Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

It had been awhile by the looks of the grass that had already grown on the grave. It kind of reminds me of the scene in Jeremy Brett's version of "The Final Problem". He has escaped Moran's attempts to kill him after Moriarty goes into the Falls. He finds an over hanging rock to rest under when he sees Watson return and he almost calls out to him. Then he can only wistfully look on.

That was awesome, wasn't it?

Posted

 

 

Oh. Honestly I think that was for dramatic effect. With Mycroft on his side, could of left at anytime after his death.

Well, don't forget he told John (in TEH) that he heard what John said at the graveside. So if his appearance at the end of TRF was just a dramatic effect, Sherlock must have lied to John in TEH. Not that he hasn't done that before, rather frequently.

You don't honestly think Sherlock would miss his own funeral? I bet he was there for the whole thing, hiding in plain sight!

 

Toby, I was responding to previous post implying that he couldn't leave till later. And Arcadia I'm confused by what you mean, about Sherlock lying?? He would have still been telling the truth.???? :huh:

Posted

Jess, I think Arcadia thought that when you said "just for dramatic effect," you meant you thought it didn't really happen.  So she said if it didn't really happen, then when Sherlock told John (in TEH) that he had been at the cemetery, it would have been a lie.  (But conversely, if it did really happen, then he was telling the truth, and all's right with the world.)

Posted

And confusion reigns! :D Yah, that's what I thought you meant, jess, but I see now how I misread it. Good catch, Carol!

Posted

Speaking of understanding people (awkward transition back to the episode), what are we supposed to make of Mycroft's two little chats with John in The Reichenbach Fall, knowing, as we do now, that Sherlock most certainly had accepted his help and they were plotting Moriarty's downfall together all along? Mycroft must have been acting a part, and the question is, why.

 

While I can't deny that John was pretty justified in giving Sherlock the kind of greeting he did when he returned, I'm beginning to think Mycroft might have deserved something even more, um, energetic. Think about it. It was he who appealed to John to look after Sherlock and protect him, while it was also his idea to (according to Sherlock, which I sort of believe) to use John for their final act. So not only did John have to watch Sherlock die, he also must have also felt responsible for his death in a way, because he had failed the "mission" given to him explicitly by Mycroft. God, what an utter bastard that big brother is. He deliberately tried to make John even more emotionally invested in his friend than he already was, just so the final shock would be all the more momentous and he'd be way too devastated by it to smell a rat? Or what?

 

I gathered my courage and watched this again recently, and it really hit me this time that Molly is totally right, Sherlock does look sad, almost from the very beginning. He knew pretty well what was coming. It might have all been more or less "under control", but it doesn't seem as if he enjoyed it. It's really interesting to compare this episode to The Great Game. Here, it's really clear that the fun and flirting is over.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have to admit that scene where Mycroft asks John to "look out for Sherlock" never quite made sense to me ... why not tell Sherlock directly? Why does John seem so angered by the request? Why is he so flippant about snipers moving in on them? Etc.

 

The other, I agree, Mycroft deserves a pop in the nose for that one.

 

As to why he was acting a part -- for the same reason Sherlock was! :smile: Whatever the heck that reason is....................

Posted

Well, I must admit I do have this very crazy theory that Mycroft thought it was time to get rid of John, so to speak. After all, he holds that friendships are inadvisable, for his brother at least ("don't get involved"), and caring is not an advantage. If Sherlock is going to take down the most dangerous criminal there is and dismantle his entire world-wide network, John the goldfish is way too much of a liability. Really, Sherlock can't afford to have a pressure point. "Alone protects him", right? A part of me believes that was the real reason why Mycroft suggested using John as the suicide witness, and was totally okay with keeping him in the dark for as long as the danger lasted, at least.

Posted

Well, considering how His Last Vow turned out, Mycroft had a bit of a point there, didn't he? Sherlock wouldn't have become a murderer without reconnecting with John.

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, I must admit I do have this very crazy theory that Mycroft thought it was time to get rid of John, so to speak. After all, he holds that friendships are inadvisable, for his brother at least ("don't get involved"), and caring is not an advantage. If Sherlock is going to take down the most dangerous criminal there is and dismantle his entire world-wide network, John the goldfish is way too much of a liability. Really, Sherlock can't afford to have a pressure point. "Alone protects him", right? A part of me believes that was the real reason why Mycroft suggested using John as the suicide witness, and was totally okay with keeping him in the dark for as long as the danger lasted, at least.

