Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Reichenbach Fall?"  

125 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

1 Coffee! In the tower, the jail, Bank of England, Lestrade: every one has a cup of coffee, but none of them was drunk in the end. Funny detail - can that mean something?

 

It strikes me as merely a dramatic theme. By the way, it's presumably tea rather than coffee. The Tower guard refers to "a cuppa," which in England typically means tea. Can't say for sure, though.

 

2 Jim using the Diamond - first I thought it was genius, but then probably it wouldn't work in normal circumstances. First, the glass has probably a foil glued inside, making it impossible to go trough, even if the glass itself is broken. Second, hitting the diamond with the fire-extinguisher must have been really precise, so the glass was fist hit by the diamond and not by the bottom of the "bottle". And those "bottles" will hardly have a perfectly even bottoms.

 

And a jeweler friend of mine says that hitting a diamond hard enough to fracture the glass would generally fracture the diamond instead. But what the heck, it's a really cool scene!

 

4 The bubble-gum scene. If I was that woman, I'd probably headbutt Jim for that look. :)

 

Think I'd have used my knee as nature intended! (Either that, or thrown up on his Italian handmade shoes.)

 

8 Andrew is apparently left handed. Martin still confuses me.

 

John seems to be somewhat ambidextrous, in the sense that he's been able to learn certain things right-handed (presumably because his instructors taught him that way). But handedness is rarely 100%, so most people define theirs by which hand they write with, and virtually all of Martin Freeman's characters write with their left hand. Also, Mr. Freeman describes himself as left-handed.

 

10 Repeat of 1972? What's that?

 

If you find out, please let me know!

 

11 Mycroft's room - the set must be a different building - there was no medieval-like stone arabesque blends on the Diogenes Club house.

 

Mycroft seems to have at least two "offices" -- one above ground in the Diogenes Club, and one apparently below ground but possibly in the same building. Now I'm thinking it might be more than two -- gonna go start a thread!

 

16 Finding the factory where the children were held: What the hell is it with that Rhododendron. What matches? There is one outside of Mycroft's living room window.

 

Sherlock specifically identifies the plant material in the kidnapper's footprints as Rhododendron ponticum. Admittedly, this species is also known as common rhododendron, but it's possible that Mycroft has a different species at his home. Also, it wasn't just the rhododendron, it was also chalky soil, chocolate, and -- umm, something else.

 

17 The mercury thing - a bit complicated, it cannot be mercury in it's metallic state, so some kind of salt, still cannot find anything being toxic within hours after eaten AND having a distinctive smell/taste.

 

Interesting. But why do you say it can't be in the metallic form?

 

21 At Bart's, the call about Mrs Hudson being shot: the look on Sherlock's face and his calmness made me believe the call was his idea to get John away. I believed it quite a long time.

 

Me too. (And I still see it that way on alternate Thursdays.) But assuming that the Moftisses were following canon in this particular situation, then the call was Moriarty's doing -- and Holmes immediately identified it as such. This may have suited Sherlock's purposes just as well as it did Jim's, which makes his facial expression somewhat misleading.

 

There are so many loose ends in that episode, they should be addressed somewhere, some time...

 

Oh please no!  :o  Moftiss already drove us nuts with their idea of explanations in "The Empty Hearse." Not sure I could take any more!

 

Posted

... and the two remaining quotes that the software wouldn't let me include in the preceding post:

 

23 I can hardly believe that Mycroft was believing in Jim's universal code. It somehow support the theory that the whole game was indeed a plan made by Holmes Bros.

 

I don't see how Mycroft could have swallowed that idea either (even if he's not an expert, he surely has people who are). But I still think the keycode was Moriarty's idea -- Mycroft just pretended to go along with it.
 

25 The graveyard scene: I think now, that what John is saying was actually a homework he'd got from Ella. "Say the things you wanted to say". That's why it looks a bit forced and stiff (along with John not being able to talk about feelings without making it into speech)
And Martin is soo good in that. No outbursts of despair - just loosing voice.

 

Good call on the "homework" -- John was finally able to say those things that he couldn't at Ella's office. Come to think of it, this further confirms the idea that the graveyard scene takes place a while after Sherlock's "death" -- for one thing, the soil over the grave is no longer mounded, it's level (although still bare). John has apparently moved out of Baker Street. And he's finally able to say things that he couldn't before.

I fully agree with you on Mr. Freeman's performance -- that scene still gets to me, every single time.

 

Posted

Is there a "Many Happy Returns" thread? I didn't see it in the Series 2 folder.

