Jump to content

What did you think of "A Study In Pink?"  

91 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

 

The thing that hasn't been done (and I haven't done it effectively in fan fiction either) is express that Sherlock kind of drops into a crime solving mode where even bodily functions like eating and sleeping are not as interesting as solving the mystery, but the rest of the time he's a normal human being. 

 

Would you care to define "normal"?

 

 

Well, OK, unpopular opinion time, but I think that a lot of the non-case time, Sherlock behaves like a normal (if somewhat entitled) human being.  He eats (and, as that meta points out and I agree, probably has a fairly sophisticated palate), sleeps (maybe erratically, but I'll bet he takes some epic naps), and probably does really normal things like sitting and playing with his phone or listening to non-classical music that he likes. I've never believed that he only wears Spencer Hart suits or ratty PJs, so there must be some days he's wandering around in jeans and a tshirt (which I would pay to see). 

 

The thing is, the original ACD Holmes was not (IMHO) an abnormal human being who stuck out like a sore thumb everywhere he went; he was an extremely intelligent, very erudite, somewhat bohemian Victorian man. Although I didn't come to the Sherlock fandom from reading ACD first, I sort of take that impression with me into Sherlock and assume that most of the time he has fairly standard habits, but we see a lot of the oddball stuff because its fun to watch.

  • Like 4
  • 2 months later...
Posted

 

Well, OK, unpopular opinion time, but I think that a lot of the non-case time, Sherlock behaves like a normal (if somewhat entitled) human being.  He eats (and, as that meta points out and I agree, probably has a fairly sophisticated palate), sleeps (maybe erratically, but I'll bet he takes some epic naps), and probably does really normal things like sitting and playing with his phone or listening to non-classical music that he likes. I've never believed that he only wears Spencer Hart suits or ratty PJs, so there must be some days he's wandering around in jeans and a tshirt (which I would pay to see).

 

Well, we do see him watching crap telly in TGG :) And now we've also seen him on Twitter (sorry, that's a spoiler, but not really an important one).

 

Watched ASiP again last night - rewatching everything from start to finish is one my methods of coping with Sherlock withdrawal symptoms - and it's a bit strange seeing that high functioning sociopath after just watching series 4. It also gives me a new perspective to the man we see in the early episodes, but I will take that discussion elsewhere.

 

I've wathed this episode so many times, probably at least 20, and I still enjoy it. That's good TV!

  • Like 3
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

What's funny is that Sherlock thinks that playing the violin and not talking for days is "the worst" of him, lol.

  • Like 4
Posted

What's funny is that Sherlock thinks that playing the violin and not talking for days is "the worst" of him, lol.

 

Well, I'm referencing a fan fic that I wrote, which is a little weird, but my head canon was that someone told him he should be prepared to tell a potential flatmate about himself, including the bad stuff.  And those two things were what he came up with as potentially objectionable; the whole head in the fridge thing is perfectly normal!

 

Oh! I know!  Sherlock has heard people referring to their moldy leftovers that they have forgotten about as "science experiments in the back of the fridge," and he made an incorrect assumption that everyone keeps bags of thumbs in there!

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, I know I do. And I grew something that looked suspiciously like an eyeball in a coffee cup once. I'm actually completely serious, mould that was the spitting image of an eyeball... this was in my younger less civilised days obviously. ;)

  • Like 2
Posted

Last week, you mean? :P
35o46Bs.gif

  • Like 1
Posted

Yes. 

Posted
Posted

I was so impressed with myself for growing an eye I took a photo. I wonder if I had left it for longer would it have eventually have become a whole person? Did I commit murder by tipping it down the sink?

  • Like 1
Posted

I'll ask Mycroft. Just in case ... which would you prefer, prison or exile?

Posted

Exile somewhere nice and warm. With sun, sea and a good wifi connection.

Posted

Yeah, but you know it's only for six months....

