Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

apparently it‘s a no turning back decision and it broke my telly life

 

 

And i have no intention watching anything else bcs even multiple rewatch is better than other crap telly. I am cursed.

 

But how glad i am to find this place after frantically searching for other victims and realise i am not alone. Greetings.

Forgive my English as it‘s not my first languange, i am from half a globe away and i sleep while most of you are awake and vice versa. Have many thoughts to contribute, don't have the luxury of free time but hopefully i can get active.

VBS, who gave you a copy of my mind?   :o
It must be  :moriarty:
 
 
Thank goodness this series is full of death-fakers. The loss of a single one of them would break my heart. (Except maybe Donovan)
 
Actually i dont even watch any TV at all bcos it is such a waste of time and i dont have much of it.  But I make time to watch Sherlock now.
I hate watching this in 20-minute installments but am even reduced to doing that when the withdrawal sets in unbearably. 
Im glad though that i am not watching this on TV, as i need the luxury of replaying scenes that i love and catching dialogue that i missed. Watching Sherlock on TV would be to me like being taken to the most exotic place on earth and then offered just an aerial view.
 
" I am cursed" yes i hear you, i am  cursed too. scarred for life. :(  but im loving it :)
  • Like 3
Posted
I have read through a good number of posts on TRF here  - but there's LOTs of them and I dont think i can read them all without losing myself in the mire of thoughts - and this may have been raised before, but why should the Chief Superintendent be so shocked on learning Lestrade has been consulting Holmes on official cases? Early in the episode, Lestrade felicitated Holmes in a public ceremony which was on newspaper front pages, and which is where he gave Sherlock that 'ear hat', so literally the whole world knew, so why wouldn't Lestrade's own boss know? If it was such a crime to consult "private eyes" on cases surely this felicitation ceremony wouldn't have happened? 

Did they really allow such an obvious and material flaw to slip through?  :( Or am i missing something?

  • Like 1
Posted

Because he bowed to the pressure of public opinion. Think what would happen if he insist that Sherlock is innocent, without investigating first about the accusation brought by some of his officers. Think about what would happen to teamwork in the future if he dismissed his people's concern without giving them more or less satisfying conclusion. Such thing also would paint him in a bad light and from there many things could happen. It is a political move on his part.

  • Like 2
Posted

What was the significance of the Baker Street assassins being killed when they touched Sherlock? In the first such instance, Sherlock tells John "he was killed because I shook his hand"..

Posted

Getting rid of cheating competitor.

Posted

But then why should they wait until someone has actually touched Sherlock to kill him?  

sorry im a little dimmer than usual today (stayed up late last night as i simply had to finish watching this, and then couldnt sleep afterwards!) 

Posted

@Arcadia: wrong person, I am as innocent as 'Father Holmes' who barged into Irene Adler's Belgravia house. O:)

If "Father Holmes" was innocent, then I'm a tree. :p

 

 

I have read through a good number of posts on TRF here  - but there's LOTs of them and I dont think i can read them all without losing myself in the mire of thoughts - and this may have been raised before, but why should the Chief Superintendent be so shocked on learning Lestrade has been consulting Holmes on official cases? Early in the episode, Lestrade felicitated Holmes in a public ceremony which was on newspaper front pages, and which is where he gave Sherlock that 'ear hat', so literally the whole world knew, so why wouldn't Lestrade's own boss know? If it was such a crime to consult "private eyes" on cases surely this felicitation ceremony wouldn't have happened? 
Did they really allow such an obvious and material flaw to slip through?  :( Or am i missing something?

 

I don't think you're missing anything, I think it's just one of those plot points you're supposed to accept for the sake of streamlining the action. :smile: But Shadow makes some good points, and really, did that Superintendent strike you as being the brightest bulb in the box? :D I can easily imagine him missing and/or ignoring everything that goes on under his nose, until it potentially affects HIS career. (Interesting how I can form such a strong opinion of a man in 2-3 five second scenes!)

 

 

But then why should they wait until someone has actually touched Sherlock to kill him?  

sorry im a little dimmer than usual today (stayed up late last night as i simply had to finish watching this, and then couldnt sleep afterwards!) 

Professional courtesy???? :blink: No need to kill a rival unless they actually make a move to BE a rival?

 

I admit that plot thread still leaves me a bit confused ... the two sets of assassins is one set too many for my poor little brain to handle.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

apparently it‘s a no turning back decision and it broke my telly life

 

 

And i have no intention watching anything else bcs even multiple rewatch is better than other crap telly. I am cursed.