Posted

 

Is there a "Many Happy Returns" thread? I didn't see it in the Series 2 folder.

 

http://www.sherlockforum.com/forum/topic/1772-episode-30-many-happy-returns-7-min-mini-ep/

 

 

Whaddya know, I'm even subscribed to it. I totally forgot.  Thanks!

 

Let's not neglect that in our rewatch!

  • Like 1
Posted

 

sfmpco:

I will always have to disagree with this. I think it's the one of the first times he lets his guard down with another human being because he genuinely is afraid for his life. However, under the circumstances where so much has been leaked about him to the press, he has to test her to see if she is still on his side, and she says twice, "What do you need?" without even questioning him or asking him to clarify anything because so steadfast is her faith and trust in who he is, then he can truly say "You." Because he knows she's a friend through thick and thin. So, I don't see it at as a manipulation, and Mofftiss has always said that he was being totally genuine in that moment.

Still, I have a just a little bit doubt. He was lying and manipulating so many times, he risks that when being honest nobody will believe him. Good that Molly is such a believer.

 

Like "the boy who cried wolf." That's the one thing about his character I really take issue with; you can laugh at it at first, but it gets old after awhile. Is it too much to hope Moftiss will have him outgrow it?

 

5 Kitty Riley - I think it is the first person, who Sherlock openly despise. His deductions are deliberately hurtful.

I've always thought that was Sherlock deliberately antagonizing the press to help along the process of destroying his reputation. Any reporter would have received the same treatment, it didn't have to be Kitty.

 

13 Spotted 1x twiddling: The Grimms Fairy Tales; 3x sniffing: the oil in the boy's room, the candy wrap, Kitty's hand.

Also, flipping the cricket bat (or whatever that thing is!)

 

14 The Looking Sad dialogue - Sherlock is really surprised when Molly says "I don't count".

Yeah, I noticed that too, I really think he never thought of Molly as anyone of significance until that moment. Then suddenly he realizes she has observational skills too (because, of course, what else would he value in another human being? :D )

 

18 Jim as a Cabbie: sooo creepy! His dark eyes looking plain black, like buttons with that one spot of light. Gives me shivers. But I still wonder how John was able to follow Sherlock without knowing where he's going. "Please follow that cab" scenario?

Weren't they going back to Baker Street? So John's cab would have followed the same route, and they just happened on the scene a minute later. (?)

 

19 Jumping over the fence / the we-have-to-coordinate scene: isn't it how the relationship between Sherlock and John (or rest of the universe) looks like?

:lol5:

22 The roof scene: ... I still enjoy the choreography of that, first Jim having the upper hand, circles around Sherlock like a shark, then the roles change - the active and passive side, attacker and defender - depicted by movement. Love that. Also like how the weather seems to play with the scene, starting with sun and ending in rain. I know it was not intended (more of a nuisance to the crew) but it turned out fantastic.

Do you know, this is the first time I ever noticed the rain! I was amazed, how could I have missed it before?

 

I love the circling bit too. It's a really great confrontation scene, and the actors play off of each other sooooooo well. I'll bet they really enjoyed playing that scene.

Posted

 

4 The bubble-gum scene. If I was that woman, I'd probably headbutt Jim for that look. :)

Think I'd have used my knee as nature intended! (Either that, or thrown up on his Italian handmade shoes.)

 

Hear, hear. Don't you just want to smack him? :smile: (And this time I definitely mean slap, not kiss!)

 

 

10 Repeat of 1972? What's that?

If you find out, please let me know!

 

Me too, please!

 

 

21 At Bart's, the call about Mrs Hudson being shot: the look on Sherlock's face and his calmness made me believe the call was his idea to get John away. I believed it quite a long time.

Me too. (And I still see it that way on alternate Thursdays.) But assuming that the Moftisses were following canon in this particular situation, then the call was Moriarty's doing -- and Holmes immediately identified it as such. This may have suited Sherlock's purposes just as well as it did Jim's, which makes his facial expression somewhat misleading.

 

Me three.

Posted

Re: Martin's handedness: He's just like me! :D Actually, I am also left handed, but learned to write with my right hand, based on a very rational argument (it's more efficient). There are things I can do with both hands equally good, some time I prefer the right hand. I learned to work (mouse and keyboard) right handed (again: it's more efficient with the keyboard's layout), but I can switch if needed. What I cannot switch is holding my cuppa (left hand), so my mouse stays on the right side. :)

Posted

Same here (generally leftie but was taught to write with my right hand, and it shows) and I too have a right-hand mouse, mostly because I gave up finding a good ergonomic left-side mouse long ago. But some stuff, like drinking, or catching/throwing things, or using a modern phone/tablet, I just do instinctively with my left hand.