  • Like 1
  • 10 months later...
Posted

Yesterday German TV aired ASIP so I took it as an occasion to re-watch it.
Did anyone noticed that Pink Lady's hair was dry? She didn't use her umbrella, so the hair should be as wet as the coat.

 

I also think they shouldn't have shown John's cane when the boys run out of Angelo's. It was so in-your-face and actually took out the impact of the scene when Angelo brings it back. BTW, "says the man at the door" line reminds me strongly of Sherlock planning Molly showing up at the therapist's door in TLD.

Aaaand the Cabbie also "talked to the people and then they killed themselves" like Eurus. Even if the talking was a bit different. :D
 

Then, a cabbie with an aneurysm? I wonder if his kids would get money if he died while driving and killed someone.

Posted

The aneurysm is straight from Doyle's original story, A Study in Scarlet. Regarding the money, only if he made it look like suicide. ;)

 

Agree about the cane -- they could have shown it by just having it in the shot.

 

Interesting about the hair. Will need to rewatch. (Darn!)

Posted

Is it possible if she dried her hair?

Maybe she took train or plane, there was presumably some waiting time when she could fix up her look and since she had short hair, it’s probably manageable to get it dry, even without hair dryer. She encountered wet weather in Cardiff, I suppose there were at least two-three hours journey. I have long hair and that is enough to let my hair dry naturally. Coat on the other hand takes much longer time, although I am wondering why didn’t she change. Her suitcase was cabin size, it’s very likely that she had it all the time with her without the hassle of checking in. We know she had clothes, wearing damp clothes are very unpleasant (as I am now that I’ve just caught in rain). It was journey day, so we could assume that whatever she was attending would take place later the day or the day after, so why didn’t she change or took it off. Did she only bring one coat?

 

 

Alrite, why stop there, let’s start nitpicking (I blame J.P).

 

Things that are a bit absurd to me, Sherlock knew that she had a suitcase from the dirt, splash pattern on the right side of heel and calf. But as a suitcase dragger, almost all the time the suitcase is positioned behind you, and you are pulling towards your direction, so it’s very unlikely to get the splash from suitcase. Maybe, unless it’s the 360 degree four wheels kind that you can drag on your side, but not Jennifer Wilson’s. It’s more likely to get splash (a lot!) by wearing slippers, not by dragging this kind of suitcase.

image.jpg

Also, Jennifer seemed like someone with decent strength. What would you do if you race against the strong wind rainy weather with tiny suitcase? You pick it up instead of patiently dragging them. And I have no idea how Cardiff looks like, but in many many part of the world, there are almost always decent amount of shelters when you want to take transport like train or plane, from the other mode of transportation you use to get there. And she seemed like someone well-to-do who could afford cab/car transportation. Rainy weather should be in her concern since she cared about her appearance and she supposedly familiar with Cardiff and the weather.

 

Also, the unclean wedding ring. How likely it is that someone who had decent amount of jewelry and cleaned them regularly would skip cleaning the wedding ring because she was unhappy with the marriage? Jewelry is jewelry, she loved them therefore she wore them, and purposely skipping cleaning one just because she spited the marriage doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. Although sometimes I purposely only make my side of bed but that is for joke XD.

 

And she is not a Londoner, so she was there for an event or something. Why did she wear her wedding ring? She was an adulterer, and hid the fact that she was married for those affairs. It is very likely they were casual hook-ups because otherwise the truth would come out eventually. Casual hook-ups mean she was to be ready with her single persona most times although it’s possible that she would only transform when she had settled down, like visiting bar in the evening.

 

@brain aneurysm 

It’s very possible that the driver still got his money, brain aneurysm often goes undetected or dismissed as other things because it doesn’t really show a lot of symptoms, I don't think he would register that the his company because most likely he would be deemed unfit for the job. I believe he probably had multiple insurance, such as accident, critical illness and death. That would cover a lot, and London Cab would have its own insurance. If you meant getting money from Moriarty, maybe not. That would be the end of his contract.

