Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

This is probably something obvious I'm overlooking, but why did Sherlock kill Magnussen anyway? He would have been taken into Mycroft's custody, so presumably Mycroft would be the person who primarily gets the information and decides what to share and what to suppress (assuming Magnussen deigns to tell him anything at all). We find out Mycroft was either already aware of or just not bothered by Mary's past. He is an ally of Lady Smallwood, but the truth of the letters is already moot since her husband has committed suicide. If the assumption is that Mycroft couldn't have detained Magnussen because the set-up with the laptop didn't work then Moftiss have a great deal more confidence in the limitations of government than I do. If someone at Mycroft's level decided to incarcerate someone to silence them he could invent charges to stick easily. If it was simple to clear Sherlock, by falsifying the video footage, inventing charges, and even creating false footage to back them up, would be even easier. 

 

It's because Magnussen is powerful as well. He himself tells Sherlock that he's the only person in the country that's more powerful than Mycroft.

 

Magnussen uses blackmail to get politicians, intelligence officers etc to get him to do whatever he wants.

 

If Mycroft refuses to publish the story of Sherlock attempting to sell government secrets then Magnussen could have started blackmailing all the politicians and everyone else in MI6 to convince Mycroft to do so.

 

Also Mycroft also tells Sherlock when they're at their parents cottage that sometimes Magnussen is an ally to the British government. That implies that sometimes Magnussen helps the British government by blackmailing their foreign enemies.

 

Mycroft just won't be allowed to do whatever he wants with Magnussen. He needs a good reason first.

  • Like 1
Posted

He wouldn't have been able to blackmail Mycroft or any other officials if Mycroft had put him away. It's not like Sherrinford would have been the only off the grid prison, Magnussen could easily have been 'disappeared,' they could have faked his death since that's something that's apparently so easy it's been done four times on the show already. 

Posted

He wouldn't have been able to blackmail Mycroft or any other officials if Mycroft had put him away. It's not like Sherrinford would have been the only off the grid prison, Magnussen could easily have been 'disappeared,' they could have faked his death since that's something that's apparently so easy it's been done four times on the show already. 

 

It depends. 

 

What's scary about Magnussen is that he keeps all the compromising secrets in his Mind Palace. Ideally he can blackmail people anywhere.

 

I think this may be a possibility:  

 

If Mycroft or his men tried to apprehend Magnussen then he could start yelling out their secrets. Even if his words don't reach the press they'll still be able to reach other figures of authority if he can cause enough confusion, dissent and distrust among Mycroft's men. Mycroft and his men could then get into trouble.

 

We don't really see much of Magnussen's blackmailing so I'm not sure of all the specifics. I'm not sure if he needs to publish secrets in the press in order for his blackmails to have weight. It may be possible that simply revealing secrets to certain figures of authority is enough to make his blackmails effective.

 

Also remember Mycroft said this about Magnussen:

 

 

MYCROFT: He never causes too much damage to anyone important. He’s far too intelligent for that. He’s a business-man, that’s all, and occasionally useful to us. A necessary evil – not a dragon for you to slay.

 

 

This implies that despite their dislike of Magnussen, the British government sometimes made use of him. i'm guessing they sometimes got him to give them secrets about their enemies. So Magnussen is an important figure. He isn't someone Mycroft can just imprison in order to save Sherlock.

 

Additionally Mycroft always says he's not the sentimental type and I think Sherlock mostly believed him when he said that. It would be wishful thinking for Sherlock to believe that Mycroft was going to stop Magnussen just to rescue him.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Hm, I don't know I just have faith (or lack of faith in integrity of those in power) that it is easy to shut people up if needed. Mycroft showing up with a load of agents in helicopters was meant to be a big dramatic show, however a couple of agents in a black ops style mission could have got into Magnussen's house and taken him out or kidnapped him. The fact he keeps everything in his head means there's no actual proof, his blackmail power comes from publishing things that the public will believe whether they are true or not, if he can't publish any of his information a big part of that power is neutralised. 

I bet CAM knew about CS, I wonder if he ever tried to blackmail him?

Posted

Hm, I don't know I just have faith (or lack of faith in integrity of those in power) that it is easy to shut people up if needed. Mycroft showing up with a load of agents in helicopters was meant to be a big dramatic show, however a couple of agents in a black ops style mission could have got into Magnussen's house and taken him out or kidnapped him. 

 

Sherlock is the one who pulls the trigger in the end so you have to consider it from his perspective.

