Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "His Last Vow"?  

157 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

They've already said they don't plan to say anything more about Irene, although they don't rule out anything, of course. But Moffat says he rather likes the not knowing, and I think he's on the right track with this one. To make the relationship between her and Sherlock more concrete would ruin it, I think -- sort of like how the Explanation ruined the Fall. Better to leave it to our imaginations.

 

Dang, I'm going to have to switch computers, this one won't let me do multi-quote. I love multi-quote! Give me some, I need it!

  • Like 1
Posted

Moffat says he rather likes the not knowing, and I think he's on the right track with this one. To make the relationship between her and Sherlock more concrete would ruin it, I think -- sort of like how the Explanation ruined the Fall. Better to leave it to our imaginations.

 

Besides, if they explain everything, where would we get our fanfiction plots?

  • Like 1
Posted
They've already said they don't plan to say anything more about Irene, although they don't rule out anything, of course. But Moffat says he rather likes the not knowing, and I think he's on the right track with this one. 

 

 

Sorry as this is quite a ways off-topic!

 

I was reading a Dr. Who article recently on the guardian online about how some people feel Moffat's version of that show is a little misogynist. It did make me think about Sherlock to an extent, because (and yes, the show is called Sherlock, so it will be man-focused, I accept) a lot of the female characters in the show are mainly there to serve the men in one way or another. It is most pronounced with Molly and Mrs. Hudson, but I also see Irene as a version of a male fantasy too. I wonder would they know quite where to take her if they brought her back. 

 

I get the impression a lot of the fans here are female, so am curious how people feel on the forum feel about that aspect of the show. I think perhaps they cast the women fantastically and sometimes the performances are elevating characters that on paper are quite functional.

  • Like 1
Posted

I was reading a Dr. Who article recently on the guardian online about how some people feel Moffat's version of that show is a little misogynist.

That's really odd -- I don't believe I've ever heard someone say they thought Doctor Who was a little misogynist.   :P

 

It did make me think about Sherlock to an extent, because (and yes, the show is called Sherlock, so it will be man-focused, I accept) a lot of the female characters in the show are mainly there to serve the men in one way or another. It is most pronounced with Molly and Mrs. Hudson, but I also see Irene as a version of a male fantasy too.

Moftiss's version of Irene is definitely a male fantasy (despite their nonsense about her being a strong, independent businesswoman).  But as you say, the show is called Sherlock, so all of the other characters -- male and female -- are primarily there to support him.  That said, however, I think this show does a better job of giving everybody an important function than a lot of shows do.  Nobody's lines are limited to "Hailing frequencies open."

 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Moffat says he rather likes the not knowing, and I think he's on the right track with this one. To make the relationship between her and Sherlock more concrete would ruin it, I think -- sort of like how the Explanation ruined the Fall. Better to leave it to our imaginations.

 

Besides, if they explain everything, where would we get our fanfiction plots?

 

And how we fill the time without speculations in the forum?

 

 

Regarding the female in the series, I think Sherlock has very good portrayal of females.  I don't really agree that the female characters are mainly there to serve the men. 

There are strong, respectable and smart characters, with independent thinking and agenda, and the male characters respect them.

(Irene, Mary, Molly even minor characters like not-Anthea, Sally, Lady Smallwood).

 

In fact, I don't see a typical female characteristic damsel in distress at all in Sherlock, eventhough Mycroft says so. He hardly know what he is talking about sometimes. :)

Posted

Ahhhhhhhh, multi-quote at last: tuzki-bunny-emoticon-038.gif

 

I am still holding it to miss me as Lady Smallwood's work, without Mycroft's interference.

 

Oh heck.  Maybe miss me is from Irene Adler.  LOL

I've seriously considered both of those possibilities and like them. (Nope, not a bit obsesssed....)
 

Mycroft's speech also raises the question of who exactly was wielding the weapon. To call Sherlock either a scalpel or a weapon implies he was under someone else's (the government's? Mycroft's?) control, yet the way we see the story unfold it seems his is acting very much on his own steam.

 

This is another open issue. We don't know if Sherlock was acting against or with Mycroft.

Oooo, good points. I'm pretty wedded to the idea of Sherlock as an independent agent, but that doesn't mean Moftiss is, does it? Maybe Sherlock is acting with Lady Smallwood against Mycroft.... :D
 

But we still want to know who the other one was, don't we? :P

 YES!!!
 

Sorry as this is quite a ways off-topic!
 
