Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "His Last Vow"?  

157 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

 

 

 

Sherlolly isn't ever happening, even if I wish it was, and I'll be wishing until the credits role on the series finale.  What do you call the very final episode ever when you call every season a series?

 

 

That's what I've always heard it called here in the U.S.: a "series finale."  

 

 

 

Right, but BBC uses "series 1, 2, 3... " for Sherlock, right?   So what do they then call what we would call the series finale?

  • Like 1
Posted

I love Mycroft and Molly more than John.  

 

*hides from Carol*

 

Hey, everybody to their own taste!

Posted

It would be interesting if Molly picked up some of the "worrying about Sherlock" aspects of ACD Watson's character. 

 

 

I would like this aspect of your plan for Molly, except worrying about Sherlock seems to be such a full-time job I'm not sure where she'll fit in her job at Bart's! Your suggestion is also interesting because they seem to be developing Molly's character, and we don't know what happens to John next season. It could be the case that sometime soon Sherlock needs to be the one worrying about John, which might in turn alter things with him and Molly too.

 

 

I love Mycroft and Molly more than John. 

 

 

Season Three John was not my favourite, but I still love him, I just don't necessarily like some of what he does.

Posted

I do like that she was given Watson's lines, though. If the Sherlock writers were working for me, I'd have made them write John and Molly as two halves of the original Watson character deliberately. I'm not sure exactly what kind of shippers that would have created though.

I'm pretty sure I wouldn't want to know... :D

 

I don't know what to wish for ... as much as I love most of the other characters, the John & Sherlock relationship is at the core and I worry too much time spent with other characters will mean less time for us to watch the boys interact. I've already said many times that I felt like John was somewhat absent in S3, and I missed him. And also I really, really would like to see them interact with Lestrade again, like in Hounds. Drat.... what we really need is more episodes.... or longer ones!

  • Like 3
Posted

And also I really, really would like to see them interact with Lestrade again, like in Hounds.

Yes please!!

 

 

Drat.... what we really need is more episodes.... or longer ones!

Yes please!

 

Or just release the uncut HLV for the (time being).

Posted

More silver fox. In fact, make him the star of an episode ^^

Posted

 

I love Mycroft and Molly more than John.  

 

*hides from Carol*

 

Hey, everybody to their own taste!

 

 

So much for the forum throw down...  ;)

  • Like 2
Posted

Lestrade... silver fox... such a fitting name.  

Posted

When a young man with boyish face ages into a mature and sexy D.I. with his crown of smattering silver....

Posted

More silver fox. In fact, make him the star of an episode ^^

 

I vote for a new, direct-to-DVD, two-episode edition.  One episode is just "Clips from Lestrade's Phone."  The other is a 90-minute H/C special titled "Why It Took Sherlock 6 Months to Be Released from the Hospital in HLV."  

 

51ee5e755612457d4d6e1f4ee133c45d.jpg

  • Like 3
Posted

 

Why It Took Sherlock 6 Months to Be Released from the Hospital in HLV.

Because he kept running away and breaking down after few hours, so he must have been reanimated and sewn together anew each time?

 

But it weren't six months. It was 3 months after the wedding and the wedding was some time in May/June :P

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

Why It Took Sherlock 6 Months to Be Released from the Hospital in HLV.

Because he kept running away and breaking down after few hours, so he must have been reanimated and sewn together anew each time?

 

But it weren't six months. It was 3 months after the wedding and the wedding was some time in May/June :P

 

 

OK, for the sake of argument:  (Because what else do we have to do until the Special?) How do you explain Mummy's comment that "Sherlock is home from hospital" on Christmas day?  Although that doesn't specify a date, it sort of implies that his release was relatively recent.  I agree with the wedding being in May (I think that's what the invitation said), but I'm not sure how to get him released from hospital in August.

 

Regardless, I'm totally up for a third episode from the perspective of the doctors, nurses, and therapists, called "How We Survived Six (Three?) Months of Sherlock Holmes."

  • Like 1
Posted

Argh... today is one of those days... I meant Sherlock was shot after 3 months from the wedding... but now I realize that I have no proof, I think I read a timeline made by a fan once, when the shooting was in September... Anyway, this would make ca. 3 months of hospital. Which still seems quite long time.

Posted

Do we ever know for certain what hospital Sherlock is at?  

Posted

Nope, no i.d. of the hospital as far as I know.

 

On one of the commentaries (TSo3, I think?) there is a comment implying that the May date for the wedding was not consistent with what actually occurred -- or something like that. At any rate, John's blog has the wedding in August and I'm inclined to think that's what they intended ... simply because an August wedding makes more sense with the rest of the timeline.

 

In the episode itself John states that he hasn't seen Sherlock for a month, and somehow or another isn't it inferred that's how long they've been back from their honeymoon? So that would put the shooting in mid-late September.

 

That's still about 3 months in hospital, though. That IS a long time.

Posted

 

Because he kept running away and breaking down after few hours, so he must have been reanimated and sewn together anew each time?

 

 

And don't forget that the doctors have to restart his heart every time.

It's not an easy task as he keeps it well hidden, also, the doctors must have been reliably informed that he doesn't have one as well.

 

:)

  • Like 1
Posted

Argh... today is one of those days... I meant Sherlock was shot after 3 months from the wedding... but now I realize that I have no proof, I think I read a timeline made by a fan once, when the shooting was in September... Anyway, this would make ca. 3 months of hospital. Which still seems quite long time.

 

Well, any way you work that timeline and whatever "fact" you use as your anchor point to figure things out from, he was still in the hospital for a ton of time.  

