Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

Ooops, missed seeing that before ....

 

Yeah, the body's almost impossible to explain, imo. *sigh* I have come to the conclusion that the only explanation is that they wanted to do something for Molly's fans, by making it look like she had an important part to play. Which she did anyway; at least, I assume she's the one who faked his death records. But that would be hard to dramatize, so they came up with the body-that-wasn't-needed.

 

The only "in show" explanation I can think of is that Sherlock was afraid he wouldn't be able to get into position fast enough, so had the body double just in case John rounded the corner a little too fast, while he was still disentangling himself from Big Blue. Because it was, indeed, all about fooling John. :(

 

It's hard to believe a man who pulled off such a well-thought-out stunt is the same man who screwed up so royally at Magnussen's house, isn't it? ;) (I'll blame the drugs...)

Posted

Second major flaw to Big Blue -- judging by the scenario that we are shown (from Sherlock's mind palace? Anderson's imagination?), Big Blue was clearly visible to John from his cab.

I think we are supposed to believe that his view is blocked by the ambulance bay. I just go and assume that it is, it makes my life so much easier. :D

 

... it wouldn't have been in that position (or possibly even inflated yet?) when John went by? It would have been at the other end, where it would have been blocked from view ... ? Or actually, I have assumed they brought it out from inside Bart's proper (near where it says "bus stop".) I can't remember if it's shown where it comes from.

Nope, they showed Big Blue being inflated just outside the Ambulance Station, at its south end -- and John's cab is shown coming in from the south.  (If you like, I can put up some screen caps in the sequence shown, but it's too late for that tonight.)  I think this is just an excellent example of Moftiss trying to explain too much!

 

Ooops, missed seeing that before ....

 

Yeah, the body's almost impossible to explain, imo. *sigh* I have come to the conclusion that the only explanation is that they wanted to do something for Molly's fans, by making it look like she had an important part to play. Which she did anyway; at least, I assume she's the one who faked his death records. But that would be hard to dramatize, so they came up with the body-that-wasn't-needed.

 

The only "in show" explanation I can think of is that Sherlock was afraid he wouldn't be able to get into position fast enough, so had the body double just in case John rounded the corner a little too fast, while he was still disentangling himself from Big Blue. Because it was, indeed, all about fooling John. :(

Thanks for that little blog link, J.P. -- my thoughts exactly!

 

There were tons of things they could have credited Molly with, other than the body. As Arcadia says, she's presumably the one who faked his death certificate. She's presumably also the one who helped him figure out how to "die" convincingly (e.g., taught him the rubber ball trick and snagged some expired blood from the hospital blood bank), told him some things NOT to do in order to avoid real death (i.e., things some of her "clients" had gotten wrong), got the medical wardrobe for Sherlock's Homeless Network and taught them how to be convincing enough to fool John. Bet we could come up with tons more.

 

Didn't Mr. Moffat say something in one of the Comic Con Q&A sessions (the charity one, I think) about a friend of his had come up with the idea (after seeing "Reichenbach") that Sherlock figured out that Claudette screamed because the kidnapper had looked like Sherlock, so he got the kidnapper's body to use in fooling John. The friend thought he had guessed what Moftiss had in mind -- but they actually stole his idea for "Empty Hearse"! I think that's an excellent example of Moftiss being so fond of an idea that they don't see its flaws.

 

It would have been far easier for Moriarty to show Claudette a video of Sherlock and tell her that he was the mastermind behind her kidnapping, and to watch out because he'd be coming after her. That would have been a far more reliable plan as well, since we've probably all had the experience of thinking somebody looked just like so-and-so, while our friend or spouse didn't see the resemblance at all. Claudette might not see the resemblance between Sherlock and the stunt double (their faces actually aren't all that similar), but she'd surely see the resemblance between Sherlock and a video of Sherlock.

 

And if they were worried that John would come around the corner too soon, they could have simply had the bicycle knock him down a bit sooner.

 

Posted

There might actually be an in-universe explanation - gore. A body that hits the pavement from that height splatters, and there would've been bits-o-Sherlock all around. Now they couldn't well show that in a pre-watershed show (see, Moriarty's brain blown out), but John, Army doctor that he is, would've instinctively expected such splatter to be there regardless and become wary if there had been none.

 

No, I don't think either that Mr. Moffat had thought of that, but when has that ever stopped us? :lol:

  • Like 2
Posted

Are you meaning that as an explanation for why they needed the corpse?  If so, I'm not following you.  I just remembered a somewhat similar reason I came up with a while back -- sound effects.  John would have (perhaps subconsciously) have expected to hear an awful "thud."

