guys, I tried this with a robe when I was in the hospital, and I couldn't manage to lift the saline off the pole and thread it through the sleeve to get the robe on.  Maybe Sherlock was just feeling better than I was for my real-world test, but the guy can hardly extend his arms to take CAM's glasses off, let alone twist around to the degree required to reposition a bag of saline!

 

(Yes, I did just admit that I tried to test a Sherlock plot point while I was ill.  Do I get some sort of crazy fan prize for that?)

In here? Not really, there are too many competition for crazies. Not me though (I think!) :P I'm just entertaining thoughts like rolling my bike down the stairs or stopping cars with my palm. XD

 

Maybe he draped the coat on one shoulder only? Yah, that IV thing is very inconvinient, I remember forgetting to position my hand properly the blood flew out instead, maybe it's old system, sounds weird, but that is what I was told. Well, I was not a very cooperative patient.

 

But those hospital gowns! Argh.. they have undying determination to expose your back area.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

But those hospital gowns! Argh.. they have undying determination to expose your back area.

 

 

And what is that even FOR?  I mean, yes, there are situations that I can think of where nurses need to have access to your backside regularly and it makes sense.  But in Sherlock's case (let's keep it all about Sherlock, of course!), his wound was on his front only, and he's obviously ambulatory enough to go meet CAM, so he's making it to the loo by himself.  So, wouldn't it be a lot more convenient from  a wound-care perspective for him to be wearing a gown version that opens in the front?  (I did see that version used in House, so I know it's out there somewhere....)

  • Like 1
Posted

I think the gowns are made to put them on the patient without the need of lifting him up. Also it's a bit inconvenient in some conditions if the patient has to bend his arms backwards to get them into the sleeves. But they are self-esteem killers for sure. Happily in German hospitals you are allowed to wear your own clothes if it doesn't collide with your condition.

 

As for the IV - maybe he just put the coat sleeve over it so the pipe(?) went out through his collar. And of course he had help with the whole action. In the past I had often problems with the IV needles, but the last one was wonderfully flexible, so I hardly felt it - and it sat on the inside of my wrist.

 

 

Actually, I am a bit confused why you are confused.
I think the mission is lethal. Sherlock...

 

The dialogue starts with Mycroft talking about needing Sherlock in the future. Alive. So sending him on a suicide mission makes not much sense, at least to me. But it might be just Friday. :rolleyes:

  • Like 2
Posted

Let's investigate this potato situation closer, shall we?
 
bbc-sherlock-series3-his-last-vow-holmesWell, it appears to me that there are not one but two piles of potatoes, so maybe someone is helping with the cooking? Pop Holmes, maybe? Wiggins?

 

But the potatoes looked peeled, not diced ... at least not yet. So here's another idea... remember the deleted scene where Sherlock is eating a tart? That's more like dessert, right? So maybe they've already had Christmas dinner, and Mum is getting a jump start on the next day's meal.

 

Or if you don't like that idea, how about this: it's early in the day at the Holmes residence, so Mum has plenty of time to cook the potatoes; but it took a lot longer than we think to get to Appledore, that's why it's nightfall when Sherlock finally offs CAM.

 

Or ... it's all in Sherlock's mind palace (CAM's still alive!)

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh, Arcadia, don't even suggest it!  (That CAM is still alive...)

  • Like 1
Posted

Let's investigate this potato situation closer, shall we?

 

bbc-sherlock-series3-his-last-vow-holmesWell, it appears to me that there are not one but two piles of potatoes, so maybe someone is helping with the cooking? Pop Holmes, maybe? Wiggins?

 

But the potatoes looked peeled, not diced ... at least not yet. So here's another idea... remember the deleted scene where Sherlock is eating a tart? That's more like dessert, right? So maybe they've already had Christmas dinner, and Mum is getting a jump start on the next day's meal.

 

Or if you don't like that idea, how about this: it's early in the day at the Holmes residence, so Mum has plenty of time to cook the potatoes; but it took a lot longer than we think to get to Appledore, that's why it's nightfall when Sherlock finally offs CAM.

