Jump to content

What did you think of "A Study In Pink?"  

91 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

I believe Martina means that the script refers to her as Andrea in the stage directions and by labeling her lines with that name.  That doesn't necessarily mean that any of the dialog refers to her in that way.  But you were just yanking our chain anyhow, right?  :P
 
However, according to Jenny's link, this scene was not ad-libbed:
 

JOHN:  What's your name then?
ANDREA:  Anthea.
JOHN:  Is that your real name?
ANDREA:  No.

 
I love the reactions the actors added to those rather stark lines, really bringing them to life.

  • Like 1
Posted

¡¡¡¡˙˙˙˙ǝposıdǝ ʍǝu ɐ pǝǝu ǝʍ

  • Like 2
Posted

Dude, how did you do that, Arcadia?

  • Like 1
Posted

If so - the whole Rachel thing must have also been staged... Suddenly the plot has a hole. Or is it me having a hole in my logic...

 

Okay, THINK!

 

Jim hired the Cabbie to stage the suicides, because he knew it would attract Sherlock. Was Pink Lady something special, or Jim hoped that sooner or later something like that would happen, that Sherlock would solve the case, find the Cabbie and be lured into the game.

 

Bad day for thinking, today. :blush:

It seems to be the general consensus that Moriarty hired the cabbie to perpetrate all those murders, with the purpose of somehow luring Sherlock into solving them. But how likely is that really?

Jim Moriarty is described as a consulting criminal - the antiSherlock - meaning that people who want to achieve some antisocial end go to him for help. So isnt it more likely that he hired the cabbie to carry out hits on behalf of someone else (maybe even multiple 'clients') rather than choosing random targets i n the hope of getting to Sherlock eventually?

Later he tells Sherlock in the pool scene in TGG to "stop prying", so why would he try to seek out and engage Sherlock instead of simply enjoying his 'work'?

 

I'd probably be able to articulate that better if I were less tired.

  • Like 3
Posted

That's an interesting conjecture -- that Moriarty may have used certain cases that he'd been hired to perpetrate in order to attract Sherlock's attention -- so that he was getting paid to indulge in revenge.  I guess it depends on whether he actually needs the income from his cases -- come to think of it, does he even get paid, or does he take on cases simply because they're fun?

 

There's a long tradition of fictional detectives being independently wealthy or otherwise not in need of income, and therefore solving crimes merely for fun.  Maybe the same applies to consulting criminals?

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I've always assumed (personal head canon!) that Moriarty serves as a consulting criminal for others, but also does his own stuff for enjoyment/entertainment.   I guess I've also assumed that while Moriarty is warning Sherlock to "stop prying," Moriarty's boredom? is his own weakness/downfall, and he really doesn't want Sherlock to stop prying.  I think that, like Sherlock, Moriarty sees this all as a clever and fun game, and for once he has a worthy opponent (Sherlock).  Like you point out, Boswell, Moriarty initiates everything and appears to be trying to get Sherlock's attention from the beginning.

  • Like 3
Posted

I don't interpret it as Jim having "hired" Jeff the Cabbie to commit crimes, so much as he provided the means. In my head Jeff sought out Moriarty ("How do I kill people and make it look like suicide?") and Jim gave him not only the know how, but provided some incentive to continue in the form of money for Jeff's kids. Chaos for chaos' sake.

 

Dude, how did you do that, Arcadia?

Magic.

 

And an upside down text generator. :smile:

  • Like 4
Posted

I just had a thought (that may or may not have come up in discussion some time back before I joined) what would Sherlock have thought if he had been at the press conference with the lady whose husband had died?  The husband's mistress was quietly standing in back with tears down her face.  I figure Sherlock would have deduced that guy was having an affair with the blond but beyond that, I haven't come up with much.

Posted

I don't interpret it as Jim having "hired" Jeff the Cabbie to commit crimes, so much as he provided the means. In my head Jeff sought out Moriarty ("How do I kill people and make it look like suicide?") and Jim gave him not only the know how, but provided some incentive to continue in the form of money for Jeff's kids. Chaos for chaos' sake.

 

Dude, how did you do that, Arcadia?

Magic.

 

And an upside down text generator. :smile:

Yes Arcadia, you've put v succinctly what I was trying to get at - Jim Moriarty being a facilitator rather than a sponsor of the cabbie's crimes (even though Jim is referred to as a 'sponsor' in the cabbie's last conversation with Sherlock) Chaos for chaos' sake does seem to be a fitting motto for Moriarty.