 

But how glad i am to find this place after frantically searching for other victims and realise i am not alone. Greetings.

Forgive my English as it‘s not my first languange, i am from half a globe away and i sleep while most of you are awake and vice versa. Have many thoughts to contribute, don't have the luxury of free time but hopefully i can get active.

VBS, who gave you a copy of my mind?   :o
It must be  :moriarty:
 
 
Thank goodness this series is full of death-fakers. The loss of a single one of them would break my heart. (Except maybe Donovan)
 
Actually i dont even watch any TV at all bcos it is such a waste of time and i dont have much of it.  But I make time to watch Sherlock now.
I hate watching this in 20-minute installments but am even reduced to doing that when the withdrawal sets in unbearably. 
Im glad though that i am not watching this on TV, as i need the luxury of replaying scenes that i love and catching dialogue that i missed. Watching Sherlock on TV would be to me like being taken to the most exotic place on earth and then offered just an aerial view.
 
" I am cursed" yes i hear you, i am  cursed too. scarred for life. :(  but im loving it :)

 

Oh hi and welcome, nice to have someone who understands.

Actually, we are not alone here. This place is good, it gives opportunity to talk about the show over and over again, it's also kind of frustrating that it makes it more difficult to forget about Sherlock. But I don't want to anyway.

 

Same here! I replayed a lot of scene; because it cracks me up, or because I have trouble understanding the dialogue.

Most of all, because it's so good.

 

I actually have Sherlock series permanently in all my devices.

:lol: at seeing the most exotic place on earth just from aerial view (actually I don't mind that at all!)

 

P.S. Some of us are doing rewatching and next week is TRF.

  • Like 2
Posted

I have read through a good number of posts on TRF here  - but there's LOTs of them and I dont think i can read them all without losing myself in the mire of thoughts - and this may have been raised before, but why should the Chief Superintendent be so shocked on learning Lestrade has been consulting Holmes on official cases? Early in the episode, Lestrade felicitated Holmes in a public ceremony which was on newspaper front pages, and which is where he gave Sherlock that 'ear hat', so literally the whole world knew, so why wouldn't Lestrade's own boss know? If it was such a crime to consult "private eyes" on cases surely this felicitation ceremony wouldn't have happened?

 

Dear me, you've got a good point there (and I don't believe it's been raised before)!  Shadow may be right -- somebody might have been rattling the Chief Superintendent's cage -- or there may be more to it than that.  (But Arcadia must be running a fever -- since when did we ever just accept a plot point?  :P )

 

It used to annoy me when a new member posted something without reading the whole thread first -- but that was back when this thread was maybe five pages long, so absolutely no apologies are needed at this point!

 

What was the significance of the Baker Street assassins being killed when they touched Sherlock? In the first such instance, Sherlock tells John "he was killed because I shook his hand"..

 

I think it's because Moriarty had told each of them that he had given the keycode to Sherlock.  They assumed it was something physical, so they thought the handshake was actually him handing the keycode over -- so they tried to stop that happening.  As long as Sherlock still had the keycode, each of them figured that they still had a chance of getting their hands on it.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Donovan and Anderson's accusation was the Met's internal matter, but the Superintendent's decision to arrest Sherlock (and make a circus of it) even before the official investigation begin is a mistake on his part. He might choose to sacrifice a few people rather than braving the storm but in light of the revelation about Sherlock's innocence in The Empty Hearse, I would be surprised if that not become at least a black mark on his record.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

Dear me, you've got a good point there (and I don't believe it's been raised before)!  Shadow may be right -- somebody might have been rattling the Chief Superintendent's cage -- or there may be more to it than that.  (But Arcadia must be running a fever -- since when did we ever just accept a plot point?  :P )

 

Does anyone have a cold compress? :sofa2:

 

In my own defense, I did say supposed to accept, not will accept!

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm re-watching tonight before my brother & his family arrive tomorrow.  John's last line before the opening credits still gets me every time even if there are no tears at this point.  It is done well with such emotion.  Now to watch Sherlock deduce the jury :)

  • Like 1
Posted

I still love Sherlock's & Moriarty's choreographed turn in their respective cells.

 

Just now noticing the video feed interference as Sherlock and gang leave Baker St to deal with the missing children.

 

I also like every time Sherlock gets mad (in any episode), he reminds me of Smaug & Khan.

 

How about another name for the Cumbersplat to reflect the character that got splat: Splatlock.

 

And as you watch, you remember that track 18 of the S2 soundtrack is called "Blood on Pavement".