I was reading a Dr. Who article recently on the guardian online about how some people feel Moffat's version of that show is a little misogynist. It did make me think about Sherlock to an extent, because (and yes, the show is called Sherlock, so it will be man-focused, I accept) a lot of the female characters in the show are mainly there to serve the men in one way or another. It is most pronounced with Molly and Mrs. Hudson, but I also see Irene as a version of a male fantasy too. I wonder would they know quite where to take her if they brought her back. 
 
I get the impression a lot of the fans here are female, so am curious how people feel on the forum feel about that aspect of the show. I think perhaps they cast the women fantastically and sometimes the performances are elevating characters that on paper are quite functional.

I have to agree with both Carol and VB on this; given that the show is called "Sherlock", they do a pretty good job of giving everyone meaningful scenes, and I don't detect any animosity towards women. Sherlock himself seems to find them rather silly and useless at first, but that's portrayed as one of his faults, not one of his virtues. I love that he seems to actually be forming friendships with both Mary and Molly in S3.
 
What I do see is a little too much fondness for the BAMF female in almost all programming, but I'm willing to bet a lot of women see that as a good thing. And maybe it is, I just personally have grown weary of it. That's my biggest gripe against their portrayal of Mary; they couldn't let her be a real person with real problems, she has to be a super agent with super problems. Yawn.
 

In fact, I don't see a typical female characteristic damsel in distress at all in Sherlock, eventhough Mycroft says so. He hardly know what he is talking about sometimes. :)

I think the damsel in distress role is taken by John, is it not? :d

  • Like 3
Posted

What I do see is a little too much fondness for the BAMF female in almost all programming, but I'm willing to bet a lot of women see that as a good thing. And maybe it is, I just personally have grown weary of it. That's my biggest gripe against their portrayal of Mary; they couldn't let her be a real person with real problems, she has to be a super agent with super problems. Yawn.

Indeed.  (But shouldn't that, statistically speaking, be BAFF?)

 

  • Like 2
Posted

I wasn't serious about "miss me" being Irene Adler, of course, but she DID send a red rose to Sherlock's hospital room. :lol4:

Posted

 

 

I get the impression a lot of the fans here are female, so am curious how people feel on the forum feel about that aspect of the show. I think perhaps they cast the women fantastically and sometimes the performances are elevating characters that on paper are quite functional.

 

 

 

 

What I do see is a little too much fondness for the BAMF female in almost all programming, but I'm willing to bet a lot of women see that as a good thing. And maybe it is, I just personally have grown weary of it. That's my biggest gripe against their portrayal of Mary; they couldn't let her be a real person with real problems, she has to be a super agent with super problems. Yawn.

Indeed.  (But shouldn't that, statistically speaking, be BAFF?)

 

 

Well, I'm female, so I'll weigh in....(Actually, no, save me from anything weight-related right now!   :D)

 

I'm really, really tired of the BAMF/BAFF female figure in entertainment, for the record.  I have a hard time identifying with figures who are brilliant, athletic, beautiful, and probably great cooks and amazing pianists.  The women on Sherlock, generally, are fairly real.  Yes, they all have their BAMF-y elements, but those are mostly just aspects of their personalities, not the whole thing.  I like that.

 

 

Also, as you guys have so astutely pointed out, the show is called Sherlock, and it is billed as a modernization of Sherlock Holmes.  By it's very nature, it is heavy on the male-led adventures and relationships because the protagonists are Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, both men.  I like that, too.  I'm capable of identifying with a male protagonist in a show like this; it really has very little to do with gender for me.

 

Which is my final point:  Moftiss have really done a good job of emphasizing how irrelevant sex and gender really are most of the time in human life.  I know we've discussed this to death, but the fact that they take sexual relationships off the table as far as really emphasizing them opens the door for the show to explore issues of love and loyalty and adventure and addiction and lots of other things that other shows usually bury under the "big romance that ends in two people having sex."  I feel like all the Sherlock characters are therefore open to me to identify with and like or dislike, because I'm not constantly being hammered over the head with gender or with a relationship portrayal that I wouldn't be interested in personally.  

 

I mean, I identify mainly with Sherlock (but with Irene's fashion style sometimes).  I had/have a best friend who is the Watson to my Holmes (although, as she points out, she might be more the Moriarty to my Holmes...), and I like to think that either one of us would risk our lives for the other.  None of that has anything to do with "Hollywood's" usual insistence that, as a woman, I should identify with the female lead and leave the men to the men.  So I actually think Sherlock is very successful on this front.

