Jump to content

What did you think of "A Study In Pink?"  

91 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

I assumed that the words had to have the gender info attached, because it is something that English lack for the most cases. But noun is absolutely plausible. Okay, I take my conspiracy theory back. Blame it on the hiatus, LOL

  • Like 2
Posted

If it were a real German-to-English dictionary, it would give gender information as well.  But apparently Sherlock doesn't consider that important enough to include (something like the Earth going around the Sun).

 

Posted

If it were a real German-to-English dictionary, it would give gender information as well.  But apparently Sherlock doesn't consider that important enough to include (something like the Earth going around the Sun).

 

As I learned reading A Study in Scarlet last night, there is actually quite a bit Sherlock doesn't consider important enough to know!    :wacko:

 

ETA:  Oh, and mind palace sounds so much more glamorous than brain attic.  lol

  • Like 2
Posted

And now the responses:

 

 

Van Buren:

His continuation of amazement (really able to feel from his POV) that this funny-crazy-rigid-stranger is actually capable of having something recretional :lol:.

And really loveeee it when Sherlock believed there was enough connection to just communicated through eye gaze and John actually understood.

 

It is such a fun bit, you also can see Lestrade looking at them, trying to figure out...

 

 

But then, to my and his defense, and all the inputs in Sherlock's Heart thread, his way and detachment of human feeling is one of his strongest suits for consulting detective. Rachel was not written for sentimental reason, but a last effort by a smart woman to communicate something important to get her killer. John, Lestrade and Anderson would not have come to that conclution and would stop at sentiment.

 

I noticed that by the last viewing. The difference between thinking of and doing something.

 

 

And, he saved John Watson life.

 

It works both ways. :)

 

 

Sitty: Molly is just adorable in this episode.  I never cease to smile, and cringe, at her little "Okay"s.

 

I still cannot figure it out: what is Sherlock actually doing? Being snarky or trying to do smalltalk? You noticed that he hesitates before he says about her mouth: "it's too... small now"? He never hesitates being snarky.

 

 TOBY: What else? Oh, yes, what really struck me this time is how Sherlock blatantly lies to John when he says he was just "biding his time" because he "knew" John would show up. That's such BS, because just a minute earlier, Sherlock's draw dropped as he was deducing the shooter to Lestrade and suddenly realized who it was.

 

He has this funny expression on his face: like a little kid trying to lie. He looked like this while talking to Janine about the wedding in the hospital.

 

 TOBY: One of my favorite bits is how Sherlock rattles off all that horrible stuff about John's past and his family perfectly matter-of-factly. He's so unemotional and unempathic about it that it took me at least three viewings to realize how awful it really all is (...) But Sherlock doesn't see it that way. He deduces the facts, but he doesn't reach the same conclusion every one else would, namely "poor sod". If there's any emotional impact for him, it is his childish pride in how fast he found it out.

 

Great observation! That is probably the reason why he gets those "piss off" reactions.

 

Then, he looks at John and he doesn't see "human wreck with baggage" but "potentially useful individual" and sets about putting him back in working order. I really don't think there's a scrap of altruism or compassion in all this. Sherlock just seems to be fed up with living and working on his own, he "needs an audience", and John has the necessary skillset plus he's accustomed to violence and strange sights, his nerves are strong and he doesn't have any other attachments that could get in the way. Perfect!

 

Not sure about Sherlock's motivations, but he is surely intrigued by Johns unusual reaction (as he was intrigued by Mary's unusual behavior during the not-dead sequence in TEH). What I'd like to know is why John reacts this way.

 

Inge l-w: When Sherlock overrides the Yard conference with his "wrong" message, it positively set my teeth on edge, because, as I have explained in the "What have we missed" thread, there are specific security overrides which can be used for both cellular telephony and TV channels.

 

I think it would be enough just to know the telephone numbers of people attending the press conference. You need to sign in for a press conference as a reporter, don't you? Sherlock could just send a mass SMS from a computer AFAIK.

 

Inge l-w: When he goes to see his therapist, the bust on her desk is the exact same one with some weird mask on used in the end credits of TEH and HLV in Magnussen' s vaults, which may not be so insubstantial, after all!

