Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "His Last Vow"?  

157 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

I was being facetious (who, me? :angel2: ) but I also think that was a lovely moment for John. Imo, what he was demonstrating in that moment wasn't forgiveness or blindness or nobility, but something better and increasingly rare; mercy. Whether he should have done it or not, whether Mary deserved it or not, is beside the point; I think the point is that he is humble enough to offer it, unlike nearly everyone else around him. Although I suppose humility is another quality that is rather out of fashion these days. But John is a little-old fashioned sometimes, isn't he? I like him for it.

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm sure this has been discussed before (probably multiple times elsewhere in the thread) but here it goes:

 

1. The 'something I've always intended to say but never have' could it be anything else other than 'I love you'? Because he has actually told John he loves him in TSOT, but I just don't see what else it could possibly be - whether meant platonically or not (I love Johnlock, but I don't believe in TJLC). What other options are there?

 

2. Does Mycroft know Mary shot Sherlock? Wouldn't he do something about it? I can't imagine him just ignoring something like that, to the point of even having the woman who did actually kill his brother in the family home for Christmas. And I can't see how there is anyway he wouldn't know, John and Mary becoming estranged immediately after would be a dead giveaway. The only way I can see around this is if John taking Mary back was a rouse to set her up somehow, but I'm not sure I believe that.

 

So, thoughts? 

  • Like 1
Posted

1. I always saw it Sherlock's attempt on comic relief, because the situation was so emotionally loaded and awkward at the same time. It made me think about the scene in the subway, when John thinks he's going to die and makes his little speech about how much he values his friend. I imagined John was expecting something similar but Sherlock just wanted to make him laugh - as I once wrote, for the first time making a joke to John and not about him. Which I thought was incredibly sweet and endearing. And I still see it that way, even after the Dreadful Subtext entered my innocent universe.

 

 

Another interesting snippets, especially that about a deleted scene...

http://finalproblem.tumblr.com/post/144125346860/chickens-ex-machina-i-know-a-lot-happened-in-his

http://finalproblem.tumblr.com/post/144120711045/sherlock-last-vow-deleted-section

  • Like 4
Posted

1. When I was watching the tarmac scene the first time, I assumed Sherlock was going to make a little speech about how lost he was before he met John, or something like that. Sort of like the speech John made at his grave. But I agree with JP, what he ended up saying was meant to relieve the tension between them.

 

2. I find it odd too. During HLV I just figured Sherlock had refused to identify his shooter, and Mycroft (and Lestrade too) was working on it but hadn't found anything out yet. But after TAB I'm inclined to think Mycroft knows all about Mary and for some reason unknown to us, chooses not to do anything about her. Whether he knew about her before or after she shot Sherlock is another point I wonder about.

 

I don't think Sherlock would participate in "setting her up", because of what it would do to his friendship with John. At least, I hope he's learned that lesson by now.

 

And Sherlock's already made it perfectly clear he thinks John is incapable of keeping secrets :smile: so I don't think John is part of any sort of "set up" either. Mycroft, on the other hand -- I think he's capable of just about anything. But if he wanted to get rid of Mary, I think he'd just do so.

  • Like 2
Posted

Will have a look at the links when I get home :)

 

I always read it as he intended to say something really serious, and then chickened out and went for a joke instead. I also wonder if John realised he was being sent to his death, I hope not or I would hope they would have a bit more of an emotional farewell, a hug or something at least. I get being reserved and 'stiff upper lip' but there is a limit, and your best friend being sent on a suicide mission would be well beyond. 

 

Also have to add: 

I don't get it when people say they don't find Mycroft scary, I find him scary for that exact reason, he seems like someone who could and would do absolutely anything, and I doubt there is even anyone who would be able to hold him accountable. 

  • Like 2
Posted

Regarding the tarmac scene and "something I've meant to tell you always but never have":  I watched this recently with my hubby, who is aware of the fan focus on this scene although not a real participant in the fandom.  He said something like, "that is clearly two guys trying to say that the friendship was important to them and failing to do so because they're guys."  He couldn't see anything romantic or even potentially romantic in the interaction. 

 

Frankly, neither can I.  I agree that Sherlock could easily have thought that he wanted to make a grand declaration of how much fun the past few years have been and how much they meant and then decided at the last second to try to lighten the mood because it was easier to laugh with John than to get too serious.

  • Like 4
Posted

IMO Sherlock looks too moved to be serious. :P

Again - the subway scene comes to mind, when he "cries" about John's fate.

If he was to say something deep and serious he would try to downplay it in some grumpy way. :)

  • Like 2
Posted

Will have a look at the links when I get home :)

 

I always read it as he intended to say something really serious, and then chickened out and went for a joke instead. I also wonder if John realised he was being sent to his death, I hope not or I would hope they would have a bit more of an emotional farewell, a hug or something at least. I get being reserved and 'stiff upper lip' but there is a limit, and your best friend being sent on a suicide mission would be well beyond.

 

Also have to add:

I don't get it when people say they don't find Mycroft scary, I find him scary for that exact reason, he seems like someone who could and would do absolutely anything, and I doubt there is even anyone who would be able to hold him accountable.