  • Like 4
Posted

I'm really, really tired of the BAMF/BAFF female figure in entertainment, for the record.  I have a hard time identifying with figures who are brilliant, athletic, beautiful, and probably great cooks and amazing pianists.  The women on Sherlock, generally, are fairly real.  Yes, they all have their BAMF-y elements, but those are mostly just aspects of their personalities, not the whole thing.  I like that.

That's an interesting point.  We don't generally see female characters who are merely BA?F types.  Whereas a male character can be a plain BA?F with no redeeming qualities, a warrior woman has to be -- at minimum -- drop-dead gorgeous as well.  But while Mary is of course very pretty, she has a girl-next-door look, rather than being a glamour queen.  She's the sort of down-to-earth woman that I enjoy knowing in real life.

 

I'm capable of identifying with a male protagonist in a show like this; it really has very little to do with gender for me.

 

Which is my final point:  Moftiss have really done a good job of emphasizing how irrelevant sex and gender really are most of the time in human life.  I know we've discussed this to death, but the fact that they take sexual relationships off the table as far as really emphasizing them opens the door for the show to explore issues of love and loyalty and adventure and addiction and lots of other things that other shows usually bury under the "big romance that ends in two people having sex."

Another good point.  Maybe this is one reason that I've been hooked  by Star Trek and by Sherlock, with very little in between.  I can identify with characters like Spock and John, despite not sharing their gender, because they're complex individuals who (unwittingly) allow me to see into their psyches.  They're both highly intelligent men, and they're both good fighters, but it doesn't stop there, as it would with an ordinary "action" show -- they both have very visible souls as well.  Added: I'm not sure how much of that is due to the writing and/or directing, but a good chunk of the credit has to go to the actors.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

That's really odd -- I don't believe I've ever heard someone say they thought Doctor Who was a little misogynist.

 

 

Help me out here- I don't watch the show! Is it really misogynist? I was thinking of giving it a go for the sake of the charming David Tennant. And because Sherlock is so good.

 

 

What I do see is a little too much fondness for the BAMF female in almost all programming, but I'm willing to bet a lot of women see that as a good thing. And maybe it is, I just personally have grown weary of it. That's my biggest gripe against their portrayal of Mary; they couldn't let her be a real person with real problems, she has to be a super agent with super problems. Yawn.

 

 

Totally. I see it as almost a quick-fix superficial nod towards feminism that seems to eschew giving a woman an actual voice- just have her punch/ shoot someone instead. Like, I don't hate Molly slapping Sherlock in HLV, and I even understand it, but I don't consider that sort of thing empowering for a character. I think Mary, whilst perhaps on paper she is supposed to be the most dynamic of the women, is the most cartoonish because of the whole secret spy thing and the shooting in HLV. 

 

 

 

 

 I feel like all the Sherlock characters are therefore open to me to identify with and like or dislike, because I'm not constantly being hammered over the head with gender or with a relationship portrayal that I wouldn't be interested in personally.  

 

 

That's a really good point. For the record, I definitely don't find Sherlock himself sexist, he seems equally capable of rudeness to either sex, and probably also willing to flirt with both men and women if it will help his case.

 

I still think that Sarah was possibly going to be the strongest female character, had they kept her. But maybe next season Mary (and the other Sherlock women) will prove surprising.

 

 

Van Buren Supernova, on 08 Dec 2015 - 01:41 AM, said:snapback.png

In fact, I don't see a typical female characteristic damsel in distress at all in Sherlock, eventhough Mycroft says so. He hardly know what he is talking about sometimes.  :)

I think the damsel in distress role is taken by John, is it not?  :D

 

 

 
Ha! I think they sort of have to get a free pass on Damsels in Distress, when Molly was so instrumental in helping Sherlock escape death in the fall- but I really, really didn't care for how they had Sherlock coming to Irene's rescue at the end of SiB, especially as it just followed on from him besting her at solving the (in my opinion, rather silly) phone code. I just thought it was pretty weak tea for the woman who is supposedly his equal. Still, overall, they do well on avoiding women as victims, and they have had a good share of female villains (if we include Mary).

 

  • Like 1
Posted

That's really odd -- I don't believe I've ever heard someone say they thought Doctor Who was a little misogynist.