Posted
Interesting. But why do you say it can't be in the metallic form?

 

Because 1 you wouldn't be able to spread it on the wrap or candies, because it always builds heavy, metallic drops and sticks to nothing because of the high surface tension. 2 eating (or better said: drinking) the metal wouldn't do you any harm, 3 it is odorless and (probably) tasteless.

 

The vapors are toxic, but you need some metallic form to fume first.

 

Quicksilver chloride has a distinctive taste, but it is too poisonous and too quick. The same with cyanide.

 

Funny, it seems to be easier to research on weird topics. Simply Mercury/Quicksilver toxicity produces so many hits that you can get lost in it, much of the information is incomplete, some of it are contradictory. :huh:

 

To canon experts: was there any story with mercury written by ACD?

  • Like 3
Posted

Afaik, we had a chemistry professor perform an experiment on himself at the University of Vienna to prove that metallic mercury wasn't toxic (fuzzy on the details, though, as it was before my time there). He drank a whole glass of it in front of witnesses, or so our professor explained, and apart from the fact that he had to stay prone till it reached the other end (because the sheer weight might've harmed his intestines otherwise) he was right as rain throughout and after the experiment. So you're absolutely right about that, J.P. . Wouldn't know of any ACD stories featuring mercury, though.

  • Like 1
Posted

That is amazing.  So the furor over mercury fever thermometers was completely unfounded?  I see what you mean about it not being spreadable too -- being of the pre-furor generation, I've had the fun of playing with the drop of mercury that came out of a broken thermometer.
 
Not that this is relevant to the episode, but I'm not so sure that there would be no long-term effects from prolonged lower doses.  Wasn't the mercury in dental amalgam the metallic form?  It definitely acted as a nerve toxin on me (though I didn't realize it till I'd had all my amalgam fillings removed for other reasons).
 
As for ACD stories, Google came up with this one (not a Holmes story, far as I can tell). wherein the narrator discovers that bismuth can be transmuted into mercury -- with the reason that the alchemists failed having apparently been their lack of electrical power.  Also this little poem:
 
 

Mercury
 
Mercury -- now please to understand
It stimulates each gland
Used in induration
And also inflammation.

Posted

This may shed some light on the dental-amalgam question -- even though metallic mercury isn't toxic as such, its vapor is.  Chewing on the stuff could, I suppose, cause a vapor to form in one's mouth, where it could then be either swallowed or inhaled.  Actually, I think my biggest problem came from having a root canal packed with amalgam, where I'd assume the main exposure would take the form of something like osmosis.

 

Posted

The problem with metallic mercury is that it is evaporating in normal temperature. And the fume IS extremely toxic. Only in that big, big factory room, as in TRF, it would probably never be concentrated enough. If you have a drop that gets somewhere where you cannot extract it in your sleeping room - you would indeed have a problem, but it would be more a chronic one and it would show after a while.

I also remember playing with the metallic form as a kid, but it was under control of my dad. We also have had some broken thermometers. The contamination in water air and food in Silesia (Polish industrial region) was surely more of a problem in those days.

  • Like 1
Posted

Yes, the amalgam. Apparently the silver in the mix should prevent mercury to evaporate. But I am happy that all that stuff is gone from my teeth.

Posted

Re 1972

Still no idea. It was a very turbulent year - make your choice

 

 

J.P., on 06 Jul 2015 - 8:12 PM, said:snapback.png

There are so many loose ends in that episode, they should be addressed somewhere, some time...

 

Oh please no!  :o  Moftiss already drove us nuts with their idea of explanations in "The Empty Hearse." Not sure I could take any more!

 

Well, if I remember and understood right, Steven says Sherlock was lying all the time on the roof. But there still are some serious why-s. Like Sherlock's apparent panic attack after Jim shot himself. And that damn code. Because at least in John's presence Sherlock seems to believe that version.

I can live with the Big Blue (even if it has a big flaw because it was visible to Jim on the roof) or even with the option that the writer don't know how it happens. But somehow I have an impression that they had a scenario for that.

 

 

Me:

Still, I have a just a little bit doubt. He was lying and manipulating so many times, he risks that when being honest nobody will believe him.

Actually, I would love to see it in the show.

