Jump to content

What did you think of "A Scandal In Belgravia?"  

105 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Terrible.


Recommended Posts

Posted

Was it this?

 

tumblr_n6ay97nIjr1ts4m7no1_500.png

 

 

  • Like 3
Posted

 

No, I meant that the "make you into shoes" line may not have been directed at Irene. Maybe it was, but to me it makes more sense if it wasn't. I think. I go back and forth on this one, tbh.

 

I think the line was directed at her, because if it wasn't, John and Sherlock's lines immediately following don't make as much sense to me.

 

JOHN: What happened there?

SHERLOCK: Someone changed his mind. The question is: who?

 

And then Irene is shown hanging up her phone.  I can only believe that such a dramatic "But who??" introduction was intended to be applied to her.

 

However, I never really thought Moriarty's shoes line sounded much like something he'd say to Irene.  But I guess he did.  :/

 

 

Therein lies my dilemma; the visuals make you think he's talking to Irene, but the dialog doesn't fit. I think I'll go with Pseud's interpretation, it makes more sense. :p

  • Like 2
Posted

Was it this?

 

tumblr_n6ay97nIjr1ts4m7no1_500.png

 

Lol, yea, I think that was it! I thought it was a photo version, but must have been getting it mixed up with others. :D

Posted

I thought she'd gotten in over her head, but I'm not convinced it was with Moriarty.

That’s what I thought too because wasn’t the scene at the end when she was about to be beheaded by what looked like terrorists imply she was running away from them all along? I guess those terrorists could have been affiliated with Moriarty but it seemed like Moriarty was more a co-conspirator/temporary ally at the time a la Moriarty/Eurus in TFP rather than who she was running from.
  • Like 3
Posted

 

I thought she'd gotten in over her head, but I'm not convinced it was with Moriarty.

That’s what I thought too because wasn’t the scene at the end when she was about to be beheaded by what looked like terrorists imply she was running away from them all along? I guess those terrorists could have been affiliated with Moriarty but it seemed like Moriarty was more a co-conspirator/temporary ally at the time a la Moriarty/Eurus in TFP rather than who she was running from.

 

 

I agree.  And the fact that she was trying to draw the British government into protecting her means that she might have gotten into some sort of international intrigue.

Posted

Hey, I think I've been ignoring you guys for a couple of weeks, what with the holidays and a vacation in there.

 

Anyway, I thought about putting this in the worst villain thread, but it goes better here.  I watched SiB last night, because it's the Christmas episode  ;) , and I think Irene may have been in more trouble than I have been thinking all along, making her a somewhat weaker villain than I thought.

 

At the beginning, Moriarty says, "If you have what you say, I will make you rich; if you don't, I will make you into shoes." And then Irene goes and has her royal client.

 

I suppose I'd always thought those two things were connected, but watching last night, I think they are separate. (Maybe I've just been an idiot all along.) What if Irene had gotten in with Moriarty, and she got in over her head; he wanted her to provide information from different sensitive sources, and he was paying her for it, but she wanted to get away from that.  The Royal client was a good excuse to get the power of the throne behind her; she said a couple of times that she didn't want those photos for blackmail, only for insurance.  The trouble was bad enough that by the end she wanted to disappear; she gave Mycroft a list of demands and ideas about "protection." If she felt safe with Moriarty's crew, she wouldn't be leaving London and her lucrative business. So maybe Irene had gotten too involved with the wrong protector, and she really did need a rescue by Sherlock?

 

The question burning in everyone's minds is . . *Who* was the young Royal vixen tied down to Adler's bedposts?  It had to be a fairly highly-placed young Royal person for all this kerfluffle, not one of the distant cousins on the fringes of the Firm.

 

My money's on Beatrice, who strikes me as knowing how to be very naughty just from her fascinators alone.  Then there was that recent incident involving her, an old sword and an injury to Ed Sheeran's face . . Ed claims that she was 'knighting' him and, both being a little tipsy, either Ed slipped into the sword with his face or Bea's grip slipped.  Fellow crooner James Blunt calls that a load of b*ll*cks.  Said he was at the same party and Ed was so off his face he fell into a table.  Don't you love it when celebs throw shade at one another? . .

 

Anyway, at the time this episode was filmed, pre-Wills and Kate brood, Beatrice would have held Harry's current position of 5th in line to the throne after her father, Prince Andrew.  That is certainly high-ranking enough to cause le grande scandale.  Just my theory.  :)

Posted

Although I have occasionally mentally played the "who hired Irene" game with real royals on my mind, it always makes me slightly uncomfortable. So, in my mind, there is some completely fictitious royal very close to the throne who is the actual posh thing who is the recipient of Irene's services.

  • Like 2
Posted

... I think Irene may have been in more trouble than I have been thinking all along, making her a somewhat weaker villain than I thought.

 

At the beginning, Moriarty says, "If you have what you say, I will make you rich; if you don't, I will make you into shoes." And then Irene goes and has her royal client.

 

I suppose I'd always thought those two things were connected, but watching last night, I think they are separate. (Maybe I've just been an idiot all along.

 

You, me, just about everybody else on this forum -- and quite possibly the Moftisses as well.  Who knows?

 

What if Irene had gotten in with Moriarty, and she got in over her head; he wanted her to provide information from different sensitive sources, and he was paying her for it, but she wanted to get away from that.  The Royal client was a good excuse to get the power of the throne behind her; she said a couple of times that she didn't want those photos for blackmail, only for insurance.  The trouble was bad enough that by the end she wanted to disappear; she gave Mycroft a list of demands and ideas about "protection." If she felt safe with Moriarty's crew, she wouldn't be leaving London and her lucrative business. So maybe Irene had gotten too involved with the wrong protector, and she really did need a rescue by Sherlock?

