Jump to content

What did you think of "A Scandal In Belgravia?"  

105 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Terrible.


Recommended Posts

Posted

No, I know.  I don't do illustration anyway; but I can see some snark about ACD in type only on the front. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Redbubble has no front AND back prints :P

If they ever allow both front and back, the Sherlock fandom will have a heyday.

  • Like 1
Posted

I love those sneaky fandom shirts you can get - like the ones for The Paper Street Soap Company for Fight Club. 

Posted

The perfect place to print John's t-shirts as envisioned by fashionista Magnussen then. ;)

  • Like 1
Posted

For the headmistress, he just wanted to get to the point of what she had to say so he could get on with what he was there for. If he'd done it the acceptable way he would to reassure here and nod sympathetically as she cried and have to slowly tease out what she had to say. Here, bam, he's got the answer, on with the show.

 

But it looked to me like all he got was a regurgitation of what she'd already told the police.  If that's what he actually wanted, it would have been far easier for him to simply ask the police for a copy of her statement.  That's why I think he was actually trying to jolt her into admitting something that she had been embarrassed to tell the police (like maybe she's not entirely certain that she checked all the doors last night).  But she didn't change her story, therefore there was presumably nothing more to it from her point of view -- so now he can get on with the rest of the investigation.

 

For a boarding school, there must be a specific security protocol in place to ensure the children are protected. I'd imagine that would included security cameras, security systems, security guards, etc. [....]

 

Also, just like TGG and given he had just had a meeting with Moriarty where Moriarty said he would burn Sherlock, I'd suspect that Sherlock actually thought that Moriarty was involved rather than an evil headmistress.

 

You're right, Sherlock was definitely seeing Moriarty under all the beds for quite a while there.  So yeah, that may well have been his first guess.  But at least he didn't let his assumptions lead him astray (as in T6T).

 

Wait a minute, I just checked Ariane DeVere's transcript, and Miss Mckenzie is introduced as the House Mistress (not Headmistress).  So I suspect that she was the only person on duty that night in that building (and that there may be other buildings with their own House Mistresses)..  The transcript also mentions a man (not in uniform) who may have been a plainclothes policeman -- or may have been the headmaster of the school (my first guess).  If he'd been a security guard, surely Sherlock would have questioned him as well.

 

The perfect place to print John's t-shirts as envisioned by fashionista Magnussen then. ;)

 

Too late, the BBC beat you to it.  They also had "I don't shave for Sherlock Holmes," thus leading me to believe that those two scenes were inserted as blatant advertising.  What I really want to know is, why the heck didn't they offer some nicely done "I believe in Sherlock Holmes" shirts between Series 2 and 3?

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, of course in that scene Sherlock was purposeful or intentional, not accidental.

What I meant with intentional is doing so for the sole reason of hurting someone's feeling, without purpose.

There's a difference between being intentionally insensitive even if you've rationalized a reason for doing so and being malicious or taking pleasure in it. I thought Sherlock was intentionally insensitive but I don't think he was malicious. It lacks entertainment for me when he's unnecessarily intentionally insensitive, like in that scene with the school mistress, especially when the person doesn't deserve the treatment. When he's being rude to Anderson or Donovan it didn't bother me in the least because they give as good as they get so it's more banter than Sherlock being a mean bully.
Posted

Haven't you ever had that relationship with someone that you just spar with all the time, and it winds up making the physical attraction a huge inferno that just consumes you both, spurred on by the fact that neither of you will give the other an inch?

 

No, lol.  The closest I ever had to that was something like a friendly rivalry, years ago.  He was asexual (as was I, without realizing it at that point), so there was no potential for it to develop that kind of ardor.  He was extremely brilliant, and extremely bored because of it.  Every moment he was trying to occupy his mind with something, but he never stayed on anything for long because he was so quick to pick up new information.  He was reserved and not unkind, but sardonic as all hell.  I challenged him on things he said.  I'm not sure whether he liked that or hated it, lol.  He was difficult to read.  Either way, we engaged in verbal/intellectual sparring on a daily basis, always testing each other.  It was an ongoing game of chess between us.  He also happened to be very attractive.  Very tall, lithe, bounteous dark hair, gray/blue eyes... a bit like Sherlock, now that I'm saying it, lol; he even had a similar coat.  It was often remarked that he had the look of an Elf (of the Tolkien variety).  Besotted girls were ceaselessly fawning over him.  He politely ignored them, and other than some sideways eye-rolling didn't display a lot of outward agitation; but in truth I think it annoyed him to no end.  I got the feeling that he seemed to feel like people always wanted something from him.  I think one of the reasons he was fine interacting with me was because he knew I wasn't after him that way.  We were both a bit loners.  Definitely one of the more singular individuals I've ever met, and one of the two legitimate, extraordinary geniuses.  I have no idea where he is now, he's managed to stay pretty well off the grid.  Probably applying his genius to some top-secret stuff somewhere, lol.

 

 

  • Like 3
  • 5 months later...
Posted

Hey, I think I've been ignoring you guys for a couple of weeks, what with the holidays and a vacation in there.

 

Anyway, I thought about putting this in the worst villain thread, but it goes better here.  I watched SiB last night, because it's the Christmas episode  ;) , and I think Irene may have been in more trouble than I have been thinking all along, making her a somewhat weaker villain than I thought.

 

At the beginning, Moriarty says, "If you have what you say, I will make you rich; if you don't, I will make you into shoes." And then Irene goes and has her royal client.