Urghgghhhh, that's really twisted. I love it. :wacko:
  • Like 1
Posted

Speaking of understanding people (awkward transition back to the episode), what are we supposed to make of Mycroft's two little chats with John in The Reichenbach Fall, knowing, as we do now, that Sherlock most certainly had accepted his help and they were plotting Moriarty's downfall together all along? Mycroft must have been acting a part, and the question is, why.

 

While I can't deny that John was pretty justified in giving Sherlock the kind of greeting he did when he returned, I'm beginning to think Mycroft might have deserved something even more, um, energetic. Think about it. It was he who appealed to John to look after Sherlock and protect him, while it was also his idea to (according to Sherlock, which I sort of believe) to use John for their final act. So not only did John have to watch Sherlock die, he also must have also felt responsible for his death in a way, because he had failed the "mission" given to him explicitly by Mycroft. God, what an utter bastard that big brother is. He deliberately tried to make John even more emotionally invested in his friend than he already was, just so the final shock would be all the more momentous and he'd be way too devastated by it to smell a rat? Or what?

 

I gathered my courage and watched this again recently, and it really hit me this time that Molly is totally right, Sherlock does look sad, almost from the very beginning. He knew pretty well what was coming. It might have all been more or less "under control", but it doesn't seem as if he enjoyed it. It's really interesting to compare this episode to The Great Game. Here, it's really clear that the fun and flirting is over.

 

I feel that John wouldn't be upset at all with Mycroft... That's just who he is. But Sherlock... Sherlock is his closest friend & he trusted 30 people over him... Mycroft, Molly, His parents and 25 @ most of his homeless network. His HOMELESS network before John.

Posted

I really think it was because John would have been Sherlock's rat. If anyone began to suspect that Sherlock might even remotely be alive all they would have to do would put 24/7 surveillance on John. As has" been posted by others, John Watson was no actor. He wouldn't be able to put on a convincing show of deep grief if he knew Sherlock was alive and well.

  • Like 1
Posted

I feel that John wouldn't be upset at all with Mycroft... That's just who he is. But Sherlock... Sherlock is his closest friend & he trusted 30 people over him... Mycroft, Molly, His parents and 25 @ most of his homeless network. His HOMELESS network before John.

We need a light-bulb emoticon! I just had an ah-ha! moment (please stop me if this was already obvious to everyone else and/or forgive me if someone has already posted the same idea):

 

Yes, Sherlock felt he had to fool John and keep him in the dark (and I regretfully agree), but he had no idea how deeply this would wound John, because -- even though John may be the most important person in the world to him -- it never occurred to him that he might be John's best friend too.  He knew that John had seen people die before, even (as he said in "Study in Pink") friends of his, and it hadn't left any obvious emotional scars.  So what's one more?

 

  • Like 5
Posted

Oh, Carol, that's so obvious... :facepalm:    (NOT!!!! :D )

 

It's good, I like it. Especially considering the last words John ever said to him before the phone call.

Posted

Yup.. I posted elsewhere that he may not have told him, per if it wasn't for Johns blog, Moriarty wouldn't have had the upper hand when it came to that fake super Nova painting. Also john is a horrible liar.

Posted

Duh...duh...duh... stupid, stupid, stupid... I know what the final problem is.  Finally I know what Moriarty meant when he said, "I told you but were you listening?"

 

STAYING ALIVE

  • Like 3
Posted

That seems to be what he says on the roof.  So when he tells Sherlock over a cup of tea that he's already told him what their problem is, he's referring to his ringtone at the pool?  Not quite what I'd interpret as "telling" someone -- but then again, he did choose the ringtone, and he does have a unique way of viewing the world.

 

Posted

It just occurred to me that if "staying alive" is indeed the Final Problem (and I think it is), then Sherlock solved it in His Last Vow. In the Mind Palace sequence, I mean. He decided to stay alive, he found a reason to do so. He was needed. How fitting that this was embedded in an, albeit imaginary, conversation with Moriarty, of all people.

  • Like 6
Posted

Just occurs to me that Sherlock was standing right there when Moriarty (presumably!) died.  So maybe the mind-palace Moriarty isn't imaginary at all -- maybe when his own body died, his consciousness fled into Sherlock's body -- like Spock's katra sharing McCoy's body in The Search for Spock, unbeknownst to McCoy.  And like McCoy in that movie, Sherlock has been acting a little different lately....

 

I don't think Moftiss are into that sort of thing (too much like the ghost stories that they make light of), but Conan Doyle might have liked the idea.

 

Posted

And that would fit the "Sherlock chasing a ghost" theory that some people have come up with. Yes, Doyle would be very excited if Mofftiss played around with the idea of Spiritualism. Seventh Heaven, so to speak.

Posted

Doesn't that belong in the "Bad Puns" thread? :P

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 137 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.