 

Help me out here- I don't watch the show! Is it really misogynist? I was thinking of giving it a go for the sake of the charming David Tennant. And because Sherlock is so good.

 

Copy-and-paste seems to have wiped out my italics on "a little," so first I'd better explain that I was being sarcastic.  It seems to me that people either like the show as-is or else consider it ridiculously misogynist (among other things).  I seriously don't recall ever hearing someone call it "a little misogynist."  So I think it's a point-of-view thing.  If you don't consider Sherlock misogynist, you'll probably like Who just fine.

 

I see [bAMF female characters] as almost a quick-fix superficial nod towards feminism that seems to eschew giving a woman an actual voice- just have her punch/ shoot someone instead. Like, I don't hate Molly slapping Sherlock in HLV, and I even understand it, but I don't consider that sort of thing empowering for a character. I think Mary, whilst perhaps on paper she is supposed to be the most dynamic of the women, is the most cartoonish because of the whole secret spy thing and the shooting in HLV.

 Yes!!!  :applause:

 

I still think that Sarah was possibly going to be the strongest female character, had they kept her. But maybe next season Mary (and the other Sherlock women) will prove surprising.

 Hopefully!  (But I still miss Sarah. :( )

 

I really, really didn't care for how they had Sherlock coming to Irene's rescue at the end of SiB, especially as it just followed on from him besting her at solving the (in my opinion, rather silly) phone code. I just thought it was pretty weak tea for the woman who is supposedly his equal.

I guess that's one reason I like Moffat's suggested post-credits scene, wherein Irene appropriates Sherlock's clothing so she can escape (alone) disguised as a male -- which, come to think of it, would have been a nice nod to the original story.  Too bad they didn't actually film that!

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

 

 

 
Copy-and-paste seems to have wiped out my italics on "a little," so first I'd better explain that I was being sarcastic.  It seems to me that people either like the show as-is or else consider it ridiculously misogynist (among other things).  I seriously don't recall ever hearing someone call it "a little misogynist."  So I think it's a point-of-view thing.  If you don't consider Sherlock misogynist, you'll probably like Who just fine.
 

 

 

Ah, I see, thank you! I will likely give it a shot, I see it is on Netflix now too.

 

 

I guess that's one reason I like Moffat's suggested post-credits scene, wherein Irene appropriates Sherlock's clothing so she can escape (alone) disguised as a male -- which, come to think of it, would have been a nice nod to the original story.  Too bad they didn't actually film that!

 

 

 

Ooh that would have been so much better. And also, nice for her, to have the opportunity to wear Sherlock's clothes.  :D

 

ETA: I mentioned to my boyfriend that we were talking about the women of Sherlock and he said we should mention Janine also, as she was very badly treated. Only, he referred to her as 'Moriarty's sister'- surely a sign my Sherlock-related-madness is contagious.

  • Like 1
Posted

I agree with you boyfriend about Janine being badly treated, both by Sherlock and by some fans, and hope that we'll see her again in future episodes.  As for her being Moriarty's sister, perhaps time will tell!

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Don't care about male or female, I take what I want and no chromosome ever enter the calculation. They can turn Sherlock into a woman and I still won't identify with her. :p

Posted

I'm really, really tired of the BAMF/BAFF female figure in entertainment, for the record.  I have a hard time identifying with figures who are brilliant, athletic, beautiful, and probably great cooks and amazing pianists.  The women on Sherlock, generally, are fairly real.  Yes, they all have their BAMF-y elements, but those are mostly just aspects of their personalities, not the whole thing.  I like that.

 

Also, as you guys have so astutely pointed out, the show is called Sherlock, and it is billed as a modernization of Sherlock Holmes.  By it's very nature, it is heavy on the male-led adventures and relationships because the protagonists are Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, both men.  I like that, too.  I'm capable of identifying with a male protagonist in a show like this; it really has very little to do with gender for me.

 

Which is my final point:  Moftiss have really done a good job of emphasizing how irrelevant sex and gender really are most of the time in human life.  I know we've discussed this to death, but the fact that they take sexual relationships off the table as far as really emphasizing them opens the door for the show to explore issues of love and loyalty and adventure and addiction and lots of other things that other shows usually bury under the "big romance that ends in two people having sex."  I feel like all the Sherlock characters are therefore open to me to identify with and like or dislike, because I'm not constantly being hammered over the head with gender or with a relationship portrayal that I wouldn't be interested in personally.  

