Jump to content

What did you think of "The Abominable Bride"?  

122 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
      47
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
      26
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
      32
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
      12
    • 6/10 Average.
      2
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
      1
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
      1
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Abominable.
      1


Recommended Posts

Posted

 

Regarding the "I made myself" comment - I took that to be an admission of responsibility, not a boast.  Mainly because he looks and sounds quite sad when he says it.  It is a far cry from the bragging about being the only consulting detective in the world, and inventing the job, in ASIP.  I thought he recognised, with resignation if not regret, that he had made himself into the man that he is - with all of his flaws, as well as his virtues.  Of course, I may have been reading too much into it. 

 

I never saw Sherlock as being unhappy with himself, or regretting being different. Even in the morgue scene with Mycroft, his question about something being wrong with them I always hear it as is there anything wrong with us - as opposite to the rest of the human race being wrong, as he assumed. Been there, done that - first you wonder what's wrong with the others, before you realize that you are the "wrong" one. :P

 

The way you write, responsibility sounds too much like guilt for me. I don't see it in Sherlock, not regarding himself.

 

If someone asked me, what made me into that - so, so sad and pitiful - introvert, almost asexual, nerdy person who would rather write online instead of chatting with (almost non existent) friends, I would give a similar answer now: that there was most probably no big trauma in my life, that nobody destroyed me, that it's how I was born, and circumstances wouldn't change much. And I don't feel destroyed or sad or pitiful. Well, watching Sherlock made me even feeling a bit proud and RIGHT being like this.

 

Of course Sherlock under Mycroft's influence was thought that you are what you make out of yourself, and that to much greater extent than other children, so he doesn't value external influences that much.

 

Well, maybe it's just me. :D Have to watch it again.

 

I wouldn't say that it is guilt.  I don't think he has anything to feel guilty about, as far as his personality is concerned.  (Though he would be right to feel guilty about some of his actions - I still can't see that it is acceptable to murder an unarmed man who isn't threatening you with violence, even if he is as loathsome as CAM.  To a lesser degree, the way he has hurt the feelings of those nearest and dearest to him, on several occasions, should weigh on Sherlock's conscience but I very much doubt that it does!)  As I said, I'm basing my opinion on the way the line was spoken, and I don't see regret but maybe resignation, because he sees his own flaws as well as his virtues.

 

I don't think there is any doubt that Sherlock is very well aware of his own strengths, and takes full credit for them.  In that moment of reflection, maybe there is an acknowledgement that he has weaknesses too, and that he takes responsibility for them as well.  I don't mean that as a criticism of Sherlock (or anyone else.)  In fact, I think it is admirable to be able to look yourself in the face and say, "I made me" whilst acknowledging that some aspects of yourself didn't turn out the way you hoped.  Surely everyone - even Sherlock! - is aware that they are not perfect.

 

It is true that John is trying to edge towards questions regarding sex and/or romance and Sherlock's experiences, or lack thereof.  However, we don't know that Sherlock is specifically referring to that aspect of himself in his reply.  I thought he was speaking of the man he is, in his entirety.  However, it is possible that his feelings regarding love/sex are more complex than either pride or shame, and that in fact he feels neither.  He has indicated very clearly in previous episodes that love and romance are not part of his life and he views them as a hindrance - following, of course, the same line as ACD's Holmes.  I doubt that he regrets this, and why should he? 

 

However, there are strong hints throughout the series, and particularly in TSOT, that he may be lonely, particularly without John, and perhaps he does feel some regret that his life turned out this way.  If he is acknowledging that he is responsible for both the good and the bad, then surely that is better than it's all my brother's/my parents'/the world's fault.

 

But, as I said, I might be reading too much into a single line, and it might be wishful thinking on my part.

  • Like 2
Posted

I liked him. I liked him much better than I had expected I would. I was afraid they'd make him too nice, but they didn't. He was his old self in my eyes, and I was happy to see him. Didn't look half as nice as modern Sherlock (I am not a fan of that hairstyle and some of his suits I thought were downright ugly), but then Sherlock Holmes was not originally meant to be attractive and I thought they got the personality just right.

