Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Theaters are supposed to be the same day as well. Just don't have the US listings yet.

  • Like 1
Posted

And US Amazon still has the DVD release date as January 12 (UK Amazon still isn't saying).

 

So they've answered most of the date questions -- at least if you live in the UK or the US.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

All of which makes perfect sense! Premiere on the 1st of the month, encore on the 10th, DVD release on the 12th. After all, that thing has been in the can for several months already! And the only "abominable" reference I could find is in the Musgrave Ritual, the celebrated indoors shooting incident notwithstanding, when Sherlock Holmes tells Dr Watson of some of his past cases, namely, Ricoletti of the club foot and his abominable wife in the same sentence as the aluminium crutch story. :D

  • Like 2
Posted

Abominable Bride... Doesn't seem like the usual pun on an original story title, but I will go over my collection to make sure.

 

It does kinda recall Mary, though, doesn't it... Not that the poor character is abominable, but she's the only bride we have ever had much to do with on Sherlock and she did prove to be something of an unpleasant surprise...

  • Like 2
Posted

only available in Britain? Boo!

Posted

only available in Britain? Boo!

 

Nope, the BBC took it down due to copyright infringement, so presumably not available (from that site) even in the UK now.

 

It worked... :blink:

Try HERE

And then try this – but put away your cuppa first! :D

 

First one didn't work for me either.

 

Second one -- love it!  More BAMF John!  :applause:

 

(Can anyone make out the last few words of John's reply -- "... while [something]"?)

  • Like 1
Posted

New pictures

 

The white building - it's Diogenes Club isn't it?

 

Yup, sure looks like it (cf. Sherlockology's photos).

 

And gotta love the Paget-esque picture in the railway carriage -- they just couldn't resist!  :D

Posted

 

 

I can break every bone in your body while naming them

 

 

 

Even better!   :bouncy:   (And thanks for using a spoiler box.)

Posted

It worked... :blink:

Try HERE

And then try this – but put away your cuppa first! :D

 

Wait a minute -- what did it say at the end of that second one?  "In cinemas 2nd January 2016"  So apparently we get to see it on TV first, then on the big screen the next day (which is a Saturday)?  Cool!

 

Added:  Nope, the 2nd is the Australian cinema date.

 

J.P., are (were?) those two different videos?

  • Like 1
Posted

Yes, the first video is a bit extended version of the first one. Maybe just try to google it - it's from... eh, today? Or was it yesterday? My obsession makes strange things to my brain.

Posted

Found it, I think, or at least a trailer that was posted just yesterday -- here it is on the official PBS YouTube page.  Like the BBC, they're doing the premiere on the 1st and a rerun on the 10th.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

In mine it says in theatres on January 2nd, and I truly hope Mark Gatiss didn't write the line uttered by Dr Watson, because Victorians were Precriptivists to a fault, he's supposed to be reasonably well educated, so he would say :"I can break every bone in your body while naming IT" since 'each' and 'every' take a verb in the singular and the dependent pronouns must follow suit!

And what is that whole sequence about when Sherlock actually freezes all action and they are shown as a set within a larger set?

  • Like 2
Posted

Mind thingy, like the scene with Irene Adler in the field. Someone used misspelled(?) name Mind Place and I actually like it a lot.

 

 

'each' and 'every' take a verb in the singular and the dependent pronouns must follow suit!

 

And how is it now? This always confused me.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

'each' and 'every' take a verb in the singular and the dependent pronouns must follow suit!

 

And how is it now? This always confused me.

 

I believe that's another of those pedantic "here's how the language ought to work" rules.  Fortunately, we who actually speak it are still free to phrase things in the way they're usually said.  ;)

 

Added:  ... or should that be "in the ways they're usually said"?  :D

 

  • Like 2
Posted

It worked... :blink:

Try HERE

And then try this – but put away your cuppa first! :D

 

Wait a minute -- what did it say at the end of that second one?  "In cinemas 2nd January 2016"  So apparently we get to see it on TV first, then on the big screen the next day (which is a Saturday)?  Cool!

 

On the other hand :huh: the BBC website says this:

 

A special episode of Sherlock is to be screened in more than 100 UK cinemas at the same time as it is seen on BBC One.

 

Fans will get to see Sherlock: The Abominable Bride, a one-off episode set in London in 1895, on New Year's Day.

 

The episode will also be broadcast on PBS in the US on the same day as its UK transmission for the first time.

 

... and I see that the second video (above) was posted from Australia.  Darn!  Apparently we (in the US and UK) do need to juggle both television and theater on the same day.  I just hope they don't have them literally simultaneously, because I'd really like to see it both times.  Of course, I don't recall that anyone has yet said what day the US theater showing will be, so maybe there's hope yet.

  • Like 1
Posted

This may be good news for some of you:

 

Sherlock: The Abominable Bride, a 90-minute special, will premiere Friday, January 1, 2016, on MASTERPIECE Mystery! on PBS at 9:00pm ET, and simultaneously online at pbs.org/masterpiece. The special will have an encore broadcast on Sunday, January 10, at 10:00pm ET.

 

I don't know whether PBS limits their streaming video to people in the US or not (and have no way of testing that myself).