 

I mean, I identify mainly with Sherlock (but with Irene's fashion style sometimes).  I had/have a best friend who is the Watson to my Holmes (although, as she points out, she might be more the Moriarty to my Holmes...), and I like to think that either one of us would risk our lives for the other.  None of that has anything to do with "Hollywood's" usual insistence that, as a woman, I should identify with the female lead and leave the men to the men.  So I actually think Sherlock is very successful on this front.

Same here, gender doesn't determine which character/s I identify with, and I'm vaguely offended when a female character is pointed out as someone who's there to attract female viewers. I think that's one of many reasons I love Joss Whedon's work so much; his female characters run the gamut from ass-kickers to distressed damsels, but they're all multi-dimensional. As are the male characters, of course. Good stuff.

 

Totally. I see it as almost a quick-fix superficial nod towards feminism that seems to eschew giving a woman an actual voice- just have her punch/ shoot someone instead. Like, I don't hate Molly slapping Sherlock in HLV, and I even understand it, but I don't consider that sort of thing empowering for a character. I think Mary, whilst perhaps on paper she is supposed to be the most dynamic of the women, is the most cartoonish because of the whole secret spy thing and the shooting in HLV.

Exactly!

 

Ha! I think they sort of have to get a free pass on Damsels in Distress, when Molly was so instrumental in helping Sherlock escape death in the fall- but I really, really didn't care for how they had Sherlock coming to Irene's rescue at the end of SiB, especially as it just followed on from him besting her at solving the (in my opinion, rather silly) phone code. I just thought it was pretty weak tea for the woman who is supposedly his equal. Still, overall, they do well on avoiding women as victims, and they have had a good share of female villains (if we include Mary).

I prefer to think that it was showing she won in the end ... because Sherlock did give in to sentiment, he's not as self-righteosly rational as he pretends to be.

  • Like 1
Posted

Which is my final point:  Moftiss have really done a good job of emphasizing how irrelevant sex and gender really are most of the time in human life.  I know we've discussed this to death, but the fact that they take sexual relationships off the table as far as really emphasizing them opens the door for the show to explore issues of love and loyalty and adventure and addiction and lots of other things that other shows usually bury under the "big romance that ends in two people having sex."  I feel like all the Sherlock characters are therefore open to me to identify with and like or dislike, because I'm not constantly being hammered over the head with gender or with a relationship portrayal that I wouldn't be interested in personally.

 

AMEN!

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

 

Ha! I think they sort of have to get a free pass on Damsels in Distress, when Molly was so instrumental in helping Sherlock escape death in the fall- but I really, really didn't care for how they had Sherlock coming to Irene's rescue at the end of SiB, especially as it just followed on from him besting her at solving the (in my opinion, rather silly) phone code. I just thought it was pretty weak tea for the woman who is supposedly his equal. Still, overall, they do well on avoiding women as victims, and they have had a good share of female villains (if we include Mary).

 

I prefer to think that it was showing she won in the end ... because Sherlock did give in to sentiment, he's not as self-righteosly rational as he pretends to be.

 

 

I know this is getting off HLV as a topic a bit, but I think that SiB is one of the episodes in which the creators were a bit more constrained by the limitations of the original story.  With Scandal, they were pretty consciously updating "Scandal in Bohemia" rather than just being inspired by it, so they sort of had to have Irene run off and escape consequences for her actions somehow as a nod to the original story.  I agree that she won in the end because Sherlock showed sentiment; he followed her and rescued her.  Maybe Irene would have figured a way out on her own if he weren't there, but he couldn't stand not to be.

 

Back to HLV and BAMF-y women and such, I usually completely ignore the physical aspect of Molly slapping Sherlock.  What really impresses me, on a certain level, is that her dialogue matches some dialogue that comes from Watson in the original stories.  In that moment, Molly was standing in for Watson, which I think is a great piece of character development for Molly that gets overlooked.  In that context, the slap makes sense, because Moftiss have a history of expressing "Watson emotion" through fights.  They updated Watson fainting at Sherlock's return to be an epic three-restaurant beat-down, so of course they update Watson's sorrow at Holmes's drug use to be Molly slapping the crud out of Sherlock.  It's what Moftiss do!

  • Like 2
Posted

I LOVED it when I realized while reading The Sign of the Four that... there were Molly's lines... basically.  

 

Why should you, for a mere passing pleasure, risk the loss of those great powers with which you have been endowed?