I like him, in that hair or the curl. But I miss The coat. 

 

 

 

He thinks he's not kind or good, and he thinks she deserves better than him.

Yes.. that is probably what makes me sympathize with Sherlock the most.

Just because you are different, doesn't mean you are unlovable.

It means you are..special.

 

 

 

 

Nope, nope, nope. I can't even begin to think about something happening to Molly.

Molly must not be harmed. Repeat: Molly must not be harmed. Not a hair on her head. I will turn absolutely monstrous if they try.

 

Wow, Moftiss better watch out, looks to me like we're forming our own Army of Women Who Take Revenge on Men right here!

 

Well, I strongly believe Molly will be harmed (don't kill me just yet), but it would break my heart too.

Just curious, is it really a deal breaker for you guys even if they are able to make a very good story?

Or, angry and monstrous but still be here? Tormented and addicted, at least I speak for myself. XD

 

 

 

Right, I get the KKK thing, that was pretty tone deaf, but I've already brushed it off ... if anyone thinks they are seriously comparing women to the KKK, they haven't really watched the show, imo.

Amen to that.

 

Around here, I think fat people do face prejudice and ridicule, but it somehow seems to be even more accepted to openly joke about slender people. "Yes, but you do not eat", "Maybe you can shop at the children's department", and, recently, "I'll just take two pieces of pie since you never have any" - this from a chubby colleague to a colleague with a very low fat percentage who is exceptionally active in sports (and consequently eats enough to feed a small country ). If the sportswoman would have replied "maybe you really shouldn't eat that", that would have been considered incredibly offensive. But for someone to comment on a skinny person was totally acceptable even though my coleague was hurt.

 

Bottomline: if everyone would just keep their comments about someone's appearance to themselves, the world would be a much nicer place.

Yup agree. Now I am not as active and 'normal' size, I used to be skinny and made fun "washing board", "watch out for the wind", "of course she can climb well, she only needs to drag that amount of weight", "I am imagining how many times that dressing gown has to make full turns if it's put on you (about dressing gown worn by someone fat)".

 

I used to eat twice as much compared to others, I even had to ask my male classmate to order food for me because the food seller took one look at me and decide that some amount was sufficient enough to feed me (and it's not! To be fair, it's normal portion but when I'm hungry, I am really hungry :)).

 

Is it okay because I'm on the other side?

Well, to me, I didn't get offended actually. Wise men say imitation is the highest form of compliment, I say, insult is the highest form of envy. And I go by this too In order for you to insult me, I would first have to value your opinion.

  • Like 1
Posted

Nothing is a deal breaker for me.  If I survived Carter's murderous rampage against my beloved Krycek and The Lone Gunmen, I can survive anything Mofftiss throws at me.   I actually don't mind if something happens to Molly (nothing like some good 'ole angst to fuel my ship!), but I do not want her killed off and off the show.  That would be really disappointing, and I'd miss her. 

  • Like 1
Posted

... He's often sad because just like Redbead the death of his brother is imminent.

This is so true.

He is not immune of love,he is afraid to love because of the consequences.

Scientifically speaking, broken heart could literally kills, it could be too slowly and too painful. Nasty. Shudder.

 

Does that mean that somewhere inside, Sherlock deeply admires Mycroft?

Yes. Actually not so deep. I think it's quite obvious that he tries to be him, at least in feelings or the lack of it department.
  • Like 1
Posted

can anyone tell me what does these notes in Mycroft's notebook means? Is it related to season 4? And what does Vernet means? Does anyone have a theory?

tumblr_o0c4qcUZJX1r9yflwo1_1280.jpg

Posted

can anyone tell me what does these notes in Mycroft's notebook means? Is it related to season 4? And what does Vernet means? Does anyone have a theory?