 

Do you think that Sherlock believes that Mycroft will go through this much trouble just to keep him safe? I don't think so.

 

Also Sherlock has a massive inferiority complex and probably doesn't like being saved by Mycroft all the time. I could understand him wanting to keep the situation in his own hands.

 

 

 

I bet CAM knew about CS, I wonder if he ever tried to blackmail him?

 

I suspect they got along great. I doubt they ever got into a conflict with each other.

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't know, he's a very rich and famous man with a very big secret, seems a shame not to use it.  :evil: Mmm, he looks warm and cosy, I'm currently freezing my arse off. 

Posted (edited)

Posting for the first time in this forum, though i have lurked here for a long time. I have seen many people say here and on other sites how much they are disappointed in John in this season. I don't deny he has done some pretty sh***y things including the beating but i won't say i am disappointed in him. For one, i do not buy some of the character arcs he has this season such as the cheating thing which just felt tacked on. I blame poor writing for why it is difficult this season to relate with John. We did not get any insight into his feelings or thought process in TST to help us understand his behavior.

 

John beating Sherlock was difficult to watch just as it was difficult for me to see Sherlock manipulate John into forgiving him in TEH, or make him the subject of his experiments in the Hound. In real world, the actions of both would be difficult to forgive. But this is fiction and we are to assume fictional people have higher tolerance to being punched, manipulated, shot etc. and that's why despite everything J & S forgive each other. Also to note John beating him in such a way is such a one-off thing which probably will never occur and only happened when John was under such emotional turmoil. Have you all never done anything truly awful when you are under immense trauma?

 

People have also pointed out how much Sherlock does for John but you seemed to have forgotten how much John has to deal with being Sherlock’s friend. He gets experimented on, is left out in all the important decisions, gets yelled at. Throughout the show until TLD, Sherlock either makes fun of John’s feelings or ignores him. Sherlock so rudely left him behind to get a taxi for himself in TST. And all that’s forgiven because he is a genius trying to solve a crime, a sociopath who doesn’t really understand emotions. Why isn’t the fandom just as understanding about John’s behavior as they are with Sherlock’s? All the criticism about John being angry at Sherlock but you ignore the reason why he is angry in the first place which is almost always at what Sherlock has done. Surely John deserves to be appreciated for standing by Sherlock through most of their friendship except after Mary died which was the only time he has ever been truly angry at him. And even then he agrees to accompany Sherlock when the latter asks him.

 

I am not trying to put Sherlock down, I understand why Sherlock does what he does but I also think John is allowed to show his frustration with Sherlock now and then and not be villanised for it.

Edited by Arcadia
Pale text is nearly invisible against the white background of certain Themes and small font size was too
  • Like 1
Posted

Posting for the first time in this forum, though i have lurked here for a long time. I have seen many people say here and on other sites how much they are disappointed in John in this season. I don't deny he has done some pretty sh***y things including the beating but i won't say i am disappointed in him. For one, i do not buy some of the character arcs he has this season such as the cheating thing which just felt tacked on. I blame poor writing for why it is difficult this season to relate with John. We did not get any insight into his feelings or thought process in TST to help us understand his behavior.

 

John beating Sherlock was difficult to watch just as it was difficult for me to see Sherlock manipulate John into forgiving him in TEH, or make him the subject of his experiments in the Hound. In real world, the actions of both would be difficult to forgive. But this is fiction and we are to assume fictional people have higher tolerance to being punched, manipulated, shot etc. and that's why despite everything J & S forgive each other. Also to note John beating him in such a way is such a one-off thing which probably will never occur and only happened when John was under such emotional turmoil. Have you all never done anything truly awful when you are under immense trauma?

 

People have also pointed out how much Sherlock does for John but you seemed to have forgotten how much John has to deal with being Sherlock’s friend. He gets experimented on, is left out in all the important decisions, gets yelled at. Throughout the show until TLD, Sherlock either makes fun of John’s feelings or ignores him. Sherlock so rudely left him behind to get a taxi for himself in TST. And all that’s forgiven because he is a genius trying to solve a crime, a sociopath who doesn’t really understand emotions. Why isn’t the fandom just as understanding about John’s behavior as they are with Sherlock’s? All the criticism about John being angry at Sherlock but you ignore the reason why he is angry in the first place which is almost always at what Sherlock has done. Surely John deserves to be appreciated for standing by Sherlock through most of their friendship except after Mary died which was the only time he has ever been truly angry at him. And even then he agrees to accompany Sherlock when the latter asks him.

