Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

Considering that evidences about Sherlock's supposed guilt are circumstantial at best, why do you think he choose to become fugitive just like Moriarty's design? Why not cooperating with the unlawful arrest?

I think it's because Sherlock knew it was Moriarty's plan to disgrace him, and he was doing what Moriarty wanted so that Moriarty would think he had the upper hand, and reveal himself. I think Moriarty wouldn't have agreed to the showdown until he thought he had Sherlock exactly where he wanted him.

  • Like 1
Posted

In that case, why Sherlock choose to engage Moriarty in his own game? What motivate Sherlock to tangle with the infamous consulting criminal?

Posted

He believed that if Moriarty thought he had Sherlock beaten, he would let his guard down and reveal his actual plan -- which would allow Sherlock to figure out Moriarty's weak spot and therefore be able to beat him.  (Sherlock tells Anderson, "I had to make him believe he’d beaten me, utterly defeated me, and then he’d show his hand.")

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Sorry but it is an explanation why he did it but not what motivate him to play (for the sake of beating Moriarty) instead of letting the bubble burst by its own unsustainable for long nature itself.

Posted

I agree that Moriarty wouldn't have been able to sustain his "Sherlock is a phony" charade for long.  But that lie wasn't what Sherlock was fighting -- he was just using that confrontation as a wedge to take Moriarty (and his organization) down altogether.

 

Posted

^^ That's it. And why he decided to do that? I cannot find a hint of his reasoning in the series, or maybe I missed it altogether. :mellow:

  • Like 1
Posted

In that case, why Sherlock choose to engage Moriarty in his own game? What motivate Sherlock to tangle with the infamous consulting criminal?

I agree that Moriarty wouldn't have been able to sustain his "Sherlock is a phony" charade for long.  But that lie wasn't what Sherlock was fighting -- he was just using that confrontation as a wedge to take Moriarty (and his organization) down altogether.

^^ That's it. And why he decided to do that? I cannot find a hint of his reasoning in the series, or maybe I missed it altogether. :mellow:

Why does he choose to fight crime rather than being a poet, philosopher or pirate, you mean? :smile: Moriarty was blowing up innocent people, enabling criminals, threatening John ... those are the reasons I can think of for why Sherlock would want to eliminate him and his network. But why he chooses to play such games; that's as many theories about that as there are about Reichenbach, I think! He's on the side of the angels, that's about all the explanation we get.

  • Like 2
Posted

So really there's no explanation or even a hint about his motivation so far in the series?

  • Like 1
Posted

If you mean, why does Sherlock see himself as a dragon slayer, I think it goes back to his childhood, when he wanted to be a pirate.  No matter what he thinks, he's a romantic at heart -- and yes, he's chosen to be "on the side of the angels."

 

Why does anybody do anything?

 

  • Like 3
Posted

So really there's no explanation or even a hint about his motivation so far in the series?

 

Not an exact one, I'm afraid.

As Carol wondered: Why does anybody does anything? I think Sherlock has a very complex mind so maybe - if asked - he wouldn't even be able to clearly name his own motivations why he does what he does either!

Maybe some more details will be revealed during S4 ...

 

By the way, does ACD himself say anything about Sherlock's motivations why he solves crimes instead of committing them?

  • Like 1
Posted

A very emphatic 'Nope' (imagine a popped P) there! In at least two of the stories he exclaims (one being the Bruce Partington-Plans and the other The Man with the Twisted Lip, that he could have made an excellent criminal, if he had chosen the dark side. Does anyone think that Lucas, being British, essentially based Anakin/Darth Vader on the duality of Holmes's psyche? Mary reads something like that off Dr Watson's blog in TEH.

  • Like 1
Posted

..... Bored to the point of start to nitpick....

 

That decision actually tactically make sense but still I wonder if there's another explanation outside of pragmatism in the long run.

  • Like 1
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

 

.... Just how high Sherlock was supposed to fall in this episode? After looking at a real case and it is only 10 metres, I am curious about it.

Posted

I don't know the distance in meters or feet, but it's a four-story building, built back when ceilings were higher, so I'd guess somewhere around 50 feet (15 meters).

 

 

 

Posted
:mellow: I see...
Posted

Sherlock 'jumped' face down from the roof, how come that it would be make sense if his 'corpse' lies on his back/side on the pavement?

Posted

They just showed this episode on PBS again tonite; I think this must be only the 2nd or 3rd time I've seen the American broadcast version (mostly I've watched it on DVD). It's amazing how many scenes they cut from it. Not to the point where it interferes with the story, but it's still jarring when you're not expecting it!

 

The ad leading up to it, I was acutely aware of what many others have mentioned; when I see Sherlock, I don't see Benedict. At. All. I didn't even realize what I was seeing for a moment. Interesting, that.