I don't think Moriarty was trying to get Sherlock's attention at this stage. Moriarty doesn't 'need' a Sherlock as much as Sherlock needs a Moriarty - in the sense that Moriarty is far less likely to suffer from a dearth of clients than Sherlock; at worst Moriarty can just go out and do his own stuff when he chooses (which eventually he does), whereas Sherlock is dependent on and constantly in search of worthy cases.

  • Like 3
Posted

That's an interesting conjecture -- that Moriarty may have used certain cases that he'd been hired to perpetrate in order to attract Sherlock's attention -- so that he was getting paid to indulge in revenge.  I guess it depends on whether he actually needs the income from his cases -- come to think of it, does he even get paid, or does he take on cases simply because they're fun?

 

There's a long tradition of fictional detectives being independently wealthy or otherwise not in need of income, and therefore solving crimes merely for fun.  Maybe the same applies to consulting criminals?

Yeah I don't think Moriarty cares about being paid either, just like Sherlock, although i'm sure any incidental gains must be massive given the scale of his operations. 

Irene Adler did say something to the effect that he didn't even want to be paid, he just enjoyed the work. She adds "now that's my kind of man"

I quite admire this man myself  :evilinside:

  • Like 4
Posted

I don't interpret it as Jim having "hired" Jeff the Cabbie to commit crimes, so much as he provided the means. In my head Jeff sought out Moriarty ("How do I kill people and make it look like suicide?") and Jim gave him not only the know how, but provided some incentive to continue in the form of money for Jeff's kids. Chaos for chaos' sake.

 

Yes Arcadia, you've put v succinctly what I was trying to get at - Jim Moriarty being a facilitator rather than a sponsor of the cabbie's crimes (even though Jim is referred to as a 'sponsor' in the cabbie's last conversation with Sherlock) Chaos for chaos' sake does seem to be a fitting motto for Moriarty.

 

I agree that seems an adequate motive for Moriarty.  (Plus, he's trying to get even with Sherlock for drawing attention to the oddity of Carl Powers' missing shoes.)

 

But what would be Jeff the Cabbie's motivation for getting in touch with Moriarty then?  I still seems more likely to me that Moriarty contacted Jeff, in order to construct an interesting puzzle for Sherlock to solve.

 

Posted

 

I don't interpret it as Jim having "hired" Jeff the Cabbie to commit crimes, so much as he provided the means. In my head Jeff sought out Moriarty ("How do I kill people and make it look like suicide?") and Jim gave him not only the know how, but provided some incentive to continue in the form of money for Jeff's kids. Chaos for chaos' sake.

 

Yes Arcadia, you've put v succinctly what I was trying to get at - Jim Moriarty being a facilitator rather than a sponsor of the cabbie's crimes (even though Jim is referred to as a 'sponsor' in the cabbie's last conversation with Sherlock) Chaos for chaos' sake does seem to be a fitting motto for Moriarty.

 

I agree that seems an adequate motive for Moriarty.  (Plus, he's trying to get even with Sherlock for drawing attention to the oddity of Carl Powers' missing shoes.)

 

But what would be Jeff the Cabbie's motivation for getting in touch with Moriarty then?  I still seems more likely to me that Moriarty contacted Jeff, in order to construct an interesting puzzle for Sherlock to solve.

 

 

Hmm..yes it is logical that Moriarty must've hired the cabbie but likely for some of his clients and not for himself. I don't think any connection between the various victims emerged at any point, or the motive/s for killing those specific people - now that would have rounded things off nicely. In that sense, i think the lovely complexity of the original Study in Scarlet was rather lost in this episode.

Up until this point, i dont think Sherlock was really on Moriarty's radar, and the point at which MOriarty begins to actively seek out Sherlock is where the Great Game begins, with Carl Powers' missing shoes marking the beginning of the beginning :)

Posted

Oh, OK, I see what you mean.  Moriarty had been hired to kill those four people, but he doesn't like to get his hands dirty, so he farmed it out to Jeff the Cabbie.

 

We don't have to look far for motive in three of the four cases.  Sir Jeffrey Patterson and Jennifer Wilson were having affairs.  Beth Davenport was a politician.  But what about James Phillimore?  Not saying that teenagers don't have enemies -- but enemies capable of hiring Moriarty?