 

Or ... it's all in Sherlock's mind palace (CAM's still alive!)

 

The clock on the wall shows that it is just past 2:00 PM, and Sherlock checks his watch during this as he his waiting for the drugged tea and punch to take their effect.  Then he's off to Appledor via helicopter, and it's not entirely dark when he shoots Magnussen.  Keep in mind that this time of year in Britain, the days are considerably shorter, and it gets dark faster - and Sherlock and John aren't at Magnussen's house for very long before things go terribly wrong - and Mycroft is quick to be there also.

 

Also after Mycroft and Sherlock have their little smoke, Mycroft sits in the end chair, the potatoes having been removed from his laptop.  His mother has moved a white cake to where  he had been sitting before.  

  • Like 1
Posted

The conclusion is ... WE NEED NEW EPISODES!!! 

crazy-2239.gif

  • Like 2
Posted

The conclusion is that his mother didn't dare set the cake in front of Mycroft while he was in the other chair lest he sneak a bite. :lol:

  • Like 3
Posted

Let's investigate this potato situation closer, shall we?

You know you are hanging out with the right crowd when above is the thing you hear at the start of your weekend. :D

 

I buy that Appledore is a distance away, that makes a lot of sense. Now that you guys mentioned it, I think Appledore is not in London, or even in England. (Not sure if they mentioned it in HLV, I don't have 90 minutes to check it..you know, a peek and then you are sucked into watching the whole thing :P). Magnussen is not British, he wouldn't keep 'his files' in foreign country.

What about passports? Nah.. Sherlock is prepared and he brings John's too.

 

So, wouldn't it be a lot more convenient from a wound-care perspective for him to be wearing a gown version that opens in the front?

Wo wo wo wo....ehm.... clear throat...he he he he he..

 

The dialogue starts with Mycroft talking about needing Sherlock in the future. Alive. So sending him on a suicide mission makes not much sense, at least to me. But it might be just Friday. :rolleyes:

I thought that was him making a case so that he could suggest the mission. It's a good case, basically a lot of people want to get rid of Magnussen or happy that he is gone. And the future when they will need Sherlock is when he brings up the mission, basically a minute after. But it might be just Saturday. :D

 

The conclusion is that his mother didn't dare set the cake in front of Mycroft while he was in the other chair lest he sneak a bite.

Aaaaaand...that is the best thing I heard today. :)

Maybe it's a thing he does regularly? OHHHHH! Maybe he sends a car and not-Athea to kidnap cake now and then..! I have just blown my own mind.

 

The conclusion is ... WE NEED NEW EPISODES!!!

Heyyyyy... what gives? XD

Eh...have you met this guy?

tumblr_mw4iz2Zcya1t0lnxjo3_500.gif

  • Like 1
Posted

This discussion about piles of potatoes was so interesting :lol4:

 

About the exile, I think that Mycroft would never send his brother to a suicide mission, maybe he thinks it could be a suicide mission for "normal" people but not for Sherlock, or maybe he only says that it is a suicide mission to convince the others that Sherlock will have his punishment.

 

 

Here's my theory: when Mycroft says "the alternative would require your permission", the alternative he is referring to is not the exile; the alternative is Mycroft faking Moriarty's return.

 

But why faking Moriarty's return? To convince the other people to call back Sherlock because he's the only one who can face Moriarty? That could be a very intelligent idea! Even if Mycroft, in this case, doesn't consider that this solution could be too hard for Sherlock, expecially after all that Moriarty did to him and after he has passed two (difficult) years to destroy all the criminal net built bi Moriarty.

Posted

But why faking Moriarty's return? To convince the other people to call back Sherlock because he's the only one who can face Moriarty?

 

Yep, exactly. In order to maintain his position in the government, Mycroft pretends to send his brother off on this deadly mission. But in secret, he fakes Moriarty's return so that the government will beg him to bring Sherlock back.

 

But I think TAB pointed to there being a different answer.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't know that TAB pointed to a different answer.  And I wouldn't trust anything coming out of Sherlock's drug addled brain - except for the fact that Moriarty is actually dead

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 95 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.