 

 

Supposedly the painter Vernet is an ancestor of the Holmes family.

  • Like 1
Posted

@ Janine Adler: You DO have a near lethal combination of names as a nickname! Poor Molly doesn't stand a chance next to your combination of charms! :smile:

Concerning the page, may I refer you to posts #27 and #44 on dear Arcadia's thread: The Abominable Bride:Does it mean anything?

We did our best to decipher it for fun!

  • Like 2
Posted

Now that we are post TAB (for most people), I would love to see Vertue, Gatiss, Moffat and McKinnon sit down for a roundtable discussion on the episode, specifically about  their choice of having it shown in theaters and how that may impact any Sherlock epsiodes of the future.

  • Like 1
Posted

Just discovered another Easter Egg while watching: the porter at the Diogenes is called Wilder, referring back to both Billy and Gene Wilder, whose spoofs of Sherlock were acceptable!

Query: why does Holmes in the introductory scene of his Mind Palace sequence use the unmistakable notes of JB's musical theme? Catering to all fandoms, making fun of the most perfectly executed Sherlock Holmes series up to date (perfectly executed, I repeat, not popular or any such advertising come-hither motions!) or wishful thinking?

Posted

Favorite image from the Special:

 

S_TAB_2838.jpg

 

Favorite quotes:

 

"Pure reason toppled by sheer melodrama: your life in a nutshell." (that could be my life as well... :lol:)

"There’s always two of us. Don’t you read The Strand?"

 

I rewatched the Special tonight (DVD hasn't come yet but I can now get legal streaming through Amazon, hurray!). I was by myself, it was dark out, I saw it on a big screen and when it came to the waterfall, I cried. I really cried.

  • Like 3
Posted

That is surprising, coming from such a thoughtful, insightful person like you! It was pure camp, played as such, seeing as it was Mind Palace re-enactment; and we both know that although ACD Holmes used "Elementary", there is NOT ONE story which includes the whole sentence, which was used much later by Rathbone. But, of course, everything is grist to their mill!

Posted

Query: why does Holmes in the introductory scene of his Mind Palace sequence use the unmistakable notes of JB's musical theme? Catering to all fandoms, making fun of the most perfectly executed Sherlock Holmes series up to date (perfectly executed, I repeat, not popular or any such advertising come-hither motions!) or wishful thinking?

I would call it an homage to the Brett series, of which Moftiss are fans. Just a little tip of the hat to one of their ancestors, so to speak.

  • Like 2
Posted

Just curious, is it really a deal breaker for you guys even if they are able to make a very good story?

Or, angry and monstrous but still be here? Tormented and addicted, at least I speak for myself.

Killing off Molly, you mean? No, I don't think so, although I would probably feel really depressed for days on end. It would depend on how they did it, of course, but I don't think any one particular happening would drive me away from the show. Well, if they killed off Sherlock, I guess that would be a deal-breaker. :blink:

 

can anyone tell me what does these notes in Mycroft's notebook means? Is it related to season 4? And what does Vernet means? Does anyone have a theory?

tumblr_o0c4qcUZJX1r9yflwo1_1280.jpg

Hi Janine! There's some detailed theories about the numbers, here. And some more theories about the notebook, here. But no one knows what any of it really means ... yet....

Posted

I bought the DVD yesterday!  Looking forward to its arrival.

Posted

I met a young gal at the January 5 TAB screening in the theater, and she was a college student, total BBC Sherlock fan, and we got to chatting a bit before she asked me if I had a "ship."  Well, I didn't have to be Sherlock Holmes to know what her ship was, and when I told her mine, she said, "Oh, we will NOT get along!!!"  But we did get along, or so I thought.  She was a young screenwriting student, I have MFA in screenwriting, and we chatted about that a bit.  We chatted about fan fiction.  I gave her my card and wrote my AO3 name on it, and she gave me her A03 name as well.  And that was the last I heard from her.  Fickle fandom.  We would have got along just fine.