 

However, I disagree with you regarding when Moriarty took an active interest in Sherlock.  He told Jeff the Cabbie about Sherlock.  And it seems entirely plausible to me that he had designed those intriguing "serial suicides" in order to draw Sherlock's attention.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I thought the motive was "it's the most fun you can have with an aneurysm." :p

Posted

Oh, OK, I see what you mean.  Moriarty had been hired to kill those four people, but he doesn't like to get his hands dirty, so he farmed it out to Jeff the Cabbie.

 

We don't have to look far for motive in three of the four cases.  Sir Jeffrey Patterson and Jennifer Wilson were having affairs.  Beth Davenport was a politician.  But what about James Phillimore?  Not saying that teenagers don't have enemies -- but enemies capable of hiring Moriarty?

 

However, I disagree with you regarding when Moriarty took an active interest in Sherlock.  He told Jeff the Cabbie about Sherlock.  And it seems entirely plausible to me that he had designed those intriguing "serial suicides" in order to draw Sherlock's attention.

Yes, i am bound to agree now. Shockingly i dont remember the details you mention, wasn't paying enough attention (must watch it again)

No excuse for having forgotten about the cabbie mentioning Sherlock's "fan"? :embarrassed:

  • Like 1
  • 7 months later...
Posted

Ok, so I know this will have been discussed before, but why does Lestrade let Donovan get away with calling Sherlock freak? He's there because Lestrade called him in, and as a senior officer referring to a consultant as 'freak' is shockingly unprofessional. Also, why does she hate him so much? She might not trust him but going out of her way to be so insulting seems a bit extreme, does anyone know why?

Posted

Hm.... I don't think there's any definitive answers in the show, is there, gang?
 
Just my thoughts... Donovan felt safe calling him "freak" the first time because the boss wasn't there to hear. Lestrade didn't call her out subsequent times because he's a good enough boss to know you don't humiliate your staff by dressing them down in front of others (I like to think he called her into the office later and bawled her out, though. :smile: ) She dislikes S. because he's rude to and dismissive of the official police. And, um.... oh, my favorite theory (not one I believe in, I just think it's funny) ... she hates him because she fancies him. :D I.e., she came on to him, but he turned her down.

 

I rather liked Sally, I'd like to see her back, but a little less mouthy. She seems loyal to Lestrade, at least.

  • Like 2
  • 1 month later...
Posted

Hm.... I don't think there's any definitive answers in the show, is there, gang?

 

Just my thoughts... Donovan felt safe calling him "freak" the first time because the boss wasn't there to hear. Lestrade didn't call her out subsequent times because he's a good enough boss to know you don't humiliate your staff by dressing them down in front of others (I like to think he called her into the office later and bawled her out, though. :smile: ) She dislikes S. because he's rude to and dismissive of the official police. And, um.... oh, my favorite theory (not one I believe in, I just think it's funny) ... she hates him because she fancies him. :D I.e., she came on to him, but he turned her down.

 

I rather liked Sally, I'd like to see her back, but a little less mouthy. She seems loyal to Lestrade, at least.

 

I agree with all of this.

 

Also, I think supervision requires some give and take.  Sometimes, you let your employees get away with behavior like this occasionally because it keeps it from popping out other places that it would be truly damaging.  After all, Lestrade is using a consultant when he has forensics detectives who the Met feels are capable of doing the job; of course the employees feel resentful and need to work the feelings out.  We saw in TSoT that Donovan is very loyal to Lestrade, so his management style must work for her.

 

We feel protective of Sherlock during ASiP because we're supposed to.  But the reality is, the world sees him as a freak and a jerk, and we had to get that message in the first episode.  That's what makes the relationship with John stand out: he's not just a person who sees Sherlock as interesting and engaging, he's the only person who isn't rubbed the wrong way.  That's the key message for me.  I think Donovan is just caught in the plot-device cross fire because they had to explain just exactly how annoying Sherlock Holmes could be.  

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh, I think in the real world I couldn't stand the guy. Because in the real world you don't normally get to see the little moments that make him endearing; like jumping in the air when he has a murder to solve, or kissing Mrs. Hudson because he's just so happy he has a murder to solve, or leaping over rooftops because he has a murder to solve .... hrm. He is a bit of a freak, isn't he? :D

  • Like 2
Posted

He definitely isn't someone most people would like (though I actually relate to him to an extent because I do see a bit of myself in him, not that I enjoy murders or anything!) but it's just bullying, whether he's actually bothered by it or not it's going out of your way to be cruel to someone who clearly has issues. Whenever you watch real life police programs they put up with all kinds of nutters and abuse and still don't call those people freaks or anything so derogatory. 