 

 OK, so you're saying maybe she didn't want protection *from* the Royal family (as I've been assuming), but rather protection provided *by* the Royal family?  As in, "protect me from these random goons, or I'll hand over some cute little photos to Charles Augustus Magnussen"?  Y'know, that makes sense.

 

At this point, I'm not at all sure *what* to think!  (D'yall think this discussion could carry us through to Series 5?)

  • Like 2
Posted

I always assumed that he collected pressure points of important people to use them for her own protection the way CAM was using them for… ah… whatever he needed them.

 

I can imagine a similar procedure: she sends a message to, let's say, an important politician: "If you don't end the investigation on me, I will send your naked photos to the Mail." I also think that when she meets with Mycroft and Sherlock, she was doing exactly this.

  • Like 3
Posted

That’s exactly how I view the way Irene operates as welI J.P. Which is why I don’t see much difference between her and CAM.

Posted

She could have ruined Mycroft’s career if Sherlock hadn’t figured out the phone code. Also, given she had a dead body double and can drug people at a moment’s notice, I’m not sure she hasn’t ruined a lot of people’s lives in an effort “to protect herself”. Also I wonder how she’s able to obtain those photos... how likely do you think they were taken by choice rather than without the client’s knowledge/consent? Also the royal client she took the photos of wasn’t the person she was running from, just the person she used to blackmail someone that she thought could help her. How is that different than CAM? I’d assume those photos could have ruined something otherwise it wouldn’t have been leverage/insurance for her at all.

  • Like 1
Posted

Although I have occasionally mentally played the "who hired Irene" game with real royals on my mind, it always makes me slightly uncomfortable. So, in my mind, there is some completely fictitious royal very close to the throne who is the actual posh thing who is the recipient of Irene's services.

 

I'm still convinced they only specified it was a female someone so people didn't immediately conclude it was Harry.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

Although I have occasionally mentally played the "who hired Irene" game with real royals on my mind, it always makes me slightly uncomfortable. So, in my mind, there is some completely fictitious royal very close to the throne who is the actual posh thing who is the recipient of Irene's services.

I'm still convinced they only specified it was a female someone so people didn't immediately conclude it was Harry.

:-D :-D :-D

 

That never occurred to me before.

Posted

This year he's been very respectable and adult, but given the fact he was known as a bit of a party boy and there photos of him naked in a party in Vegas (at least I think that's where it was) Harry is definitely who I'd have suspected!

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm not sure if I would have thought Harry if they had said a male royal. As it is, I haven't really thought of any of the real life female royals while watching this episode. The closest I've come is, 'I wonder what the relationship to the queen would be (e.g. granddaughter, grandniece, etc.) or what number in line for the throne they would be.

  • Like 2
Posted

I think most of Britain would have thought Harry, knowing the reputation he used to have. 

Posted

Taking what Mycroft's friend the equerry said literally, a case could even be made for it being not an actual royal, but, for example, the child or grandchild of some lady in waiting or personal secretary of the Queen:
 
 

A person of significance to my employer.
 
... a young person.
 
A young female person.

 
 
Near as I can recall, the only hint that the person is actually a royal herself is the scene where Irene enters a room where someone appears to be tied to the bed, and says "Have you been wicked, Your Highness?"  Taken at face value, the client is indeed a member of the Royal Family.  However, we do not even know whether the feet on the bed belong to the "young female person" (could be some other client), nor do we know if the client (whoever s/he may be) actually rates being addressed as "Your Highness" (after all, Irene specializes in role-playing)."

 

And even if the client is indeed the "young female person," note that the term "Your (Royal) Highness" may extend down to the sovereign's great-grandchildren and their spouses -- a pretty wide field.

  • Like 1
Posted

It took me 3 years and some days to realize, that when Sherlock enters the right password to Irene's phone, it's NOT his last try. She unlocked it to show him the mysterious code, so he had at least three more attempts. :blush:

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh, right -- he had made three guesses (one remaining), then she showed him what turned out to be the airplane seating plan.  I never thought of that at all!  Turned out he only needed one more anyhow, though.

Posted

 

 

 

What if Irene had gotten in with Moriarty, and she got in over her head; he wanted her to provide information from different sensitive sources, and he was paying her for it, but she wanted to get away from that.  The Royal client was a good excuse to get the power of the throne behind her; she said a couple of times that she didn't want those photos for blackmail, only for insurance.  The trouble was bad enough that by the end she wanted to disappear; she gave Mycroft a list of demands and ideas about "protection." If she felt safe with Moriarty's crew, she wouldn't be leaving London and her lucrative business. So maybe Irene had gotten too involved with the wrong protector, and she really did need a rescue by Sherlock?

 

 OK, so you're saying maybe she didn't want protection *from* the Royal family (as I've been assuming), but rather protection provided *by* the Royal family?  As in, "protect me from these random goons, or I'll hand over some cute little photos to Charles Augustus Magnussen"?  Y'know, that makes sense.

 

At this point, I'm not at all sure *what* to think!  (D'yall think this discussion could carry us through to Series 5?)

 

 

Yeah, that's what I was getting at.  

 

And we do need to drag this out for a while, it looks like.  Maybe we should just systematically do each episode, scene by scene, to see if we missed anything...

  • Like 3
Posted

Isn't that what we've been doing? :p Okay, not very systematically.... not any system I recognize, anyway. :d

  • Like 3
Posted

OK, then, SiP, scene 1.  What do we think of the shadows on the wall in John's bedsit?  What do they tell us about his character? Do they foreshadow his emotional affair with Eurus in S4?  :P

  • Like 2
Posted

They foreshadow the darkness that will overtake him when he beats Sherlock. 

  • Like 4
Posted

Help, I’m having English class flashbacks...

  • Like 2
  • Haha 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.