 

That page also has a slightly different, longer trailer than any I've been able to watch so far (apparently the one I'd been unable to play earlier, judging by the surrealistic Mind Palace scene), and I'm very pleased to hear Holmes actually say

 

 

"Come, Watson, come -- the game is afoot!"

 

 

I also love that scene with Lestrade, who reminds me very much of Colin Jeavons' "Lestrayd" in the Brett series.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Quibbling aside, I definitely dislike this version of Dr Watson! In less than two minutes he bullies Sherlock Holmes twice, once with the army doctor prouncement, right-in-your-face attitude, and in the sequence of "wear the d****** hat", which, I reiterate, reminds me of the Michael Caine film, where the good doctor was the crime solver and Holmes was an out-of-work drunken actor!
By Heaven, if they manage to let down all the fandom and realise our worst fears as to its quality, then the materialisation of S4 will become more than problematic, given the controversy over BBC licensing fees!
The seventh art is a very fickle mistress, after all! Not that I would particularly mind seeing Mr Moffat end up with egg on his face, the duplicitous, cunning master puppeteer! Over the years, [in my opinion] he has proven time and again that he is not a Holmes fan, just a talented scriptwriter with the ability to sell his ideas, for which we fall! The proverb goes, fool me once... : he has fooled the fandom repeatedly! What does that say about us?

  • Like 1
Posted

Basically, it says that we are Sherlock addicts, never mind lowering the quality over the years, not paying attention to proper British English, since he is so quintessentially a British character, following their fancies and having an eye on the bottom line, namely putting bums on seats! Over here the cinema screening is on January 2, I only need to book in time! Moriarty would say: well, good luck with that!

Posted

I truly hope Mark Gatiss didn't write the line uttered by Dr Watson, because Victorians were Precriptivists to a fault, he's supposed to be reasonably well educated, so he would say :"I can break every bone in your body while naming IT" since 'each' and 'every' take a verb in the singular and the dependent pronouns must follow suit!

... not paying attention to proper British English, since he is so quintessentially a British character, ....

 

I can think of two pretty significant reasons why it's actually preferable to avoid being too pedantic:

 

1.  Victorians didn't necessarily talk the way they wrote.  Yes, they appear to have been pretty stuffy folks, judging by their written works.  But everyone I've ever known (except for my Aunt Bernice) writes more formally than they converse, and I'm willing to bet the same was true of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.  Even though Doctor Watson surely knew very well to say "it" in school, he presumably spoke less formally in less formal circumstances.  If that weren't true of most people, Chaucer's double negative and split infinitive would have died out long ago!

 

2.  Sherlock has a 21st-century audience.  Even if the dialog in Conan Doyle's stories actually was accurate for his era (which I doubt), it nevertheless sounds very stilted to our ears, and would make the characters seem "stagy."  Since Moftiss want their characters to sound lifelike (in whatever century), they very logically write their dialog in a more relaxed way than Sir Arthur did.

 

Quibbling aside, I definitely dislike this version of Dr Watson! In less than two minutes he bullies Sherlock Holmes twice, once with the army doctor prouncement, right-in-your-face attitude, and in the sequence of "wear the d****** hat", ....

 

But "bullying" (as you put it) is Watson's job -- and has been all along!  Conan Doyle's Watson was forever despairing of Holmes's personal habits, and made no bones about it.

  • Like 2
Posted

Just saw the extended trailer, and, on first viewing at least, I really like Watson and I really dislike Holmes!  

 

For me, MF has (perhaps) done something really interesting with the Watson character.  Instead of playing "Victorian ACD Watson," it looks to me like he's playing "what John would be like if he lived in the Victorian era."  That's a subtle difference, but I think I can see it coming through there.  I feel like we're going to learn something about John's psyche even though we're probably going to argue for a year about whether this episode is canon to the series and then whether the additional 20 minutes in the cinema are canon to the episode!

 

I hate to say it, but I'm not sure I'm on board with what BC has done with Holmes here.  I've tried to stay away from commentary and even from most of setlock because I didn't really want to form an opinion, but I figured the trailers were fair game.  From this little snippet, Holmes seems to have a very flat affect that's foreign to our Sherlock and not even the same layered disdain and wit that floated below the relatively flat affect of Brett.  I'm a little worried that I'm not much going to like this Holmes.

  • Like 2
Posted

THIS Holmes is going to be a pastiche made up of the leftovers of things like the Rathbone films, The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes and even Sherlock Holmes's Younger Brother: in short, of everything but the kitchen sink! It will be long on effects and dramatic situations, emotionally charged music, mesmerising backdrops and a whole load of hogwash in terms of plot and storyline!

As for Dr Watson, in ACD, he took a much more distanced view of his friend's antics, which was reflected in his sporadic visits and his infrequent messages, but who stood in awe of Holmes, even when the latter had overdone it with taxing his iron constitution or indulged in one of his less salubrious habits. It was always Holmes the master (ful) and Dr Watson the loyal acolyte. Definitely not this version. How much of a love-hate relationship does Mr Moffat have with his childhood reading material, anyway?

Could someone change the thread's title, since we now have definite dates?

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 99 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.