 

John's emotion at the end (and beginning) of the episode....feels

  • Like 1
Posted

I had to watch early too, not sure when my next chance will be.
 
Soooo ... Carol and I were having a discussion over in the "Best episodes" thread (it starts right around here if you want to look at it) where I was bemoaning the fact that TEH has kind of ruined Reichenbach for me.
 
Alas, after this rewatch I still feel the same way ... some of the emotional resonance has been robbed, for me, because I'm so aware that Sherlock (and Mycroft) are much farther ahead in the game than it would appear from what we see onscreen. In other words, things are not quite as desperate as they seem. And it seems crueller than ever to leave John out of the loop, I don't care how bad a liar he is.
 
Oh well, it's still an exciting cat and mouse episode. They really did kill Jim off too soon; it's a thrill to watch him and Sherlock fence. And Sherlock's even scarier than Jim in a couple of scenes; at Kitty Riley's flat, and when Sherlock is staring Jim down on the roof; I wouldn't want to face that!
 
I'm still bothered by the 2 sets of assassins; it's unnecessarily confusing, imo, and the ones "protecting" Sherlock don't really make sense. Why protect him? Why not try to get the code from him by any means necessary?
 
And I still don't understand why John was so hostile to Mycroft when the latter informed him of the assassins' presence. It's like John resented being asked to look out for Sherlock! :blink:  But I think I finally figured out why that scene exists; Mycroft needed John (and by extension, the audience) to believe that he and Sherlock were not on good enough terms to work together, so that later, John wouldn't suspect Mycroft had something to do with Sherlock's "death". Or something like that.
 
Other stuff (I think I've forgotten half the questions I had while watching, though... :(
 
-- I noticed the assassin watching John looks similar to Sherlock when in profile, due to the fuzzy hair. Could he be ... the Other One? And that's why he was "persuaded" (in TEH) to stand down, instead of being killed outright? Probably not, but that's what occurred to me
 
-- Also, it's not really clear that he IS watching John; the way it's filmed, it's just possible he's watching Lestrade, in which case we never see the assassin who was watching John.
 
-- I've always thought -- and still do -- that Sherlock is manipulating Molly when he goes to her. However, I think he was genuinely stung when she said earlier "I don't count" -- he realized that once again his callousness wounds her, and she doesn't deserve that. So when he says "You do count," I think he's being truthful ... she counts, because she's a human being. But he also says it because he knows it will get him what he wants, her cooperation.
 
-- I do think Sherlock was hoping Jim would be convicted at the trial, so he wouldn't have to go through with the rest of his plan. 
 
-- On the other hand, if the goal was to take down Moriarty's network, then Sherlock had to "die" under any circumstance. But it occurred to me ... maybe that part came later. First, he just had to survive the confrontation with Jim. Then later, what with Mycroft noticing that he has an unemployed detective underfoot, he convinces Sherlock to stay undercover and go after the network. I like this idea because it makes Mycroft the cold-hearted b *st*d here instead of Sherlock. Well, okay, they share the title.

 

-- I know there's more but I can't think of them ....

  • Like 1
Posted

It still scars me..

 

I don't cry, had my tonsils removed long time ago, and pretty sure I'm not growing adam's apple, but..

 

There is a lump in my throat.

...

 

See you guys in Many Happy Returns.

  • Like 1
Posted

It still scars me..

It is pretty graphic, in its way. I'm a little blue myself. Poor John, it's horrible for him.

 

Think how much worse it would be if they hadn't shown us Sherlock alive and well at the very end. The Moftisses do have a merciful streak after all! :)

  • Like 1
Posted

John's assassin was the guy in the stairwell, Lestrade's assassin was in the cubicle and both were on screen for briefly with the stairwell guy getting the most on screen time.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

It still scars me..

It is pretty graphic, in its way. I'm a little blue myself. Poor John, it's horrible for him.

 

Think how much worse it would be if they hadn't shown us Sherlock alive and well at the very end. The Moftisses do have a merciful streak after all! :)

Gosh.. that would definitely drive me nut like a brown..!

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm still bothered by the 2 sets of assassins; it's unnecessarily confusing, imo, and the ones "protecting" Sherlock don't really make sense. Why protect him? Why not try to get the code from him by any means necessary?

 

The freelance assassins "protecting" Sherlock don't care about him -- they're just after the keycode and each of them wants to be the (only) one to get it from him.  After that, I doubt that they give a damn what happens to him.