 

I am not trying to put Sherlock down, I understand why Sherlock does what he does but I also think John is allowed to show his frustration with Sherlock now and then and not be villanised for it.

Welcome to the forum! :welcome:

 

Yes, Sherlock has certainly behaved very badly towards John in previous seasons (I still think the fake suicide was the worst). I think most fans let him get away with it, so to speak, because they presume he doesn't know any better. John on the other hand has been widely regarded as a moral figure, a Good Man, and so it shocks people more when he acts not good.

 

I've never seen him that way so his character development this season bothered me much less. Personally, I liked the bit with the cheating, I found it totally believable and I think it fits into the story because it serves as yet another reason for why his grieving process is so tough - he wasn't at peace with Mary or himself when she died, so it's even harder for him to let go and come to terms with his loss. Also, it was a much needed example, in my opinion, of why John isn't perfect. And it illustrates his point about Mary believing him to be better than he is because, as far as he knew at least, she would never have suspected him of having an affair.

 

I am not so sure. I think Mary might have noticed something but it probably wasn't a huge deal for her. After all, it was just texting and it was over fast.

Posted

 

I guess what's eating me is not so much John's motivation for saving Sherlock and whether it should be credited to Mary or not, but the possibility that he might not have saved him at all. 

 

I believe it was written this way to make Mary the all knowing saint. Until now we had never any reason to believe John would not go and save Sherlock immediately if he thought Sherlock was in danger. Watch ASIP, TGG, TAB etc for the many times John rushes to save Sherlock. It's in keeping with Moftiss' head canon that Mary is apparently the glue that holds their friendship together. The side effect of that is we are now made to question John's loyalty towards Sherlock. 

Posted

 

Have you all never done anything truly awful when you are under immense trauma?

 

Not to the extent of beating someone up, no. Not kicking someone when they are lying on the floor bleeding. I hated the manipulated forgiveness in TEH too, I thought that was close to unforgivable and no way should John have laughed about it, but the beating just gives me a very visceral reaction, to the extent it actually surprises me, and I can't forgive it.

 

I do think the affair is in-keeping with John's character. It was a shitty thing to do, but at the same time I wasn't all that surprised - he hardly seemed like a guy who would be happy with a typical life, though it was what he seemed to think he wanted. Also, it was just texts.

 

The main reason I think the reaction to John is different to the reaction to Sherlock is as Toby said John was the moral, good character. He was the one guiding Sherlock into being more human - chastising him when he is unnecessarily harsh, forcing him into being more polite. John may have had a violent streak, but it was usually directed more towards protecting Sherlock. It was expected that John would always be Sherlock's defender, not his attacker.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Welcome to the forum! :welcome:

 

Yes, Sherlock has certainly behaved very badly towards John in previous seasons (I still think the fake suicide was the worst). I think most fans let him get away with it, so to speak, because they presume he doesn't know any better. John on the other hand has been widely regarded as a moral figure, a Good Man, and so it shocks people more when he acts not good.

 

I've never seen him that way so his character development this season bothered me much less. Personally, I liked the bit with the cheating, I found it totally believable and I think it fits into the story because it serves as yet another reason for why his grieving process is so tough - he wasn't at peace with Mary or himself when she died, so it's even harder for him to let go and come to terms with his loss. Also, it was a much needed example, in my opinion, of why John isn't perfect. And it illustrates his point about Mary believing him to be better than he is because, as far as he knew at least, she would never have suspected him of having an affair.

 

I am not so sure. I think Mary might have noticed something but it probably wasn't a huge deal for her. After all, it was just texting and it was over fast.

 

 

 

 

Thanks for the welcome, Toby.

 

The thing about cheating is that though I understand he needs to be given flaws, it was disappointing to see him having such as common ordinary joe kind flaws. I mean Sherlock has this traumatic childhood experience to explain his 'sociopathy', Mary has some badass cool backstory, but John is given this lame mid life crisis type arc. John is ordinary only in the sense he does not have great genius skills and is a much more compelling and interesting character than this . Someone on this thread mentioned how we no longer know what does John brings to the show. He is supposed to be the emotional and moral figure but it seems like Moftiss do not just want Sherlock to be the intellectual superior to John they want him to be morally superior as well.

 

 

 

 

 

Posted

 

The main reason I think the reaction to John is different to the reaction to Sherlock is as Toby said John was the moral, good character. He was the one guiding Sherlock into being more human - chastising him when he is unnecessarily harsh, forcing him into being more polite. John may have had a violent streak, but it was usually directed more towards protecting Sherlock. It was expected that John would always be Sherlock's defender, not his attacker. 