 

Of course Boton has a point about it being a plot device, and I get that that's the real reason, I suppose I'm just ignoring that level and looking at it more from the characters point of view. It does it's job as a plot device because it does show a lot about the characters instantly, Sherlock's effect on people, John's reaction, Donovan's disdain. 

  • Like 3
Posted

About Sherlock, I agree with you that I would be scared by a person who's happy if there's a murder to solve, but he isn't happy for the murder itself, but because he has something to do. I'm very attracted by the character of Sherlock and I think that, if I met someone like him, I would behave like John. I think that Sherlock is a difficult peron to deal with, but I think he's also capable of very profund feelings, even if he doesn't show it.

  • Like 2
Posted

The therapist says John has trust issue, Mycroft says John is very loyal, very quickly.

 

I think Sherlock being 'rude and annoying' is one of the reason John is drawn to him.

 

John is having trust issue. I can imagine when someone goes to war, there are so many things that could open their eyes. Maybe the thing the believe they are fighting for are not real, or not what it seems. *cough*WMD*cough* Maybe the nature of war is so f-up that you are questioning yourself everyday. Maybe there are ways to many unethical things that they have to do to another human beings in the name of shaky justifications. Maybe the system is so corrupted and the practice is so grey in the field that they have to turn blind eye and choose not to see because those things happen at war. Innocent people are killed between enemies, friends and troops are sacrificed or left behind to save the rest, manipulation of mission to achieve results. War is dirty.

 

I am not sure how to explain it, if we put it in everyday life, it's something like doing volunteer work or joining conservation organizations to contribute to environment and animal well-beings, only to find out that they do unethical things also, sometimes it's inevitable because things are never black and white but you lose your faith in the concept.

 

And John sees it all, there is no glory in war or being a war veteran, there is no romanticism in surviving it. Dedication, patriotism, solidarity and heroism, they are all shaky questionable concepts that have been wrapped so well for presentation. Nothing can be trust because almost everything is a mask.

 

Then Sherlock shows up. He says what he thinks and thinks what he says. He doesn't bother to butter up anything because he doesn't lie. He is perceived as rude and annoying but he doesn't care because he doesn't lie. He is not wearing a mask like what ordinary people wear, it should be a fresh air that John would appreciates. Sherlock is also not just someone honest, but he backs it up with brilliant and logical observations. I believe if someone told me I am an idiot like everyone else, because they prove they are far superior, I wouldn't mind because well, it's true. And it's far easier to trust that person. At least that what I see from John's eyes.

 

Hmm.. how much exactly is Mycroft going to offer John to spy on Sherlock?

Oh, is it Mycroft trying to buy friend for Sherlock? (MYCROFT!!)

It's funny that John does 'spy' on Sherlock and work with Mycroft; danger night, drug den, 'broken-hearted' Sherlock.

 

Has he ever attempted this with Mrs. Hudson before?

 

John and Mrs.Hudson would gladly spy on Sherlock for his 'well being' once they know Mycroft is Sherlock's brother I suppose, instead of arch-enemy. :D Mycorft is a clot sometimes eh?

 

I love that both Sherlock and Mycroft think the other is being dramatic and over the top without realizing that they themselves behave the same way, and John sees through all that with both," I am glad you are above all that." :rofl:

Geniuses are idiots in some way. :p

  • Like 3
Posted

About Sherlock, I agree with you that I would be scared by a person who's happy if there's a murder to solve, but he isn't happy for the murder itself, but because he has something to do. I'm very attracted by the character of Sherlock and I think that, if I met someone like him, I would behave like John. I think that Sherlock is a difficult peron to deal with, but I think he's also capable of very profund feelings, even if he doesn't show it.

Exactly.

I would be very very interested with someone like Sherlock. To talk to him, to see how he deals with things, and to watch him dance (not Moriarty way of course :p)

  • Like 1
Posted

Sherlock does lie, though. Horribly, and especially to John. Of all his traits, that is the one I have the most trouble dealing with. I keep hoping that he will learn that it's a Bit Not Good and stop, especially with John and Molly, because they each in their way trust, aid and adore him, and deserve better.

:soapbox:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 144 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.