  • Like 1
Posted

And that was the last I heard from her.  Fickle fandom.  We would have got along just fine.

It happens to me all my life.

 

I thought it could be a curse of INTJ/P-folks.

Maybe we intimidate people so much that they do as if they liked us - and they are just scared? :blink:

Posted

Oh, there are so many reasons people do things like that. One might be too shy to follow up, the other so disorganized that they've already lost the address (that would be me), another was just being polite but never intended to follow up because of reasons ... I know the tendency is to take it personally, but just as often it's for some other stupid reason.

 

These box office numbers alarm me ... there's been so many times I've been a fan of some small, cultish thing, then everyone else discovers it, and it starts to go down in quality, and I lose interest. I guess everything loses steam eventually (even my beloved Buffy) ... but I hate it.

  • Like 2
Posted

Dear Arcadia, the whole concept has already grown too big for its boots, and since the major stories have been executed, the playing field will shrink as the fandom expectations grow, so, we can keep our fingers crossed and hope that it will not implode under its own weight, a bit like Mind Palace Mycroft having only three more years to live!

And how DARE they call it a global success, when most of Europe, the whole of Africa except South Africa, and most of Asia were pointedly not included, allegedly due to copyright reasons! :angry:

  • Like 1
Posted

Nothing is a deal breaker for me.  If I survived Carter's murderous rampage against my beloved Krycek and The Lone Gunmen, I can survive anything Mofftiss throws at me.   I actually don't mind if something happens to Molly (nothing like some good 'ole angst to fuel my ship!), but I do not want her killed off and off the show.  That would be really disappointing, and I'd miss her.

 

 

Killing off Molly, you mean? No, I don't think so, although I would probably feel really depressed for days on end. It would depend on how they did it, of course, but I don't think any one particular happening would drive me away from the show. Well, if they killed off Sherlock, I guess that would be a deal-breaker. :blink:

Oh dear..

You are doomed guys.

Now they know you will continue watching even if they killed Molly.

 

 

 

And that was the last I heard from her.  Fickle fandom.  We would have got along just fine.

It happens to me all my life.

 

I thought it could be a curse of INTJ/P-folks.

Maybe we intimidate people so much that they do as if they liked us - and they are just scared? :blink:

 

 

Oh, there are so many reasons people do things like that. One might be too shy to follow up, the other so disorganized that they've already lost the address (that would be me), another was just being polite but never intended to follow up because of reasons ... I know the tendency is to take it personally, but just as often it's for some other stupid reason.

Why I am the only one who feel relieved if there is no follow up?

Posted

... she asked me if I had a "ship."  Well, I didn't have to be Sherlock Holmes to know what her ship was, and when I told her mine, she said, "Oh, we will NOT get along!!!" 

 

I have to admit, this idea of identifying so strongly by "ship" confuses me a little.  Maybe it's because I'm, ahem, "a certain age."  Maybe not.  But I don't really understand why some fans are so wedded to seeing certain shows through the lens of a relationship they hope happens.

 

I mean, I understand *having* a ship, and I understand being disappointed when the show seems to flat out deny that your OTP will ever get together.  And, as you know, I will argue against certain ships just because I think they aren't supported (or are actively contradicted) by the canon, or that they would harm the trajectory of the canon in some way.  But I'm not sure I understand more or less rejecting an entire person just because of their like or dislike for a possible fictional romance.

 

***

 

Regarding the "who made you"/"I made me" discussion.  I really love that exchange, and I love that we've started talking about it here.  The way it keeps sounding to me on repeat viewings, Watson is effectively saying, "What happened in your past to scare you of letting other people in? What was so tragic that you will turn away friendship and love so that you don't ever get hurt again?"  

 

And Holmes is claiming credit/taking responsibility/admitting that he's in a cage of his own instruction, but we get the sound of Redbeard.  Moftiss had better follow through on giving us more of the background on Redbeard, because I still can't imagine to my satisfaction why a grown man would still feel so damaged by the death of a childhood pet that it substantially changed the trajectory of his life.  