 

I thought it too, but these are two different statues, even if they look very alike. On the other hand, CAMs Mind Palace representation might be as imprecise, just as Sherlock's seem to be. The strange mask, I think, is an ancient version of a headset and was used by the operators in old telephone switchboards - like this one

 

------------------------

 

Ah, one more observation: the staircase at 221B is mirrored in UP.

 

Afganistan or Iraq scene: at the moment when John says: we don't know anything about each other, I don't know your name... to what Sherlock response is: I know you are... he doesn't notice that John is actually asking him to say something about himself... A self-centered git. :D With an infuriating tendency to assume others can read his mind.

 

Okay, I spent more time writing than watching the episode. It's exhausting being a Sherlock fan...

  • Like 1
Posted
ETA:  Oh, and mind palace sounds so much more glamorous than brain attic.  lol

 

"Brain attic"? that sounds like me. :D I even used the comparison several times relating to my memory: a very cluttered attic where you never can find a thing you need, but you might find it some time later, while you look for something else.

Posted

And now the responses:

 

 

 

 

Sitty: Molly is just adorable in this episode.  I never cease to smile, and cringe, at her little "Okay"s.

 

I still cannot figure it out: what is Sherlock actually doing? Being snarky or trying to do smalltalk? You noticed that he hesitates before he says about her mouth: "it's too... small now"? He never hesitates being snarky.

 

 

The hell if I know.  I can't figure it out either.  Why he makes all the comments about her lipstick and mouth to begin with... like why is that even worth his time to comment/snark on?  Then he does the same thing in ASIB to poor Molly.  I guess maybe Mofftiss was just having a good laugh at Molly's expense?  Like... "watch our rude consulting detective walk all over this poor, enamored girl while she swoons?"  I mean Sherlock loves commenting on people's weight (Mycroft, Molly, John?), but that's about it for him and appearance comments (well, besides John's ridiculous 'stache but that totally deserved it).  

 

The ridiculous side of me who has read too much Sherlock-Molly meta on Tumblr is all.... this means something....

 

SebTip_1.gif

Posted

Ah, one more observation: the staircase at 221B is mirrored in UP.

 

Oh, thank you!  I remember being puzzled by that when I watched the pilot, and thinking vaguely that I must be misremembering.  Somehow it never occurred to me that they might have changed it for the 90-minute episodes -- maybe I was just too engrossed in watching to actually think about it (Jeff Hope would be so disappointed in me!).

  • Like 1
Posted

I just noticed that John is on the wrong side while walking up the stairs for the first time. :)

 

I really cannot decide about the Angelo's restaurant scene. Some parts I like better in UP, some in ASIP. I would mix them If I could.

I like the UP Angelo better, as well as the the rest is transport/girlfriend/boyfriend dialogue (except the bit when Sherlock realizes the suggestiveness of John's question)...

Posted

Wahhhh! My DVD player's not working!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted

watching it right now and I noticed Sherlock's hand movements when he is first looking at Jennifer Wilson's body while still at the doorway to the room.  Never noticed the movement he made before in that scene.  As I've said before, Benedict could be completely incapacitated except for a finger and give the acting performance of his life.  And I just noticed how Sherlock's facial expression changes as he talks with Jeff the cabbie shortly before Sherlock says he'll take the gun.  It was a subtle shift in expression that was barely noticeable.  Also the whole which pill bottle thing reminds me of:

 

 

 

Now, a clever man would put the poison into his own goblet, because he would know that only a great fool would reach for what he was given. I'm not a great fool, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But you must have known I was not a great fool; you would have counted on it, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.  Not remotely. Because iocane comes from Australia, as everyone knows. And Australia is entirely peopled with criminals. And criminals are used to having people not trust them, as you are not trusted by me. So I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you.  Yes -- Australia, and you must have suspected I would have known the powder's origin, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.  You've beaten my giant, which  means you're exceptionally strong.  So, you could have put the poison in your own goblet, trusting on your strength to save you. So I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But, you've also bested my Spaniard which means you must have studied. And in studying, you must have learned that man is mortal so you would have put the poison as far from yourself as possible, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.

 

A virtual pat on the back to anyone who can identify where the quote is from :)

  • Like 1
Posted

The Princess Bride.

 

Correct so here's your virtual pat on the back.