 

I suppose I'd always thought those two things were connected, but watching last night, I think they are separate. (Maybe I've just been an idiot all along.) What if Irene had gotten in with Moriarty, and she got in over her head; he wanted her to provide information from different sensitive sources, and he was paying her for it, but she wanted to get away from that.  The Royal client was a good excuse to get the power of the throne behind her; she said a couple of times that she didn't want those photos for blackmail, only for insurance.  The trouble was bad enough that by the end she wanted to disappear; she gave Mycroft a list of demands and ideas about "protection." If she felt safe with Moriarty's crew, she wouldn't be leaving London and her lucrative business. So maybe Irene had gotten too involved with the wrong protector, and she really did need a rescue by Sherlock?

  • Like 1
Posted

That's pretty much what I'd assumed that she was in over her head and was using what she could to try to get Moriarty off her back for long enough that she could find a way out and disappear. She assumed the Royal pics would be good leverage against Mycroft for that to happen. 

Posted

I think I'd always given her too much credit that she was able to play both sides simultaneously, but now I think you're right.

Posted

I thought she'd gotten in over her head, but I'm not convinced it was with Moriarty.  It's my impression that she had "hired" Moriarty to help her figure out how to blackmail Mycroft ... so she was already in trouble before she contacted Jim, it seems to me. Although I agree it seems like there should be a connection between "I'll make you into shoes" and the introduction of Irene. But I'm not sure there is.

  • Like 3
Posted

I thought she'd gotten in over her head, but I'm not convinced it was with Moriarty. It's my impression that she had "hired" Moriarty to help her figure out how to blackmail Mycroft ... so she was already in trouble before she contacted Jim, it seems to me. Although I agree it seems like there should be a connection between "I'll make you into shoes" and the introduction of Irene. But I'm not sure there is.

No? I always thought it was her on the phone.

Posted

It is, I *think* Arcadia meant there's no connection between the shoes and what (or rather who) Irene is doing at that moment. 

  • Like 1
Posted

The fact Greg thinks Sherlock makes a feminine erotic moan when he's happy is hilarious. 

  • Like 2
Posted

I have the impression that Jim hired Irene to bait Sherlock with the "royal" case, so he can get to Mycroft. In the end he is able to prevent the BondAir action, which would be a pressure point on Myc (because it was Sherlock's fault). Sherlock cracked Irene's phone, so there was at least a payoff for the whole trouble, but I bet Mycroft had a lot to explain to his bosses.

Not sure why Jim have done this, maybe he was consulted by someone or he was just bored.

  • Like 1
Posted

I thought she'd gotten in over her head, but I'm not convinced it was with Moriarty.  It's my impression that she had "hired" Moriarty to help her figure out how to blackmail Mycroft ... so she was already in trouble before she contacted Jim, it seems to me. Although I agree it seems like there should be a connection between "I'll make you into shoes" and the introduction of Irene. But I'm not sure there is.

 

^ Same.

 

I have the impression that Jim hired Irene to bait Sherlock with the "royal" case, so he can get to Mycroft. In the end he is able to prevent the BondAir action, which would be a pressure point on Myc (because it was Sherlock's fault). Sherlock cracked Irene's phone, so there was at least a payoff for the whole trouble, but I bet Mycroft had a lot to explain to his bosses.

Not sure why Jim have done this, maybe he was consulted by someone or he was just bored.

 

I think they "hired" each other in a sense.  They wouldn't have worked together unless it had been mutually beneficial, at least at the start.  They both wanted something out of it.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

It's a sign of devotion - i love you so much I'll make you into shoes so you can always be with me. :P

  • Like 2
Posted

Lol, I never said they treated each other as equals or possessed equal power.  :P

 

 

Posted

No, I meant that the "make you into shoes" line may not have been directed at Irene. Maybe it was, but to me it makes more sense if it wasn't. I think. I go back and forth on this one, tbh.

 

My take is that Jim was hired by someone to help plan the Bond Air plot, too. If he's the "Consulting Criminal", then he doesn't necessarily have any personal reason to blow up a bunch of people; he's just selling his expertise to someone who does. Same with Irene and her goal of blackmailing Mycroft. Or the gallery director and her fake painting. Nobody ever gets to Jim because he's not actually involved in perpetrating the crimes, he just advises people how to pull them off.

  • Like 2
Posted

The fact Greg thinks Sherlock makes a feminine erotic moan when he's happy is hilarious. 

 

Greg is totally thinking, "Oh, I've got to get a video of this to add to my collection of embarrassing Sherlock videos!"

 

It's a sign of devotion - i love you so much I'll make you into shoes so you can always be with me. :P

 

Well, really, if someone is going to kill me in a gruesome fashion, I do hope to live on as a nice pair of stilettos. 

  • Like 3
Posted

No, I meant that the "make you into shoes" line may not have been directed at Irene. Maybe it was, but to me it makes more sense if it wasn't. I think. I go back and forth on this one, tbh.

 

I think the line was directed at her, because if it wasn't, John and Sherlock's lines immediately following don't make as much sense to me.

 

JOHN: What happened there?

SHERLOCK: Someone changed his mind. The question is: who?

 

And then Irene is shown hanging up her phone.  I can only believe that such a dramatic "But who??" introduction was intended to be applied to her.

 

However, I never really thought Moriarty's shoes line sounded much like something he'd say to Irene.  But I guess he did.  :/

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Well, really, if someone is going to kill me in a gruesome fashion, I do hope to live on as a nice pair of stilettos. 

 

 

9845a584d85618b18754eeaab16b37dc--sherlo

 

There's a funny pic somewhere where the other half of the phone call is actually Seb Moran, and they're talking about cereal or something equally as silly. Can't remember where I found it though. 

  • Like 3
Posted

^ :lol:  I want to see that.

 

I want to see this, too.

 

50602177ffa2f41ffa718d6927c7b140--sherlo

 

 

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 111 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.