 

The other assassins work for Moriarty, and in this episode they're assigned to be ready to shoot Sherlock's friends if he doesn't jump.

  • Like 1
Posted

I had to watch early too, not sure when my next chance will be.

 

 

-- I've always thought -- and still do -- that Sherlock is manipulating Molly when he goes to her. However, I think he was genuinely stung when she said earlier "I don't count" -- he realized that once again his callousness wounds her, and she doesn't deserve that. So when he says "You do count," I think he's being truthful ... she counts, because she's a human being. But he also says it because he knows it will get him what he wants, her cooperation.

 

 

I will always have to disagree with this.  I think it's the one of the first times he lets his guard down with another human being because he genuinely is afraid for his life.  However, under the circumstances where so much has been leaked about him to the press, he has to test her to see if she is still on his side, and she says twice, "What do you need?" without even questioning him or  asking him to clarify anything because so steadfast is her faith and trust in who he is, then he can truly say "You."  Because he knows she's a friend through thick and thin.  So, I don't see it at as a manipulation, and Mofftiss has always said that he was being totally genuine in that moment.

 

Also, because of her blog and that she's aware of him trying to flatter her into doing things for him, I don't see him truly being able to manipulate her.  She is a willing participant in whatever help she can offer him.

  • Like 1
Posted

John's assassin was the guy in the stairwell, Lestrade's assassin was in the cubicle and both were on screen for briefly with the stairwell guy getting the most on screen time.

That's what I think too ... but the image of the guy in the cubicle was so fleeting, and so ambiguous, I'm just saying it could mean something else. A deliberate red herring to make us think he was Lestrade's assassin, when really it was the guy in the stairwell; which means there's an assassin we didn't see. I don't really believe that, I just keep holding out hope there's more to the explanation for the "Reichenbach deception".

 

 

I'm still bothered by the 2 sets of assassins; it's unnecessarily confusing, imo, and the ones "protecting" Sherlock don't really make sense. Why protect him? Why not try to get the code from him by any means necessary?

 

The freelance assassins "protecting" Sherlock don't care about him -- they're just after the keycode and each of them wants to be the (only) one to get it from him.  After that, I doubt that they give a damn what happens to him.

 

The other assassins work for Moriarty, and in this episode they're assigned to be ready to shoot Sherlock's friends if he doesn't jump.

 

 

Oh, I understand that ... what I mean is, since the first set of assassins were there for the key code, why didn't any of them try to get it? And why send assassins for that anyway -- their job is to kill people, not get information from them.

 

Oh ... THOSE assassins weren't there to get the information! They were just there to kill anyone who did try! Carol, as a conductor of light you are unbeatable. Of course, that finally makes sense! :cowdance:

 

I still find the two sets of assassins needlessly confusing, but then, maybe they're meant to be, to keep you guessing as to what's going on? If so, it sure worked on me!

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I had to watch early too, not sure when my next chance will be.

 

 

-- I've always thought -- and still do -- that Sherlock is manipulating Molly when he goes to her. However, I think he was genuinely stung when she said earlier "I don't count" -- he realized that once again his callousness wounds her, and she doesn't deserve that. So when he says "You do count," I think he's being truthful ... she counts, because she's a human being. But he also says it because he knows it will get him what he wants, her cooperation.

 

 

I will always have to disagree with this.  I think it's the one of the first times he lets his guard down with another human being because he genuinely is afraid for his life.  However, under the circumstances where so much has been leaked about him to the press, he has to test her to see if she is still on his side, and she says twice, "What do you need?" without even questioning him or  asking him to clarify anything because so steadfast is her faith and trust in who he is, then he can truly say "You."  Because he knows she's a friend through thick and thin.  So, I don't see it at as a manipulation, and Mofftiss has always said that he was being totally genuine in that moment.

 

Also, because of her blog and that she's aware of him trying to flatter her into doing things for him, I don't see him truly being able to manipulate her.  She is a willing participant in whatever help she can offer him.

 

 

Well, let me put it this way ... I would like you to be right!

Posted

Then agree to agree with me.

  • Like 1
Posted
Arcadia:

-- Also, it's not really clear that he (the sniper) IS watching John; the way it's filmed, it's just possible he's watching Lestrade, in which case we never see the assassin who was watching John.