  • Like 2
Posted

Dear J.P. the n. means noun, like any dictionary meaning. Nice nitpicking skills, by the way! Have a :rose:!

@sfmpco and SherlockedCamper, although the whole pill thing is straight from ACD, it reminded me of the Danny Kaye film with the flagon with the dragon ditty!

  • Like 2
Posted

 

I so love this film :wub:.

 

eta: And for compare&contrast, here's the Princess Bride scene:

 

  • Like 2
Posted

watching it right now and I noticed Sherlock's hand movements when he is first looking at Jennifer Wilson's body while still at the doorway to the room.  Never noticed the movement he made before in that scene. 

 

You mean when he outstretches his hand like he was trying to feel the vibes of the room?

 

 

And I just noticed how Sherlock's facial expression changes as he talks with Jeff the cabbie shortly before Sherlock says he'll take the gun.  It was a subtle shift in expression that was barely noticeable.  Also the whole which pill bottle thing reminds me of:

 

This is a symphony. A feast. Christmas, New Year and Birthday all at once. :) BC has an amazing ability to controll every muscle on his face.

  • Like 1
Posted

Both hands do something at separate times just before he walks into the room towards Jennifer Wilson's body. I think he is still listening to Lestrade at the time. His arms stay close to his body and his hands each make a subtle movement before you see him walk in with his left hand in his pocket.

  • Like 2
Posted

I finally ended up watching this on my tiny, tinny laptop. Sigh. Time for a new DVD player, evidently.
 
Initial reactions: I think, if I had just happened on Sherlock, instead of seeking it out because I'd heard so much about it ... based on the first few minutes, I don't think I would have been very interested. To me the Afghanistan footage looks like cheap video and somehow unconvincing; and then we have a series of people we don't care about wandering off into the night and ending up dead. I am not, at heart, a fan of crime dramas, and this all seems like fairly typical stuff.
 
Then Sherlock swans into the scene. That's it, I'm in love for life. So if I had managed to survive the first few minutes, instead of just channel-surfing to the next thing, I would have been a fan anyway. But I wonder if I would've lasted that long, or ended up watching a repeat of Lost.
 
Then a little later we get that magnificent showdown between Weird Mystery Man and John. I knew there was a reason I loved Martin Freeman!! OMG, two marvellous characters in one show, can it get any better? Well, yeah, Mystery Man turning out to be Mycroft instead of Moriarty; that was brilliant. I loved the Mycroft scenes. And then there's the drugs bust sequence; Lestrade is just wonderful in that, my sympathies are all with him at that point. This show is just sooooo cool!
 
Molly; the way I read Sherlock's expression, he's genuinely surprised to notice she's changed her appearance, and genuinely does not associate this occurrence with his own presence. (As we find out later, this is a man who thinks he's unlovable, so why would he?) His "mouth's too small" comment later indicates to me that he doesn't think she's anyone important; just a phenomenon that he's commenting on. How he gets from that to apologizing to her in SiP is still a mystery to me.
 
By the way, I still laugh at the state of Donovan's knees (simply because it IS so horrible!) but I cringe when he insults Molly. Why is that? I guess because Donovan seems to be someone who gives as good as she gets?
 
Also by the way, we had a discussion awhile back as to why some people think John is so kind and sympathetic (and some people think he isn't) ... and it seems to me the answer's right here in this episode; the look on his face when he sees Jennifer Wilson's body. He's intentionally being used here as a foil to Sherlock's indifferent behavior, so yeah, I think we're meant to interpret him as the "kind" one, right from start.
 
I too love the way Sherlock uses his hands when he enters the crime scene. Like he's communing with the body or something. Neat.

 

The giggling together. Sherlock walking on furniture. John's reaction to "geniuses need an audience" and Sherlock's complete cluelessness that it also applies to himself.
 
Oh gosh, I could go on but I have a million other things to do (darn it!!!!) I basically love everything you all have written and it's a wonderful introduction to this crazy world Moftiss have created for us. Bravo.
 
 

 

 

I dunno, maybe I'm a bit hypersensitive on Sally's part because she's a woman, but the knees thing really rubs me the wrong way.   Like to me that's just sooo beyond her always calling him "freak" or Anderson being just generally rude and defensive (rightfully so based on what we saw in the pilot).   Off topic, but can I just say, though, that Sally got a wonderful makeover from the pilot.  Sooo much better.  She's really beautiful.