 

 

Tbh John isn't as good as he portrays himself to be.

 

He has pretty dark interests. Sherlock pointed this out to him in His Last Vow when he said the reason why John chose Mary is because she was an assassin. John chose Sherlock as his best friend because Sherlock was a wannabe sociopath and wanted to partake in his adventurous life. John joined the army because he wanted adventure. John couldn't stand the peaceful honeymoon life so he went to a drug den and attacked a junkie (yes I know it was self defense but John went there looking for trouble).

 

John's dark side isn't something he can control. It needs to feed off dark and dangerous situations on a regular basis or it starts to negatively affect John e.g. his psychometric leg injury in A Study in Pink after returning from war. 

 

In The Lying Detective, John hadn't been on an adventure for weeks since he had a falling out with Sherlock after Mary's death. His dark side had boiled up so I can see it exploding in that moment and see John taking all his frustration out on Sherlock.

 

It's not like John hasn't done very dark things in his past. In A Scandal in Belgravia, he told Sherlock that when he was in the army he actually killed people despite being a doctor.

 

So I think it's in character for John to beat up Sherlock harshly. 

Posted

Welcome to the forum, mishab! Good to have you join the debate.

  • Like 1
Posted

Posting for the first time in this forum, though i have lurked here for a long time.

Welcome to the forum, mishab! :welcome: Glad you've finally come inside!

 

I won't say i am disappointed in [John]. For one, i do not buy some of the character arcs he has this season....

I have always contended that Moftiss doesn't really understand John. For example, I don't think he craves danger or seeks out dangerous people (as expounded incessantly by Moftiss and mentioned here a few posts ago). As you may have heard me say while you were lurking, I think he's merely not afraid of them, and therefore does not actively avoid them the way most people do. He barged into the drug den, not because he was seeking danger, but rather because Mary's friend had asked him to rescue her son. As a doctor he's concerned for Isaac's health, and as a soldier he's not afraid to go there.

 

John beating [sherlock] in such a way is such a one-off thing which probably will never occur and only happened when John was under such emotional turmoil. Have you all never done anything truly awful when you are under immense trauma?

Thank you! I get it that people hold John to a higher moral standard than they do Sherlock -- but that doesn't mean he never snaps. We all have our limits. God knows I've encountered mine a few times. (I do feel that was one instance where the writing could have shown a tad more restraint, though. ;) )

  • Like 1
Posted

For some reason I just turned that around in my mind, and I find the idea of Sherlock kicking John like that far more out of character and horrifying. Why is that?

 

To answer my own question, I guess it's because Sherlock's always been shown to have iron control over his emotions, and also less tendency to hold other people accountable. So it's harder for me to imagine him taking out his frustrations that way. Which kind of casts John's "positive" qualities of caring and responsibility in a new light, doesn't it? If he hadn't cared so much, if he weren't so invested in placing blame, he would have had more control of himself.

 

But then he wouldn't have been our John. A two-sided sword, these emotion thingies.

 

 

Have you all never done anything truly awful when you are under immense trauma?


Not to the extent of beating someone up, no.

Me neither. But then I've never been in the situation John's been in either.

 

For some reason, I feel compelled to say that just because I understand John's behavior, that doesn't mean I condone it or find it acceptable. I think we're meant to be horrified by it. This is John at his lowest low (I hope!) and it ain't a pretty sight.

 

But I think it's also an example of Moffat's writing at its best; using exaggerated fictional situations to illustrate something real and true about our own world. In this case, that even the best of us have a monster inside, and this is what can happen if you let it get out. So don't let it get out.

 

Which is why (sorry! This is how my brain works!) the end of HLV still upsets me. Yes, it's fiction, it's exaggerated ... but it still puts up a mirror to the real world. And in the case of HLV, I don't think we're supposed to be horrified by Sherlock's action, I think we're supposed to cheer it. And that's not something I want to see happening in the real world. Even though it probably does, and more often than I would like to think. :(

  • Like 1
Posted

Au contraire, I don't think we're supposed to cheer when Sherlock shoots Magnussen. He saw that he could not beat Magnussen with his intellect. He had lost. So he cheated. He kicked over the chessboard.

 

It's a victory only in the sense that he keeps Magnussen from winning, and that's what does make me want to cheer just a bit. The slimy bastard thought he had Sherlock cornered, and so he did. But he still didn't win.