 

Another nitpick, John deduced that Jennifer died from asphyxiation and choked on her own vomit. This is very unlikely and absurd conclusion, because she faced down/side. Even recovery position in first aid recommend lying on the side to prevent choking of vomit or tongue.

And I always wonder about the writing arrangement on the floor. Some languages are written from right to left, but definitely not English. Isn’t it more likely that the first few letters contain more residues from her nail polish than subsequent letters?

image.jpg

 

And she died while writing those letters. But her head was turned to the right. So she’s rather dedicated her last energy to turn her head than finishing the letters. If she was writing it the whole time the head was on the right, the letter arrangement would be mostly different , messier, not in neat line and the first letter wouldn’t be that far from her.

 

 

Work first. Catch you later.

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I believe she was at Lestrade's press conference, so that's at least part of the reason she was in London.

Posted

Also about the floor scratching, I know Rache is from the ACD story, but it would have made more sense to scratch 'cab.' Shorter and easier to understand since the likelihood of someone like Sherlock coming along and realising it was a password is slim to none. Unless, of course, she knew Sherlock would be involved after him texting 'wrong' to everyone at the press conference.  

Posted

Did anyone noticed that Pink Lady's hair was dry? She didn't use her umbrella, so the hair should be as wet as the coat.

I thought her coat was only wet underneath the collar, where it hadn't been exposed to enough air to dry.  That's how Sherlock figured out that it had been turned up against the wind earlier.

 

I also think they shouldn't have shown John's cane when the boys run out of Angelo's. It was so in-your-face and actually took out the impact of the scene when Angelo brings it back.

I hadn't considered that before, but I think I agree.  The impact would have been greater if the reveal had waited until Angelo returned it.

 

 

Posted

Yea you're right, he makes a point of running his fingers under her collar. 

 

And ditto with the cane. 

Posted

... I always wonder about the writing arrangement on the floor. Some languages are written from right to left, but definitely not English. Isn’t it more likely that the first few letters contain more residues from her nail polish than subsequent letters?

image.jpg

 

And she died while writing those letters. But her head was turned to the right. So she’s rather dedicated her last energy to turn her head than finishing the letters. If she was writing it the whole time the head was on the right, the letter arrangement would be mostly different , messier, not in neat line and the first letter wouldn’t be that far from her.

It looks to me like there actually is a faint pinkish tinge to the R and the A, probably enough to account for the small amount of polish from her ground-down fingernails.  My question would be, what supplied the black pigment for the remaining letters?  Eyebrow pencil?  Odd that it wasn't mentioned, whatever it was.

 

Regarding the position of her head, perhaps she was propped up on her elbow while she was writing, but collapsed after completing five letters.

Posted

Sometimes when you scratch wood like that it just naturally turns dark, I don't know why. Moisture in the wood, maybe? But I've seen it happen. Altho in this case it does look suspiciously like the letters have been burnt in with a match, doesn't it?

 

Maybe she pulled her upturned collar over her head to keep her hair from getting wet?

 

"Cab" is shorter, but "Rachel" is more specific, being the password for her phone account. Track down a cab, you might not get the right guy. Track down her phone, whoever has it is probably the killer?

 

Annnd..... that's all I've got. :smile: Agree about the cane, that's always bothered me.

 

Oh, and I don't think that's supposed to be the same lady at the press conference. I think I read that somewhere. Or maybe I just now made it up. Too sleepy to check.

 

 

 

Posted

Cab is less specific but also gives a clue that someone like Lestrade could follow up - have a look on CCTV for cabs leaving the area, it would take a while, and he might never find the right one, but at least it'll give him a direction to look. No one other than Sherlock could have figured out Rachel. 

Posted

True.  Though if she *was* at the press conference (which is plausible, whether we saw her or not -- several people are only barely visible), then she might expect Sherlock to be in on the case, since it had already reached critical mass.