  • Like 3
Posted

That is surprising, coming from such a thoughtful, insightful person like you!

 

Pure reason toppled by sheer melodrama: my life in a nutshell.

 

 

I have to admit, this idea of identifying so strongly by "ship" confuses me a little.  Maybe it's because I'm, ahem, "a certain age."  Maybe not.  But I don't really understand why some fans are so wedded to seeing certain shows through the lens of a relationship they hope happens.

 

I mean, I understand *having* a ship, and I understand being disappointed when the show seems to flat out deny that your OTP will ever get together.  And, as you know, I will argue against certain ships just because I think they aren't supported (or are actively contradicted) by the canon, or that they would harm the trajectory of the canon in some way.  But I'm not sure I understand more or less rejecting an entire person just because of their like or dislike for a possible fictional romance.

 

It is kind of odd, I agree. I mean, I feel very sympathetic towards people who desperately want two characters to be together. It used to happen to me all the time with books. Sometimes I had to have a peak at the ending early on, while there was still a chance to get out of the story before I grew too fond of the people in it. But because I know what it's like to really, really, really want two characters to be together, I think I have all the more reason to feel kindly towards those who have a similar wish, even if it should be mutually exclusive with mine.

 

The good thing about fictional reality is that it isn't absolute. If you don't agree with a story's outcome, you can always re-write it inside your mind (or even on paper), and no harm done to anybody. I am pretty sure we all see a slightly to very different show when we watch Sherlock, yet here we all are. Why should we go at each others throats because one person might prefer one version and the other a different one? It makes no sense.

 

I find myself appreciating more and more how Sherlock requires the viewers to make some kind of sense of what they're seeing. I think the newer episodes and especially the Special invite speculation and personal interpretation and allow for many different readings. It can be frustrating because there are so many questions and so few straight-forward answers, but it's also nice to be able to be so involved.

  • Like 5
Posted

Oh dear..

You are doomed guys.

Now they know you will continue watching even if they killed Molly.

Oh, but we didn't say we wouldn't take our revenge on Moftiss in some other way..... :evil:

 

And that was the last I heard from her.  Fickle fandom.  We would have got along just fine.

 

Why I am the only one who feel relieved if there is no follow up?

 

 You're not. ;)

 

Regarding the "who made you"/"I made me" discussion.  I really love that exchange, and I love that we've started talking about it here.  The way it keeps sounding to me on repeat viewings, Watson is effectively saying, "What happened in your past to scare you of letting other people in? What was so tragic that you will turn away friendship and love so that you don't ever get hurt again?"  

 

And Holmes is claiming credit/taking responsibility/admitting that he's in a cage of his own instruction, but we get the sound of Redbeard.  Moftiss had better follow through on giving us more of the background on Redbeard, because I still can't imagine to my satisfaction why a grown man would still feel so damaged by the death of a childhood pet that it substantially changed the trajectory of his life.

Same here, it makes no sense (to me) to introduce the idea, then go nowhere with it. Altho there is that "red herring" notation in Mycroft's notebook ... arrgghh! They've done it to us again, haven't they .... created some fiendish clue to make sure we stay insane until the next series comes out! :d

 

My first thought was that Redbeard was a nickname for "the other one". I suppose under the right circumstances the loss of a sibling could close one down for life...... ohhhhh. Especially if one were somehow responsible for the loss..... eep. :blink:

  • Like 3
Posted

Unfortunately I can join this discussion only now, because I watched the special only two days ago (in italian at the cinema).

I found it amazing. It was fantastic, I liked it very very much!

I think that the most impressive element was the fact that everything that had happened wasn't really in the past, but in Sherlock's head! It was a great surprise when Sherlock woke up on the plane (even if I could have imagine it before, because sometimes some modern elements were mentioned, like hard disk and virus, for example).

:lol:

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.