 

 

5 Kitty Riley - I think it is the first person, who Sherlock openly despise. His deductions are deliberately hurtful.

I've always thought that was Sherlock deliberately antagonizing the press to help along the process of destroying his reputation. Any reporter would have received the same treatment, it didn't have to be Kitty.

 

Yes, but it also means that Holmes Bros. were playing a game with John the whole time. A game that started at the end of HOB. Very nasty game. Poor John. Actually one can tell it was mirroring TGG, but now it was Jim who took the bait.

 

 

4 The bubble-gum scene. If I was that woman, I'd probably headbutt Jim for that look. :)


Think I'd have used my knee as nature intended! (Either that, or thrown up on his Italian handmade shoes.)

 

Hear, hear. Don't you just want to smack him? :smile: (And this time I definitely mean slap, not kiss!)

 

Slapping is too girly. He would enjoy that.

As a surprising alternative: lick his face in CAM style.

Posted

...if I remember and understood right, Steven says Sherlock was lying all the time on the roof. But there still are some serious why-s. Like Sherlock's apparent panic attack after Jim shot himself. And that damn code. Because at least in John's presence Sherlock seems to believe that version.

I can live with the Big Blue (even if it has a big flaw because it was visible to Jim on the roof) or even with the option that the writer don't know how it happens.

 

I don't think that's exactly what Mr. Moffat said, but I'm too tired right now to go get the actual quote.

 

Regarding the panic attack -- I think Sherlock realized he had used up all his alternatives.  He had been hoping right up till that moment that he could avoid "dying" but now there's no one left to negotiate with.

 

Of course Sherlock seemed to believe the code was real when John was around.  So did Mycroft.  That's their usual MO, isn't it -- fool John?

 

Second major flaw to Big Blue -- judging by the scenario that we are shown (from Sherlock's mind palace? Anderson's imagination?), Big Blue was clearly visible to John from his cab.

 

Posted

Regarding the panic attack -- I think Sherlock realized he had used up all his alternatives.  He had been hoping right up till that moment that he could avoid "dying" but now there's no one left to negotiate with.

 

If it was genuine, this was Sherlock's second confrontation with overwhelming emotion in quite short period of time. Poor Sherlock.

 

But - why should he panic, if the "dying" was one of the anticipated "13 scenarios"?

I seriously doubt he was so upset because he was going to betray John. This is not how he thinks.

Was Lazarus so dangerous? It was not the first time Sherlock faced possible death.

And I don't have the impression he would "allow" himself having fear of heights.

 

 

Of course Sherlock seemed to believe the code was real when John was around.  So did Mycroft.  That's their usual MO, isn't it -- fool John?

 

Well, I wish I knew. :wacko:

 

 

Second major flaw to Big Blue -- judging by the scenario that we are shown (from Sherlock's mind palace? Anderson's imagination?), Big Blue was clearly visible to John from his cab.

 

thwow.gif OMG, OMG - you're right! :o

I cannot recall reading this before, nor I actually noticed!

 

Again - is it a plothole or a fan pitfall? 

 

BTW, I took a look at the credits - TRF was written by Stephen Thompson - the same who wrote TBB :blink:

 

PS: Sherlock has deduced both the diamond cufflinks and the tie pin just by shaking the boxes :D

Posted

The scene when they meet Molly at Bart's - Sherlock is quite nasty here, talking about her "relationship" with Jim (jealous again?). And he doesn't even try to manipulate her - he's very direct this time.

 

Ah, and again there are pictures from an electron microscope while he is analyzing the footprints.

Yes, as Carol pointed out in TGG thread, it is possible that it's not what he sees in HIS microscope, but the mental images of what he sees.

Posted

 

Me:

Still, I have a just a little bit doubt. He was lying and manipulating so many times, he risks that when being honest nobody will believe him.

Actually, I would love to see it in the show.

 

Someone doubting him because he's lied so many times before, you mean? So would I ... if he learned from it. Not if they just make a joke out of it.

 

Although they sort of did that at the end of TEH, with John ... who then went on to forgive him a little too quickly, imo. But that's what John seems to do, accept that Sherlock is what he is, which is one of his finer qualities, I suppose.

 

 

 

5 Kitty Riley - I think it is the first person, who Sherlock openly despise. His deductions are deliberately hurtful.

I've always thought that was Sherlock deliberately antagonizing the press to help along the process of destroying his reputation. Any reporter would have received the same treatment, it didn't have to be Kitty.

 

Yes, but it also means that Holmes Bros. were playing a game with John the whole time. A game that started at the end of HOB. Very nasty game. Poor John. Actually one can tell it was mirroring TGG, but now it was Jim who took the bait.