 

********

 

But of course the real reason is that in Doyle's original story "A Study in Scarlet," the word "Rache" is written on a wall in the victim's blood.  Lestrade is convinced that if they can "find Miss Rachel," everything will be explained -- but it turns out that the killer has actually written "revenge" in German, in order to divert suspicion.  No way the Moftisses could resist playing with that!

 

Posted

And if it's blood it would turn dark as well, but the fingers were not bloody enough.

Unless the conference was in Cardiff, her being in press conference would counter all the other deductions. Or the press conference happen at different timeline.

 

Yup writing Cab would be reasonable, she would have bit of time to turn her head. XD

Regarding the position of her head, perhaps she was propped up on her elbow while she was writing, but collapsed after completing five letters.

It would be more likely for her right arm to stretch above her head and head resting on that imo. Anyway, I always found the JW pilot's body position much more belivable, SIP is too neat, too symmetrical. Legs weird, hands weird. Wrong wrong wrong! It looks like someone propped her.

Hmm, how if the kids who found her did that? Making her turn right, arranged the right hand to be similar with the left, and both legs symmetrical. One of the kid could have acute OCD and couldn't help it, although OCD person would leave the way she supposed to be because it explains her story.

 

Anyway, one thing that could probably redeems Jeff Hope a bit, just a bit, he didn't kill for pleasure of watching his victims die. He was probably not a natural psychopath at all, but driven by anger, helplessness, compassion for his children, and yah, a bit of psychopathy in forcing victims to play pill roulette.

  • Like 1
  • 2 months later...
Posted

It's taken me awhile, but I finally started reading the Sherlock scripts that are available here and there. Starting with ASIP, natch.

This one says it's a "final shooting script - green amended". Does anyone know what that means? Because there's like 3-4 lines of dialogue at the very end that are printed in green, and that's all. Wonder if that means that's the only thing that changed from previous versions.

At any rate, a couple things jumped out at me. I've often seen where fans guess that John was thinking about suicide, because of the close up of the gun in his drawer near the beginning of ASIP. I never saw it that way, myself, it seemed to me they just showed the gun so it's presence wouldn't have to be explained when he went back to get it later. However: in the script, Moffat makes a point of John looking at the gun: 

Quote

John’s look holds on the gun for a moment, like it’s a curious temptation to him --
-- then he firmly closes the drawer.

So now I'm more inclined to buy the "suicidal" theory. John's also frequently described as feeling humiliated by his "weakness", which I also never picked up on. Defensive about it, maybe, but not humiliated. Interesting.

But even more interesting to me is this scene that never made it into the final cut. Lestrade meets a mysterious someone (Sherlock) on the roof after the press conference: 

Quote

 

A tall, thin man is standing with his back to us right at the edge of the roof, looking out over London. A silhouette.
LESTRADE: Okay. What am I getting wrong this time?
SHERLOCK: No notes. No prior sign. Each of them in a strange location that means nothing to them where they’ve never gone before... That’s not how I’d kill myself.
On Lestrade. Glances uneasily at the edge of the roof, where Sherlock is standing.
LESTRADE: ... So. How are you doing these days?

 

I remember some of us speculating that Sherlock was the one who was, if not suicidal, then at least not placing very much value on his own life. Now I'm convinced we didn't just imagine that. 

And also how neat, the way that scene ties in with both the end of TRF, and the end of TLD, when Sherlock says he doesn't know how to spend the currency of the life Mary saved. Makes me appreciate both those scenes even more.

Another interesting thing is how thoroughly we see the story through John's eyes. Moffat provides plenty of descriptions for what John is thinking/feeling; but almost none for Sherlock. A different actor could have interpreted many of his lines so, so differently. I'm curious to see if, in the later scripts, when the pov switches to Sherlock, if we get more descriptions of his inner thoughts. 

Why did I wait so long to read these? I'm fascinated! (Takes less time than actually watching the show, too. :P )

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 132 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.