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

Why It Took Sherlock 6 Months to Be Released from the Hospital in HLV.

Because he kept running away and breaking down after few hours, so he must have been reanimated and sewn together anew each time?

 

But it weren't six months. It was 3 months after the wedding and the wedding was some time in May/June :P

 

 

I maintain it was a six-month recovery.  The wedding, according to the invitation, was May 18.  The next time reference we get was when John says at the beginning of HLV that he hadn't seen Sherlock in at least a month.  Now, is that a month from the wedding?  If so, that makes it mid-late June.  Even before he escaped from Hospital Janine remarked over his injuries that he wouldn't be working for a long time, and a long time isn't 3 months.  To make matters worse, he DID escape from hospital and made his injuries much worse, thus lengthening his recovery process.  The next time frame we get is Christmas.  Whether this is an actual time line or not, they are the only points of reference we have.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

 

Why It Took Sherlock 6 Months to Be Released from the Hospital in HLV.

Because he kept running away and breaking down after few hours, so he must have been reanimated and sewn together anew each time?

 

But it weren't six months. It was 3 months after the wedding and the wedding was some time in May/June :P

 

 

I maintain it was a six-month recovery.  The wedding, according to the invitation, was May 18.  The next time reference we get was when John says at the beginning of HLV that he hadn't seen Sherlock in at least a month.  Now, is that a month from the wedding?  If so, that makes it mid-late June.  Even before he escaped from Hospital Janine remarked over his injuries that he wouldn't be working for a long time, and a long time isn't 3 months.  To make matters worse, he DID escape from hospital and made his injuries much worse, thus lengthening his recovery process.  The next time frame we get is Christmas.  Whether this is an actual time line or not, they are the only points of reference we have.

 

 

I tend to agree.  I do think there's a little bit of wiggle room on the release-from-hospital end, in that you could argue that he got out sometime in November and that still feels like something that just happened to his mother, especially if Christmas is the first time she saw him since he got out.  

 

I do think three months is a long time to be in hospital, but I lean toward the entire recovery being six with most of it hospitalized.  But any way you slice it, our hero did himself some major damage with his little escape trick!  :-)

  • Like 1
Posted

Or just release the uncut HLV for the (time being).

 

The rumored 5.5-hour cut of HLV appears to have been a misunderstanding.  The finished episode is 1.5 hours, and they just about always film several takes per scene -- 5.5 hours of film would be a bit under four takes, on average.  (And the HLV audio commentary on the DVD says that their rough cut of the episode was just about the right length, right off the bat.)  Sorry!

 

On one of the commentaries (TSo3, I think?) there is a comment implying that the May date for the wedding was not consistent with what actually occurred -- or something like that. At any rate, John's blog has the wedding in August and I'm inclined to think that's what they intended ....

 

Hey, what they intended doesn't count!  :P  If it's not in the finished episode, it's not canon -- especially if it contradicts what was explicitly said or shown in the episode (e.g., the invitation).  And John's blog has other apparent date inconsistencies (e.g., as Julia Mae has pointed out, Sherlock and John really can't have met at Baker Street, London, at 7 pm on January 30th in broad daylight).

  • Like 2
Posted

Yeah, yeah, yeah ... :tongue:(<--- that's the closest I can get to a raspberry....)
 
Do they have rehab hospitals in Britain?

Posted

Do they have rehab hospitals in Britain?

 

I assume you mean for Sherlock to have spent however many months in?  They're bound to have something to serve that general purpose, regardless of what they may call it.  Assuming they could have gotten him to stay put in one of those, any more than he was staying put in a regular hospital.

Posted

Well, yes, they must have facilities, but what I mean is, are they called hospitals?

 

I guess it doesn't really matter, because I just having real trouble believing Sherlock was in hospital (even rehab) for 3 months, let alone 6.

 

Occams' Razor -- the simplest answer is, they goofed on the time frame.

Posted

Well, Sherlock would not have actually been in hospital for a six-month heal.  Hospitals move their patients out as quickly as it is safe to do so.  So likely Sherlock would have been moved to a physical rehab center to complete his recovery.

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, yes, they must have facilities, but what I mean is, are they called hospitals?

 

I guess it doesn't really matter, because I just having real trouble believing Sherlock was in hospital (even rehab) for 3 months, let alone 6.

 

Occams' Razor -- the simplest answer is, they goofed on the time frame.

 

That may be the simplest real-world explanation, but I'd like to find the simplest in-universe explanation.

 

He was literally at death's door to begin with.  (Also, seems clear that he's by no means a model patient.  We've actually seen him over-exert himself to the point of starting to bleed internally again.)  Alex and I know a young woman who suddenly and unexpectedly collapsed from a heart attack.  Someone trained in CPR happened to be right there at the time and was able to revive her, so her case was somewhat similar to Sherlock's.  She was in the initial hospital for a couple of months, and then in a different facility for intensive therapy for several more months.  So I don't find it at all unrealistic that Sherlock could have been in various health-care facilities for as long as six months.  (And Mummy may simply refer to the overall experience as "being in the hospital.")

 

Now, I'm going to assume that the wedding really was on May 18th, as shown in the episode.  At some later time, Kate shows up at the Watsons' door, and Mary says that John hasn't seen Sherlock in about a month.  Obviously they saw each other at the wedding, so it's now at least mid-June -- but it could be considerably later (if they've seen each other since the wedding, but then not recently).  Things seem to go along pretty quickly from that point till Sherlock is shot, so from the shooting until Christmas is presumably no longer than six months -- but could be considerably less.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.