People doesn't find Mycroft scary because they understand how he think and that's safety on itself. He exudes an air of constant and reliable person, that's also a factor to consider. Had he behaves like Jim 'The Joker' Moriarty then yes, he would be scary to most.
  • Like 2
Posted

But unlike the subway scene he knows he actually is about to die, and genuinely won't ever see John again. He was shamming in the subway scene, but to do it when he knows this is the last time they'll be together... I don't know. Seems less likely to me. 

 

I think that's what makes Mycroft scary, that you would think him calm, polite and civilised but he could make a call and have you disappear any time he feels like. You expect it from Moriarty, Mycroft could lull you into a false sense of security so you never expect what's coming. 

  • Like 3
Posted

Lulling someone into a false sense of security is exactly what Moriarty had done. Molly Hooper, Sherlock Holmes, Kitty Riley and who else off screen. That actually a common method which both sides employ at times. The difference is, Mycroft is constrained by the limits of his influence while Moriarty is a loose cannon.

Posted

I hope he's constrained. He seems pretty omnipotent to me. I agree with Pseud, that's what makes him scary; he really IS the government, apparently. Hard to hold accountable.

Posted

The nature of the kind of influence that Mycroft most likely have is, he might be a coordinator and or overseer of many but he is not the one with real power. His is 'borrowed' and therefore he must ensure that he doesn't cross certain people if he wants to keep his current authority. Besides, you doesn't actually needs a bestowed title or role to be able to do things that should be beyond your scope. That's why official rank is not the end of all.

  • Like 1
Posted

Again, I hope so. I agree that would probably be the case in the real world, but in Sherlock world, I'm not so sure. Plus I think in either world, Mycroft could pull in a lot of favors. As can Sherlock, actually. They're both rather scary, come to think of it. Oh, the things those Holmes boys get away with ...... :smile:

  • Like 1
Posted

Seems likely to me Mycroft is the head of SIS, and who is above SIS I don't know. I'd guess it's technically the prime minister but I doubt that's true in reality. It's like in America, I doubt Obama really has that much control over the CIA since most of what they do is secret. 

  • Like 1
Posted

In CIA terms, Mycroft is more like a Super User than the real head of an intelligence agency, which would expose him to the public and come with a boatload of red tapes that would actually hinder him from doing his job. Above SIS is JIC.

  • Like 1
Posted

I wouldn't think Mycroft would be at the head of an organization but rather part of an elite group that overseas such organizations and pulls their strings.  In a way, he is invisible to the general public, and yet he is so high up in the government that he can come and go at Buckingham Palace and probably has tea with the Queen a few times a year.  He probably has her ear.  At least, that's my head canon.

  • Like 3
Posted

Perfect! :d

  • Like 1
Posted

The Consulting Government :lol:

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, that's exactly what he has been since the original Bruce-Partington plans: a clearing-house for all government dealings and decision-making! Will the esteemed fellow members please, please, please, read the original stories? *fuming*

And everybody seems to forget Lady Smallwood and her superior status as both Mycroft's political boss and Sherlock's actual client! He need only have texted her on the way to the aeroport, and the whole "Miss me" scheme could have been put in place, over and above Mycroft's head, and to lull Mary into a sense of false security.

Posted

But as you've pointed out yourself, Inge, Moftiss are not slaves to the original stories. So even if we do read them, it doesn't mean everything will work out the same in the TV show! (Wearing my "Ms. Logic" hat today! :d )

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh man... just noticed something else... when John is revealed at Leinster Gardens, he has been sitting in Sherlock's wheelchair from hospital.  Which means Wiggins got him him there.. or possibly John.

  • Like 2
Posted

OK, new theory (for me, anyway).

 

In ACD canon, Mary Morstan is left without the bulk of the Agra treasure, which essentially frees her up to marry Watson and become a very middle-class doctor's wife.  

 

What if John throwing the flash drive in the fire place is the analog of there being very little Agra treasure for the original Mary Morstan to deal with?  What if this is a parallel event to Sherlock "emptying the Appledore vaults" by shooting CAM?  Both events would accomplish the same purpose as the original actions in ACD canon, but in a more modern way.  So, by destroying most of Mary's AGRA "inheritance," John is resetting things to normal and allowing himself and Mary to move forward?

  • Like 4
Posted

Here's another little niggling thing about Molly being questioned regarding Sherlock's bolt holes - if Sherlock hadn't set it up with her that she might possibly be questioned, then why didn't she show more concern for his escape from hospital in his condition?  I realize he wasn't being cared for at Barts, but she would have been told he'd been shot and was critical.

  • Like 1
Posted

Here's another little niggling thing about Molly being questioned regarding Sherlock's bolt holes - if Sherlock hadn't set it up with her that she might possibly be questioned, then why didn't she show more concern for his escape from hospital in his condition?  I realize he wasn't being cared for at Barts, but she would have been told he'd been shot and was critical.

 

Depends on who questioned her?  What if Lestrade came by and, without telling her that Sherlock was on the lam, asked her for information about Sherlock's known bolt holes?  Sherlock still could have set her up at some point in the past to be ready for such a question, but she might not have to know exactly what was going on to answer the question calmly.

 

That, or, like one good fan fic I read suggested, maybe he escaped to her flat, maybe with her help, and she was the one that provided the initial medical assistance he needed to make the escape with a wheelchair and what looks to be some sort of saline drip but obviously no morphine and no visible central line.

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 99 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.