 

As for the splattering, seems like the pool of blood might have sufficed.

 

Posted

There might actually be an in-universe explanation - gore. A body that hits the pavement from that height splatters, and there would've been bits-o-Sherlock all around. Now they couldn't well show that in a pre-watershed show (see, Moriarty's brain blown out), but John, Army doctor that he is, would've instinctively expected such splatter to be there regardless and become wary if there had been none.

 

No, I don't think either that Mr. Moffat had thought of that, but when has that ever stopped us? :lol:

I've wondered about that, actually ... wouldn't there be more damage than just blood? Although now that I think more about it, that still doesn't work, because the "splattered" body wasn't the one John saw up close. Unless you're saying the splattered bits were still lying there? (I can't believe I'm having this conversation.... :blink: )

Posted

Are you meaning that as an explanation for why they needed the corpse?  If so, I'm not following you.  I just remembered a somewhat similar reason I came up with a while back -- sound effects.  John would have (perhaps subconsciously) have expected to hear an awful "thud."

 

In that case, wouldn't a sack of potatos have sufficed? :p

Posted

I've wondered about that, actually ... wouldn't there be more damage than just blood? Although now that I think more about it, that still doesn't work, because the "splattered" body wasn't the one John saw up close. Unless you're saying the splattered bits were still lying there? (I can't believe I'm having this conversation.... :blink: )

 

Just so. I think John would've subconsciously noticed if there weren't some scattered pieces of guts and similar splattered in the general vicinity.

 

(I'm sure that you can google such pavement impact scenes, btw, if you want to know more details, but I'm not recommending it).

Posted

Aha! Another case solved, then! :D
 
I don't know if it's the same physics involved or not, but I once saw a squirrel get hit by a fast-moving truck. The poor thing literally blew to pieces on impact. Thankfully I was too far away to see details, but that was more than enough to fuel my overwrought imagination for years afterwards. So I think I'll pass on the googling!

Posted

I'm not sure Barts would be high enough to produce those kinds of results.  Lots of broken bones, lacerated internal organs, severe concussion.  Now the people who jumped from the burning Word Trade center - well, that's another story more akin to your squirrel.

Posted

"Like" doesn't seem appropriate! :smile: But yeah, I get it.

  • Like 1
Posted

Cracked skull, possible caving in - face distortion, etc.

Posted

John would have (perhaps subconsciously) have expected to hear an awful "thud."

 

Well, actually John have heard an awful thud as Sherlock hit the Big Blue. Only it sounded quite different. All those velcros tearing open, the whole ballon serving as a sound amplifier... Which leads to another flaw: If the dead body should serve as a optical trick - it had to land somewhere near the landing zone for Sherlock... which was already occupied by BB and people handling it.

Shall I make another T-shirt: BigBlue is Bollocks (erm... sorry)?

 

 

As for the splattering, seems like the pool of blood might have sufficed.

 

In that case I don't think John would notice anything - he was fully concentrated on the fact that Sherlock jumped from the roof and going into shock.

 

Stupid Lazarus. It belongs both to TRF and TEH...

  • Like 1
Posted

The need for a body was not restricted to the scene of the jump alone. There was a funeral thereafter, the one Sherlock's parents didn't attend.

  • Like 1
Posted

Are you meaning that as an explanation for why they needed the corpse?  If so, I'm not following you.  I just remembered a somewhat similar reason I came up with a while back -- sound effects.  John would have (perhaps subconsciously) have expected to hear an awful "thud."

 

 

In that case, wouldn't a sack of potatos have sufficed? :P

 

Precisely!  And that's roughly what I assumed it was till I watched "Empty Hearse."  They just way over-explained the whole thing.

 

The need for a body was not restricted to the scene of the jump alone. There was a funeral thereafter, the one Sherlock's parents didn't attend.

 

See above.  (Though sandbags would probably be more appropriate than potatoes, weight-wise.)  Nobody would be expecting an open casket.  And even if they did, the stunt double wouldn't have fooled anyone.

 

Posted

There go the great minds -- running in the same gutter again!  ;)

  • Like 1
Posted

Hehe, crossposted with Carol with the same thought. But you cannot burn a sack of sand.

In case it was a cremation, of course, it is hard to say from the grave itself.

Posted

Egad, we cross-posted twice in a row!