 

Yes, I'm afraid that's exactly what it means. Another reason TRF has slipped down a little bit in my list of favorites.

 

 

 

 

4 The bubble-gum scene. If I was that woman, I'd probably headbutt Jim for that look. :)

Think I'd have used my knee as nature intended! (Either that, or thrown up on his Italian handmade shoes.)

 

Hear, hear. Don't you just want to smack him? :smile: (And this time I definitely mean slap, not kiss!)

 

Slapping is too girly. He would enjoy that.

As a surprising alternative: lick his face in CAM style.

 

Ewwww!!!! No! I'm too girly for that ..... Actually, poking him in the tongue with a sharp object would have been rather satisfying.

Posted

 

...if I remember and understood right, Steven says Sherlock was lying all the time on the roof. But there still are some serious why-s. Like Sherlock's apparent panic attack after Jim shot himself. And that damn code. Because at least in John's presence Sherlock seems to believe that version.

I can live with the Big Blue (even if it has a big flaw because it was visible to Jim on the roof) or even with the option that the writer don't know how it happens.

 

I don't think that's exactly what Mr. Moffat said, but I'm too tired right now to go get the actual quote.

 

Never fear, Arcadia is here! :) Here's the exact quote from at least one article: "Whereas all of Sherlock’s emotion on the rooftop when he’s talking to John in “The Reichenbach Fall” is completely faked — he’s just trying to give his friend a bad time so he’ll be in an emotional state to believe what’s about to happen" source

 

Still, I think it's well to remember that Mr. Moffat tends to speak in grandiose terms, and it's quite possible that "all of Sherlock's emotion...is completely faked" actually means "some of his emotion...is mostly faked."

 

Regarding the panic attack -- I think Sherlock realized he had used up all his alternatives.  He had been hoping right up till that moment that he could avoid "dying" but now there's no one left to negotiate with.

 

Of course Sherlock seemed to believe the code was real when John was around.  So did Mycroft.  That's their usual MO, isn't it -- fool John?

 

Second major flaw to Big Blue -- judging by the scenario that we are shown (from Sherlock's mind palace? Anderson's imagination?), Big Blue was clearly visible to John from his cab.

I think we are supposed to believe that his view is blocked by the ambulance bay. I just go and assume that it is, it makes my life so much easier. :D

 

I still explain the "panic attack" as his reaction to seeing a man blow his brains out 5 inches from his face; a man that on some level he felt kinship with. If Sherlock ever had a death wish, this was a pretty graphic depiction of what giving in to it would be like.

 

I like to think, though, that he was hoping there would be another outcome that didn't involve faking his death. But since his whole plan for taking down Moriarty's network seemed to hinge on his being dead, I don't know why he would wish for another outcome; unless it was to spare John's feelings. But its seems pretty well established that he didn't take John's feelings into account.... aghgh, it's maddening!!

Posted

 

Someone doubting him because he's lied so many times before, you mean? So would I ... if he learned from it. Not if they just make a joke out of it.

 

Both ways could be interesting - but what I actually meant would be some important issue that would backfire on Sherlock because he's lied one time too many.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I think we are supposed to believe that his view is blocked by the ambulance bay. I just go and assume that it is, it makes my life so much easier. :D

Not sure if we should discuss Lazarus now or with TEH, but here it goes: The yellow line is showing the same spot on both pictures to show where the cab stopped. The red line is where the cab came from. The Big Blue was visible from cab's POV.

Of course we can assume that John didn't notice because he was too occupied with the situation, but still...

 

pmqunxqm.jpg

 

And Final Problem's little comment, that I found.

Posted

I think I get it ... but at what point in the narrative is the bottom shot taken from? If that's the exact moment John's cab went by, then yeah, I don't see how he could have missed it. But isn't that spot the end point, where they were moved it after Sherlock jumped? So it wouldn't have been in that position (or possibly even inflated yet?) when John went by? It would have been at the other end, where it would have been blocked from view ... ? Or actually, I have assumed they brought it out from inside Bart's proper (near where it says "bus stop".) I can't remember if it's shown where it comes from.

 

It occurs to me this scenario wouldn't have worked if John hadn't been called away to see to Mrs. Hudson -- nice of Moriarty to oblige! Also I wonder if John hadn't come back at all, if this particular deception would have been necessary. Or if he'd come back five minutes later, would Sherlock have simply stood there and waited for him? Would the sniper have waited too? Good thing John's so predictable.... :D

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 237 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.