Oh I thought they were different actresses?

 

 
You know what, you're right.  Different actresses.  I didn't even remember that.  All I remember is that bright yellow jacket and bad skirt in the pilot.

 

 
Wait, what? Really? Oh man, I really do see but not observe. Or maybe it's that I know and do not remember? How embarrassing.
 


 
I so love this film :wub:.

Oh, yes! :boing:  It's a tradition in my family to watch this movie every year at Christmas. We still quote it at each other ... "Get it?" "Got it." "Good!" And I still howl with laughter at the knighting ceremony every time I see it. Not to mention the "true that is brew" sequence. And the ridiculous magnetized armor. OMG. :rofl:

  • Like 3
Posted

BTW (again! :smile: ) this is the kind of role I would love to see BC in....

Posted

watching it right now and I noticed Sherlock's hand movements when he is first looking at Jennifer Wilson's body while still at the doorway to the room.  Never noticed the movement he made before in that scene.  As I've said before, Benedict could be completely incapacitated except for a finger and give the acting performance of his life.  And I just noticed how Sherlock's facial expression changes as he talks with Jeff the cabbie shortly before Sherlock says he'll take the gun.  It was a subtle shift in expression that was barely noticeable.  Also the whole which pill bottle thing reminds me of:

 

 

 

Now, a clever man would put the poison into his own goblet, because he would know that only a great fool would reach for what he was given. I'm not a great fool, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But you must have known I was not a great fool; you would have counted on it, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.  Not remotely. Because iocane comes from Australia, as everyone knows. And Australia is entirely peopled with criminals. And criminals are used to having people not trust them, as you are not trusted by me. So I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you.  Yes -- Australia, and you must have suspected I would have known the powder's origin, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.  You've beaten my giant, which  means you're exceptionally strong.  So, you could have put the poison in your own goblet, trusting on your strength to save you. So I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But, you've also bested my Spaniard which means you must have studied. And in studying, you must have learned that man is mortal so you would have put the poison as far from yourself as possible, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.

 

A virtual pat on the back to anyone who can identify where the quote is from :)

 

Is that Princess Bride?

Posted

I finally ended up watching this on my tiny, tinny laptop. Sigh. Time for a new DVD player, evidently.

 

This is your opportunity to get a region-free one! You can get either a regular region-free DVD player, or you can get a Blu-ray player that's region-free as regards regular DVDs (though I don't think any of them are region-free as regards Blu-ray disks).

 

Initial reactions: I think, if I had just happened on Sherlock, instead of seeking it out because I'd heard so much about it ... based on the first few minutes, I don't think I would have been very interested. To me the Afghanistan footage looks like cheap video and somehow unconvincing; and then we have a series of people we don't care about wandering off into the night and ending up dead. I am not, at heart, a fan of crime dramas, and this all seems like fairly typical stuff.

 

Then Sherlock swans into the scene. That's it, I'm in love for life. So if I had managed to survive the first few minutes, instead of just channel-surfing to the next thing, I would have been a fan anyway. But I wonder if I would've lasted that long, or ended up watching a repeat of Lost.

 

That's exactly how Alex and I found Sherlock -- we had heard nothing about it till maybe 30 seconds before it started, then we got to a friend's house just as she was turning on the TV. We were intrigued by what little the friend had time to tell us ("Sherlock Holmes in the 21st Century"), but I think I was really hooked by "We'll start with the riding crop."

 

I've heard that the Afghanistan footage is from a documentary, by the way, so it's real, just not filmed according to Hollywood standards (presumably because the camera crew was being shot at).

 

...Mystery Man turning out to be Mycroft instead of Moriarty; that was brilliant.

 

Yup! I bet they fooled everyone who had ever heard of Moriarty -- letting us be betrayed by our own cleverness.

 

You know what, you're right.  Different actresses.  I didn't even remember that.  All I remember is that bright yellow jacket and bad skirt in the pilot.

 

Wait, what? Really? Oh man, I really do see but not observe. Or maybe it's that I know and do not remember? How embarrassing.