 

Good observation. :)

 

sfmpco:

I will always have to disagree with this.  I think it's the one of the first times he lets his guard down with another human being because he genuinely is afraid for his life.  However, under the circumstances where so much has been leaked about him to the press, he has to test her to see if she is still on his side, and she says twice, "What do you need?" without even questioning him or  asking him to clarify anything because so steadfast is her faith and trust in who he is, then he can truly say "You."  Because he knows she's a friend through thick and thin.  So, I don't see it at as a manipulation, and Mofftiss has always said that he was being totally genuine in that moment.

 

Still, I have a just a little bit doubt. He was lying and manipulating so many times, he risks that when being honest nobody will believe him. Good that Molly is such a believer.

  • Like 1
Posted

My observations:

 

1 Coffee! In the tower, the jail, Bank of England, Lestrade: every one has a cup of coffee, but none of them was drunk in the end. Funny detail - can that mean something?

2 Jim using the Diamond - first I thought it was genius, but then probably it wouldn't work in normal circumstances. First, the glass has probably a foil glued inside, making it impossible to go trough, even if the glass itself is broken. Second, hitting the diamond with the fire-extinguisher must have been really precise, so the glass was fist hit by the diamond and not by the bottom of the "bottle". And those "bottles" will hardly have a perfectly even bottoms.

3 The break in - story wise it is directly after Jim was released by Mycroft. Somehow didn't pay attention to that before.

4 The bubble-gum scene. If I was that woman, I'd probably headbutt Jim for that look. :)

5 Kitty Riley - I think it is the first person, who Sherlock openly despise. His deductions are deliberately hurtful.

6 Just wonder if the mention of Bach standing up from his deathbed to finish his work is a hint for Jim's return - in whichever way it may happen.

7 Jim uses the term Pressure Point (someone that they want to protect from harm) Is it, by any chance, a hint of his connection to CAM?

8 Andrew is apparently left handed. Martin still confuses me.

9 After Sherlock picks up the apple with IOU, there is a little hint of smile on his face.

10 Repeat of 1972? What's that?

11 Mycroft's room - the set must be a different building - there was no medieval-like stone arabesque blends on the Diogenes Club house.

12 John mocks/confronts Mycroft. It seems he is one of the few people who don't find Myc scary.

13 Spotted 1x twiddling: The Grimms Fairy Tales; 3x sniffing: the oil in the boy's room, the candy wrap, Kitty's hand.

14 The Looking Sad dialogue - Sherlock is really surprised when Molly says "I don't count". He is trying to behave normal all by himself and isn't really good at it.

15 Sherlock doesn't have a clue about the Solar System, but he knows fairy tales!

16 Finding the factory where the children were held: What the hell is it with that Rhododendron. What matches? There is one outside of Mycroft's living room window. wtf.gif
 
17 The mercury thing - a bit complicated, it cannot be mercury in it's metallic state, so some kind of salt, still cannot find anything being toxic within hours after eaten AND having a distinctive smell/taste.

18 Jim as a Cabbie: sooo creepy! His dark eyes looking plain black, like buttons with that one spot of light. Gives me shivers. But I still wonder how John was able to follow Sherlock without knowing where he's going. "Please follow that cab" scenario?

19 Jumping over the fence / the we-have-to-coordinate scene: isn't it how the relationship between Sherlock and John (or rest of the universe) looks like?

20 The scene at Kitty's - I think I have written everything already, about how great it is.

21 At Bart's, the call about Mrs Hudson being shot: the look on Sherlock's face and his calmness made me believe the call was his idea to get John away. I believed it quite a long time.

22 The roof scene: well, the fact that I don't know what Sherlock knows, what is genuine emotional reaction and what is acting for Jim - that still drives me crazy. There are so many loose ends in that episode, they should be addressed somewhere, some time...
But I still enjoy the choreography of that, first Jim having the upper hand, circles around Sherlock like a shark, then the roles change - the active and passive side, attacker and defender - depicted by movement. Love that. Also like how the weather seems to play with the scene, starting with sun and ending in rain. I know it was not intended (more of a nuisance to the crew) but it turned out fantastic.

23 I can hardly believe that Myctroft was believing in Jim's universal code. It somehow support the theory that the whole game was indeed a plan made by Holmes Bros. Inluded Sherlock's death, which made him able to go after Moriarty's network.

24 Mycroft in the Diogenes club after he closes the newspaper, he makes Sherlock's gesture of thinking.

25 The graveyard scene: I think now, that what John is saying was actually a homework he'd got from Ella. "Say the things you wanted to say". That's why it looks a bit forced and stiff (along with John not being able to talk about feelings without making it into speech)
And Martin is soo good in that. No outbursts of despair - just loosing voice. I know that.

  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 237 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.