 

Sherlock saw that he couldn't beat Magnussen by winning, so he sacrificed his own integrity to beat him by losing.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

 And in the case of HLV, I don't think we're supposed to be horrified by Sherlock's action, I think we're supposed to cheer it. And that's not something I want to see happening in the real world. Even though it probably does, and more often than I would like to think. :(

 

In terms of real world politics, what Sherlock did to Magnussen can be summed up as:

 

YcQT4OI.gif

Posted

Can somebody give me examples of John as a moral compass? Because I see him more like helping Sherlock to behave and better blend into the world of goldfish. His most important influence in my eyes, is his presence in Sherlock's life, the fact, that he was willing to give his life for his friend (TGG). This was the mean reason why Sherlock changed, not what John did or did not.

 

Maybe it's because I clearly see John as a war veteran, which (after seeing and reading a lot of stuff about this issue in my younger years) automatically means someone with a dark side and lot of "luggage" to carry around, someone in deep trouble. I never saw him as fluffy and nice as most people seem to think, because he is small, round and hobbity.

 

So the morgue scene wasn't a surprise, even if I don't say it was right.

Plus you have to remember that Sherlock snapped as well. He was about to kill a person, who - although despicable as hell - in John's eyes was still innocent. It was clear that Sherlock lost the touch with reality. He was a dangerous junkie. Maybe it triggered another inner program in John: If there is a dangerous person around, and you have nothing else but your hands as defence, you better make him unable to move. The same happened to poor Wiggins, btw.

 

I'm not defending him. I'm trying to understand. (Understand a completely fictional person, written by two different guys who don't even seem to have one consistent idea about their character - what does it say about me? :huh: )

  • Like 2
Posted

Can somebody give me examples of John as a moral compass? Because I see him more like helping Sherlock to behave and better blend into the world of goldfish. His most important influence in my eyes, is his presence in Sherlock's life, the fact, that he was willing to give his life for his friend (TGG). This was the mean reason why Sherlock changed, not what John did or did not.

 

Well in The Final Problem, John was the first one to protest to Mycroft's idea of crashing the girl on the plane. However you could argue that was an attempt by John to get Mycroft to 'behave better'. 

 

I don't see how helping Sherlock to 'behave better' means that John isn't a moral compass. I mean isn't the entire purpose of a moral compass to help people behave better?

Posted

I meant the way Sherlock communicate with other people. It's not so much a question of morality but manners. :P

 

And the question of the plane - it's not so much about morality in my eyes, but of a lesser evil. One life against many? (because the we don't know if the people on the plane are still alive)

 

I think it's mostly overseen detail - the girl is talking about a Big Wheel she's seeing from the plane. In a big city. Which means the plane is going to crash over London. How many people would die?

  • Like 1
Posted

Au contraire, I don't think we're supposed to cheer when Sherlock shoots Magnussen. He saw that he could not beat Magnussen with his intellect. He had lost. So he cheated. He kicked over the chessboard.

 

It's a victory only in the sense that he keeps Magnussen from winning, and that's what does make me want to cheer just a bit. The slimy bastard thought he had Sherlock cornered, and so he did. But he still didn't win.

 

Sherlock saw that he couldn't beat Magnussen by winning, so he sacrificed his own integrity to beat him by losing.

 

Yes he did. But when does he - or anyone in the show - acknowledge that? That's the piece I'm missing.

 

Well, Mycroft did, sort of, by calling Sherlock a murderer. But since there's no consequences in the end, it doesn't mean anything. To me.

 

Can somebody give me examples of John as a moral compass? Because I see him more like helping Sherlock to behave and better blend into the world of goldfish. His most important influence in my eyes, is his presence in Sherlock's life, the fact, that he was willing to give his life for his friend (TGG). This was the mean reason why Sherlock changed, not what John did or did not.

 

Maybe it's because I clearly see John as a war veteran, which (after seeing and reading a lot of stuff about this issue in my younger years) automatically means someone with a dark side and lot of "luggage" to carry around, someone in deep trouble. I never saw him as fluffy and nice as most people seem to think, because he is small, round and hobbity.

 

So the morgue scene wasn't a surprise, even if I don't say it was right.

Plus you have to remember that Sherlock snapped as well. He was about to kill a person, who - although despicable as hell - in John's eyes was still innocent. It was clear that Sherlock lost the touch with reality. He was a dangerous junkie. Maybe it triggered another inner program in John: If there is a dangerous person around, and you have nothing else but your hands as defence, you better make him unable to move. The same happened to poor Wiggins, btw.