 

They recast two characters for the 90-minute episode. Sherlock and John are played by the same actors, of course, as are Mike Stamford, Molly Hooper, Mrs. Hudson, Anderson (despite losing the beard), and Jeff the cabbie. But yup, Sally Donovan is different (though played with the same accent), and so is Angelo. I had noticed the first substitution, but it took Alex quite a while to convince me that Angelo was different (I finally had to look it up on IMDb).  I was also convinced (until a couple of minutes ago) that they had recast Ella Thompson (John's therapist), but all the websites I've checked say she was played by Tanya Moodie in both versions.

  • Like 2
Posted

And then there's the drugs bust sequence; Lestrade is just wonderful in that, my sympathies are all with him at that point.

 

Really? With Lestrade? Wow, my sympathies are almost entirely with Sherlock in that scene, to the point where I share his outrage. Just imagine someone marched into your place with a bunch of people who detest you and went through all your stuff on a pretend drugs bust, to bully you into cooperating! Really. Lestrade is lucky that Sherlock isn't like me, I'd have regressed to the age of, lets say about 3 years old, gone into a sulking fit and refused to be of any further help whatsoever. :lol:

 

Of course from a mature point of view, Lestrade is totally in the right (I guess), but I am not exactly known for being mature... Another reason why I love series 1 Sherlock so much, I guess. I seem to identify with his "bratty" side. Of course I can keep myself in check because I tell myself "who are you to act like you're special", but Sherlock actually is special, so...

 

  • Like 2
Posted

I like the poison-deduction-connections. .D

 

One more thing (for today): did you notice that the Pink Lady came from Cardiff where the filming studios are?

  • Like 1
Posted

 

watching it right now and I noticed Sherlock's hand movements when he is first looking at Jennifer Wilson's body while still at the doorway to the room. Never noticed the movement he made before in that scene. As I've said before, Benedict could be completely incapacitated except for a finger and give the acting performance of his life. And I just noticed how Sherlock's facial expression changes as he talks with Jeff the cabbie shortly before Sherlock says he'll take the gun. It was a subtle shift in expression that was barely noticeable. Also the whole which pill bottle thing reminds me of:

 

 

 

Now, a clever man would put the poison into his own goblet, because he would know that only a great fool would reach for what he was given. I'm not a great fool, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But you must have known I was not a great fool; you would have counted on it, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me. Not remotely. Because iocane comes from Australia, as everyone knows. And Australia is entirely peopled with criminals. And criminals are used to having people not trust them, as you are not trusted by me. So I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. Yes -- Australia, and you must have suspected I would have known the powder's origin, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me. You've beaten my giant, which means you're exceptionally strong. So, you could have put the poison in your own goblet, trusting on your strength to save you. So I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But, you've also bested my Spaniard which means you must have studied. And in studying, you must have learned that man is mortal so you would have put the poison as far from yourself as possible, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.

A virtual pat on the back to anyone who can identify where the quote is from :)

Is that Princess Bride?

Yes it is, a virtual pat on the back for you too! :)

Posted

I like the poison-deduction-connections. :D

 

Okay, so here's a nice tidbit for you, not by me but gleaned from the findings of the more observant side of this wild fandom:

 

Two weird connections --

  • John Watson / Jennifer Wilson
  • John's child will be a girl / Jennifer Wilson's was a stillborn girl
  • John and Jen are lefties
  • John's a minor celeb / Jennifer had a job, probably "something in the media"
  • John goes through relationships like water / Jennifer is a serial adulterer

 

Important details 'bout Jennifer Wilson --

  • Unhappy marriage for over 10+ years
  • Stillborn daughter born 14 years ago (well in the range of 10+ years)
  • "Rachel" -- her daughter's name -- means "lamb"

 

Strange coincidences, yes? But the universe (well, Moftiss's) is rarely so lazy. :)

 

And don't forget Moftiss's love of nursery tales -- if the Watson kid does end up stillborn, then that means

  • Mary had a little lamb
  • Its fleece was white as snow*

 

 

*white, as in a cold and dead body

  • Like 5
Posted

Doubt that they'll do that -- but please remember that the real Mary Morstan was stillborn, so she may be John's connection with Jennifer Wilson in that category.

 

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 132 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.