 

Good point regarding the sand.  If there was any chance of cremation, they could have used a hundred and some pounds of selections from the butcher shop -- or any random body of approximately the right weight.

 

Posted

Sorry but are cremations common in the UK? A cremation would certainly be convenient in this case of course.

And I assumed John would have had occasion to see the body at least once more before or during the funeral, since he and Mycroft would have been the only people in charge of managing the whole thing.

As for "And even if they did, the stunt double wouldn't have fooled anyone.", if they expect us to believe Claudette was fooled by the double, then why not everyone else too? :) after all peoples faces do look different in death, especially a violent one.

Posted

Sorry but are cremations common in the UK?

I can't speak for the UK, but here in the US cremations are not really common, but are nevertheless considered perfectly normal. When a body is cremated, though, the ashes are often kept by the family, or scattered, or entombed in a special building full of little drawers. Although they could presumably be buried in a grave, I don't think that's common.

 

... I assumed John would have had occasion to see the body at least once more before or during the funeral, since he and Mycroft would have been the only people in charge of managing the whole thing. <snip> ... if they expect us to believe Claudette was fooled by the double, then why not everyone else too? :) after all peoples faces do look different in death, especially a violent one.

Mycroft wouldn't have dared allow John to see the body. While he might have been too traumatized to notice, he had seen the real Sherlock after his fall, and therefore might not have been fooled by any explanations along the line of "well, of course he doesn't look like himself, he fell off a building." It would have been a huge risk, and for what purpose? Better by far to simply claim family privilege and keep the coffin closed.

 

There would be a similar risk allowing Mrs. Hudson or Greg Lestrade to see the imposter. They knew Sherlock very well, and might notice some subtle difference, and wonder about it, and perhaps mention it to each other, and ....

  • Like 1
Posted

It seems to me that if they (Moftiss and/or Mycroft) wanted to use a non-Sherlock body, they'd have been far better off to see that the face was properly bashed in -- and I'm sure Molly would have been glad to oblige them in that regard.  In which case, the ridiculous part isn't using the body double, it's allowing John to see the real Sherlock after the fall.  So yeah, find a body that matches Sherlock's general description, give it a nice shampoo and set, bash in the face, and let John see that.  Then you can even have an open-casket funeral if anyone has the stomach for it, and you can certainly bury it in Sherlock's grave, no questions asked.

 

Come to think of it, if Moriarty considered the look-alike to be a loose end and therefore had him eliminated, I am vastly surprised that the body was left in such a recognizable condition.  Surely a suspicious look-alike could be a liability even when dead.  Why not eliminate him via a nice shotgun blast to the face?  (Which would also save Molly some work.)

 

Presumed answer to both points -- because you couldn't show it on the BBC, especially in Sherlock's time slot.  But still -- why give that explanation, when it raises far more questions than it answers?

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

As for the splattering, seems like the pool of blood might have sufficed.

 

In that case I don't think John would notice anything - he was fully concentrated on the fact that Sherlock jumped from the roof and going into shock.

 

That's another thing I've wondered; once someone recovers from shock, wouldn't they start noticing little details that didn't add up? Like there being blood but no bits, e.g. So I'm thinking the body had to be utterly convincing, or John would've started to suspect something after he recovered. For what that's worth.

 

 

Sorry but are cremations common in the UK?

I can't speak for the UK, but here in the US cremations are not really common, but are nevertheless considered perfectly normal. When a body is cremated, though, the ashes are often kept by the family, or scattered, or entombed in a special building full of little drawers. Although they could presumably be buried in a grave, I don't think that's common.

 

Just as a point of interest ... cremated remains at the national cemeteries, such as Arlington, are buried. Don't know about other cemeteries, though.

 

Presumed answer to both points -- because you couldn't show it on the BBC, especially in Sherlock's time slot.  But still -- why give that explanation, when it raises far more questions than it answers?

Mercy? They knew we would need something to occupy us through the next hiatus? :p

  • Like 2
Posted

Actually, the real reason is apparently that Moffat and Gatiss considered it a challenge to let John see and even touch the real Sherlock after he falls, and still believe that he's actually dead.

Posted

You mean ... they were only thinking about THEMSELVES? Not us long-suffering fans? How dare they.....

  • Like 1
  • 1 month later...
Posted

Considering that evidences about Sherlock's supposed guilt are circumstantial at best, why do you think he choose to become fugitive just like Moriarty's design? Why not cooperating with the unlawful arrest?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 232 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.