 

I'm still puzzled why John is so hostile to Mycroft in their first meeting in the Diogenes Club. You'd think he be concerned about Sherlock, and maybe thank Mycroft for warning him, but instead he walks out like he has no intention whatsoever to do anything to protect Sherlock. 'Tis a puzzlement.

 

And I still don't quite get the significance of the hidden camera in 221B. It never leads anywhere, nor am I ever sure who planted it; Mycroft, Jim, or one of the assassins?

 

In answer to Shadow's question; Sherlock's not on his back until the emergency personnel roll him over; he's sort of on his front/side until then. Two ideas; I'm guessing bodies bounce a bit, disarranging the limbs. And I'm also guessing all but the most dedicated suicides instinctively adopt a defensive posture as the ground approaches? Something I hope never to find out first hand, but that's my thinking.

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Defensive posture like curling into a ball? I find it strange that Sherlock at least didn't try to mimic the crumpled posture and or the kind of disarray of limbs that come from bouncing on a hard surface.

 

:mellow: This curiosity probably also suit the thread 'My obsession is bad'.

Posted

Something like curling into a ball, yes. I would think one's instinct would be to protect one's head. And he was in disarray ....
F2riUVI.jpg?1

  • Like 1
Posted

So really there's no explanation or even a hint about his motivation so far in the series?

 

My guess,

While we (if I can speak for anyone) adore Sherlock, it's still a fact that there is something very dark about him. Someone who 'enjoys' murder and being able to detach himself from the pain, fear and suffering of the victims is certainly not a common bloke.

 

I'd say his motivation is simply that he enjoys it, it stimulates his mind and he can't live without it. Peaceful is boring and almost hateful for him. He is raised right and has good influences around him, but sometimes I think what makes him choose the side of an angel is not only that. He enjoys solving crime, which is imho, is on higher range and more exciting mind game than creating one. It's easier to create problem than solving it, isn't it?

So Sherlock would find opportunity to beat Moriarty on his own game is very appealing.

 

 

Something like curling into a ball, yes. I would think one's instinct would be to protect one's head. And he was in disarray ....F2riUVI.jpg?1

Very limited knowledge, but I had seen (not in close proxomity thank goodness) someone fell from second story and died on spot while there are quite a lot of case people survive from higher fall, like several cases of people survived a skydiving incident when parachute didn't open, normal range for skydiving that I'm aware of is 10000 to 14000 feet.

In middle range, few stories building, I stayed in a place where suicide or fatal accidents from apartment is not uncommon thing.

 

So... I don't know what to conclude actually...oh my..:blanket:

  • Like 3
Posted

Well, it could be just a cinematic decision. It would look rather funny if he lied on the pavement outstretched like a bear-shaped-rug. Plus his face would be damaged, and we needed his face to recognize him. Of course we know he haven't fallen at all, but to fake damaged face would be much harder to achieve.

  • Like 1
Posted

He enjoys solving crime, which is imho, is on higher range and more exciting mind game than creating one. It's easier to create problem than solving it, isn't it?

So Sherlock would find opportunity to beat Moriarty on his own game is very appealing.

 

That's a very astute observation! I think you may be absolutely right about that.

 

I had seen (not in close proxomity thank goodness) someone fell from second story and died on spot while there are quite a lot of case people survive from higher fall, like several cases of people survived a skydiving incident when parachute didn't open, normal range for skydiving that I'm aware of is 10000 to 14000 feet.

In middle range, few stories building, I stayed in a place where suicide or fatal accidents from apartment is not uncommon thing.

 

Apparently there are all sorts of factors involved, not just distance. Wikipedia has some interesting examples.

 

Of course we know he haven't fallen at all, but to fake damaged face would be much harder to achieve.

 

If we accept the gist of Sherlock's explanation to Anderson, then he did fall, he just cheated on the landing.   ;)   But yes, faking a face-first landing would've been both difficult and pointless. I'm just as glad that he went for a minimalist approach.

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm just as glad that he went for a minimalist approach.

Me too!

 

And that minimalist approach still makes me shudder everytime I remember my first watch, wrongly spoiled, thinking that Sherlock is indeed dead.

It doesn't help that I am a GoT watcher/reader.

Posted

Somebody told you that Sherlock died in this episode?  Ouch!  Were they confused, or just being mean?

 

Guess I'm lucky that I saw it with no preliminary input from other viewers -- just watched what happened in the episode -- and was pretty sure all along that he was faking.  I mean 1) he's the title character of the series, and 2) he's Sherlock Holmes, for pete's sake!  Oh, and 3) I'd just read "The Empty House."  ;)

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 237 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.