  • Like 3
Posted

I LOVED it when I realized while reading The Sign of the Four that... there were Molly's lines... basically.  

 

Why should you, for a mere passing pleasure, risk the loss of those great powers with which you have been endowed?

 

I had the same reaction; I was rereading The Sign of the Four, and I came across that line, and I was just gobsmacked.  There's Molly's lines, and they were taken from Watson, not from anyone else! That tells you a ton about the Sherlock-Molly relationship.  (It's also probably one of the reasons I don't ship Sherlolly.)

  • Like 2
Posted

 

I LOVED it when I realized while reading The Sign of the Four that... there were Molly's lines... basically.  

 

Why should you, for a mere passing pleasure, risk the loss of those great powers with which you have been endowed?

 

I had the same reaction; I was rereading The Sign of the Four, and I came across that line, and I was just gobsmacked.  There's Molly's lines, and they were taken from Watson, not from anyone else! That tells you a ton about the Sherlock-Molly relationship.  (It's also probably one of the reasons I don't ship Sherlolly.)

 

 

Sherlolly isn't ever happening, even if I wish it was, and I'll be wishing until the credits role on the series finale.  What do you call the very final episode ever when you call every season a series?

 

 

54a78add788db_-_crying.gif

 

 

... but regardless of that, I'll take any added importance for Molly in the show simply because I love the character.  It doesn't have to be in the context of something romantic with Sherlock.  If anything, giving her importance outside of some romantic trope is more meaningful to me than if she's just a love interest.  I'm now laughing at the thought of Sherlock and the words "love interest."  Anywho...

 

I do think it's funny that of my two favorite current shows, Sherlock and The Walking Dead, I adore characters that didn't even exist in the books/comics, Molly and Daryl respectively.

  • Like 1
Posted

I'll take any added importance for Molly in the show simply because I love the character.  It doesn't have to be in the context of something romantic with Sherlock.  If anything, giving her importance outside of some romantic trope is more meaningful to me than if she's just a love interest.  I'm now laughing at the thought of Sherlock and the words "love interest." 

 

 

Molly is probably as much my favourite character as Sherlock and John, even though she's barely in the show compared to them! But I do have dark moments where I wonder if the whole Sherlock-going-back-on-drugs thing will have been the bad kind of eye-opener for her, and she'll lose interest/ patience in him (both romantically and friend-wise), thus we'll see less of her. I sometimes forget that while we see her in Sherlock's mind helping save him at the end, in the series reality their last scene probably ended with a pretty negative aftertaste for Molly. Then again, Molly's already had a lot of moments that for most people would have been the last straw.

 

I do like that she was given Watson's lines, though. If the Sherlock writers were working for me, I'd have made them write John and Molly as two halves of the original Watson character deliberately. I'm not sure exactly what kind of shippers that would have created though.

  • Like 5
Posted

I love Mycroft and Molly more than John.  

 

*hides from Carol*

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

 

Sherlolly isn't ever happening, even if I wish it was, and I'll be wishing until the credits role on the series finale.  What do you call the very final episode ever when you call every season a series?

 

 

 

 

That's what I've always heard it called here in the U.S.: a "series finale."  

 

 

 

 But I do have dark moments where I wonder if the whole Sherlock-going-back-on-drugs thing will have been the bad kind of eye-opener for her, and she'll lose interest/ patience in him (both romantically and friend-wise), thus we'll see less of her. 

 

(The quote above is from bedelia1984, but I made a right mess out of quoting.)

 

I don't think we'll see less of her.  I think, if the creators are serious about using her as a bit of a Watson for Sherlock, that we will see more of her because of the drugs.  A friend can sometimes go places and stay in situations that a romantic interest should not.  Not to put too fine a point on it, but I would advise someone like Molly not to get involved with an on-again-off-again drug user because the risks are just too high if the relationship got more serious.  But I would have no qualms about saying that a good friend could help another friend stay sober.  

 

It would be interesting if Molly picked up some of the "worrying about Sherlock" aspects of ACD Watson's character.  I know that John worries about Sherlock on some level, and I know that he's been around to "supervise" during at least one danger night, but John just has not (so far) really put his foot down about the drugs -- and I don't think he should.  He's the character that follows the ACD trajectory of sticking with Holmes regardless of his behavior.  But Molly could express the worry and concern to Sherlock, just like she did in HLV.  And this might make the character development all around that much more interesting, because Sherlock would be forced to realize he has more than one person who cares.

  • Like 4

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.