 

I'm not defending him. I'm trying to understand. (Understand a completely fictional person, written by two different guys who don't even seem to have one consistent idea about their character - what does it say about me? :huh: )

 

It says you're a Sherlockian. :P

 

I always thought the greatest insight into John's character was when he first met Mycroft, and refused to either back down or cooperate. In light of more recent events, maybe we're supposed to think that was sheer contrariness, but at the time I thought it showed he was courageous and incorruptible; i.e., moral. So that's colored my view of him ever since.

 

Also the grief he exhibits when he sees the pink lady's body, and Soo Lin's; his discomfort when he realizes he's embarrassed Sherlock with his blog; his empathy with Westie's fiancée; his little kindnesses to Mrs. Hudson; little things like that point to him being a decent man. Again, in light of later developments, we could just say he's better at pretending to be decent, but that's not where I go with it.

 

And this one's controversial, but I believe the decision to shoot the cabbie was a moral one, because I believe he thought Sherlock would be murdered in front of his eyes if he didn't. YMMV.

 

Oh, and there's what is possibly my favorite line from TAB: "By God, you will hold yourself to a higher standard." So Sherlock thinks John's a moral compass. That's probably the main reason I do; I tend to believe whatever Sherlock believes (and what does that say about me? :smile: )

 

To turn it around, what has he done that makes him not a moral compass? Kicking Sherlock isn't immoral if you accept, as I do, that he's not quite in his right mind at that moment. Shooting the cabbie is immoral if you believe he didn't think he had a good reason. Marrying an assassin? Well, he didn't know that's what she was. Forgiving her? Forgiveness, even if misplaced, is never a sin in my book, but a lot of people hold that against John. And so on. Morality's such murky territory, it's hard (for me at least) to know what to think, sometimes.

 

I do think in later episodes John was portrayed as becoming more inured to Sherlock's rough handling. That's probably not a good thing.

 

And a final thought; John doesn't have to be moral himself to be a moral compass. He just has to point the way. Through example would be lovely, but not absolutely required. :smile:

  • Like 3
Posted

Au contraire, I don't think we're supposed to cheer when Sherlock shoots Magnussen.

 

Same here, I definitely didn't see it as something to cheer.  I thought it was conveyed as a dark and desperate situation all around, and nobody "won".

 

I knew someone who had been homeless for a few weeks as a teenager.  During that time, they stole from some people in order to eat.  They asked me what I thought once, if it was wrong.  Stealing is wrong, no one has the right to take from another... but sometimes people do what they feel they have to.  I don't feel in the proper position to either approve or disapprove.

 

They're not the same situation, obviously, but they both leave me with the same sort of ambivalent feeling.  It's not okay... but it is what it is.

 

 

(For the record, my earlier post was not me saying that I think it's okay to run around like a vigilante bumping off bad guys willy-nilly.  Taking a life is very serious and I generally don't believe that anyone has the right to decide if someone lives or dies.)

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

I don't think we are meant to cheer, it's meant to be shocking and a failure. The way it goes into slow-mo, the way John freaks out, Mycroft's reaction with the flashbacks of Sherlock when he was little (was that meant to be related to Eurus somehow? That Sherlock was going dark like her?), it's not filmed as a triumphant moment imho. 

  • Like 2
Posted

And this one's controversial, but I believe the decision to shoot the cabbie was a moral one, because I believe he thought Sherlock would be murdered in front of his eyes if he didn't. YMMV.

 

Except that Sherlock wasn't really being murdered, he was willfully gambling with his own life.  The cabbie seemed actually pretty harmless at that point.  You could easily argue that John couldn't have known that at the time, but even making that assumption, he didn't seem too put out after finding out what really happened.  His reaction was basically, "You're an idiot, but he wasn't a very nice man, so... dinner?"  Lol.

 

I don't disagree that it was a moral decision, I'm just playing devil's advocate here.  =]

 

 

Yes he did. But when does he - or anyone in the show - acknowledge that? That's the piece I'm missing.

 

On the subject of things we never get to see (and I know I'm getting way off topic here), I would really have liked to see Sally Donovan's reaction to learning that Sherlock was innocent after Reichenbach.  I was so looking forward to seeing her eat it; I feel robbed, robbed!

 

Okay, back to John, lol.

 

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh, Donovan... I always wanted John to tell her where to stick it when she's being particularly mean. I love it in fics where John sort of stops, looks at her and says dangerously, "What did you just call him?"

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 103 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.